Designing Resident Evil (Patreon)
Content
Game design is really complicated. Even before you get to the immensely talented people who work incredibly hard programming, modelling, animating and texturing games, the people who write the story and the dialogue, the musicians who compose the music for the game and the voice actors who bring characters to life, and of course the QA testers who make sure the game isn’t just raw garbage on release day. Even before the monumental and intricate work of everything else that goes into a game, the most basic element, the gameplay, is itself really complicated.
Why is that? Well, I suppose on a very basic level game design is about understanding how people react to things, and what kinds of reactions you want from a player and why, and then figuring out how to get them and every little part of that is a huge question in and of itself. Today I want to ask how Resident Evil makes you afraid on a technical level. Like, how do you make a game that makes people react like this:
https://www.twitch.tv/sophie_frm_mars/clip/CourageousKnottyStapleOMGScoots-FdTR6G5wFskmplB1
If you want to understand game design, Resident Evil is actually a great place to learn.
Resident Evil may, at times, struggle to tell a story in the games that you can follow along with and understand, but it tells a crystal clear story in its design, and today I want to look at that story, to understand the franchise from a different perspective. This is the story of a franchise that threw a lot at the wall and had to sift through everything that stuck, combining and recombining, deconstructing and redesigning until today, when we find ourselves in the midst of the Resident Evil Renaissance. This is a game design story of years of hard work producing a truckload of hits and a fuckton of misses, that still manages to bring everything back around and produce some of the sharpest Triple A games being made today. This is
Everything you love, over again - Designing Resident Evil
Welcome to Resimania, a video essay trilogy about the Resident Evil franchise where I’ve played over 90 hours of zombie video games and people keep giving me money so I keep talking about it.
Like all good stories, our story tonight contains big hunky men, some of them good, some bad, large rocket-propelled grenades, and at least one hypothetically cute dog. In this episode of Resimania we need to expand our scope a little bit, but not to look at all the rest of the games or the multimedia franchise - rather we need to think about the extraneous attempts, the discarded projects, the content that hit the cutting room floor. Your selfies are hot and your posts are bangers, congrats sweetie. But now show me drafts.
Video games, of course, were invented by Satan to destabilise society by convincing teens to smoke estrogen and touch butts, and as such the industry has always been the domain of evil. Where was I going with this bit? Eh. Capcom were reportedly on the brink of bankruptcy when Resident Evil 1 was being developed, which is why the team behind Resident Evil started small.
In fact, when Shinji Mikami was first tasked with the Sweet Home remake that would become Biohazard, the game we call Resident Evil, he was the entire team. The game was entirely his vision, at least while Capcom added more staff to his team and he trained them up for the project. Sound designer Hideaki Utsumi said in interviews that he used the voices of the staff for the moans of the zombies in early games - you can actually hear him as some of the zombies in Resident Evil 2, and even Shinji Mikami voices some of the zombies of the orignal.
Resident Evil 1 was first imagined as much bigger in scale with whole entire extra mansions that were cut as the vision ran headlong into the various limits of budget, team size and the memory capacity of the PS1. Like I said, the company was nearly bankrupt, something that Capcom has only nearly been one other time, at least according to popular speculation after, uh,
Capcom is a big company with lots of different franchises but the story of Resident Evil can be kept close to a surprisingly small crew, and lots of factors can be attributed to why Resident Evil 5 and Resident Evil 6 are like that but one really simple thing we can point to is that they were literally made by different people. Ever since RE5, Capcom has been swapping out people in the team between each game, which has proven more effective in recent years as they released 4 of the best Resi games ever made.
Yes, a lot of this video is going to be fawning over how absurdly good 7 & 8 and the recent remakes of 2 & 3 are, and I make no apology for that. They whip. They rock. They fuck. It’s worth spending a long time talking about how good they are. The Resident Evil Remakes are hot girl shit and I will prove it.
But this is also going to be a technical breakdown, so for this episode welcome to my game design laboratory! We’re doing science! My game design laboratory may look like the other side of my living room, but trust me… science!
To draw us into the world of game design, I want to ask a question: is a scary moment part of the plot? Undeniably it’s important to your experience of a story, but is it a part of the story?
Let’s start with an illuminating example. In Resident Evil 2 Remake, the interrogation room of the police station contains a two-way mirror. In Leon’s playthrough the mirror has already been smashed, but in Claire’s playthrough when you go into the interrogation room it hasn’t yet, and then of course, it does - a licker explodes out of the mirror and tries to do whatever that tongue do.
With the game environment changing in the two playthroughs based on something that happens in one of them, it would feel silly to say that that licker encounter here is not part of the plot of the game.
Now we’re starting to think a bit about how Resident Evil really works. Lots of modern games work on making their enemy AI cleverer and balance the challenge for the player almost mathematically, programmatically spawning in enemies - not so in Resident Evil, not even in the most recent games or the remakes. Every enemy is placed carefully, lovingly, and there are a finite number of them. You could give names to every zombie in Racoon City and I would be disappointed if I found out the developers hadn’t done that. Using our haunted house analogy from last time, this is no surprise - every fright and scare has a lot of thought put into it.
So let’s go on: Is Mr. X attacking you in the library plot? Is it canonically something that happens in the story of the game? It isn’t a cutscene, but in basically every playthrough I’ve ever seen, the part where you have to move the library shelves across is under immense pressure because Mr. X is coming to get you very soon right in that moment with only seconds to spare. That’s a designed tension in the game, it’s clearly been planned to happen like this every time, even though in the moment how close Mr. X is, is incredibly variable depending on your strategy. It doesn’t have to happen but the fact it almost always will is indicative of the level of sharp and insightful game design at play in the remakes.
Resident Evil gameplay typically incorporates survival horror, combat and puzzles, but when you play a Resident Evil game over and over, the finite and carefully designed enemy encounters start to feel like their own constantly evolving puzzle, and you come to know the solutions so well that specific fights become quasi plot points in the game, and in a sense they are. Somebody planned each and every encounter with every ghoul and goblin in the series. In Resident Evil 2 this is especially apparent, where each encounter with a licker is extremely tense and memorable. They even have their own musical theme!
If you’re familiar with my channel, you know I usually won’t shut about all these whacky ideas I have like how we maybe shouldn’t set fire to the planet, how we should share the fruits of society between all its inhabitants, how maybe cops shouldn’t be allowed to just murder people, but this is the game design episode. The other episode in the series will be about the ideology of Resident Evil, so I'm straining as hard as I can not to bring up politics in this one.
CIA Femboy, you pretend to be apolitical, how do you do it?
Capitalism is the only economic system that supports cat boys
Great.
Let's talk about world design.
Part 1: Raccoon City
Let’s start by talking about the setting. It’s good to think about the settings of Resident Evil games because in a very literal sense game design is tied to the worlds that the games are set in, but for Resident Evil this is even more true than in other franchises.
The original Resident Evil came out in 1996. In 1996, games looked like this:
And yet somehow, in 1996, Resident Evil looked like THIS
Resident Evil was able to look like this through a little visual trickery. While the character models on-screen were live-3D animation, everything else in shot is a pre-rendered background. This is the hidden reasoning behind Resident Evil’s iconic fixed camera angles - loading a pre-rendered background with some characters on it takes a lot less processing power than running a full live 3D environment.
Because of this approach, the designs of the mansion, the police station, and the rest of Raccoon City are all driven by the enemy encounters, the puzzles and the puzzle of the setting itself because you almost never see a part of any of these settings that your character isn’t currently standing in. In Fallout New Vegas or Cyberpunk 2077 you can go right out into the desert and see the city from far away, but in the original RE trilogy the only part of the world that ever exists is the bit right in front of you - literally! The slight lag between shots is the computer loading in the next powerpoint slide that your 3D model will run around in front of.
You can actually see a little of how the 3D design influenced the RPD of Resident Evil 2 versus the RPD of Resident Evil 2 Remake. The safe room at the bottom of the stairs that contains the darkroom is surprisingly hard to find in the remake - I’ve actually seen players miss it altogether - and that’s because in the original game when that safe room was put there, there was a camera pointed right at the door. It was impossible to miss. In the remake when you control the camera, it’s possible that you ran out of the hallway where you just encountered 4 zombies, saw the stairs and legged it as fast as you could up to the next floor without even looking around, missing one of the few places in the game where enemies can’t follow you and one of the rare places in the game where you can save your progress.
Hey, CIA Femboy! You got a take on this?
Twink Rights!
Yeah - I mean, what rights don’t twinks have?
The right to have cops at pride
Uh huh
The right to work for private military contractors
That’s not true
The right to enact a genocide against indigenous Guatemalans to protect the free market interests of a fruit company
That’s a real thing the CIA did
Yes it is
Yes it is
In his superbly written atlas of the designed worlds that we explore in video games titled Virtual Cities, Konstantinos Dimopoulos describes Raccoon City like this:
“Nestled deep in the foggy but wonderful Arklay Mountains, Raccoon City was a typical American city of the Midwest. Surrounded by a craggy countryside of lakes, rivers and ravines, as well as the old-growth Raccoon Forest, the city was part of nature’s beautiful, diverse tapestry.”
And I agree, there is something very organic about Raccoon City. It feels like a natural space that people really live in, and I think that part of that comes down to the way you progress through the whole thing as one map. You never have to wait on loading screens between areas because every time you move across half a room the game switches to a new fixed camera angle revealing two more chompy boys for you to get killed by instantly.
It seems like an interesting trade-off, the way that movement is hampered by the fixed camera angles versus the organic free-flowing design of the world, but I think there is an argument to be made that it’s not a trade-off, but a trade… on. I’m trying to say the fixed camera angles are Good, Actually.
A lot of focus is put on fixed cameras as a tone-setter in survival horror: lack of control, building of tension, blah blah blah. However, this tends to describe the approach in videographic terms, rather than… ludological… terms? Damn I invented a word for video game science and it turns out it already exists! Isn’t latin fun?
I mean that we talk about how the fixed cameras make the game look instead of the impact that they have on the gameplay, and this might sound like splitting hairs but you’ll probably understand what I mean better later. The fixed camera angles make it more stressful to navigate the world, because there could be a zombo right there where the shot changes, and that makes you move through the world slower, paying more attention to the environment, which they’ve been able to make look better because of the fixed camera angles, paying more attention to colour, contrast, lighting, style, decor. The fixed camera angles and the design of the world feed into one another in a symbiotic cycle. It’s not a trade-off, it’s a win-win.
Konstantinos Dimopoulos goes on:
“Raccoon City was originally mentioned in the first Resident Evil, but only visited by players in its 1998 sequel. Even then, little of the actual city was shown, but players and critics were too satisfied to notice. Building up the excitement apparently worked, as did the pre-rendered backgrounds that allowed for higher resolutions and greater detail than would have been possible in real-time 3D. These backgrounds lent the world its distinct feel and permitted controlled framing and the effective setting-up of scares.”
This is a recognizable feature of the way these games work: the gameplay drives the creation of the world. It might seem strange. If you were setting about creating Resident Evil 2 you might imagine that the setting would come first and then all the puzzles and their pieces and the enemy encounters would get fitted into it, but game design is an iterative process. You might have the basic concept of the setting first, but the shape of the gameplay dictates the shape of the world.
What I like about the Police station in Resi 2 is that it doesn’t try to explain a chronology of what happened. It isn’t the set of a murder mystery, spoonfeeding you clues to the timeline of events, it’s just a place where people used to work. It’s messy, it’s chaotic, and it looks like it was abandoned in a hurry in order to form a defensive perimeter which then collapsed.
As Konstantinos puts it:
“Raccoon City feels like it actually existed before the zombies; it is deeper than a cardboard prop connecting indoor levels. Its varied zombies are representative of a wider population, and the few roads shown are rich in street furniture, architectural variety and activity. They feel both typical and representative enough to paint images of a wider town before the catastrophe. Besides, the skyline of Raccoon City (glimpsed in the main menu) was modelled after Montreal. The vast police station, on the other hand, seems iconically odd, as it was housed in a former art museum in order to explain the bizarre puzzles scattered throughout the building. It is such overlapping influences, restrictions and sensibilities that shaped Raccoon City: an intriguingly skewed vision of American Midwestern urbanism crafted by Japanese game developers using late 1990s technology under the influence of 1970s and 1980s zombie movies.”
One element that can really help us unpack the difference between the worlds of Resident Evil 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, and 8 as opposed to Resi 5 and 6, is elevation.
A lot of classical stories like to play with senses of elevation as well as distance, and this is something that can make the design of a fictional world incredibly compelling. In Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy the pilgrim starts at the middle point of the afterlife and has to travel down to the lowest part of hell before climbing all the way up into heaven. In Lord of the Rings some of the darkest moments of the stories take place underground, and the end of the journey is a volcano - a mountain that you first have to climb and then throw the One Ring down into. In the most significant philosophical work of the last 80 years, Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines, some of the nicest, goodest characters live on the ground level or beneath it, while The Prince, the pinnacle of all evil lives at the top of a skyscraper, which creates a sense that the world is perfectly upside down, perverted and wrong because of the parasitic vampire-like exploitation of the working class by the bourgeoisie.
There are, however, reasons besides communism to play with elevation in your fictional world - there aren’t really, but all the boys will stop watching unless I pretend they know a little more than me about this. How do video games even work? What does this button do? Ooh did I win?
In Resident Evil you descend deeper into the chaos and madness of the Spencer Mansion, first hoping to escape, then pushing deeper through the secret facilities underneath and finally arriving at the lab where you are shown the ultimate life form making the fight with the tyrant the final barrier between the subterranean evil of the Mansion and your airborne escape by helicopter.
In Resident Evil 2 you explore the police station, open an underground passage to the car park, travel down further into the sewers and then the Umbrella facilities beneath the city. In Nemesis you are chased across the city by the chonky lad, reinforcing the sense that nowhere on the surface of the city is safe now that the T virus has bubbled up out of the sewers and onto the streets, and once again you find yourself in a deep underground facility at the end of the game. Speaking of subterranean horror, the original Resi 3 even had giant worms, because once again: this is a franchise for women, and women love giant worms.
Not to belabour this point unendingly, I just want to point out one more small example. In Resident Evil Village, the village itself is the neutral elevation, and each boss exists in an area not too far from the village as the crow flies, but on quite different elevations. For example, Lady Dimitrescu and Heisenberg absolutely fucking loathe each other, and Castle Dimitrescu is, well a castle, while Heisenberg’s factory sits in a massive chasm in the earth, creating a physical sense that both characters are powerful and important but in opposing ways. That isn’t the example I meant though. In Donna Beneviento’s house, when you unlock all of the escape room puzzles, but before you activate the nightmare baby, you have to climb into a well. It’s a dead-end in the earth, a deep, narrow chamber, and clearly a bit of an homage to The Ring. The game is building your sense of dread proportionally to how far down you go in the level.
The point is, playing with elevation can give something a sense of significance. The first three games take you down underground, Resi 4 ends with a big fight on top of a castle, elevation isn’t everything but it is key to a lot of the series’ world design, so when the games give you wide open flat levels where you just ride around in a hover boat hunting black people...Resident Evil 5 is really racist. It bears repeating. However it’s also boring and bad to play, and which of those is the greater crime? Who can say. It’s the racism.
Resi 5 starts in a city then travels to tribal wetlands then wildly whips back and forth between oil fields and the exploitative neocolonialism of petrol companies and Indiana Jones-y puzzle temples. Chapter 5 is more or less just 5 consecutive boss fights, and yes, some of them take place in an underground Umbrella facility but all of the significance is killed by a combination of neither knowing nor caring what it is that you’re fighting and the fact there are just so many bosses in a row. More like Resident Evil 5 bosses in a row. Gottem. Chapter 6 takes place on a boat, then a plane, and then crash lands inside the crater of an active volcano, where Wesker, much like the One Ring, is shot from a helicopter by two CIA agents with rocket launchers. It’s a mess! Where’s the progression?
Like I said, elevation isn’t everything, but it and all the other issues are tied closely together in the same way that they would be tied together well in a game that worked. In the other games, the feeling of progression that the elevation and other design elements give you make you feel like you’re moving up a chain of power. Police station, police chief, secret experiments, Umbrella corporation. Evil cult, monster cultists, evil prince, mutated cult leader.
In Resident Evil 5 on the other hand, you just go from one place to another place to another place to another place. There are two car turret fights back to back, and in the second one, the car isn’t even moving. You just go wherever the fuck the game decides you’re going, and then, at the end, Chris Redfield punches a fucking boulder. Chris Redfield. Punches a boulder. In a volcano. And it’s not even to defeat Wesker, it’s just to make a stepping stone for Sheva to jump on.
Resident Evil 6, likewise, is a mess.
There are clear design intentions you can tease out, for instance: in Leon’s playthrough you start low and end high and in Chris’ playthrough you start high and end low, and the crossover point is where the two men find Ada Wong. It’s like poetry, it rhymes. However, Chris’ playthrough starts at the top of a chinese tenement building and works downwards and then cuts to a flashback to Eastern Europe, where the level design is almost completely flat. In a series that is notorious for its deep underground labyrinths, the flatness of the level tells you immediately not to give the slightest fuck about it, while the narrative is trying to tell you that this is the driving force behind Chris’ entire character. The intentions were there but there is absolutely no consistency or coherent design ethos. Jake and Sherry’s story is the most extreme version of this, going up and down and to different countries simply wherever the story needs them to be to interact with the other characters rather than having any kind of structure of its own. Ada’s playthrough, which should be the one that ties everything together, revealing the deepest truths of the global political corporate conspiracy, also just kinda goes wherever.
The game that should have given the most concrete sense of the world of Resident Evil instead makes it harder to believe that there is any kind of coherent world setting. If you ignore Resi 5 & 6 it’s actually a lot easier to imagine Resident Evil as one contiguous world, because the world design ethos is the same.
Resident Evil settings are campy, schlocky and fun, with horror lurking just beneath the surface. They draw together unrelated aesthetics and ideas in ways that make them make sense together. A carnival of hillbilly horror or gothic horror or bioweapon horror - a haunted house with a motivating theme.
These aren’t the only settings of the main series though, because as it happens, Resident Evil 4 was in development for 6 years, and in that time the team developed several different iterations of the game, with the world being completely overhauled several times in between, so before we move on from world design, let’s talk about
Part 1.5: Four Resident Evils
Speaking to GameSpy about Resi4 and its previous iterations, Hiroyuki Kobayashi, producer on both Resident Evil 4 and Devil May said:
“The first story idea we had was going in to destroy the main base of Umbrella in Europe. The second concept was that Leon was hit with a bizarre disease in which he started to see illusions and monsters that weren't really there. He would attack and strike out at them, but he couldn't do them any harm. The third version had zombies. It simply didn't feel fun. Then we said, "NO MORE ZOMBIES!" and that was that.”
This is a pretty good summary, but you need to know there were actually 4 versions of RE4, not 3, and it’s important to talk about all of them. The version that Kobayashi didn’t mention here is the cool version.
Cool version
I call the first version of Resident Evil 4 that they were developing the “cool” version because of something I think is funny on wikipedia, although that’s not like, a name that the developers called it or anything. On wikipedia it says that the original version was going to be more “cool” and that eventually Shinji Mikami stepped in to say that Resident Evil isn’t supposed to be cool and that’s when the project spun off and became Devil May Cry instead. If you dig into the sources, that’s not what anyone actually said, and Mikami’s problem was with the action oriented format the game was taking and the lack of exploration or puzzles compared with previous games. There’s the lesson kids: don’t believe everything you read on wikipedia.
That said, this “cool” version was going to be a big departure, and Resi 4 probably wouldn’t be what it is today if it weren’t for the “cool” version. The protagonist, Tony, was - as opposed to cop protagonists in previous instalments - going to be someone with special powers gained from Umbrella’s experiments, and his bombastic combat maneuvers weren’t showcased well in fixed camera angles, so the team decided to leave the iconic pre-rendered backgrounds of the franchise behind and opt for a dynamic camera system instead.
Resident Evil so meaningfully shaped the survival horror genre and Resident Evil 4 so meaningfully reshaped it, that I think it’s fair to say that the genre as a whole owes something here to the “cool” version.
Part of what was happening here, it seems, was that Shinji Mikami was beginning the process of moving on from Resident Evil and trying to hand over directorial and creative duties to other staff, but at the same time couldn’t completely remove himself from the project. This first “cool version” that became Devil May Cry was directed by Hideki Kamiya but when it got underway, Mikami felt that it just didn’t fit with the world of Resident Evil that they had built so far, and so Kamiya took the project to Capcom and rebranded it as Devil May Cry.
For the discussion of world design it’s interesting to note that knowing they were giving Leon Kennedy a fun little European gap year, members of the dev team spent 11 days in Spain and the UK taking photos of statues and architecture for texture reference. I hope one of them tried a Wigan kebab.
Fog version
The next version of the game retained some of the previous elements while starting to move a little closer to what we’re familiar with. The protagonist was now Leon and he would have a side kick, and in the game he would be in the main headquarters of Umbrella in europe.
This fits in well with the established lore, because in Resident Evil 2 you can actually find a note explaining where Chris has gone where he says he’s in Europe dating “hot chicks” but on a closer read the message is clearly code for a mission he is on investigating Umbrella Corp. Having Leon infiltrate Umbrella as well, could have worked well by continuing the franchise pattern of having the series protagonists just barely miss each other but never quite link up. In this version, Leon was also infected with the virus giving him special powers like Tony.
This version wasn’t officially scrapped or spun off, but rather iterated upon, leading to the hook man version!
Hook man version
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OAK8EkCmLf0
In 2005 when RE4 finally shipped, pre-order copies included a playable demo of an earlier version of the game, which had been shown off at E3 back in 2003. The demo has Leon traversing some sort of old building with fancy decor and old paintings, as the building comes to life and attacks him with suits of armour, dolls, a mounted stags head, and finally as a painting of a man holding a large meathook comes to life and chases him around the level. This is the hook man version and honestly? Resident Evil IX should be hook man. I’m just saying what everyone else is thinking. I’ve become a hook man stan through researching and watching the demo. Give me that stabby hooky spooky boy!
In the hook man version, Leon sees everything in a bluer hue when the house comes to life to attack him, making it unclear if he is really lucid or in some kind of dream, and something I find really interesting is that one of the scares in the demo are living dolls. I said before that Beneviento’s house in Village didn’t seem to have a clear gothic horror inspiration but have we found the inspiration here? Capcom please, if you turned the spooky doll nightmare house from the hookman version into Beneviento I am begging you, please put hook man in Resident Evil IX.
The developers said that there wasn’t really a fully fleshed out backstory to hook man or the setting, and that makes sense, because it seems like the developers were just playing with different mechanics and preparing the engine while the writers worked on the setting and story. The other really compelling thing about the hook man version is that it’s literally a haunted house, and I cannot tell you how vindicating that is. However, it might have been the literal haunting of this setting which was it’s downfall.
Shinji Mikami was the one who insisted that in the original Resident Evil nothing was going to be supernatural, and all of it would turn out to be from Umbrella’s sinister science. This is my speculation, but it might be that the much more paranormal, ghostlier feel of hook man might have been why it didn’t go anywhere.
Which is why you have to hire me to write it! I have the hook man’s entire backstory figured out! He isn’t a ghost at all, there’s a scientific explanation for all of it, and it all starts when his lover is tragically killed where are you going no please wait let me tell you about hook man!
Hallucination version
The fourth iteration of RE4 before what was actually released saw Leon infiltrating not Umbrella’s headquarters but instead the castle of Oswald Spencer, the wealthy eugenicist whose mansion you explore in RE1. Again, Leon was going to have a young female sidekick, but something pretty special about this version was that the two of them were going to be accompanied by a zombie dog. Would the dog have been cute? Hypothetically - a cute frankenstein dog? I can imagine that working. Would Leon have been able to pet the dog? Now we’re asking the really important questions.
This setting where two protagonists explore Oswald Spencer’s castle, of course, is actually the premise of a Resident Evil 5 DLC, where Jill and Chris go to confront Spencer and Wesker, and then Jill is MIA presumed dead. Of course, in Resident Evil 5 all of this is communicated by flashback unless you play the DLC, so I’m left wondering why they didn’t stick to this premise for Resident Evil 4.
So what did we learn from all this extra detail about scrapped games that they never made? I don’t fucking know. I write the script, I make all the jokes, I edit the video, do I have to draw your conclusions for you too? Jesus.
Part 2: Resource and inventory management
When you’ve played a few of these games and you can see the ways in which the good ones are good and the bad ones are bad, an incontrovertible statement forms in your mind: Resident Evil has a rhythm. What makes a good Resident Evil game? I hope we’ll answer that today on a quite technical level, but a nice, fun, sexy answer is that the games that are good are so good because they have the rhythm. What do I mean? Let’s take an example.
In Resi2 Remake you get the red book to put in the statue’s hand to get the sceptre to retrieve the jewel to put in the box to get the police badge to activate the computer to open the armory in the S.T.A.R.S office. In the S.T.A.R.S office there’s a battery which goes in the detonator which knocks down the wall which gets you to the statue puzzle which you solve for the third medallion allowing you to open the secret underground passage from the police station to the parking lot. Those are two short sets of steps which lead you to a weapon upgrade and a new area to explore. Game progression is made possible by you completing steps which will not always be consecutive or available one after another, but link together in a satisfying way. It comes to feel a lot like cooking a complicated meal. Several steps are required to make a sauce, which itself is just one part of one dish, and if you have the timings perfectly figured out you find yourself dancing around the kitchen through what should be a daunting task in a way that is instead exciting and fun.
In reality the red jewel can’t be fitted into the box to retrieve the police badge until you get into the observation room. If you’re playing as Claire you can’t get into the observation room until that sweet licky boy busts through the two-way mirror at you in the interrogation room. If you’re playing as Leon you either hop through the already smashed window or get into the observation room with the Club Key. You do it different ways depending on your playthrough but the item is withheld until a certain point in the game either way around, meaning that the steps I described before can’t be completed in that order by the player.
You have to have opened the secret passage and completed the parking lot story before you can get the bejeweled box, so you can already see how finding your way through all of this even when you know all the solutions to the puzzles is quite challenging, but the keen viewer will have also noticed that every solution involves some kind of item. You get the thing to take to the place to do the thing to get the whatever to open the blah blah blah. The club key, even, is one of four card-suit styled keys that open specific doors around the station.
The thing about items is: they take up inventory slots.
If you have 8 inventory slots and need to carry your pistol, knife, spare ammo, several different keys, the items that solve puzzles, boards to board up windows to stop zombies coming in and a little green herb to make yourself feel better, you can see the issue, right? And realistically your pistol does nothing against lickers so you want to carry the shotgun or the grenade launcher which are long items so they take up two inventory slots instead of one.
This is something that the franchise has played with since day one. In the original Resident Evil, Chris’ playthrough was labeled “hard” and Jill’s playthrough was “easy” and there were few mechanical differences between them because the simple but monumental difference between them was that Chris only has 6 inventory slots and Jill has 8. Look who doesn’t have pockets now, men!
Resi 2 Remake and Resi 3 Remake give you extra pouches to increase your inventory two slots at a time throughout the game from a minimum 8 up to a maximum of 20. At the same time, the game keeps giving you new kinds of enemies to fight, and each new kind of enemy needs a new kind of weapon.
As you navigate the Spencer mansion, the Raccoon City police station, the streets of Raccoon City, the Baker family home or Eastern… Europe… you catch little glimpses of how the rhythm should go, little bits that make the puzzle pieces lock nicely together, but the eternal challenge is the balance of your weapons, ammo, items, and inventory. If you know how the complete playthrough is supposed to work and you can reliably defeat every enemy in the game, you can take part in the dance, experience the beautiful totality of the rhythm, but if you can’t, either because of your own skill as a player or because of the design of the game, it can be frustrating in an unpleasant way.
A lot of people, for instance, get stuck in the RPD parking lot, because new items aren’t readily apparent and the steps to open the next area for exploration aren’t as clear as in the rest of the game. The dance that should go “enter the new area, clear out the enemies, pick up the items, solve the puzzles, rinse and repeat” gets stuck between steps 3 and 4.
In the comments, a lot of people pointed out after the last video that I didn’t talk about Resident Evil Zero despite claiming to be covering the main series of games, and that’s because Resident Evil Zero is a piss little game for clowns, and babies. Clown babies. A garbage game for hogs.
That’s not my real take.
I don’t think Resident Evil Zero is particularly bad or good. It’s not RE6 - it’s very much cut from the same cloth as RE1, RE2, and RE3 - and it’s certainly no Code Veronica, but let’s talk about why some people don’t like it, and why I don’t think most people understand what they don’t like about it.
In Resident Evil Zero, in the training facility level, once you have the Fire key, you unlock the fire key doors to go to the study and move the table to stand on the table to reach the moose head to get the iron needle to solve the clock puzzle to get into the clock doors so you can get microfilm A and then get microfilm B to get the MO disk to put the MO disk in the podium to solve the desk puzzle to open the knight doors to get into the chess room to solve the chess puzzle to get the EVIL book to retrieve the black statue wings allowing you to construct the black statue, balancing the scales and opening the door to the next area.
As much as it might sound like I’m just listing things the way I was before, in a good Resident Evil game you complete short phrases of puzzle solving that allow some flexibility or at least the illusion of it. Because you could either solve the Painting Riddle or find the Parrot’s Missing Beak, you both feel free to do whichever you want first and enjoy the challenge of inventory management. Chokepoints are rarer because the player almost always has multiple options for what to do.
In Resident Evil Zero you are almost always just trying to solve the next puzzle to progress to the next stage with no overlap or flexibility, and with that the challenge of inventory management disappears as well - why worry about what you’re carrying if the miscellaneous items you have on you will almost definitely be exactly what you need for the next puzzle?
In Noah’s video, Noah says what I’ve seen a lot of people who dislike the game say: that RE0 is bad because it’s silly. It has an opera singer mind-controlling leeches on a train, and yes that is silly, but with all due respect to the OG, I think Noah is wrong here. “Opera singer mind-controlling leeches” is silly in exactly the same way that all of Resident Evil is silly all the time.
In Resi2R you are chased by a giant alligator in the sewer, in Resi3R the massive bulbous head of the Toy Uncle rolls down the hill and nearly crushes you, in Resident Evil 4 there is a quick-time event where you sprint away from a 30-foot statue of a 4-foot man, in Resident Village, Heisenberg. None of these things are seen as detractors from the franchise the same way I unironically love when the snake busts up through the toilet in Hard Ticket To Hawaii and then Ronn Moss drives through the wall on his motorbike and shoots it in the head with a rocket launcher.
I would argue it isn’t an aesthetic issue at all, but instead that magical rhythm simply isn’t there. The wonderful dance of gameplay that makes a Resident Evil game just right is missing from Resident Evil Zero and it has a lot to do with inventory management. If the leech-singer had been in a game that got the rhythm right we would all unanimously agree that it’s very silly but doesn’t detract from the game.
Joseph Anderson regularly says that “gameplay is king” and as serious and political as my hyper-pretentious commie trans girl media analysis gets, it’s hard to disagree there. That’s why I’m paying so much attention to game design here - gameplay is king, and it’s the experience of the gameplay that shapes your experience of the game first and foremost. Next episode, for instance, I will spend an inadvisable amount of time talking about Resident Evil 5 & 6 in a positive light because I’ll be analysing the franchise politically, but there’s no way round where I could ever call either of them good games because they are simply piss and/or ass to play. They suck.
In an incredibly ironic move, the silly and contrived fiction of Resident Evil Zero is a perfect reflection of the real problem. The game takes place in a second very similar mansion in the Arklay mountains right next to the Spencer Mansion. It’s a pale imitation of the Spencer mansion in the way that Resident Evil Zero is a pale imitation of what makes Resident Evil good. It feels like they had a lot of bits and pieces on the cutting room floor and wanted to make a prequel to increase the hype for the Resident Evil Remaster so just stuck them all end to end with no thought to rhythm of the dance.
Resident Evil: Code Veronica - uh oh, here we go again, I’m sorry - Resident Evil: Code Veronica among other kinds of massive dumpster fires is a massive game design dumpster fire too. In the biblical sense. The Cyberpunk 2077 sense. The game is actually broken in at least a couple of extraordinary ways that anyone should have noticed if anyone was checking.
Famously, a late game solution requires you to have a fire extinguisher item which you plausibly left in a puzzle that demands you give it all your metal items really early in the game, and if you didn’t have the foresight to think you might need the fire extinguisher later then the game becomes uncompletable at this incredibly late stage. In real life of course, a fire extinguisher is a very important item in a crisis - In Resident Evil, you have no way of knowing whether it will be more important than the Pirate’s Wooden Leg or the Pocket Watch Shaped Like A Dinosaur.
Another problem - an outright glitch on some platforms - is caused by an item called the Player Manual. The Player Manual is a book that tells you how to play the game because fuck you and fuck intuitive self-explanatory play experiences I guess. It’s an item that takes up an inventory slot despite actually being a file that you can also read in your files tab, and that causes its own problems with players who don’t realise that they have an inventory slot taken up by a completely unnecessary item for half the game, but it also causes a problem when the game gets confused by the item which is also a file. When the player goes into the file tab to read the player manual as a file, the game deletes the manual, but the next selected item after the manual for some reason becomes inexpendable - in other words, when you use the item it doesn’t disappear. So in a game where, at least in theory, inventory management matters a lot, a bug makes it possible to either wind up with a permanently occupied slot you can never empty, or literally infinite ammunition or healing items.
This bug is pretty funny and would be a little game-breaking in most games, but I hope that I’ve explained the delicate balance of inventory and resource management in Resident Evil enough that you understand why it’s especially bad here.
Inventory management isn’t something I thought I would ever actively enjoy, but somehow Resident Evil, at its best, makes deciding what should be in your inventory actually fun. Like, at the end of Resi 2 Remake, when Leon gets to a slow moving elevator on which he will have his final battle with Mr. X, the elevator needs a special type of fuse plug to work. The same is true for Claire and her big battle with William Birkin. The thing is, the fight will start as soon as you use the plug, and the plug takes up two inventory slots, and here, after everything, faced with this, I felt elated. I never thought I would actively enjoy inventory management but Resident Evil 2 Remake showed me how wrong I could be.
Okay, let’s talk a bit more about guns.
Guns are hot but cucked leftoids don’t want anybody to have them
So you support community self defense?
Why are you promoting terrorism?!
I swear to god I will send you back to twitter and ask for a refund
I’ll come back as an NFT and be more powerful than you can possibly imagine
The only thing I really worry about with making videos this long is like - what if there’s someone watching who isn’t having a good time? Like, someone who’s just seething because they think all my video game opinions are just fucking terrible, but they feel like they have to watch it all for some reason. It’s ok. You don’t have to. Just go do something you like. Call your best friend for an hour just to see how they’re doing.
On the face of it, weapons and ammunition seems like a pretty simple game design element. If you want to make the game harder, give the player less ammo and make each bullet do less damage. Still, here, Resident Evil manages to innovate.
In many games, different weapons do different things, for instance crowd control for stunning or even taking out many enemies at once, long range versus short range for different combat arenas, elemental buffs and debuffs. Nonetheless, the weapon progression remains simple. At the start your basic weapon is ok at killing basic enemies, at the end you have the mega weapon that’s ok at killing the boss monster or really good at killing 12 basic enemies at once.
In Resident Evil, weapons are far more locked to specific enemies. Plant monsters and lickers don’t give the slightest fuck about your shitty little toy pistol Leon, put that shit away. On the other hand plants are weak to fire and lickers are weak to acid, both of which Claire has in her big girl gun, the grenade launcher. In Resident Evil 4 Leon encounters a special type of regenerating zombie that seemingly has no weak spots - that is until you view it through an infrared scope, when you realise the living organism has these little organs randomly placed around the body that you can take out with one hit provided you hit them exactly on target. This is such a cool idea, and takes your rifle, an already precious high powered weapon, and makes it ten times more precious as a resource because it’s the only weapon that can kill this specific really shitty enemy. The game even acknowledges this outright a little later on by giving you one of these guys that you have to get past and covering him with spikes so if you don’t shoot him right in his weak spots you’re fucked!
This was such a cool idea that when the plant monsters were redesigned for the Resi 2 Remake, they included similar little organs on the bodies that you can shoot if you don’t have any kind of incendiary weapons and if you hit them just right it takes them out! You however are probably panicking and won’t spot them, because a zombie made of trees is coming to bite your head off.
In Resident Evil 3 - the original and the remake - the weapon you use to kill Nemesis once and for all is a special Umbrella prototype energy weapon, because the developers know that giving each type of enemy its own special weapon makes the enemy more special, and of course Nemesis, the most special boy ever to live, deserves a gun that’s just for him. It’s also, however, an extension of this philosophy, that aiming and shooting is a mere technicality - the real game is in the management of ammo, and weapons, because the core of the game is in the items and the inventory. Nemesis gets his own gun which is itself a puzzle because all weapons in Resident Evil are puzzles.
Residents Evil 0, 1, 2, 3, Code Veronica, and 7 all used storage boxes, which can be accessed at various points and always contain everything you left in any of them. This works to facilitate the more puzzle-focused gameplay because you never know when the Mayor’s Shoe is going to turn out to fit into the Cobbler’s Door Puzzle and open the next area, so it makes inventory management a fun challenge.
Resident Evils 4 and Village use a primary and secondary inventory system where the main inventory that the player has access to is backed up by a secondary inventory they can only access when talking to a merchant. This is because those games are far more combat-focused, and as a result inventory management isn’t something that’s meant to be fun in them. You just buy more inventory space when you need it, and managing your inventory is never really a concern. With that however, the joy of managing your inventory is never really a possibility, and I think that’s a bit sad.
But what’s all this about merchants? Money? Buying? Combat focused gameplay? That sounds bad and scary, and not like Resident Evil to me. I think it’s time to talk about
Part 3: Video Game Economics
Too many games have economies now because they want to sell you stuff.
Part 4: Speedrunn-- okay seriously, even if it can be summed up very simplistically, this is a really interesting topic.
In the last ten to twenty years we have witnessed a lot of changes in gaming, some of them expected - better graphics, more striving towards total 3D realism - and others less expected. For example, why do so many people like to play games where they work?
Isn’t that a contradiction? A work game? And yet, work simulators are more popular today than they’ve ever been.
Since the beginning of video games there have been games that put the player in the shoes of someone with a particular profession - often police or military, and not to leave it unsaid: plumber - but these games weren’t focused on the nature of the work itself and many deviate from the player character’s job altogether.
Some of the earliest work simulators, one could argue, were games that let people explore the fantasy of having a really cool job where the player has a lot of power and agency, like Rollercoaster Tycoon or Sim City, but what’s really curious about this trend is a move towards jobs that don’t offer any obvious power fantasy. There are now not only games that allow us to design our ideal theme park or city but games that simulate being a truck driver, train driver, farmer, or a courier.
For my part I think I can offer an insight from the perspective of someone who has a job for which there exists a job simulator game. Yes, there is a YouTuber Simulator, and while in some respects it does simulate the life of a content creator, the uneasy feeling I get thinking about the game may tie into what people actually enjoy about this type of game. I feel uneasy thinking about all the labour that I put into my job being sold as an experience to be played, though I should acknowledge the chip I probably have on my shoulder here - a lot of people tell me I earn too much and that my job is easy, where I actually haven’t had a full day off in months and barely cover a two-person household’s expenses even with money from patreon, twitch, adsense and (very rare) sponsors.
I uhhh, live at the bottom of my bank overdraft… I love being a rich content creator.
All these gripes and grievances are because the idea that someone else would try out even a pale facsimile of my job just for fun is a bit insulting. I imagine there are truck drivers who feel this way about Truck Driver Simulator, of course. But to resolve the apparent contradiction of games where you work, and this tension around job simulators, I think we need to interrogate what “fun” even means.
We have an idea based on a layman’s understanding of neurochemistry that fun is this thing that happens. You succeed or get a reward and so on and your brain gives you dopamine at least in theory, but if that were the case then why have a game at all? Why not just have the ending screen? Mario gets the princess every time and my brain slime goes brrr, perfect game 10 out of 10 remember to like and subscribe.
Why isn’t Animal Crossing just a mall where you have infinite money? Well, because the rewards themselves aren’t what makes us happy. The nice thing about home decor in Animal Crossing is the challenge of decorating your house the way that you want, and even more so when each adornment requires you to spend hours farming, fishing, building etc. because the experience of fun is in the game itself, rather than in the reward.
In The Utopia of Rules: On Technology, Stupidity, and the Secret Joys of Bureaucracy, the extremely smart-pilled and quotable-champ, late great David Graeber writes:
“Western intellectual traditions have always tended to assume that humans’ powers of reason exist, first and foremost, as a way of restraining our baser instincts. The assumption can already be found in Plato and Aristotle, and it was strongly reinforced when classical theories of the soul were adopted into Christianity and Islam. Yes, the argument went, we all have animalistic drives and passions, just as we have our powers of creativity and imagination but these impulses are ultimately chaotic and antisocial. Reason - whether in the individual or the political community - exists to keep our lower nature in check, to repress, channel and contain potentially violent energies in such a way that they do not lead to chaos and mutual destruction. [...]
The emergence of bureaucratic populism, as I’ve been describing it, corresponds to a complete reversal of this conception of rationality - to a new ideal, one most famously summed up by David Hume: that “reason is and ought to be the slave of the passions”. Rationality, in this view, has nothing to do with morality. It is a purely technical affair - an instrument, a machine, a means of calculating how to most efficiently achieve goals that could not themselves be in any way assessed in rational terms. Reason cannot tell us what we should want, it can only tell us how best to get it.”
In essence, it’s fun to manage to do stressful or complicated things, and that is a fundamental part of video games. From an analytical perspective we often talk about fantasy and power in games, but from a design perspective these aren’t really very useful concepts. Instead, from a design perspective we can think about the feelings we want to elicit in a player and how the balance of challenge and reward creates those feelings.
The kind of stress that this challenge creates is the flipside of the satisfaction that you get from labour. The good feelings that you experience when you clean, or gather fruits, or build something are counterbalanced by the stress of a chaotic, messy world.
But what does all of this have to do with economies, and what does it all have to do with Resident Evil?
Game genres are usually named for core mechanics, and Resident Evil is a survival horror franchise. Horror is when the game makes you afraid, but what are survival mechanics? You could say they’re mechanics that mediate whether or not the player character is alive, but health is a prime example of that, and yet lots of games that aren’t survival games have health as a mechanic. I think the best way to define it is that the balance between the challenge of surviving and the reward of progression through the game is the core focus of the game. Survival as a mechanic is the labour of staying alive. You could think of it like a job simulator where the job is not to get munched by a zombie.
So: Video game economics.
Economies exist in video games wherever resources are exchanged between parties. In Prey, the item recycler is a kind of economy, because your resources are converted and exchanged and you get a different resource back. Along the same lines, skill points that can be spent fungibly into a skill tree are a kind of video game economy. There is a mechanical bleed between experience points and video game currency where a lot of games will let you spend the points that you got in a level on rewards, whether the game calls those points currency or not. Video game economies are complex and wide-ranging and in some cases extremely predatory where the economy is priming players for spending real actual money on in-game purchases where their real money translates into video game currency which cannot translate back. Here however, thankfully, this is not the case.
Economy actually comes from a Greek word for household management, and in this regard, I think it’s interesting to see how economies within games interplay with inventory management. Specifically, in Resident Evil, games tend to be either more inventory management and puzzle focused or more combat focused and feature explicit trade with currency.
Remember the 6 slots that Chris Redfield in Resident Evil 1? In Resident Evil 4, Leon has 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, uhhhhhhhh a lot.
It’s safe to say that the puzzle of inventory management is a thing of the past here, and yet it is still possible to run out of space. If you do so, and you want more, you have to go see the most delightful character in the game. The Vendor, a bafflingly cockney man in deep rural Spain wearing a face mask and a hooded trench coat, is an iconic example of Resident Evil camp, a character who exists only to give a face (and voice) to the economy mechanics and yet instantly a fan favourite.
Likewise in Resident Evil Village there is a jolly rotund fellow called The Duke who operates a travelling shop just like The Vendor which appears wherever you go and allows you to top-up ammo, upgrade guns, buy more inventory space, sell unnecessary items and even improve your character stats. Consider that in Resident Evil Village there are puzzles you can complete to give you big crystals which sell for a lot of money allowing you to upgrade your inventory size or make other large meaningful changes. This is remarkably similar to the puzzles in The Remakes which you solve in order to get extra slots in your inventory.
In Resident Evil 4 as opposed to previous games, enemies drop items when they die, which are determined in part by random chance. When you boot up Nemesis on Normal Mode, there are a precise number of handgun bullets you can get through the entire game - not so in RE4 or RE Village. Interestingly, although the games haven’t strayed into the toxic and predatory world of in-game purchases, randomised item drops do rely on a similar game logic to gambling, and we could point out how this kind of game psychology is inherent to games that bring in currency and trade mechanics, however, what I’d like to focus on is that in Resi there is clearly a push and pull between inventory management and economy mechanics, and that this is tied closely to a push and pull between puzzle and combat mechanics.
And if we’re going to acknowledge that, I’m just going to say it outright: economy mechanics aren’t fun. Inventory management can be fun. Currency management cannot.
People don’t like to be overly critical of Resident Evil 4, and I’m aware that I already have been and I’m trying not to burn through my good will with the resi fandom, but at the same time I think it’s extremely worth our while to consider the ways that the design of 4 led to the design of 5 which led to the design of 6. In other words: To what extent is everyone’s favourite resi responsible for the crimes against gaming that came afterwards?
In particular, I’m talking about the Vendor. I’m sorry comrades, but you knew this capitalist dog was going to get it eventually, no matter how funny his accent is.
In RE4 there was The Vendor, a thinly veiled in-universe explanation for the currency and purchasing that had been added. In RE5, the thin veil has blown away like a tissue in a hurricane, and the economy mechanics simply appear between each level with no diegetic explanation. On top of that, RE5 was co-op and added a lot of new mechanics to the base of 4 to accommodate that. RE6 threw yet another boatload of additional unnecessary mechanics on top of that.
With the push and pull between puzzles and inventory management versus combat and economy mechanics, I think we can pretty solidly argue that RE4, RE5 and RE6 are an observable progression of feature-creep, leading to the awful bloated mess that nearly killed the entire franchise. We’ll talk about this more later, but Village clearly recycles a lot from RE4, and while it is itself a masterpiece, just like RE4 was, I find myself asking:
Is my favourite large son the beginning of the end?
Is The Duke a herald of oncoming feature-creep for this new Resident Evil trilogy?
Are video game economies bad?
Usually capitalist ones are, yes.
Wow I really expected some kind of complaint from CIA Femboy for that one.
I’m an anarchist
Um… what? Since when?
Socialism can exist with free markets but tankies won’t admit it. The only problem with capitalism is monopolies
That’s not what an anarchist is
The problem with the left today is--
What?!
What, I’m a leftist.
You literally work for the CIA.
I’m still a human being
Jesus christ
Examining the difference between what makes inventory management in Resident Evil fun and what makes economy mechanics distinctly less so reveals the core thesis of design philosophy here. Inventory management, like a job simulator, is fun because it’s a little stressful in a specific way that you can master and draw satisfaction from. You are succeeding at the job of not getting munched and that feels good.
When, however, you get currency, be it money or points, for shooting zombos only to spend that money on more big gun and more space to fit more bigger gun in, the stress has been designed out. You’re not supposed to think about it, but you still have to think about it, you still have to choose to spend your currency on, and in creeps a new kind of stress. This stress however, isn’t fun. This is the paralysis of choice stress, the what-if-I-spend-my-money-badly stress, the sold-my-soul-to-company-store stress. This isn’t the rewarding challenge of a skill that can be mastered, this is the nagging feeling that whatever you do, you could have done something better, but not in a way that you understand. There’s nothing there to get good at, but the game still makes you think about it long enough to doubt yourself.
I say that this gets at the core of the design because everything in Resident Evil is a finely weaved balance between frustration and progression. Resident Evil isn’t a franchise that takes you on a rollercoaster of different emotions - it’s more like Dark Souls - there’s one feeling, all the time, but it feels really good. It’s a bit like the job simulator feeling, but more extreme. It’s like you paid off all your debts to Tom Nook in Animal Crossing and then said “OK, now give me the hard stuff!” That’s the feeling. It’s the rhythm. It’s the stressful fun of Resident Evil and the labour of survival horror.
It feels so good to get it right because that feeling is all about discovering a new set of skills and then mastering them, and the absolute peak of those feelings is
Part 4: Speedrunning
Let’s talk a bit more about stressful fun. I’ve been talking for [insert time here] about Resident Evil’s game design now, and a clear emerging pattern is that where other games employ a balance between challenge and progression, Resident Evil uses challenge in harmony with progression. It’s like what I talked about with the fixed camera angles before, a symbiotic relationship between how stressful the game is and how fun the game is.
Being a Resident Evil fan is like the perfect relationship - even when it’s stressful it’s just more fun. But ladies, if your man is the wrong kind of stressful and bores you with tedious Call of Duty aesthetics, you’re dating Resident Evil 6. Dump him, honey.
Stressful fun is the same kind of apparent oxymoron as a horror game - do people really want to be frightened when they play a game? Isn’t gaming supposed to be relaxing? You shouldn’t want to spend your free time draining a slime-filled bathtub to get a key to a swamp puzzle. Let’s explore the sick little minds of Resident Evil fans, horror fans more generally and why people enjoy being stressed.
We’ll start with specific examples of where RE is at absolute peak form to illustrate my point.
In the Raccoon City Police station the lights are out - of course they are, don’t think about it too hard. Some zombie ran around with a hammer smashing all the lightbulbs - so you have to look around the station with a flashlight which casts a narrow beam.
Searching for everything with a torch is stressful, because it makes the act of searching more technically difficult, and that added stress makes all scenes in the dark scarier. We like to philosophise about the human tendency to be afraid of the dark, but this is something else. Think about it: would you rather have a torch or just not have one? It’s actually scarier to have a torch in a game than just be in a low light environment
Only a little part of any room is visible to you at a time, which adds a whole extra level of complexity to the act of just looking at stuff. It’s exactly the kind of change that makes gameplay a little more stressful in exactly the way that makes it more fun. You constantly worry that your beam will move across a spooky little guy and you’ll have to switch to fight mode, but at the same time searching with the flashlight is a discernible skill you can master, which feels really good.
The earliest rooms that still have lights on are the rooms where there are typewriters which you use to save. The fact that the lights are on in all safe rooms makes an enormous difference to your experience of the space. These are your comfort zones in between the zombie-filled corridors of the rest of the station, which you know you can fall back on when the stress is too intense, but by the time you make it to the top floor you will have probably developed a level of comfort with the torch and gotten used to lit rooms being safe, and then you enter the library, which is well-lit and seems safe at first, and then you plummet through the rotten floorboards onto the lower level and get swarmed by zombos. See how the game gave you a basic stressful situation to master, and then right at the point where you were getting used to it the game completely fucks with your sense of safety. In exactly the same way, the main hall of the station is a safe room for most of the game, and enemies can’t come in safe rooms, but when Mr. X shows up and follows you around the building, he doesn’t give a fuck and walks right into the main hall anyway.
For another example let’s think about the kennels.
In the lower level of the police station where you find the parking lot, the morgue, the shooting range, the generator room the holding cells and the kennels - I love this dumb little game. Why are all these things next to each other? It’s like the art museum part of the station is just offices and all the parts that are actually a police station are just shoved in the basement. Right: where was I? In the lower level of the police station, you encounter a bunch of zombie dogs. Obviously the idea of a dog that doesn’t die when you shoot it is one that would send a shiver down the spine of any American police officer, but here it isn’t the monster design but an innovation of level design. The scariest part of this whole level is: the doggy doors.
There are little gaps in the walls that let the dogs run around get between rooms you wouldn’t expect them to be able to, and outside in the halls of this level there are weird barricades in the halls that stop you from being able to move straightforwardly, but the dogs can jump clean over them. The level design hampers your movement while at the same time giving them extra ways to move more easily. It feels more realistically scary in the sense that it resembles another sentient mind hunting you, it feels like a real entity is coming after you, especially in contrast to the zombies.
The dogs are really not smart when you get a good look at them, running into walls and botching basic turning mechanics, but they don’t need to be smart to be scary - they’re dogs. What makes a dog scary in real life is its speed and ferocity and the game replicates that perfectly by giving the dogs extra ways to maneuver the map that you can’t use and actively blocking off your points of ingress and egress.
Basically the same concept is at play on a much, much larger scale in Resi 3 Nemesis. Nemesis is just set to follow you around via the shortest path possible, but he can also jump really high and far if you manage to get too far away, and he occasionally bursts through walls, creating shortcuts that you wouldn’t have.
Video games are magical things, and different people express their love of video games in different ways. Some of us express how much we love a game franchise by getting a tattoo of the Nemesis on our ass, some of us express it by making hours upon hours of video essay about the various aspects of the series, and some people express their love by learning to play games really, really fast.
Let’s talk about speedrunners.
To want to dedicate so much of your time to the minute details of mastering an almost completely non-transferrable skill, play and replay a game until all possible appeal and basic visceral fun has gone out of it and past the point where it transforms from a piece of art into an unknowable other, mechanical and cold, the green raining code of the matrix streaming down before your unblinking eyes, you have to want to suffer, at least on some level. Speedrunners are people who like to suffer and gamers are people who deserve to suffer, so they fit in really well.
In a video on speedrunning, notorious beaver botherer Hbomberguy described the appeal of speedrunning as “logistical fun” like the satisfaction of “doing your taxes early”, and I’d like to expand on the distinction between that and what I’m describing here, because while similar I think they are distinct. I think Harry is right on the money that speedrunners in general enjoy the “logistical fun” of figuring out how to get through a game really quickly, but I also think that ordinary people don’t enjoy games the way that speedrunners do, necessarily. Or, sometimes they do, and that’s what’s so utterly fascinating about Resident Evil.
When people get into Mario 64, certainly, they aren’t very interested in completing the game as fast as possible, but speedrunners are. Fundamentally, these are different experiences. When you play Resident Evil, though, the beginner player and a speedrunner both want it to be over as soon as possible, albeit for different reasons. When Nemesis appears at the start of Resident Evil 3: Nemesis I cannot wait until the end of the game when I’ll put my great big gun in his mouth and oh we did this joke already.
Each section of the game puts pressure on the player to complete it and move on to the next, and each game design element makes that a struggle, and so the basic appeal of playing these games works a lot like how speedrunners approach a game.
The developers seem to be in conversation with the speedrunners too, viewing them as their most dedicated fans. In RE2R, when you blow up the wall to get the final medallion in the west storage room, that makes a lot of noise, and noise, of course, attracts lickers. Naturally, you’ll try to get out of there as fast as possible, and that’s why the developers put one of the only quicktime events in the whole game blocking your path to the library. You have to hold and wait to move the bookshelf with a licker right behind you! It’s agonising! This is part of what I was getting at at the start of the video - this is a part of everyone’s experience even though you technically could do things differently. That’s just how sharp the world, mechanics, and enemy encounter design are.
The people who like Resident Evil are people who enjoy stressful fun, and the people who like stressful fun are people who will like Resident Evil, but the people who like it the most, the ones who need the really hardcore shit make it even more stressful for themselves on purpose. After speedrunners began trying their hand at speedrunning the early games, highly competitive players started doing No Damage runs, where - like the name says - you have to get to the end of the game without ever once being hit by any attack.
From there the speedrunners of the Resi franchise really entered sicko mode. This was the birth of the knife-only run, where players aren’t even allowed a gun. In some ways this run is interestingly easier because you have far fewer items to manage in the inventory, but in other ways you have to defeat an entire city full of zombies with only a knife.
What’s particularly interesting about the speedrunning community and the Resident Evil games is that when the developers came to make Resident Evil 1 Remake, they put in a tonne of extra modes. One of them is called “real survival” and is based on early versions of the original, where the item boxes weren’t connected so you just had to know where items were if you put them down, which is kind of a fun development note, but also the item boxes were connected in the final game because it was just kind of bad to have them disconnected.
Other modes, though, seem to be made especially for speedrunner challenges. One mode is called “ODZ” or “One Dangerous Zombie”, where occasionally instead of the zombies that were supposed to be in a room, there’ll be one, very dangerous zombie - a zombie covered in grenades who runs at you when you enter, meaning that if you shoot him you die instantly.
The first thing here obviously is just, what the fuck, who would want this, you’d have to be sick to play the game this way, and yet people do. The second thing is, the developers didn’t just patch in this game mechanic, they wrote an entire backstory for the zombie! He’s covered in grenades because he’s a member of the team that the protagonists came to the mansion looking for! They made him canon! They made the One Dangerous Zombie a canonical character!
I just can’t get over this running grenade zombie, what an amazingly awful thing to do to yourself. Damn, that’s pretty hardcore! I mean I’ve heard of--
Did you think that was all?! Did you think that was the most extreme mode?! You fool?! You buffoon?!
The most extreme mode that Resident Evil 1 Remake is called Invisible Enemy Mode and when you turn it on, EVERY ENEMY IN THE GAME TURNS INVISIBLE. This isn’t normal gaming, this isn’t logistical fun, this isn’t… fun. Is it?! Does it sound fun to you? Because to me it sounds fucking incredible. I can’t even pretend I don’t get it, I’ve got the Resident Evil fever. That sounds amazing!
My favourite thing about the ODZ mode is that once you switch it on, it’s just on forever, and you can’t ever turn it off no matter how much you restart the game, so if you turned it on and then you try Invisible Enemy mode, sometimes you’ll go in a room where you think you know how many invisible enemies there are and there will just be one invisible dangerous zombie who runs at you and if you hit him he explodes killing you instantly, and I say again: this sounds amazing. This is the appeal of playing Resident Evil. This is it. Some sort of bug crawls in your ear when you play Resident Evil and you start to enjoy absurd, punishing misery. It should be awful, it makes no sense, but it fucking rules.
Like I said before, different people express their passion about Resident Evil in different ways, and I’m not a speedrunner. I’ll never be a speedrunner. I played all of Untitled Goose Game on release day and that was maybe the one time in my life that I was in the top 100 fastest playthroughs of a game, just for a fleeting moment. The way I process my Resident Evil fever is by writing about it, and that’s why I want to share something I think is really special here, both in appreciation of the games themselves, and the people who play them at an unthinkable and frightening speed that I will never understand.
If you complete Resident Evil Remake in Invisible Enemy Mode in under 5 hours, the game gives you a little bonus picture of Chris and Jill that says “well done”, and then it shows you this letter:
“Thank you for taking the time to play all the way through 'biohazard' (Resident Evil). If you're reading this letter, I salute you! You are truly a remarkable player! I imagine you must have had some pretty memorable experiences along the way.
The pain of seeing the "Game Over" screen time after time... The sweet taste of victory after you finally beat the game... The feelings of camaraderie you shared with your character... The excitement... and the overwhelming sense of dread.
We believe that games are more than just the product of a team of developers. It takes the support of dedicated players like you to make a game worthwhile.
For this reason we are truly delighted when someone enjoys one of our games as thoroughly as you have.
Therefore, on behalf of the entire staff, please allow me to express our gratitude and congratulate you on a job well done!
Thank you very much for playing!
Shinji Mikami”