Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Big Shiny TV Poll 2

  • 12 Monkeys 27
  • Andor 54
  • Arcane 40
  • Battlestar Galactica (2003) 38
  • Buffy The Vampire Slayer 56
  • Dark 16
  • Deadwood 30
  • Fawlty Towers 24
  • Haunting of Hill House 28
  • His Dark Materials 11
  • Justified 28
  • Legion 9
  • Mindhunter 40
  • Person of Interest 20
  • Pushing Daises 21
  • Rome 22
  • Schitt's Creek 13
  • Sherlock 38
  • Shogun 19
  • Star Trek The Original Series 26
  • The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance 11
  • The Expanse 56
  • The Magicians 21
  • The Wire 35
  • Twisted Metal (Season 2, Season 1 is in our back catalogue) 4
  • 2025-09-24
  • —2025-09-29
  • 687 votes
{'title': 'Big Shiny TV Poll 2', 'choices': [{'text': '12 Monkeys', 'votes': 27}, {'text': 'Andor', 'votes': 54}, {'text': 'Arcane', 'votes': 40}, {'text': 'Battlestar Galactica (2003)', 'votes': 38}, {'text': 'Buffy The Vampire Slayer', 'votes': 56}, {'text': 'Dark', 'votes': 16}, {'text': 'Deadwood', 'votes': 30}, {'text': 'Fawlty Towers', 'votes': 24}, {'text': 'Haunting of Hill House', 'votes': 28}, {'text': 'His Dark Materials', 'votes': 11}, {'text': 'Justified', 'votes': 28}, {'text': 'Legion', 'votes': 9}, {'text': 'Mindhunter', 'votes': 40}, {'text': 'Person of Interest', 'votes': 20}, {'text': 'Pushing Daises', 'votes': 21}, {'text': 'Rome', 'votes': 22}, {'text': "Schitt's Creek", 'votes': 13}, {'text': 'Sherlock', 'votes': 38}, {'text': 'Shogun', 'votes': 19}, {'text': 'Star Trek The Original Series', 'votes': 26}, {'text': 'The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance', 'votes': 11}, {'text': 'The Expanse', 'votes': 56}, {'text': 'The Magicians', 'votes': 21}, {'text': 'The Wire', 'votes': 35}, {'text': 'Twisted Metal (Season 2, Season 1 is in our back catalogue)', 'votes': 4}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 29, 13, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 24, 0, 40, 22, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 687}

Content

Before we get started, last week's poll winner was Comedy Horror. So we're going to finish the trilogy and watch Army of Darkness! Thanks to everyone for their wonderful suggestions, we're going to keep them to build a future poll.This week's poll was an absolute beast to wrangle. We started with almost 200 suggestions, and had to narrow it to just 25! We reviewed every single response, and tried to pick a good variety of genres for the poll. If your favorite didn't make the cut try not to fret, just because a show isn't on this list doesn't mean we won't do it.

This poll is a little different from normal, in that the winner(s) don't necessarily guarantee we'll get to them right away, it's more of a chance for us to get an idea on what kind of shows y'all are interested in. You can also vote for as many shows as you like, so it's the most helpful if you put a tick beside any TV show you'd be interested in watching with us!

Last note is that these shows are all ones that we'll watch together, we'll have a future poll to cover the shows that will be Chandra only (last year we mixed them all into one poll).

So without further ado, here are the 25 poll options:

Comments

djKENTO

Let’s go DEADWOOD!!!

Nathan Jasper

Oh yes, I so hope 12 Monkeys or Dark Materials wins!!

John Colson

Disappointed that The Sopranos didn't make the cut but at least Mindhunter did. David Fincher (Seven) is the creator.

Patrick

Rome would be so awesome, such a shame it came out before the TV industry was ready for shows of its ambition. Somewhere out there is an alternate universe where it got its planned 5 seasons and spawned even more historical epic series. Edit: Didn't realise it was multiple choice so I also voted for Mindhunter and The Expanse!

N.T. Stars

I hate this poll. There are too many good things on it. I love it and hate it.

Ian A

Oh man! So many great choices. Nice suggestions everyone! I picked mostly shorter ones and 1 uber show with a billion seasons just cuz its in my top 3 favorite shows ever.

Darian Harman

This is a ridiculously amazing list. I have friends everywhere, so say we all!

Dan

Pulling for Justified! If anyone hasn't seen it, just watch the first episode and come back to this poll with your thoughts 👍

Kevin Karst

BUFFY!!! 😍😍😍 Still my favorite show after so many years, I must have watched every episode more than 10 times.

Michael Jones

Andor. It’s only 24 episodes and it’s some of the best TV of any kind ever.

Lesley and Zack

We rewatch Haunting of Hill House often, but Andor would probably be my second choice!

Lesley and Zack

Nevermind. I take it all back. I just saw Dark is on there. Best show of all time. It will blow your minds.

KamikazeCDN

Shame Sons of Anarchy didn't make the cut this time around but I'll hold out hope that one day that show will get the attention is deserves. In it's absence The Expanse and Mindhunter get a tick from me.

Stropheum

12 monkeys is amazing

jasonm

I think you would love Buffy, but it's a big undertaking for a channel. 7 seasons and the spin-off, and they overlap for four seasons.

Jayson Phillips

I'm so tired of Andor people always dominating, Arcane is so much better! She is already watching book of Boba Fett!

TONY T

mindhunter pls, give me a reason to rewatch it

Sam

I mean, The Wire is objectively the best show ever made, so I'm voting Buffy the Vampire Slayer for some healthy competition.

schizophrenia

Almost too many great choices. You could pick randomly and still come up with something good.

Rhiannon

Not enough votes for Twisted Metal season 2!!!! The second season is even better than the first.

Rhiannon

That's a great show.

Snuggelbum

waaaaaaay too many options here in my honest opinion... also, it would be smart to differentiate between mini-series' and full, multiple-seasons series. full series' will tie up your channel for a HUGE amount of time compared to a mini-series.

Snuggelbum

also, the only real choice on this list is Shogun, and you know it

Joshua Gideon

Hopefully if they go that route they somehow find the standard definition of Buffy as we fans know HD version butchered the show

ShadowDrgn

So many good choices: Buffy, Justified, BSG (maybe the greatest show ever made) only personal preference that's not on this list: Sons of Anarchy

Matthew Langley

So many great shows, but The Magicians is so fun, you'd absolutely love it and it needs more attention. Needs more votes!

Alecco

DARK its such a good, unique and relatively small series!

Jon Johns

I'm curious, what about Andor don't you like?

neil katz

Expanse pluuuuuuease

Nathan Jasper

I love that Buffy beat Andor by two votes lol

Bo

Just joined the patreon and found this poll. Pleasantly surprised that Buffy The Vampire Slayer has gotten so many votes. Bummed that The Wire didn't get more votes (it's so damn good!). Absolutely flabbergasted by the fact that The Expanse gets so many votes. The universe in that show is pretty, but the writing is horrible, and the actors even worse. Almost all the characters are so hopelessly caricatured and predictable. You just don't care enough about any of protagonists to engage in the show. And it suffers from that Netflix sickness of stretching the show longer than it should. By the end of season 3, I had started fast forwarding, just out of sheer boredom.

Kay

Belated mail in vote for BSG