Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

*PLEASE READ BEFORE COMMENTING*Alright guys over the next 5 weeks we'll be wrapping up 3 shows (Mushoku, Chunibyo, Steins Gate) so it's time we switch things up soon!We want to hear some show suggestions HOWEVER please try to follow the rules:- 1 Show Per Comment- Mention the genre OR What show it should replace in brackets- Like other comments that you agree withWe already have a list of shows we're both interested in as well as previous suggestions, but it never hurts to get some new ideas😊

Comments

HBelmont67

Don't Toy With Me, Miss Nagatoro, High School Romcom

Mariiiii

Grand Blue. Genre? Comedy

Marco

Black clover

Aira

Clannad and Clannad After Story (to replace Chuunibyo as the romance anime)

Eli Gamarra

MADE IN ABYSS (Replacing Steins)

Jarnomansfield

Smoking behind the supermarket with you - [genre: slice of life / adult relationship rom com]

Dgxude

Made in Abyss (adventure) so it could replace Steins Gate

Elexis

Hibike Euphonium (Music,Drama)

Nkyoma

Darling in the Franxx, genre: Drama, science fiction, and romance on the side Very good anime you will love it!!

HBelmont67

Hokkaido Gals are Super Adorable, High School Romcom

Thomas Mai

Komi can’t communicate to replace chunibyo 🙏🏽

Luifer Chacon

Ramparts of ice, it’s similar to polar opposites and made by the same author, just a little more dramatic

Gerald Tam

blue box to replace chuninyo for romance. its peak and its a really good pick as season 2 will be dropped in october so u guys can just keep it going non stop :)

cLMischka

Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky - Romantic drama, and slice of life

Goldfish

Sound Euphonium - Music, Drama

Eli Gamarra

Daemons of the Shadow Realm (Replacing Mushoku) by the creator of Fullmetal Alchemist

steviemoe

Witch Hat Atelier [Mushoko Tensei]

Clo

Grand Blue, it’s a diving comedy show. Yes, diving show…

Jefam99

Golden boy. Its an unhinged comedy and ive never seen anyone react to it. Its one of my favorites. Its also relatively short running anime with shorter episodes so you could watch it all in a few hours

Silver

Re:Zero season 4 to replace Mushoku

Broodixian

Golden Time (Romance/Chunibyo)

Solitude23

"Spice and Wolf" Remake (Fantasy/Drama)

Kels

Fairy Tail. Genre: magic I guess? But it’s shounen

Saucy

Blue box - genre: Romance! The new season will come out in October so it’s a great time to catch up!

Kels

Fruits Basket: romance and trauma

Blizzard

Lycoris Recoil

Xxuoll

That time I got reincarnated into a slime

Jongoe

Witch hat Atelier Fantasy, in the same vein as Frieren

Gai Valentine

Made in Abyss. Genre: Dark Fantasy, Adventure, Sci-fi

Kels

Link click: mystery time travel (kinda) and trauma

Damacais

Undead Unluck to replace Mushoku or Steins Gate, its a sleeper hit but new season is coming early next year probably

Kels

Wind breaker: kinda like gangs?

Peace

isekai ojisan, genre: isekai,comedy

Kels

Kuroko no basket: basket ball!!

Sergio

Now that My Hero Academia is finished, your guys should do that

kostaninki

Comedy: grand blue. And blue box🤩

Snakeplus

Don't Toy With Me, Miss Nagatoro, Romcom please

Jefam99

Eden of the east. Its a quality anime with an intriguing first episode and the whole way through you are trying to find out whats happening. The English dub is good as well. I would maybe categorize it as a mystery/adventure?

Blizzard

fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works

Sergio

Lovely Complex, genre: old school romcon

Mike Baker

Key the Metal Idol Forgotten classic from 30 years ago. I only ask because no one across all of YouTube (but English YouTube and Japanese YouTube) has ever reacted to it.

Kels

Dungeon Meshi: fantasy! But hilarious

CloudAscended

Fairy tail. Genre: Shonen. I think you guys would really enjoy it.

Sergio

Fruits Basket

TI1509

Re-zero season 4 instead of Moshouku you’re missing out absolutely madness. Season 4 genre: straight horror

Jarnomansfield

Hey!! They’ve already completed 86 it’s in the collections enjoy! What else would you want to see ?

Kels

My Hero Academia

Ropo Studios

Sound! Euphonium - genre slice of life / musical drama

Casper

Sentenced To Be A Hero (Mushoku replacement)

Jefam99

Death note. Im surprised you havent watched it yet, its a staple for a lot of reaction channels and will definitely get views. I'd love to see cara's opinion on misa misa. The English dub is very good, and if you like it, when you are finished you can replace it with code geasse that has similar vibes and voice actors (although probably not quite as good as death note)

Cryptex

Delicious in Dungeon (Dungeon Meshi) genre : fantasy/dungeon explorer?

Kels

Witch Hat Atelier: fantasy and honestly a must watch. The fact that you guys haven’t watched this yet is shocking

RPSiege

Skip and Loafer [Slice of Life / Romance]

TI1509

Made in abyss, genre adventure Amazing story and world building, won anime of the year for a reason.

David78

Blue box

Omega

Which hat atelier - genre fantasy adventure

Frank Manera

Asobi Asobase Genre: TRUE comedy

K1MCH1

Romance, slice of life and Drama* haha. You don’t add the second one you listed because that’s pretty much spoiling it. Theirs a reasons shows and movies don’t list that💀. Especially based on covers haha.

Daniel

Wistoria: Wand and Sword (fantasy/magic - could replace mushoku)

TI1509

Ramparts of ice, genre romance / slice of life Set up in the same world as polar opposite and in my opinion it’s even better

RPSiege

Chihayafuru [Slice of Life / Sport / Romance]

Sam Cj

Fairy Tail, Genre: Fantasy

SirSkyRage

Made in Abyss (replacing steins gate)

Sk dragon

witch hat atelier fantasy

Cryptex

Shangri-La Frontier genre: action/ (gaming/mmorpg)

K1MCH1

Already listed at ^^

StabKingPro

Dealing with Mikadono Sisters Is a Breeze, romcom

Susak09

I Want to End This Love Game (Romance)

MaxiRh

Made in Abyss Simply a great adventure story and worldbuilding, such a beautiful and terrifying show at the same time

Shucks

SOUND/HIBIKE! EUPHONIUM to replace steins gate. MUSIC DRAMA

K1MCH1

At top^^

LateDp

I think I’d be cool if you guys watched The Hobbit movie trilogy since you guys watch LOTR even though it’s been a while

CoolFrog2137

Plastic memories genre romance

dedly

Lycoris recoil - action, sol

Roger Powell

The Klutzy Class Monitor and The Girl in The Short Skirt [Rom-com, Rom]

Trinity

May I Ask for one final Thing Fantasy/Comedy/Action

Jarnomansfield

[side note this will be a great replacement for polar opposites. Same author completely different tone but with the same character development]

Havenot14

Wistoria Fantasy basically black clover meets Harry Potter meets mashle

dedly

they already did 86 check it in collections

Eli Gamarra

Smoking Behind the Supermarket with You (Replacing Chunibyou) Adult Romance

Jefam99

Nana might fit with the vibes of the channel. Its a drama and the whole anime feels like your watching really good gossip

Kurri

not nagatoro thanks

Yuruga

Also made by Kōcha Agasawa - same mangaka that wrote "You and I are polar opposites".

Roger Powell

Uzaki-chan Wants to Hang Out [Rom-com, Rom]

crack

Why don’t you guys have a community chat channel btw?

LateDp

Fate/Zero

LateDp

Shikimori’s not just a cutie is a romance you guys would enjoy

Eli Gamarra

Gals Can’t Be Kind to Otaku!? (Replacing Chunibyou) High School Rom-Com

Kels

Oh my god! Yes!

Qba

There's No Freaking Way I'll be Your Lover! Unless... [romcom]

Valkerion

Rent a girlfriend romance

krok

Yeah, this is my pick as well. I'm really into this show as of late

Kurri

VOUCH

Brandon

I Want To End This Love Game just finished airing and is exactly your guys cup of tea.

Skyvvood

Definitly Re:Zero s4 it’ll be done in the time yall finish up those shows

Navirei

Blue box high school rom com

LateDp

Sound Euphonium is a great one!

Dan

Clannad (romance to replace Chunibyo) the goat romcom

K1MCH1

A Sign of Affection Genre: Romance Came out like last year and was super PEAK. Pretty well known and everyone’s desperately waiting for S2!

Shucks

Chat you wont regret this one prayge I've been trying for a year

Irvin Hernandez

Record of ragnarok genre:action, dark fantasy, and supernatural

Brandon

They stopped their ReZero reactions. They probably don’t like it.

Dan

goat shounen imo

Steve Schrader

A Sign of Affection - Romance [replacing Chunibyo]. One season, 12 episode adult cast romance.

Trixie

Hajime No Ippo - Sports

sadaholic

to be hero x would be a wonderful show for y’all to watch. that could definitely replace mushoku tensei.

Mihail Maftei

I mean, they watched everything including S3, right?

Vitero27

My Hero Academia ~ Shonen

TW

Marriagetoxin - Action, Romcom

cLMischka

Yeah you're right hahah

Vitero27

This is my recommendation also

Eisen

I know it's a minor one but Astra Lost in Space : Sci-fi, mystery A hidden gem and it'll make sense to replace Steins Gate

Vitero27

Yup I think they would love it

Icvrus.arw

It is time to experience Clannad & Clannad After Story - Romance, Drama, Tears. It is a classic.

TW

Daemons of the shadow realm - Action/Shonen (replace either steins gate or mushoku)

Vitero27

Yup I think they would love it this is another really good one

Jarnomansfield

We can wish. I’ve given up on Komi and nagatoro…. Those will get the after a decade has passed treatment like chunibyo and be a great revisit when it finally happens 😂

D4NT3I0I

Beyond the boundary. Romcom, action, supernatural It has 1 season, 1 prequel OVA, and 1 movie

Equinoux

Fruits basket

GhostPhil

Black Lagoon (in English Dub): Black Lagoon is an action-packed crime thriller anime set in the gritty criminal underworld of 1990s Southeast Asia. Genres: - Action: Features fast-paced, over-the-top gunfights, nautical battles, and martial arts. - Crime / Thriller: Focuses on smuggling, piracy, mob syndicates, and contract jobs. - Girls with Guns: Highlights lethal, heavily armed female leads like Revy.

GhostPhil

Genre is Romance and Comedy

Jongoe

Also the previous work from the author of Polar Opposites

Sky-Spider05

In the Clear Moonlit Dusk or Watari-kun's ****** Is About to Collapse

Bastian OR

Don't toy with me miss Nagatoro - Romcom

Airferi23

Clannad Slice of Life,Drama, romance. Also a Visual novel adaptation like Steins Gate. Since you are on a roll with them why not continoue

TW

Mistress Kanan is devilishly easy (RomCom) more 100 gfs vibe than serious

harry

Please ramparts of ice is so so good you will love it because it’s so similar to you and I are polar opposites!

Alex Cabrera

Puella Magi Madoka Magica [Magical Girl] Don't let the genre color your expectations though

Crofo

Spice and Wolf: Merchant meets the Wise Wolf. Slice of Life/Romance/Drama A classic that’s being remastered, mostly ignored by reactors

Eisen

Hyouka : mystery, slice of life I'd say it's kinda like modern high school version of Apothecary Diary Also same studio as Chunibyo and Violet Evergarden so quality guaranteed

Lee Cherng Yan

Mob psycho 100 Supernatural,action,comedy

Lukasz B

Kono Oto Tomare!: Sounds of Life Hidden gem, slice of life, music.

Crofo

I’m really hoping that’s not true. I didn’t see any indication that they dropped on purpose

Kosse K

Awesome suggestion! Kind of a cult classic

DaffyMcRonald

Sentenced to be a Hero - genre: fantasy

Crofo

Would love to see! Either the original or the remake

Sneaky

Oh MB I must have missed it

Coolyo8901

Saekano -How to Raise a Boring Girlfriend- (its a romcom)

Mihail Maftei

They mentioned in the description of the final re zero reaction that they will keep an eye out for s4 :"> They probably didn't have time for it yet :)

Simon

Scum's wish - a different kind of romance

PyraStorm

I saw Grand Blue. Im gonna second that. Comedy

Crofo

Criminal lack of Yuri in their romance choices, a great rec

soniq

Made in abyss replacing (steins gate) (dark mystery adventure) and if you don’t trust me trust live action nami (Emily Rudd) it’s her favourite anime

91bennil

Medalist - drama and sport

91bennil

Pseudo Harem - romance, comedy

91bennil

Journal with Witch - drama

Toro E

The magic ends with *Mushoku*, but the magic continues with *Witch Hat Atelier*.

Cara & Prez

We liked S3 the most of all seasons! We always said it’ll eventually come back but it’s always about timing/scheduling, so dw we don’t hate it😂

R S Degurechaff

Delicious in Dungeon (Dungeon Meshi) genre: fantasy comedy

Alkampus

Kimi Ni Tadoke - [romance/slice of life]. Older romance anime that nobody mentions.

Kapitány Zoltán

Highschool of the Dead (genre: absolute normal zombie apocalipse series, nothing indecent...)

fazi1349

Grand Blue- genre: comedy

Ray H

Sound! Euphonium - Music/Slice of Life 3 full seasons and a couple movies of glorious music, drama, and teen angst. Coming of age + tribulations + perseverance + team work = the most underrated anime.

Dan Cervantes

Made In Abyss (adventure/horror) maybe the best ost in all of anime

Pedro Lobo

The Ramparts of Ice [Romance/Drama] to replace Chunibyo

Pedro Lobo

Re:Zero S4 [Pain/Suffering] to replace Mushoku Tensei

ivelh0-0

The World God Only Knows (genre: romance/comedy/harem)

Bailey Badcock

Also season 2 of ramparts will be just like polar opposites in the sense that it airs next season and will be the final season. Meaning that by the time they get to it they can watch the whole thing start to finish.

HBelmont67

Genre: Fantasy Shonen (also DEFINITELY watch the English dub)

HBelmont67

Wait, they HAVEN'T??

Pedro Lobo

Grand Blue [Comedy/Diving] To replace Steins Gate

Dan Cervantes

Code Geass (sci-fi/strategy/drama)

Richard Rear

To your eternity. Pain.loss,

Dan Cervantes

Fate/stay series (fantasy) specifically so that you can get to fate/strange fake

Glitchy88

Don't Toy with Me, Miss Nagatoro Genre: Comedy/romance

Dan Cervantes

No Game / No Life (isekai/comedy/strategy)

Pukar Sedai

Don't Toy With Me, Miss Nagatoro is so good. Its romcom

SirSkyRage

also has genuinely the best soundtrack out of any anime (in my humble opinion) kevin penkin my goat

eyalmazuz

I know the chances are low But, Blue Period is an amazing anime, I'm sure you will love it. The genres/themes are "coming of age" and "drawing", so it'll remind you of dangers in my hearts a bit.

eyalmazuz

Grand blue is also amazing, I would highly recommend. It's a pure comedy show

Weaboo Trash

Umamusume: Cinderella Grey - Sports anime (you don’t need to know anything about the source material)

Ryuuji Gremory

Akatsuki no Yona; Fantasy, Adventure, Romans, Shojo

Ryuuji Gremory

Well since the original skips a volume and the remake actually has a sequel in 2027 on the horizon.

Lukasz B

Action, martial art, school

RavenFighter91

Digimon ( season 1 from 1999) it's one of the original isekais so would replace Jobless Reincarnation

Mkj9u

Fruits Basket Genre: Romance

Teedo

Blue box! Romance, top tier anime. I’ve been pushing for this one forever

Kosse K

'Campfire cooking in another world' for something light and funny

Cara & Prez

Never looked into it properly, any experience with using it/being in one?

TripMcDub

Sentenced To Be A Hero - Fantasy. Replacing Mushoku

TripMcDub

Ramparts of Ice - Drama/Romance. Replacing chunibyo (as youve probably already heard made by the same author of Polar Opposites)

Doccyy

Madoka Magica - dark fantasy

Yandiel Lopez

Darling In the Franxx it is, science fiction, mecha, romance, and drama. It is one of my favorite Romances and the main Girl almost everyone knows or at least recognizes her Zero Two.

SciTails

This, but only if we're talking about the remake (Spice and Wolf: Merchant Meets the Wise Wolf). That way, they are more likely to also watch S2. Also, this is a rare one they should watch in English, although I don't know if they've ever done that for a show.

Yandiel Lopez

Blue Box Is the best Romance of all time it motivated me to get back into sports and since the creator is a girl is has a more realistic romance (Like how the girls would actually react and not straight out of a dream fantasy). Its a Sports and Romance show.

Icy_WIllow

Samurai champloo (action/adeventure)

crack

Well you guys can have a paid members chat or a free chat and most people just go in there to chit chat about shows and movies you can also have specific chats like show recommendations or spoiler talk stuff like that

John Ng

Danmachi. How to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon (fantasy/magic)

FriedRice

Witch Hat Atelier (Fantasy)

BS41

Journal with witch - [slice of life, drama]

BS41

Read the entire light novel series. One of my favorites. And another season of the remake is coming soon.

Dillon leeming

Berserk 97, classic senien. Massively influential. Vinland saga is one of them. Not perfect but best anime version

Jason Sandoval

Wotakoi. Replacing chunibyu. Genre: romance, comedy

BS41

Umamusume cinderella gray - [sports, drama]

Maruko87

My Senpai Is Annoying

Maruko87

genre is romcom

Pentre

Hinamatsuri, it's a comedy, pretty lighthearted but with emotional moments that make you love the characters

Maruko87

I don't know anyone that has ever reacted to that, would be really interesting :)

Fwddd

The Klutzy Class Monitor and the Girl with the Short Skirt, nice and funny little over the top romance.

Joshua tobar

Shikimori’s not just a cutie - romcom / slice of life

BS41

Though I am an inept villainess - [drama, fantasy, historical period style similar feel as apothecary diaries.]

Mr.Comfy

It should be noted this one is ALOT slower than most romance anime out there. Its still full of heart and good.

momin abdullah

The eminence in shadow(fantasy/action/comedy)

BS41

Great show, been over a decade since I watched it.

BS41

Lord of Mysteries- [drama, fantasy, action. Could replace steins gate.]

KeanuofRivia

Plastic Memories, genre is romcom, replacing Chunnibyo

Amphyprion

Echoing a lot of other comments -> Made in Abyss [Adventure, Fantasy, Mystery]

Lucas Miño

Secrets of the silent witch [fantasy, comedy], replaces mushoku

Lucas Miño

This is not a rom com xd

Yoann Bigor

The apothecary dairies is returning soon ( October)

kirimaru

Full Metal Panic! (Action/Comedy/Sci-Fi — Chunibyo replacement)

Dan Cervantes

Bungo Stray Dogs (action/comedy)

Olivia

Fruits basket it’s a romance

JP

Rezero

Enrique 99

Uma musume cinderella grey- spokon

Inc

Ramparts of ice (romance) its made by the same author as polar opposites

Kapitány Zoltán

Paripi Koumei (it's a hidden gem music anime with some reverse isekai elements)

BS41

English dub is well done. It's also a show that has not been reacted to much by others. I try to suggest shows that are on the lower end for number of reactions. Get kind of tired seeing everyone react to the same shows.

DetectiveYuki

Shoushimin Series (Mystery slice of life)

max_g

Love Unseen Beneath the Clear Night Sky. different than usual rom coms

max_g

damn wasn't expecting to see this

KeanuofRivia

Admittedly its been awhile since ive seen it so I wasnt entirely sure how to categorize it. I thought I remember some funny moments tho. What's your suggestion on genre?

BS41

Insomniacs after school - [romance]

Astriea

Witch Hat Atelier - Fantasy/Magic/Adventure

LukeHorde

Ramparts of Ice - Romance genre. Perfect time to start watching it since it is by the same mangaka as Polar Opposites, and S2 is about to start airing once Polar Opposites ends.

Jwrld

Evangelion

Bigmeadow

I think following up [Steins Gate] with Lord of Mysteries would perfect tone wise.

Blizzard

Agents of the Four Seasons

Sky-Spider05

In the Clear Moonlit Dusk High school Romance/Romance/Shojo

Darkwing Duck

That would be amazing, doubt it'll have a chance unfortunately

c__curly

A Place Further Than The Universe - Slice of life/drama

Dakhin

KonoSuba: An Explosion on This Wonderful World! Megumin spinoff to complete konosuba before season 4 in 2027

GrimFire

Witch hat atelier genre fantasy

LashedTeacher

Fairytail - adventure - large number of episodes could replace Mushoku

gokoproductions

As the greatest human within the comments section, my like counts don't matter. However, after observing some of these peasants put in their requests, I felt the need to pick the best suggestions out of them. -Ramparts of Ice (romance/drama) -Blue box (romance/sports/drama) -Made in Abyss (fantasy/trauma) -Grand blue (comedy)

gokoproductions

rip I didn't follow the rules. however, I'm above the rules. I'm him.

Maximus3537

Genre: Adventure / Romance. Could replace: mushoku The original was an all-time classic, but you might as well experience the remake since it is vastly improved visually (and will be ongoing and covering more material over next few years).

Tepoz00

Blue Box, romance/sport

Panda

A sign of affection, romance. ITS BEEN SO LONG

Bastian OR

Sh*t, my suggestion didn't make it but I still gotta like because of the confidence. Oh well, Ramparts and MiA are good stuff.

Volele

Kimi ni Todoke (From me to you) Absolutely goated romance that is a little older (2010 era) so rarely makes it into polls. Would kill to see a react channel give it a watch. Its top 3 in my book.

Khior

Fruits basket!!

Remington Odell

I second this! Witch Hat [fantasy/drama].

c__curly

Ahh yes a fellow person of culture 🤌🏼

Justin Ramos

I'm going to throw in Blue Box for Romance. Especially since season 2 is about to come out in October.

Ltnorm

Space Battleship Yamato 2199 "Spacebattles, military science fiction and space opera"

gelato

Tower of God, action / adventure

Keishi

Smoking Behind the Supermarket with You [Replaces: Chunibyo]

Ryan Vybz

Kuroko's basketball it's a sport like Haikyuu pleaseeee

Simon B

Grand Blue - Comedy / Romcom

GhostPhil

On Youtube a Channel called "The Heck" are watching it at the moment, they recently started with season 2. But yeah sadly it's from a time, where reactions wasn't really a thing. But it would actually be a show that would make for some great reactions. Same with Jormungand.

Charcoal

Shangri-la Frontier has always a want to see reactions too. Genre is action/shonen based in a video game. It’s SAO but with more focus on the actual game

Mr Evans

Lord of Mysteries - mystery, fantasy, action. I'd say replaces mushoku pretty well.

Raphael Geissler

sword art online / fantasy / action/ romance (replacing mushoku)

Nakirium

MADOKA MAGICA!!!! (Psychological/Drama) The new movie is finally coming out soon for english and I'd LOVE for you guys to be caught up by the time it's streamable!!!! Fun Fact: it's also THE anime that popularized the "3-episode rule" that so many people are familiar with today. (it wasnt the origin of the 3-episode rule, but it IS the biggest anime to use it)

Norbert

Kenichi: The Mightiest Disciple (Shonen/ Martial arts) i really recommend english dub

ScorpioAres

Orb: on the movements of the earth A mix of science, history and philosophy.

Hatoma

Yeah, you should definitely watch Re:Zero season 4. So far, it's the best, and you will love it for sure.

Tyler Lucas

The ancient magus’ bride [fantasy, with mystery and romance]

細流

I completely agree with that! I recently watched the newly released movie (I live in Japan), and while there were a few parts that left a bit to be desired, I still absolutely loved it. As always, after replaying the story in my head over and over to fully grasp it, I found myself falling in love with this series all over again.

Nicotele

Don't Toy with me Nagatoro [Chunibyo]

Nicotele

Yes! Nagatoro fantastic one for a reaction!

Nicotele

Yes Nagatoro!!! Awesome for a reaction!!

J

since everyones mentioning romance anime im gonna recommend my second favorite after chunibyo and arguably one of the best romances, oregairu aka my teen romantic comedy aka snafu, im sure you have heard of it and the only thing i can warn yall about is its a dialogue heavy show with very complex dialogue and emotions, you might not understand everything they say unless you dive into it but thats okay.

David Rosen

Nichijou - My Ordinary Life - slice of life

muffin

日本からこんにちは! Hi from Japan! Based on the anime you’ve watched so far, I personally recommend **Saekano: How to Raise a Boring Girlfriend** [Romcom]! Also, **Clannad / Clannad After Story**, which was requested by someone else, is a series I really want you guys to watch at least once in your lives. I’m sure it will have a lasting impact on you!

Sky-Spider05

Watari-kun's ****** Is About to Collapse Romance, Comedy, Drama, Slice of life, Seinen

HBelmont67

That would be SUPER fun 😆

Kosse K

For something outside of the norm 'Gundam Witch from Mercury'. Mecha with a mix of drama and a standalone series as far as gundam. Maybe replacing mushoku but doesnt necessarily line up with any of the three.

Kosse K

Yes I just outed myself as a gundam person haha

Arbiter

The Ancient Magus' Bride (slice of life/romance)

LunarEntity

Umamusume (sports anime)

Andrew Diseker

Love After World Domination, rom-com satire of “Power Rangers” type shows, the couple is cute and funny and the rom-com “conflicts” are over the top!

Jlile

Love Beneath The Clear Night Sky Romance

Mad Man Moon

Yes this would be a great one for them to watch too!

MikeyD

Sentenced to be a hero and Gachiakuta!!

MikeyD

Also Clevatess and Daemons of the Shadow Realm!

David Ozug

Hyouka - a show from 2012 and one of my all time favorites. High school setting with mystery as the main genre. Great animation and great characters!

Rey

Nichijou - My Ordinary Life - genre: Comedy

Feko

Smoking Behind The Supermarket With You . Genre: Adult Rom-Com, Age-Gap, Mature, Slice-of-Adult-Life

Al-Dente123

Ramparts of Ice - Romance

Al-Dente123

That Time I Was Reincarnated as a Slime (Mushoku replacement)

Al-Dente123

Gals can’t be kind to an otaku - romance

Barney Schneider

One of the most underrated shows!!! Sooo good

Keve131

his and her circumstances! comedy romance drama

Luka Kovačević

"Ascendance of a bookworm" Genre would be Isekai, fantasy, adventure. It would be a good anime to replace Mushoku tensei. It's one of my favourites and it's also been airing a new season right now that's almost finished. I hope you give it a try.

ValeMare

TONIKAWA: Over The Moon For You [Romance/Comedy] I went through all the comments and liked a bunch of them, but I couldn’t believe this wasn’t there… I don’t expect to get a lot of likes but at least it’s been mentioned now lol

Aaron Wright

Crest of the Stars (Which then becomes Banner of the Stars). Sci Fi Space Opera with a strong romance plot through out. Older show, but amazing.

Savldj

Golden kamuy Action, comedy (Replaces mushoku)

paris

Skip and Loafer (romcom/slice of life)

mellon 100

Great Pretender. It’s a con-artist heist show — four arcs, each one a different country, each one built like a puzzle where you’re being lied to alongside the characters. Genuinely one of the best-looking shows on Netflix and it’s criminally under-reacted. Great for a poll because every arc has its own payoff, so it never drags.

mellon 100

Vivy: Fluorite Eye’s Song. 13 episodes, original story, and the animation is absurd for a non-adaptation. An AI built to make people happy through song gets told she has 100 years to stop a war between humans and AI. It’s self-contained, it’s paced like a thriller, and the fight scenes go way harder than the premise suggests.

mellon 100

Shadows House if you want a mystery. Faceless nobles served by living dolls in a mansion nobody’s allowed to leave — the whole show is about figuring out what’s actually going on there. 13 episodes, very atmospheric, and reacting to it is fun because the audience is working it out at the same pace you are. Fair warning: season 1 answers some of it, not all of it — there’s a season 2.

Itz A Dolphin

Don't Toy with me, Miss Nagatoro, Romcom, lets make it happen!

Mooch

I would love to see you guys react to Clannad!

EllaH

Agents of the four seasons - romance, trauma

Shadow Jacker

dont toy with me nagatoro romcom FTW

Rotumn

Lots of good choices. I want to throw out Fruit basket 2019 the 3 season show. I read the Manga and felt the anime dealt with a lot of the story even minor side character stories. I know Prez likes the other members of the cast having a part in the story and their own stuff. It is a romance with a little of the supernatural but only a little. This was a great show and think it has elements you both will like.

hellog

Omg yes wind breaker!!!!

Levi Montgomery

Sign of affection would be amazing (romance,adult cast)

Vania

Witch Hat Atelier

Undeath Ghost

Sound! Euphonium (Also called Hibike! Euphonium). (Patreon Only, music/drama)

Undeath Ghost

I'm In Love with the Villainess (Comedy, Romcom)

Undeath Ghost

Ascendance of a Bookworm (Isekai)

Undeath Ghost

Umamusume: Pretty Derby (Sports, Drama)

Undeath Ghost

Tonikawa: Over The Moon for You (Romcom)

Undeath Ghost

Just keep voting for it. Komi was the 2nd best show on the last romcom poll. If you keep it up itll happen eventually. I've been waiting a year+ for Sound! Euphonium to even make it onto a poll... and it FINALLY DID

Undeath Ghost

Me to brother, me too.... AND IT MADE IT ONTO A POLL FINALLY SO VOOOTE FOR IIIT

paris

Tada Never Falls in Love (romcom)

Sergey (Horn)

Eden of the East - detective (or mystery?) This series is vaguely reminiscent of Death Note and Code Geass

KOU

Wotakoi! 🙌🏻💕 Genre: romance comedy (chuunibyou replacement)

KOU

Ore monogatari (my love story) Genre: romance comedy (chuunibyou replacement)

KOU

Kono oto tomare sounds of life Genre: music, drama

swag ramen

Please continue rezero

Netsureim114

Welcome to Demon School Iruma-kun (comedy, shounen, isekai)

Netsureim114

To aru series (a certain magical index, a certain scientific railgun, a certain scientific accelerator) (replacing steins gate)

LateDp

Love Unseen beneath the clear night sky

Jarnomansfield

For sure!! I keep voting for them anytime they show up.

Aayan A

Tune into the midnight heart!! its a banger and as someone whos caught up with the manga its peak genre: romance, mystery

Jeffrey Tate

Rock is a Lady's Modesty. Music, Comedy, SOL.

Sky-Spider05

Tune In to the Midnight Heart Romance, Comedy, Shonen,school, Harem, Showbiz

snirek43

Rezero season 4, best season yet by far

Mr_Blonde

Marriage Toxin was a real pleasant surprise from this past Spring for me and it got renewed for a 2nd season. The animation and VA work is really top notch. Genre: RomCom Battle Shonen? It's hard to explain lol

Blue67

Every anime reactor is dealing with copyright strikes and you want them to react to one of, if not the most copyright struck animes of all time? Not if they value their channel.

s

Witch Hat Atelier (fantasy)

hellog

Witch Hat Atelier [Mushoko Tensei/fantasy]

hellog

Ramparts of Ice [Chunibyo] !!! (Could also replace You and I are Polar Opposites bc its the same author and thats ending soon! Genre: romance/slice of life)

hellog

Haha I'd say..the genre is more sports/slice of life??? loll. with the sports being fighting LOL

hellog (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-19 15:00 Wind Breaker [slice of life/sports/found family]
2026-09-15 20:26 Wind Breaker [slice of life/sports/found family] Also wind breaker is animated by Cloverworks! Who’s done my dress up darling and fragrant flower!

Wind Breaker [slice of life/sports/found family] Also wind breaker is animated by Cloverworks! Who’s done my dress up darling and fragrant flower!

deadSpawn

i want to watch your reaction after end of chunibyo series about this anime, welcome to the ballroom genre - sport, drama this anime have 2 seasons and finished

can can

kill la kill [genre: Action, Comedy, Fantasy] Change of pace, its heavy on satire and exaggerating anime tropes. Also probably fastest paced anime youll watch.

AlgoBienMX

Angel Beats [drama, fantasy, supernatural, action, and comedy]

Tyler Smith

I think you’d love Vinland Saga [Action, Adventure, Drama]

Gandy[Fated]

we really need a blue box reaction its been too long

Spencer

Eminence in shadow - isekai,comedy,fantasy Replacing mushoku

Jacob

My happy marriage (Romance, Supernatural)

darth tig

to be hero X (action, Fantasy)

wease

Aoashi - sports ( season 2 coming out right now)