Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

🚨NEW SHOW POLL🚨 (Mushoku Replacement)

  • Witch Hat Atelier 331
  • That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime* (Prez has seen S1 & 2 FULLY with some S3) 169
  • Wistoria: Wand and Sword 119
  • Eminence in Shadow* (Prez has seen in 2024) 143
  • Grand Blue Dreaming* (Prez has seen S1) 149
  • Delicious In Dungeon 160
  • Daemons of the Shadow Realm 39
  • 2026-10-11
  • 1110 votes
{'title': '🚨NEW SHOW POLL🚨 (Mushoku Replacement)', 'choices': [{'text': 'Witch Hat Atelier', 'votes': 331}, {'text': 'That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime* (Prez has seen S1 & 2 FULLY with some S3)', 'votes': 169}, {'text': 'Wistoria: Wand and Sword', 'votes': 119}, {'text': 'Eminence in Shadow* (Prez has seen in 2024)', 'votes': 143}, {'text': 'Grand Blue Dreaming* (Prez has seen S1)', 'votes': 149}, {'text': 'Delicious In Dungeon ', 'votes': 160}, {'text': 'Daemons of the Shadow Realm', 'votes': 39}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 11, 15, 21, 51, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1110}

Content

New show time! As this is the Mushoku replacement (we miss it already) that means all show types are allowed, so we tried mixing in different things, and it was hard deciding what will follow up after those 3 seasons of peak😭Just a reminder romance shows have their own poll which will happen AFTER Chunibyo is finished (about a week or so)

Comments

PyraStorm

Grand Blue is peak

Kurri

EMINENCE MENTIONED HOLY PEAK!?!?!1

Nkyoma

Grand blue!!! You will die from laughing

HarshMellow786

These are all shows I would love them to watch but it's so hard to choose

Sk dragon

witch hat is absolutely gorgeous

VagaBocchi

I know witch hat is going to take it, but i had to give my vote for Wistoria, my fav Dan Machi spinoff 🥲

cash money

Black Lagoon in Eng Dub

Aayan A

Eminence is shadow would be so funny

Razzafe

Grand blue or slime

DocGreen

Fate zero if you haven't seen. It's modern dark fantasy that is really good with lore that is 20 miles wide and 40 miles deep.

Capt'n Ren

Would love to see Cara watch Eminence but really want them to enjoy Witch Hat first since it's a single season.

Squid112

Witch Hat Atelier is amazing. Delicious in Dungeon is a close second!

HBelmont67 (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-13 01:00 Delicious in Dungeon is SOOOO funny. Also, it's usually limped together with Witch Hat Atelier and Frieren as the "Fantasy Anime Trinity." ✨
2026-10-11 20:17 Delicious in Dungeon is SOOOO funny. Also, it's usually lumped together with Witch Hat Atelier and Frieren as the "Fantasy Anime Trinity." ✨

Delicious in Dungeon is SOOOO funny. Also, it's usually lumped together with Witch Hat Atelier and Frieren as the "Fantasy Anime Trinity." ✨

Saaaamy.W

Witch hat is amazing, but dang I was hoping for a new sports anime🥲 “Ace of The Diamond” is peak (better than Haikyuu in my opinion) and “Ao Ashi” isn’t better but a contender for sure.

Sergey (Horn)

Prez has already seen it (on TGL Reacts channel)

Clo

I will always vote this because of the diving episodes 🤣

snflwr

Hardest I’ve laughed for any show

‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎ ‎ ‎‎

Delicious in Dungeon I honestly think that would a an amazing show to watch. Reincarnated as a Slime is a good show but half of season 2 is very VERY poltical it can be boring at times but it get's better later on

Cara & Prez

We HEAVILY considered Ao Ashi it was the last show to miss the cut, but we're keeping it on our list for the future

GTB

I'm up for Delicious in Dungeon, Witch Hat Atelier, or maybe Tsugai. I've dropped the others. - Witch Hat Atelier => Movie-quality animation (outstanding for a series). As a manga reader, the story is great but takes a little while to show that it’s a seinen series and reveal the real stakes. - Delicious in Dungeon (the highest-rated on the list) => One of the best in modern fantasy. Original and unique, with amazing world-building and plenty of humor, and the anime has top-tier animation/OST. Plus, the story will be finished in 2 seasons. - Tsugai => Not as good as the other 2, but I enjoyed watching Season 1. Tengoku Daimakyou (Heavenly Delusion) definitely should be on your list ;).

Nicotele

Witch hat is great, BUT I think would be better after season 2 comes out. For that reason my vote goes for Wistoria. Still seems witch hat will win and its only 12 episodes so also cool something that is not as long.

Nicotele

Is very good, but the best sports anime is Hajime no Ippo and that would be a fantastic reaction.

Nicotele

Consider Hajime no Ippo as sports anime. Absolute best sports anime out there. Is on a league of its own I think.

TheRealJayron

Are we deadass not picking slime guys..... PLEASE I BEGGG SLIME TIMEEEEEE

TheRealJayron

Surely people who know peak will come and vote for Slime OR Eminence in shadow 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

Eli Gamarra

Wistoria is its own series. It’s not a Danmachi spinoff

Saaaamy.W

Good to know it’s in the pipeline, thanks🙏

VagaBocchi

They are written by the same person and have the shared characters/locations so saying Spin off is not far off? Fair to say it exists in an alternate reality of the same world or temproally forward or backward

Vitero27

I would prefer an anime that you both are reacting to for the first time (I enjoy those reactions more) but this is a pretty solid list regardless.

Itz A Dolphin

Wisteria is pretty good, highly recommend

Alkampus

Rent a girlfriend robbed 💔

Daniel Pitts

I'm surprised Daemons of the Shadow Realm isn't getting much love. It is better than the title suggests. Anyway, Witch Hat and Slime 3 are both great choices too.

Savingstumps

This is a hard one, all of them are great. Wistoria season one was really good, season 2 just takes off. Danmachii (same author) is really good too. Ended up voting for Grand Blue. I think Cara would really laugh at that one.

KnowHope

Honestly, I love all of these but it'd be cooler to see something both of you haven't seen before. Regardless, of my preference, I'm still tuning in on whichever wins.

Kels

Should do witch hat and then Delicious in Dungeon then you guys have done what is considered the fantasy anime trinity together with Frieren. You guys will love both of these.

Melhk031103

eminence and grand blue both peak comedy. Wistoia genuine slop dont understand why people like it, but to each their own i guess.

eyalmazuz

Ao Ashi is GOATed!!! it was one of the few anime that made me want to continue right away with the manga, and it was even before s1 finished airing. But the story overall is really really good. Ao Ashi is slow burn with big payoff IMO. it does get compared to Bluelock a lot (for better or worse), so need to remember that they are difference in their style. I would highly recommend it!

Gandy[Fated]

Yh but I’m pretty sure it’s in the same world

Gandy[Fated]

We really need a tomodachi game reaction idk how y’all haven’t done that yet. And my whole life’s purpose would be fulfilled if you do Tokyo revengers

Eli Gamarra

Not in same world. The only spinoff of Danmachi is Sword Oratoria, which they dropped the ball on for the anime, but the novels are amazing. To date, there’s nothing indicating that they are part of the same universe, or connected in any way

VagaBocchi

Um like I stated previously, they have some of same characters in design and name. And its created by the same person. Plus the magia Vander tower tower is literally identical to the dungeon tower

Undeath Ghost

I look forward to them being equally mad at the show for the reasons I'm mad at it.

gruntmaster1

Damn, can't believe we're missing out on Grand Blue.

Pukar Sedai

Please watch Slime. Its so fking good