Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

You know the deal but here's a reminder of the rules:- ONE Show per comment- Like other comments you agree with - If you see a comment asking about a show we've already seen feel free to reply to it letting them know or we will as soon as we see it- Bonus Rule: Fragrant Flower will start once Dress Up S2 is done, that show is still guaranteedThese can be ANY shows! We'll be replacing 100 GF very soon (not sure how we'll cope)but Classroom & SNAFU will also need replacing once we're done with them

Comments

KZ

STEINS GATE!!!! PLEASE I BEG!!!!

jpizzle

Spy x family

Malchior

Teasing Master Takagi-san

Zy

Wistoria

Kels

Fruits Basket!

flowww

Nier Automata ver1.1a

Zy

Vanitas no carte

MudoV

Lycoris recoil

K1MCH1

Tonikawa: Over The Moon For You

Alpi

Lord of the mysteries

Zy

Toulet bound hanako san

Devin

Blue box

KC

A Place Further than the Universe

DaffyMcRonald

Love, chunnibyo, and other delusions

Idraaa

Erased

Marco

Gachiakuta

Tyler Lucas

The quintessential quintuplets

MishkaTho

Hell’s Paradise

0451Jim

Unlimited Blade Works

Leon

Mashle Muscles and magic. (Specifically season 1. Hilarious and good action, didn’t enjoy second season as much for the hilarious part, but great action.)

El

Shangri-La Frontier I have no reasoning, I just wanna see you guys watch it 🤷‍♂️

Coolyo8901

Saekano: How to Raise a Boring Girlfriend

kostaninki

More than a married couple, but not lovers

AverageVP

The quintessential quintuplets

Misaka Nettowaku

A Certain Magical Index Franchise 📘 Main Series: A Certain Magical Index (Toaru Majutsu no Index) Set in a world where science and magic coexist, A Certain Magical Index follows Kamijou Touma, a high school student in Academy City, a technologically advanced metropolis where students train to develop supernatural powers called Esper abilities. Despite having the weakest level—Level 0—Touma possesses a mysterious power in his right hand called Imagine Breaker, which can cancel out both magic and science-based powers. His life takes a sudden turn when he encounters Index, a nun from the magical side who holds 103,000 forbidden grimoires in her memory. From this point on, Touma finds himself entangled in conflicts between powerful magic factions and cutting-edge scientific organizations, balancing danger, ideology, and a struggle for peace. ⸻ 📗 Side Story: A Certain Scientific Railgun (Toaru Kagaku no Railgun) Set in the same universe and often running parallel to the main events, Railgun shifts focus to Mikoto Misaka, one of Academy City’s top-ranked Espers, known as the “Railgun” due to her signature move. This spin-off explores the scientific side of the universe more deeply, showcasing Mikoto’s daily life, friendships, and the darker conspiracies hiding behind Academy City’s high-tech surface. It provides a more grounded, character-driven look at the world, with emotional stakes and strong female leads. ⸻ 📕 Side Story: A Certain Scientific Accelerator (Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator) This spin-off centers on Accelerator, the most powerful Esper in Academy City, whose ability allows him to control vectors like force, electricity, and momentum. Despite his fearsome reputation, this series explores his inner struggles, redemption arc, and how he deals with the aftermath of events that occur in the main Index storyline. It’s a darker, more psychological look into the toll power can take on someone—and how even the strongest can be vulnerable. ⸻ 🎬 Why React to This Franchise? • Complex Worldbuilding: Blending science fiction with fantasy in a unique setting. • Moral Dilemmas: Many episodes challenge your views on justice, power, and sacrifice. • Diverse Characters: With memorable personalities across science and magic factions. • Epic Showdowns: From mental chess battles to all-out supernatural wars. • Multiple Perspectives: Each series adds depth to the universe through new angles.

Ricky Huckle

A Sign Of Affection plz 🙏

Racc

Gekkan shoujo nozaki-kun

Coolyo8901

The Quintessential Quintuplets

Dj_Cve

Summertime rendering

OfficiallyGames

"Uzaki Chan Wants To Hang Out" (Has 2 seasons and total of 25 eps - Comedy / Slice of Life)

OfficiallyGames

Yes! Don't see many reactors watching this despite it being such a good show!

LateDp

Shikimori’s not just a cutie

Krymsunn

you're cooking

Kurri

idk if you guys are asking for live actions but id love to see dexter

jordan

utawarerumono mask of truth

Cryptex

Ascendance of a Bookworm

Link

I wish!!!!

Cryptex

Romantic Killer

Spencer

Zom 100: bucket list of the dead

WhopsInc.

2.5 Dimensional Seduction

Equinoux

Fruits basket the romance goat

Lona

Black Clover especially because the next season is underway 🙏🏽

Ciego

Prez has seen s1 over at TGL reacts fairly recently no word on if they will do s2 yet tho

Cryptex

Tsukimichi

TheWnderJac

Love, Chunnibyo, and other delusions!!

Kurri

theyve seen it

Ciego

Prez is watching this over at TGL reacts if your interested.

zylex

Summertime Render

Cryptex

Dungeon Meshi - Delicious in Dungeon

Kurri

mid

Kurri

cook

Kurri

LOL

Vyper

Re: Zero season 3 please :)

Ciego

Prez is watching this over at TGL reacts if your interested.

Waylan Snider

Nevermind, apparently they’ve seen it

TI1509

Re-Zero season 3 has everything you guys loved about the show, it honestly the best one yet.

Cryptex

Snow White with the Red Hair

Rassaa

Blue Box!!!

MishkaTho

I thought so haha thanks for the info

Some Kinda Abomination

I haven’t seen anyone else suggest it, but Mushoku Tensei Jobless Reincarnation is a pretty good one. 2 seasons out already with about 50 episodes and season 3 is on the way next year.

Lukas

March comes in like a lion

Sawwwwa

Monogatari series

Ciego

100% a joke but Yugioh (just because Prez references it alot on TGL lol)

Ciego

Prez recently saw this on TGL.

Lukas

Seirei No Moribito

Javier

ReLIFE

GodsFury101

That time I got reincarnated as a slime

Lukas

golden kamuy

Michael

Monogatari

rama h

Odd Taxi

soniq

Made in abyss

soniq

Summertime rendering

Shana

Tonikawa!

Damacais

Undead Unluck

Yetzer C. R.

Hello! well... if you like to try "gore" anime... maybe you can try Higurashi: When They Cry - GOU Is a "remake" of a 2000's anime but in 2020... I watch it not knowing about this at first but you can still enjoy it that's what People said for this "new" audience There's not much People that reac to this so I'll be for that ;) You can try one ep see if People like it... have a nice day ^^

Yousef

March comes in like a lion

Some Kinda Abomination

Thank you for this information. I was unaware he had seen it, and didn’t even know there was another channel he reacted on.

Sk dragon

umamusume cinderella gray

soniq

Heavenly delusion

Rycen Bonifacio

Food wars, its just as unhinged as 100 gf

GhostPhil

Don't Toy with me Miss Nagatoro

GhostPhil

Black Lagoon (English Dub)

Harun Aslan

Komi can‘t communicate

Al-Dente123

More than a Married Couple, but not Lovers

Al-Dente123

The Wrong Way to Use Healing Magic

Al-Dente123

The World is Still Beautiful

Yetzer C. R.

The show is a mix of psychological horror, mystery, gruesome murders, paranoia, suspense and a deeper story beneath all the violence...

soniq

To your eternity

Ciego

Prez is watching this over at TGL reacts if your interested. its only a monthly upload based on a sub tier request so it could end any time but they are upto s2 ep5 tho, there is hope it will be a regular with each poll over there one day same as Grand Blue its a monthly request they are on ep9 with that one.

Kapitány Zoltán

So I will recommend the ones noone else will... First: Arakawa Under the Bridge

Sergio

Tomo-chan is a girl

Rycen Bonifacio

Thank you for letting me know, I'll check it out

Charcoal

Dr Stone is one of my favs. For sure worth a try, especially after seeing how much you guys enjoyed Apothecary Diaries

Dantin

kimi ni todoke

rama h

Kono oto tomare

wiski

Bottom-Tier Character Tomozaki

wiski

The only show I actually want to watch the English dub of.

Aise

Darling in the franxx

Hatoma

Re:Zero season 3

Kenneth Penderis

They already did this on their other channel TGL reacts

Hatoma

Kaiju N°8

Ciego

Prez is watching this over at TGL, caught upto the weekly eps too

Magride

Rokka no Yusha

rama h

Bakuman

Davlen

How the realist hero rebuilt the kingdom

Davlen

The Duke of death and his maid

Blizzard

I think one of you have already seen it but Konosuba is gold

Kenneth Penderis

They already saw it on the other channel Called TGL reacts

Davlen

By the grace of the gods

Cabrito

Fruit basket

Magride

Forgotten sadly but really good

Kenneth Penderis

They're watching it on their second channel TGL reacts

Magride

Irregular at Magic high School

Bob

Girls band cry

Magride

Death Parade

RPSiege

Fruits Basket

Magride

Black Bullet

RPSiege

Skip & Loafer

RPSiege

Chihayafuru

Magride

Demi chan wa

Magride

Drifters

Pedro Lobo

Summertime Rendering

RPSiege

Odd Taxi

RPSiege

Orb: On the Movements of the Earth

Magride

Prison School 🙃

Magride

Shadow house

GodsFury101

WHAAT!? I didn’t know they had another channel! Dang.. what a shame

Kenneth Penderis

You guys should check before you name an anime so that people do not repeat the same series just like the series if you agree

Kenneth Penderis

Your making it tougher for them to go through the comments

JD

Ouran Highschool Host Club

JJ

Case study of Vanitas

Cara & Prez

Really enjoyed Mushoku (especially S2) but yeah I saw it fairly recently unfortunately

JD

This!!!! Please!

Enson

Danmachi! Is It Wrong To Try To Pick Up Girls In A Dungeon?

Cara & Prez

It's actually Prez's original channel on YT, that's why some shows have been "girlfriend reacts" where he's already seen a show

GodsFury101

So you mean there’s still a chance? 😉😁

Enson

Komi Can’t Communicate

Cara & Prez

It's definitely a potential for "girlfriend reacts" since it's been a while since Prez saw it

ghosty

1.)chivalry of a failed knight (chivalry of a failed knight is massively slept on and it is amazing )

Cara & Prez

We usually wait a bit so it’s not something Prez has seen recently…but yeah there’s a chance in the future

GodsFury101

I’m fine with waiting, such a good show. Thanks for letting me know.

Kurri

bro did not read the rules

Kurri

tgl is the original, cara and prez is the 2nd 🤫

Toro E

danshi koukousei no nichijou n.nn

ghosty

Bro can not reed there is only one

Saucy

The Summer Hikaru Died!

Krymsunn

Case Study of Vanitas

Bob Owen

Rascal does not dream of Santa Claus

Krymsunn

Fena Pirate Princess

Krymsunn

Astra Lost in Space

EllaH

Wind breaker

Krymsunn

Kokoro Connect

Krymsunn

Grimgar Ashes and Illusions

Krymsunn

Great Pretender

Pedro Lobo

Prez already watched almost all of season 1 on TGL channel.

Drakojin

Very unlikely But a classic: Slayers

VagaBocchi

Dealing with Mikadono Sisters Is a Breeze

Pedro Lobo

Prez already watched Black Clover in the other channel.

Pedro Lobo

Prez is reacting to it in the TGL channel, almost caught up to the weekly already.

Pedro Lobo

The GOAT mentioned! Love to see it.

Pedro Lobo

Prez already watched almost all of S1 on TGL channel.

Pedro Lobo

Good days when Kurri was posting "mid" in every single episode of Black Clover at TGL 😂 Brace yourself, it's coming back in 2026.

Pedro Lobo

They are going to react to it already. They just needed to watch the 2 movies before starting the new season, and they already did, so we will probably see some reactions for the new season soon.

Pedro Lobo

Ty for reminding me how old I am...

TheAnimeJunkie

Beck: Mongolian Chop Squad (Music/Band Anime)

Access

Clannad

91bennil

Nodame Cantabile

Ja'far

Angel Beats!

MESHA

Tomo Chan is a girl

MESHA

Signs of affection

Sjeg84

Clevatess

Cara & Prez

Yep we’re starting it this week! It’ll be a Patreon exclusive alongside call of the night

KZ

MUAHAHAHAHA

Cara & Prez

Once I’m caught up…it’s time to run it back😤👀

Rabestor

Hi there, is there any estimation for call of the night becoming not exclusive or will it ever?

AJ

tomodachi game

DarkDoom

The Legend of Vox Machina

Ash

Tsukimichi moonlit fantasy

K1MCH1

Please check comments first before commenting. It makes voting/sorting easier for EVERYONE.

max_g

Golden Time

Jonathan

Love chunnibyo and other delusions

Zul Lee

Komi san can't communicate

Shawn Allen

SPY X FAMILY!!! 🥰🥰🥰

Ara J

I really want to see you guys watch Kuroko No Basket! Hopefully it’s something new for you to enjoy. It’s a sports anime on basketball and it’s my favourite sports anime till this day and i watched it when i was young!

Tittus

a sign of affection

Shawn Allen

Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood

Tittus

wistoria wandandsword

Tittus

food wars

lel L

More than a married couple, but not lovers

lel L

Sword art Online

Bill0g

Delicious in Dungeon / Dungeon Meshi

V

LYCORIS RECOIL!

Bill0g

Teasing Master Takagi-san

Kurri

ur not slick editing that shit buddy

Astriea

Lord of the Mysteries

Astriea

My Love Story with yamada-kun at Lv999

Astriea

Wind Breaker

Cryptex

7th time loop

Cara & Prez

Some shows like Call of the Night are patreon exclusive, meaning they are S Tier only and won’t be coming over to YT

Rabestor

Hi, thanks for responding so does that mean they wont be coming to" a rank supporter " on patreon?

Eli Gamarra

Alrighty guys and gals, is it time for Made in Abyss?!

Gai Valentine

To Your Eternity Season 3 is coming soon

Eli Gamarra

It is not wrong! Everyone should try!

Eli Gamarra

There’s like over 300 comments it’s kinda hard to check them all if you’re not on a computer or have a lot of time.

Eli Gamarra

I saw they were releasing something new for Gate but it’s a spinoff and now I’m sad about it

Eli Gamarra

The copyright strikes are strong with this one

Eli Gamarra

Absolute legend of a show

Itz A Dolphin

Ouch the pain, the trauma,. thumbs up from me.

Itz A Dolphin

I third. Fruits Basket was my gateway anime.

JNES

Dealing with Mikadono Sisters Is a Breeze

Magride

Yes Fremy, I was so attached to her back then

Magride

he left the 1) in it :)

Magride

really cute slice of life this one

Mardos

Monster

Magride

those will need to be added to the other Gate Bellow

Engineer

More than a married couple but not lovers

Eoin

More than a married couple but not lovers

JAMES D'ALESSANDRO

I went through the whole list before I posted it...sorry if i missed it

soniq

To be hero x

Eric The Viewer

@Cara & Prez, Will you be watching Mushoku Tensei Season 3 on the channel?

Seán

K-on! its amazing you will like it alot

JayceC

Summertime Rendering

J star

Welcome to demon school iruma-kun! Severly underrated show 😭

swag ramen

Dawg, too much fan service

swag ramen

Erased (boku dake ga inai machi)

Cara & Prez

That’s correct, a part of our S Rank benefits is patreon exclusive shows that only come to that tier

Cara & Prez

Dw we managed to find a system to check the comments but AFTER the first few hours (those are insane lol)

Cara & Prez

Not sure yet as the other channel is moving away from anime, as for here we would defo wait a while before watching it

JayceC

Hello World anime

JayceC

Noragami

Eric The Viewer

I was silly enough to buy the new movies, then a few weeks later, they finally put them on crunchy roll.

Arbiter

Vivy: Fluorite Eye's Song

Arbiter

fate/grand order absolute demonic front babylonia

jpizzle

I said this earlier!

jpizzle

This is the 3rd time someone commented this 🤣

Arbiter

The ancient Magus' Bride

Arbiter

Lycoris recoil

Arbiter

dusk maiden of amnesia

Arbiter

darker than black

Arbiter

Beautiful Bones -Sakurako's Investigations

Shawn Allen

Lol admittedly I commented this before reading through all 200 previous comments. But I'm pretty sure my other recs are not duplicates. BUT I STAND BY MY SPY X FAMILY REC LOL 😂😂😂

Wooly

Grand blue do be a banger

Ducky

Wind Breaker :)

Ducky

A Sign of Affection :3

Ducky

Lord of Mysteries

Ducky

Lookism

ghosty

I never said I didn't edit it I saw the post but not the rules commented then saw then saw the rules and then proceeded to change it .is it not ok to make mistakes any more jezz

Arbiter

Fate/Apocrypa

Arbiter

Plastic memory

Arbiter

summer ghost

Arbiter

Tsukimichi moonlit fantasy

Arbiter

the tunnel to summer, the exit of goodbyes

Enrique 99

Mushoku (although I've already seen it, prez)

Enrique 99

That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime

LJ

I don't see anime specified so... Extraordinary Attorney Woo

Diego Maldonado

More than a married couple but not lovers

SaltyMango

Jujutsu kaisen or konosuba

Stodzas

Disastrous Life of Saiki K

Stodzas

Domestic Girlfriend

Undeath Ghost

Hibike! Euphonium; also called "Sound! Euphonium" (A great coming of age story centered around High School Band. The story is completely adapted so you can see it start-to-finish. Absolutely gorgeous animation and unforgettable music)

Undeath Ghost

Zombieland Saga (Has similarly strong levels of comedy to 100GFs, in that sense it's a good replacement. FANTASTIC SHOW and the new movie just got it's theatrical release date in a few months so we may see it next year!)

Undeath Ghost

Ascendance of a Bookworm (Has great a storyline and is severely underestimated. Fantasy story)

Undeath Ghost

The Quintessential Quintuplets (A great harem anime that is a bit more "traditional" than 100GFs but still has great characters. In that sense it's a good follow-up to 100GFs)

Undeath Ghost

Just look at it this way Eric, you're supporting the creators! Bunny Girl Senpai deserves it

Kurri

actual dogshit off my shoe is coming back

meharoz

Highschool Dxd for the culture (decent plot as well). Perfect replacement for 100 girlfriends

MickFoley299

Rent-A-Girlfriend It is a pretty good series if you give it a legitimate chance and not go in expecting it to be bad.

BaBorrow

Golden Kamuy

Fukayo

Steins;Gate

blippys

More than a married couple, but not lovers. goated romcom.

arden

Fruits Basket

arden

Fairy Tail

arden

That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime

arden

The Elusive Samurai

John Ng

You should react to the current season anime for "Clevatess". It's a very good dark fantasy. Highly recommend it.

John Ng

Another very good current season anime for reaction, "Silent Witch".

Emir

Rascal Does Not Dream of Santa Claus

Blizzard

Love, Chunibyo, and other delusions

Engineer

Tokyo gouhl only first season tho the other 2 seasons are eh

Pedro Lobo

Prez already watched it in TGL channel.

Marcus SG

Ouran highschool host club

Marcus SG

Couple of cukoos

Marcus SG

Farming in a another world

MickFoley299

While that is one of my favorite series, I feel like it is a show much more suited for TGL to react to. It really feels like the vibe that works better there.

Undeath Ghost

They're already going to watch this. They were catching up on the movies they missed first. We'll probably be seeing episode 1 soonish

Undeath Ghost

I think it's fine overall. Similar to how Domestic Girlfriend is fine, overall. For both shows you have to go in 1) not assuming their bad and looking only at their faults 2) suspend your disbelief a bit. That said there are lots of better options out there first though, ya know?

sutto247

As a Reincarnated Aristocrat, I’ll Use My Appraisal Skill to Rise in the World

sutto247

how a realist hero rebuilt a kingdom

Legiey

To be hero x

Enson

The other channel is moving from anime to movies.

Arbiter

fate zero

Arbiter

Code Geass

Max Bretl

March comes in like a lion!

Carl Rigney

The Eccentric Family "Fireworks fight in a flying teahouse powered by booze. Truly, that is the meaning of summer."

ghosty

this was so good to peak isekaI

ghosty

S2 PEAK SEASON 3 MID

Carlos Gonzalez

It has comedy, a saucy maid, a circus, other dimension, three seasons, and a resolution

LilSmartAss

the eminence in shadow ?

Mad Man Moon

My Love Story (Ore Monogatari). Absolute classic wholesome and hilarious romcom. Satchatootos!

Mad Man Moon

It's so good! Bocchi the Witch lol

Mad Man Moon

Also Barakamon. Massive wholesomeness, amazing story and characters. I've never seen anyone react to it before, and it totally deserves a watch!

MickFoley299

I just feel like the series is relevant right now since Season Four is currently airing and they would likely then be caught up and be able to watch cour 2 as it airs weekly.

Ciego

Prez saw this pretty recently over at TGLreacts.

Manuel Bajcic

I would love you to see chihayafuru

Daniel

moriarty the patriot

Trixie

Initial D

jack

darling in the franxx

momo_jc

orb : on the movements of the earth

momo_jc

TO YOUR ETERNITY

momo_jc

BUNGOU STRAY DOGS

momo_jc

THE SUMMER HIKARU DIED

Kitty the blacksmith

"7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy!"

KZ

YES!!!! But unfortunately it’ll never be done because barely anyone is gonna vote for it 😔

KZ

@ghosty ignore kurri. The guy is a dumb ass and gets his fix from annoying the fuck out of people

KZ

Oh no… that anime was so good but I was way too scarred by that anime. And I usually tend to have the stomach to handle these types of animes. I guess binging it wasn’t the best decision

Magride

No problemo

Magride

You’re fine who cares. Since you corrected

Magride

Shit. The views would flow. Well it is what it is

Pedro Lobo

There are enough shows to make 2 separate pools with the most mentioned/liked here. One with the romance anime, and the other with the rest, it would be nice.

Eli Gamarra

We could make 2 lakes let alone pools

Cara & Prez

We mentioned this ain’t just for 100gf but also after classroom and snafu (which are like 5-6 weeks away from being done) Basically we’re getting as many options and opinions now then will decide what goes on what poll😁

Pedro Lobo

I've always struggled with the words "poll" and "pool". And I guess I will continue... This shit never enters my brain, lol.

Kapitány Zoltán

Detectives These Days Are Crazy! is an ongoing show, but it's an interesting ride so far...

blasphemouscok

Lycoris Recoil. Not sure if yall have seen it but its fun

Bear

Ancient Magus Bride is SUCH a good show. Literally one of my favorites; definitely a must-watch for y'all. I 100% believe it’s right up your guys’s alley, and I’m sure a lot of people would love y’all’s reaction

Marv

Wind breaker would be a nice watch 👌​

ARod13

Akame ga kill

LateDp

Sound! Euphonium

GhostPhil

Interspecies Reviewers 🫣😏

GhostPhil

Such an underrated show this season and not enough reactions to it

GhostPhil

Yeah this and Cowboy Bebop are the only shows for me, where I prefer the English Dub over the original one. Not just because it maybe better, but because it just fits so well. The harsher sound of the English language really adds to the shows

Sergio

Wistoria: Wand and Sword

Eli Gamarra

I really cannot wait for you guys to watch Fragrant Flower. I have been hyping it up so much that your expectations are probably through the roof at this point, but don’t worry,CloverWorks has been doing SO SO SO amazingly with the adaptation that I actually have nothing to complain about for once other than there not being more episodes.

AverageVP

Since everyone is thinking it but no one has said it I'll say it: Gushing over Magical Girls

na

Ping Pong the Anime! Can we change it up from allll romantic/slice of life plz? I love SNAFU but some more variety would be great, Cara and Prez. Not meant as a critique, just how I feel.

na

THIS!!!!

Ryzuz

Haven't you heard? I'm Sakamoto

momo_jc

Summertime rendering

Ray H

Just finished this one and was impressed once I got used to the animation.

Cristian T

Uma Musume cinderella gray part 2 comes out this October

Undeath Ghost

I want this so bad... this show doesn't get enough attention and its SOOOO GOOOOD

Kii

Gundam Witch from Mercury

Thomas Mai

weathering with you!

Luifer Chacon

ORB on the movements of the earth

Dylan Casey

More than just a married couple, but not lovers is PEAK you guys have to watch it

JRL

Golden Time

Valkerion

I haven't seen it in the comments yet. Rent-A-Girlfriend is fun

Ungobungo

fire force is incredibly PEAK

Fliies

Insomniacs after school, an underated gem.

Robbie Corrie

If you guys haven't seen it already, I would be very interested to see your reaction to Anohana: The Flower We Saw That Day

Shucks

Sound! Euphonium. I know this post is old and I've seen a few people comment this one, but after going through a decent bit of your guys' catalog, this show would be perfect for you guys.

Shucks

Everyone needs to pick a quintessential quintuplet. its like picking charmander, bulbasaur, or squirtle. yall gotta treat that show like the sporting event it is.

ApologeticCanadian

Blue Box for the next romance show seems like it would be a great fit.

Feko

Wotakoi: Love Is Hard For Otaku