Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Hearthside Chat Questions (Patreon)

Published:
2020-11-25 15:18:21
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Content

Hey there friends! Jake here to humbly request some queries for our Hearthside Chat hitting your feed tomorrow. Post your questions here and I will bring them to your Band of Boobs/Choo Choo Crew and our Daddy Murphy!

Much love, stay safe!

Jake

Comments

Gianni Pappas

For each party member: What are you looking t Forward to exploring with your character the most?

Samual brewis

How do you guys manage to keep such a strict schedule?

G.X. Barnett (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Throughout all of her D&D characters, has Emily hit race/class bingo yet?
2020-11-25 15:20 Throughout all of her D&D characters, has Emily hit race/class bingo yet?

Throughout all of her D&D characters, has Emily hit race/class bingo yet?

chlo!

what was the most nerve wracking part about starting a whole new campaign? and on the flip side, what was the most exciting?

Alex

For Emily - What Discworld book are you reading now and which one do you think you’ll read next?

Josh

If you could each homebrew one race to play as what would it be?

Edward Booth

What difference between the campaigns are each of you enjoying the most?

Ryan Coogan

When are you guys going to make Jake watch anime?

Evan Gakeler

If you had to liken each of your characters to a grocery aisle, which aisle would it be?

Brenda Gibbner

Do you guys have any plans for multiclassing

Eli Lores

What method do you use to come up with such great and entertaining characters

jenavieve

frick marry kill: zonk, honk, fonk

Kris Barnes

What are your character’s favourite foods?

Peach

Is Jake considering taking a level in monk?

Devlin Macpherson

As a DM how far ahead do you have planned in eldermourne? Do you have specific plot points in mind? Or do you re-evaluate after every ep?

Caleb Abel

For each party member: How would each of your characters celebrate thanksgiving?

Brenda Gibbner

What do you think would happen if bookvar met paw paw?

Arknon

When is Jakes one shot planned to take place? He did promise to do one before the year was over...

Alex Davies

Will you ever do a crossover with Zac’s new pod in some way?

Chris Yzaguirre

I have to know who was behind the popular jenns trynstagram account?

Breanna

How long is an episode typically before editing? Whenever i suggest the pod to friends I’m like “it’s a perfect amount of Dnd per episode!”

ananarama

What would a band of boobs or choo choo crew thanksgiving look like?

Thomas O'Brien

If you had to bring back 3 previous villains, forming a suicide squad in order to tackle a bigger threat, who would you pick?

David Donnel

Short answer “no”, long answer “yes!!” Why did Murph decide to do a DK Holiday special?

Eric miner

What is your favorite new thing in Tasha's?

Nanda

When you guys can get back to your old recording schedule, will you? Or do you like this remote format

KeganExe

I truly just want to hear everything and how Emily scores episodes. Tools and programs used, touch points, inspirations, generally vibes she's going for, etc.

Nick Garito

For Dungeon Daddy Murph, what was one thing you had secretly planned that you were most excited about but never got to explore/reveal/or surprise the party with? (S1 or 2)

Jordan Sommers

If jake is constantly pretending to be Daniel day Lewis. Who are the rest of the boobs idols?

Cookie

How has editing/maintaining sound levels changed since the pandemic kicked in and you started doing episodes separately from one another?

Schafe

have any of your new characters surprised you yet having made a decision or something that you'd not have expected of them when you concieved the character?

Nathan C. (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Has playing D&D professionally changed how you think about the game or how you enjoy playing it? Do you still play for fun on your own time? Any differences between home games and Naddpod/Dimension20?
2020-11-25 15:21 Has playing D&D professionally changed how you think about the game or how you enjoy playing it? Do you still play for fun on your own time? Any differences between home games and Naddpod/Dimension20?

Has playing D&D professionally changed how you think about the game or how you enjoy playing it? Do you still play for fun on your own time? Any differences between home games and Naddpod/Dimension20?

Andrew E

Murph, What is your favorite homebrew rule that you’ve used in either of the campaigns? This question is also valid for Emily, Caldwell, and Jake!

Sturt

What ever happened to Ulfgar and Alanis? Did they end up together

Paxton

Why are you afraid of the ring

Erik Qvistgaard

What would the boobs, the bon fréres and the eldermoune crew be thankful for this last year?

Hunter Ives

What are each of y’all’s favorite non-role playing board games? I.e Monopoly, Sorry, etc.

Tabitha

For everyone: Who would you choose from either campaign 1 and/or to body slam you into a table. Or just in general.

Francis A Leyco

What would be the favorite side dish of Thanksgiving for the band of boobs and the choo choo crew?

Jack M

Overall thoughts on the turducken as a potential dnd monster?

DK Donkey Kong

Anything in the new Tasha's Cauldron book the group is looking forward to incorporating/trying out in the campaign?

King of the City Pigeons

Daddy Murphy: How has your DMing changed from episode one of season one to now?

Sage stetson

What would the hot boys do with the Allcaster if they had unrestricted access

Walter

For the party, Are there any nightmares you are excited to face? Or would like to face through out the campaign?

Harrison Fry

@Murph are you still hoping to publish a NADDPOD monster manual?

Matt Pearce

Will Jake or Caldwell ever do a guest spot on Dimension 20?

Theodore Giesen

When are we getting Jake on Adventuring Academy?

Michael Kessler

Has anyone found a new subclass or feature from Tasha's Cauldron of Everything that they're excited to bring to the campaign? Or ideas for future characters?

Payt Suro

What is the worst way to eat a watermelon, and what is the thing you would like least to find inside a watermelon after having already eating some of it?

Ming Wang (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 When are you watching the 3rd D&D movie? The first one was favourite @Murph
2020-11-25 15:21 When are you watching the 3rd D&D movie? The first one was favourite @Murph

When are you watching the 3rd D&D movie? The first one was favourite @Murph

Jacob Buttarazzi

For Murph: did your overarching plans for Bahumia change over time? Was there anything about the way the story went that surprised you?

Bryce VonFange

Dump question just to irritate Murph.... When is startspawn showing up? #never forget

Michael

For the DM’s: when planning the design of a campaign or world, what do you think is the most important thing to nail down first? And for all of you as players, what establishing facts do you look for to latch onto in a DM’s setting?

Maggie Schaller

Hey y'all! In the world of Eldermourne, there already feels like a lot to explore. Besides a river boat cruise, what are you most excited to see?

Brooke Seaver

For Murph: what is something you learned from DMing in the last campaign that has influenced your decisions for the new one?

Alistair

Hey Jake, where's that one shot you promised us? 2020 is almost over, sweetie. 😁

Tom Sardo

Any tips on differentiating your characters. Just finished a campaign with my favorite character that I feel like I poured everything into and starting to build my next but feel like I am recreating the same character in many ways. I am always so impressed with the dimension 20 crew and the cast here being able to create and role play unique characters

Dylan Jacob

Hey Guys, myself and a few of my friends are looking to start an actual play podcast. We have a pretty concept that hasn't been done yet. I was wondering if daddy murphy has some tips on how to run a podcast compared to running a home session.

Dane Larson

Before meeting the Choo Choo crew, Hank didn't really have a place to call home, how would he have faired in the one big apartment with the Trinivale (spelling??) Gang?! Would Jens let him have 6 hot plates?!?

Liam Wright

What's the backup plan for a TPK? Would you fudge the recording or just accept your collective fates, and re-write parts of the campaign?

Richard Lawson

Who would win in a fight (balanced and levelled): Moonshine vs Fia/ Hardwin vs Hank/ Bev vs Zirk

Julia V

I’d love to hear more about your character creation process! Where do you pull inspiration from, how do you decide what race/class, how do you land on a character voice?

Clayton

Do you guys have a contract, do your agents get involved in this, or is this purely friends working together splitting the profits? I'm very curious about the behind the scenes aspect of podcasting. Also, what programs do Emily and Murph use for sound/music editing? Thanks!

Hannah McFarland

Murph: how do you make everything so smooth story wise when something happens you didn’t prep for?

Justin Thyme

If you had to roll up a new character right now, what Race/Class combo would you be interested in?

Wilting Moon

For all - one of my favourite things about dnd is the feeling of personal growth and insight. What - if anything - have any of you as people been able to learn from your characters, past and present?

Khristian A Seaward

I know you have all touched on this a bit, but what has been the strangest part of transitioning from Campaign 1 to Campaign 2?

Colin Whelan

Jake, with all of the DnD experience you have at this point, are you or the group considering letting/making you DM a one shot like Emily or a side campaign like Caldwell? If so, do you have any ideas for a general setting?

Sadie (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Do y’all ever listen to any other lighthearted or fairly silly D&D podcasts? Dungeons and Daddies or The Adventure Zone for example? And if so, do any of them ever spark ideas for things you can do with your characters/in your campaigns?
2020-11-25 15:22 Do y’all ever listen to any other lighthearted or fairly silly D&D podcasts? Dungeons and Daddies or The Adventure Zone for example? And if so, do any of them ever spark ideas for things you can do with your characters/in your campaigns?

Do y’all ever listen to any other lighthearted or fairly silly D&D podcasts? Dungeons and Daddies or The Adventure Zone for example? And if so, do any of them ever spark ideas for things you can do with your characters/in your campaigns?

Stephen Beggs

For Murph - after so many sessions can you generally work out what the PCs are going to do or you still surprised when they formulate their plans...?

Jack Francis West

Starting a dnd podcast soon w some mates- any tips???! ❤️

Maggie Schaller

ALSO, it's been a stressful few weeks! What have you been playing/watching/enjoying over the last few weeks to get through?

Amanda E. (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 What are d&d books do you find most useful for dming? Which ones for as a player?
2020-11-25 15:23 What are d&d books do you find most useful for dming? Which ones for as a player?

What are d&d books do you find most useful for dming? Which ones for as a player?

NICK BOEKELOO

Murph, what's it like being the only adult of the group during the intros? Love the dad energy trying to make everyone say their characters names, it's hilarious.

Billie Ash

Massive fan of character creation so I'd love to know if you had any character concepts that didn't make the cut for eldermourne?

Matthew Rossi

Which of the new PCs would make the worst party guest?

Thomas Raker

What are all of your highest creative aspirations? In your dream world what would you all be doing in 5-10 years?

Victor T (Balnor's Boy)

If the band of boobs was in Eldermourne instead of the Choo-choo Crew, what differences would have occurred?

Daisy Jago

Once we're through the whole pandemic situation do you think you'll do a UK tour again? The manchester live show was truly something special. That night I drank two bud heavies and had a McDonalds and I was deeply unwell as a result. Would love that again. Also do you think future live shows will exclusively be The Choo Choo Crew or is there a chance for the Band of Boobs, Retrieval Team 22 or even the Bon Freres to return?

Dan Murphy

Was bladesinging ever a possibility for Fia? Seems to fit the sword wizard feel wonderfully. Love the direction Emily took!

Richard Jacob Meadows

I'd like to know how Jake feels having a character who is essentially on his rock bottom, I love all of his characters so much

LowlyWorm

Emily, how do you produce music so quickly? I’m getting into production myself and you’re a role model

Cody Smith

Have you guys ever considered making character-themed dice for the merch store?p

Kegan Padot

For Murph: You’re able to give out information/clues/exposition very naturally and in-character while DMing, while my NPCs sound very stiff and samey when I try to do the same. How much dialogue for an NPC do you have preplanned and how much is improvised?

DMCDawg

Do any of your characters, in any of the campaigns, hold viewpoints that you would say you personally disagree with? Do you think it would be hard to play someone who you fundamentally disagree with?

Andrew Muller

What characters do you play in your home games?

Ashen

hey guys! emily, i was wondering if you would consider uploading all of the unposted music used in the podcast? there is one (i think it’s “the kingshammer,” but im not sure) in particular that i absolutely adore and would love to be able to listen to so i could use it as a soundtrack to my own life. thank you!

Karl Otto

For Emily, did you have to dig into any unique music styles for crafting the Eldermourne soundtrack? And, in what whys are the compositions for this campaign different than C01?

Casey Carson

For Murph, Caldwell, and Emily: as a DM how do you make sure that all of your players are consistently engaged when you have a larger group? A couple of my players are pretty quiet when we play and sometimes it’s hard to get them to interact. They always say they’re having fun, but I’m worried they’re just saying that because the rest of the group enjoys the game. Thanks love you guys!

Leah Oats

For the DMs: how do you manage the TOTM combat? Do you have a sense of precisely where everyone is on the grid or do you think of it more abstractly?

Baron Breakfast (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 What D&D characters would the Choo Choo Crew create for themselves if they played D&D? Murph can feel free to answer for Bukvar.
2020-11-25 15:24 What D&D characters would the Choo Choo Crew create for themselves if they played D&D? Murph can feel free to answer for Bukvar.

What D&D characters would the Choo Choo Crew create for themselves if they played D&D? Murph can feel free to answer for Bukvar.

Oska

First of; the new campaign is incredible, you are all incredible and thanks for all the great content! What do you guys reminisce the most about the first campaign? Best memories or details of the world?

Kevin Wixom

As the DM in our little group, I'm having trouble creating unique, easily identifiable npcs. I'm doing ok with voices, and do have notes on each with backstory to try to give them characters, but Murph's npcs are so easy to tell the difference and feel so organic in his storytelling. How much work behind the scenes goes into making them come alive the way he does? This definitely also applies to Caldwell and Emily for their campaigns, but even from the very beginning with Scoutmaster Denny Murph's npcs have been as real as the pcs.

Trey

DM Questions for everyone: what's the process for building these amazing worlds and stories? I'm obsessed with every adventure you four are on! Love you guys a lot- you've made this year so much more bearable!

sesamese

i hope we get a cluck ganebowl update, could the pcs tell us about some other options they were considering for pcs? i think caldwell mentioned looking into astral self monk during the ua episode

Jacob Buttarazzi (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 For the whole crew: how much of your work week is now spent on D&D and how does that compare with how you thought your career would go a few years ago?
2020-11-25 15:24 For the whole crew: how much of your work week is now spent on D&D and how does that compare with how you thought your career would go a few years ago?

For the whole crew: how much of your work week is now spent on D&D and how does that compare with how you thought your career would go a few years ago?

Mak

Will pawpaw make Stan lee esque cameos?

Isaac Wilson (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 What was the first PC each person ever played in D&D, and what characteristics of those characters have snuck into ones that we have seen on the podcast? Obviously we got to see Jake grow with Hardwon Surefoot, but it would be a cool trip down memory lane for the rest of the crew, :).
2020-11-25 15:24 What was the first PC each person ever played in D&D, and what characteristics of those characters have snuck into ones that we have seen on the podcast? Obviously we got to see Jake grow with Hardwon Surefoot, but it would be a cool trip down memory lane for the rest of the crew, :).

What was the first PC each person ever played in D&D, and what characteristics of those characters have snuck into ones that we have seen on the podcast? Obviously we got to see Jake grow with Hardwon Surefoot, but it would be a cool trip down memory lane for the rest of the crew, :).

TheNoodleDoodler

If the choo choo crew was in the Bahamia campaign how do you think it would have gone?

Yydrasil

I guess this week already answers my question, but Do you guys ever get tired of Dming that you need a mental break?

David Carpenter

Why does Emily not currently play Binky Fiasco in the Eldermourne Campaign? Will Binky Fiasco make an appearance at some point?

Lewis Nichols

Any plans to tour the geeky blinders/Choo Choo crew once the world is back to normal? Would love to have you guys back in Manchester

Abby Zachek

Have you guys ever played games like Vampire: the masquerade or Werewolf: the apocalypse? If so any tips on getting started?

Robert Z.

To all PCs, what is the nugget of lore dropped by Murph about the wider world of Eldermourne that you are most excited to learn more about later in the campaign?

Jordan Fields

If the Band of Boobs and Choo Choo Crew met, how would each of your characters get along?

Allie-Gator (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Looking at yourselves as new players(or dm), which parts of D&D did you find yourselves immediately attached to and which parts were intimidating at first? Also, do you have an all time favorite character you've played?
2020-11-25 15:25 Looking at yourselves as new players(or dm), which parts of D&D did you find yourselves immediately attached to and which parts were intimidating at first? Also, do you have an all time favorite character you've played?

Looking at yourselves as new players(or dm), which parts of D&D did you find yourselves immediately attached to and which parts were intimidating at first? Also, do you have an all time favorite character you've played?

AceJaxter

Jake, when is that one shot coming? Also, in what setting would you have it in?

Mak

Has it been frustrating playing at a lower level after campaign 1?

Spencer

I neeeeed to know Hanky McSpanky Chonkfish’s method of cooking lasagna on a hot plate

Lee Southwell

For everyone: what’s your favorite bit that you’ve committed to over the course of the show?

John Ballantyne

When playing new character how do you maintain the role-play? Recently started a new campaign and I’m struggling to get out of the headspace of my old PC. Any advice or tips would be appreciated :)

Jayden guerra

will amir come back for this year's holiday special?

Brooke Seaver

Caldwell, what were your biggest inspirations for creating Zonk?

Thomas Gunn

How do you manage large scale combats? Fights are more fun when they are larger but how do you keep track of it all. Tracking 5 PCs and enough monsters for a challenge is really taxing. Any tools or tips to make it more manageable? Thanks and I'll take my answer off air.

Emily Lalande

For everyone: I’m loving the spooky gothic fairytale vibes of Eldermourne so far (especially the Slavic elements — shout out Fia Boginya). What are your favourite fairytales? And where are you taking inspiration from for your characters (for NPCs or the religious pantheon in Murph’s case)?

Brookestore

At of all the PC who's family thanksgivings would you most/least want to attend

Mak

Did you draft any other characters before landing one the ones you chose?

Mike Hamrick

First, I'm absolutely loving the new season. Keep it up, choochoo two crew! My question - how do you get the audio to sound like you're all still in the room together now that you're playing remote, and how do you keep your interactions so synchronized and natural? I've DMed a game with 3 of my 7 players remote and it is always miserable and constantly hitting snags with the "wait, what did you say? I missed that"...

simplythoughtless

Waddup choo choo crew! Love the new campaign so far, you are all fantastic. What are your processes for coming up with a voice for your characters? I know Jake mentioned he practices on his bike rides, but what about everyone else? Cheers guys, keep it up and stay safe!

Dana Kayser

Emily- I Love Fia's slavic influences! Like Bukvar and Volk... Is Fia short for anything? I thought it could maybe be Afiona (Афиона, Macedonian for Poppy). Or are there any more specific choices you made for Fia about her character which are slavic-inspired?

Caelan Crease

For Emily (and maybe daddy Murphy) since bookvar is already bad at stealth, have you considered plating him in armor? Even if just to help with the cowardice?

Diego Jorquera

Sorry guys big fan and this has probably been asked before but what is the thing that surprised you the most about the first time you played dnd? How was it different to what you expected it to be?

Jesse

Do you guys notice any personality quirks or traits from the players slipping into their characters, perhaps unintentionally? Or any Murph-isms sneaking into NPCs?

TheRealTimon

Not really a question, but I am so T H R I L L E D to see the DK holiday special on the schedule. Love you guys!

Charles Leon

I know Emily reads a lot of books to prepare for the characters she plays. Do Caldwell and Jake do the same? If so, wich one? Ps: I love the new charactonks

Anonymous

Does designing combat encounters for the choo choo crew feel different than doing the same for the band of boobs?

Jane with Song

If there is a world where two of your PCs (from any campaign including home games) were to hangout together, which two do you think would be good friends, or is there a pair that will really dislike each other? Also, remember to rest well! Content can wait, but you can only do your magic with a long rest!

Brandalf The Bae

Are there plans for another holiday episode this year? I have made it a tradition to listen to the Crickmas special during the holiday season and would love more NADDPOD holiday cheer in my Crickmas stocking. Thank you for all your hard work 😘 Edit: and who could forget the legendary Frostwind holiday sode. Yugo style.

Sara

You all do a great job on making decisions based on your character. Any tips to become a better role player?

Joseph Goldstein

Thank you all for everything you do. This year is much more bearable because of your tireless efforts. My question is really for Jake, Caldwell, and Murph: What’s it like playing with the greatest dnd player of all time, Emily Axeford? Does it add extra pressure to your characters decisions?

Kaitlyn

Can we PLEASE get a ‘dads after dark’ talk show ft henry and balnor. Please.

John Gallant

I feel like your characters in C1 only became solidly best friends during the Galaderon saga (~ Ep 13) whereas it feels like your characters in C2 have been friends since Ep. 2. Do you think your character friendship fro C1 influenced how you've portrayed your friendship in C2?

Brenda Gibbner (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 What advice would you give for someone wanting to start a d&d podcast? My friends on discord and I are planning to start one at some point
2020-11-25 15:27 What advice would you give for someone wanting to start a d&d podcast? My friends on discord and I are planning to start one at some point

What advice would you give for someone wanting to start a d&d podcast? My friends on discord and I are planning to start one at some point

Mike Hawley (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Why is “Funky Word: Kill” the highest form of D&D-based comedy? Real question: When are the McElroy’s going to be guest staring on NADDPOD?
2020-11-25 15:27 Why is “Funky Word: Kill” the highest form of D&D-based comedy? Real question: When are the McElroy’s going to be guest staring on NADDPOD?

Why is “Funky Word: Kill” the highest form of D&D-based comedy? Real question: When are the McElroy’s going to be guest staring on NADDPOD?

Grant Kenny

If it pleases the court. Will there ever be a Bahumia crossover in Eldermourne? How goofy would a Galad X Fergus crossover Oppa Freddy vs Jason style.

Elliot Cooper

I really loved the Hot Boy Summer mini campaign - Emily did a great job DMing! Any chance she'll reprise her role as Dungeon Docent in the upcoming months? If so, what sort of crew or scenario would she be interested in running?

Taleisha G

What part of how you picture your character has changed the most since the beginning of the eldermourne campaign? I love the show so so much, you’ve all inspired me to start dming my own campaign with my friends and hopefully lots of goofs! Thank you oh so much and enjoy your holiday break!

Juni Dasgupta

What are some things in your new characters you like more compared to the Band of Boobs? And what are some things you miss about the Band of Boobs (aside from how OP you guys ended). ***also Fia finding privacy to change was absolutely hilarious given how moonshine was***

Cunty Omega

Ahoy! I'm a wannabe good DM and one thing I've always loved about NADDPOD (don't sing yet) is how innovative and unique combat encounters are! For Murph (and Caldwell and Emily as fellow DMs) how do you design combat to be creative and extra enjoyable for players? As players, what features in combat make it even more engaging than normal? Thanks for all the amazing content and keep up the good work!!

Vemund Dyrskog

Did Jake purposefully nickname Henry Hank so that he could later more easily fit in with Zonk and Bonk? Or was it just a coincidence?

Nick Rees

Jake, when are you going to dm for Murph, Emily, and Caldwell?

Crane

You guys have played so many games of dnd over your lives. What is your favorite moment from one of your home games? Love from rhode island

Dave M

What are you referring to when you talk about Fia's level of warpriest? Is her clerical domain War?

3v3nt H0r1z0n

Are you enjoying having a low, group charisma score? I didn't like it at first but then found it made me a better player by having to find unique and targeted approaches to social situations.

Colin Stevenson (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Murph, what is your thought process on creating the "power creep"? While the party & battles get stronger, the magnitude of their influence and level of issues they can tackle also scale. Any tips on how to make a campaign go from a small pond to a huge ocean, and do you take inspiration from anywhere on how to pace the power creep?
2020-11-25 15:28 Murph, what is your thought process on creating the "power creep"? While the party & battles get stronger, the magnitude of their influence and level of issues they can tackle also scale. Any tips on how to make a campaign go from a small pond to a huge ocean, and do you take inspiration from anywhere on how to pace the power creep?

Murph, what is your thought process on creating the "power creep"? While the party & battles get stronger, the magnitude of their influence and level of issues they can tackle also scale. Any tips on how to make a campaign go from a small pond to a huge ocean, and do you take inspiration from anywhere on how to pace the power creep?

Nils

Will we ever see a battle royale with all played characters from both campaign? If not, if all characters was the same level, who do you think would win?

Fresh Beeps

Do you have guests lined up, and why is that guest Mavris but in a sexy witch costume?

Brookestore

Weird question but if all the characters each of have played teamed up (ie, onyx, moonshine and fia) who's would make the best party

Rachel Loney

Did Caldwell go into campaign 1 knowing that Bev would be queer/have a crush on Erlin or was it more of a spur of the moment thing when they started talking about other Green Teens?

ThatManGareth

This is for Murph. Compared to Bahumia, which had some stories which weren't AS tightly tied to the main storyline, (more like side quests) Eldermourn feels much more tightly interwoven together. Have you changed your writing style to to accompany this, like a murder board with the strings connecting related events, or is it just early enough we're still uncovering new exposition? Also, second question, are guests still gonna be a thing for campaign 2?

CharlieB

For Murph: as a DM I am consistently amazed by your ability to pull out fresh voices and keep them consistent for your NPCs. Do you plan the voices ahead of time as well as the personality?

Rai (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Jake - so far it seems you’ve only played performance d&d. Do you thinks you’d play differently in a home campaign? Emily, Caldwell, Murph - how is playing on the podcast different from playing at home for you?
2020-11-25 15:28 Jake - so far it seems you’ve only played performance d&d. Do you thinks you’d play differently in a home campaign? Emily, Caldwell, Murph - how is playing on the podcast different from playing at home for you?

Jake - so far it seems you’ve only played performance d&d. Do you thinks you’d play differently in a home campaign? Emily, Caldwell, Murph - how is playing on the podcast different from playing at home for you?

Scott Meldrum

You've said you don't want to take campaign 2 all the way to 100 episodes and level 20 like campaign 1, but did you set out with the intention of hitting 100 eps and level 20 in campaign 1? (Also, what level did Balnor end at? He was always a level or two behind)

Daniel Green

Would you consider allowing a homebrew grappler style feat for Hank, so Shank could grab an enemy from behind and Hank get advantage on his attack? Or some kind of feat that allows a synergistic team up with Shank and Hank when using hand to hand combat... oh! Call it Shadow Boxer 😂

Frank

My question: I really want to start DMing, but I’m nervous bc I feel like I need to memorize all the rules and be an expert Emily-tier player before I do. Any advice on how to get started or overcome this?

Ash Kealz

When is the Scramble man going to be released? I was actually excited to hear that i could have a Paw Paw plushie. And a second question is, is Jake going to Dm a session in the near future?

iplaythelarynx

Big ups to the choochoo crew!! Emily, has your stint as a dungeon docent affected the way you play?

Ryan Coogan

Murph, what kind of scary films/tv/video games inspired the setting of the new campaign? Are you a big horror fan in general or was there one specific property that made you say “a horror-themed campaign would be really interesting”?

Braxton Robinson

Me and my friends just played a dnd campaign where we all played different anime characters traveling from different anime worlds. If you guys could roleplay as any fictional character who would you do? This question is for all of you

Claire Hoppe

Do you think your old characters from the last campaign would get along with the new ones?

Emil

My question is for the DM’s What has been your fav monster/character for combat in the campaigns you’ve done

Maronic27

where can listen to the final Metal City for Sonic :(

KatandBen

Hi Jake! What have you found challenging about learning Henry Hogfish's class?

SHANE STOKES

What would the band of boobs think (specifically) about the choo choo crew, and vise versa? Like what would moonshine think if she met Honk?

Joseph

How aggressively would the Band of Boobs act to put out a forest fire relative to the Choo Choo Crew? How about a barn fire? Really, I’m just wondering about an in depth breakdown at the fire fighting capabilities of each team. No need to mention the bonfrayers, as I’m assuming that they would be the most qualified.

skullpunkzero

Hey friends! I recently saw an artist on twitter who was upset that someone else had used one of their original characters as a dnd character without permission. The person who used the character didn't seem to publish or make any money off of it, they just used the art to give their character an appearance for their own campaign and personal drawings. What are your thoughts on this kind of thing? Would you guys be upset if someone played their own personal campaign as Moonshine, Hardwon, or Bev?

Clay Gilkerson

Are there any new magic items/class options from Tasha's that you'd be excited to use in Eldermourne?

Sarah G.

Are there any plans for guest stars on this new adventure? I have been binging Fantasy High all week, so I would love to see any of the DImension 20 peeps again (especially Lou or Ally!).

Abby G

not a dnd question, but what media have you most enjoyed over the past few months? (tv, film, book, podcast, music, anything)

Mojojojo

Is Hank a handkerchief user or a farmer blow type a guy?

Alex C.

Any Jake-ventures planned? Really want to see the last, missing DM in action.

Max Telmer

Murph i am really liking all of the Stormlight elements introduced so far like bonding sprites/speaking oaths and batilda's shardblade-type sword. Do you plan to include more?

Holly Garrick

This would be for anyone who has Dm'd in the party - how do you know when to drop in information about the overarching plot, and how do you do so without giving too much away? I always struggle with this when DMing as I can never tell what will be too obvious, or what will not be obvious enough that they will note it down or remember it. Cheers!

Vonvonvon

(Love the new arc and everything about you all) the only thing I miss is silly voiced animalayic characters like the Bullywugs and the Kobolds. Any chance good old MurphMurph will lay any silly voiced animals in Eldermourne? #sillyvoicedanimalsplease

Matt Solarczyk

Of the two campaigns, which characters, NPC or PC would you guys most want to have a drink with? Also, more importantly, is Henry Cavill now Hank or Honk Cavill?

Talia

Would you all ever consider doing a oneshot with the first campaign character's in 2nd campaign setting? I would really like to see how they would react to the same situations.

Mitothy

This is for anyone who wants it - can you give us 3 (or more or less) tips on engaging roleplay? Could also pose to Murph/Em/Caldwell (Jake DM something already), any tips on setting a scene in such a way that it draws out engaging roleplay?

Paul Westmore

Murph, how did you get so fucking good? Emily, how much do you have decided about your wonderful characters, and how much is improved in the moment? Jake, a rose to you for showing the human fighter is an insanely versatile and interesting character that has all the potential and depth of any other "more interesting" builds. Caldwell, how many sprites do you think Zirk can befriend through the next 90+ sodes?

Ashtyn Jones

If campaign 2 became a live action movie, who would you cast the choo-choo crew as?

Paul Smith

For the PCs - what so far has been your character's biggest contribution to the world of Eldermourne? To what extent are you exploring Murph's world vs. shaping the world together?

Carter Milius

It's been established that Shank loves the shadows of potato skins, so therefore, can Shank eat people's shadows??🤔😂

Aliyah Veltz

Do you feel like recording remotely has added to the new-ness of campaign 2/ to separating it from campaign 1? In what ways do you try to negate the negative effects of recoding separately?

SuicidalLobster

For Jake From not knowing about DnD to where you are now, do you think you have the courage to play a wizard or a sourcer? Also thank you and the boobs for making me smile through my harshest days.

Kimberly Tevis

What's the best poolside snack if not shrimp scampi?

Sammo Cando

Could we ever get a mixed bag where the BoB fight one of Akarot's titans that didn't get released?

Dylan

Hey gang! Wanted to ask a bit about the world of Eldermourne. I know that all the PCs are based on traditional 5e races like Vedalken and Elf, but is there any difference in the world other than mechanically? Like would people call Zirk an ‘elf’ or is he just another human? I love the world building and wanted to know!

Jestar Omega

How do you guys deal with DM/Player burnout?

Brian Korda

For Bookvar - what are the best ways to crit on my homework

Jason Maurer

Greetings from an American in Sweden! This is a question for the DMs (sorry Jake)! As a DM in my own campaign, I've been trying to find that good balancing act between good story content, interesting developments, and exciting battles. For the battles, because it's often so difficult to find a sweet spot between just difficult enough and too difficult, I find myself fudging monster rolls (making them less powered) to make sure that my players aren't just quickly killed off. How much "DM fudge" do you guys do in your campaigns and what are your tips for avoiding it? I truly love all of you – the podcast is a beacon of light and I always look forward to the next episode. Thanks so much for making it!

Jeff Sparrow

What are the BoBs and CCC thoughts on one another?

Robert Cottingham

To anyone who uses an accent on the show: Do you find yourselves practicing when not recording/thinking in another voice that's not your own? I'm tired of being plain ol' Rob from Georgia and want to be Fia Bonkginia from Eldermourne

Anonymous

What are some of the challenges of playing your new classes/subclasses?

Mike Johnson

Question for murph Can we get a one shot where emily gets to play a coffee sorcerer binky fiasco. And the boys get to play equally broken/mess around characters?

Rémi Maloney

Murph - Do you mind allowing a peek behind the screen, and letting us know if the whole boxing event of Episode 2 was just a consequences of the jokes about Old Timey Boxing of episode 1, or you actually had planned that?

Nick Rees

Emily, Caldwell, and Murph, do you prefer being the dm, who knows everything or being a player and being taken by surprise? Fuck you, I love you, eat a rat.

Jordan

What were some other character ideas you all played around with for Eldermourne?

Andrey M

A bit of an odd question, but I’ve always wondered how NADDPOD fits into your lives. The Patreon has grown quite a bit, but you’re always talking about side projects, so I’m just curious is NADDPOD now your main schtick? How do you guys find time for everything? What does an average recording take?

Jor Elare

Primarily DM question, but I'm sure all of you had some input. How have you tried to contend with the 'campaign 2 conundrum' of making the stakes too high initially and trying to immediately pick up where the BoB left off? Obviously Murph has done a fantastic job setting up this first arc where it feels natural but still higher stakes than Moonstone did, but is there the temptation to go too big and too deep too early on character choices, deaths, etc?

Marisa

Since we’ve done this for campaign 1, dream celeb cast for your campaign 2 characters ? (Im thinking Anya Taylor joy as Fia).

Alexander

DM question, do you have any advice on creating an interesting world and/or creating a compelling story? I'm a new DM and would be interested to hear what you all have to say.

Cherrie Alfonso

My friends had conversations about how magic gets bent to do things mostly in line with what the spells says but kinda different, like the kind of shenanigans you all pull. How do y'all find a nongame breaking balance? Like how does Papa Murph know when to reign the shenanigans in?

Mak

More reasonable question: Hey y'all! What is each of your favorite NPCs this season? We all know Balnor was a favorite in season 1, but Bookvar is probs top 5 this round for me. More Boob/Chew-ish question: How would each of your characters suffer through/survive quarantine? I've heard a bit from the Boobs via Baggin it with Balnor, but I want to hear from the crazy minds that created them! Also maybe the Trinyvale trio as well? I can't imagine Jens would do with being cooped up in his apartment with his many, many non-paying roommates.

Jordan Suleiman

This is for Emily: Fia seems to be way more reserved than moonshine, at least in terms of nudity and affection. Was that a conscious decision for the character, or was it something that developed naturally?

Ryan Natwick

Is Jake still going to DM this calendar year?

Dantes Gutiérrez

Have you thought about adding another permanent PC to the crew?

Emily D

Murph, how do you create such interesting NPCs that make players want to keep interacting with them? Emily, Caldwell, and Jake, what features of NPCs make you want to keep coming back to them?

Joseph Wilkinson

Would you all be interested in hearing an episode with full cinematic sound effects and mixing? It can take some time to create, so I’d want to make sure you’d be down before jumping down that rabbit hole. Making each hero have unique sounds is a blast and adds to the depth of the story. The swipe of bone claws for Honk, the full out sprinting of Fonk, and the delicate glass tinkling of Zonk

Rémi Maloney

Murph, what was your most conscious choice to change the way and themes you designed for the campaigns between Season 1 and Season 2? Besides "the story starts right away", obviously.

Ethan Brown

This ones for the daddy master: how do you find motivation to continue dming?

Stephen C, shortest beard in Bahumia

Are the Band of Boobs the gods of Eldermourne? Hardwon the artist/Creator, Moonshine the queen of decay/The Reaper, Bev and his goofs/The Trickster? Does that mean Balnor's one too? (Where was the 4th god?)

Thundermammal

DM question. How do you feel about bringing famous dnd lore characters into your homebrew campaigns? For example, the Choo Choo Crew finding Strahd in Eldermorne.

Aidan Boyle

Would you ever do a crossover episode with any other actual play shows?

Dominic Brown

Hi Murph, newbie DM here. How far ahead do you plan each session? And what format do you use? (Ie word document or physical notes etc) and how do you keep track of NPC position, stats and HP? Thank you

DisClever

There has been a lack of character mounts in the campaigns (probably due to Hardwon's completely justified hatred of equine) other than the odd polymorphed ghost pirate elephant or parent's old airship. What kind of mounts would your characters have to ride around on?

Christina Manry

My question is for everyone. We have a brand new player in our party, and sometimes it feels like she is nervous to jump in with her (her character's) opinions or actions. How can we make her feel more comfortable that, even if her actions put any sort of strain on the party, it will still make for a fun session; possibly even more fun depending on the hijinks she might be thinking of?

Jamilla Petrie-Shah (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 For all the players: how did you come up with the names for your Eldermourne pcs? They're so unique and fit so well with each pc so I'm really interested to know how you made that decision & also if you had any alternative name ideas for them (for example is there a parallel universe in which Emily is playing Binky Boginia?) :)
2020-11-25 15:40 For all the players: how did you come up with the names for your Eldermourne pcs? They're so unique and fit so well with each pc so I'm really interested to know how you made that decision & also if you had any alternative name ideas for them (for example is there a parallel universe in which Emily is playing Binky Boginia?) :)

For all the players: how did you come up with the names for your Eldermourne pcs? They're so unique and fit so well with each pc so I'm really interested to know how you made that decision & also if you had any alternative name ideas for them (for example is there a parallel universe in which Emily is playing Binky Boginia?) :)

Abby G

so i got some of my friends to start playing dnd with me over the past few months, and it’s all of our first times, and we’re really struggling with not just doing combat, talk to one npc, discuss what to do from there, repeat. do y’all have any suggestions on how to integrate story and character aspects more into playing in general, and also how to avoid just getting crunchy during combat?

Gig ⭐️

Question for everyone, what do you think each of your pc's favorite colours would be?? love the podcast :)

Daisy Morris

Were the players given the chance to pitch their character backstory to Murph first or was the background created and the players slotted into their setting before it was taken to the PCs? Thanks!

Claire After All

DM question: I'm always looking for more efficient ways to run battles with multiple enemies! My players just stumbled their way into a cyberpunk vampire lair and things got... chaotic. What do you all prefer to use for combat tracking?? (And would you ever be willing to post any sorts of sheets you enjoy using?) Thank you!!

Alex Widdison

Jake, did you know that the echo created by the echo knight class technically is not considered a "creature" which means it can't provoke opportunity attacks or be targeted by certain spells. Love the podcast and thanks again for all the amazing content!

Lungless

Murph, I have been DMing for about a year now, and I still have to take a panic poop 10 minutes before every game. Does this happen to you too?

Lori P.

Do you ever have problems bouncing back and forth between multiple campaigns? Does D20 lore ever accidentally make it into naddpod, do you ever find yourself thinking or acting like the wrong character, or applying rules of one game to another?

Steven Woodford

What are the choo choo crew's favorite foods?

Chris E.

If Murph kills your characters, how well you get back at him in real life?

Aver (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 I started playing d&d because of shows like NADDPOD and D20. Under that influence. I love exploring my DMs world and talking to PCs and running goofs. I started DMing recently and am trying to make it fun for my PCs who have never played before. My instinct as a DM is to introduce goofs opportunities, but I also feel like I am distracting and confusing my fresh players. How do you guys balance goofs and driving plot as DMs (more for Duncle Caldwell and DMily)?
2020-11-25 15:44 I started playing d&d because of shows like NADDPOD and D20. Under that influence. I love exploring my DMs world and talking to PCs and running goofs. I started DMing recently and am trying to make it fun for my PCs who have never played before. My instinct as a DM is to introduce goofs opportunities, but I also feel like I am distracting and confusing my fresh players. How do you guys balance goofs and driving plot as DMs (more for Duncle Caldwell and DMily)?

I started playing d&d because of shows like NADDPOD and D20. Under that influence. I love exploring my DMs world and talking to PCs and running goofs. I started DMing recently and am trying to make it fun for my PCs who have never played before. My instinct as a DM is to introduce goofs opportunities, but I also feel like I am distracting and confusing my fresh players. How do you guys balance goofs and driving plot as DMs (more for Duncle Caldwell and DMily)?

Daniel James

As have many people, NADDPOD operations have had to change based on the pandemic. As a listener, I have to say on our end it seems like nothing has changed so kudos! Do you miss getting together to play? I have to imagine logistically it’s easier for those that need to travel. Loving the new campaign!

Alex aka Zol Ark

With the release of Tasha’s Cauldron of Everything what subclasses peeked your interest? And would that have been enough to change your class?

M. T. Kadisin

Hey all! Loving Campaign 2: Eclectic Choo-Choo Crew. You guys never cease to impress and hillariate. (not sure that's a real word!). First one goes out to Murph: You've let your players get away with some top grade, cartoon level shenanigans. How do you know when to draw the line and say no, instead of begrudgingly allowing the madness to continue?

Arwyn Robinson

Murph, how do you navigate when players have backstories that would put them at odds with each other or would contradict the story? Do you ever make them change elements of their backstories of do you adjust on your end?

Laney Bird (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 If you could pick one spell, feat or class feature from the D&D handbook to be able to do in real life, what would you pick and how would you use it?
2020-11-25 15:45 If you could pick one spell, feat or class feature from the D&D handbook to be able to do in real life, what would you pick and how would you use it?

If you could pick one spell, feat or class feature from the D&D handbook to be able to do in real life, what would you pick and how would you use it?

Arwyn Robinson

Emily, what has been your favorite piece of music you've written for the show and why?

Tocayo

Jake, how the hell do you maneuver this snowstorm of questions you get every hearthside chat? How do you decide which questions to answer and which to send to an eternal purgatory of uncertainty?

Charlotte

Is their name spelled Sib, Syb, Cib, Cyb, or something else?

Zach Horn

If Fonk, Bonk and Honk all had dating profiles, what would they include in their bio and what would be their go to pick up line? Murph can answer as himself. Been a fan since 8bit book club, keep up all the amazing work!!!

masterofmerc .

I remember hearing about a NADDPOD video game at some point...maybe? Any updates for us in that regard?

Casey White

We killed a green dragon and got 28 platinum (bringing me to around 500gold). Our dm said you can buy whatever you want and all of us players got super excited. I then looked at the guide and realized I couldn't even buy an uncommon item. I am level 9 and just want something cool. How do you recommend making serious cash in dnd? We are already opening a food truck where we sell tacos. I have the bag of spices and then the dm gave me an endless bag of tortillas which are dope but mostly meme.

Dayna K Brown

DM question! I'm DMing Curse of Strahd and for some reason my players (2 rangers, a bard, and a paladin/warlock) have decided to try and convert Barovia to communism. One of the rangers has even started reading the Wikipedia page for Karl Marx on session in character to an NPC. Phrases like "Eat the rich" and "The real plague on this land isn't the devil strahd, but the concentration of wealth with the few". How am I supposed to DM this and how in the world should NPCs react??

Amelia (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Have any of you tried other systems beyond D&D and if so what are your favorites?
2020-11-25 15:46 Have any of you tried other systems beyond D&D and if so what are your favorites?

Have any of you tried other systems beyond D&D and if so what are your favorites?

Ross Gilliland

What is the worst Thanksgiving food?

Carey Compton

I'm really thrilled that Campaign Choo-Choo has included a non-binary character in it right off the bat, and your other games have featured characters from all over the LGBT spectrum, which is *chef kiss*. At what point in the character design process do you make this decision? And Murph: do you make these plans ahead of time, or do you mostly go with the flow? Representation is super important and I think you're doing a great job 😘

Barback of Penance

To the Choo choo crew: What are you hopes for character development this season?

Hannah Osborne

For Emily: your music is absolutely beautiful—you’re so talented! What inspiration do you draw from when you’re composing your music?

Ryan Stokes

What have you guys been to doing for your physical and mental health this year during the pandemic

Arwyn Robinson

Caldwell, how much of the fan art influences your drawings of the characters when you make the art for the show? Do you have a clear picture in your head at campaign zero what everyone's characters look like before hand and the fan art doesn't influence? Or do you adjust based on what you see in the fan art?

INFINITE

Hey Jake, Murph, Caldwell, and Em! I’ve been having so much fun watching/ listening to naddpod the past year, and watching the various other dnd actual play shows you’re all involved in(minus jake I think but Goat show is really fun) My question is, how does one get into the dnd actual play space? I understand I could make my own show, but I’m much more interested in being a cast member for other dnd creators. I’m an actor and LOVE treating home games like actual plays but I’d truly enjoy getting to help put to together some shows on someone’s cast or help with writing. Should I just bite the bullet and make my own show/campaign with some friends? Do I need to grind away in dnd sub pages on Reddit trying to meet people making shows that way? I understand y’all’s route to actual play is and will be much different than mine but any advice would be appreciated, thank y’all so much.

Brian Flake

Hey BoB/CCC!! While spending Thanksgiving alone this year, I imagine I will be reminiscing about meals of Holidays Past. If you guys could join me in reminiscing, what do you think thanksgiving traditions would look like in the context of all/some of the characters you have played? Do you think Mac was forced to drink his family's basic brew??

Arwyn Robinson

Jake, do you think you'll journey into the realm of a spell caster class? If so which one and why?

Travis

(Question for daddy Murphy) how different is the preparation process for Eldermourne from Bahumia? How do you attempt to wrangle in the shenanigans in a darker, more high concept world?

Thunderdave

What are the dimensions of the hearth?

Neil henderson

Question for Emily, the master of magic manipulation. I play a Warlock and I roll like garbage. Are there any ways besides the Eldritch Mind invocation and upping my constitution score to protect my concentration spells?

Miriam Yifrach

Hi Murph! How much of Eldermourne was influenced by The Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson? Sprittle reminds me so much of Syl and the other spren!!

wilson menary

What are zonk, bonk, and honks favourite foods?

Ray L.

Question for everyone: have y'all considered or would you consider playing an asexual character at some point? Signed, an ace girl who's always on the lookout for more asexual characters to adore

Caerezosa

Hi guys! I’m new to being a DM and I was wondering how many little Easter eggs and hidden trophies you guys throw into a location before you decide enough is enough. I always feel bad when my players roll a Nat 20 investigation in an empty room and I feel like I have to make up something cool for them to find like a cursed dagger that gives bad directions or something. What do you suggest? Thank you so much for all you do, you guys are amazing!

Steven Hoffart

Question 1: the Crews favourite appetizers.

Jack McAlevey

For Murph: has your style of world building and planning the long-term adventure changed at all in running Eldermorne vs Bahumia, and if so, why? For everyone: do you feel that recording 100% remotely from the beginning of the campaign has affected they way you play or perceive the world of Eldermorne?

Steven Hoffart

question 2: For Caldwell and Mutph, are you going to work in poison and potion making for the alchemist?

Olivia

Hey Naddpod! What would happen if everyone switched PC characters for a one-shot? (It can be from any of the campaigns.) Who would you want to play as first?

Daniel Roush

Question for everybody. How do I get gud at improv? I've been playing a semi-weekly game with friends for about two years, but I still struggle with roleplaying through questions or situations I wasn't expecting.

INFINITE
>>48362316

Read up on communism, see how the people reacted in countries affected by it, and see how the ideals of those people align with the ideals of the people in your Barovia. Also you’re part of the game too, if diving into government, especially a system you’re unfamiliar with, you can always let them know that and try to brainstorm a workaround.

PlagueQueen

Questions for the Band/crew, I have always wanted to play DND but I don’t really have a group or anyone local that I can do this with. Any suggestions of ways to get into the DnD world?

Olivia

Questions for Murph! Can you extrapolate a little on the two campaign setting ideas you were torn b/t before starting Campaign 2? How did you land on the wonderful Eldermourne? (Also, how do you approach designing your BBEGS (big bad evil guys) since Thiala was such a fun one to watch!)

spike mccue

This is a non-DnD question. You all don't talk about this much, or at all, but this podcast has been extremely successful. It's one of the top 10 creators on Patreon (according to Graphtreon). What has that been like for you all, personally?

Tom Amos

MURPH!!! Have there been any huge moments in either campaign that was something you happened to make up on the fly, then ended up being canon and completey changed something else you already had planned

Stephen Von Jett

I’ve been running a campaign on Discord for 5 months. We’ve never played in person. Several of us have never met in person. How have you all adjusted to disparate play? Do you lose something by not being in the same room?

Connor MacLean-Kennedy

Question for everyone: does anybody else picture Henry as Frank from shameless (us version)?

Broghar The Bugbear

Hey boobs, big fan, this one is for Murph. I've heard you reference the Wheel Of Time and always wondered if you have ever used them as inspiration for world building, or NPCs, or mechanics, etc...

Certainly Not Brent

my sweetheart has expressed to me that she wants to play DnD, but only if she "can turn into a dragon and kill everyone." What are your suggestions for how to handle this request? Love the show and all of you, I stan Hot Boy Summer forever

K Millan

hey! Love the pod of course of course, thanks for helping me get through some rough patches the last few years!!. My Q is: as a player, I sometimes feel like my group takes forever to get places and we all agree that sometimes the pacing feels off. we've talked to our DM and they agree too, and while they said they would push us along more, it'll probably get better with time. Any suggestions on how to immerse myself more to get more into character quicker during sessions/ any tips on that in general? Thank choo chooooo

waking epiphany

Hey friends! Obviously it’s too early to discuss this for the Choo Choo Crew but did the Band of Boobs have backup characters waiting in the wings in case their original characters met their ultimate end? We got to hang out with Jvellin for a a few episodes (rest in power, King) but did Jake have him already worked out before Hardwon had his vampire dirt nap? Emily and Caldwell, did you have secondary characters ready to go in campaign 1, just in case? Is this even too taboo to talk about? Am I jinxing something by even mentioning it? Was this already asked at some point and I missed it (I’m not completely done with campaign 1 yet)? Love you all lots and enjoying the hell out of campaign 2!

Kevin Grow

Sup naddy daddies, have you adapted any new features or anything from Tasha’s? If so, which ones?

Gabi H

This year has been rough, so I’d love to hear your favorite memories from 2020, dnd related or otherwise. (The C1 listening party definitely makes my list.)

Benny Lava

Question for Murph: how do you break the Ren laugh tick? I introduced it with a throwaway NPC in my campaign for a quick gimmick but it very quickly took over our campaign and now our real lives. I'm scared I'll never be able to laugh sincerely again.

Thale

Docent, Duncle and Daddy: How much do you prepare for one session, and how do you gauge the time your players will spend on that session? Do you prepare linearly or just see where the players go? Bonus Q: How do you roleplay mysteries, or dropping hints etc throughout a story?

Maia Costea

Choo Choo Crew, asking for Behind the Scenes Choo Choo Choices : Are you implementing changes based on Tasha's Cauldron release, or saying "we started the campaign already, so we'll keep the PC options as they were before"? Just asking because it has alot of dope modifications. Also not really a question, but my heart is BURNING for a Cluckgane update. :(

Robin Roberts

Did you know that in the Kriol language choo choo means boobs too? Although it's usually said quicker like "chuchu".

Zachary Cunningham

DM Question: How much do you tell your players about the world before they make their characters? Or do you build the world based around the characters they make?

Mitothy

Oh oh oh I have another question - Not really sure who this should be directed to, but ... For those of us hopeful little podcasters out there, do you have any tips for starting a podcast, either specific to the actual play genre or not?

Kjersa

Hey y’all—what instruments do you think each PC from Eldermourne would play?

Leondatwani

The Greatest Minds of our generations. What homebrew races or classes have you wanted to play in 5e? Or if you were to make a homebrew class or race what would it be?

billy nuttall

Question for everyone, what is your favorite DnD mechanic? It could be something like wild magic, or rage, but could also be something thats been home-brewed like the boxing or arcane.

Robin Greer

Hey Jake! If you dm'd your own campaign, what would the setting be? PS love all of you and the show!

Lisa H

This one is for everyone, but especially Emily and Caldwell! What is it like adjusting to a lower charisma party? Does it change the way you approach in-game challenges?

FumblesOBrian

For our lovely DMs: How do you keep your players on track, in particular when there is a time-based event going on? For example, I was DM'ing a time-based module where certain things happened after a designated amount of time passed. At the end of the campaign, my players were upset with me and said they felt like they didn't even get to play the full module, and my only response was "i tried getting you to do more, but you were too preoccupied with a side quest"

Double Decker Bologna Sandwich

This one is for Caldwell, Emily and Murph. Each of you brings something unique to your DM campaigns - could you give some tips on the differences between structuring short arcs like HBS as opposed to the entire Behumia arc? Thanks and you're all real cool, even Jake 😉

Mike McClosky

Question for everyone's favorite city pigeon: I'm planning on starting a new homebrew campaign soon, what are your best tips, tricks, or advice for creating a cohesive theme when worldbuilding? The setting for Eldermourne is incredibly well put together, and I'm looking to steal some strategies.

Duncan

Are there any plans for a guest DM(Brennan?) at some point, so we can see all four of you in a party together?

Mathew Schrader

Question for everyone. Have you guys had a concept that sounded really cool but wasn't actually good? If so, what was it? I had a trident fighter that was fun but was kind of not that great.

Certainly Not Brent

what video games have been getting you through this year?

Kevin S. (Kalsiq) (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Not sure if anyone has asked before but how did each of you get into D&D and what did you think of it at first?
2020-11-25 16:05 Not sure if anyone has asked before but how did each of you get into D&D and what did you think of it at first?

Not sure if anyone has asked before but how did each of you get into D&D and what did you think of it at first?

Anonymous
>>48362700

Discord! Many friendly d&d groups always looking to take in new players and welcome to the hobby.

Mel R

So this question is kinda based on all the goofs and shenanigans in the podcast, what has so far been your favorite use of a spell that was not the spell's initial intended use (creative use of a spell beyond its written intended scope? idk not sure how to word this, but hope it makes sense! EDIT: creative spell use might be the better phrasing??)

Duncan

For Murph and Emily: What's the process for writing music like? Does Murph request certain vibes for certain scenes, or does Emily listen to the episode and just do what feels right, or do you meet in the middle somehow?

Justin Chrisco

Hey everyone- wondering what has been the biggest challenges for coming up with the new characters (amazing btw). Like you guys jumped into the new crew without missing a beat they fell just as fun as the originals campaign and can't wait to have them explored more

Carter Milius

Q for Murph: I know in Campaign 1 you always made comments about the party having a lot of NPCs, sooo how does it feel giving them three right out the gate?😂 (At least Spritel is like Navi but can't talk!)

Samuel Jasek

Jake Do you think Hardwon and Tread would become a musical duo the likes of Simon and Garfunkel after the campaign ended?

THEJordonBrown

Hello! I wanted to thank y’all, first. I discovered NADDPod at the beginning of quarantine, and catching up on all the Boobs/22/Hot Boys/Choo Choos has been a rare high point for me this year. Thank you for what you do. My question: Who is everyone’s favorite villain they’ve faced/played, and why is it Galad?

Adam Michael

NADDPOD Game Question: What’s the likelihood of being able to order a Mumford and Children ale at the tavern in Moonstone?

InsertName

Question to Bonk, Honk, and Zonk. How did you come up with your character ideas? Did you pull from other sources of media, or did you know anybody in real life that you drawing inspiration from? Qustion to Honk: Are you thinking of multiclassing to monk so you can use your fists more effectively?

Evan O'Neal

Question to the DMs (including future Jake): I am a DM and really enjoy short term adventures a-la Hot Boy Summer for my players. I try to create non-traditional settings with 5e rules, such as redneck samurai setting, heavy scifi magic space setting, and more. This generally works OK, but curious if you have tips on how much the rules can bend before breaking. Also any other wild setting ideas are welcome.

Elizabeth Egel

What are some of the personality traits that your old and current characters share? I know that the characters in this campaign are super different from campaign one, but when you are playing are there any mannerisms or thoughts you have as these new characters that you used to have in campaign one as well?

Noah James Perito

A question for the Murph-Master, you mentioned the potential of doing upwards of 70 episodes for C2 - do you think the characters will get to level 20? If not, what level do you think is a good place to end a campaign?

Doug Herring

Question for Jake and Caldwell: If you were to DM a mini-campaign set in Bahumia like Hot Boy Summer, where/when would you set it? (I'd love to see Jake run an arc set at the Iron Deep Dwarfanage or Caldwell explore the Green Knights' time in the Summer Court)

Pontifex (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Anyone looking forward to cyberpunk 2077? Caldwell/Emily/Murph if you could homebrew a naruto jutsu in d&d which one would you choose?
2020-11-25 16:13 Anyone looking forward to cyberpunk 2077? Caldwell/Emily/Murph if you could homebrew a naruto jutsu in d&d which one would you choose?

Anyone looking forward to cyberpunk 2077? Caldwell/Emily/Murph if you could homebrew a naruto jutsu in d&d which one would you choose?

Joe Wakefield

Hey Choo Choo Band of Boobs Crew If you were to make a magic weapon based off your characters what would it be and what would it do?

Jake of all Trades

I want to actually play dnd but I don’t know how to find other people to play with, any suggestions on how to find a group?

Eagledink

You guys wanna play some wow.?

Aurora Morrow

A question for Murph and the 'Onks: With a grimdark world like Eldermourne but a group like the choochoo crew, how do you balance bloodborne/witcher style horror arcs and themes with the general madness? Especially as the campaign goes on and stakes get higher for the crew and Eldermorne as a whole.

Michael Critz

When will we have a Jake character crossover? Maybe an odd couple weightlifting gym starring Hardwon and Hank called “Hot Plates”?

Kreamcheese

Not even really dnd related, but how have you guys been holding up this past year? Physically, mentally, the whole shebang.

Jessy G (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Question for Murph & the gang! The games you guys run are amazing and I think partly because the main story and the characters stories are so well woven together. How much of the character’s backstory do the players give the DMs before you start a campaign? Or is it a more organic natural evolution that is just magical due to you’re combined awesomeness as performers / players / humans? Love to you all, and stay safe - from Jessica in Thunder Bay.
2020-11-25 16:17 Question for Murph & the gang! The games you guys run are amazing and I think partly because the main story and the characters stories are so well woven together. How much of the character’s backstory do the players give the DMs before you start a campaign? Or is it a more organic natural evolution that is just magical due to you’re combined awesomeness as performers / players / humans? Love to you all, and stay safe - from Jessica in Thunder Bay.

Question for Murph & the gang! The games you guys run are amazing and I think partly because the main story and the characters stories are so well woven together. How much of the character’s backstory do the players give the DMs before you start a campaign? Or is it a more organic natural evolution that is just magical due to you’re combined awesomeness as performers / players / humans? Love to you all, and stay safe - from Jessica in Thunder Bay.

Carly Anne

Do you try to include any pieces from your old characters in your new characters or do you prefer to keep them completely separate. Do you find threads of truth that run through each of your characters?

Caleb A.

Not a question but if you see this, if Amir ever does a character one shot for this campaign please have him use the weird chill guy voice he does in ep 378 of IIWY, absolutely hilarious

Hunter Vaught

For Jake and murph: do you think Henry may take the new fighting style for unarmed fighting, if so would murph possibly home brew it to be 2D6’s instead to make up for you not using you’re halberd.

Jessy G (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Total fluff question, when can we expect production to begin on the NADDPOD produced D&D 4 film? :p
2020-11-25 16:18 Total fluff question, when can we expect production to begin on the NADDPOD produced D&D 4 film? :p

Total fluff question, when can we expect production to begin on the NADDPOD produced D&D 4 film? :p

Emily E Morris

Hey y’all, I love the show and am so excited to see what Eldermourne is going to bring. I have had this question for a long time but always missed the call. What are Luna’s stats and how do you play a “good” werewolf? I’m trying to play a circle of the moon Druid who is also a werewolf. Thanks so much, from Emily Allen (Eric’s girlfriend who got him hooked on the show).

Matthew K

Do you think the cigars that Fia smokes contains additives or is it all natural just tobaccee and water??

Aaron Black

A question for Emily: Now that Order of Scribes is official, do you see Fia leaning more towards that path? If not, (this could be an open discussion for the group) how do you feel about the Order of Scribes in terms of theme and power?

katie brown

What was your very first dnd character/ your first campaign experience?

Spore Zealot

Along the same lines as the homebrew Naruto question: Matt Mercer homebrewed the Bloodhunter class for CR, Mathew Colville homebrewed the Illrigger class for The Chain, have you (Murph and the crew) ever considered homebrewing a class for Naddpod? Emily mentioned multi-classing because 5e doesn't have a witch class, has Jake or Caldwell ever wanted to play an archetype that wasn't represented by one of the 5e classes? Has there ever been discussion about making one?

Emily Piner

Do any of you, Murph included, have any crazy character ideas that you would like to play for a one shot, but are not necessarily viable for an entire campaign? For example, I have an idea for a warlock whose patron is an MLM, and they have to keep signing on new warlocks to keep their patron happy.

Meredith Froehlich

hello!! do you think that the band of boobs and the choo choo crew would get along? why or why not? i feel like everyone would get along well! especially moonshine and fia. i especially feel like henry would truly love some crick hospitality. what do y’all think? thanks!!

Whitney Peterson

Have you guys ever considered doing some video game streams via twitch? I love hearing you talk about the games you play and think it would be extra fun to watch you play, hopefully just as a stress free thing :)

Jackson Keppen

As a DM (or a player), do you have any suggestions on how to make a world more inclusive? I'm cis, straight, and white but a lot of my friends aren't and I want to smoothly include more of them in my games.

RPKB

To the whole crew--I really love the fight against Queen Ezra, and I thought the way it pulled out story and conflict in the fight in a way that gut-punched the PCs was really clever and quite cinematic. I was wondering if you have had a similar experience in a home game? I have considered doing something with the players I have in my own game, but I just feel like without the more performative aspect of playing for a podcast, it could just come across as bullying my players. Love the show, and I am loving the Choo-Choo Crew!

Jordan Lyons

Da crew: I know you can't tell us everything, but how has the process of background development for your Eldermourne characters differed from Bahumia? What was the process you each went through? To precious Daddy DM: how much self-written character background is too much for your PCs? I tend to go overboard as a player.... 😬

Matteo Cina

Is it better, in real life or in play, to be a dumb winner or smart loser?

Jazzypiantrum

How much of the story Is improvised? How far ahead do you plan?

Scott Boegeman

Question for the DMs: One of the newer players in the game I run is having some issues with non-combat scenes, especially when they get to see all of the neat ways the experienced and creative casters use their spells to solve problems. I want to build some encounters that help that player shine, without explicitly telling the casters something like "your magic doesn't work here." Got any tips on building encounters like that?

Jason Matthews

How would you other characters interact with eachother?

Lucas Lindholm

What is the absolute worst thing about your new characters?

Anyssa

(For anyone who's DM-ed) What's your process for creating entirely new worlds/settings? How much do you figure out ahead of time vs. throughout the campaign? I'm especially interested in how you handle the different races and political structures.

Molly Flores

If the Band of Boobs and Choo Choo Crew were in quarantine, what new hobbies would each character take up? I'm picturing Hardwon following along with Bob Ross videos, etc. Love you all! Thanks for keeping us sane during our own quarantines!

Connor McFarlane

Emily/Jake/Caldwell, do any of you have a backup PC in mind in case Fonk/Honk/Zonk dies?

Scott Boegeman (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Question for everyone: Do you have any background in tabletop games other than D&D?
2020-11-25 16:29 Question for everyone: Do you have any background in tabletop games other than D&D?

Question for everyone: Do you have any background in tabletop games other than D&D?

Rachael

Not really a question, but who else thinks it would be awesome if they would be able to put together a 2021 calendar with fan art?!

Ryan Vaughn (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 How has it been doing everything remotely during covid times? My D&D group started playing remotely a little over a year ago and its been great (Discord + Roll 20), it has its difficulties but there have been bright spots too. I've been the DM now for a few months and having the ability to draw battle maps and campaign illustrations digitally and upload them to Roll 20 and share them on our discord has been wonderful. Is there any part of your new recording and playing set up that has been a surprising benefit over playing in person?
2020-11-25 16:29 How has it been doing everything remotely during covid times? My D&D group started playing remotely a little over a year ago and its been great (Discord + Roll 20), it has its difficulties but there have been bright spots too. I've been the DM now for a few months and having the ability to draw battle maps and campaign illustrations digitally and upload them to Roll 20 and share them on our discord has been wonderful. Is there any part of your new recording and playing set up that has been a surprising benefit over playing in person?

How has it been doing everything remotely during covid times? My D&D group started playing remotely a little over a year ago and its been great (Discord + Roll 20), it has its difficulties but there have been bright spots too. I've been the DM now for a few months and having the ability to draw battle maps and campaign illustrations digitally and upload them to Roll 20 and share them on our discord has been wonderful. Is there any part of your new recording and playing set up that has been a surprising benefit over playing in person?

Maaronerfan

If the band of boobs and the choo choo crew swapped places, how do you think Bahumia and Eldermourne would be affected?

Ava

What has changed in y’all’s lives now that podcasting is your job? Could you see yourself doing a non-entertainment job?

Anonymous

Oh, also, one final question for Emily: what's your thought process when picking spells? Do you go with whatever seems coolest/most interesting, or do you like to follow a character theme?

Isaac Knowles

Here’s a question for Jake, Caldwell, and Emily. What drew you each of you back to the fighter, half-caster, and full caster with a sword roles?

Sea Slug

Emily/Jake/Caldwell/Murph, do you think you could take your Eldermourne PC's (Bookvar for Murph) in hand to hand combat?

Corey Van Idour

Question for Big Daddy Murph. I noticed in campaign one you were very generous to the band of boobs in giving magic items and permanent boosts( Hardwons ever enlarging hammer, Permanent stat boosts from the elementals or the deck of many things) How do you feel that affected the balance of the encounters? Do you plan to do more often temporary boosts for the Choochoo crew instead of the powercreeped band of boobs?

Marty Shaw

Hey Everyone! A little off the beaten path here but I've often been impressed by everyone's apt sports references! Last week there was references to hockey, football, and I laughed so damn hard at Murph's reaction to Caldwell's hell in a cell comment. What is everyone's sport of choice and who are your favourite teams? Much love from Canada!

Mahr

For Bonk Bonk Zonk Vervonk, will you ever get to make better potions by finding ingredients throughout the adventure? It seems like a cool collecting thing, as your past characters have collected patches, teeth, etc.

Billy Glosson

Emily have you considered the arcane domain for cleric in your hybrid class? Jake have you looked at the Way of the Astral Monk as perhaps a multi class option?

Austin Johnson

What is Hank's favorite hotplate recipe? I have this feeling that Hank can grill a cheese with the best of them.

Bobby Huggins

A question for everyone, commenters included: If you could pick one DnD spell or ability to have in real life, what would it be? What if it had to be an ability your character has?

Kai Raphael

Murph, can you give a little insight on how much of a scene you write around NPC's? As in do you write whole paragraphs or just bullet points? Thanks for the amazing stories so far, keep up the good work!

Amanda

Emily, are there any differences in musical inspiration while writing songs for this campaign vs. the first one?

Brandon Harris

I recently got my girlfriend into the show and she has a few questions: The first is for everyone: where do you draw your inspiration from when designing your characters? What are the roots of Fia, Henry, Beverly, Moonshine, etc...? Do you draw from your favorite media, or something else? The second question is for Jake: as the newest player amongst everyone, what was it about dnd that made you keep coming back week after week? Last question for everyone: if you could play dnd with anyone dead or alive, who would you play with?

Emily C

What the hek happened to those who bent the knee?

Michael Conrad

A question for everyone: Besides Brennan playing Deadeye, Emily is the only player who has done multiclassing with her characters on the show. Are there any mutliclass builds that you all have wanted to try? And for Emily, are there any other multiclassing builds you are interested in but haven't been able to play yet? P.S. Henry and Fia have inspired me to do a War Cleric/Echo Knight Fighter build in my current home game.

Tristan Nguyen

A question for the entire Choo Choo crew: how much planning do you guys do individually with murph for your character back story related archs? How much of it is a surprise to you as players and how much did you already know was going to happen? (Hope you guys are staying safe during the pandemic sending my best wishes from Australia 💕)

Samantha Olthof

I am playing in a campaign where one of the PCs is Evil and it's causing a lot of interparty tension and even PVP combat. I even retired my Good aligned character because it didn't make sense for her to be on board with the stuff our party gets up to. How would you guys advise dealing with party conflict like this?

Alex

What is Henry, Fia, and Zirk's mile times?

alethea

I'm going to college soon and was wondering how should I go about finding people to play with while still maintaining my hot girl persona? thank you and much love!

Brittany Tielke

Question for all of you: Which npc voice of Murph's is your favorite and least favorite? A few of my favorites are, of course, Ren and Sebastián's ghost.

Budget Builders

Did Murph tell Emily and of the plans for the Bahumia season or even this season? My DM is my brother in law and whenever he has an idea for something he will run it by me to see if I think myself as a player and others will like it and its only between him and I. I never tell anyone and I dont let that effect how I play my player either. Thank you guys for filling all 10 of my hours at work with the laughter and shenanigans of the "choo two boobs" .

Casey Brenner

Hi pals! If you were to be participants in a naddpod-wide “Secret Santa” holiday gift exchange that includes all characters and NPCs, who would you most want to be your gifted and giftees?

Parker

What merch would you love to see get made, but would be totally impractical/impossible to do?

Two Deers Beep

Hardest part about starting a new campaign or any advice for someone? About to finish up my 1-20 game that me and my friends have been playing for the last 3 years that I DM

Jeffrey Steck, Lord of the Fjord

Is everyone as great as Murph at talking to themselves? What would a convo between Hank and Hardwon or Fia and Moonshine sound like?

Cameron

For the DMs: How much further ahead do you have planned in your campaigns for the show vs your home games. How much more of the world is fleshed out / do you have more of an idea of where you want the story to go?

Jason Scott

Curious to hear about the differing approaches to NPCs. I know Murph uses generic stat blocks for most - but did an NPC like Balnor get a full-on character sheet when he became a series regular?

Steve, aka, Spaghetti

Question for daddy Murphy: what are the chances of the choo choo crew can get a Star Spawn cat named Grahkklm. They are from the Rrakkma module and they would certainly fit into the atmosphere of Eldermourne. They could easily be a train yard cat that lives in the same train yard as Fia!

Catalina Canales (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Hello choo choo crew, I love Naddpod <3 My question is: You always have such Amazing dialogue, do you think some of them before hand, like "oh, if this thing happened I could say something along this lines!" Or is it fully improvised in them moment. I feel like after my sesions I can think up amazing comebacks and phrases, but in the heat of the moment a lot of times I can't really come up with something poetic. (When I can I feel so great for the rest of the session, like "hell yeah, I gave my Emily speech!" jhdbjsdb) Love and happy hollydays!!!
2020-11-25 16:53 Hello choo choo crew, I love Naddpod <3 My question is: You always have such Amazing dialogue, do you think some of them before hand, like "oh, if this thing happened I could say something along this lines!" Or is it fully improvised in them moment. I feel like after my sesions I can think up amazing comebacks and phrases, but in the heat of the moment a lot of times I can't really come up with something poetic. (When I can I feel so great for the rest of the session, like "hell yeah, I gave my Emily speech!" jhdbjsdb) Love and happy hollydays!!!

Hello choo choo crew, I love Naddpod <3 My question is: You always have such Amazing dialogue, do you think some of them before hand, like "oh, if this thing happened I could say something along this lines!" Or is it fully improvised in them moment. I feel like after my sesions I can think up amazing comebacks and phrases, but in the heat of the moment a lot of times I can't really come up with something poetic. (When I can I feel so great for the rest of the session, like "hell yeah, I gave my Emily speech!" jhdbjsdb) Love and happy hollydays!!!

Chris Gibson

I’m playing a Gunslinger who’s themed as a kind of anti-magic Witcher/Van Helsing style guy... what would be the most fun to multi-class with?

Marius Johannessen

Curious how the players "know" how much of "hand on the wheel" each of them should have. Like balancing their own and their co-players time in the spotlight and influence of story.

Rachel Long

Is Bookvar a particular book? Like if during one of Bookvars mission impossible missions he was hiding in a bookshelf and was picked up and opened, what would the reader see?

Blair the bugblair barblairian

One of the things I love about Naddpod is the fusion of mechanics and lore/roleplay that you guys often have. Do mechanics serve as writing/improv prompts, or do you have ideas that you try to find mechanics to fit with later? Is it different depending on if you are playing or DMing?

PATRIARCH

What’s your favorite kind of cheese?

DieBard

Brian, putting out a new episode each week is impressive. How do you do it? What is your recording/editing process like?

JessMayWin

If you could have anyone - famous people/ historical figures/ fictional people - guest star on your show who would you choose?

Santiago Trujillo

How can I find someone to play dnd with? I've joined discords and tried to get some friends to play but it all falls through 😅

Bryan Holt

I'm finally playing as a player on a game this sunday. When moving from DMing several games a week to finally being a player how do you temper your reflex to use the powers you once held? Is it difficult to give up control?

Dom & Holly

Question for the Daddy DM, Do you plan the cliffhanger endings to each episode prior to the session, or is that sometimes improvised on the spot if the players take the story into a direction you didn’t anticipate?

Nicolas P.

For Murph, Emily, Caldwell, and Jake, if you had to choose, what would be your real life skill proficiencies? Let’s say you each have 3. Huge fan of the pod and love you guys.

Stuffandsuchrqg

Hey Dunkle, Does Zirk have adhd or something similar? Definitely getting some positive vibes from zonk. Thank you! I love all your characters.

Kora la Bora

I've been DMing for a group that my husband is in for a while and I was wondering, Em and Murph, how do you manage the power dynamic between you two when playing? I know you've worked together for a long time but I find it's hard to not have my husband as a sounding board for ideas about the session. And it's hard not to bring my personal pet peeves about him during a session. You two do an amazing job managing that from a listener prospective or at the very least just editing it out 😉

Jack Campau
>>48366112

improved pact weapon hexblade warlock with sharpshooter/elven accuracy if you can swing it. If you wanna invest less levels/time though there's always assassin rogue or gloomstalker ranger. Hope that helps friend!

Dave M

For Murph: How much input, if any, do you get from the players when building the world? For example, do you ask what kind of place they want their character to be from and then build a locale around that?

Tobias Oliver

Jake, who’s the better shadow boxer; Shank, Hardwon in his cabin, or Jake in the bathroom before a boss fight?

William

For the players- It's pretty clear that each of the PC's have a good dash of tragic backstory. Without spoiling anything, can you tell us what the characters were like before everything started going wrong for them? Were they always mostly alone like they are now or did any of them ever have groups of friends and acquaintances? Did Henry peak in college?

Maddie

Bringing this back... what the heck happened with Cluckgane Bowl?? I am dying to know!!

MJPindara

Hey Gang! How would the Choo Choo crew celebrate thanksgiving, if it did/does have an Eldermourne equivalent. Thanks and enjoy the holiday!

Kaylie Elise

To Murph; where there any plot points in campaign one that you didn't get to use but had prepared for? Seeds you dropped in the campaign that never got brought up? Like storylines that you planned for Iron Deep or things you had planned for the Summer Court?

Robert G Anderson

For the players- what is the perfect Sunday for Zirk, Fia, and Hank.

Burke

Murph, what are some perks and challenges you’ve found in going off the board and making a world with races and mechanics that are totally unique to you? On the one side you have even more creative freedom, but I imagine most WOTC and Kobold Press books are designed with high fantasy in mind. What’s it like to leave those tropes behind?

Everett Pidgen

What moment do you think made the biggest impact on your characters in the previous adventures like the band of boobs and retrieval team 22? I think it would be interesting to see what you guys though

Hoid's Friend

What's everyone's favorite/most memorable nat 20 and nat 1?

Lance Minnis

Hey Choo Choo Crew! LOVING Eldermourne and your characters! What advice would you give a small party of non actors/not trained improv performers so that everyone respects each other's space around the table, yes ands, and doesnt meta as the players in a session? An how do ya'll feel about people using content from you guys to homebrew their own games...dying to make a crick elf and pal with a bullywug sidekick in the crick! Thanks for keeping up the awesome!

tacticalgrandma
>>48366814

The subreddit lfg is a good place to start- definitely a process to find a good group but I got there!

tacticalgrandma

Emily's gotten to show off some great multiclass builds already on the show- but do any of you have some weird or crunchy subclasses or combos you'd like to play? Or does Emily have any more planned for Caldwell's Campaign 2?

Ted H.

Hey if you’re all the band of boobs and there are three of you does that make Murph the girl from Total Recall and the fans Arnold Schwarzenegger? Seriously though I’ve been DMing my first game for a few sessions and I have a player who’s a long time friend but he only really cares about the combat and will check out or complain at story/role play portions and it kind of takes some of the other players myself included out of the flow of the game and I don’t really know how to approach him about it, any advice would be very helpful. Your all beautiful little lights in this dark shadowfell like time, Love you all

Joe S

Jake, imagine you had to play a spellcaster, what class would it be, and what's the character pitch?

Julia De Hart

Which NPCs from Eldermourne do you think each of your Bahumia characters (+Balnor) would be friends with/get along with the best?

Joe S

You're all experts at making a radio show... but what would be the absolute worst audio only character builds.

Wylie Whiteaker

would naddpod ever consider having dnd players that are famous on twitch tiktok or youtube as guests or even forgotten realms authors like Erik scott de bie?

Kavanagh Golka

What are some of or your favorite multiclass combos you have either tried or wish to try in the future? My favorite is the barbarian totem warrior (with the bear totem) mixed with the druid Circle if the Moon to turn into a bear. Give it a shot if you want to be a character with over 200 health and resistance to all damage except psychic! :P

Anonymous
>>48365353

It totally was until one night he heard a father like voice through the void of space and time and now it’s a tuna melt paired with a cold Bud heavy.

Connor Blanchard

Dear Choo Choo crew, when will the esteemed Yugo be making a crossover appearance on season 2?

Lucas Boyer

My question is for Murph. If the choo choo crew encounters the Deck of Many Things and someone draws the Knight card, would you consider having it be Balnor again? I just like the idea of him falling through portals and going on adventures.

mentallo

Is there any chance of a mini-campaign based on pro wrestling? Based off Murph's rhymes in HBS I think he has what it takes to be either a beloved babyface like Dusty Rhodes or a vile heel, in the vein of Ric Flair.

Dawson Mudd

If you could have any super power what would it be

Hayden Saxon

How much did Emily's previous time abroad influence her creation of Fia? And (if at all) what specifically about her travels inspired aspects of the character?

NoLifeKitty

Is there any modules you guys have seen lately you’d be interested in playing as a player? (Like avernus, frost maiden, sthrad)

Scott Reutter

Question for Murph: As someone who has been a DM for only a year, I find myself looking for help concerning gently guiding my players to objectives without taking away from their goofs and shenanigans. Are there things you can faithfully depend on to reel people in on an objective without dictating their actions completely? Thanks in advance, Fuck you, I love you, Eat a rat, Scott R. By the way I need more Hot Date. It's too good

Daniel L Hodson

Every DM ive ever played with has had a very loose structure to how they run their games. Putting us in a town after an encounter and just asking what we want to do. that always results in awkward silences and drags in the session. Murph always seems to have a plan for where his players are going to go. What advice do you have to avoid a "sandbox" feeling that won't overwhelm the players without abandoning the illusion of choice?

Decker Ames

Question for the Dungeon Daddy himself; now that you've experienced a full campaign with the now titled choo choo crew, how much of this campaign is planned in advance? Are you taking a more improvised approach?

Theodore Carraro

Seeing as most of the 2 crew has DM’d at this point (can’t wait for Jake’s Jampaign) would you say you each prefer DMing or being a player?

Terran Benedict

Have any of you ever listened to the podcast Dungeons and Daddies (Not a BDSM podcast)? And can you please do a collaboration of some kind with them? They play 4 dads lost in the Forgotten realms trying to save their sons and Beverly desperately needs more fathers.

Brian

How has starting the podcast changed your life for the better? I found the podcast in a rough patch in my life and I always look forward the new episode especially when I’ve had a rough week.

Alfredo Gomez

Question for Murphy, what would you do if you got a tpk in like the second episode of the season? Would you just start over, or would you try to salvage it even though the story hasn't even really formed yet.

Nathan

How do you bring it up to your dm that other players are casting more then the amount of spell lots they have a day or using more ki points that they had. At the time this happened we were all lvl 2. A monk, druid, paladin, and myself an artificer.

Will Brannon

Hey everybody! Hope you are all staying safe and enjoying your Bananthksgiving! My question for yall would be what class would fit each of your characters if they couldn't be what they are now? (example, Nature Cleric for Moonshine, Paladin Bookvar etc)

Brian

For murph, have you ever read fan theories about the show and ever actually put them into the lore of the world or has the lore always been made from and the crew?

Barbie Pootsky

For Daddy Murph and the 2 Crew: How has your playstyle developed or changed from the beginning of Campaign 1 to now?

Dan N

How do you suggest handling dice rolls in roleplay-heavy scenarios? Does it make more sense to roll a die before speaking with an NPC and base the interaction around the result, or start speaking with the NPC and make rolls during key moments in the conversation? I ask because in my last session I tried to butter up a henchman in a bar to try and milk him for information but ended up too deep in the scenario and was subsequently poisoned and incapacitated. Only after did I realize I should have probably made a die roll somewhere to gauge my effectiveness.

tacticalgrandma

How are you all liking the new sourcebook, Tasha's Cauldron of Everything? Is there anything in it you're thinking about using?

Kyle Hewitt

Why did you not call Henry Cavill bird "Henry Caw-vill"??

Rick Jones

What spells or abilities do you miss the most about the BOB, and inversely, what spells and abilities are you exited to explore in the future of the CCC?

Scott Reutter

Question for Emily, With Tasha's Cauldron being out for a bit now so that people could really delve through it and pick it apart, are there any classes or subclasses (or multiclass options) that speak to you for fun utility/combat/shenanigans?

JayForce

Who would survive the longest in a post government wasteland like Fallout? Both characters and person. My money is on Henry for the characters. For the real people probably Murph cause he would probably have some random unimportant tidbits of knowledge that are so obscure it would actually end up helping in the apocalypse, seems like that kind of dude.

Rachel Harris

Loving Campaign 2! Curious to hear how you would think your campaign 1 characters would interact with campaign 2 chapters? I’m imagining PawPaw and Bookvar we get along swimmingly! :)

Geraint

Release the letter? 😍

Maria Burns

What blends of races are each of the PCs? We know Zirk has some elf because of his ears, and Fia has some orc because of her tusks, but what else is in the mix? And what about Hank? Asking to better picture (and maybe draw) them!

Scott Reutter

Question for Jake, Any feats or multiclass or anything out of the norm planned for Hank? With the Ritual Caster feat, you could get find familiar and Caw Caw could live again (and potentially have advantage on melee attacks!)

Connor

Question for the Choo Choo Crew: When coming up with your characters for campaign 2, did you try to focus their design based around a specific archetype? Or did it revolve around a specific aspect of the characters personality?

Samson

Has jake played any dnd games outside of the pod?

Matthew Tyler Helm

Hey gang! Cricksgiving is almost here so I'm going to be really cheesy and ask the age-old question: what are you thankful for? I'm so thankful for all the work you all do. I lost my PawPaw (his true family moniker) last week, and the long drive to the funeral was made much shorter with you three in the car with me. Love you boobs, Matthew Helm

Coelacanth

It sounds like you guys are recording more often, rather than in big sessions. What kind of impact does the crew think that's had on your play?

WaxesWane

Question for Murph, Eldermourne is obviously a different world, but is it part of the same Multiverse as Bahumia? Like, if the Choo-Choo crew went to the Astral plane, would it be the same one Salice resides in?

Zhade

Question mainly for Murph, but interesting food for thought: Is it possible that in campaign 2 we get some kind of cameo from characters in campaign 1? Perhaps a visit from an elderly time and space traveling warrior with a love for tuna sandwiches?

Nick Wittman

Question for Emily and Caldwell! Now that you've had a chance to run games for Naddpod how do you feel its influenced you as players

Daniele the Dastardly Dame (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Hey, gang: a heartfelt question. A few days ago my very first D&amp;D character died (not counting some small guest starring in the past): I felt very attached to my kindhearted dwarf in search of atonement, and since we had another session scheduled only two days later I frantically had to create an impromptu character without having really the time to mourn. Did this ever happen to you? How do you deal with it? Am I being too softhearted to be affected this much? Thanks for your kind help. Daniele the Dastardly Dame
2020-11-25 18:20 Hey, gang: a heartfelt question. A few days ago my very first D&D character died (not counting some small guest starring in the past): I felt very attached to my kindhearted dwarf in search of atonement, and since we had another session scheduled only two days later I frantically had to create an impromptu character without having really the time to mourn. Did this ever happen to you? How do you deal with it? Am I being too softhearted to be affected this much? Thanks for your kind help. Daniele the Dastardly Dame

Hey, gang: a heartfelt question. A few days ago my very first D&D character died (not counting some small guest starring in the past): I felt very attached to my kindhearted dwarf in search of atonement, and since we had another session scheduled only two days later I frantically had to create an impromptu character without having really the time to mourn. Did this ever happen to you? How do you deal with it? Am I being too softhearted to be affected this much? Thanks for your kind help. Daniele the Dastardly Dame

Tino Bambino

Watup choo choo crew! I’m dming a campaign and one of my players and my good friend is non-binary. I want to have representation in our game without it coming off as pandering or hacky. Do you guys have any advice for a DM or even a player for that matter?

shrimpy_senpai

***Spoiler-ish*** For Emily I've been wanting to ask but In your song "one big bed" the line "the necromancer's sick" was this a quiet head nod or referencing about erdan's (a necromancer) surprise possession/sickness in the campaign???? It probably isn't but WOW ever since having that realization, that line hits SO different for me than it did before. The necromancer was sick.

Anonymous
>>48371528

P.s. the setting is in a 1940s magical new york (inspired by unsleeping city) , they’re about to find a subway dragon!

Matthew Ritsko

Hey there! Thank you so much for all the entertainment and laughs you’ve provided in an otherwise bleak year! My wife and I are curious if you’ve ever imagined what your personal ability scores are. Can’t help but be curious who has the highest STR, DEX, CON, INT, WIS, and CHA, haha! Have a happy cricksgiving!

Donny

Caldwell and Jake, have you considered multiclassing as well? If so, what other classes interest you?

Mage Hand

Hello most honorable boobs, I have been playing in 5 campaigns with my closest friends. One of my closest friends was my ex and we recently had a falling out. How do we divide the campaigns? How should our characters be dealt with in the campaigns they are no longer in? I always admire your communication as a group. Thanks!!

Dustin S.

has any of the characters you've played as left an impact on how you live your everyday lives and/or changed how you interact with other people

shrimpy_senpai

****For Players OR player pcs**** If you/ your characters were royalty or symbols of status what would your/their signature/family dish? Ex: House Sewastion's and shrimp scampi.

Anonymous
>>48371842

I’m sorry to hear that man. I went through kind of a similar situation and I gotta say communication really helped for me. Chatting with my friends about what they wanted to do and looking forward to creating something new. Good luck! I hope your question gets answered!

Orangeleader398

Hey gang! If you could bring one NPC personality from Campaign 1 and put it into a new NPC in Eldermorne who’s personality would it be and why?

Brother Lagniappe

Question for the DMs: Recently I ran a session that went very poorly. I was stressed from real life and wasn't able to complete some of my prep work that made the session confusing and tedious for my players. Now I know I should have just postponed the session, but can't do that. My question is, should I roll with what happened and just make adjustments moving forward? My other thought was to retcon the whole encounter, say that what happened was "all just a dream" (they spent the night before in a magic grove of light). and restart the encounter with some tweaks. The narrative of this game is much more Saturday morning cartoon vs typical dnd. PS Murph did you ever see the fanart i made of Theobald cutting the rope?

Vijay Maharaj

Since y'all have created all different kinds of story driven content before, how does that compare to building the story of a campaign? Also, has being in a story driven campaign changed how you guys think about creating other content? AKA Are we ever getting Season 3 of Hot Date?

Benjamin Wright

When Murph is building his world's, where does he typically start? Do you start with the major conflict, the vibe or something completely different. Same Q goes to the two other beautiful budding DMs within your ranks.

Anonymous

hey guys! i know caldwell mentioned that eldermourne 'looks' like claymation in his head, but what about the rest of you? do you imagine scenes while you're playing them, and if so, how do they look to you? live action, anime, 3d animation, etc.?

Connor savage

Would you guys ever consider doing a “My Hero Acedmemia” typos thing were you put out a drawing or some sort of deal for the Patreons and we submit an NPC into the game?

Austin M Ryan

I am playing the BBEG in my friends campaign. I used to play in the group but had to drop out because of scheduling conflicts. He's a high level bard parading as a cleric of bahamut. We're going to reveal that I'm playing him next session. What would be a dope first line?

Dave 3D Art

Why can't there be a magical hotplate? Feels like it would only take a few mild enchantments to create a functional one. Surely enough for Six.

Riley McCann

Question for Murphy, Caldwell and Emily! (Sorry Jake) When did you guys first play dnd? How old were you? Who were your first characters? What campaigns were they in? Murph, did you pop out of the womb DMing or did you start as a player? What was your first DM experience?

SamBean

Your characters are always so full of well... character, what it y'alls process when it comes to coming up with these wonderful PCs?

Laurawr

Which improvised character moments ending up having unforeseen lasting consequences throughout the rest of the campaign?

Jordan

all of your guys characters eventually get heavily tatted, do u guys have any tattoos? and if you had to what would u get as a full back piece? lay out the scene

Supsupcool

Will anyone else multi class later on in the campaign?

Santiago Trujillo

Question for the band of books and/or choo choo crew, what are your GOAT Thanksgiving foods. Thats in regards to the GOAT Show.

Joe

@emily did you think about the wizard-blade singer subclass instead of mutliclassing?

Vander

Have you guys looked into Tasha's book yet? Anything that excites you?

Sawyer Erstad

Are you using the new rules presented in Tasha's Cauldron Of Everything?

Luke Kell

Were there any classes you were debating on playing before you settled on your character?

Jordan Jenkins

How have you guys found playing over zoom in the main feed? Is it just more convenient and similar to recording the short rests or are you looking forward to playing in person again?

sphiggs

When's the Bookvar plushie coming out?

Andy H

Question for murph: Where do you take inspiration for your world? And when you hit a roadblock, what do you do? - from a fellow DM

Jamie Advincula

did you have anything planned for Ramusset (spelling?) the port city briefly mentioned in Bahumia ep. 75?

Steph

Which NPC would you want to get a beer with from Eldermorne?

Mirarreiro

Jake: Do you think Hank Honkhonk is ever going to use the halberd as the story progresses or are you sticking to boxing?

Fandom Encounters

Murph and Caldwell have created incredible and rich worlds, and Emily created the ideal beach town of Bahumia - if you guys were going to play a game of dnd set in an established fictional world (avatar, game of thrones, adventure time, etc), what would you choose?

kettec4t

Do you have any plans of testing other systems, maybe for a Patreon goal?

David Moelker

Has Zirk ever lost a patient? And if so how did it affect him, And did he use their bones for potions to later give Hank HonkHonk? And separate question for the Direct Messenger Himself, How do you go about describing scenes so Well? And Finally, will we be seeing Hank's precious Hot plate Come to life like Bookvar with the Awaken spell?

Bugsy

Jake, what type of Campaign would you like to run and what would be your title?

Swamp Daddy 42

Emily, you play a damn Stars Druid?!? Where? Who are they? What’s their deal yo?! I have a Firbolg stars Druid named Bohdi. He’s a navigator on a pirate crew. Love the class. Also, what’s your thoughts on changes in new Tasha’s?

Francis Poirier

How much time does it take to record one episode and how much time does it take to edit one, comparing to the final product?

Callum Clark

If you could pick any npc from either campaign to permanently join your party who would it be?

Ben Kloosterhouse

What is everyone’s favorite class to play? Will Jake ever run a campaign?

Kevin Smith

How do you find transitioning from a character you played for years to a brand new character? Has there been any difficulty?

Cameron McEwan

Hey Choobs! If you (as actual people) had to live in Eldermourne, what jobs do you think you’d have?

Amy Apps

Fuck, marry, kill: Nana Kindleaf, Pendeghast and Cooter

Cameron McEwan

One for Jake: if Hank could be incredibly /above/ average at something or in some way, what would he choose?

Anonymous

This is a question for the Direct Messenger, what was the creation process for the world of Eldermourne?

TransCrafting

Emily, what is Fia's favourite book? And what is your favourite book? Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

Garrett Morrow

Hey guys! I love your show so much, it’s my favorite thing. It’s actually inspired me to start DM’ing for some friends of mine. Its a lot of tough work, and you guys do such an amazing job at it, but I wanted to ask something simple. What’s your trick to describing locations? Whenever you guys do it, I really do feel “transported” there ;) I was just curious about your process. Thank you for everything, Callooh Callay! P.S. Jake, I know this question doesn’t necessarily apply to you, but I still love you the same. Walls up!

BenMightSmite

Daddy DM Murphy:Would you ever consider releasing the world of buhoomia(probably spelt that wrong) as possibly your own book so we could run games in that world

Saint Siah

I am always so curious to see you guy’s character sheets! It would be cool to see how your characters develop

SamBean

Not really about the campaign, but are there any books, games, or shows that any of you have gotten into that you would recommend to us Naddpoles?

Dustin K

+1 for your thoughts on Tasha's

Indie21

Please oh please the lot of you: Hello from down under! I DM for a great group of people and during our strict lockdown here in Melbourne we switched to playing over Zoom. Our Fighter was negotiating with a map merchant for a map of the city they were in and asked to inspect the map. When they were shown the map they 'screenshot' the game (unbeknownst to the rest of us) and refused to barter further. I out away the map thinking everything was hunky dory. Later, when the map was crucial, my player claimed their character had a photographic memory and showed the screenshot to the rest of the group! Being a benevolent DM and all of us getting a good laugh out of it, the gag became canon and we've done some great stuff with it: eg, we keep a record of our adventures entitled 'Zashier's Photographic Memory Journal'. I know this will bite me later, so my question is this: how do I mess with them and what shenanigans can I throw their way to make them (hilariously) regret their actions? Hope you're all well on that end of the world!

Lee Blatchford
>>48369670

So much the same!! Found Naddpod at a real low point and it has help keep me sane through laughter! 👍

Todd Sarjeant

What was the hardest thing to learn (Jake) or master (Caldwell and Emily) about characters or DM’s (Bryan)?

Scott Hewson

For Emily: how have your influences or approach to making music changed with the new campaign? Are there any instruments or styles you haven’t incorporated yet but are still dying to try? (Maybe a collab???)

Hannah Earl

Emily - Not a question but consider this alternate multi class build for 5e witch: Sorcerer/Druid. I really want to play a Phoenix sorcerer/wildfire Druid bc it seems rad and also like is cool narratively.

Hannah Earl

What color is Bookvar’s binding? Is he a leather book and how refined is his binding? Is he a fancy lad because Murph’s voice makes him feel like a fancy lad?

Arknon

Question for Caldwell, Jake, and Emily: Do you have any plans for multiclassing (or more multiclassing)?

Kayla Bella

Question for Murph; do you think this new campaign will be as exploratory as the last? The BoB traveled all across Bahumia and beyond, but it seems easy to get into the rhythm of a city in Eldermourne and not stretch too far beyond it.

Jay V

How do you all go about creating and building a world to live in? Eldermourne is such a strong setting and all the characters have such a fun and unique relationship to it! How much of a role has everyone had in creating the world of Eldermourne, or is this a DM Murph exclusive?

AMbaldursson

Mr. Tanner, How are you prioritizing your prepared spells for Dr. Zonk. Do you prioritize ritual spells so you can use your slots for elixirs or do you dismiss the elixirs for other healing spells mb?

Will Smith

Jake, Are you planning to keep the fist as your primary weapon? I liked the idea of Henry being a 2-handed weapon wielder like Hardone but the bone claws sound awesome. If you do keep the claws will you upgrade or use fist weapons instead of just the bones?

Nathaniel Carlson

A question for the whole band of boobs: did your characters have any specific inspiration behind them when you created them? Were there any characters or even real people that fed into your image of your characters?

Lord Josmar

For all players - With Hank’s switch to fists from the halberd, this makes me wonder how many other character detail decisions were made in game rather than during character creation?

Steven Noel C Cruz

Question for the whole crew: at some point, will there be content that resembles a marvel-esqe avengers level of agency that requires the band of boobs, the Trinyvale trio, the choo choo crew and whatever comes after to address an appropriate epic conflict or event?

SyrupSampson (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Murph - how does it feel to design your own gods for this campaign? Last campaign you used the traditional D&amp;D pantheon but you went a different way this time. Did you have any inspiration for doing that? Or any inspiration for the gods themselves that you can discuss without spoilers?
2020-11-25 21:46 Murph - how does it feel to design your own gods for this campaign? Last campaign you used the traditional D&D pantheon but you went a different way this time. Did you have any inspiration for doing that? Or any inspiration for the gods themselves that you can discuss without spoilers?

Murph - how does it feel to design your own gods for this campaign? Last campaign you used the traditional D&D pantheon but you went a different way this time. Did you have any inspiration for doing that? Or any inspiration for the gods themselves that you can discuss without spoilers?

Jordan Daniels

Not a story question, but I would love to know anything more about the NADDPOD video game!

Israel Solis

Curious to hear more about the crew's classes and where they hope to go with it if they get to reach lvl 20 like Bahumia! that'd make for a really good reflection at the end of this campaign because I remember Emily bringing up she'd like to get awaken familiar but the storyline made more sense if she multiclassed and gave up some druid levels.

Gudni Lindal

Question for Papa Murph: The podcast sounds crisp as fried chicken, the tunes are banging and the mixing is ASMR level stuff. There's probably a bunch of people here thinking of doing their own recordings of DnD sessions after listening to you guys, either for private or podcast use, but have no idea how. Could you tell us a bit about your recording process, programs and gear? How do you guys sound so good? How do you deal with recording over Zoom? Why do we never hear your cats in the background? We're all locked in because of the pandemic anyway, we might as well buy some microphones and learn sound mixing. Happy for any advice. Thanks, keep up the amazing work!

DrewPetursson (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-17 02:00 Question for Murph: I'm about to begin running my first proper campaign, for a group of mixed experience mostly newer players. How do I balance bringing them out of their shells and into a comfort inhabiting their characters, while introducing the idea of consequences &amp; stakes for choices their characters make?
2020-11-25 22:07 Question for Murph: I'm about to begin running my first proper campaign, for a group of mixed experience mostly newer players. How do I balance bringing them out of their shells and into a comfort inhabiting their characters, while introducing the idea of consequences & stakes for choices their characters make?

Question for Murph: I'm about to begin running my first proper campaign, for a group of mixed experience mostly newer players. How do I balance bringing them out of their shells and into a comfort inhabiting their characters, while introducing the idea of consequences & stakes for choices their characters make?

Brendan Wohlers

Two parts here for the whole crew! What is the location or cultural phenomenon of the eldermourne world that you are most excited about? Murph, without giving away too many details, did you have a favorite location, character conflict, or ideal while you were world building that you hope the band will explore? I think The Chosens was about personal freedoms limits and was wondering if you had such a theme in mind for eldermourne.

Kane Sanchez

A short one; why didn’t they hit level 20 in campaign one?

Nathan Rome

I think this was asked about trinivale/bahumia but I'm interested to hear it for new characters: how would your characters from different campaigns get along if they met each other?

Wit & Whimsy

BLADESINGER: Does Emily have any interest in Tasha’s new bladesinger? SPRITES: Are sprites similar to Brandon Sanderson’s Spren from Stormlight Archives? NEW RACES: what new race would you create under Tasha’s custom race rules?

Joshua Daley

Any updates on the graphic novelization of the band of boobs

Rob T

My sisters weren’t able to get past all the dragon pussy talk of campaign 1 but they absolutely love the Campaign 2 so far. How have you reacted to the change to far? Any goals for the future in the campaign?

JimJam

can y'all upload your podcasts to a youtube channel as well? I mainly get my podcasts from that and I'd appreciate it if y'all uploaded there as well, you don't even need to record video, just put your podcast logo for the visual

JimJam

Also can we get more baggin' it with balnor? I know they're supposedly "dead" but it is somewhat outside canon

Maguire Mulligan

Question for the Hunk Jake - how heavily did your love for the name Hank play into naming your character Henry and almost forcing the nickname Hank?

Jewel

Question for Daddy Murphy: Which character from the Choo Choo Crew would Akarot become weirdly fixated on like he did with Beverly?

Jewel

Question for the everyone: If you had to eat something made entirely from Bukvar's ... materials, what would you most want to eat?

Kevin Tan

Question for daddy murphy - how much time do you prep for each episode, and how much do you know about the direction of the story at the start of every campaign?

Tattoo'd P-psychologist

Really interested to hear how each player is jiving on their new characters and the respective roles they play in the ChooChooCrew! Especially, how has this campaign been for you while transitioning from the personalities and roles of the Band of Boobs?

James Yorkshire Pud

Hey you beauties, naddpod really butters my crumpets. What are your characters' favourite movies? And why is Balnor's 'Rampage' feat the Rock

Melissa Titus

I have a player advice question: I’m currently in a campaign and my character was already kind of self-centered (my plan was for her to evolve over time.) however, the dm baited me with a magic item that was cursed. I fully forgot it was cursed when I was looking at my inventory during a fight and used it. Now my character is magically self-centered (the magic triggered her to care about no one but herself.) the other characters don’t know (the players do of course.) How do I back out of basically becoming a villain and turning on my party?

Christina Sewell

For everyone: What is your favorite thing that another player has done so far this campaign?

Candelario -Candyman- Ramirez III

Hey, gang! Two questions: 1) Have you checked out the new Animaniacs on Hulu? 2) Does Balnor have the ability to jump dimensions and have a "Baggin' It w/ Balnor" with the new group of heroes?

Ezekiel J Dean

Advice on starting a stream/podcast (just for fun) with players (and a DM) who aren't actors or comedians?

Anonymous
>>48385160

I could be wrong, but I thought they did, tbh. Maybe it's been too long since I listened to the finale.

Frank Mastromatteo IV

Question for The Choo Choo Crew: did you each have other classes you were considering for this campaign? What ultimately led you to choose each of your classes? Question for Papa Murph: Do you have any guidelines for what classes your players pick in terms of keeping the party balanced mechanically and production wise? Also, if you were to be playing a PC in Eldermourne, what classes would you choose and why?

James Lloyd

What is that one class that you would just never play because it is just eww for some reason. For me it is the Bard, I have a mental disconnect with how performance can cast such powerful spells when others have to make deals with devils, Gods or study in a library (having said that, the College of Eloquence, Greek philosopher inspired Bard has piqued my interest).

Emma B

DM/all players question.. How you you write characters backstories into the campaigns? How much of it would you say comes from the players when they design their characters, and how much does Murph create as the DM? Then, from an overall campaign point of view, do you start with the characters and build initial plotlines and arcs from them, or do you start with a rough storyline and build characters to fit into that?

Emmie

FMK Sewastian Syb and six hotplates

Branch

Question for DM especially Murph. How/when do you make the decision to introduce the deck of many things. It’s always really interesting and can introduce some great stuff story wise like our favorite dad Balnor but it can also kinda blow up the whole game

panpolypuff

Any interest in running some other game systems for one-shots? I’d love to hear y’all go nuts on a Grant Howitt 1-page game or something.

Cook

What’s the biggest thing you’ve ever seen?

Fenn Crane

Ohhhh what software do you use to edit the audio???

ItzTK

Have you guys considered playing other systems? Could call the podcast Not A DnD Podcast.

Ben from Cleveland

Sorry if this has been asked, will Jake take the new unarmed fighting style from Tasha’s? Seems perfect for him, love y’all

Emmitt Kussrow

What modern, processed food item would reduce each of your characters to 1 HP (or, twist, full HP) upon consuming it? Cheez Whiz? Warheads candy?

Henry Whittington

So which is a better band name Better Space Control or Roundhouse Soufflé

Devin Tyler

One of my players wants to shillelagh his long bow to shoot magic arrows. Is that a thing? Should it be a thing?

Mahde Alchab

Just started a homebrew session and this is my first time DMing! My players have been having a great time with it so far but I noticed that combat gets a bit boring where it just turns into my players just waiting their turn to roll dice and they never seem to talk to each other or flavor their attacks. Any advice for making combat more engaging?

Andrew

If you had to pick either the Band of Boobs or the Choo Choo Crew to quarantine with, which party would you choose and why?

Justin Neal

I can’t really think of a comedic question, so I’ll just ask a practical one. As a DM, how do you go about balancing encounters?

Jennifer Wyrick

For all the players: what spells/abilities are you most looking forward to getting as you level up?

grodon909

If you could make your own class, what would it be like?

Alyssa I.

What genre is Bookvar? I know he was awakened but I don't remember if it was ever said what kind of book he was.

Mason McCauley

Players: Lots of tables use session 0 to establish expectations in games, dynamics, and characters. What is something you always like to discuss during a session 0 or what is one question you think a DM should always ask their players during that time? DMs: I know Murph put out a pretty great fighter subclass a while ago. That got me wondering, are there any subclasses or races that you have homebrewed for your games? If so, how did you go about doing that?

Jai Toms

Question for Jake: When are you going to host your own mini-campaign?

Anonymous
>>48398151

RAW, it explicitly states in the spell that it works on a quarterstaff or a club in your hands. Rule of Cool? Do what you want!

Obispolee

My question is, I'm trying to write a Homebrew campaign and I'm struggling to create my world I just keep hitting writer's block what are some things you do to help you create your worlds?

Ethan Bridenhagen

For Murph, in prepping for campaign 2, what were the best and worst fairy tales you read for inspiration

Ashen

Jake, any chance we’ll see you dm-ing, whether it be a side camping or a one shot?

Pugachu 123

A question for the players. If your characters from the old campaign met your new characters do you think they would get along?

Keegan Acquaotta

What made you guys decide to go for a new setting instead of Bahamia 2.0?

James Giesbrecht

Thomas Middleditch said he would love to be invited on as a guest for Naddpod, is there any chance of this crossover?

Fallon

What is the best way to make a one-shot fun and interesting but within one session? I want to play with some people but we can’t meet up often, so starting a full campaign would be difficult.

VerminFang

If Murph were to have had his own PC for the setting what kind of character would he be most excited to play in it?

michaelopolis

Just want to say “shout out to the choo crew”! Love you all so much.

lilly smoke

If the band of boobs from c1 all made a time capsule to be opened after the first one of them died, what would they put in it? Possibly one big one or individual ones? Thank you!

Error

Not sure if it’s been said, but train enchanted so the Choo choo crew can use it like hard ones sky ship? Idk might be to broken