Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This week, we finally get around to reviewing the perpetually requested 1992 coming of age debacle, The Buttercream Gang. And mostly talk about how naughty the title sounds.

Comments

Matt

Watched it yesterday and holy shit is it creepy in that “Mormons are trying really hard to not understand normal human relations and as a result there’s a truly disturbing amount of unspoken sexual shit going on in this anti-city cult propaganda thing”.

Michael S

So excited to see this come up. Found a copy on VHS in my old closet at my mom’s house when cleaning it a few years ago. Holy crap.

Danica

I read that at least three times as The Buttcream Gang before my brain finally registered the extra “er”… I’m not sure if it’s better or worse now lmao

General Contact Unit Problem Child

You know the kid who played Pete in this went on to have something of a descent mainstream acting career. That actually makes me kind of happy because I get the impression he really was trying with the material he was given here.

Jessica Eastvold

Eli!! I had just taken a sip when that intro skit came up and the “ I can see her bone!! Or DNA is everywhere! We gotta burn the house down! Elden you gotta eat her!” Every joke better than the last I nearly choked on Mountain Dew! 😂😂😂

Matt

He looked like a teenage William Fichtner, so there’s also that.

Peter Kyrouac

I have been waiting too. Growing up as a kid in a non-denominational Christian household in the 90s, we had this VHS tape at home. Some of my friends had it too. By the time we got to high school, this was our go-to movie to put on and roast.

Atomic Squirrel

There’s an -er? Wait, there’s an -er! Now my brain is broken.

Matt

Yeah, like a lot. That’s a big downgrade.

Matt

Hi Eli

Raffael Passero

“The creamy loads of white frothy cream around my hands and face and mouth with creamy cream gang!” Eli, you are a prince

Markus Nävergård

This reminds of the times i´ve seen like headlines of " heart warming story of 12 year old selling his toys to buy medicine for his sick little sister" that is not a heartwarming story. it is a horror story, but i guess the " can doo,bootstrap,gumption" mentality is so bred in to America that it has to be presented that way because any other way to see it is to go " this is WRONG!"

Adrian Black

I can literally give you any information about being a sweaty ass kid/adult that you need. My sweat sweats

Morris Salisbury

As an American, I absolutely despise those stories. The same with a 97 year old lady still working at Walmart because she can’t afford to retire. Those stories show what an abject failure our society is.

Markus Nävergård

Gumption!grit! bootstraps! the myth of " i am a selfmade man, i had nothing, two empty hands"

Laura Lusby

I fell asleep while listening to this and had one hell of a dream about baseball and Noah’s actual given name.

Golden

So who was the LEAST likely to teach hanky code? Marsh? Heath?

AlteraGoodCivilization

Can we start an official petition that Noah, Eli, and Heath have to refer to themselves as The Buttercream Gang from here on out?

KimbaKat

Cara saying this is boring was my spirit animal. Can we please enter the fall with some more fun movies or commentaries. I don't want to be a Negative Nancy but this year has been an overall dud. I know you guys can do better, it just feels like whoever is setting the schedule this year is not doing quality control and due diligence, because almost every episode this year is a preamble about how sorry the movie/documentary this week is boring. You are right the movie is boring congratulations. It doesn't make a good episode though. The bonus episodes have been shit too which makes it more unjustifiable. You have all of secular media to go through and someone chooses the most skip worthy and uninteresting shit come on.

Taru Tikkanen

Glad that Cara, too, noticed the similarities between the ”bad kid”, and Carmy from The Bear.

Maggie

OMG THIS IS THE ONE IVE BEEN WAITING FOR!!!!!

Tim Durning

I grew up outside Philadelphia. Went to Catholic school for 12 years. They showed us this movie in the library when I was in 1st grade. The announcement of this movie sent me into a time tunnel of memory that I had never experienced so I’m so excited to revisit this movie that has stuck in my memory for 20+ years!

LisaLisa

I love when Cara is a guest! Awesome episode, as always!

I Fight Horny Patron Names

Spaghetti fried it ketchup is awesome, try napolitin spaghetti! Its a Japanese dish made by a chef who wanted to make a uniquely Japanese dish using the rations available to American soldiers on a nearby base.

Laura Lusby

Also I’m watching this again while awake. I went to high school in the 90s in a smallish town in Texas that had a “Pioneer Days” and the baseball fields were in “Old Settlers Park” and I used to call the little league baseball games with my dad and this movie just reminded me that Baptists in Texas and Mormons in Utah are super duper not that different.

Anna Sparks

I don’t know what’s worse, the fact that I didn’t realize (at the time) that this was a heavily religious themed movie, or the fact that I’ve seen this movie TWICE in SCHOOL

Kate Gardner

There is, but I don't think it has the same actors. So, it's one of those.

Kate Gardner

I never requested it, but I've been dying for you to do this movie. I just knew it would come up eventually. By the way, don't worry about the sewage pipe leaking into the swimming hole. Nobody in that town has an anus or a bladder. They're like Ken dolls down there.

Kate Gardner

At a community college I went to, an office worker was celebrating their 80th (or somewhere around there) birthday. I was like, "Jesus, I hope they just like working here."

Mr. Dougson

My family owned this on VHS. Noted on the credits today: 'Screenplay is based upon a concept by FORREST S. BAKER & BRUCE NEIBAUR.' Kitsch simplistic Mormon testimony building fantasy wet buttercream dream.

Exmo Ang

My grandma had a subscription to this movie company. She got new movies from them all the time.

Mitch Bain

"The Churny Butter Cummers" damn near killed me

Parlan Stuart

33:10 , thanks, Eli, for saying what we were all thinking! 😀

Mara

They showed us this at my public high school years ago. Them calling everything treats is burned in my mind

Joseph Michell

Cara may live in LA but I grew up there before all these picking up kids rules I went to Eagle Rock by Occidental and it used to be like than seen in dazed and confused where the teacher is telling the kids about Nam. I went King middle school in Silver lake man we would dodge traffic to get food from across the street then back in time for bus. Then our bus drop off was an Arco on the corner of fig and pass Robles. This kid Thomas has a whole side walk built for him by elementary school because there wasn't one and he got hit walking home. He lived only broke his arm. I got put in Ambulance in front of the school but that was soccer related and not anything to do with us roaming the North East Los Angeles and the greater metro area.

Zach Van Stanley

It also sucks for all of the people who weren’t able to get those stories. For every person who gets a “feel good” story, how many people are there without one? How many people put on a go fund me for their younger sibling and couldn’t raise the money because they don’t know anyone with money?

Zach Van Stanley

I also feel the same way about “inspirational” overcoming adversity stories, especially when they involve disability. Usually it’s just some generationally rich person who doesn’t understand that not everyone can afford expensive treatments.

AK

It also sounds a bit like Spaghetti Al’Assassina

Uriah Jackson

I can't say for spaghetti with catsup, but I did have a friend who told me about how her mother used to make pizza with sauce made from catsup and mayo. I tried it once and it wasn't awful.

Erika Calabretta

I was so excited for this! We had them on VHS, and it was pretty much the only thing my parents said we could watch without supervision

Party Cat

I grew up with this movie. We owned it on VHS. My favorite thing is when you watch movies i was tortured with as a child!! 😁

Jeffrey Cowell

I had never heard of this movie until now, but after listening to them describe the Buttercream Gang, I wonder if The Mystery Team was also referencing this movie.

Austin Hawks

Cara, the sweat looks like that cause an adult spritz them with water for the scene

Echo Cian

Cara yelling at Eli only to realize she wrote the exact same joke might be one of the top GAM moments.

Morris Salisbury

When I visited Costa Rica there is an ice cream sandwich type thing with the brand name of Treats or something. I still think of them to this day…