Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Made a few alterations to yesterday's page and thought I might as well post it again.

I'm trying really hard to get that fine balance of Nick obviously being worried about Charlie but also not making the comic scary or uncomfortable to read! I think it's important to show at least one example of Charlie's disordered eating behaviour, though.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Mx. Phoenix

Looks good, Nick's eyebrows didn't look quite right before but now you can clearly see his worry. It's hard finding that balance between the heavy and the light stuff but so far, you've been doing a great job 👍

Megan Barker

I like this revision 🥰🥰👍

Keefa Shine

I like this edit. The previous version seemed a bit.. aggressive? or drawing attention to the fact. this seems more subtle and in line with Nick's character.

Anonymous

Hey Alice, don’t overthink it, I can’t speak for others, but when I comment that I’m sad or mad or annoyed, it’s not because you wrote it wrong - it’s at the situation. Eating disorders SUCK. And you’d do your story disservice by pretending they don’t. It supposed to be uncomfortable and upsetting, because it simply is. From what I see so far it’s done very well, and Nick is super attentive and it’s heartwarming. It’s good that people care about characters and get mad for them. I personally wish I didn’t read what happens later because that makes me overthink everything that happens now. So I’m trying to take it one page at a time :)

Paméla Bertrand

You did a great job with this revision!!! Nick absolutely looks worried and we know he loves Charlie so hes going to approach this topic as best as be can. Plus, we know your comic is about a love story, so I don't think you could make it uncomfortable to read. Eating disorders can happen to anyone. You're highlighting one population that's severely ignored for EDs (boys) and I think that's noble. Part of Nick's love for Charlie is loving all of Charlie, if that makes sense. Gah sorry if this got rambly. I really love this comic and I really admire Alice's work and I'm really glad I can support and be a patron :)

Anonymous

Okay I’m the genius who now went to the original to see what the issue was after I commented. I saw Nick’s original face more as a “okay no more starring with concern, time for a PLAN.” And kind of assumed he whispered the first panel question in the first place and, well, he did not mean to put him on the spot with “everybody else finished” just... simply said it. But I do agree that it’s more with his character, when we think about the fact that he did a good research, to not put Charlie on the spot and instead whisper the first question, without pointing out others finished, and being concerned in the last panel instead. I think Nick coming up with a plan would be very him and sweet too though. He’s doing very well for a young boy dealing with a big issue.

aliceoseman

I'm glad you think so!! And I completely agree - comments from readers on Patreon are so helpful!!

Bryn

alice!!! the page # isnt on here!!

Juni B. Joons

I love this edit ❤️ I feel it's it's more inline with Nick's character. I appreciate the change to the text as well; as someone who has suffered from an eating disorder I understand the stress Charlie is feeling and it definitely made me kinda stressed when Nick pointed out his not having finished eating so I imagine Charlie would feel similarly.

Jeska

Ohhhhh I love this version

Doddz Co

Good work Alice!

Mat

This looks so much better imo! I like this revision.