Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This week's episode of Design Delve is now available!

Files

How to Spot AI Art in Games | Design Delve

This video is brought to you by Death at Fleming Manor, a forensic mystery with art inspired by 1960s European detective comics. Explore eerie scenes, analyze evidence, and complete death certificates and emergency reports. – https://store.steampowered.com/app/3758950/Death_at_Fleming_Manor/ In today’s episode, J & Ludo discuss how they spot AI art is games and how you can do the same! Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/SecondWindGroup Second Wind Merch: https://shop.secondwindgroup.com/

Comments

Willhart

Some notes: the most advanced video model currently are Seedance 2.0 and Minmax H3, which both support videos up to 30 seconds long, and with lots of reference images. Also some LLM models to code animations via vector art which bypasses many video model limitations, making them harder to notice. There are image models that have been trained for pixel art style, which tend to look much better compared to general models with wider focus. Retrodiffusion has been experimenting with stuff like animations and minecraft textures too, and has tools for fixing color palette and pixel alignment. Funnily enough the Flemming Manor game you mentioned kinda looks like AI, since I see that particular comic like art style used a lot by chatGPT. It has Blurry text and images on the background, burned out colors, morphed ears, strange inconsistencies on textures. Fortunately the "SUPERTHUMb Game Art" YT channel shows how everything was actually made with different layers and textures on CLIP STUDIO PAINT. It has only 19 subscribers, so you should definitely shout them out..

Nicarus86

I really don't have an issue with AI being used as long as it's an aid like using it as a springboard to get an idea going. Need to visualize a concept that's hard to explain by words alone? Have AI generate an image or scene, then have artists actually make it authentically. One good example of this is when that AI dress popped up on Twitter/X and everybody started drawing characters in said dress. Once regulations are properly set for AI, I think it could potentially grant artists a fantastic method to elevate their works by either helping with consistency within their own individual works or as an idea visualizor.

Badger

The problem with LLM creations is the theft used to train the program every item made past that start is fruit from a poisoned tree. I get that it is a cost saver or can open up other markets faster but at a greater cost once you take the cheap fast option quality is never the standard going forward. Fast & Cheap or Cost & Quality.

Davsau

I feel like there needs to be some sort of not for profit, independent group where devs can submit their game, show their work and get certified as 100% Human. I hate that we have to treat buying games like we’re buying dolphin safe tuna.

August Li

My cousin has a small merch firm that started using AI a bit into 2025 to generate product sample art for clients (they help develop merch, posters, plushies, figures, and the requisite design and art to make those products for IP holders). Before this, they needed their artists to draw original art for the samples and wrap that and render that on a 3d object or photoshop it onto stock photos of some store or place, for some clients they would 3d uv print a sample and photograph in a small office studio. This kind of takes time unevenly from artists since not everyone can do every step, though some can. The art also may never get seen or might only get seen by a handful of people making the decision. AI art just generating product samples in a wide variety of scenarios or variations has saved their artists time for stuff that will more likely see the light of day.

Nanimon

Kinda disgusted that you didn't mention the environmental impact of ai data centers. You make it sound like the only ethical issue with using them is purely legal and if they just legally acquired rights to the training data then it'd be fine for them to contaminate water supplies, emit massive amounts of CO2 in the middle of the climate crisis, give locals incurable diseases, destroy forests for more data centers and all the other material harms this technology causes. If any art project needs that sort of damage to be made then it shouldn't exist.

Ronny Cook

I'm going to play a little bit of devil's advocate here. It's not stealing. It's copyright violation. It's exactly as justifiable as piracy of games and television. Anybody complaining about AI training but justifying piracy should reconsider one of the two positions. For the record, I don't think either is OK. If you don't want to pay the creator, don't consume (or otherwise use) the media. The only real exception I can see is abandonware, where there is no path to paying the creator. Full disclosure here, I was an enthusiastic pirate as a kid - and later of fansubbed anime where there was no local distributor.

AbsimiliJon

No, mate. Nobody in the creative field *needs* to use tech based on plagiarism that costs people their jobs, bends the global economy over a barrel and wrecks the environment.