Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

EMINEM'S MOST CONTROVERSIAL ALBUM! CASTLE & AROSE & FRAMED were 10/10 songs ngl...

HOLY FUCKING SHIT bro who stole eminem's name and started rapping under it i have never heard him sound so booty i felt physical pain listening to him for the first time ever... CASTLE & AROSE were 10/10 beautiful songs. I think he put them at the end of the album to try his best to make us forget it😭 shit did NOT work

if he ever raps like he did on "in your head" again please warn me so i plug my fucking ears

FRAMED also stood out HEAVY 10/10 I'm 100% sure its from the relapse:refill era... I CAN'T WAIT TO LISTEN TO KAMIKAZE NEXT💦💦💦

Walk On Water - 4:38

Believe - 15:40

Chloraseptic - 23:47

Untouchable - 33:20

River - 42:30

Remind Me (Intro) - 51:57

Remind Me - 52:18

Revival (Interlude) - 58:45

Like Home - 1:00:00

Bad Husband - 1:07:43

Tragic Endings - 1:15:13

Framed - 1:21:55

Nowhere Fast - 1:31:54

Heat - 1:37:55

Offended - 1:43:10

Need Me - 1:51:30

In Your Head - 1:58:16

Castle - 2:03:00

Arose - 2:08:27

RANKING - 2:18:36

SONG RAKING, (SPOILER IF YOU READ IT)

FAV TO LEAST

Framed

Arose

Castle

Tragic Endings

Walk On Water

River

Believe

Remind Me

Like Home

Bad Husband

Nowhere Fast

Heat

Offended

Need Me

Untouchable

In Your Head 

Chlorasepetic

Files

Comments

Rhys

The biggest issue for me with this album is the mixing on some songs. His rapping style was clearly something he tried and just didn't work, but how do you be the most popular rapper in the world and have a song be mixed like tragic endings is. Wild

Joseph

Nice, just finished mmlp2

Vishow

"You got buns, I got Asperger's"

Paul_ Fifa

Kamikaze is such a banger album after this disappointment, can‘t wait

Nunya

I agree with the mixing being off, I honestly wish he’d re-record this and balance the vocals better. The vocals sound too.. forward? Like the sibilance is too much, I have to adjust my device audio to tone down the ttsts noise — it’s too clean. But I don’t think the bones on this album are bad

Pizza_Mozzarella

some people dislike the fact that he doesn't "go hard" on this album, for me that's not an issue as sentimental songs are nice when done correct. The problem is that the productions is very hollow, his flows are super awkward and jarring, his punchlines and wordplay are straight up dad jokes. Framed is the only song I go back to. The best thing Revival did was it functioned as a bait to get Em pissed off and go ballistic on Kamikaze. I honestly think Em is at his best when he is the underdog and has to rap to prove himself, like Kamikaze or songs with features. Like Fuel in DTOSS with JID pushed Em to show that he can bring the new generation's arguably best lyrical rapper and still remind people he got the dawg in him

Nunya

Ver I’m sorry bro, I love your reactions but I can’t make it through, too painful ! I’ll be first in line for kamikaze haha

SanderAK

I need the Kamikaze reaction right now

Jack Castro

I am a Stan but I am also honest to admit when a song of his doesn’t hit, this album is not the mess people say it is, actually I am glad I heard your reaction because I really listened to his verses and his rhyming still impeccable, shit this album has some great verses I don’t give a crap what these fair weathered fans say

Joseph

Slowly getting to that point. Jeez this album is terrible

Vishow

Your booty is heavy duty, like diarrea

VERTICILE

>The problem is that the productions is very hollow, his flows are super awkward and jarring, his punchlines and wordplay are straight up dad jokes. Framed is the only song I go back to nailed it

Jack Castro

I see the comments and Kamikaze is a return to form for Em, I think you will love it, I liked Revival but can see why fans were disappointed, it’s not what we are accustomed to because he tried something different

Cameron Riddell

Framed isn’t from relapse but it is a sequel to 3 am

Vishow

Best bar of revival.

Paul_ Fifa

Also don‘t let us wait too long on Kamikaze please, we need that shit asap

Mr. blaze

First bar of the album “why are ecxpectations so high?” Last bar of the album “now I know”. Deep, too bad the album was bad overall. Just has some good songs on it

Tim Colter

You finally made it through Revival. Kamikaze and Music to be Murdered by (side b) are next. And those really pick up. Both albums are a treat after enduring Revival. I think that's why Kamikaze came out so "quick", try to wash that taste away. And Death of Shady is the greatest Eminem album ever made. So it's about to get awesome after this Also really excited to see Bad Meets Evil done. You'll love that compared to thia

Joseph

TDOSS is the best produced album of Eminem by far and his verses are friggin insane, but nothing beats Eminem on MMLP in my honest opinion. His flows and verses there are just something else. Still, TDOSS is so good. Without spoiling anything; the whole theme of that album is incredible (not sure if theme is the right word here)

Alon

Castle and Arose are 10/10 for sure. But I think you pretty much got what we all got when we first heard the album too. I think the worst thing about the album is how many awkward and stilted flows there were. Its hard to know what even went wrong overall here externally. I think maybe he was having some sort midlife crisis. It felt like he completly lost his confidence in his ability and it shows all throughout the project. In the intervening time between MMLP2 and this he was releasing songs/verses that were filled with stuff like that. I think something happened where he kinda forgot how to make good songs. With some exceptions. Maybe Revival needed to happen for him to bounce back as hard as he did. Luckily its all up hill from here thank god lol. Kamikaze is a crazy bounce back and the following albums are even better.

Destare

Seeing Vert sit through these booty painful songs has me crying 😭😭

Smiile

i actually cant wait for the last 3 album reactions

Lia

ur so fucking funny I can’t watch without laughing

J Rex

Oh my god, I can't wait for you to get to MTBMB. It's so fucking good. When's the Kamikaze stream gonna be on?

Glenn Burns

This album is an absolute mess. Framed can't save it.

Ash

Sure it has some good, even great songs but the album in its entirety is pretty bad. Been a long time since I came back to this and it reminded me of the pain I had to endure during my first listen. Gotta appreciate Eminem stepping outside the box though. 🤷‍♂️

Luckigrl

420 I can’t with you…it will be interesting to see if you enjoy kamikaze & MTBMB

Lia

tragic edging ft. Skyler grey

Stefania Tepes

Sorry, I skipped all the way to framed and castle and arose! I can't listen to this again! I feel bad for you Verti! Looking forward to the next album!😬

SVGE Dom

Revival sucks I think it’s because he is using a terrible flow pattern. Hand full of good songs on this but mostly terrible

SVGE Dom

Also every album from here on is great again on god

Hope E Cochrane

I liked Bad husband. He takes responsibility. He always made Kim out to be this horrible evil cheater, but he cheated too. Many times long before she cheated but he never talks about that. Just made people hate her when in fact they hurt each other. She wanted the not- famous, Marshall.

D1.st

Even if my political views don’t match with Em and I have a lot of recent criticisms of his action in recent time due to it being hypocritical for what he’s preached over his career I still recognise him as a good artist, just this album was straight mid and ass except castle and arose + the first song foreal.

RB9

Album gets too much hate, there are some songs with little replay value but some of my favorite em songs in the last 10 years are on this album, walk on water is beautiful idc what anyone says, believe is crazy underrated, river is great, bad husband is great, and castle and arose are amazing, it gets weighed down my the ehh songs so much that those are slept on

Mafi

Didn’t even watch yet bout to rn but wym plug your ears for in your head??? That last verse is fucking fire as fuck bro what

Emball

not from relapse, just his best relapse impression

Jordan Turner

Don't worry it gets better after this Album. Trust!

Emball

Em had a scrapped album in 2007 he was planning on releaseing but overdosed. A lot of the songs have leaked and fans had make recreations of the tracklist. Would you do a reaction if I sent you it?

Mafi

Nah bro idgaf bump me in your head is fire ur trippin

Mladen Markovic

This is my first time listening to the ENTIRE Revival album on the Patreon and I don't think I'll ever do it again. Sometimes I think he intentionally made it bad so he can do Kamikaze right after.

Zeldenx23

I personally enjoyed the album, It is corny. But I enjoyed it as a young teenager,and now im an adult nostalgiac i suppose. It was my first eminem album listening to at launch. Even got it burned on cd.

Zeldenx23

Framed isn't a relapse leftover. It's a complete sequel to 3am :)

Rhys

I can't stand his flow on in your head either, a lot of people give props to that song and i can't stand it honestly.

Joseph

420 Jesus Christ I finally made it through. I will never listen to this album again lol. I don't even really like the songs you liked Verti. Better to pretend the album doesn't exist.

SVGE Dom

The rest of his albums are 10/10 on god

Bjartur

I never even listened to this album because I've just been told it's fucking terrible. Kamikaze is quite good though and MTBMB is one of his best.

Tim Colter

You said during chloroceptic that Em was making fun of SoundCloud rappers. And that's right. This album is like a mirror of rap and our society/politics in that time. The album is about an Older Em fitting in with "today's" rap. So he takes a lot of the most popular flows at that time and ads his spin to it. While trying to actually give a "Message" This album is why people started saying he was "an old guy yelling in the wind" But it's really rebounds back after this album

Daniel Lopez

I can’t wait for kamikaze MTBMB and TDOSS

Daniel Lopez

He remixed chloraseptic to diss Joe budden for criticizing this album and hinting that he was about to release kamikaze and diss everyone who said something negative about him

Chow

PLEASE listen to the chloraseptic remix

A6G

Not liking the cranberries chorus on in your head is criminal though let’s be real. Zombie is an absolute banger. Not liking it is just inappropriate

JR_24

How careful verti is being with his words shows a deep problem with society. Everyone cares so much about other people’s politics its never that deep 😂😂

Kenny

420... damn some parts there were rough

Brandon ghgghh

u should listen to the chloraseptic remix its a whole lot better

Emily Gray

I don't get how people think this is not an " Eminem" album. He's always Been political, he's always had a million flows. I feel like often people miss the point in his non catchy, songs.

ColeJank

All I can say is… we told you lol.

gofur

another great reaction vertical cylinder !

Kai Hunt

you shouldve listened to the chloraseptic remix AFTER listening to revival ngl cuz hearing it before listening to this album is pretty confusing nlg. I personally think this album is NOT as bad as people say it is but I dunno.

Mason Standley

Love the reactions mate, and you are entitled to your own opinion but I can’t help but feel you let the hate around this album influence your opinion before even listening to it 😅 I could be wrong but I think you should listen to bar breakdowns because a lot of bars go over your head (they went over mine too until I watched breakdowns) much love & keep it up brother

Luis

Some of the music on this album genuinely makes my autism need to leave the room.

Vishow

Your reaction to heat 🤣🤣

Vishow

Revival was bad because em forgot about dre

Vishow

"She wants a computar lodged in her vagina"

WhoIsWho

I genuinely thought this was a troll album when I first heard it. But sadly it wasn't :(

Lia

brotha we waiting for kamikaze where are uuuuu

Briana Bonner

I know I’m a bit late, but relapse, and especially recovery were hated when they came out. Relapse made sense for em, but recovery, he put his heart and soul in that album and people just bashed it. Which is one of the reasons why he’s gotten insecure musically.

Rob O'Sullivan

For me this album, as a man who started listening to the (clean version!!) Slim shady LP when it was released, shows conscious progression which, personally some people just don't want, but I personally prefer to some of the stuff on TDOSS

JaSheesh 2K

I have to admit I actually like this album for the most part. Sue me 🤷🏻‍♂️

Jamie Young

Same..I’m surprised Vert wasnt really feeling it, there are a ton of bars and some really interesting concepts and flows. Believe is a personal favorite.

Marco Garcia

Album is fire but I respect your opinion you are gen z this is the best I expect from you. Jk bro love ya

onemonster

I feel like this album is kinda just experimenting or maybe he just was trying something new but it didn't land well with the fans yk but that's just me

Demceez

he foretold how his fans would react to the album on 'walk on water' think he was tryng something new and just wanted to get some non eminem thoughts off his chest..

Laci Hodnett

you hate it… i personally really love this album. one of my favorites. he always has talked ab politics lolll. ppl need to stop being so soft.. he voices his opinions which is what i love ab him.

RealKOE

major L from you vert

KingKaneki Ken

atrocious ah take bro can't believe you hated on bad husband LMAOOO usually you're funny but this is clearly you hating for the sake of it

Brandon DeLeeuw

I don’t know how anyone hates this album. I guess if you’re not into the messages behind the music this would fall short but it’s just one of the many versions of Eminem.

alexinio05

I mean can I be honest I agree with most of this, BUT believe is one of my favorite songs i absolutely love it, and I also dont mind offended and heat

alexinio05

but other than that i agree, and im a BIG eminem fan. I dont mind river or untouchable either but those are more in the ok category.

Darion Ruiz

I know a lot of people didn’t like this album, but my personal faves were definitely bad husband, castle, and arose.

roberts veselis

So quiet video... and.. yea revival is hit or miss.. i kinda liked his wierd poetic flow

larry ♡

I definitely agree that the flows on this album are not the best but I still think it's not as bad as most ppl think, I only can repeatedly listen to about 5 songs from it and the rest I skip but I probs have a bias cos me n the family got the cd at release and listened to it all the time lol, I actually listen to more songs from this than from kamikaze , I'm surprised you hated in your head so much lol the chorus definitely carries it for me cos I love the original song that's sampled for it

Jmo

Probably my favourite on the album, one of my favourite ever em songs icl

PatD

This is my favorite reaction lmfao I love seeing my reaction with someone’s else face, I was pumped waiting for this album and then almost quit listening to him lol

IVANSINCHI

LMAO YOU WERE IN PHYSICAL PAIN Imma be honest me too bro it was actually hard to just sit there.

zayne ibrahim

I’m pretty sure the concept or the lyrics were from the relapse era, but its revival em that’s rapping. You can hear it in his voice. Theres no accent and his voice sounds more mature

LH39

that thing about not doing something if you feel it is not 100% is nice of you to share verti. I also struggle with that a lot

Brandon Erickson

Castle & Arose saved this album from F tier. They were so good that along with the Chloroseptic remix, the album gets a C-. Also, "Framed" was one of the cringiest songs here. Shame on you.

Dylan Orr

Idk if anyone said but ‘Framed’ is actually a sequel to ‘3 A.M.’ In the original he describes his murderous tendencies as a second personality, and in this song it’s his other personality waking up and believing he was framed when in reality he did it all

Milky

Between this and Encore I'm not sure which I think is his worst album, but there are quite some songs I do enjoy a lot in this album: Walk on water Believe In your head Castle Arose Offended (WITHOUT THAT ATTROCIOUS CHORUS) Heat and Framed are OK Untouchable's second half is good So that's 9/17 songs at best, the rest I wouldn't want to sit through...

Ryan Eman

I do think this album is over-hated a bit but it is CLEARLY his worst album. But with that said Walk on Water is the most underrated song of his whole catalog for me. The production is underwhelming and the preaching songs are annoying. But the writing is still brilliant.

Terifictaylor10

Framed sounds so weird to me. The verses sound like he is trying to rap like Snoop but it just sounds strange.

Terifictaylor10

Mark Wahlberg used to be in a group called "Marky Mark and the funky bunch" Em probably used it on the hook as a jab at him because they didn't get along. As far as I know it wasn't a beef but Em would poke fun at how sily it was

Patrick

This album is one of the most annoying things to me... like imagine Walk On Water opener, Castle/Arose finish...and somehow not only is it not a classic, its actually just pure trash. If he had made it a shorter album and kept it focused on introspection, getting older, etc it could have been so fucking good... Still, I love Castle/Arose (though I wish they were just a single long song if Im honest, especially since Im never listening to the album start to finish again :P)

Hannedon

I like how he keeps missing all the best music videos 🫠 (Framed, Fast Lane, etc)

samuel baulch

The offended freestyle was pretty lit 😂

Briana Bonner

29:28 The only way I can describe this is that after MMLP2, Eminem got his health situation fixed up (he had a condition where he had to scream / be really loud to actually hear himself), and I guess he never let go of that style. And since his vocal cords didn’t support that type of style, that’s why he sounds like that. Also, this was the period where he focused more on the technical side of a song more than making a good sounding song. Like with In Your Head, I love that song personally but it’s a good example of this problem. Not focusing on a sound and just rapping.

Briana Bonner

This is random, but I hope you see this cause random info is always cool. The revival we have was rushed and released all in 2017. And you might be thinking “he had 4 years since mmlp2”, which your right. Eminem had an almost finished version of revival from 2016, but scrapped it for whatever reason and rushed out this one. It shows because a lot of these tracks aren’t even from 2017 Walk On Water - 2017 Believe - 2017 Chloraseptic - 2017 Untouchable - 2017 River - 2017 Remind Me (Intro) - 2010-2017 Remind Me - 2017 Revival - 2012-2015 Like Home - 2017 Bad Husband - 2014 Tragic Endings - 2011 Framed - 2017 Nowhere Fast - 2017 Heat - 2017 Offended - 2017 Need Me - 2012 In Your Head - 2013 Castle - 2010/2011 Arose - 2017 Even though I say the majority is from 2017, a lot of the instrumentals are from MMLP2 sessions, since Eminem stopped working w/ Rick Rubin after that album, any beat made by him on that album is from 2012-2013.

Magagins

brother we get it you have a preconceived opinion of the album based on the way it was received. you are hating on every single song no matter what even that last flow on offended, at least try to hide that you are reacting based on how it was received lol

Berserk

This album hurts my heart! When I listen to walk on water, believe, tragic endings, framed, castle and arose.. I’m like yes this SHOULD be a classic and then I listen to the rest, I just become sad of how unfitting it is to Eminem and objectively bad.

Berserk

FRRRRAAAAAAAAMMMMMMMEEEEEDDDDDD

Justin Lee

Framed isnt from Relapse but it is supposed to be a prequel to 3AM