[COLUMN] The Selective Nostalgia of Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero | by Darren Mooney (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
Note: This piece contains spoilers for Godzilla Minus Zero, which opened in theaters this weekend. It also contains allusions to - and links documenting - extremely graphic real-life history, which may be unsettling.
There is an interesting moment in Godzilla Minus Zero as traumatized naval scientist Kenji Noda (Hidetaka Yoshioka) ruminates on his sins. He confesses to feeling the weight of countless soldiers pushing down on him, and the hope that perhaps through his actions in response to the arrival of the monstrous Godzilla and King Ghidorah might offer him some path to redemption.
At the climax, Noda gets his wish. After one of the traps designed to hold King Ghidorah malfunctions, Noda bravely drives a jeep into the combat zone to set it off manually himself. However, while trying to escape, his vehicle crashes. Noda is pinned under it as pilot Kōichi Shikishima (Ryunosuke Kamiki) enters the fray. Following the plan, Shikishima ignites the fuel to immolate the temporarily incapacitated Ghidorah. In doing so, he also kills Noda.
After Noda’s death is reported, Shikishima panics. The two were friends. They had survived the events of Godzilla Minus One together. Shikishima is wracked with guilt that he may have indirectly caused the death of his colleague. To allay his guilt, Noda’s colleague Makoto Aoyama (Masami Nagasawa) lies to Shikishima, telling the pilot that the scientist was actually killed by Ghidorah. This is portrayed as an act of kindness, sparing Shikishima further trauma and horror.
It is also an entire plot thread that feels very instructive when it comes to Takashi Yamazaki’s twin Godzilla films, Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero. These are two films that often feel like they are consciously and actively avoiding reckoning with any sort of guilt or responsibility, perhaps even using the horrific trauma of the Second World War, and in particular the atomic horror that Godzilla represents, as a way to avoid directly confronting the elephant in the room.
Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero represent something of a “back to basics” approach to the iconic movie monster, taking the creature back to his roots. Ishirō Honda’s Godzilla was released in 1954, less than a decade after the dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the Japanese surrender. The film literalized the anxieties of the atomic age, with the eponymous monster awakened by atomic testing and defeated by a new weapon of mass destruction.
Godzilla Minus One rolled the clock back even further. The film is set in the immediate aftermath of the Second World War. The cast is made of characters who have lived through the conflict. Shikishima’s parents died during the firebombing of Tokyo. In Godzilla Minus Zero, it is revealed that Kanji Murakami (Min Tanaka) lived through Hiroshima only to later see Matsumoto destroyed by King Ghidorah, evoking the true story of Tsutomu Yamaguchi, who lived through both atomic bombings.
Many of the characters in Godzilla Minus One are explicitly veterans of the armed forces of Imperial Japan. Shikishima was a kamikaze pilot, albeit one who lacked the resolve to follow through on the suicide run. Noda was a naval scientist. These men are dispossessed in postwar Japan, dishonored by defeat and returning to a country in ruins. They are also implicitly emasculated, with the Japanese military apparatus dismantled by the victorious Allies. Their arc consists of them using their military skills to defend Japan.
One of the more interesting aspects of Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero is the extent to which the films are interested in and engaged with America, both textually and metatextually. As a filmmaker, Yamazaki is very heavily influenced by American cinema. He cites Star Wars, Close Encounters of the Third Kind and Back to the Future as his “origin story.” The best sequence in Godzilla Minus One is riffing on Jaws. And, fitting, Steven Spielberg is a fan.
And this external curiosity arguably paid off. Godzilla Minus One was a massive hit. It was the highest-grossing live action Japanese film of all-time at the American box office. It earned the franchise its first Academy Award. Godzilla Minus Zero just topped the American box office in its opening weekend, beating The Cat in the Hat and scoring the biggest opening weekend of any live action non-English-language film. These films are truly international.
The films themselves are very fascinated by Japan’s relationship to America in the immediate aftermath of the war. In Godzilla Minus One, the American military seemingly abandons Japan to deal with Godzilla on their own. In Godzilla Minus Zero, the Americans plan to abduct Godzilla and confiscate Murakami’s research to weaponize it. Meanwhile, Murakami harbors his own revenge fantasies of using Godzilla to destroy New York in retaliation for the bombing of Hiroshima.
This portrayal of the turbulent relationship between Japan and the United States is far from unique within the larger Godzilla franchise. The Godzilla film immediately prior to Godzilla Minus One, Shin Godzilla, spends its entire first half having the Japanese administration beholden to the self-interest of the Americans. Given that it’s widely held that the atomic bombings of two civilian targets could constitute war crimes, and America’s role in shaping postwar Japan, this take is not unreasonable.
However, this willingness to explore the troubled relationship between the United States and Japan as victor and loser of the Second World War only serves to draw attention to the conspicuous absence of any other larger geopolitical or social context from these films. Watching Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero, the understanding of the Second World War is that the United States won and that Japan lost, and that these soldiers must find some purpose and dignity amid the ruins of their homeland.
Going back to the Second World War is an interesting choice, but it makes sense for Yamazaki as a filmmaker. Yamazaki is an inherently nostalgic director. In fact, Godzilla Minus One was not his first time working with the atomic monster. The classic version of Godzilla had a minor cameo in Yamazaki’s early film, Always: Sunset on Third Street 2, the second in a trilogy of films covering Tokyo’s recovery from 1958 through 1964.
Godzilla Minus One also isn’t the first time that Yamazaki has made a movie with a kamikaze pilot at its center. He adapted Naoki Hyakuta’s The Eternal Zero, about a young law student (Haruma Miura) who discovers that his grandfather was Kyuzo Miyabe (Junichi Okada), a kamikaze pilot who – like Shikishima – was regarded as a coward for not following through on his suicide run. The film ends with Miyabe reaching a state of calm as his plane flies into an American aircraft carrier.
The Eternal Zero was a somewhat controversial film in Japan. Critics considered the film “creepy, weepy apologia for the war.” There was outspoken pushback on the film. “They’re trying to make a Zero fighter story based on a fictional war account that is a pack of lies,” opined filmmaker Hayao Miyazaki. “They’re just continuing a phony myth, saying ‘Take pride in the Zero fighter.’ I’ve hated that sort of thing ever since I was a kid.”
The film was embraced by nationalist elements of the establishment. Japan’s Prime Minister at the time, Shinzo Abe, gave the film “high praise.” This is perhaps not a huge surprise. Abe and Hyakuta were “close.” Hyakuta was among the first to publicly confirm Abe’s passing. Abe appointed Hyakuta to the board of Japan’s national broadcaster NHK, where he stoked controversy by decrying the Tokyo tribunals convicting Japanese war criminals and denying the Nanjing massacre.
Japan has a long history of downplaying its involvement in war crimes across Asia, denying various atrocities. In this context, Yamazaki is an interesting filmmaker, with Inagaki Takatoshi contending that “there is no filmmaker in Japan working today who is as focused on Japan during and after World War II as Yamazaki.” As such, what Yamazaki chooses to talk about – and what he pointedly opts not to talk about – is important.
Yamazaki’s films walk a fine line. They are critical of the government and the leaders responsible for the Second World War. However, they valorize the soldiers, who are often presented as true patriots. The Eternal Zero ends with Miyabe finding peace dying for his country. The Great War of Archimedes suggests that Vice Admiral Tadamichi Hirayama (Min Tanaka) deliberately sabotaged the battleship Yamato in the hopes of forcing a surrender and thus saving Japan as a nation.
In Yamazaki’s films about the Second World War, no soldier of Imperial Japan is ever shamed by what they have done or even by what other soldiers have done in their name. They are, instead, shamed by poor leadership, leadership that is often judged to have failed its own people rather than the between 3,000,000 and 10,000,000 Chinese people killed as a result of Japanese imperialism or the victims in Manila or Nanjing. These films do not argue that the Japanese soldiers and civilians were also victims in the war, but that they were the only victims.
One might assume, for example, when the haunted scientist Noda breaks down in tears at the terrible things that he has done, that the film might be obliquely acknowledging the human experimentation conducted by Japanese scientists on prisoners in China, including Americans. It certainly fits with how much Noda knows about the utility of decompression and liquid nitrogen when employed against human flesh, both of which were subjects of those grotesque war crimes.
However, from the way that Noda and the people around him talk about it, it seems more likely that he feels guilty over the loss of Japanese lives, implicitly his involvement in the kaiten program, the suicidal human torpedoes. Perhaps the reaction to Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero might be different if they were set in Europe, featuring a group of former Wehrmacht soldiers and a German scientist who knows a lot about creative ways to kill things as they form a militia to defend the German people after Hitler’s suicide.
This has been a source of controversy around the films. Godzilla Minus One did not get a theatrical release in Korea, a country that has very strained relations with Japan owing to Japan’s imperial legacy. When the film was released on Netflix in South Korea, it prompted debates about the portrayal of the Japanese military. Inuhiko Yomota, author of The Menace from the South Seas, one of the seminal academic works on Godzilla, called Godzilla Minus One a “dangerous movie.”
And the response to these criticisms might simply be to point out that this is not what these films are about. Not every film needs to directly address these past atrocities. Japan does not need to constantly apologize for those crimes. However, when a film is explicitly set in this specific context and dealing with these specific themes, the absence of any engagement with these events feels very pointed. It raises the question of why these films are set in this era at all, beyond the nostalgic aesthetic.
The suggestion that the films can avoid this uncomfortable subtext serves to imply that attitudes towards the military apparatus – not just the people who served, but the weapons and vehicles they use, the skills they honed – can be separated from the wider context in which that apparatus was built and the purpose to which it was set. Even Spielberg’s Raiders of the Lost Ark is haunted by the Holocaust. After all, any horror film fan knows what is not shown is often as important as what is.
Indeed, Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero even seem odd in the larger context of the franchise, where films further from the immediate aftermath of the Second World War have grappled with Japan’s place in the world more skillfully. Godzilla, Mothra and King Ghidorah: Giant Monsters All-Out Attack, the twenty-sixth film in the franchise, reimagines Godzilla as the manifestation of the victims of Japanese imperialism, manifesting against a nation trying to forget.
“The souls of countless people who fell victim in the Pacific War have congregated in the body of Godzilla,” explains Professor Hirotoshi Isayama (Hideyo Amamoto), at the turn of the new millennium. “Why is it trying to destroy Japan?” asks reporter Yuri Tachibana (Chiharu Niiyama). “Because people have forgotten it completely,” Isayama responds. “Forgotten the agony of those killed in the war... forgotten their cries...”
Even in Shin Godzilla, a movie just as skeptical about Japan’s relationship to America as either Godzilla Minus One or Godzilla Minus Zero, there is a rejection of Japanese nationalism. Japan only survives through international cooperation – using German computing power to decode data, sharing information with the French to block plans by other powers to drop an atomic bomb and even China providing tankers to help move necessary chemicals quickly. Former geopolitical rivals have to become allies, if anyone is to survive.
In the closing scene of Shin Godzilla, functionary Rando Yaguchi (Hiroki Hasegawa) ruminates on what the monster represents. “Japan,” he begins, before catching himself. “No, humanity must coexist with Godzilla.” There is a sense that it is necessary for Japan to look outside itself when dealing with an existential threat on this level. In contrast, the subtext of Godzilla Minus One and Godzilla Minus Zero suggests that nowhere outside Japan – and maybe America – really matters.
Noda’s death in Godzilla Minus Zero is very instructive in trying to understand how these two films see the world. Terrible things have happened, and countless people have suffered, but it’s not worth dwelling on the particulars because there has been enough pain and torture. However, it’s always worth asking whose discomfort is deemed more important.