Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 478673072.mp4

Downloads

Content

This girl and her minions are about to piss us tf off 😭 (hence the stank face lol)

Files

Comments

Granat HD

Oh yeah this arc, one of my favs ngl

Pedro Lobo

Idk who I hate more... Sagami with her shitty personality, or her 2 friends who just keep laughing and nodding in the back, who doesn't even have their own personalities, and just agree with the shitty one.

Lukas

I only caught on to this recently after rewatching the series multiple times. if you actually just look at the order of events and try to keep in mind that this show is from the perspective of an unreliable narrator, it becomes very clear that Yukino is actually just as much at fault for the situation getting out of hand as Sagami, if not even a bit more.

Lukas

I have watched this show at least two dozen times and only picked up on it recently so I don't blame you for not making the connection, but Yukino is just as much at fault for the situation getting out of hand as Sagami is, maybe even more. You need to keep in mind that Hachiman is an incredibly biased and unreliable narrator so how the show frames events can be off. Sagami isn't trying to annoy Yukino just because she is jealous, Yukino actively humiliated Sagami in front of the entire comity during that first meeting. It was basically just one gigantic insult. That's why Hiratsuka-sensei had a disapproving/worried look on her face during that meeting. Keep in mind that the LNs are written in first person from Hachiman's POV and Sagami represents the type of person he has the strongest bias against. Everything Sagami does gets presented in the most negative possible light and every flaw she has gets exaggerated. It's easy to let the presentation sway your opinion, when just looking at the events as they happen would really paint a different picture. For example, Sagami did not originally intend to just push all of the work onto Yukino. She started the first comity meeting herself and was on time for it. For all we know, her intentions were sincere and she really wanted to be the chair. There is no evidence presented in the show to suggest otherwise. It's only AFTER Yukino publically humiliated her in front of 50+ people that she starts to not care anymore, a bit in the vein of 'If you are so much better than me, then just do it yourself'. What Yukino should have done, as the support to Sagami as Sagami had requested, was to wait until the meeting was over and then bring up the issues to Sagami in private. That would be more in line with Yukino's idea of how to conduct the service club in the first place. Don't give her a fish, but teach her how to catch them herself. But Yukino's personal issues about her sister undermined that. I also want to point this out now because this dichotomy stay's relevant throughout the show. Oregairu is actually very good at stuff like this. It's one of the view stories where the 'unreliable narrator' actually means something and you actually have to pay attantion to the difference between how people are presented, and the actions they actually take.

Pedro Lobo

The only reason I don't see it as her fault, is the presence of Haruno. Sagami knows nothing about what needs to be done for the event, so when 1 little thing is 30% done, she thinks it's all done. That's when Yukino enters and shows what needs to be done. But, with Haruno there, Yukino kinda thinks she needs to do these things. Yukino should rely more on others? Yes. But, with Shiromeguri calling Haruno there out of nowhere, and saying "Oh, when Haruno was in the committee, she was able do to this and that... You can do it too, right?". Then when Sagami, who wants to slack and push her work on others, sees that, she finds an excuse to keep doing that, saying that things worked out that way when Haruno was in charge. More salt to Yukino's wounds. So, yes, Yukino have her share of fault here, but most of the fault is on Sagami for being a shitty person, + Haruno wanting to push Yukino in that kind of situation, + Shiromeguri for calling Haruno there. Shiromeguri even realizes later in this episode that calling Haruno there was a mistake. I would probably say it's something like 25% Yukino's, 10% Shiromeguri's, 15% Haruno's and 50% Sagami's fault.

Pedro Lobo

I honestly don't think Yukino humiliated Sagami there, and she couldn't point what was wrong after. They were behind the schedule. When something like that happens, in the middle of a meeting, you don't wait for the meeting to end to then tell the person that the job was still incomplete and that you are behind schedule. You need to do it right there and fix it, specially when you are behind schedule. If she waited to tell Sagami after, what would happen? The ppl in charge of the job would think it's all fine, wouldn't take more action, then they would be informed that they are behind schedule only in the next reunion, when things were even further behind schedule. It would be worse for everyone. Could even be worse for Sagami if things got out of hand.

Pedro Lobo

And correct me if I'm wrong, because I've only watched the anime, I didn't read the LN, but I always interpreted that the look Hiratsuka had was because of Yukino being compared to her sister, as the camera shifted to Hiratsuka's face right after Shiromeguri compared Yukino to Haruno, and Yukino showed disconfort. And Hiratsuka knows that one of the main problems in Yukino's life, is the comparison to her sister.

Sebastian Cevallos

I love how this story gives them an interesting problem and an interesting solution on what is still a low stakes day to day scenario

Lukas

This was the first meeting. They were, at worst, slightly behind schedule. Nothing that could not have been fixed easily. Really, they had more than enough time. And because of how this was handled, they fall even further behind. If they can make it up from being further behind than they were in the beginning, with less time to spare, then they could have easily made up for anything early on. So if Yukino wanted keep them from falling behind further, then talking to Sagami after the meeting would have been the correct choice anyway. And yeah, Yukino absolutely humiliated Sagami. She completely undermined her when Sagami tried to be a proper chair, to the point were everyone was talking about how good Yukino would be. Not only is that humiliating, it also goes entirely against Yukino's ethos on how to run the service club, all because she was emotionally compromised because of her sister.

Eric The Viewer

With a character like Sagami, a downfall is this time, high school 2nd year, would be the best thing all around. It would let her learn from the failure, without any severe long-term harm. So, yeah, root for cumuppence.

Undeath Ghost

You really have to love and hate the moment Sagami hands the "Chairwoman Stamp" to Yukino and publicly delegated the responsibility to her. It was at this moment that everyone in the room as a witness went from "Yukino SHOULD be the chairwoman" (what they said during the initial meet) to "Yukino IS the chairwoman and Sagami's taking all the credit" Love because you can tell everyone in that room is actually on Yukino's side. Hate because you know not a single one of them is going to do a damn thing to fix the really messed up thing going on here.

Undeath Ghost

I do agree that a lot of Sagami's "bad acts" are intentionally colored that way because of the way the story is framed. I do agree that both parties are at fault to an extent. That said, Sagami also hasn't even confronted about Yukino about what she doesn't like. Sure, undermining her leadership publicly like that IS pretty bad, yes. But at the same time, Sagami just shuts down and says nothing instead of actually asking her to stop.

Undeath Ghost

I think you're personally underselling Haruno's shittiness. I actually think shes more at fault that anyone except Sagami. I'd say something more like 50% Sagami, 25% Haruno, 5% Shiromeguri (Her only blame lies in forcing Haruno's past accomplishments on Yukino... but she has no way of knowing about any of their families dynamic/expectation and so it's a very honest mistake), 20% Yukino. If Haruno had just had the good sense to not instigate MORE complications into a school she has nothing to do with any more than Yukino would have behaved as she usually believes and made Sagami actually follow-up her claim of using this chance to "grow into a leader". Instead, she's made Yukino's life harder and made her an enemy... all because she encouraged behaviour you can tell she knows is wrong. She had this clearly disapproving look at Sagmumi's behaviour as a chairwoman... and then decided to support her JUST to instigate troubles for her sister. There's tough love. There's also just butting your nose into somebody else's business.