Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

This week, Heath finally gets his wish, and we spend an episode talking about a genre-defining masterpiece instead of a bad movie.

Comments

Nolan B.

What an awesome idea! I can’t wait to hear all of your thoughts..this was a favorite growing up.

General Contact Unit Problem Child

does this count as a body swap movie? I feel like it was a body swap machine at some point earlier in the script writing process but they decided face transplants were marginally more scientifically plausible

tsukiouji

So glad y'all are doing this fucking MASTERPIECE

Harper Court

I had a part time job when this came out. I was talking to a friend about how dumb the entire premise was when a full timer commented, all shocked that we found it unrealistic, that "Well, they used lasers!" So, that became a phrase that infected my family and friends when something dumb happened. "They should have used a laser!" I honestly would have bought a brain-transplant more.

Markus Nävergård

face off is such a stupid movie. It is not awesome movie it is so dumb. it is like made to psychologically appeal to the male brain

Gmork

It's the platonic ideal of an action movie. All frosting w not a hint of substance. You don't pretend it's art or real life, but sometimes it's fun to watch a little pro wrestling for the phenomenan that it is.

Gmork

Making it more "realistic" would have been worse. This is a silly, over-the-top nonsense romp and it's glorious.

Gmork

If you're not into Face Off, action movies will never be your jam. This is every stupid, silly, aggro, toxically masculine, sugary trope on steroids without a moment wasted trying to be "serious" and it's incredible.

Markus Nävergård

it is the platonic definition of an action movie, that is true.

General Contact Unit Problem Child

I feel like the guys needed a guest who’s not seen the movie before and doesn’t hold it in reverence. …ideally a woman

General Contact Unit Problem Child

The reason virtually no one knows about the face transplant thing is because it’s illegal. Like the removed a man’s face without consent

lesimir

You want Cara to not have fun with THIS? :D

Gmork

Noah is correct in that torture is effective *only* when you can immediately verify the results, eg what is the combo to this briefcase? Beyond that, they'll tell you something (whether they know the truth or not), but there's no immediate incentive to say anything true. At best, it'll generate multiple false leads.

Matt

I never watched this in the ‘90s because my mother would never have allowed it and then I didn’t get around to it until now. Now I know why every 14-year-old boy thought it was the most amazing movie ever made. Watching it for the first time as an adult is like…hoo boy, ah, now I understand a few more things about why everyone else is like that. Also this movie is dumb as shit.

Harper Court

I love silly movies and I can suspend disbelief as much as the next person but this was just a bridge to far for me. Ymmv.

Markus Nävergård

i would have done it. i´d be like my grandpa. " this is dumb. this si so dumb. do not booh nerd me Heath!"

BT Dubs

Yes, YES! A MILLION TIMES, YES!

lesimir

For a while I just sat on the floor in the middle of the room listening and laughing. It's also lovely to hear people, especially these guys, talk about the stupid things they actually like :D

Gmork

"I don't need the bullet wound back anymore." "What the fuck are talking about?" "Oh nevermind. I asked the doctor they killed to give me back -- doesn't matter."

Blue Star Comics

I felt so much joy over the course of that description when I realized it was Fateful Findings.

Taru Tikkanen

They've done "Street Fighter", and "Double Team" as patreon bonus episodes.

Jim Phynn

You guys dropped the ball on one aspect of the big surgery scene by not calling out the fact that they took Travolta’s face off before they took Nic Cage’s face off. Even assuming they didn’t have a large enough surgery team to do them both at the same time, wouldn’t it make more sense to take off Nic Cage’s face first? Because, you know, bad guy…

Victor Field

The joke about John Travolta's son is a bit off, given what happened to his real son.

My dog is more sentient than Claude

They also did Blood Sport, but I'm ok with more It's like how they've done Demolition Man and Stop or My Mom will Shoot, but I still want them to do the Sly Stallone comedic 'masterpiece' Oscar

Chris

I'm partway through the episode and I have absolutely loving hearing the guys nerd out about a movie they all love. I think this is an awesome choice... Once or twice a year lol. I don't know that I like it as much as hearing you guys tear apart back movies though lol

Peter Kyrouac

I cannot wait until next week when Fateful Findings finally gets the GAM treatment. Now I don't have to resign as president of the bank.

Peter Kyrouac

Great question! It's because on The Scathing Atheist Episode 637 released May 15, 2025, Dr. Andrew Shail provides the Professor Farnsworth quote stating: "...having heard Noah, Heath, and Eli call the American Graffiti close either the "Breakfast Club close" or the "Animal House close" on GAM over 400 times now, I'm beginning to suspect that we might have evolved from filthy monkey men." And thus an era ended.

J. Vizzle

Why not "Sec-tacular" instead of the more cumbersome, "Secular-tacular?"

Peter Kyrouac

Me too, my friend. It's a magical day!

Matty B

I think the secular-tacular experiment is a success. A Good-bad movie can be GAM'ed and be entertaining.

Robert Fitzgerald

Morman movie road trip-Diabolic- get Werewolf Ambulance for guest masochists.

Markus Nävergård

in a way, this movie is more realistic than mission impossibles weird holo masks.

Wustite

Since y’all finally did Face Off, does that mean Methgator is a possibility?

Echo Cian

Woman here. When I saw it for the first time a few years ago, it fucking ruled (although I also don't remember most of it by now and can only remember having a good time with the stupidity then)

Sparrow

Its like a conglomeration of all the ideas deemed too stupid for Arnold Schwarzenegger movies.

J. Vizzle

I see (said the blind man as he pissed into the wind). 😁

MC Laugh

Raise your hand if you got 7 minutes in and had to go watch Face/Off 🙋‍♀️

Markus D

I will say that I prefer the That Aged Well Review of Face/Off better because while both hosts found the movie funny, they fully acknowledge that it's stupid and bad.

Rumored Local Cryptid

Y’all made me watch this movie and now I throw up every time I remember that freaky family dragging their greasy fingers down each other’s faces. 😭🤣