Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Files

NIGHTMARE SWARM ~ BERSERK UNCENSORED

Comments

El of house Wood

You should re review black swordsman now that you known what happened prior.

BlahBlahman

I would say do the Black Swordsman again with the special chapter

Aud

I want to see you more satisfied with this story progression!

BizarreJoe

skip the prototype, its a novelty.

Joe Clarke

I think the prototype is a fun peak into an early draft but nothing mandatory. I would however LOVE to see you read the "Lost" chapter and give us your thoughts on that please.

Waifu Connoisseur

The Prototype is a novelty. It is not canon. it is definitely worth talking about. Black Swordsman is worth revisiting.

Jay Alexander

so the prototype chapter is not part of the actual story, think of it kind of like an unaired test pilot without the ideas being fully formed. It is fun to see the early seeds of Miura's creative journey though and I'd definitely enjoy a re-review of the black swordsman though it may be worth it to fish lost children first as I sort of see it as a belated continuation of that first arc

Jane Sorensen

I'm so glad I subscribed to patreon to see these as they come out. It's almost like I'm a child again, listening to my father tell a bedtime story. If, of course, my dad is a disheveled goblin disguised in the body of a sylvan elf and he's reading me a rated R graphic novel.

Patrick

Proto chapter is okay but its more of a novelty I feel. Seeing early designs from Muira is fascinating but if you're looking for ties to any emotional or dramatic themes of Berserk I didn't personally find any.

Knobody13

Proto chapter is pretty meh. It's kind of like a pilot of the very beginning of black swordsman. The black swordsman definitely hits harder after you have context, but I feel that all of your original criticisms of it still hold true. He just wasn't great at drawing/writing manga yet. I personally don't think it's worth a revisit, and am anxious to see you get to the later parts of the story.

Cairo Copper

I don't think the prototype is required reading by any means, but it is good just to compare and speculate just what Miura had planned for the series and what it ended up becoming as it went.

Joshua

Yes, review prototype and re review black swordsman.

John

I'm tempted to vote no since I'm so hungry for you to progress, but a re-review of black swordsman with the new context could be very interesting! The proto chapter is meh, take it or leave it, if you're curious what Miura's early ideas/rough draft of Berserk looked like, go ahead. But I definitely prefer the version we got.

Jay Alexander

I do think the story implies there's something of a supernatural element to the extraordinary degree of Casca's traumatization, but on the other hand I can't disagree with you that it's hard to have anything but complicated feelings about her state. I'm a bit of two minds about it though, because on the one hand it is a very cruel way for the story to treat her character and victimhood but on the other hand one of the things that I think makes Berserk special is its willingness to take risks with how it emotionally confronts its audience and I can't help appreciating it for that even when it arguably misfires

Diehard_Centaur

I think the "Proto" chapter is pure novelty. I mean its pretty cool to see Berserk's rough draft but that's all it really is. Love your thoughts and analysis as always, criticisms included. I will as appreciate that you do not just "read what's on the page." Part of what makes Berserk wonderful is how chooses to trust the reader. Furthermore, due to the nature of the story and telling, it leaves so much room for different, valid perspectives and interpretations on things while remaining very extremely enjoyable. While many do champion the Golden Age arc (for obvious reasons) as the best arc in Berserk, I humbly disagree. Berserk has so much in store for you and I am excited to see you digest the small stories within this grand epic, the philosophies and commentary within, as well as the development of some of the most complete characters in any media. (An opinion sure but not far fetched I don't think). Thank you again for giving me something to look forward to every week!

Mopman43

I think looking at the Prototype would be interesting, but not necessary if you don't feel like it. Now, a re-review of Black Swordsman I think would be really cool. I do have one suggestion, though- please, if you do that, could you do some commentary on the differences in the art between Black Swordsman and Lost Children? Guts especially evolved over the course of the Golden Age to look much different by the start of Lost Children. If you don't feel up to commenting on the art that's totally fair, but in general, I think a re-review of Black Swordsman should be about both how things read now that you know Guts' backstory, and also about how Miura has evolved at his craft.

Colton Davis

Here’s what I’ll say about the prototype. There’s some cool demon designs in there. That’s it. There’s really not much there.

Jerry Golf

A re review could be pretty interesting I am debating wether or not to suggest the Lost chapter, as it could very well not be considered cannon , as it was withheld from volume releases for a reason

Joe Williams

Also there's a chapter (82) Miura removed from Berserk because he said it revealed too much of the world's cosmology but it introduces maybe my favorite world-building concept of the entire universe. You've already read past where it was set so it wouldn't spoil anything. So just sayin if you want to cover it I think folks would definitely be interested.

A small creature

"Maybe show some slight progress so I have hope as a reader that there could be something in the future" - aww buddy, this is not the section of the story for hope.

Dylan Breslin

I recommend finishing the Lost Children section of the Conviction Arc before doing your Black Swordsman reread. Lost Children feels like Miura taking another crack at Black Swordsman now that he has a much firmer idea of Guts as a character. Black Swordsman is certainly much better on a reread but I think the added context of also having finished Lost Children shows how Miura's writing has improved.

Acoleyte

Re-reviewing Black swordsman would be a very nice video, reading the prototype though is entirely up to you. its not necessary and more just shows some ideas Miura had while he was preparing for the full serialization. also while i completely understand your feelings on the state of Casca's character. All i can really say is voice your criticism, but also trust in miura.

Ivy Beal

Seeing a retrospective on the Black Swordsman arc would be welcome, the context helps roughen out some of the edges, having that fresher in your mind as you finish the Lost Children would be worthwhile. As every one else has said the prototype chapter is a bit of fun but there isn't much there. I wouldn't read the 'lost chapter' (82) that people keep talking about. Miura regretted it and labelled it non canon as he felt it revealed too much too early and that he didn't want them set in stone.

Gradient

The prototype is essentially an early draft of Berserk and definitely falls into the realm of novelty than mandatory reading, but by all means I'm sure many here would still be interested in what you have to say. In terms of re-reviewing The Black Swordsman, I personally don't think you'll get as much out of it narrative-wise as some people say. I find the most interesting aspect of looking back at the very beginning of Berserk is getting to see where the art began and how much it has evolved up to a certain point. You get a great sense of how Miura has developed as an illustrator over the years the further along you get in Berserk.

Jackson teal

I’d like to see the proto chapter and black sword man’s re-review. Berserk is fast paced but I love it. When it comes out biweekly one chapter and then monthly, then the hiatuses, it feels like the chapters are never fast enough with how long the wait is. So in that sense, the fast paced nature is really complementary. But for me, berserk never skips the Really important moments when it needs to slow down. The cliff with casca, the sprint, campfire of dreams, cracks in the blade, bubbles of futility. These chapters stand out sooooo much more because these are slow deep character chapters in contrast to the fast pace story. The fast paced story to get to these moments is more than fine for me. I don’t really care about seeing multiple chapter setup for guts to get his signature sword, that’s just not what berserk is about. If berserk was plot heavy or narrative heavy as say one piece, I feel like it’d lose something in the fast pacing and tight character moments that make it so great. Though berserk does get a lot more plot heavy in later arcs so I guess you’ll like those more. Anyway love the reviews. Also the art is chefs kiss soo good!!

Lews

I recommend finishing the conviction arc, my absolute favorite arc. After that I think it'd good to reread black swordsman/proto if you like!

John

It's 100% not canon. Miura removed it because he changed his mind with how something in the lore would work, and that chapter contradicts it. But it's an interesting chapter

John

But on the flip side, Black Swordsman happens between the events of Golden Age and Lost Children, so if he wants to get closer to reading the events chronologically, he should do his re-read now

Rand al'Thorfinn

I'd definitely be down for a video with a black swordsman revisit + prototype. That being said, like others have pointed out, prototype is kind of just a fun novelty, where you can see some of the beginnings of the series. It's similar structure/story wise to black swordsman, but has a different tone and much less depth. It's definitely not mandatory reading in my mind, but it's a neat little thing in regards to Berserk's origins as a series. Also, the spot they've got prototype in the books is weird (though I'm not sure there would be a good place for it), and breaks up the pacing of The Lost Children mini arc; so maybe doing that video after you finish Lost Children (if you do decide to make said video) would be best pacing wise for your own reading.

Blake Walden

Prototype feels a LOT like Vampire Hunter D to me

Aaron

A post Golden Age retrospective of Blackswordsman would be a really cool video. The prototype chapter was something added to the non-deluxe edition of that volume as a bonus so I dont think it needs a deep dive since it just gives you an idea of what things have changed and what things stay the same for example the Brand's design only changes slightly between prototype and canon. Then there's the eyepatch for Guts that got removed entirely.

Aaron

Which video got remonetized? I'll put that shit on loop.

Jon Knows

Agreed. I think reading the Lost Children first would better and doing a re-review after that.. but on that note I would leave the "prototype" chapters for a later date, because I would love to have at least SOME Berserk content after we get caught up with the manga.

Niel

Like you, i don't like the lost of agencie of Casca, but it makes the event even more horrible. The eclipse and what Femto did broke her. You predicted in another video than Casca would pay an horrific price for Griffith actions. We are there.

Eric Closs

When you continue the lost children arc, you might want to consider the following comparisons: Jill and young Guts // Jill's Father and Gambino // "Elf Queen" and Griffith.

Jon Knows

I would love to see a video where you give your thoughts about The Black Swordsman arc now that you know the full context. However, that can also be left to a later date, because you will eventually catch the series as it is still unfinished. If you're going to read and/or do a video about the prototype, read the Lost Children first.

Rick Fox

I think that looking at the prototype and the black swordsman arc in one video would be worthwhile. You could see some evolution from Miura there I think and the comparison could be worthwhile as it covers some similar material.

IBG_Music

Do what you want, re review of the black swordsman is awesome!

Chema Sanchez

Prototype is not worth it imo i´d prefer you continue the main story tbh

Aaron

your critique of Miura being choppy when getting back into gear after a big climax is true. I would like to give some context to why that maybe. It largely has to do with the Manga industry as a whole. Mangakas (manga writers and illistrators) put in insane hours to make the deadlines publishers put on them. When Miura was releasing these chapters he was putting them out twice a month with only a few breaks in that time. Ironically he had a month and a half break between Armament and He Who Hunts Dragons. Which might explain the uptick in zoning into the narrative.

Hawk of Light

I mentioned this a long time ago in one of your videos, but yes, berserk has a tendency for having unnecessary nudity a lot of times, this is because berserk publishes in young animal (a Japanese adult magazine for men) so editors make it pretty much mandatory for anyone who publishes their manga in that magazine to have some sort of nudity, (trust me I bough one of their issues and it’s almost every two pages there’s boobs or a sex scene lol) The prototype is pretty much irrelevant to the story, could make for a fun short video, although I would prefer to hear your thoughts about the BSM arc next.

Andrew Light

Reliving this story again with you is such a joy!! Gosh, I even got into Patreon for the first time. Thank you for it!! As for what to make the next time, I don't really remember whether I read Prototype in my reading through, so I am curious to get it summarized by you (plus, some reminiscing on the road you've made from not liking Berserk to appreciating it will never be not heartwarming to watch (the power of Berserk fans)). That being said, I can't wait to see your experience with the next chapters, so either way - I am all for it.

tealtraveler

A relook at the black swordsman would be great. Tacking on the Proto chapter alongside it would be good to do in the same video. And this would be a perfect point in your reading of Berserk to go back and reflect on where it started.

Lorenzo Linares

Jill wasnt hiding from her dad, but from her Dad's drunk friends. Earler in the chapter one of her Dads friends says something like "sorry about last night" and then there is a panel of Jills face and all you see of fear on it..... the implication is clear.... i dont think you picked up on this.

Lorenzo Linares

Finish the Chapter of Lost Children first please!.... its my absolute favorite part of Berserk

Samuel Tardif

I would like for you to continue with the story, but I would also like to see how your view of the black Swordsman changed, don't care much about the proto-chapter though.

Beignet Boy

I would save prototype and rereview of Black Swordsman until you catch up with the volumes.

benjamin ibañez

I do think a reread of the beggining would be a good idea at this point, considering you have all the relevant information for the Black Swordsman. I guess you could read the prototype if you do this.

NKellyy

I think revisiting the black swordsman arc would be pretty cool but you should do it after finishing the conviction arc completely. Checking out the Prototype would also be cool, its a fun read.

David Sonne

You should check out the prototype chapter, it's really neat. Maybe after Lost Children or Conviction arc? Love your vids.

Matin Nikoomanzar

It's better if you make a short separate video from the prototype chapter after the arc because it is a really short story and he drew that when he was really young so there is no depth to the story. but it is still a fun read and you should check it out later!

quaxk

I think do the prototype maybe after conviction

Jacob Martinez

Would definitly enjoy a retrospective review of the Black Swordsmen

Sam Lindsay

I feel that you should finish the Lost Children section first and then do a retrospective of The Black Swordsmen. Because I'm always down for more berserk content in any shape or form.

Alex

A bunch of people are suggesting to do after Lost Children/Conviction But then they’re also saying any excuse for more content, if that’s the case I think it would be worth you tackling that now, give your current take (that will already be more developed since your initial read) and then perhaps to do another similar “review” at the end of conviction in the same vein, to reflect how things have changed. See, more content, everybody wins Loving your experience with this work so far Daniel. Arigato! P.s. Just realised you’re referring to the “prototype” chapter and not the “omitted” chapter that was never officially “published” but had been distributed online as “pre-lease” content before Miura decided it was “too revealing”. Not sure how you would feel about seeking out content that sheds a lot of light on what we expect to be part of the grand conclusion to this story. But in all fairness, anyone who calls themselves a fan of this story has seen this lost chapter and it is very interesting, and gives a lot of context to the nature of the world. I won’t blame you if you’d rather experience things as Miura seems to have wanted though, so you’re choice ^_^

Derrick McBride

I noticed 2 things that you might find important, Jill isn't hiding f get father from what I remember, but her father's friends, so while he dad is messed up, he's not that messed up. The other thing which I love, is that when guts is being confronted by the towns people, he's thinking to himself how easy it would be to murder them all, until puck stops him

Frederick Jaskowski

re-reviewing Black Swordsmen with Golden Age "hindsight" would be interesting. the Berserk Prototype is interesting to see what ideas did or didn't end up staying in the actual story.

Frederick Jaskowski

indeed, the "Lost Chapter" is definitely one of the most interesting bits of lore/worldbiulding and a final bit of character insight for Griffith/Femto(which to be honest is probably the more interesting part), and it definitely still fits into the story we have. and also, as usual, amazing artwork. the only reason not to read it(well, besides "Miura said so") would be Daniel's own words from his Eclipse coverage where he said he liked not knowing the details of what Griffith was seeing in the deepest darkest parts of that whole vision thing he had during his transformation.

Chema Sanchez

i think it´s better if he gets on with the main story and maybe when he catches up do the re-reads and side stories