Parllel world Manga Artist: The Cost of the Thing [422] (Patreon)
Content
Naruto was in trouble.
Not the anime. The anime was fine. The ratings had settled at 7.8% after the Pain arc and had held there for eleven weeks without moving in either direction, which for any other property in Japan would have been a triumph and which for Naruto was the flattest stretch the series had seen in four years.
The trouble was that everyone had noticed.
"Eleven weeks since the Pain arc ended and I have not once been excited to sit down on a Thursday."
"That's not fair. The aftermath episodes were good. Naruto being carried through the village was good."
"That was week one. I'm talking about weeks two through eleven."
"Konoha rebuilding. Danzo being named candidate Hokage. Kakashi not being named Hokage. Political stuff."
"I don't watch this show for political stuff."
"Shirogane cut all the filler. There's no filler. Everything airing is manga content."
"I know there's no filler. That's what's confusing me. It's the actual story and it's still not landing."
"It's a comedown. It's just a comedown. The Pain arc was the highest this anime has ever been and everything after it was always going to feel like this."
"How long does a comedown last"
"apparently eleven weeks"
Rei was aware of it.
He had been aware of it before it happened, because he had lived through this exact stretch in a previous life and had watched a fandom spend years complaining about it. He had cut over fifty episodes of filler out of the Japan version, which had solved the pacing problem entirely and had done nothing whatsoever about the structural one.
The structural one was that the Pain arc was where Naruto's personal story resolved.
The boy had wanted the village to acknowledge him. At the end of the Pain arc the village carried him through the streets on their shoulders. That was the goal, closed, on screen, in front of twelve percent of the country.
Everything after it was a different story wearing the same title.
"So what do we do about it," Kobayashi had asked, in a production meeting in week six, when the ratings had held flat for the fourth consecutive fortnight.
"Nothing."
"Shirogane-sensei..."
"There is nothing to do about it. This is the shape of the story. Naruto got what he wanted and now the story has to become about something bigger than what he wanted, and that transition is uncomfortable, and it is supposed to be uncomfortable." Rei had tapped the schedule. "We hold. We run the Five Kage Summit as written."
"For how long?"
"Until Sasuke walks into the room."
The Five Kage Summit began in week twelve.
It did not start well.
The first two episodes were, by any honest reading, the least eventful Naruto had produced in three years. Five leaders in a room. Formal introductions. Argument about jurisdiction, about the Akatsuki, about who bore responsibility for the tailed beasts. Danzo manoeuvring. The Raikage furious about his brother. Gaara, twenty years old, trying to be heard by men twice his age.
The ratings held at 7.8%.
"Two episodes of adults in a room talking about policy."
"It's setup."
"It's ALWAYS setup. That's what I said about weeks two through eleven and then it was still setup."
"Gaara's speech was good though"
"Gaara's speech was excellent and nobody in that room listened to him which was the point"
"honestly that hit me. Gaara stands up in front of five leaders and says something true and they talk over him because he's twenty and they've decided he's a child"
"He's a Kage. He's literally the same rank as them."
"He's a Kage who used to be a monster and they all remember it. That's the subtext and Shirogane doesn't spell it out once."
"ok that's a good scene but two episodes of it"
"THREE. There's a third one next week."
There was a third one.
It aired on a Thursday in the eight o'clock slot, on Kyoto Television, and it opened on the Raikage demanding to know why Konoha had failed to deal with Sasuke Uchiha.
Kajiwara Nobuhiko was not watching.
He had followed Naruto for years and had stopped opening the tape recorder on Thursdays about a month earlier, without deciding to, in the way that you stop doing things.
His wife asked him about it once and he said the show had got boring, which he did not entirely believe when he said it.
Tsukamoto Ryoji was nineteen and had watched Naruto since he was thirteen.
He was in his first year at a university in Osaka and he watched it in the common room of his hall with somewhere between four and eleven other people depending on the week, and the number had been going down.
That Thursday there were six of them.
"Is anything happening in this one."
"Kage summit part three."
"Part THREE."
"Just watch it."
"I'm going to do my reading."
"You've said that for four weeks and you've never once done the reading."
The episode opened on the summit chamber.
The Raikage was on his feet, which he had been for most of two episodes, demanding that Konoha explain how a nineteen year old defector was still alive and still operating and still killing people who worked for him.
Danzo deflected. Danzo was good at deflecting. He had spent two episodes being good at it and Ryoji had spent two episodes disliking him with an intensity that surprised him, because Danzo had never once raised his voice or done anything overtly villainous on screen. He simply answered questions with other questions and let other men take responsibility for things.
Gaara tried to speak.
The Raikage cut across him.
"He's doing it again," somebody in the common room said.
"He does it every episode."
"Gaara's the only one in that room who's actually right and they won't let him finish a sentence."
Then the doors opened.
Not the main doors. A side entrance, off the corridor where the samurai guard were stationed, and the animation cut to the corridor and there was a body on the floor and a man in white kneeling beside it.
Ryoji sat up.
"Wait."
"What."
"Shh."
The cut back to the chamber. Nobody inside knew yet. The Raikage was still talking.
And then the sound design did something that Ryoji would try to describe to people for years and would never get right.
The dialogue kept going. The Raikage kept shouting. And underneath it, very quietly, at the edge of the mix, there was a sound from somewhere down the corridor that was not part of the conversation.
Nobody in the room reacted to it.
The audience heard it.
Somebody in the common room said, "What was that noise."
"There's no noise."
"Listen."
Six people leaned toward a television.
The chamber doors came off their hinges.
Not opened. Came off. The whole frame went, and the smoke came in with it, and standing in the gap was a figure in black with a sword and one eye visible under the hair.
The common room made a noise.
Ryoji was up out of his chair.
"SASUKE"
"HE WALKED IN"
"HE WALKED INTO A ROOM WITH FIVE KAGE IN IT"
Five of the most powerful people in the world, in a fortified chamber, surrounded by samurai, staring at a nineteen year old who had come through the door alone and had not said anything yet.
Then Sasuke said one line, and it was not a threat, and it was not a speech.
[Where is Danzo.]
The common room detonated.
"HE'S NOT HERE FOR THEM"
"HE DOESN'T CARE ABOUT ANY OF THEM"
"He came through five Kage to get to ONE MAN"
"He's nineteen. He is NINETEEN."
The fight, when it started, was the fastest thing Naruto had animated.
Rei had made a specific decision about this sequence, which was that Sasuke should not appear to be winning at any point. Not once. The original had let the fight breathe as a contest.
The Raikage went through a wall and Sasuke went with him.
Amaterasu came out and burned everything it touched and did not stop burning.
Sasuke's Susanoo formed for the first time in the series, ribcage first, incomplete, skeletal, and the animation held on the way it did not fully close, because he could not hold it yet.
And the Raikage broke through it anyway, and took his arm off at the shoulder to do it.
"THE RAIKAGE TOOK HIS OWN ARM OFF"
"He didn't hesitate. He didn't even look at it."
"That's the scariest thing this show has ever done and there's no blood in the shot"
"That man cut off his own arm rather than let a teenager escape and then he KEPT GOING"
Ryoji was standing with both hands on the back of a chair.
There were now eleven people in the common room. Word had gone down the corridor.
The episode ended with Sasuke pulled out by Tobi at the last possible moment, half dead, Susanoo collapsed, and the Raikage standing in the wreckage with one arm, and the last shot was not on any of them.
It was on Gaara.
Gaara, standing in the ruins of a summit chamber, looking at the place where Sasuke had been.
The credits rolled.
[2channel - NARUTO EP - SASUKE AT THE SUMMIT - PART 1]
"NARUTO IS BACK"
"NARUTO IS BACK. ELEVEN WEEKS. IT'S BACK."
"I have not been out of my chair for this show since the Pain arc and I am currently standing up"
"THE RAIKAGE CUT OFF HIS OWN ARM"
"I want to talk about the sound design. Did anyone else catch it. There's a noise under the Raikage's dialogue for about fifteen seconds before the door goes and nobody in the room reacts to it."
"I heard something and thought my speakers were broken"
"It's not your speakers. It's deliberate. Shirogane put a threat in the audio mix that the characters can't hear and we can."
"That's terrifying actually. We knew before they did."
[2channel - NARUTO GENERAL - PART 903]
"Serious post. I've been one of the people complaining for eleven weeks and I want to say something.
I think I was wrong about the last eleven weeks.
Not because they were exciting. They weren't. But go back and watch what those episodes actually did. They spent three episodes establishing that these five people cannot agree on anything, that Danzo is a coward who won't take responsibility, that Gaara is the only honest person in the room and nobody will listen to him, and that the Raikage's rage is the load-bearing emotion of the entire summit.
And then Sasuke walks in and every single one of those establishing beats pays off in about six minutes.
The Raikage's rage is why he takes his own arm off. Danzo's cowardice is why Sasuke came. Gaara's silence at the end works because we spent three episodes watching him be ignored.
I complained for eleven weeks that nothing was happening. Something was happening. I just couldn't see it because I was waiting for a fight."
"this is the best post in this thread"
"You've just described every Shirogane arc ever made"
"I KNOW. That's what's embarrassing. I've been watching this man's work for six years. I should have known."
"We all should have known. Steins;Gate was twelve episodes of nothing. Clannad was a whole season of nothing. He does this EVERY TIME and we fall for it EVERY TIME."
"Fourteen years and we still can't tell the difference between setup and filler while we're inside it"
"He cut all the actual filler out of Shippuden and we still called the real story filler"
"we are the problem"
"we have always been the problem"
[2channel - GENERAL ANIME - THE THURSDAY PROBLEM]
"Genuine question for the board. Pokemon is at 7pm Thursday and Naruto is at 8pm Thursday. Is anyone else watching both?"
"I have a six year old. I watch both. I am watching Pokemon with my son and then he goes to bed and I watch Naruto."
"Same but with a nephew"
"Shirogane has one man's audience watching two of his shows back to back for two hours on the same night on the same channel"
"He didn't do that by accident"
"He absolutely did not do that by accident"
"So the 7pm slot wasn't a compromise, it was a runway"
"a what"
"He put the children's show in front of the adult show. Kid watches Pokemon at 7, kid goes to bed at 7:30, dad's already sitting on the sofa with the television on."
"...that's evil"
"That's not evil that's just competent"
"It's a bit evil"
Ryoji did not go to bed after the episode.
He went down the corridor to the room of a second year he barely knew, because the second year had a full set of Naruto tapes going back four years, and he knocked at half past nine and said, without preamble, "Do you have the Chunin Exams."
"What?"
"The Chunin Exams. Sasuke versus Gaara. Do you have it."
The second year looked at him for a moment.
"You watched the summit episode."
"Yes."
"Come in."
They watched Sasuke versus Gaara at ten o'clock at night, six years of story earlier, two thirteen year olds in a forest, one of them with a chirping in his hand and the other one made of sand and crying.
When it finished, neither of them said anything for a while.
Then the second year said: "He was the good one."
"Yeah."
"At thirteen, in that fight, Sasuke was the one saving people."
"Yeah."
Ryoji sat on the floor of a stranger's room in his first year of university and thought about the fact that the anime had spent six years getting from one of those shots to the other, and that he had watched every single episode in between and had not once, at any point, been able to identify the moment where it turned.
He went back to his own room at one in the morning and did not do his reading.
The ratings came in on Friday.
The Five Kage Summit episodes one and two had held at 7.8%.
Episode three: 10.6%.
The largest single-week jump in the history of the series outside the Pain arc, and the third highest rating Naruto had ever recorded.
Kobayashi brought the number to Rei's office personally, which he did not normally do.
"Eleven weeks flat and then this."
"Yes."
"Shirogane-sensei, I want to ask you something and I want a real answer."
"Go on."
"Did you know it would hold at 7.8 for eleven weeks?"
Rei put down his pen.
"Yes."
Kobayashi absorbed that.
"And you let it."
"I let it."
"We could have moved something. We could have brought a flashback forward, we could have restructured..."
"We could have," Rei agreed. "And then last night would have been a good episode instead of the one they'll still be talking about in years."
He picked the pen back up.
"You can't spend eleven weeks establishing that five powerful people cannot agree on anything and then have the audience feel the door come off its hinges, unless the audience has actually spent eleven weeks in the room being bored by those people. That's not a side effect of the structure. That's the mechanism."
Kobayashi stood there for a moment.
"The audience spent eleven weeks calling us boring."
"Yes."
"And you took it."
"I take it every time," Rei said. "I've taken it for fourteen years. It's the cost of the thing. If you're not willing to be called boring for eleven weeks you can't build anything that lasts more than eleven weeks."
Kobayashi wrote nothing down, because there was nothing to write down, and went back to his floor.