Beta Reader Text: Chapter One - Manual (Patreon)
Content
“Not only does God play dice with the Universe; he sometimes casts them where they can’t be seen.”
— The Nature of Space and Time, Stephen Hawking and Roger Penrose
A “manual” in the context of a vehicle conjures two concepts: The first is a manual transmission, which makes sure that an appropriate amount of energy flows from the engine to move the vehicle at a reasonable speed but which requires the driver to change gears at the right time. The second is the owner’s manual that every new car comes with that details the features of the vehicle and their function, as well as providing advice for keeping it in good condition. Both fit the context of this chapter.
Every tabletop roleplaying game has a manual transmission. The Storyteller’s hand on the gear shift and feet on the pedals are key determiners of how quickly and smoothly a story flows. Like a manual transmission, learning when and how to shift gears takes a little bit of explanation and a lot of practice. At the start, there will be a lot of stalling out, revving too high before shifting, riding the clutch, and other familiar rookie errors of the exercise. Not only that, but every vehicle (every game) is a little different and takes some getting used to — even for those who have been driving for decades.
Every tabletop roleplaying game has rules that its designers intend to help gaming groups tell the kinds of stories the game is meant to tell. Like a motor vehicle, a game’s rules don’t require that a driver have a deep understanding of the mechanics just to get around from day to day. Dashboard displays, steering assemblies, and the various hooks, buttons, and compartments are meant to be intuitive and familiar. Most of the time, the owner’s manual ends up gathering dust in the van’s glove compartment. But when the owner needs to know what a mysterious warning icon means or what kind of bulb is needed to replace a burnt out indicator light, that manual is handy. And sometimes, reading the manual can reveal useful features the owner might never have realized that the vehicle had.
In this chapter, we’ll be exploring techniques that can help a Storyteller drive the action of each scene and create a pleasant ride for everyone in the troupe. We’ll also do a deep dive into the mechanics of the Storytelling system in general and Deviant in particular.
Cadence
One of the Storyteller’s most important jobs is maintaining the chronicle’s pacing, such that it conforms to player expectations without stagnating or moving too quickly. Many tools help with this. Some are inherent to the Storytelling system. Others are specific to Deviant. Many come down to a Storyteller’s skill and experience, although they include techniques that can be learned.
Player Dice
One of the main ways a Storyteller sets the pace of a scene and controls the level of dramatic tension in it is by calling for dice rolls (or not doing so).
In general, scenes that require more rolls and/or call upon players to take turns making them require more time at the table than scenes with few or no dice rolls. The former can take an hour or more of play time to decide the outcome of events lasting less than a minute in-world, while the latter usually proceed in real time or faster.
Anyone Wins: The Storyteller calls for everyone in the scene to make the same roll, and if any of the characters succeed, the whole cohort benefits. Perception rolls and rolls to remember information often work like this. This usually guarantees that someone will succeed (unless everyone’s dice pools are very small) while leaving somewhat in the air exactly who gets to take the credit. They’re low-stakes, and it’s not unusual for a Storyteller to reward the largest number of successes — such as providing more details or a cooler description of the character’s achievement of the objective — even in the absence of an exceptional success.
Everyone, make me a Wits + Composure with a –2 penalty. April, you got no successes, so you don’t notice anything untoward. Brian and Cassie, you had one success each, so you notice some shadows moving outside your safehouse. Daryl, with three successes, you catch a flicker from the roof of the building across the street and realize that it’s the scope of a sniper’s rifle pointed in your safehouse’s direction.
Weakest Link: The Storyteller calls for everyone in the scene to make the same roll, and if any of the characters fail, the whole cohort suffers an undesirable consequence. Actions related to stealth, chases, and athletic feats are often handled this way, but it can be used anytime the Storyteller wants to introduce a complication related to that roll but wishes to leave to chance exactly who suffers that complication. Mathematically, these rolls greatly increase the likelihood that someone will fail on the action, and the larger the number of characters involved, the greater the risk of collective failure. Usually, the character with a small dice pool is the unlucky one, but if it ends up being someone who should be good at the action, bear that in mind when describing the failure (p. XX).
Everyone roll Wits + Stealth as you try to sneak past the guard tower. Eliot, Frances, and Grace succeeded, so they aren’t spotted. Hector, the bag of tools you’re carrying makes a loud rattling sound, and you’re barely a quarter of the way when the guards shine a big spotlight right at you and raise an alarm (if Hector’s dice pool is middling or small) OR Hector, you’re sneaking by just fine, but a raccoon comes out of a bush and starts making a fuss at you, attracting the guards’ attention (if his dice pool is good) OR Hector, you’re a quarter of the way to your destination when you realize that the perimeter is too closely watched, and there’s no way your friends will get past unnoticed unless you do something to attract the guards’ attention away from them, so what do you want to do (if his dice pool is incredibly good)?
Attenuated: As Weakest Link, but a character who achieves extra successes can cancel out the failure of a comrade. An exceptional success should nearly always allow this; they’re rare enough even with large dice pools that they aren’t much of a concession but let the player who pulls it off feel good about her character’s triumph under pressure. One or two extra successes (two or three total successes) is more generous. Assuming the players rolled simultaneously, the Storyteller can use the result as a creative prompt to describe how some characters’ competence or good luck cancelled out other characters’ failure. As long as all the successful characters had enough extra successes to carry their friends, the cohort as a whole doesn’t suffer a complication.
Everyone roll Strength + Athletics at a –3 penalty to jump from one rooftop to the other. Ivy and John, you got one success each, so you clear the gap, although it’s a near thing. Kevin, you didn’t get any successes, but Laura had an exceptional, so how about this? Kevin slips on some gravel just before he makes the jump. His arms windmill, and everyone gapes in horror as it becomes clear he’s about to plunge to his death ten stories below. But Laura grabs him by the jacket just in time and pulls him from the precipice. Before he can thank her, she grabs one arm and one leg and throws him over the gap, where he lands gracelessly but safely on the other side. Then Laura jumps the gap, making it look effortless.
Champion: The success or failure of an action or scene hinges on the result of a single character’s roll (which may be resisted or contested by the opposition), whether because he’s the only character present or because it isn’t one his companions can reasonably help him with. Even if the Storyteller doesn’t have a catastrophic complication in mind when calling for this kind of roll, it makes the roll seem momentous enough that the champion is more likely to spend Willpower on it, and the other players at the table will often physically lean forward to watch the result of the roll. A Storyteller should feel free to take the number of successes into consideration when describing the results, even in the absence of an exceptional success. A more than marginal success should feel like a big deal to the players — earning the champion a veritable high-five from everyone at the table. These rolls should be uncommon, this-is-your-chance-to-shine moments, since they exclude the participation of the other players. For quick fights involving one Renegade against a few faceless Baseline goons, this Down and Dirty Combat is usually a much better option than detailed violence unless the rest of the cohort can be involved in the action within a turn or two of its beginning.
Matt, you climbed up the sheer wall of the warehouse and slipped in through the window, but one of the four Junotech thugs below spotted you. You can slip out the way you came, but they’ll raise the alarm, or you can drop down and pummel them into silence before they have a chance to call for backup. Attack? Let’s resolve this with your Strength + Brawl, which they’ll contest as a group of goons. You take some hits but keep them tied up long enough for your cohort to find another way in; everyone roll initiative (contest is a tie) OR one of them gives you a fat lip (take a point of lethal damage), but none of them has a chance to call for help (Matt wins the contest by one success) OR you take out two of the goons, but one of the other two raises the alarm (thugs win the contest by one success) OR you take out the goons quickly and silently, so that by the time your cohort finds another way in you’ve already had time to rifle through the thugs’ pockets for key cards (Matt wins the contest handily) OR they’re tougher than you thought, and not only do they alert the rest of the Junotech agents in the warehouse, they give you a savage beating before your friends can come to your aid (thugs win the contest handily).
Teamwork: This is similar to Champion, except other players’ characters can contribute dice to the primary actor’s pool, thus increasing her odds of success. This gives the other players something to do beyond watching the primary actor make the crucial roll. In action scenes where boosting an ally’s action comes at the expense of her own action for the turn, it’s usually safe to allow any number of players’ characters to serve as secondary actors, even if the target roll is an instant action. Outside of action scenes, allowing multiple people to act as secondary actors for an instant action can render it a veritable foregone conclusion — almost an Anyone Wins roll — so the Storyteller should only allow this if that’s what she’s going for. Extended actions are better candidates for multiple secondary actors, but players should be able to provide reasonable justification for how they are able to improve the primary actor’s chances within the narrative.
Naomi takes the lead in researching city records regarding the conspiracy’s early history with only 30 minutes before the records office closes (no time for an extended action), a simple Intelligence + Academics roll. The other members of the cohort — Onri, Patience, and Qasim — fetch, carry, and sort documents for Naomi.
Mixed Teamwork (Optional Rule)
By default, teamwork actions involve every participant rolling the same Skill. If the task requires Intelligence + Crafts for the primary actor, all the secondary actors roll Intelligence + Crafts to add dice to the primary actor’s pool. Under this optional rule, that’s not the case. The Storyteller should feel free to allow players to suggest different dice pools as long as the narrative justification makes sense. One secondary actor could use Wits + Larceny to shoplift materials the primary actor needs, for example, while another uses Intelligence + Computers to find design specs online that the primary actor can use as a starting point for his own project. Because these involve each character participating in the narrative process of the primary actor’s project, it not only makes success more likely, but it also engages more players in the task. The primary actor’s success becomes the entire cohort’s success.
Duel: As Champion, except the participant makes several rolls. This might be an epic battle with a nemesis, a side scene with multiple potential complications on the path to achieving an important task, or simply an extended action on a solo project. Particularly in large troupes, these should be rare because they tend to use up a lot of table time while preventing other players from participating, especially if there are large stretches of narrative time between rolls. Unless it is an extended action, calling for rolls involving different Skills makes these more dynamic. These tend to work well as cross-cutting cues (p. XX); when the character fails a roll, the Storyteller introduces a complication and moves to another player’s character.
Ryan leads the conspiracy goons on a merry chase to buy the rest of the cohort time to get the job done. He steps into view and fires his pistol at them (Dexterity + Firearms). On a success, any damage grants an equipment bonus when he attempts to goad them into giving chase (Presence + Intimidation). Ryan intersperses Physical actions to overcome obstacles (without completely giving the goons the slip) with Social ones to keep them from breaking off the chase. Failure on a Physical action makes it harder to stay in the chase, while failure on a Social action means the pursuers start to suspect this is a ruse.
Play-by-Play: Participants take turns declaring actions and making rolls, whether or not anyone rolls initiative to determine the order of actions. These scenes emphasize the importance of every action its participants take. They’re the equivalent of action movie scenes that use slow motion to show the impact of every punch and kick. It’s no accident that detailed violence (Deviant, p. 196) involves a lot of dice rolls, although Play-by-Play isn’t limited to scenes of violence (although they are the most common). When the cohort is at a distinct advantage over their opposition, this cadence emphasizes their awesomeness. When they’re at a disadvantage, it conveys the desperation of the situation. This cadence is generally reserved for scenes that involve the entire cohort, even if they are split between a couple of different locations, both because the players of any uninvolved characters may not be able to meaningfully participate in the game for a long time and because these are the scenes where the cohort comes together to achieve something remarkable together (and no one wants to spend a major climax off-screen).
After weeks of planning, Shenequa, Taylor, Uve, and Wren are breaking out of the conspiracy facility where they’re being held captive. Shenequa uses her electrokinesis to disable the door alarm on their cell (Scar Finesse roll for a Directed Variation). Taylor rips the door off its hinges (Strength + Athletics). Uve crawls along the ceiling to scout ahead for any guards (Scar Finesse to activate Brachiation, since it’s a Controlled Variation). The others follow, staying slightly behind. When Uve spots a pair of guards (Wits + Composure), Wren and Taylor take up positions to ambush them (Wits + Stealth). The struggle is short (a few Strength + Brawl attacks), but one of the guards has a chance to shout, which is bound to attract more guards. Wren steals the face of one of the fallen guards (no roll, since Face Thief is Persistent for her) and moves in the direction back-up is likely to come from. Meanwhile, Taylor rips the cover off a ventilation shaft (Strength + Athletics), which Uve explores (Wits + Survival), and Shenequa grabs a guard’s walkie-talkie, using her electrokinesis to broadcast several false messages to confuse and distract the guards (Scar Finesse roll). Wren delays the guards for a minute or two (Manipulation + Persuasion), but they have protocols, and so she has to lead them back to the rest of the cohort. Just as they arrive, Shenequa cuts the corridor lights, plunging them into darkness (Scar Finesse roll). Taylor and Wren can see perfectly in the dark, so they move to engage the guards in hand-to-hand combat (more Strength + Brawl rolls). Meanwhile, Uve has found a path to the outside of the facility, although it’ll mean getting past a battery of whirling, high-speed fans (likely a cinch for Shenequa’s electrokinesis). He lets the rest of the cohort know. Shenequa uses her electrokinesis one last time to send a shock from the guards’ walkie-talkies that stuns the last of them. Taylor and Wren have taken out several others, but noise from farther down the corridor indicates that more are on the way. Taylor lifts his friends into the ventilation shaft before leaping up after them (Strength + Athletics).
Diceless: To some extent, dice are a brake on gameplay. That can be a good thing; requiring a player to assemble and roll a dice pool can buy the Storyteller precious seconds to figure out what happens next. But they’re unnecessary a good portion of the time. If the risk of failure is negligible (good dice pools, plenty of time to keep trying until they succeed, etc.), calling for rolls would interrupt the flow of play (frequently the case in talky scenes but also applies to transitions and downtime), or the Storyteller needs events to unfold a specific way, don’t call for a roll.
Other Dice Tricks
Fundamentally, dice are a creative prompt for the Storyteller. They introduce opportunities for the events of a story to proceed along paths that neither she nor her players anticipated. Because they are usually based on a character’s traits, however, they are not completely random; a character who is good at a category of task is significantly less likely to fail at them than one who is incompetent at those tasks. As a Storyteller, understanding how dice work makes it more likely that they will be a useful creative aid rather than one that frustrates your expectations in decisively unentertaining ways.
Know the Math
Dice are probabilistic tools. A Storyteller can’t be assured of a specific result when dice hit the table, but he can stack the deck in favor of one outcome or another. Knowing whether a roll is likely to succeed (achieve at least one success) doesn’t require a degree in statistics. Here are the odds (values rounded to nearest full percentage):
[table]
#Dice 1+ Success 1+ Success with Rote
Chance 10% 19%
1 30% 51%
2 51% 76%
3 66% 88%
4 76% 94%
5 83% 97%
6 88% 99%
7 92% 99%
8 94% <100%
9 96% <100%
10 97% <100%
11 98% <100%
12 99% <100%
13 99% <100%
14 99% <100%
15 <100% <100%
[end table]
The math for exceptional successes is more complex (10-Again, 9-Again, or 8-Again? What about exceptional success on three successes instead of five? Rote?), but a web search for “Chronicles of Darkness dice probability” can get all the pre-crunched numbers a Storyteller could want.
The underlying formula for the table above is simple enough. The odds of achieving at least one success is 1-(n^x), where n is the probability of failure on each die (70% or 0.7 in the Storytelling system) and x is the number of dice.
For example, two dice would be 1-(0.7^2), which becomes 1-(0.49), which equals 0.51, or a 51% chance of success. Meanwhile, five dice is 1-(0.75), which becomes 1-(0.16807), which equals 0.83193, which rounds to 0.83 or 83%.
This formula can be extended beyond dice to include any series of trials (dice rolls). The odds of succeeding at least once is still 1-(n^x), but n is instead equal to the likelihood of failure on any roll. Meanwhile, the likelihood of failing at least one of those rolls is simply n^x.
If a character has two dice to roll on an action (51% or 0.51 per roll) and takes that action four times during the scene, rolling each time, the chances of succeeding at least once are 1-(1-0.51)^4), which is 1-(0.494), which is 1-0.05764801 or 94%. On the other hand, the chance of succeeding every time under these conditions is 0.514, which is 0.06765201 or 7%.
All this isn’t an attempt to turn your Deviant game into a statistics course but to instead illustrate two important points:
If you allow multiple attempts to achieve success, the likelihood of eventually succeeding is much, much higher, even if the dice pool is small.
If you demand multiple successful rolls to avoid complications, the likelihood of an eventual complication is way, way higher.
This is why Anyone Wins and Weakest Link rolls quickly approach “cohort always wins” and “cohort always loses,” especially in large troupes.
Even with six dice apiece (each granting a whopping 88% chance of success), the chances that at least one of five players will fail is close to even (47%). If the Storyteller requires two such Weakest Link rolls, that climbs to 73%. Three of these rolls raises that likelihood to 85%, and four rolls all but assures it (92%).
Conversely, an Anyone Wins roll with a mere two dice apiece for each of five players takes the odds that somebody succeeds straight to 97%. An Anyone Wins roll is almost always a mere formality.
This is true whether the rolls happen simultaneously (such as if all players roll) or consecutively (one or more players roll multiple times).
Know Why Dice Are Rolling
Players roll dice because they’re told to do so — whether by the rules or by the Storyteller. A Storyteller isn’t required to roll dice, and thanks to the Storyteller’s screen, she’s free to ignore the results of any rolls she does choose to make. This isn’t to say that she should arbitrarily ignore dice results or pretend they’re unnecessary, only that she has more discretion to do so when it serves the narrative.
To Choose Between Outcomes: Sometimes making (or calling for) a roll is a way for the Storyteller to convey that he thinks that the current situation is reasonably likely to suffer a complication. He may or may not know exactly what failure will mean when he calls for the roll, but the number of dice he rolls is a measure of how high he wants the risk of complication to be. Two dice is almost the same as flipping a coin and a great way to decide between two equally likely outcomes, even if one isn’t necessarily a success to the other’s failure. More dice increase or decrease the likelihood of complication, depending on whether success means “complication” or “no complication.”
To Make Players Nervous: A key component of horror is that its protagonists do not have complete information. Very often they have less information about their situation than the audience has, and the audience obviously knows far less than the writer. Rolling dice behind the Storyteller’s screen or calling for players to make rolls without providing an explanation invites players to draw their own conclusions about what their characters are missing about the situation. Particularly offline, the clatter of physical dice on the table, followed by furious notetaking, can set off alarm bells for the participants on the other side of the curtain. In these situations, the sound of many dice rolling is more likely to create tension than the sound of a few. Overuse of this can dull its impact, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. A Storyteller with a terrible poker face who cries wolf so often that the players no longer scamper when he gives the alarm can still surprise them when he introduces a real wolf.
To Keep Things Fair: Game mechanics that work the same way for everyone prevent roleplaying games from seeming arbitrary or unfair to their participants. This doesn’t mean everyone is equally likely to succeed at every task, but those who invest character creation traits and Experiences the same way (thus conveying the player’s priorities for the character’s skill sets) will be on an equal footing. When the Renegades come into conflict with Storyteller characters, players expect that their antagonists are bound by the same mechanics.
To Make Things Seem Fair: Most Storyteller characters don’t go through the full character creation and Experience expenditure process, so nothing guarantees that they’re an equal match for the cohort. Players have the advantage of numbers; more than likely, one of them will get lucky or come up with a solution that is so clever that the Storyteller would have to be a jerk not to just go along with it. When the Storyteller really doesn’t think something should work (but doesn’t want to veto it outright), giving the appearance of leaving the result to the dice can lend an air of plausible deniability when failure happens. As described above, an actual or de facto Weakest Link roll or other repeated rolls to avoid failure will eventually result in a failure, which most players will accept as the usual whims of luck and roleplaying games. That’s not to say a Storyteller should overuse this tactic, since even players who aren’t stats nerds are eventually going to pick up on the vibe if it feels like they can’t win no matter what they do. As an additional note of caution, be prepared to toss your “soft no” out the window and give them what they want if the troupe somehow manages to beat the odds and makes several successful rolls in a row; it will make them feel both lucky and awesome.
To Make Someone Look Awesome: Part of a Storyteller’s job is to give every player’s character a chance to shine, and that often takes the form of giving her opportunities to roll her biggest dice pool. It can also apply to the cohort’s antagonists, in the sense that if the troupe discovers that even their proverbial (or possibly literal) biggest guns have little or no effect, it makes it clear that they will need to take a different tack than the one they favor.
To Encourage Creativity: Roleplaying simulates fiction in that tried-and-true solutions don’t guarantee continued success. Characters who solve their problems the same way, using their strongest abilities, are more or less asking to encounter problems that can’t be solved using their preferred approach. No, a Storyteller shouldn’t refuse to give characters opportunities to play to their strengths, but he also shouldn’t hesitate to force them to compensate for their weaknesses. An enemy constantly surrounded by dozens of bodyguards might be proof against a kick-in-the-door attack, but he could be vulnerable to betrayal from within or something that cuts off the financial backing (and so his ability to pay his goons); but the players might not know that a direct assault is futile until the first time they attempt one and it goes badly for them.
Remember to Use Modifiers
Even players who don’t know the math quickly get a feel for their likelihood of success, which allows a Storyteller to convey how difficult a character is likely to find a given task:
[table]
Net Dice Pool What It Conveys
0-1 Fatalism: This is a long shot. Either circumstances are overwhelmingly bad, or the character shouldn’t have been attempting this action in the first place. Spending Willpower can mitigate this, but it’s better to find another way to solve the underlying problem, if possible.
2-3 Anxiety: This is risky. This is the dice pool size most likely to prompt Willpower expenditures to achieve basic success. Equipment can also help, often without depleting a limited resource. Unless the character must perform the action herself, it’s a good idea to ask for help from someone with more skill.
4-5 Trepidation: This is much more likely to succeed than fail, although repeated rolls will turn up a failure eventually. Spending Willpower can almost make success a certainty, as can good equipment.
6-7 Confidence: This is a safe roll — or as safe as trusting the dice can usually get.
8+ Certainty: At this point, you’re just rolling to see if you get an exceptional success, as failure is statistically very unlikely unless multiple consecutive successful rolls are necessary.
[end table]
The statistical sweet spot where players feel like they have a shot but don’t regard the roll as a foregone conclusion is 3-7 dice. When the stakes are high, players are likely to take any reasonable measures available to them to get to eight or more dice. Specialties, equipment, teamwork, Variations, and Techniques (Shallow Graves, p. 199) affect a narrower range of rolls, while spending Willpower can affect nearly any roll but is a limited resource.
To add uncertainty, the Storyteller should likewise assign penalties (and occasional bonuses) based on the circumstances. For these purposes, consider Defense a penalty to appropriate attack rolls. Untrained penalties (especially on Mental Skills) also come into play.
[table]
Net Bonus/Penalty What It Conveys
–5 dice Impossibly adverse circumstances. Most characters shouldn’t even try. There should always be some way to get out of making rolls with penalties this high. Otherwise, the Storyteller is setting up the cohort for failure in a way that won’t feel good to the players.
–3 or –4 dice Really bad circumstances. There will be fist-pumping if the character pulls this off. Certain severe Tilts impose penalties of this sort. Too many rolls with a penalty this severe is going to frustrate the players (except in Anyone Wins situations), but the occasional one is fine when it’s narratively appropriate.
–1 or –2 dice More difficult than usual. These are the penalties a Storyteller should assess most often, and he shouldn’t hesitate to impose them somewhat liberally except to Weakest Link rolls. Most moderate Environmental Tilts impose penalties at this level. Players will tolerate these penalties unless it starts to feel like they apply to every roll.
0 Typical circumstances.
+1 or +2 dice Easier than usual. Most equipment bonuses fall into this category, and teamwork involving a single secondary actor often does as well. Willpower spent to offset modest penalties often puts a character into this range.
+3 or +4 dice Character is at a significant advantage. Willpower expenditures can achieve this, but only the very best equipment (or potent Variations) can do so.
+5 dice Extremely favorable conditions. Unless the character’s normal dice pool is very small, this almost guarantees at least minimal success.
[end table]
Contested Rolls
Contested rolls complicate this considerably. They don’t make the player’s handful of dice any smaller, and the player often doesn’t know how many dice the opposition is rolling, both of which have a psychological effect. Mathematically, they work out to a dice penalty roughly equal to the opposition’s dice pool on average, but it’s more complex than that. A one-die pool can conceivably beat out a 10-die pool, although it’s extremely unlikely. However, it’s usually safe to use this when eyeballing the rough odds of a character defeating an opponent on a contested roll.
Storytelling System
As a Chronicles of Darkness game, Deviant runs on the Storytelling system. This core system has some elements that are universal to most roleplaying games and many that are specific to the Storytelling system. In this section, we’ll dissect those elements.
Extended Actions
Not every action that requires a long time is an extended action. An instant action can compress hours, days, or even weeks of activity into a single roll. Likewise, a time-consuming activity not on any timetable doesn’t usually require rolls at all. Extended actions that involve repeatedly rolling dice until the target number is reached are boring. They’re much more interesting when each individual roll means something within the narrative. Here are some ways to use extended actions to craft interesting scenes:
Competition of Quality
If characters are in competition with one another, an extended action can determine which of them produces superior results. Whoever has the largest number of successes at the end of the competition wins. These competitions can be made uneven by giving some competitors better equipment bonuses than others or by introducing time limits (potentially with interruptions that reduce the number of rolls some parties have to accumulate successes).
Competition of Speed
If characters are attempting to complete the same or different tasks faster than one another, an extended action can determine who finishes the task more quickly. This can be made uneven if one competitor requires more successes than the other, such as if it requires 10 successes to climb a rope to the top of a cliff but only 5 successes to saw through that rope with a sharp rock. Competitions of speed can also be handled using the chase rules (Deviant, p. 211).
Beat the Clock
The character must accumulate the requisite number of successes before time runs out. This can create some tension in itself but it’s much more effective when each roll has a clear narrative effect, to prevent its feeling like rolling until the goal is achieved (which is boring). To increase that tension, don’t reveal the exact number of intervals the character has in which to achieve the objective. Instead, use narrative to convey this using the looming threat, such as describing the smell of smoke as getting stronger, the security guards becoming more suspicious, etc. When you decide how many intervals the cohort has before time runs out, sketch out some quick stages to follow each roll; later stages can even impose penalties due to an unstable environment or other factors. These rising complications need not involve the active character directly. They could just as easily fall upon the rest of the cohort as they’re forced to distract (or silence) curious guards, tread water, put out fires, or whatever.
Thermometer
The Storyteller has a minimum and maximum benefit she’s willing to allow based on the number of successes the character accumulates towards a target, with degrees of success in between. This is a good way to handle research. Every few accumulated successes reveal a little more information or clearly put the character on the path to doing so (such as finding a book on the exact subject he’s studying). Each failed roll introduces some complication, potentially one that lowers the upper threshold of success (the catalog says the library has this book, but it’s not where it’s supposed to be, for example). It also works for restoring a complex broken machine to operation, with a few successes getting it to turn on or start, for example, a few more to allow it to perform one of its normal functions (badly), and so forth until it regains full functionality.
Side Project
Extended actions need not represent activities that demand a character’s full and constant attention. They can instead represent long-term projects that fill spare moments between the other events of the chapter. A Deviant might spend weeks gathering and arranging materials to build a bomb, modify a vehicle, or design a Prototype (Clades Companion, p. 56) that can be used against the cohort’s enemies. Unless the project is beyond the Remade’s skill, eventually he will complete the project, but the question of when this happens remains up in the air. The Storyteller might allow one roll per chapter for a truly off-screen activity. For one central to the events of a chapter or story, the character may have to spend a scene or more before each roll to acquire additional supplies (or address the fallout of a significant mistake, if the previous roll was a failure).
The Math on Extended Actions
A part of the drama of extended actions is that the characters attempting them are likely to succeed but might suffer complications along the way and always feel like the danger of failure is real. When deciding on the target number of successes an extended action requires (usually ranging from 5 to 20), bear the character’s relevant traits in mind (including any potential bonuses due to teamwork and/or equipment).
[table within sidebar]
Dice Average Successes per Roll Average Successes on Three Rolls Average Successes on Five Rolls Average Maximum Successes
1 0 NA 0
2 1 NA 1
3 1 3 NA 3
4 1 4 NA 5
5 2 5 8 8
6 2 6 10 12
7 2 7 12 16
8 3 8 13 21
9 3 9 15 27
10 3 10 17 33
[End table within sidebar]
Group Activity
The most dynamic uses of extended actions involve other characters in ways that drive the events of a scene, chapter, or story. It is important that the Storyteller convey the rules the group activity will follow, as it will shape the choices the players make.
Assistance: Additional characters serve in the normal role of secondary actors, rolling the same Skill and contributing additional dice equal to successes. This works best in situations where the primary actor has one or maybe two assistants, as too much help can render failure extremely unlikely, sucking the drama out of each individual roll.
Group Project: The secondary actors may contribute in other ways, rolling different Skills and contributing their successes as additional dice to the primary actor’s pool. This works well with complex projects that are easier to abstract than to play out, such as organizing a lobbying or whisper campaign or building an occult contraption. For example, the primary actor might call upon Subterfuge to start vicious rumors, supported by allies using Investigation (to dumpster dive for evidence of the target’s malfeasance), Larceny (to plant incriminating evidence), Persuasion (to turn key allies against the target), Expression (to write memorably lurid articles describing the target’s bad behavior), or other Skills the Storyteller deems acceptable. An occult contraption, meanwhile, might lean heavily on Occult but allow contributions by characters with Academics, Crafts, or Science. Although this dramatically reduces the risk that the primary actor will fail (since secondary actors are both numerous and likely to contribute Skills for which they have large dice pools), it allows more players to feel like their characters are a useful component in the cohort’s overall effort, so this weakness can be ameliorated by introducing a complication for any secondary actor who fails to add successes to the primary actor’s total.
Interruptions and Milestones: This resembles a Side Project but involves other members of the cohort in the between-rolls scenes. These can involve the whole cohort in the action or just a few of them, but each secondary actor can only contribute one relevant roll to the group effort — although the scene itself might require other rolls to address the problems within it, and the Storyteller could award a bonus or impose a penalty to the secondary actor rolls based on how successful the scene was.
Investigation
The investigation system (Deviant, p. 210) is closely related to the extended action system, particularly its Interruptions and Milestones permutation. Whether singly or in a group, the Remade engage in a scene that gives them insight into a larger problem or puzzle. At the end of it, they come closer to a fuller understanding of what they’re investigating (receive a Clue). If things go badly during the scene, they still receive a Clue, but it’s a little less useful in furthering the investigation (or actively hampers it, on a dramatic failure). The cohort can also “rush” to the truth before they’ve accumulated enough Clues, but it results in complications.
The dice pool to uncover the Clue depends on the method the character(s) are using to investigate. The Storyteller should feel free to assign a bonus or penalty to a roll based on the events of the scene. An engaging but short scene might afford a small benefit or disadvantage on the roll, while an elaborate one with several rolls could grant a massive bonus if perfectly executed or impose a substantial penalty if it’s a complete fiasco.
Number of Clues
The decision of how many Clues are required to uncover the truth rests with the Storyteller and is almost always exactly equal to the number of scenes she expects the cohort to devote to the mystery at hand. Picking that number is a pacing decision. An investigation that requires a few Clues can often be completed in a single chapter if the cohort is single-minded in its pursuit, while one that demands ten or more Clues could stretch across an entire story (or longer if the Renegades have little opportunity to focus on unraveling it).
Most of the time, the players don’t know exactly how many Clues are needed to complete an investigation, but the Storyteller should clearly communicate when they’ve successfully uncovered the truth. It is often a good idea to convey the scale of the investigation in broad terms so that players have some sense of how bad an idea it is to rush the investigation. They might regard facing slightly stronger opposition as an acceptable risk but consider being overwhelmingly outnumbered and outgunned an outright suicidal pursuit.
Elements
A Clue’s elements can always be spent to further the investigation. This can be applied in several different ways:
Uncover Clues: At the culmination of a scene, a character makes the roll to uncover the next Clue. The elements of any Clue — even an incomplete one from a failed roll — can be expended to grant a bonus to uncover the next Clue. Finding a corner piece of the jigsaw puzzle makes it easier to fit the other pieces together.
Lead-up Scenes: The Remade may also use elements to boost a roll during one of the other scenes that further the investigation, even one that doesn’t seem directly related to the Clue, such as a bonus to an Athletics roll to climb a fence.
Culmination Scene: Investigations in roleplaying games are rarely undertaken out of pure intellectual curiosity. They nearly always precede some action, whether it’s an attack on a Node or a high stakes meeting with an elusive Renegade to secure her help. The Broken may use any elements remaining to boost their dice rolls in the scene that is the culmination of their investigation. Alternatively, they may spend elements to impose a penalty to a conspiracy action taken during the culmination scene, as they have taken measures to make sure the conspiracy is off-balance. Especially dramatic moments in a chronicle can stretch out a culmination scene to affect an entire chapter — for better or worse.
Retroactive Preparations (Optional Rule)
Knowing what lurks ahead helps the Renegades prepare for it — even if the players (or the Storyteller!) aren’t quite sure what they’ll need. Under this optional rule, players can spend an element to retroactively define some reasonable preparation they made for the current scene — whether it’s one of the Clue-gathering scenes or the culmination scene.
This could be a piece of personal equipment the character could reasonably have with him but which the player didn’t specifically mention having on his person when the scene started. It can instead be the prompt arrival of a member of his cohort who isn’t tied up elsewhere. It might even be an action taken prior to the scene that impacts it or its aftermath, but this is subject to Storyteller approval, who may require the expenditure of multiple elements or introduce additional complications related to the action. This advantage shouldn’t last beyond the current scene.
Tainted Clues
Tainted Clues are usually either self-inflicted (by choosing to take a dramatic failure to get a Beat) or rare. However, they have a strong impact when they occur, subtracting a success from rolls to advance the investigation until their element is used (imposing a –2 penalty to an affected roll). Which rolls this affects at her table is a decision for the Storyteller, but here are some broad possibilities:
Unlimited or Not: If Tainted Clues have unlimited effect, they impose their penalty to all rolls in scenes that will end in the cohort uncovering a Clue. The Storyteller may instead only apply this to a single roll during each scene or only to the roll to uncover the scene’s Clue’s. It could instead only affect the culmination scene, encumbering the Broken’s actions when they matter most. A common balancing consideration is that a player may not invoke the element of a Tainted Clue except for actions that would have their successes reduced by the Tainted Clue.
Group Clues vs. Individual Clues: The Storyteller should decide whether the effects of a Tainted Clue (including the option to invoke its element) apply only to the character who suffered the dramatic failure that created it or whether it affects the entire cohort.
The more rolls a Tainted Clue potentially impacts, the more likely the players are to invoke its element at the earliest opportunity.
Major Complications
Renegades (and some players) aren’t renowned for the patient care they put into planning their operations before executing them. Even those who would like to approach strikes against the conspiracy and its agents with caution don’t always have the opportunity. Time spent investigating the enemy instead of acting against it is time that enemy has to expand its power and influence, which makes any operation conducted against it that much more dangerous. Leaping before they look can land a cohort in a lot of hot water in the form of “one major complication per Clue they fall short,” but what does this mean?
The Opposition: A conspiracy can achieve a great deal within its sphere of influence, but it is considerably more dangerous when faced at its centers of power. If the culmination scene takes place at a conspiracy’s Node, the conspiracy may spend a major complication to take an additional conspiracy action that doesn’t count towards its limit for the chapter — and may spend multiple complications this way. However, these actions must be confined to the events of the current scene.
External Factors: Complications need not stem from the conspiracy directly. They can involve factors beyond anyone’s control, such as an Environmental Tilt or the arrival of an interested third party who adds chaos to an already volatile situation. They could also target individual characters whenever they fail on a roll, automatically converting that failure to a dramatic failure (but still awarding a Beat when they do so).
Time Sensitive Missions (Optional Rule)
Often a cohort doesn’t have the luxury of time to carefully research a target before taking action against it. A Linchpin will arrive in a week and leave a day later, and if the cohort isn’t ready to strike when she is in town, they’ll miss the opportunity and waste any time they spent probing the Node’s defenses ahead of an attack.
This optional rule combines the Investigation system with the Beat the Clock version of extended actions. The Storyteller provides the troupe with a limited ration of scenes that they can devote to some mixture of conducting their investigation and advancing any of their other goals (such as coming to the aid of a Loyalty Touchstone). For maximum pressure, this limit should be close to the number of Clues required to reveal the truth before the culmination scene. If they allow themselves to get distracted, they have the choice of either aborting the operation or proceeding with it knowing that the culmination scene will involve that many more unexpected complications.
While the Storyteller might choose not to reveal exactly how many Clues the investigation will require, she should usually be pretty clear about how much time the cohort has to complete it — and whether this is to be measured in scenes (which encourages the cohort to engage in them together) or in-world time (which encourages them to take a divide-and-conquer approach to the investigation).
Action Scenes
Whether it’s a chase through a crowded city street or a violent showdown with conspiracy goons in an office building, action scenes are meant to be exciting — to feel fast-paced even as they stretch out a few seconds of time in-world into minutes or hours of play time. The base mechanics help with this, but a Storyteller can enhance this by using some tricks.
Consider Intent
Deviant asks that participants in a fight declare their intent up-front before a fight begins (Deviant, p. 195). In practice, many troupes dispense with this step, as it is usually obvious to the players what their characters are expecting their violence to accomplish. However, as the Storyteller, it is important that you know what their opposition wants to achieve.
Capture: The enemies hope to restrain or incapacitate one or more of the Renegades in order to bring them to another place — whether it’s a police lockup or a conspiracy facility. They’re more likely to deploy nonlethal options like Tasers, tranquilizers, catchpoles, grapples, or specified targets (Deviant, p. 197) to apply Tilts.
Drive Off: The conspiracy’s agents want to convince the Renegades to leave the area. They may do this by applying or threatening overwhelming lethal force (such as explosives or bursts from automatic weapons) or by unleashing nonlethal effects to which they remain immune but that make it virtually impossible for the Deviants to continue (such as gas cannisters that apply the Noxious Fumes or Thin Air Tilt, or flashbangs that temporarily blind or deafen). Numerical superiority or a large tactical advantage is usually necessary to get this to work, unless the targets aren’t looking for a fight or become convinced that enemy reinforcements could arrive any second.
Feel Out: The conspiracy agents are trying to map out the Renegades’ capabilities to identify strengths to negate (or emulate) and weaknesses to exploit. The agents’ objective is to draw out and document these traits, which sometimes requires at least the appearance of an intent to capture or kill, since the Remade need to believe that the danger is real. Agents are equipped with cameras, microphones, and stranger scanning equipment, often connected via cell signal or satellite so that the data is preserved even if the agents are wiped out.
Flee: Sometimes the Deviants’ opponents don’t want to fight at all. In fact, they’d rather do anything else and will flee at the first opportunity. Disciplined soldiers might make a tactical withdrawal, with some designated to cover the retreat of the others before exiting themselves. Desperate noncombatants (or those not expecting to fight supernatural creatures) might rout, stampeding their companions in their urgency to get away from the monsters assailing them. Although this might be fine with the cohort in some cases, it is less than ideal if their goal is to take prisoners or if frantic foes hamper the Broken by getting in their way or launching desperate attacks that nevertheless distract them from more strategically significant targets.
Guard: The conspiracy agents seek to protect a person or object from capture, death, or destruction. It could be a Linchpin or another VIP, but it might instead be a cargo or an Icon (or Devoted) that’s powering up. Their tactics could be as simple as driving off attackers or carrying the objective somewhere the Renegades can’t easily reach it, but in some cases, they seek only to delay in anticipation of a point in the action when protecting it is no longer relevant.
Kill: The attackers want the Broken dead. If they incapacitate one of their targets, their first priority is to put a proverbial bullet in the back of his head. Storytellers should deploy characters with this motive sparingly and only when they can’t reasonably achieve their objective; no one enjoys being on the receiving end of a TPK. For rare exceptions to this, the Storyteller should clearly communicate to the players that if the cohort pushes its luck, the death of one or more of their characters is on the table and give them an opportunity to leave the situation before any bodies hit the floor.
Lure: The conspiracy’s agents want to lead the Deviants elsewhere. It might be a trap or ambush, or it could be intended to put them on a collision course with another of the conspiracy’s enemies. If the attack is a provocation, the conspiracy agents are likely to flee in the direction of the target zone as soon as they’re sure they have the cohort’s attention. If the attack is a delivery mechanism for disinformation (such as if the attackers carry falsified credentials or have been fed false intelligence they’re expected to divulge to the Renegades when put under pressure), the combatants may be so outclassed by the Broken that they have no chance to flee before they’re captured or killed.
Rob: The Remade have something the attackers want, and they intend to take it from them by force. This could be cash (in the case of a mundane robbery), conspiracy resources like Prototypes and Icons, or something like blood or hair (such as if the conspiracy wants a DNA sample or a component to use in sympathetic magic). The attackers might incapacitate or kill, but it isn’t a necessary component as long as they get what they came for. Once they have it, they rarely have a reason to stick around to finish off the cohort, especially if the Renegades still have a lot of fight left in them.
Tag: The conspiracy’s agents want the cohort to lead them to a person or place. It might be the Renegades’ safe house, a trusted friend, or an ally who has thus far eluded the conspiracy. In any case, they aren’t shooting to kill but to wound, and then either they or their allies will tail the Remade in hopes they will lead them somewhere of strategic importance. This might be one the conspiracy already knows about, but they might be interested in learning where the Broken go after a crisis.
Set the Stage
Whether the troupe relies on theater of the mind, a quick sketch on a whiteboard (or the virtual equivalent), or a gridded battle mat, the Storyteller should have an idea of where the participants and major features of the environment are. These details offer players choices and encourage the kind of tactical thinking that makes action scenes fun. A gun battle or chase in a high-walled cubicle farm should feel different from one in a forest or in a busy shopping mall.
Formation: In fights, antagonists clustered in one place promote different tactics than ones scattered across a larger area, and ones behind fortifications or safely out of reach on balconies demand different approaches than ones standing in the open or closing to engage in hand-to-hand combat. Who starts the scene where depends heavily on the circumstances. An opposing force that expects trouble is more likely to arrange its members in a tactically advantageous way than one on the receiving end of an ambush or who is taken completely by surprise while going about their business.
Layout: Determine the key features of the scene. Is there furniture, machinery, or other large objects that offer cover or complicate sightlines or movement through the environment? Is there a panel of switches or buttons that could plunge the area into darkness, close a door that might otherwise permit the arrival of reinforcements, or activate an industrial magnet that will pull all metal in the area towards itself (or otherwise add chaos to the already complex situation fights often are)? Are there catwalks, open pits, ladders, stairs, or other features that enable (or threaten) three-dimensional movement?
Environment: Environmental Tilts set the conditions under which an action scene takes place. While Deviant gives them a descriptive name and offers possible examples of when they might apply, remember that they are primarily a mechanical effect. Thick fog could scan as Poor Lighting, for example, and a muddy riverbank could be Slick, Viscous, or both. Remember too that an Environmental Tilt may only be in effect for a part of the scene, such as a cluster of thorny bushes between the cohort and their enemies, offering them the choice of spending more time circling around or enduring the hazards of the Jagged Tilt. In chases, allow a character with the Edge to direct the action through areas affected by an appropriate Environmental Tilt. Don’t overburden scenes with these, but an appropriate Environmental Tilt that affects an entire scene or one or two that complicate parts of the locale can make action more interesting for everyone.
And…Action
Sometimes, it’s clear to the Storyteller that a specific fight or other action scene will happen in an upcoming chapter because the players convey their intent loud and clear beforehand, often by reconnoitering the battlefield and planning their tactics at length during the current chapter. This gives her an opportunity to plan the confrontation in detail.
For all its emphasis on the horror and tragedy of the Remade condition, Deviant permits and even encourages its protagonists to solve at least some of their problems with physical activity, including violence. A dramatic heist or climactic fight scene, if well-planned and executed by the Storyteller, can be a memorable event. Even when forced to improvise an action scene, the Storyteller can create a dynamic event by looking for opportunities to add interesting twists as the scene unfolds.
Consider planning the action in stages. Rather than laying all his cards on the table as soon as the curtain comes up on the scene, the Storyteller keeps some surprises in reserve. These might be time-based, such as reinforcements arriving on the second turn of the fight or the vat of melted steel pouring into one of the molds on even-numbered turns. It could instead be triggered by events, such as the first time the cohort takes out an opponent in the scene, when their leader is wounded, or if an ally throws an ominous-looking switch on the wall. Here are some events that can complicate an action scene:
Alarum: The Renegades’ actions raise an alarm, putting all the conspiracy agents in the facility on high alert or provoking a response by emergency services. This might be the result of a failed attempt at stealth and skullduggery, the careless discharge of firearms or attention-grabbing Variations, or a Scar coming into play at an awkward moment. This will usually have minimal impact on the initial scene, but it adds urgency to several successive scenes. Conspiracy agents are alert and actively seeking the intruders, rendering scenes that could have been handled through infiltration or diplomacy into desperate action scenes and running battles in a race against time before enemy confusion gives way to organized and overwhelming opposition.
Environmental Tilt: The events of the scene (or events off-screen) create an Environmental Tilt that affects some or all actors in the current scene. If global, it might be a power outage that imposes the severe Poor Lighting Tilt, the sprinkler system set off by the smoke from the pyrokinetic Deviant’s fires that create the Downpour Tilt, or an explosion that threatens to bring down the whole building and behaves like the Earthquake Tilt. If localized, falling debris could create an area with the Jagged Tilt, a spreading fire could create the Inferno Tilt, or the activation of a giant industrial fan could produce the Crosswinds or Currents Tilt for those passing through the affected area.
Protocol Change: Some Renegades carefully research the opposition before they undertake an important operation, whether they intend to deploy violence or not. They obtain keycards, uniforms, and passwords, map out security cameras and alarms, and learn the timing of shift changes and resupplies. Even when a facility’s personnel maintain strict, predictable protocols and suspect nothing, events can disrupt their routines — and the cohort’s carefully laid plans. Additional security might be brought in to protect a VIP during a surprise inspection, valuable equipment might be moved to a different storeroom while the usual one is cleaned or renovated, or an unrelated data security breach might necessitate facility-wide password changes.
Reinforcements: Some of the Deviants’ opponents might not be noticeable when the scene starts, only revealing themselves once the Remade have committed themselves to hostilities. This could be anything from a sniper on overwatch on a nearby balcony or roof to camouflaged agents to security guards in an adjoining room who respond to unexpected gunfire.
Scars: One of the Broken’s Scars manifests in a dramatic way at a crucial moment. The conspiracy’s agents might have brought this into play intentionally, or it might be bad luck or an attack brought on by stress (or Murphy’s Law).
Unexpected Capabilities: One or more of the cohort’s enemies in the scene reveal unanticipated abilities. They might possess Prototypes (Clades Companion, p. 56) or Icons, or perhaps they’re Devoted (or other occult beings). Regardless, the supernatural abilities they bring to bear escalate the threat the Renegades face in the scene.
Social Maneuvering
Social Maneuvering bears a close resemblance to the Investigation system in that it encourages the Renegades to work at a goal over the course of multiple scenes to achieve an objective — in this case, convincing a Storyteller character to divulge information or do something else the Remade wants.
Conspiracy Agents and Doors
Renegades often find it useful to manipulate conspiracy agents in order to achieve cohort goals. Enemies they might be, but they often have information without which stealth operations are more difficult and infiltration missions are all but impossible. Some can even be convinced to act against the conspiracy’s interests, whether out of sympathy for the Deviants’ plight or because it furthers the agent’s personal ambitions.
Whether because their personalities were compatible when the conspiracy recruited them or because they have soaked up the organization’s cultural norms during the course of their membership, conspiracy agents reflect the Virtue, Vice, and Principles of the organization they work for. As a result, for the purpose of social maneuvering, they treat the conspiracy’s Virtue and Vice as their own and count the conspiracy’s Principles as additional Aspirations they possess. While this can be an advantage to overcome or a liability that the Renegades can exploit, in either case it behooves those who fight a conspiracy to learn what makes it tick.
Researching a Target
A good first impression can make the difference between being able to move forward with an operation in a week or having to spend months securing an asset’s cooperation. Smart Renegades who need information or assistance from those outside their cohort take steps to identify a convincible target and ensure they make a good first impression. This process can be handled as an Investigation. Determine the required number of Clues as follows:
Access: Unless the Broken already have a specific target in mind, identifying an agent who has some access that the cohort can exploit requires a single Clue. Finding an agent with greater access privileges within the organization requires more Clues. Agents with significant access but minimal power (security personnel, custodians with master keys, etc.) usually require two Clues. This is typically three Clues if the target is the Linchpin of an Exploitative, Structural, or Temporal Node and five Clues if they’re the Linchpin of a Hierarchical Node.
Approach: Knowing who has the power in a conspiracy and what arguments they might find persuasive is of little use if the cohort has no way of making contact with them. Ordinary agents with no special access to conspiracy resources don’t increase the required number of Clues. Devoted add one Clue. Linchpins add half the Standing of the conspiracy to the number of Clues required to find an opportunity to approach them (rounded up). This can also be used to make contact with someone who isn’t an agent of the conspiracy but who has strategic value — such a Devoted’s Loyalty Touchstone or a rival conspiracy’s agent who might be willing to help the Renegades because it advances their own interests.
Conspiracy Traits: Learning a conspiracy’s Virtue or Vice or one of its Principles requires Clues equal to half its Standing (rounded up) per piece of information. Remember that a crisis point can change one of a conspiracy’s Anchors and Principles (Deviant, p. 231).
Personal Traits: Learning an agent’s Virtue, Vice, Aspirations, or what is likely to constitute a breaking point for them (or the identity and tenor of one of their Touchstones, if a Deviant) requires one Clue per piece of relevant information.
Building Rapport (Optional Rule)
People don’t usually go into a social interaction with a specific goal in mind. Even when they do (interviews, sales pitches, etc.), that goal is rarely in their minds during the interaction itself except in brief flashes. Conversation flows naturally out of the interplay of personalities and shifts gradually from topic to topic. Only afterward is there time to process the consequences of that interaction, whether it’s a fond memory and a few new inside jokes or a negative reaction to how much of a jerk that one guy was and a gnawing sense that you made a fool of yourself.
Under this rule, even if a character doesn’t go into a social situation with a specific goal in mind, his player still makes a roll to remove Doors at the end of the scene. The next time the Broken attempts to convince the target to do something he wants he benefits from the reduced number of Doors. If he has removed more Doors than the target has, any “extra” opened Doors count as previously opened Doors on a future favor request.
Forcing Doors
Sometimes, waiting and subtlety just aren’t warranted, desired, or possible. In these cases, your character can attempt to force a character’s Doors. This degree of urgency is high-risk, high-reward. Forcing Doors often leads to burnt bridges and missed opportunities.
When forcing Doors, state your character’s goal and her approach, then roll immediately. The current number of Doors apply as a penalty to the dice roll. The subject contests as normal (which is subject to any wound penalties he might be suffering). If successful, proceed to resolution as normal. If the roll fails, the subject is immune to further efforts at social maneuvering from your character.
Hard Leverage: Hard Leverage represents threats, drugging, intimidation, blackmail, kidnapping, or other heavy-handed forms of coercion. It drives home the urgency required to force open a character’s Doors. Hard Leverage that causes the victim to suffer a breaking point removes one Door (if the modifier to the roll — not considering the character’s breaking points — is greater than –2) or two Doors (if the modifier is –3 or less). Threatening a Deviant’s Loyalty Touchstone counts as Hard Leverage with an effective modifier equal to (5 - Loyalty rating). Hard Leverage only works on a victim once per interrogator, after which the impression level becomes forever hostile. Moreover, the victim’s impression of anyone the victim perceives as being in league with the interrogator also drops to hostile.
Note: The Hard Leverage mechanics above differ from the ones in other Chronicles of Darkness games, which require the one using Hard Leverage to be the one suffering a breaking point or other Integrity trait failure. Because of what Faltering represents, this doesn’t make sense for Deviants. This gives Hard Leverage a substantially darker cast in a Deviant chronicle — one that makes human rights abuses a potentially effective means for one character to secure the cooperation of another. Inclusion of Hard Leverage warrants additional discussion of safety tools.
Adding Systems
Deviant provides a lot of systems to render mechanically situations that are reasonably likely to arise narratively. First, it’s much easier for a Storyteller to look up a rule than it is for him to write a new one. Second, it sets player expectations so that they understand the risks in most situations their characters face and can use that information tactically. Third, the variety of existing systems can serve as examples Storytellers can use to build new ones to address needs specific to their chronicles — whether it’s a single-use subsystem or one that comes up again and again.
Example 1: Dehydration/Starvation
With rare exceptions, Remade need food and water just like anyone else. Some Renegades struggle to secure consistent access to these essentials. They might be living on the street, in the wilderness, or in a post-apocalyptic hellscape.
Dehydration/Starvation Basics
• Hungry: A character who goes more than 24 hours without eating or drinking suffers the Hungry Condition (p. XX).
• Exertion: The onset of this Condition occurs more quickly if the character engages in heavy exertion while deprived. Every six hours of exertion counts as 24 hours if only food is lacking. If the character has neither food nor drink, every three hours counts as 24 hours.
• Partial Starvation: If the character eats (and drinks) some but much less than she needs, she can go twice as long. Typically, this means every two days of partial starvation counts as one day of complete deprivation, although exertion can shorten this interval.
• Low-Quality Food: Consuming rotting, dirty, or improperly prepared (raw squirrel, for example, or human meat) food or drink requires a successful Resolve + Stamina roll (with the penalty for the Hungry or Starving Condition — p. XX). If successful, the Deviant enjoys the full benefits of the meal. On a failure, he suffers food poisoning, suffering the Sick Tilt in action scenes for the next 24 hours, and advances his hunger (or thirst) by one day. Food or drink that humans can’t safely consume (sea water, for example, or dirt) provoke the Resolve + Stamina roll, but success only prevents the character from getting violently ill; it does nothing to ease his hunger pangs.
• Sourcing Food and Drink: Finding potable water in civilized areas isn’t usually difficult. Finding food or water in rural or uninhabited places requires an extended Wits + Survival action to locate a source of food or water (each roll is eight hours, with failures delivering low-quality supplies and dramatic failures sourcing nothing at all). The roll may suffer a penalty due to scarcity and will require more successes based on how many people the character is attempting to feed (3 successes + 2 per person to feed them adequately for a day). The roll to find food in human-inhabited areas is the same, but each roll instead requires one hour.
This system intended for a story or chronicle in which hunger and/or thirst is a looming threat to the cohort’s survival. It assumes that the characters will be hungry a good part of the time and that it will drive behavior by offering positive reinforcement rather than by loading up the Deviants on terrible penalties that will be frustrating for the players. It uses Conditions similar to Fatigued (Deviant, p. 322) and Soulless (Shallow Graves, p. 209), and borrows the Magnitude 1 effect of the Philia Scar (Devoted Companion, p. 16) for one of its Beat triggers. Its mechanics don’t involve rolling dice, so players have a clear idea how close to the brink their characters are.
Example 2: Training Animals and Manticores
The Clades Companion (p. 19) divides animals into three broad categories of intelligence: dull, smart, and near-sapient.
Dull animals can’t be trained, as they are creatures of raw instinct incapable of processing human commands. They include reptiles, fish, and invertebrates, as well as many birds.
Smart animals can learn and so can be trained. Most mammals are smart, as are some birds.
Near-sapient animals are exceptionally intelligent and capable of solving problems and expressing preferences. Few animals are near-sapient — dolphins, great apes, and a handful of others.
A Manticore can be much more intelligent than other members of its species.
Humans generally regard themselves as the only truly sapient animals on Earth. Manticores granted full sapience are Deviants with the Uplift Form (Clades Companion, p. 16).
Training an animal — even one from a thoroughly domesticated species — takes a lot of time. Working dogs, for example, require one to two years of training before they’re ready to be service animals, assuming their training starts when they’re young enough and that they receive consistent training. Wild animals or ones who are less well suited to training take longer and are sometimes impossible to train.
Basic Commands
A character with the Manticore Companion Merit (Deviant, p. 101) that reflects a smart or near-sapient companion, or one who has a smart animal as a pet, is assumed to have previously provided rudimentary training so that it knows how to obey the following commands when she issues them:
Attack: The animal attacks a target indicated by its handler until it suffers bashing damage in excess of its Stamina, any amount of lethal damage, or until commanded to do otherwise.
Come/Heel: The animal comes to its handler and follows her until commanded otherwise.
Down: The animal stops making noise and sits or lays down (handler’s choice) until commanded otherwise.
Leave It: The animal drops whatever it is carrying or stops interacting with something it was handling.
Stay: The animal retains its current position until commanded otherwise.
Training a smart animal to obey these commands can occur during downtime lasting at least six weeks, as long as the character devotes at least an hour a day to the training. This is shortened to four weeks if the character devotes three hours a day to the training and lengthened to eight weeks if training is irregular.
Advanced Commands
In addition to basic commands, domesticated smart or near-sapient animals can learn to obey more complex commands. Teaching a smart animal to obey a new command requires a month of practice. Smart animals can learn a number of advanced commands equal to the handler’s Animal Ken dots +1, while near-sapient animals can learn three times as many commands. Wild animals can’t be issued advanced commands; they only behave in these ways when they choose to.
Fetch: The animal will fetch an object the handler throws or indicates within the scene and bring it back to her. As a separate command with Fetch as its prerequisite, the animal can be ordered to bring the object to a place or person in the scene that the handler indicates. As a separate command with Fetch as its prerequisite, the animal can be ordered to go find an object, animal, or person familiar to it (or one it identifies through Recognize) and bring it to its handler (or to someone else it recognizes whom the handler indicates).
Frenzy: Once given the order to attack, the animal will continue to do so even if injured — until it is either incapacitated or ordered to stop.
Guard: The animal will protect a person or place indicated by its handler. If it is approached by an unfamiliar animal, stranger, or other intruder, the animal will attempt to alert its handler. As a separate command with Guard as its prerequisite, the animal will also execute another order it knows (such as to attack) if the intruder persists — chosen when its handler gives it the order to guard.
Herd: The animal will attempt to control the movements of a target or class of targets its handler indicates — such as keeping a child or flock of sheep away from danger or driving a bear into a trap.
Pack: The animal will obey orders issued by one of its handler’s companions (other members of the cohort, family members, etc.), although the handler’s commands take precedence, and the animal must be familiar with these people before it will take orders from them. As a separate command with Pack as its prerequisite, the animal will obey orders issued to it by anyone who gives an appropriate signal (such as a hand sign or command word), although the commands of its handler and her companions take precedence.
Perform: The animal will respond to various commands to take physical actions, such as to beg, roll over, or “speak”. As a separate command with Perform as its prerequisite, the animal can be taught to execute a complex series of actions, such as navigating an obstacle course.
Recognize: The animal can be ordered to identify and interact with objects it has good familiarity with, although it can get confused by objects that resemble each other. This recognition is imprecise and reliant on the animal’s senses. A colorblind animal can’t be ordered to identify something as green, for example. As an additional command with Recognize as its prerequisite, the animal can recognize objects its handler describes, although it must still be in terms the animal’s senses can discern.
Respond: The animal can be ordered to respond to certain situations, executing its other orders whenever circumstances demand. The handler’s player can issue orders even when her character could not do so, but the command roll suffers a –4 penalty. As an additional command with Respond as its prerequisite, the penalty is only –2.
Variation: The Manticore activates or deactivates a Toggled Variation or directs a Directed Variation as its handler indicates.
Advanced commands don’t come naturally to most animals and require regular practice. For every month that goes by during which the animal doesn’t practice its advanced commands for at least an hour a day, its handler suffers a cumulative –1 penalty to issue these commands (to a maximum of –5). This penalty fades at the rate of –1 per month once practice resumes and can be reduced by –1 per week with a regimen of at least three hours per day.
Near-sapient animals require more attention than merely smart ones. Insufficiently stimulated, these creatures become bored and surly. Keeping them cooperative requires at least three hours per day, and penalties for not practicing advanced commands accumulate at the rate of –1 per week (maximum –5). However, penalties fade at the rate of –1 per week once the animal is receiving adequate attention.
Issuing Commands
Issuing a command the animal knows when it’s in non-stressful situations usually succeeds automatically. In action scenes or other unfamiliar environments, issuing a command requires a successful Presence + Animal Ken action.
Suggested Modifiers: Animal is hungry (–1) or injured (–2). Command is in keeping with animal’s natural instincts (+1 or +2) or in defiance of them (–1 to –3).
Training an AI
Training an AI works similarly to training an animal, although most AIs don’t have bodies with which to execute common tasks. Issuing commands to an AI requires an Intelligence + Computers, and the number of advanced commands one can learn is based on Computers instead of Animal Ken.
The Beast Mastery Variation (Shallow Graves, p. 105) provides a supernatural means of commanding animals, but this is system is primarily geared towards players who have purchased the Manticore Companion Merit (Deviant, p. 101) or have a pet (potentially one that’s a Loyalty Touchstone) and wants to teach it to carry out useful tasks. Because this training likely occurs during downtime, that process is largely abstracted, while the act of issuing commands is what carries the risk of failure. In-world, these are situations that are likely to be chaotic and stressful for the animal. From the perspective of a system within a roleplaying game these are the situations where failure is likely to be more narratively interesting.
Renegades
In addition to the mechanics available to all Storytelling games, Deviant provides Storytellers with tools specific to chronicles focused on the Broken.
Threat Level
A troupe’s choice of threat level has the greatest impact on the tone of a chronicle, determining as it does the scale of the character’s Variations, the extent of their Scars, and the potency of their opposition.
Mutation (Standing 1): These offer the grittiest, most street-level stories. The characters are little more than Baselines with special abilities (and unusual problems). For a cohort at this level, simply surviving from day to day — even in the absence of conspiracy intervention — may be a serious challenge. Scars and the conspiracy can come into play, but the scarcity of resources and the danger of discovery are more likely to introduce complications.
Hyperplasia (Standing 2): These are still somewhat grittier, although individual characters have the option to select one extremely potent capability (with the commensurate downside). The Renegades are distinctly more potent than Baselines, although they can still be overwhelmed by numerous opponents or ones with occult resources of their own. Scars and conspiracy activity become more important sources of plot complications.
Dysplasia (Standing 3): This level offers a solid compromise between street level freaks and ones who wield godlike power. The Deviants can probably overcome most mundane obstacles to survival, and unless the troupe is small (or the cohort is specialized), the characters probably have enough variety of Variations between them to solve most types of problems. Unless none of them is speced for combat, they can probably hold their own against small groups of conspiracy agents unless they’re heavily armed or have Devoted, but successful strikes against the conspiracy tend to require careful planning.
Invasion (Standing 4): At this point, the Storyteller can probably take the gloves off. The conspiracy is the Renegades’ main adversary and one worthy of respect, for it can bring considerable resources to bear against Broken who thwart its designs. And the Remade had better be proactive in doing that, because otherwise the conspiracy will rapidly acquire occult and mundane resources that make it an even greater threat to them.
Metastasis (Standing 5): These chronicles trend towards gonzo. The cohort has enough Magnitude of Variations to throw around that it can easily find occult solutions in most scenarios. Even a lone Renegade who is speced for it can operate independently in a lot of different situations with minimal personal risk. The conspiracy is increasingly forced to manipulate situations to its advantage by dangling Touchstones and exploiting Scars, which it’s more than capable of doing.
Metamorphosis (Standing 6): The Renegades are veritable gods, albeit ones with larger-than-life flaws for their enemies to exploit. Their antagonists wield outsized influence and maintain connections with even more dangerous conspiracies of the Web of Pain. Baseline goons are little more than scenery for the Deviants to chew up and spit out, and it often takes the cooperation of multiple enemies with powerful supernatural connections to challenge the cohort directly. The Renegades are often their own worst enemies, as Scars drive them constantly to behave in counterproductive ways.
Surveillance
The threat of conspiracy attention is a considerable check on attention-grabbing Renegade activity. Merely owning things Baselines take for granted carries a risk. The surveillance rules are meant to deliver a particular story arc. While Deviant suggests rolling Surveillance at the beginning of each chapter, it makes planning the next chapter considerably easier if the Storyteller rolls it at the end of each chapter or in the time between gaming sessions. It means she already knows whether the conspiracy can use its actions to target or identify the cohort’s associates — or whether it must content itself with advancing Projects.
At the beginning of each story, the inherent –5 penalty for not yet using Overt Variations/Scars can render the Renegades all but invisible to their enemies unless they have other risk factors — such as owning a car or cellphone or having a job, bank account, or permanent residence. This permits a bit of breathing room the Remade can use however they’d like, whether it’s bonding with Loyalty Touchstones, gathering resources, or plotting the downfall of their enemies. A cohort that has nothing but Subtle Variations and Scars enjoys this protection constantly.
It’s quite likely that the first surveillance roll will fail. This is okay. The cohort will have ample opportunity to shed their initial protection and draw the eyes, ears, and goons of the conspiracy down upon them. The Storyteller can still draw the Renegades into the Web of Pain by investing Effort in Projects that make it clear that the conspiracy is up to something the Broken might object to or by conspicuously dangling Conviction Touchstones.
As the story progresses, the conspiracy (and therefore the Storyteller) can take steps to flush the Renegades out of hiding even if the surveillance roll fails:
Temptation: The conspiracy lulls the cohort into a false sense of security, not pursuing the Deviants in a serious way. Large conspiracies send only token attacks, while small ones don’t send anyone at all. Meanwhile, the Storyteller emphasizes the unpleasantness of the lives the Remade are leading, illustrating the difficulty of getting by from day to day without a safe place to rest their heads, a dependable source of income, a way to get around town, or a means of connecting to the wealth of information available to people in an internet-connected society. The goal is to encourage the Renegades to compromise some of their operational security to attain some flesh-and-blood security.
Pilot Fish: Even if the conspiracy can’t target the cohort directly, it can make their lives and living situation considerably worse. For example, crooked cops on their payroll might start harassing Baselines in the area instead of doing their jobs, allowing organized crime to run rampant in the neighborhood, and those mobsters might try to shake down the Renegades. Fighting back could land one of the Deviants in the hospital or goad him into deploying Overt Variations.
Project: A conspiracy not spending its actions on pursuing the Renegades is one that can invest Effort into long-term Projects. The Storyteller can hint at this in-world by mentioning the appearance of conspiracy iconography in unexpected places — such as on semitrucks, at constructions sites, or in advertising. The Broken might overhear people discussing the conspiracy’s latest product announcement in glowing terms or catch a news clip or talk show segment featuring an interview with a Conviction Touchstone. She can also allow the players to explore it more directly using the optional Set the Stage scenes at the end of each chapter (Deviant, p. 230). Whatever the message or medium, it’s clear that the conspiracy is up to something, it’s probably not a good thing, and the Renegades are probably the only ones who can stop it from achieving its goal.
Once a surveillance roll succeeds, opportunities abound to place pressure on the cohort. It then becomes much easier for a conspiracy to manipulate the Renegades into actions that will make future surveillance rolls successful.
Vivisection
Deviant has a clear implied gameplay loop that’s reflected in both its game fiction and its mechanics. It tells the stories of ordinary people who have been transformed into supernatural creatures (Deviants) that have superhuman abilities (Variations) but are also saddled with unearthly vulnerabilities as consequence of their occult nature (Scars). Usually, this Divergence is a direct consequence of some shadowy organization or another (a conspiracy) meddling in things they don’t fully understand. Even if a conspiracy isn’t to blame for the Divergence itself, one of them pursues the protagonists (Renegades), who do not want to work for the conspiracy or otherwise further its goals.
The Deviants have an overwhelming psychological need to protect a handful of close friends (Loyalty Touchstones) and hurt (and ultimately destroy) a handful of hated enemies (Conviction Touchstones). If they fail to follow these drives, the Renegades’ Scars grow worse and ultimately kill them. These Touchstones get entangled in conspiracy plots in various ways.
The conspiracy has a lot of resources, including the service of loyal Deviants (Devoted) and some other supernatural capabilities (Icons), but for the most part it is run by ordinary humans (Baselines) using mundane methods to track, pursue, and bring the Renegades to heel. The conspiracy is part of a loose network of interconnected organizations that all have some interest in the Divergence (the Web of Pain).
All this sets up a constant battle of wits and arms between the Renegades and the conspiracy that wants to control them. The Renegades by turns elude the conspiracy and attack it, seeking its destruction. If they successfully destroy the current conspiracy, another conspiracy in the Web of Pain steps in to pursue the Renegades, and the cycle begins anew, albeit with higher stakes.
Shallow Graves devotes a lengthy section to different potential endings for a chronicle featuring Renegades (p. 170), most of which involve choosing when and how to break the default gameplay loop so that the chronicle can reach a satisfying conclusion. We therefore won’t be discussing that again here. Instead, we’ll focus on the systems that enable the default gameplay loop.
The systems as presented in Deviant are the defaults for the setting, but it’s possible to make changes to some of the system and setting assumptions of the game. For the most part, we present these in purely mechanical terms in this section, but you’ll see alternate rules in action in this and later chapters, especially when we discuss altering the genre assumptions of a Deviant chronicle.
Character Creation
Storytellers may adjust the trait allowances for characters during character creation, allowing them to play characters who start out more powerful and experienced than usual.
Extra Experiences
Most traits can be represented by bonus Experiences that may not be used to purchase new Variations and may carry additional limits on what traits they can improve.
[table]
Rank Bonus Experiences
Survivor 5
Established Renegade 10
Renegade Role Model 15
Potential Threat 25
Serious Threat 35
Living Legend 50
Conspiracy Bogeyman 100
[end table]
Storytellers should clearly indicate any traits that can’t be purchased or improved with bonus Experiences:
Acclimation: This is arguably the most powerful trait in the game. Consider restricting initial Acclimation to 2 regardless of starting Experiences (or Shallow Graves Forms) or forbidding the purchase of Acclimation with bonus Experiences entirely. To reflect a cohort that has achieved significant self-mastery, consider awarding one or two dots of Acclimation for free, reducing the bonus Experiences amount accordingly — capping Acclimation at 3 or 4 or leaving it limited to 2.
Attributes: These affect Scar Power/Finesse/Resistance, which makes them common purchases in Deviant chronicles. Consider limiting Attribute purchases to no more than half the bonus Experiences (rounded up). Attributes cannot be increased above 5 dots without the addition of Superhuman Attribute.
Merits: The ten-dot restriction on Merits during character creation normally forces some hard choices regarding these remarkable quirks and capabilities. While restricting these isn’t usually necessary, consider interactions between Merits (especially ones with an Acclimation prerequisite) and any Variations/Scars, as these can become quite potent.
Skills/Specialties: These reflect a character’s mundane capabilities and have minimal impact on Variations or Scars. They make a good way to reflect characters who were elite prior to their Divergence. Skills can’t be increased above 5 dots.
Threat Level and Standing
Deviant never explicitly assigns a number value to its named threat levels. A Hyperplasia threat level chronicle features a Standing 2 conspiracy and Renegades with 6 Magnitude of Variations each (including 1 Magnitude from Origin), but depending on how players spend their Experiences, they could average 9 or 11 Magnitude of Variations long before they destroy their initial conspiracy.
When Black Vans refers to “Threat Level” or “Standing” when talking about the cohort (rather than the character creation process or conspiracy), it is doing so to indicate the average total Magnitude of Variations possessed by the cohort. A Threat Level 1 or Standing 1 cohort is one whose members average fewer than 6 Magnitude of Variations, for example, while a Threat Level 7 or Standing 7 cohort is one whose members average 18-20 Magnitude of Variations (including one from Origin).
High-Standing
Because starting Variations are measured in Magnitude and not Experiences, they need to be handled separately from other traits. For Renegades with levels of power that exceed even Metamorphosis, Storytellers can use the Standing chart (Deviant, p. 235) to assign Magnitude of Variations and determine the conspiracy’s traits. If the conspiracy has Standing 8, for example, each Remade begins with 20 Magnitude of Variations (plus one additional Scar-free Magnitude based on Origin) This usually works best in a one-shot or short chronicle, as Broken with very large numbers of Variations are often difficult to challenge and have limited options for advancement.
Dedicated Cohort
The Dedicated Form (Shallow Graves, p. 62) can be used to represent characters who possess some qualities of Deviants but have not (yet) been fully Remade, but if all members of the cohort have this Form, it can also be used to change how the Divergence itself works within a chronicle.
In this variant, all Deviants are Dedicated. This means they lack Touchstones but do not suffer Instability for failing to further a Touchstone each chapter, nor do they become Ferals due to the lack of Touchstones — although they can suffer Instability from other sources. They instead have an Integrity trait and a Baseline’s complement of Anchors (Deviant, p. 187) and Aspirations (Deviant, p. 95). They can purchase Acclimation normally and doing so doesn’t cause them to lose the Dedicated Form. Consider mandating, restricting, and/or forbidding the purchase of some or all the Form’s optional effects.
It’s possible to build on the default Dedicated Form qualities to change the nature of individual Deviants, a certain “species” of Remade, or all Broken.
Scar-Free Variations
Although Scars are a central component of Deviant: The Renegades, troupes who want a chronicle where they are minimized have options:
Clean Variations: Each Scar-free Magnitude of Variation with no downside costs 3 Magnitude of starting Variations or 3 Experiences per dot. A Magnitude 3 Variation, for example, would cost 9 Magnitude of starting Variations or 9 Experiences.
Destabilizing Variations: Each Scar-free Magnitude of Variations costs 2 Magnitude of starting Variations or 2 Experiences per dot but has one of the following limitations:
• At the beginning of each story, the Deviant suffers additional minor Instability equal to half the Scar-free Magnitude of Variations they possess (rounded up), minus 1 + their Acclimation, to a minimum of 0. For example, a Renegade with 3 Magnitude of Scar-free Variations and Acclimation 0 would suffer 1 additional minor Instability at the beginning of each story (half of 3, rounded up, is 2, minus 1 is 1). This option is available whether or not all the Variation’s Magnitude is Scar-free.
• The Broken suffers one additional minor Instability at the beginning of each story for each Magnitude 3 or 4 Scar-free Variation they have, and one medium Instability for each Magnitude 5 Scar-free Variation. This option is only available if all the Variation’s Magnitude is Scar-free.
The Storyteller may mandate or disallow some of the options above.
Colorless Variations
Normally, a Variation’s type (Mental, Physical, or Social) matches the type of the Scar entangled with it. In this variant, that isn’t the case. Scar Power, Scar Finesse, and Scar Resistance are determined in one of the following ways:
Selected: When a player purchases a Variation, she decides whether it is Mental, Physical, or Social. The Scar Power/Finesse/Resistance of the Variation matches that type. This is the simplest option.
Weakest: The Deviant’s lowest Power, Finesse, and Resistance Attribute determine every Variation’s Scar Power/Finesse/Resistance.
Strongest: The Deviant’s highest Power, Finesse, and Resistance Attribute determine every Variation’s Scar Power/Finesse/Resistance.
Average: The Deviant’s Scar Power/Finesse/Resistance for all Variations is the average of all Power/Finesse/Resistance Attributes (rounded up). For example, a character with Intelligence 5, Strength 2, and Presence 2 (a total of 9 dots of Power Attributes) would have Scar Power of 3.
Required Traits
Normally, players can select Variations, Scars, and Forms for their characters freely (subject to any limitations the troupe may set). In this variant, however, certain of these traits are required for every player’s character. This is usually used to make members of the cohort seem like they come from the same “world” — or at least from the same conspiracy’s Divergence projects. This can narrow the options, rather than mandating them.
For example, the fiction in Shallow Graves features a super soldier program whose members all wield a deadly shriek gun and are especially tough (in mechanical terms, they have the same Cutting Firearms Lash and Carapace), and each has a notable Persistent Scar (although each Deviant’s Scar is different). Most have both signature Variations, although a few replace one or the other (but never both) with a different Variation. This makes them more coherent narratively; they’re all the product of the same series of experiments.
In some chronicles, these required traits might be universal to all Remade of a certain pedigree — or to all Broken worldwide. These function as a form of world-building by describing how the Divergence works in a narrower way than the default given in Deviant. These could represent “families” or “schools” of Remade.
For example, consider a conspiracy (or world) in which all Deviants have the Symbiote (Deviant, p. 90) and Summoner Forms (Shallow Graves, p. 64). Rather than wielding supernatural power directly, they must work through proxies external to themselves and that are not fully under the Broken’s control. Perhaps the Divergence involves a dangerous ritual to summon a demon or spirit and bend it to the postulant’s will — and those who fail to command the entity are devoured, slain, or dragged to fates worse than death by that being.
Destabilizing Forces
Instability serves several mechanical and narrative purposes in Deviant. It is both a means of incentivizing certain behaviors (while disincentivizing others) and facilitating a character’s long-term advancement (and decline). For troupes that wish to change what it means in-world (damage done to a Deviant’s soul, which worsens under certain kinds of pressure) or to reduce its prominence, consider implementing one of the following alternatives.
No Drip
Remade don’t suffer minor Instability at the beginning of each story. This alone significantly reduces the pressure Instability creates.
To diminish it further, remove the automatic minor Instability for failing to pursue a Touchstone.
To keep it relevant but rare, increase the difficulty of healing Instability through Touchstone interactions. “Advancing a Touchstone” for purposes of Instability requires that the Deviant or her cohort suffers a complication in the service of furthering her Touchstone.
No Instability
If the troupe also wishes to eliminate the added complexity of Instability, consider using the following rule, which still acknowledges the effects of certain Variations, Scars, and Adaptations:
• The highest Magnitude Variation in the cohort grants a bonus to conspiracy surveillance rolls — no bonus at Magnitude 1 or 2, a one-die bonus at Magnitude 3 or 4, and a two-die bonus at Magnitude 5.
• Whenever something would cause the Broken to suffer minor Instability, they lose a point of Willpower, instead. The player may accept the Guilty, Shaken, or Spooked Condition (player’s choice) to ignore this effect but may not do so if she already has all three Conditions.
• Whenever something would cause the Deviant to suffer a moderate Instability, they instead suffer a point of lethal damage that can’t be healed more quickly by supernatural means. The player may spend a Beat to ignore this effect.
• Whenever the Remade would suffer a major Instability, they instead suffer a point of aggravated damage that can’t be healed more quickly by supernatural means. The player may spend an Experience to ignore this effect.
• Players may purchase new Variations or improve existing Variations at a cost of 1 Experience per Magnitude — gaining new Scars or increasing existing Scars to ensure entanglement is legal.
Stability Alternatives
By default, Stability is a form of occult health that takes damage from actions such as failing to uphold one’s Touchstones and heals when the Deviant behaves in accordance with his supernaturally imposed impulses. Like all Chronicles of Darkness games, its intent is to put the player more fully into the mind of the monster she is roleplaying. Although a single occult health track is one way such a system can work, there are many ways to model a Deviant’s monstrous nature or (in the case of the Integrity trait that Baselines have) the cumulative effects of trauma. When designing such a system, here are some general considerations before we delve into specific options:
Multiple Tracks: Does the Stability alternative replace the normal Stability track, or is it in addition to it? Multiple Stability alternatives could represent different kinds of stress or trauma — such as representing exposure to violence, violation, and supernatural forces — with different kinds of Instability having different effects as it rises.
Acclimation: Consider whether and how Acclimation affects the trait. In the default occult health model, it increases the number of Stability boxes the Broken has. However, Acclimation already provides several advantages, so it might not affect a Stability alternative at all, particularly if characters have multiple Stability tracks.
We’ll provide several examples of alternate Instability systems in Chapters Four and Five.
Monster’s Code
The Remade adheres to a code that involves avoiding some behavior and situations (proscriptions) while seeking out other situations and partaking in other behaviors (prescriptions). Instability is measured from 0 to 10 dots. If it has the potential to cause the End Stage Condition, this occurs if the Deviant reaches Instability 10.
A Deviant Falters when she experiences something that violates one of these proscriptions or prescriptions — whether as an active participant or a passive victim. The dice pool used for this roll depends on how serious a violation the Broken commits or suffers, with potential modifiers based on her Acclimation rating or other factors.
For an event to constitute Faltering (and so require a roll), it must be applicable to his Instability or higher. For example, if a character with moderate Instability (3-6) Falters if he suffers a moderate or grave violation but not if he commits a minor violation.
• Minor Violations (Low Instability 0-2): Only the most ascetic (or innocent) adherents to the Broken’s code can Falter for such venial lapses. Avoiding these situations is almost impossible for most Remade. The base Faltering roll is five dice.
• Medium Violations (Moderate Instability 3-6): Most violations fall into this range. They include troubling behavior that might tempt the Deviant or experiences that draw unmistakable attention to what he has become. Effects that normally cause a minor Instability (such as “dying” while possessing a victim with the Body Snatcher Variation) are medium violations. The base Faltering roll is three dice.
• Major Violations (High Instability 7-10): Only the most heinous crimes and horrific experiences count as Faltering at this level. Effects that normally cause medium Instability (such as teleporting into a solid object using the Translocation Variation) are major violations. The base Faltering roll is one die. This is a chance die if the result of an effect that would cause a major Instability (such as killing his own Loyalty Touchstone).
Roll Results
Success: The Deviant’s convictions hold firm, although the trauma marks him for a time. His Instability remains the same, but he gains a Minor Trauma Condition (p. XX) appropriate to the nature of the experience.
Exceptional Success: Not only does the experience not shake the Remade’s faith, the challenge to it only deepens his dedication to his principles. His Instability remains the same and he either resolves a Minor Trauma Condition or gains a beneficial Condition appropriate to the experience, such as Informed, Inspired, or Steadfast.
Failure: The Broken’s trauma deepens in a lasting way. His Instability increases by one and he gains a Minor Trauma Condition appropriate to the nature of the experience.
Dramatic Failure: The experience shakes the Deviant’s faith in himself and his devotion to his principles. His Instability increases by one and he gains a Major Trauma Condition (p. XX) appropriate to the nature of the experience.
Recovering from Instability is never passive. It requires intention on the part of the Deviant and action that her code encourages or mandates. The Remade rolls dice based on the scale of the deed (with a bonus equal to half her Acclimation, rounded up), which is contested by a dice pool equal to her current Instability dots. If the Broken overcomes her Instability, she loses a dot of Instability.
Minor Deed (One Die): The action requires a negligible sacrifice or minimal investment of time (no more than a scene). Something as simple as confessing her actions or talking through her pain to someone often suffices.
Significant Deed (Three Dice): The action requires a significant sacrifice in the service of the Deviant’s code or a considerable investment of time (demanding an entire chapter). It could be an injury that takes days to heal, for example, or the permanent loss of something or someone not of central importance to her.
Major Deed (Five Dice): The action demands the Remade lose something or someone important in the pursuit of her code or undertake a time-consuming quest or project (lasting a full story).
Violations and Deeds
We’ve left specific examples of Violations and Deeds intentionally vague. Depending on what these represent (and how harsh the troupe wishes the consequences of them to be), it might not be possible to reduce accumulated Instability, or it may carry a cost in Experiences — one Experience per dot if a Thermometer, three Experiences per dot if using a Monster’s Code. Instead of Acclimation granting a bonus to Deed rolls, it adds boxes to the Instability track — one box per point of Acclimation if using a Thermometer and one box per two Acclimation (rounded up) if using a Monster’s Code.
Thermometer
This has some qualities of both the default Stability mechanic and a Monster’s Code. The Deviant may have a single Stability track, representing her accumulated Instability. She may instead have several such thermometers, each representing different sources of Instability of trauma.
Choose one:
• Default: The Instability Thermometer follows the rules in Deviant except as follows: Each minor Instability increases Instability by one. Each medium Instability increases Instability by two. Each major Instability increases Instability by three.
• Code: The Instability Thermometer follows the rules for Monster’s Code except as follows: A minor Violation automatically increases Instability by one, a medium Violation increases it by two, and a major Violation increases it by three.
• Hybrid: The Instability Thermometer follows both sets of rules. Events that would automatically cause Instability do not also count as Faltering; they cause Instability normally, instead.
An Instability Thermometer has five boxes. Whenever it reaches five Instability, reset Instability to zero, and the Deviant gains an appropriate Minor Trauma Condition (if triggered by gaining a minor or medium Instability or suffering a minor or medium Violation) or Major Trauma Condition (if triggered by gaining a major Instability of suffering a major Violation).
Side-Effects (Optional): Instability may have an adverse effect (or more rarely, a beneficial one), whether each time it increases, for a long as it remains at an elevated level, or both.
Continuums
In this model, a Stability track emphasizes balancing two conflicting sets of impulses, and favoring one over the other (or seeking a balance between the extremes) is either a recipe for disaster (albeit two different flavors of disaster) or a strategic choice (each comes with advantages and disadvantages).
In a Continuum, Instability ranges from 0 to 10. 0-3 means the first type of Instability is stronger, and 8-10 means the second type of Instability is stronger, with 4-7 meaning they are in balance. Newly created characters have Instability 5.
Here is a typical array:
• Instability 0: End Stage related to Instability #1.
• Instability 1: High Instability #1
• Instability 2-3: Moderate Instability #1
• Instability 4-6: Low Instability #1 and Low Instability #2
• Instability 7-8: Moderate Instability #2
• Instability 9: High Instability #2
• Instability 10: End Stage related to Instability #2.
Give each of the two types of Instability its own (mutually exclusive) Monster’s Code, or use the default Thermometer method of rendering Instability (and allow it to be healed normally). Gaining Instability #1 actually reduces Instability, such that gaining a dot of Instability #1 reduces the total dots of Instability by one.
Low Instability (in either direction) usually has no adverse effects. Moderate Instability in one direction or the other has a small negative effect or both a small positive and small negative effect. High Instability in either direction has a large negative effect or both a large positive and large negative effect.
Character Advancement
The accumulation of Beats and Experiences determines the rate at which a cohort’s members grow in power. Adjusting the number of Beats to an Experience is one means of adjusting this pace, but here are some other considerations that go beyond it.
Absence and Beats
By default, characters whose players are absent during a chapter do not receive any of the Beats the rest of the troupe earns. This incentivizes regular attendance. As a variant, absent players receive the same number of Beats as the other Renegades. If a cohort has five players and only four are present to earn 24 Beats (six Beats each), for example, they all earn six Beats.
This ensures that every character advances at the same pace, which makes it a little easier for the Storyteller to plan challenges for the cohort. It also serves as acknowledgment that everyone in the troupe is an adult and has outside responsibilities that might force them to miss a session now and again. Chronic absence can be handled through discussion of expectations, rather than relying on punishment in the form of missed Experiences.
Fixed Experiences
Rather than track Beats as a source of character advancement, each character receives a fixed Beat or Experience award at the end of each session — one Experience per chapter is typical. Beats are still awarded normally, but they serve as tokens that can be exchanged for the benefits in the third paragraph of the Beat Economy sidebar (Deviant, p. 97). These tokens can be pooled or individual, as the troupe decides.
Plot Twist (Optional): The players can exchange Beats for plot twists like those of the Blessing Variation (Deviant, p. 141) — one Beat for either Magnitude 1 effect, two Beats for a Magnitude 2 effect, or four Beats for a Magnitude 3 effect. Alternatively, she may heal Instability. One Beat heals a minor Instability. Three Beats heal a medium Instability. Nine Beats heal a major Instability.
Variation Rarity
Variations are game changers. In a long-running chronicle, the accumulation of Variations can limit the Storyteller’s options for challenging the Renegades. It can also encourage players to take on more Scars than they can reasonably roleplay or comfortably endure. Making Variations harder to purchase after the chronicle begins can increase the game’s longevity and prevent matters from escalating too quickly. A troupe has many ways of accomplishing this:
Scar Empowerment: Instead of buying Variations at a cost of 4 Experiences, whenever the Deviant develops a new Scar, she may spend 4 Experiences to empower it. A Scar that hasn’t been empowered cannot entangle any Variations. A Scar that has been empowered can entangle any number of Variations, subject to the normal entanglement limits. Although this variant makes Variations more numerous, it incentivizes more low-Magnitude Variations instead of a smaller number of high-Magnitude (and therefore generally more disruptive) Variations.
Harder Scar Gain: Normally, a Deviant can heal a minor or medium Instability (or downgrade a major Instability to medium) once per chapter by developing a new Scar. Under this variant, choose one:
• No Minor: Remade can only develop a new Scar by healing a medium Instability or downgrading a major Instability to medium, either one of which he may do only once per chapter (but not both).
• Major Only: Remade can only develop a new Scar by downgrading a major Instability to medium, which she may only do once per chapter.
Magnitude Pricing: Purchasing a new Variation costs Experiences equal to its Magnitude (or twice its Magnitude, if Variations are to be very hard to develop later), instead of the usual flat 4 Experiences cost. Increasing the Magnitude of an existing Variation costs 1 Experience per one-Magnitude increase and must obey the usual rules of entanglement. If Variations cost 2 Experiences per Magnitude, any Forms that allow the purchase of Magnitude of Variations with Merit dots (or Experiences) should cost 1 additional Merit dot or Experience per one Magnitude of Variation.
Milestone: Purchasing a new Variation, increasing a Variation’s Magnitude, and/or increasing Acclimation is only allowed rarely and when it makes sense within the narrative (i.e., subject to the Storyteller’s discretion) — no more often than once per story and probably less often than that.
No Growth: Characters can’t purchase new Variations or permanently increase the Magnitude of existing Variations.
Outside Motivation
By default, Touchstones shape Remade behavior. They are an important way for Broken to gain Instability and their primary means of healing it. A troupe that wants to downplay the assumed metaphysics of Deviants (i.e., that they have powers because of their damaged souls) will often eye Touchstones for alteration.
Reduce/Remove Instability
The simplest solution is to use one of the alternate Instability systems earlier in the chapter.
All Feral
All the Renegades are Ferals. They neither have Touchstones, nor can they forge new ones. This tends to drive a Deviant chronicle towards a quick and tragic ending, although Variations like Traumavore (Shallow Graves, p. 102) and Absorb Instability (Devoted Companion, p. 15) can extend its life.
Natural Healing
Deviants recover from Instability just as Baselines heal flesh-and-blood injuries. Minor Instabilities heal at the rate of one per two days, medium Instabilities at the rate of one per week, and major Instabilities at the rate of one per month.
Occult Rest (Optional): A Broken heals Instability more quickly if she doesn’t use her Variations. For Controlled, Involuntary and Toggled Persistent Variations, this means not activating them (or not activating them intentionally, for Involuntary Variations). In the case of Perpetual Persistent Variations, she is considered resting them during any period when she doesn’t benefit from them in any narratively significant way. For example, merely having Carapace doesn’t count as benefiting from the Variation, but if she takes less damage because of Carapace’s protection, she is not considered to be resting. When resting, a Deviant’s Instabilities heal in half the usual time, but if she uses her Variations, she loses all the benefits of rest so far. For example, if the Broken is waiting for a medium Instability to heal (which normally requires one week but can be reduced to three and a half days with occult rest), if she uses a Variation on day #3 (but before 3½ days), she loses the benefits of all three days of rest.
Permanent Damage (Optional): Under this variant, major Instabilities don’t heal over time, although they can still be downgraded by accepting a new Scar.
Bedrest (Optional): This combines Occult Rest and Permanent Damage with one change: A Deviant may heal a Major Instability by completing a full month of uninterrupted occult rest.
Alternate Motives
Replace Touchstones with other forms of outside motivation, such as by giving Remade two short-term Aspiration slots and one long-term Aspiration slot (instead of limiting them to just one short-term Aspiration) — optionally replacing any one Aspiration slot with a Virtue or Vice. This can’t result in more than two short-term Aspiration slots, one long-term Aspiration slot, one Virtue, or one Vice.
If your troupe isn’t also reducing or eliminating Instability, this can complicate the Deviants’ ability to recover from Instabilities, so consider adding the following effects to these (in addition to their normal benefits):
Short-term Aspiration: In addition to its normal effects, fulfilling the Aspiration heals a minor Instability or downgrades a medium Instability to minor.
Long-term Aspiration: In addition to the effects Baselines enjoy, furthering a long-term Aspiration heals a minor Instability or downgrades a medium Instability to minor, while resolving one heals a minor, medium, or major Instability.
Virtue: In addition to the effects Baselines enjoy, a character who regains all Willpower by satisfying a Virtue heals a minor or medium Instability or downgrades a major Instability to medium.
Vice: In addition to the effects Baselines enjoy, a character who regains Willpower by satisfying a Vice heals a minor Instability or downgrades a medium Instability to minor.
Merit Access (Optional): Shallow Graves offers the Merits Beloved Community, Sacred Code, and Victim Profile, all of which replace a Touchstone slot with a pattern of behavior that allows a Deviant to heal (and gain) Instability. All normally have an Acclimation prerequisite, but as a variant, waive that prerequisite — or even grant each player’s character one of these Merits for free, either in lieu of or in addition to one of the other motives.
Web of Pain
The web of conspiracies that create, pursue, and hunt Broken is a central component of the default gameplay loop of Deviant and has several mechanics that reference or rely upon the assumption that someone out there is hunting the Renegades. It’s the Web of Pain Chronicle for a reason, after all!
These systems can be emphasized or deemphasized by individual troupes or for specific chronicles.
Subtle vs. Overt
Generally speaking, Overt Variations achieve obviously impossible things. In some ways, this makes them more powerful than Subtle Variations, which usually allow characters to do ordinary things more consistently, quickly, or forcefully. Potent Subtle Variations like Carapace are usually passive or reactive; it’s hard to do anything with them. In a similar way, Overt Scars are difficult for even a casual observer to miss, but Subtle Scars aren’t completely undetectable.
Sometimes the distinction seems artificial. Carapace is pretty easy to overlook when a Deviant takes marginally less injury from a switchblade, for example, but it’s pretty damned obvious if the Remade shrugs off an artillery round. Consider modifying this system in one of the following ways.
No Distinction: For troupes that hate the Overt/Subtle dichotomy (possibly after a few arguments at the table over the designers’ decision to make one Variation Overt instead of Subtle, or vice versa), the easiest solution is to eliminate it. This necessitates a few changes:
• Remove the –5 penalty to Surveillance rolls if no one in the cohort has used an Overt Variation in the current story.
• The Disfiguring Scar Standard Deviation is not available.
Occult-Only: In a chronicle with diminished conspiracy influence, remove the Overt tag from all Merits, but retain them for Variations and Scars.
Merits-Only: Variations and Scars don’t track Overt vs. Subtle, but Merits can still be Overt and affect Surveillance rolls normally.
Nuance: To add some nuance to the calculus of Overt vs. Subtle Variations and Scars, choose one or both of the following:
• Magnitude: If the Deviant made a scene with an Overt Variation/Scar during the previous chapter, the bonus to the conspiracy’s next surveillance roll is equal to the highest Magnitude Variation/Scar involved, plus one per each additional incident (to a maximum of +5).
• Subtle: Subtle Variations/Scars have the same effect on conspiracy surveillance rolls as Overt ones, but any bonus/penalty is halved (rounded up). In the case of the –5 penalty for not using an Overt Variation/Scar since the beginning of the story, this penalty falls to –3 if he has used Subtle Variations/Scars, but not Overt ones. A Subtle Variation is considered used when it is activated (if Toggled, Controlled, or Involuntary) or when it has a significant narrative effect (such as Carapace reducing damage from an attack or Camouflage aiding a Stealth action). A Subtle Scar is considered used when it generates a Beat.
Influence
This uses the expanded conspiracy action rules from The Devoted Companion (p. 19).
To make the result of conspiracy actions a little more predictable, allow conspiracies to benefit from the Safe Sevens optional rule (p. XX). As long as it has seven dice for the action (after any voluntary or involuntary penalties), it automatically achieves a basic success.
Assume the conspiracy attempts to achieve the maximum benefit of its action, accepting voluntary penalties to its conspiracy action rolls sufficient to reduce it to no fewer than seven dice (if it wants to succeed with no complications) or one die (if it accepts an automatic complication).
The Storyteller may still choose to roll for a conspiracy action, but doing so becomes a pure creative prompt.
Conspiracies
Some troupes want a mechanic like conspiracy surveillance that operates from different principles, while others want to remove conspiracies entirely. Here are some options for doing that.
Pseudo-Conspiracy: The cohort’s antagonists aren’t a conspiracy, but mechanically they behave like one in many ways. Surveillance rolls might represent unwanted public scrutiny, rival cohorts who get in the Renegades’ business, or curious supernatural creatures (or ephemeral entities) that attempt to draw the Broken into their inscrutable designs. Although handled as a single conspiracy, individual “agents” might have little or no relationship with one another or might be one another’s enemies or competitors
No Conspiracy: The Web of Pain either doesn’t exist or doesn’t play a prominent role in the chronicle. The Storyteller might still lean on some conspiracy mechanics to represent other kinds of collective opposition, but this is the exception rather than the rule. Don’t use surveillance or other conspiracy systems. Whatever antagonists the cohort may routinely face, a conspiracy isn’t the dominant one.
Collateral Damage: Although no human institutions pursue the Remade, on some cosmic level (or due to the chronicle’s genre conventions), their powers have messy unintended consequences. This works like No Conspiracy, but whenever a member of the cohort activates, Directs, or benefits significantly from a Variation while Baselines are present (other than Loyalty Touchstones or similar close allies), the Storyteller may make a special surveillance roll:
• The dice pool for this is equal to the Magnitude of the Variation used, treating Subtle Variations as two Magnitude lower.
• The Storyteller may invoke this roll a number of times per chapter based on Threat Level — once at Mutation (Standing 1), twice at Hyperplasia (Standing 2), three times at Dysplasia (Standing 3), and so forth all the way to 10 times if the average Magnitude of the cohort’s Variations would normally put them in the sights of a Standing 10 conspiracy.
Roll Results
Success: The Deviant’s use of Variations inadvertently hurts or frightens someone (or damages something) in the current scene. It might instead create complications for the Remade or her cohort.
Exceptional Success: As success, but it either hurts or frightens many people, kills someone, or causes major damage or destruction to property. Any complication it creates for the Broken or her cohort is particularly serious or long-lasting.
Failure: The Deviant’s use of the Variation doesn’t have any unexpected side-effects.
Dramatic Failure: As failure, and the Storyteller may not make another collateral damage roll during the current scene.
Example #1: Trauma Gauges
The power unleashed by the Divergence doesn’t cause the Broken’s soul to crack, inflicting Scars upon him, and the trauma represented by Scars isn’t what unlocks the power of Variations. That said, some rare Baselines, when under sufficient stress, will tap into potential they never dreamed they had, and finding oneself suddenly in command of unnatural powers (whatever the source) does tend to be life-altering.
Basics
• During character creation, Variations must be entangled with Scars normally. After character creation, each Magnitude of Variations (new or existing) costs 3 Experiences and need not maintain legal entanglement with Scars (or be entangled with a Scar at all). Increasing Scar Magnitude doesn’t permit a free increase in the Magnitude of any entangled Variations.
• Scars retain their normal type (Mental, Physical, and/or Social), but Scar-free Variations have a single type of the player’s choice at the time of their purchase.
• Deviants have one long-term Aspiration slot, two short-term Aspiration slots, a Virtue, and a Vice. They do not have and cannot forge new Touchstones.
• Remade don’t have a Stability track. Instead, they have three Trauma Gauges — Mental Trauma, Physical Trauma, and Social Trauma. Each gauge starts at 0 dots of Shock and can go up to 5 Shock during play. Acclimation doesn’t change the maximum number of dots a gauge can contain.
• At the start of the chronicle (not each story), each player assigns dots of Shock equal to Standing to his character’s Trauma Gauges in any configuration between Mental, Physical, and Social.
• Whenever the Broken suffers a Shock, the player makes a roll based on the type and severity of the experience, potentially modified by other factors. This roll occurs at the end of the scene and applies to the sum of all events in the scene.
Shock Rolls
All Shocks are at least one of Mental, Physical, or Social. Mental Shocks have the potential to increase a character’s Mental Trauma rating. Physical Shocks have the potential to increase a character's Physical Trauma rating. Social Shocks have the potential to increase a character’s Social Trauma rating.
Mental Trauma concerns the Broken’s perception of herself and of reality, as well her sense of control over her body and mind. Most people believe they have free will, think they have a decent understanding of the laws of reality (including any supernatural elements they’ve incorporated into that understanding), and don’t consider themselves criminals (much less murderers). Mental Shocks challenge, if not outright overturn, those perceptions, forcing the Remade to consider what else she might be wrong about.
Physical Trauma is the cumulative history of harm done to the Deviant’s body. Physical Shocks include injuries, serious illness, poisonings, overdoses, and surgery. Even if the transformed makes a full recovery, there’s a chance of some lingering or permanent damage.
Social Trauma reflects the Remade’s history of navigating social situations, making friends, and maintaining healthy relationships. Social Shocks involve being rejected socially (or the perception or fear of rejection) or being unjustly accused or unfairly punished.
Some experiences involve two or even all three types (getting stabbed in a fight where the Deviant kills his opponent would be both a Mental and a Physical Shock, for example, and it could also be a Social Shock if the person he killed was a close friend who turned on him).
• Shocks are classified as Minor, Significant, or Major. Minor Shocks are universal to the human experience. Significant Shocks are much more serious; most people only suffer a few of them in a lifetime. Few people suffer a Major Shock even once in their lives, and those who do are often subjected to the pity or revulsion of those who learn of their experience.
• A player never rolls Shock more than once per Trauma Gauge per scene; only the worst experience of each type applies.
• The severity of the experience determines the base die pool used in the Shock roll — five dice for Minor Shock, three dice for Significant Shock, and one die for a Major Shock. This dice pool can’t be improved by spending Willpower or modified by positive Conditions (such as Steadfast or Inspired).
Roll Results
Success: The Deviant weathers the trauma as well as a person can. Her Shock rating remains the same, but she gains a Minor Trauma Condition (p. XX) appropriate to the nature of the experience.
Exceptional Success: The Remade grows through the experience. She reduces the Shock rating of the relevant Trauma Gauge by one, resolves a Minor Trauma Condition, or gains a beneficial Condition appropriate to the experience, such as Informed, Inspired, or Steadfast.
Failure: The Broken’s trauma deepens in a lasting way. Her Shock rating in the relevant Trauma Gauge increases by one and she gains a Minor Trauma Condition appropriate to the nature of the experience. If her rating in the appropriate Trauma Gauge was already five, it resets to zero, and she gains a relevant Magnitude 1 Persistent Scar (usually one that matches the Trauma Gauge) or adds one Magnitude to an existing Scar.
Dramatic Failure: The experience is life-altering. The Deviant resets the Trauma Gauge to zero and either gains a new Magnitude 1 Persistent Scar (usually one that matches the Trauma Gauge) or adds one Magnitude to an existing Scar.
Modifiers and Recovery
• If the Broken’s total Scar Magnitude is 8 or higher, the Remade does not roll for Minor Shocks. If their total Scar Magnitude is 16 or higher, they don’t roll for Minor or Significant Shocks. Broken always risk Trauma when they experience Major Shocks, and their tolerance for lesser shocks does not translate into additional dice when making Shock rolls.
• Effects that inflict Instability are Shocks of a type that matches the Scar or the Variation’s entangled Scar, or of a type chosen by the player when developing the Form or Adaptation that inflicts the Instability. Touchstone-related Instability (such as from Faltering) is a Mental or Social Shock, as determined by the Storyteller based on the circumstances. Minor Instability is a Minor Shock, medium Instability is a Significant Shock, and major Instability is a Major Shock. These are always rolled even if the character has a high total Scar Magnitude.
• The player of a Deviant with Acclimation 1 or 2 chooses one of Mental, Physical, or Social Trauma when she purchases Acclimation 1. She adds dice equal to the relevant Resistance Attribute (Resolve, Stamina, or Composure) to all Shock rolls against that type of Trauma; Superhuman Attribute doesn’t affect this, and Uplifts use their base Physical Attributes (Clades Companion, p. 17). The player of a Remade with Acclimation 3 or 4 chooses two of the three types of Trauma. One with Acclimation 5 enjoys bonuses to all Shock rolls.
• The minimum Magnitude rules for unentangled Scars apply normally (Deviant, p. 111), but Scar-free Variations can be entangled with legal Scars.
• If a Deviant would develop a new Persistent Scar as the result of a Shock roll and has (or immediately purchases) a Variation that is not currently entangled with an existing Scar, she may choose to develop a Controlled or Involuntary Scar and entangle it with the unentangled Variation.
• At the beginning of each chapter after the first chapter of the chronicle, the player may reduce the amount of Shock in one Trauma Gauge by one.
• A player may permanently reduce the Magnitude of a Scar by one (or eliminate a Magnitude 1 Scar) at a cost of 2 Experiences.
[Full Page shock sidebar]
Shock Examples
Minor Mental Shocks (Roll Five Dice)
Credible threat of nonlethal physical violence (issued or received)
Hurt or supernaturally influenced someone in self-defense, by accident, in accordance with Virtue, or to protect a loved one
Witnessing unfamiliar, nonviolent supernatural activity
Committed non-violent crime to survive, to protect a loved one, or in accordance with Virtue
Body or mind behaves in unexpected ways
Significant Mental Shocks (Roll Three Dice)
Credible threat of lethal physical violence (issued or received)
Killed someone (including by supernatural means) in self-defense, by accident, in accordance with Virtue, or to protect a loved one
Witnessed a death or found a dead body unexpectedly
Witnessed unfamiliar, violent supernatural activity
Committed a nonviolent crime (or exerted supernatural influence) for selfish reasons
Body or mind behaves in unexpected and frightening ways, including as victim of nonviolent supernatural influence
Major Mental Shocks (Roll One Die)
Torture (issued or received)
Committed cold-blooded murder
First-hand exposure to scenes of extreme human misery or carnage
Compelled by force or supernatural influence to perform deeply objectionable acts (as victim or perpetrator)
Minor Physical Shocks (Roll Five Dice)
Suffered three or more bashing damage or any lethal damage, whether due to attack, accident, environment, or Scar/Adaptation
Suffered a Tilt or Condition due to injury, exertion, drug/poison, or deprivation
Exposed to a level 1 or 2 extreme environment long enough to suffer damage or to a potentially dangerous moderate Environmental Tilt
Routine, minimally invasive surgery
Rendered bed-ridden by an illness for more than a day
Significant Physical Shocks (Roll Three Dice)
Suffered three or more lethal damage or any aggravated damage, whether due to accident, attack, environment, or Scar/Adaptation
Suffered bashing damage in rightmost health box
Suffered a Persistent Condition representing a serious and long-lasting illness or injury
Exposed to a level 3 extreme environment long enough to suffer damage or a potentially dangerous severe Environmental Tilt
Life-threatening medical event, major surgery, or treatment for an illness requiring a lengthy hospital stay
Dangerous drug overdose or poisoning
Major Physical Shocks (Roll One Die)
Suffered three or more aggravated damage, whether due to accident, attack, environment, or Scar/Adaptation
Suffered lethal damage in rightmost health box
Exposed to a level 4 extreme environment or multiple potentially dangerous severe Environmental Tilts
Extensive and invasive surgery or a lengthy battery of medical tests and treatments
Near-death experience
Minor Social Shocks (Roll Five Dice)
Rejected or mocked by a stranger
Argued with a friend or loved one
Put foot in mouth or otherwise embarrassed oneself in front of a small group
Spent a week without meaningful human contact or access to social support network
Was stood up for a minor social activity with one or a few people
Wrongfully accused of a minor crime, unkind action, or other failure to adhere to a social contract
Significant Social Shocks (Roll Three Dice)
Divorced or broke up with long-term partner
Publicly humiliated
Rejected or mocked by a friend or loved one
Disappointed by or disappointed a friend or loved one
Spent a month without meaningful human contact or access to social support network
Threw an important party and nobody came
Wrongfully accused of a serious crime or major indiscretion
Disproportionately punished
Major Social Shocks (Roll One Die)
Betrayed by or betrayed a close friend
Went viral for all the wrong reasons
Disowned by one of her parents or children
Spent a year without meaningful human contact or access to social support network
Wrongfully incarcerated or severely punished in spite of innocence
[end shock sidebar]
This modification illustrates what a complete rework of the game’s Deviant-specific systems might look like. It’s intended to satisfy troupes who dislike the emphasis the core mechanics place on the Deviants’ damaged souls, who feel stifled by the laser focus on Touchstones, or who feel uncomfortable with the idea that the powers the Remade wield might come from (occult) disabilities. It still maintains a heavy emphasis on the harsh lives the game’s protagonists lead but does so while giving them a veneer of being little different from Baselines. The conspiracies are still a threat (or as big a threat as the Storyteller chooses to make them), and players are still incentivized to play up their Scars in exchange for Beats. Finally, it uses the design space offered by Scars to permit an endless menu of Conditions suitable to reflect the physical, mental, and emotional damage that Shocks represent.
Example #2: Scylla and Charybdis
Instability is an essential component of the Divergence. True, too much of it quickly leads the Broken into End Stage, but without Instability, the Remade’s Variations cease to function.
Basics
• The Stability track is a Continuum (p. XX) with a range from 0 to 10 dots. A Deviant who accumulates 10 Instability suffers the End Stage Condition (Deviant, p. 321). One who falls to 0 Instability gains the Husk Condition (p. XX). Acclimation doesn’t increase the length of this Instability track.
• Deviants begin play with Instability 5 but don’t gain Instability at the beginning of each story. At the beginning of each story after the first, players may increase or decrease their character’s Instability by no more than their Acclimation.
• Whenever she would suffer/heal a minor Instability (or downgrade a medium or major Instability), the Remade increases/decreases her Instability rating by 1. Gaining/healing medium Instability increases/decreases Instability by 2, and major Instability adds/subtracts 3 Instability.
• Variations are Scar-free. Each Magnitude of Variations purchased after character creation costs 3 Experiences.
• Variations are Colorless (p. XX), rather than taking their type from either Scar. When a Deviant develops a new Variation, her player chooses whether it is a Mental, Physical, or Social Variation.
Stagnation vs. Volatility
Instead of entangling Scars with her starting Variations, the Broken’s player chooses two Scars of the same activation method. The first is the Deviant’s Stagnation Scar, while the second is her Volatility Scar. The Stagnation Scar manifests most strongly when the Remade has low Instability, while the Volatility Scar manifests most strongly when the Broken has high Instability. Each of these Scars must have (or be given) defined effects at every Magnitude (from 1 to 5), including Standard Deviations.
[table]
Instability Rating Effects
Instability 0 Stagnation Scar is Magnitude 5, Volatility Scar is suppressed, and the Deviant suffers the Husk Condition (p. XX).
Instability 1 Stagnation Scar is Magnitude 5. Volatility Scar is Magnitude 1.
Instability 2-3 Stagnation Scar is Magnitude 4. Volatility Scar is Magnitude 2.
Instability 4-6 Stagnation and Volatility Scars are Magnitude 3.
Instability 7-8 Stagnation Scar is Magnitude 2. Volatility Scar is Magnitude 4.
Instability 9 Stagnation Scar is Magnitude 1. Volatility Scar is Magnitude 5.
Instability 10 Stagnation Scar is suppressed, Volatility Scar is Magnitude 5, and the Deviant suffers the End Stage Condition (Deviant, p. 321).
[end table]
Example Scar Pairs
A Deviant’s Stagnation and Volatility Scars should complement one another and reflect their implied relationship with Instability. Ideally, they should also have some narrative connection to one or more of the Remade’s Variations. Here are some examples:
Sensory Deprivation/Glitch: The Broken finds the sensations the world offers distracting. Only by closing her eyes and ears can she avoid being overwhelmed and exhausted. Likely Variations include Shadows of the Past, Specialized Sense, Astral Travel, Predator’s Cunning, Precognition, Sensor Array, and similar Variations that provide information or heighten awareness.
Paranoia/Amnesia: The Deviant has been betrayed so many times and in so many ways that they find they can’t trust anyone. When their memories overwhelm them, they cope by choosing to forget the past. Likely Variations include Face Thief, Holographic Projection, Shadows of the Past, Memory Thief, Telepathy, Psycho-Onomastics, and others that engender distrust of reality or the people in it.
Concentration/Deterioration: The Remade struggles to control powers that threaten to consume him, but if he keeps them too bottled up, he finds it difficult to use them at all. Likely Variations include Boneless, Enhanced Speed, Flight, Gigantic, Miniaturization, Translocation, Animal Transformation, Integrate Technology, Sacred Flesh, and similar Variations that reflect impossible physical transformations.
Preparation/Depletion: The Broken’s powers are reliant upon rituals to activate and recharge them. When she is at her most stagnant, she can’t wield them except with considerable advance preparation, but they have a longer duration. When she lets her Divergence rage out of control, she can unleash her abilities more spontaneously but can’t sustain them for more than a few seconds at a time.
Special/Power Build-up: The Deviant’s Variations defy his control. When his Instability rises, they activate of their own volition, but he finds it easier to tap into and direct them. When his Instability is low, they’re less likely to activate when he wants them to but also less likely to manifest inconveniently. His Stagnation Scar is a penalty to Scar Finesse rolls: This is a –3 penalty at Instability 0-3, a –2 penalty at Instability 4-6, a –1 penalty at Instability 7-9, and no penalty at Instability 10.
This is a simple modification that works best in a low threat level chronicle or one where there is much less emphasis on Scars. Because of the way the Husk Condition must be resolved, it is quite likely that conspiracies don’t trust or attempt to recruit Deviants who have lost their Variations, and many Renegades are likely former Husks who betrayed and murdered a Loyalty Touchstone to regain their abilities.