Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Mixed Bag of Holding: When Did Things Come Out? - Deep McDonaldland Lore (Patreon)

Published:
2025-07-30 18:33:17
Edited:
2025-07-30 18:34:56
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Downloads

Content

It's the return of the world's worst game show! Things Knower Emily quizzes the 2 Crew on categories like TV Shows That Happened, Pop Culture Phenomena, and of course, Tunes!

Files

Comments

Broghar The Bugbear

I'm at work, and this just picked my whole day up! Y'all the best 💚

Clever Innuendo

I was literally trying to pick what to listen to when this popped up, awesome.

Jason Ramirez

YESSS MCDONALDLAND LETS GOOOOO!!!1!!!

Isaiah

What a way to spend lunch :))

kaylee w

Skaldova was legit so peak, great campaign and created WDTCO

Blaize Gordon

I needed this episode today! Thank you!

hobblelobble

I’ve thought it was thursday all day and this update did not help BUT it is deeply appreciated tysm 2crew

Ramsey

Love to find out i was born in the same year as the Juicy tracksuit

ksm11

I'm usually excited whenever y'all upload, but seeing this segment specifically put me in an amazing mood. I can't wait for the other drivers around me to look at me like a loony because of all of the laughter.

WesKane

Yusss another!

Peregrine

MurphMurphMurphMURPHMURPHMURPH

Anthony

I'm wondering when the next Orlando live show and review of Donkey Kong Country at Universal's Epic Universe is coming out 🫣

hobblelobble

The thing is, the 2 Crew always bickers. What’s special about WDTCO is that there’s a RIGHT answer so the razzing that ensues is so justified when two of them are inevitably wrong but are making assertions like they have phds in pop culture

Bryce Peterson

Please keep making this game. Also going forward, I wonder if no one gets it dead on in the first round, the next person to get it should only get 1 point.

Mars Sink

Everyone knows sonic’s iconic human girlfriend

Dave 3D Art

When did ROM Space Knight come out?

Jon

YESSIR

Argonautica

McDonald's was the third biggest video chain in the country by sales in the early 90s according to some person on reddit.

Cal

mcdonaldland? My zillenial mind doesn't conceive.

Cicero the jester

It would be so funny if one question was just really early like when did the second crusade begin

Mantross

I got Wayne's World from a McDonald's

Patrick B

MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! MURPH!

Courtney F.

I fucking love When Did Things Come Out! Literally played it with my whole fam, doing music on Spotify. We loved it. Can't wait to listen!!! 😍

Evelyn!

My 1999 ass was THRIVING on the Sonic and Paul Blart back to back questions

Brigid

MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH

Crystal T

It's interesting to listen to this being a few years older than the gang (I'm 42). I was old enough to remember when these things came out, but I'm not always exact with a year.

adrieenna (she/her)

i love these episodes 😭😭 i like to use the info for a trivia program i run at the library lol

beefclapper420

2 mins in and they’ve already changed all the rules. When did they fold so easily

Xan Anthony

MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! MURPH!

Shane C

I truly love this, please keep doing them

John Garcia

This was kind of thrilling

Matthew Duggan

My parents bought our copy of Land Before Time at McDonald’s. Just wanted to validate Murph.

CommodoreBlue

A guest spot on this show would be great. Would love to see if a newcomer can manage to scoop the title from Murph.

Silky

The Berlin wall came down in 1989, two years after Reagan said that famous quote. It was the result of massive protests in East Germany, American politics were important in the overall international political situation but did not make this happen. It was a success of the will of the people! This isn't criticism, I just wanted to share this with the people reading the comments because it was a really powerful and inspiring moment in history :) Edit: props to Emily for knowing that it was 1989 from the top of her head, and mentioning it so it didn't end up sounding like everyone assumed it must have been the same year as the speech!

The Fun Yaunt

Murph, Murph, Murph! I thoroughly enjoyed this and would gladly listen to “When Did Things Come Out?” on a regular basis 😄

Kendall MacKay

This show is so inexplicably fun & I would fuckin love for y’all to do it more often!!

Liz

All those hours I spent in the mid-2000s watching VH1’s I Love the ’80s and I Love the ’90s has really paid off while listening to this. 😂 Gotta admit I was shocked y’all didn’t nail the Bowflex one after getting the hints—I thought everyone knew when Chernobyl happened!! (Then again, maybe not everyone has read entirely too much about nuclear disasters on Wikipedia...)

Sarah D

Um, actually Murph should have gotten the 2 points for the Blue (Da Ba Dee), the song was released in Italy in late 1998, but did not reach international audiences until 1999

Liz

Oh that’s such a fun idea!! I feel like my sister could really get into this. If they ever end up releasing another one of these eps while I’m visiting family, I’m gonna see if they will play along with me!

Liz

Also damn you for putting the Homestar Runner voice in my head, Murph!! Trying to do work and all I can hear is “Tunes! Games! Characters! [some other category I can’t remember] Hee-email!”

ananarama

I love When Did Things Come Out. I vote for more

moondanse

i vividly remember getting a vhs of a britney spears and n*sync documentary video at mcdonalds... props to murph

Sam Ninegar

Every 2-4 months seems like a good cadence for When Did Things Come Out. Any more and it risks the oversaturation that claimed Surprise Round.

Andre Smoovy

Blue was released in 1998 in Italy, but didn't achieve worldwide success until 1999. The question didn't specify in the US. Murph was robbed. Justice for Murph. Also, more of this show please. I love it.

Andre Smoovy

I'M SO GLAD I WASN'T THE ONLY ONE. #UNITE4MURPH

KoboldB0i

Murph! Murph! Murph! Murph!

Kerry

This tickles the part of my brain that loves trivia so please continue to do this!

Doctor Ransom

MURPH!!! Fuck the burgers and buy the tapes!

Tim

“We wanted to fuck the burgers and watch the tapes” T-shirt when?

A$

Murph, Murph, Murph 🗣️

Ben Scott

I say this with love and respect. I am 21 years old and this show is not built for me. I love that you love doing it though.

Brandon Rowand

I could listen to a WDTCO daily but that’s just me

alli

absolutely would enjoy this joining the rotation of standard eps (could be paired with a view crew or adventure book theatre as their short rest or something) because it’s so fun every time!!

jared Blewett

Murph winning on an anchorman question is poetic

Stacie

WHY is this so compelling?? Best game ever 😄 please keep playing regularly!!

Katie Lackey

I hate to say it- but I love this 😂😂

Ashton Johnson

So when are we moving this to a the monthly rotation I need more of this in my life. Would be a cool idea to do a WDTCO and then a surprise round short rest or vice versa. A week of pure chaos every month 🤣

heavy harry

This show has NO business being this entertaining

Helcroft

MURPH MURPH MURPH

Sjsharks93

Great show, really enjoyed it. My one suggestion is maybe you could incorporate flipping DVDs in some way?

Jedd P

I adored this, you should do this more often and paired with surprise round! Like tortle tank and dungeon court

Krystine W.

[Insert Murph chant here]

A$

I love getting to confidently guess and then being so wrong, somehow my confidence doesn’t wane each time (in my mind all 2000s stuff came out in 2008)

Amanda M

MURPH MURPH MURPH

Sarah Dawson

Legit this was a thrill to listen to lol

emery board

i NEED when did things come out in the off week rotation. i love it so much

gabe mack

Best thing I’ve heard on here in a while keep do them like d&d court

Gwilson

I'm a fan, this was fun.

derek howard

I would love for this to be thrown in a little more often along with the dungeon courts and Tortle tank!

Amanda Beswick

I love this, I hope this joins rotation

Will

This is so good

aiyana graham art

I really enjoyed this and I enjoyed the inclusion of real world history (like the Berlin Wall)

Sand Panda

I enjoy it. I'm same age as y'all so it is fun to guess along.

Tocayo

Murph! Murph! Murph!

Nic Q

“Grimace cucked my father” — sentences I never thought I’d hear

Jae Beezy

So happy to see the return of my favorite game show

Ashley

I love this series! Side note: Once when I did shrooms I spent a good chunk of the night just listening to the Last of the Mohicans soundtrack. it was delightful.

Peregrine

I can’t believe Murph fricken hates Anchorman 2 so much

connor sparks

The McDonald animated films RIPPED when I was a kid

Erikguerrero

I could easily watch this weekly

wick

WHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN

wick

MURPH MURPH MURPH

Santa Grinch Hugging HumBaba and two Fairies

Murph why are you my dad? obviously i share a lot of Nerdy Interests with my Father but the McDonald's Land Lore is too on point to a Thanksgiving Lore Drop my dad gabe about Mayor McCheese

Jacob B.

Im shocked at how many of these I got correct for being born in 2000. Also my mom is two years younger than Caldwell. That feels wild to me.

Ilana Galpert

I'm going to bravely stand up for the people who like this show and want to keep hearing it, but prefer it intermittently as a mixed bag. I'm confident I'll be outvoted though.

Leo G

This should just be the show now

Jae Beezy

The Nickelback slander is uncalled for

Tylerscer

Murph Murph Murph Murph

Matthew Cagle

I remember my family buying Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom from McDonald's lol. MURPH! MURPH! MURPH!

Tucker Collins

Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph Murph

mars

please make this a monthly show this is the kind of trivia I LIVE for

Juhbathehutt

Please god make this a monthly type of game. It's just too good!

trinacicc

this is the greatest single production in the history of things that came out

Raedeb

Yes! Keep bringing back!

nicknasty

The whole D&D thing is played out. Time to hard pivot to When Did Things Come Out? every week forever

Craig Weatherhead

Please do this as a monthly show!!!! Yes!!! This was so entertaining

Campbell

MURPH MURPH MURPH

K Guard

I am baffled by Movies at McDonalds. What are you talking about, Murph????

Tim G

More please! Also combine this with the new game show that’s kind of sweeping the nation about the spell components lol

Hammy

When did Naddpod come out? Was it during the first or second Bush administration?

Blake

I would listen to this weekly but could settle for monthly

AXWH

I CANNOT get enough of the creeping penumbra of geopolitical collapse across Emily's hints

JC

An absolute delight, definitely would want to have this be a recurring bit since there’s such a wide spread of topics that can be picked and the competitive banter is top notch. I find I have better success blind guessing since I’m both just a shade younger than them and always missed pop culture by a little bit. I was closer when given hints related to history or politics.

A Mo

Please dear God I need more of this

Steve Slatky

I am so extremely disappointed in Caldwell to not mention the great carl barks who created scrooge. One of the Greatest cartoonists to ever do it. He wrote and inked every Donald duck creating the entire duckberg universe.

Paul Gonzalez

Murph! Murph! Murph! Why is this damn show so genuinely good 🤣

Ian Vega

I clicked on this so fast lol absoLUTELY at LEAST once a month! I love you guys freaking out, and just trying to guess along is so much fun. I'm assuming you will be switching out how will be asking the questions, based on the winner, or just cycling so everyone gets a turn. Either way, super looking forward to the next one.

Squibbles

Monthly!! I love that I can play along

Aaron McNeil

I didn't like the last episode of this.

Verona Dropco

love having a little crumb of the only other podcast (lonely island seth meyers) I listen to in NADDPOD lol

Isaac K

Love this so much, please do more of this and more often. Also MUUURRRRRRRRPPPPPPHHHHHHHH!!!!!

aloox

Absolutely LOVE this and would listen to as much as you give us. I def wanna steal this as a drinking game and I think I found a way to scale it for more players. So if you have like 5 people playing, and in the case everyone knows it's early-2000s but don't all wanna be forced to pick 01-05, picture this. Person A: 2005 Person B: I'm also very confident it's 2005 but that was already guessed. Person B can attempt to guess the EXACT month, but if it's wrong and it was 2005, the points go to Person A. You can only scoop the points for guessing the same year if you get the month exact. This can be rinsed & repeated for multiple players. Haven't tested it yet so we'll see how it goes, but I love when y'all do games like this, they're super fun!!

Yuncle Ben

Movies at McDonald’s? I don’t think so.

Zanna

"Get him dude. Fight him physically"

KodiBenz94

I would listen to this every month for sureee. So much fun

Miikra

How the fuck did this silly little bit become such a engaging and fun show. I am hooked!!

Bloop bloop

I’m going to guess 755 AD

Bob McCoog

Same. I don't know if it was a New Jersey thing but my Mom's copy of Ghost was from McDonald's so yes can confirm

Dale Jefferson

I swear I remember my mom buying Jurassic park at the Macdonalds drive through.

Liz

I’m two years younger than Caldwell and I was in sixth grade in the year 2000… you sure you got your math right???

BarbF

Monthly please!! This is one of my favs!

OminousLozenge

Monthly! As an 80's kid, When Did Things Come Out is feeding my soul.

Brian

Murph!…Murph!…Murph! Murph! Murph! Murph! (Murph gets a 90s chant that slowly catches on)

Jacob B.

Yeah I goofed. I thought 86 was a longer time ago

Huascar Holguin

I absolutely loved this episode, I can’t believe the comeback

Heliks

I fuckin love this stupid ass game

Fiel

Turn the W upside down, it’s an M. Good job Wurph

Max

Monthly!

xatlern

What a comeback! I'd definitely be down for y'all to do this more often, maybe with rotating hosts. I thought the two points for dead on/one point for closest system worked out really well, and I'm not just saying that because I was one of the people who suggested it in the comments of the last episode 😂

Peydon Bush

Pop culture and things: when did they come out? Did they come out? Let's find out!

my guy

MURPH! MURPH! MURPH!

Fiel

I would like to see this as a regular thing. Yknow, competitive game show where you keep Stats. See the meta develop. Know who has the strongest categories. Learn so much about what happened in each year that you become trivia gods. It’d be awesome

Clemming

Definitely enjoy this show a ton, could be a great mix up to the schedule along with surprise round.

Emz

Such an absurd game lol. Honestly I'm fine with it being occasional because I enjoy the other nonsense extra shows you do more. The real question is: am I bad at this game because we aren't the same age or am I just wildly bad at dates?

Emily Downie

Love this as a once a month type thing, agree with someone else that rotating hosts would be fun but Emily smashed it!

Theo Pinehill

This hit me in the nostalgia, I’d listen to this once a month for sure.

ak

Yes to having this regularly :^)

Doug C.

I like this as a Mixed Bag, like quarterly or so.

Wyl

big yes to this being a regular thing!

Arillusine

Monthly or every two months of this would be great! The deep dive sleuthing things that potentially happened around the same time to triangulate was super fun to listen to!

Reed Kierce

Love when they guess years, maybe a celebrity/cartoon birthday category?

Austin Soren

I like this concept a lot, I just worry it will burn out quick if it happens too frequently. Maybe once every other month?

John Hartigan

This was really fun and funny. I hope you guys record more of these sometimes

George

I was not aware of McDonald’s ‘I’d hit it’ campaign, but were YOU aware that their official McFlurry, launched in partnership with Shrek The Third, was dubbed The Ogre-load?

Don Johnson

MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! MURPH!

Final Girl

I think maybe every two months would be great for this, and love the idea that you might be track of stats etc. However! I think if you get it dead on AFTER the clue, you should only get one point.

Astrala Chrome

Great show idea, glad y'all are keeping things fresh. But I need those surprise rounds 😭

Josh Kumar

I want this show quarterly. Let me review my KPI's every three months while I listen to Murph drop insane McDonald's lore.

snoogans

MURPH! coming in hot with the sweaty W. You love to see it!

Adam Kepper

I NEVER LOST HOPE IN MURPH! Except for at the end where I confidently as a huge anchorman fan thought anchorman 2 came out in 2019... These last 5 years I swear...

Adam Kepper

How about this for a points system? 3 points for getting it on the first round(I think it should be worth more) 2 points for getting it after the hint 1 point for being the closest 1 point for murph lore.

Tylerscer

This is so fun to play along with

Cheyenne

Monthly, weekly, daily. I'm obsessed

Antonio

Monthly at most but every 2 months or whenever is my vote. I think we need continued teasers sprinkled throughout all of the short rests with a score tracked. I loved this episode and it definitely gives me bar hangout vibes. Also of course [redacted] won that’s his favorite movie series.

Overmind_Slab

This was a lot of fun but I think it’s a format that would really benefit from guests. Getting to see the process someone goes through to slum dog millionaire their way to an answer is a lot of fun.

Evan Cordero

No tiny L's here. Just a big fat W

Marc Capo

I'd love this as often as possible it's slightly sweeping the podcastverse

Jess Wagoner

I know this was a joke idea, but im pretty into it hahaha. I love trying to guess along and I love hearing the crew reason their way to an answer. I wouldn't mind monthly or every other month or something

Andrew Wruth

I need more. Outstanding work

Greg Jovi

Yeah this has to make it into the rotation of "off week" pods for sure. Murph's reverse engineering is sending me.

Hal Martenson

FOR ALL THE GRIMACE HEADS!! Personally would be down to have WDTCO replacing Dungeon Court for a while!! Such a good time.

Dillon Babcock

this episode fuckin rocked. I REALLY thought y'all were gonna talk about the Wacky Adventures of Ronald McDonald which was this wild animated show they released on VHS for sale at McDonald's in the late 90s/early 00s. also, though it didn't affect his SWEEP WIN (MURPH MURPH MURPH), murph was actually right on blue (da ba dee) coming out in 98, it's first release was in October of 98 and then it was dead in the water for about a year until it started to get played on the radio ! this is obviously a VERY important correction tyvm

Sharkie Murphy

PLEASE put this in the episode rotation I need one every three days

Winterbat

MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH

Andrew Bonkginya

My favorite show. This should be regular in some capacity. You could add new categories or have a themed day. Please more when did things come out, the nation is clamoring.

Zachary Kuhl

This country, nay, this world needs more When Did Things Come Out.

DemonLordSparda

This undoes all of his tiny L's and gives him a major W.

Nifty

We need this as a daily show

Two Deers Beep

I was such a hater at first but I love this now do it monthly please!!!! So good so fun to play along

Two Deers Beep

Also I really think yall could easily turn this into a board game. Probably a lot of money to be made there I’ll take a small cut for the idea!

chlo!

maybe donald duck really IS serving WW2… so insightful

Robin Neuhaus

Definitely do this more! Super fun to listen to!!

Spencer Bloom

I absolutely hate to say it but when did things come out is officially sweeping the nation. We demand more!

Spencer Bloom

Surprise round made it to segments, we demand WDTCO make the jump as well.

everett harbaugh

i’d like more of this show for sure, i’d honestly be happy if you swapped it out for tortle tank

Bransy330

When Did Things Come Out: Murph's Beautiful Mind

Jenna H

Jake said #notAtMyMcDonalds Murph! Murph! Murph!

Andrew Burgess

This every 5 or 6 weeks would be amazing

Abe Sinay

Love it definitely more often

Jonathan Yarberough

Murphy crashing out is my favorite part of Naddpod 😭 this as a mixed bag is AWESOME, but more DUNGEON COURTS OF COURSE

Alrec von Zarovich

That McDonald's bit made me laugh like a crazy person. My coworkers were like "What's up?" And I was like "So... McDonald's-"

Erik Moser

Moooooooore (also spell check)

C

Love these! Definitely want more

9on

MURPH! 🗣️ MURPH! 🗣️ MURPH! 🗣️ MURPH! 🗣️ MURPH! 🗣️ MURPH! 🗣️

Tenkura

Sonic’s first on screen kiss was in 1993 in the second episode of Sonic SatAM. Murph got that point!

Katy C.

Would love this as an every other month kind of show

Jorde

I loved this one! Need more historical events with niche pop culture hints lol it’s genuinely interesting to hear what triggers people’s memory

Katy Howells

I can’t believe we get a Homestarrunner reference in 2025, that makes my heart happy

Zerolott

I'm sure someone has already said it, but I'm Blue came out in 98 originally in Italy.

Mnixon

Thank u murph

Martin

Every other month type of show!!!!!!

pluckythechicken

I think the previous winner should be the Thing Knower next time. Id also love it every other month, or even thrown into the off week mix

rikky

waiting with bated breath at the final questions and murph pulling out the win made me understand the crazed energy that some people have towards sports

Kaidan C

“Fry satchel… fry underwear?” What the hell was Emily talking about?

Connor

Homestarrunner mention!

Lila Goldenberg

just a voice in the crowd but i would prefer this & surprise roundy content over the cartoon reviews

EllCee

I’d listen to a million When Did Things Come Outs, so I’m down for as many as you want to make! I love all the deep cut random knowledge and I *really* love when y’all start throwing elbows a little. Sometimes we can show our friendly but very deep competitive streaks, as a treat!

Patrick E.

I didn't love the format originally but Emily's delightful hints have elevated the formula and I am now a true believer in When Did Things Come Out

Mikel

Emily's hints are great. Definitely want more WDTCO but I also like it as an occasional beautiful treat

Natural Dragon

I would like if this is recurring. This is fun. I think you should only get 2 points if you guess the correct date in the first round of guessing. After that everything should just be 1 point.

Corbett Stovall

Love this show. Think it might be fun to rotate hosts somehow. I liked how in the first episode we got to see everyone’s fixations, especially murph’s belief that culture peaked 1999-2001.

Yan Giroux

More of this please! Monthly would be best!

Nick White

MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! I also agree with many comments above; scoring should be 2 points before hint, only 1 point post hint

teenybatty tarot

MURPH MURPH MURPH!!!!! This has gotta be a staple

Ali

After thinking it was a silly but fun idea for a one off episode I don't waste time listening to these. Get this in the rotation for sure. And yeah Emily did a great job the hints were an incredible addition.

Brody Riehlman

NEED this monthly, it’s actually tew good🙂‍↕️

Alexis Rausch

Okay but actually please release this monthly, Im going back down to short rest tier for financial reasons and I would love to still listen to this

narsty

MURPH MURPH MURPH fr love this so much I’m already craving more

Juiced

I love this show so much actually, I would adore getting it monthly!

Rafi

Monthly I beg

Georgia

MURPH DESERVED VICTORY!!!!!!!!!!!! this show is so fucking funny you can do this monthly for Sure

Zaq Putnam

NADDPOD game shows are at their best when the rules are nebulous

tacticalgrandma

I know they’re all about the same age but I swear Murph is the one Gen X among the late millennials.

King of the City Pigeons

Yes, please more of this. And have Emily be the host. She’s great but if it’s the three boys they get rowdy and it’s soooo funny and stupid hearing them get so competitive over the dumbest game ever lol

Kaidan C

I love this show, finally my nigh autistic ability to remember movie dates is worth something

Julie

Monthly please!! So so fun!!

Tannictor

Yes please monthly cannot get enough!

Scrumblina Brumblina

Murph, I immediately was on your side during Mcdonaldgate. McDonald's had their own branded cartoons on VHS that i was briefly really into as a child. Absolutely huge W worthy of a feast

Geraint

Please do more of this!

Eli Huxtable

"Cause baby you're a fiiiire zirk" lives rent free in my head, god dammit Hugh. I thought he'd have a better grasp of the Perry eras.

Evil Grimace

More Grimace(tm) content please.

anneon

love this sm but i think it might stay golden for longer if it's not too often, maybe bi-monthly?

matty

MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH

V

More more more!

Britt Hobson

Please do this monthly! It's so much fun!!!!

Screeb

Yes, please more of this!! Gen z here, we had fun guessing these too

Goggalor

MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH

Zee Z

MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH Also yes plzzz would love to see this once a month!! I love that yall said it was a one time thing and never again and I was SO excited when I saw the notif that it was back again

chris

Once a month at a minimum! Weekly at best

Andrew

MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! MURPH! MURPH!

Peydon Bush

Tortle tank is the best, and this was nice! But, i think just occasionally would be best

Brigid

I want these all the time! What about special guest stars?

Brock Monette

This was great, we need more of this

Intestinal-Bookworms

Love it. Made me remember when you could buy McDonald Land original movie VHS movies for a hot minute

Sam

Any episode where yall have fun is incredible to listen to so if u love this plz keep doing it

Liam Harvey

Between this and the family chat turning into a debate because someone posted a quiz night page recently, i really want more of this sort of thing

Steppa

Really enjoying this as a mixed bag, and would honestly love more like it!!

nina ッ

this was so fun!! do you guys mind saying the winning year when emily announces who won? i forget what year everyone is saying

Mike Conroy

MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH MURPH!!!!! Would love to see more of this show! As an avid IMDb user, I was absolutely delighted when the Skaldova short rests were taken over by guessing casts and years things came out, and have been clamoring for more since! Would love to see this become a more standard show, along the lines of Surprise Round or Tortle Tank

A.J.

it would be very fun to have a newlyweds game version of this! like asking caldwell and jake when murph and emily's wedding anniversary is, what year caldwell kids were born, etc

Connor

More of this for sure!

Brett Miller

Obsessed with these, would LOVE it to be a regular thing if yall continue to enjoy it☺️

J.

PLEASEEEE make this a reoccurring monthly show. Genuinely have been so obsessed with this and the last one, it makes me want to play along and/or try playing this with my friends for our own nostalgia trip.

PastaCortez

No disrespect but I’m not keen to this again on Patreon. One full episode was more than enough. There have been more interesting premises dropped after a couple episodes (like Spellcheck) that id like to see come

CU

I’d take this over D&D Court or Tortle Tank any day!! This could be its own podcast imo

belle

this was super fun and enjoyable and would love to see more eps in the future, but maybe not on a regular basis. yall have so many fun show premises that i love, including tortle tank, spellcheck and other jeopardy style quiz shows, (my fave) surprise round - so i’d be happy with this show added to the rotation of other shows yall revisit! but that’s just me, i still had fun with this mixed bag regardless :)

Rain

I would love for this to be in the rotation of shows a la Tortle Tank and Surprise Round!!

Owen Rath

Late to the party, but thought of a good scoring idea— give a question, then everybody guesses a year. Then we look at how far away the guesses were to the correct year, and they get that many points (ie- if it came out in 2002, and Murph guesses 1998, he gets 4 points). Winner is the one who has the fewest cumulative points after all the questions (golf style)

Jessy G

Just listened to this as part of a slew of content to break up our 12 hour drive home. My husband, who isn’t a naddpod listener is obsessed and immediately asked if there was more! We were both dyyyiiinngg with Emily’s “Japan’s new word” fact. Rotation for sure, new podcast?! lol the nostalgia hits so good for us 35+ fans!

Chris Taylor

Bimonthly sounds good as this may burn out without REALLY on it topics and “on the same year” trivia

Alana Ochoa

yes more of this in eps!!!

Kyler Cunningham

Please for the love of God do more of these, this could be a weekly show and I would LOVE IT

Trenton W

Make it monthly!

Nathaniel F

Redbox’s history will blow your mind.

Sarah Sullivan

Please do more of these we listen and guess along while making dinner and my spouse shouts “HOW DO THEY NOT KNOW WHEN THE BEATLES BROKE UP” over and over. We love these!!

Mynne Maxine

Caldwell got robbed. Also, this would be a great monthly podcast. Everyone loves dungeon court, but doing it too much will make every episode start to sound the same.

Brassius Longjaw

I beg you to watch "The Mean One" for a mixed bag of holding. I think Murph would really love it!

Makayla Greene

I need to keep score next time why do I feel like I’m absolutely smoking you guys lol

SSS Tier Crickwater Enjoyer

This is the world’s best game show and you’ll never convince me otherwise. It should replace football (soccer)’s place as “the beautiful game”.

Dr. Eggman

I'm leaving Murph in my dust istg

Jasmyne Schierbaum

May I suggest a secret Oops All Sonic episode where either all of the events in every category are sonic-related, or all the clues are sonic-related.

Micheal Van Wagner

I don’t know why but I fucking love this show lol. I’d pay an extra tier to get it weekly lmao

Tayci Stallings

We had the VHS's of Ghost and Adams Family Values from McDonalds. I am loving this show, it's so much fun and would love a monthly or bimonthly episode!

Lockwood Warlock

I would absolutely listen to this regularly I am kinda loving the trivia episodes

OGBlake

My girlfriend doesn't understand Dnd or any of your other content and absolutely loved this. Please do more

John Castle

The game show that’s sweeping the nation! Frankly, I love the mental gymnastics you all get to do in this game. Genuine, relatable comedy that doesn’t get lost in the tank like some of the bits can (still love getting lost in there though, just nice to have a change).

Robert

The victory speech at the end was sincerely moving.

Greg Jovi

I just saw the adult happy meal, Murph must be fully erect right now

Clio

LOVE THIS SHOW

SoupLightning

Almost choked on water 'Grimace cucked my father"

AlDente

Monthly!! So good

J. Gro

I'd love to see this in the off-week rotation!

Phfylburt

Terrible hint idea. Someone should say as their last hint whether or not Queen Elizabeth II was the reigning monarch or not.

Percolatte

I'm living for the journey of 'when did this come out' going from "worst idea for a show ever" to "this was great, we could do this monthly" (I am in support of more!)

Emily

Murph: in times of years Caldwell is right, in terms of spirit, im right I’m using that 🤣

Mubeen Khan

Please run this at least once a month. Honestly this could replace DnD Court

tre blessing

since you asked and we're voting, this is really fun, '86 here so the references hit w me, but I still don't know if we need one every month. in the rotation for sure. I am *really* hoping for another Twoyal Tumble in January!!

CommodoreBlue

Really want to hear this with a guest.

Nikolaus Cox

Absolutely make this a regular show!

Lizardcera

Gotta be Zac. He would kill at When Did Things Come Out

Julie Whittinghill

How to Save a Life? No sorry, I think you meant How to Trip a Bird

Jenna H

Just relistened to this, god I love worlds worst game show when did things come out. Would love to have this in the rotation to replace dungeon court every so often.

Grass

I’m too young and cute to know about movies at McDonald’s

compost babie

Sorry to comment a year later but that is absolutely foul