Beta Reader Text: Chapter Two - Engines (Patreon)
Content
“Players don’t mind being railroaded as long as the train is going somewhere they want to be.”
— Beth Kinderman
Characters are the prime movers of a Deviant chronicle’s machinery. Unless they are placed in positions where they will be put into motion, the entire chronicle will move sluggishly or not at all. A chronicle is a means of telling a story (or many stories), yes, but it is fundamentally an exploration of its protagonists’ experiences, motivations, and actions. The Remade have rich, colorful, and frequently fucked up inner lives, and a well-run chronicle uses its events to bring those out for each player’s character.
Character Sheet
Some players have a clear vision of who their characters are and will convey that to the Storyteller in unmistakable ways. Many have clear ideas but either don’t want to write elaborate character histories or simply don’t have time to do so. Others have a general sense of who their characters are but expect to fill in the details about their past as the chronicle progresses and shape their development around the events of the story. And some, for various reasons, will only offer a character sheet as a starting point for the Storyteller — and possibly an incomplete one, at that.
Whether a player hands you a character sheet with question marks next to some of the Touchstone slots or a detailed character sheet, a 20-page background, a spreadsheet of 200 named supporting characters, and a wiki with an in-character diary, they are providing information about the kinds of things they want their characters to do. Part of the Storyteller’s job is to receive those signals and incorporate them into the chronicle.
Backstory
Some players enjoy writing elaborate character histories. They do this to get inside the Deviant’s head so that it’s easier to roleplay him once the chronicle begins, to offer the Storyteller plot hooks they hope she will introduce at some point, or both. They convey an investment in the character’s story and a desire to be at the center of the chronicle’s narrative at least some of the time. While some people who play tabletop roleplaying games socially don’t really want to be the focus of the story, in the Venn diagram showing the overlap between them and those who write elaborate backstories for their characters, the circles barely share a few pixels.
As a Storyteller, these players can make your job easier by giving you starting points — characters, factions, plot lines, and even chronicle-specific themes. However, they also want their backstories to matter, so they can get frustrated if they feel they put in a lot of extra work that never gets so much as a nod within the story. Unless you’re running a solo chronicle, no player’s character’s background can dominate the events of the story all the time without the other players being left out. Especially if multiple players write detailed backstories, certain potential pitfalls emerge.
Too Many Characters
Real people have complex webs of connections ranging from childhood classmates to colleagues they just met yesterday and from familiar faces at the local shops and restaurants to close friends and soulmates. Roleplaying games are primarily stories, however, and so follow the rules of fiction. This requires a certain economy of characters, meaning the narrative only has space for a limited number of significant characters before they start to become indistinct. The players’ characters are the most important ones. Storyteller characters (whether introduced by a player or the Storyteller) are necessarily secondary and ultimately disposable. Touchstones are a special case that we’ll cover later in the chapter, but for the most part, backstory characters fall into three categories — important, significant, and insignificant.
Important characters are those the player reasonably expects to be central to the story some of the time. Touchstones are always important. Other important characters are those represented by Merits like Retainer, the Deviant’s Progenitor (whether or not she is represented by a Touchstone or Merit), or people with close connections to the Remade (a lover or spouse, for example, or a parent or child for whom he is a primary caregiver). Players usually want to have some say in how the Storyteller portrays these characters. The expectation is that they will appear at least once per story, if not every chapter, unless something takes them out of the chronicle — and that that will not occur lightly. Putting them in jeopardy or giving them a dark secret? Sure, but they shouldn’t die just to give the Broken a motivation or betray him except as a direct consequence of the Deviant’s actions, and not without some buy-in by the player (more on that later in the chapter). To keep them from bogging down play, important characters should be few in number and mostly represented by Touchstones and Merits.
Significant characters are those the player hopes will put in an appearance at some point during the chronicle but has less investment in the context. The Storyteller has de facto permission to use them in whatever way makes sense in her chronicle. These make good characters to drop in to drive a story or introduce a new plot hook, or to add to stables of recurring Storyteller characters who serve some useful narrative purpose in the chronicle (whether as an exposition fountain, a resource, or a source of comic relief). Some significant characters meet grisly ends on-screen or are dragged off to potentially terrible ends off-screen, while others attain enough prominence within the story to become important characters. Because their introduction and recurrence are in the hands of the Storyteller, significant characters can be much more numerous than important characters, although this is truer in a long-term chronicle than one of shorter duration.
Insignificant characters are those the player expects will probably remain confined to her character’s backstory. They mostly serve as flavor, conveying the tenor of the Broken’s prior connections. A Deviant with many insignificant characters with criminal entanglements is distinct from one with wealthy and powerful connections. Whereas significant characters can serve as informal contacts and allies (albeit not ones who provide assistance often or consistently), insignificant characters do not have a strong attachment to the Remade and so require coaxing (and social maneuvering), to convince them to help her — if they appear in the story at all. The inclusion of an insignificant character in the chronicle is entirely up to the Storyteller, who shouldn’t feel any obligation. Unless the player stipulates that a specific insignificant character not appear in the chronicle, the Storyteller is welcome to hurt, abduct, kill, or otherwise use insignificant characters in any way that serves her story — including rendering them significant or important. Insignificant characters can be as few or as numerous as the backstory demands.
If a player offers a character backstory that has a lot of named (or implied) characters in it, be sure to clarify which ones he considers important, significant, and insignificant. This will allow you to ensure the inclusion of the ones he is most interested in.
If multiple players offer detailed backgrounds with many characters, talk it over with them to see if any can be combined into shared named characters. This isn’t always possible; players can be protective of their background characters, and sometimes it just doesn’t make sense that the two Remade are connected through that character. But when it works, it’s much easier to include one character in a chronicle than two.
Cooler in the Backstory
Sometimes a character has capabilities or connections in her backstory that are not reflected in her traits. A player wants her to be a brilliant surgeon or a master thief or an Olympic athlete, but the dots just don’t add up. One reason this happens is that players often like to play characters who were remarkable even before their Divergence. Mostly, though, this reflects the realities of character creation. Even Remade with the Variations to go toe-to-toe with a Standing 6 conspiracy have the same number of starting Attribute, Skill, and Merit dots as one facing a Standing 1 conspiracy. At other times, a character’s appearance or manner comes with social advantages, stigmas, or both that aren’t readily reflected with mundane traits — such as a very young or very old character. Shy of offering additional Experiences during character creation (p. XX), there are several ways to explain this discrepancy:
That Was a Long Time Ago: The Remade possessed remarkable skills, but they have atrophied with disuse or simple age. At the age of 65, the legendary stunt pilot isn’t capable of the aerobatics of her youth, for example.
Unsung Casualty of Divergence: The Divergence greatly diminished the Broken, stripping him of finely honed skills. This isn’t reflected by Scars, simply in the apparently reduced traits implied by his backstory. This adds another layer of tragedy to the Deviant’s circumstances.
That Was Before the Accident: Not everything needs to be blamed on the Divergence. Some injuries leave lasting damage. A torn knee ligament can be career-ending for an athlete, and a severe blow to the head can cause a variety of disorders affecting anything from motor function to emotional regulation.
Holding Back: The character’s capabilities are still there, but circumstances conspire to make them shine less brightly at them during the early part of the chronicle than they did in their backstory. This works best when the difference between the backstory version of their capabilities and the character creation version isn’t huge or concerns abilities that are unlikely to come into play until later in the chronicle. The player’s early Experience expenditures are largely geared towards making the character creation version of the character into the backstory version.
Natural Variations (Optional Rule): The Clades Companion introduced the concept of Natural Scars and Variations (p. 8), which reflect inherent qualities not tied to the Divergence but which closely resemble Scars and Variations. These are easy to adapt to other purposes, including reflecting a unique mundane capability. Without an appropriate Form, Natural Variations are only available at character creation, must be entangled with an appropriate Scar, can’t be of Magnitude 3+, and count against the character’s starting Magnitude of Variations. They must be Persistent and Subtle (with the exception of Perpetual Gigantic 1 or Perpetual Miniaturization 1) and must be a capability a Baseline could conceivably have. They don’t count towards limits on Magnitude of Clade Variations (for better or worse) and aren’t considered supernatural. Powers that manipulate or shut down supernatural abilities and powers do not affect them. This includes Variations and Adaptations that increase or decrease Magnitude or suppress them entirely, as well as Instability, so they never improve during play. Powers that directly oppose the effects of a Natural Variation do so automatically and without a Clash of Wills.
Natural Scars (Optional Rule): Natural Scars can be used to reflect a permanent injury, disability, or inherent disadvantage unrelated to the Divergence. They are wholly mundane and not affected by Instability; the only way they may manifest, worsen, or fade after character creation is due to the events of the chronicle (such as an arm being amputated or a child “outgrowing” Omega). Natural Scars must be Persistent, are not counted in the limits on unentangled Scars, are usually of low Magnitude (rarely 3+), and generate Beats when they create complications for the Remade or her cohort. Without an appropriate Form, Natural Scars cannot entangle Variations.
[Half Page or Full Page Sidebar]
Common Natural Scars
Conspicuous Appearance (Deviant, p. 161): Noteworthy tattoos or scars, visible birth defects.
Dependency (Deviant, p. 162): Prescription drugs to manage a chronic illness.
Evil Twin (Shallow Graves, p. 122): Has since reformed himself but did a lot of bad things at some point in the past, earning a terrible reputation and making lasting enemies.
Genetic Disorder (Deviant, p. 163): Chronic fatigue and various other chronic illnesses.
Hemophilia (Deviant, p. 164): Hemophilia or use of prescription blood thinners.
Missing Limb (Deviant, p. 166): Nerve damage, birth defect, amputee, or paralysis.
Omega (Shallow Graves, p. 125): Child, disability, old age.
Phobia (Deviant, p. 167): Phobia.
Sensory Deprivation (Deviant, p. 168): Nearsighted, hard of hearing, blind (in one or both eyes), deaf (in one or both ears).
Silence (Deviant, p. 168): Speech impediment, deaf, damaged tongue.
Sleepy (Shallow Graves, p. 127): Chronic fatigue or insomnia, narcolepsy, sleep disorder.
Sluggish Metabolism (Deviant, p. 168): Old age, chronic illness.
Thin Skin (Deviant, p. 170): Small child, old age, chronic illness.
Traumatic Memories (Shallow Graves, p. 128): PTSD
Common Natural Variations
Chronological Alignment (Shallow Graves, p. 86): Lucky, gambler, con artist, child, old age.
Emotion Amplification (Shallow Graves, p. 105): Charlatan, con artist, slimy politician.
Enhanced Speed (Deviant, p. 117): Martial artist, Olympic runner, legendary tracer.
Gigantic (Magnitude 1 and Perpetual only; Deviant, p. 119): Giant, NBA/NFL player.
Hyper-Competence (Deviant, p. 122): An expert in their field.
Internet Acuity (Shallow Graves, p. 96): Master hacker
Miniaturization (Magnitude 1 and Perpetual only; Deviant, p. 126): Child, little person.
Shadows of the Past (Deviant, p. 129): Master detective or forensics specialist.
Superhuman Attribute (Deviant, p. 131): Paragon of inherent talent.
Tool Mastery (Shallow Graves, p. 91): Contract killer, master craftsman.
Vocalization (Shallow Graves, p. 103): Ventriloquist, opera singer.
[End Sidebar]
Sticking Out
A detailed backstory can be full of useful plot hooks, but sometimes the details don’t mesh with the histories of the rest of the cohort or with the chronicle the Storyteller has in mind. Too many specifics can explain details that would have been more enjoyable for the Storyteller to explore and reveal during play. Discussion before character creation commences can often head this off before the player gets too attached to a concept or backstory detail. Once the backstory is written, discussing the parts that don’t quite fit and finding a way to adjust or compromise on the details can usually get a result that everyone is happy with.
White Space
A bare bones background or one that doesn’t exist at all presents its own challenges but offers opportunities, as well. It’s important not to jump to conclusions about why a player chooses to keep character history details to a minimum. Sometimes it betrays a lack of interest in those details — or is the consequence of busy lives with limited free time to write detailed backstories. At other times, it is an intentional choice, however. This is most obvious when paired with the Amnesia Scar, but it can come up in any situation where a player chooses for her character’s past to remain something of a mystery even to her. She might be a Deviant of many mysteries, revealing surprising facets of herself as the story progresses. Or maybe she remains a closed book, and only unusual Skills or Merits reveal the person she is beneath her enduring mask.
The optional Opening Flashbacks rule in Shallow Graves (p. 167) is made for these kinds of characters but isn’t required for it to work. The player could decide on her character’s secrets and either reveal them in play or use them to guide Experience expenditures. A player may instead create a character who seems like an open book but who has capabilities that invite questions that whose answers seem likely to be disturbing, such as: Why does the stand-up comic have two dots in Firearms and a Specialty in Sniper Rifles? The expectation, of course, is that the truth will eventually come out at a dramatic moment.
Revealed Advantage (Optional Rule)
In a chronicle that emphasizes secrets or features characters who have secret pasts, the Storyteller may permit players to spend Experiences during a chapter to purchase one Skill, Specialty, Merit, or Variation. This is allowed once per chapter per character, which can’t be reset by Adaptations, and costs a point of Willpower. The Willpower cost is waived if the character already spent a point of Willpower to add dice to the action the new capability the revealed advantage will enhance (such as the purchase of a dot of Athletics immediately before attempting to jump from the roof of one building to another). Purchase of a Variation this way also inflicts a minor Instability and requires that the Deviant already has a Scar that can legally entangle it. The character must immediately use the revealed advantage and the player must reveal the source of this capability in-character before the end of the chapter. If the troupe is using the Opening Flashbacks rule, she may instead offer to explain the capability the next time she is the subject of a flashback (and can’t pass her turn to another player when called upon to do so).
Touchstones
Touchstones are a key driver of Deviant behavior, characters a Storyteller can use to bait plot hooks of all kinds. They encourage players to consider who are the most important people in their characters’ lives and incentivize regular interaction with those characters under the threat of Instability. For players for whom writing elaborate backstories filled with colorful characters comes naturally, the main obstacles are narrowing it down to just five Touchstones and finding enough screentime at the table to interact with them as much as they’d like. However, for players for whom this exercise is not second nature, or who prefer to develop attachments to Storyteller characters during play, coming up with five Touchstones can seem an insurmountable obstacle. In fact, many such players will quietly skip this step, not realizing how important it is in a Deviant chronicle.
Here are some strategies to help players who struggle to decide on Touchstones:
Shared Touchstones: Another member of the cohort may already have a Touchstone it makes sense for the Broken to share. An antagonist who has earned the enmity of one Renegade is very likely to piss off another, and a friendly Baseline who hangs out with the cohort can certainly befriend multiple Remade within it. Plot hooks involving shared Touchstones provide stronger motivation for the cohort to get involved. They also reduce the number of Storyteller characters who need to be introduced and kept within the chronicle’s focus.
Touchstone Divorce: Some players assume that once they’ve selected a Touchstone, that’s it. They’re saddled with that person (or place or thing) until one of them dies. Remind players that Touchstones can change. A Deviant can break up with his girlfriend or decide that the guy who bullied him in high school just isn’t worth it and be done with that relationship. Faltering handles this in a mechanical way; the more often the Remade blows off her friend or ignores her hated Progenitor in favor of larger concerns, the more likely that character is to fall off his emotional radar permanently. But Broken can also abandon an existing Touchstone up to once per chapter to make way for one that the player finds more compelling.
Intracohort Bonds: Although the previously discussed caveats apply (Deviant, p. 286, nothing prevents a Deviant from selecting other members of their cohort as Loyalty Touchstones — or as Conviction Touchstones, although that comes with warning labels, not just caveats (Shallow Graves, p. 33). Such an intracohort bond doesn’t provide a Storyteller character who can be used as a recurring plot hook, but it at least ensures that the Renegade has a built-in interest in the plot threads other members of the cohort pursue. A Touchstone slot filled with another player’s character can be narratively interesting, and certainly more so than a blank space where a Touchstone should be.
Vague Touchstones: Sometimes, players feel like they’re expected to understand their Touchstones, but they struggle to conjure up details — especially Conviction Touchstones, since their characters don’t necessarily understand the motives (or in some cases, the real identities) of these antagonists. Encourage the player to name Conviction Touchstones with a general description only, such as “my Progenitor,” “my Progenitor’s assistant,” or “the boy who broke my heart.” Shoot for at least one Conviction Touchstone that is clearly linked to the conspiracy, and at least one who isn’t obviously connected to the Web of Pain. When you need to bait a plot hook, give one of these characters a name and get them involved in the story, informing the player that this is “her Progenitor’s assistant” (or whatever general description applies).
Wild Cards: If a player is still stumped on some (or all) his Touchstone slots — or if he really wants to take a wait-and-see approach — have him put an asterisk in any slots that would otherwise be blank. These asterisks mean he has those Touchstones (in the usual mix of Conviction and Loyalty), but they haven’t yet been defined in play. Once the chronicle starts, the player may retroactively declare a Storyteller character the cohort meets as a Touchstone, replacing one of the asterisks in an appropriate slot with that character’s name. These wild card Touchstones don’t begin as Wavering and don’t count towards the limit of selecting one new Touchstone per chapter. At the end of the first story of the chronicle, the player may fill in any number of the rest of the wild card slots using any of the methods above. Any wild cards that remain are those the player is giving the Storyteller permission to select and introduce at her discretion.
Once the player has chosen his character’s Touchstones, it usually falls to the Storyteller to invent ways to bring them into the chronicle in ways that drive the story. We’ll discuss some techniques for doing this later in the chapter.
Assets
Players want chances for their characters to shine. The dots on a character sheet communicate the obstacles a player expects the cohort to face and how she hopes to help overcome them. In most cases, lots of combat abilities indicate an interest in engaging fights, for example, and an abundance of “knowing things” abilities usually convey an interest in a chronicle heavy on investigation. This is less certainly the case later in a chronicle, as players spend some Experiences in response to events (often to compensate for holes in the cohort’s capabilities), but during character creation, exceptions to this are rare.
When planning each chapter of a chronicle, it behooves the Storyteller to take each character’s assets into consideration and to make an effort to introduce obstacles that will let everyone show off what they can do — to solve a problem with ease that may have been beyond the capabilities of anyone else in the cohort. Keep this as fair as possible. You don’t have to maintain a literal checklist of which players have had a chance to use their assets, and which are currently on the to-do list, but make sure everyone gets a turn in the talent show.
Variations
As supernatural abilities that are usually unique to the individual Broken (at least within the context of a cohort), Variations permit a Deviant to achieve what would be impossible for Baselines in the absence of special equipment. They frequently define a character’s role within a cohort and easily solve certain classes of problems. Many times, they are the Broken’s hammer in want of a nail — her default response to any obstacle that stands in her way. As Storyteller, giving players nails to hit with their characters’ favorite hammers helps keep them coming back to the gaming table.
Consider as well how the use of a Variation can sometimes create more problems than it solves. Overt Variations attract conspiracy attention and cause breaking points in most Baselines — including Loyalty Touchstones who haven’t seen the Deviant deploy them before. Controlled Variations require a successful Scar Finesse roll to use, and they exact their full price when activated, even if the effect the Remade wants is of lower Magnitude than his full capabilities. Involuntary Variations activate at inconvenient times, and most are Overt when they do so. You don’t want to punish Broken for using their cool powers, but encouraging some hesitation and cost/benefit analysis before they do so is perfectly in keeping with the themes of the game.
Adaptations
Every Deviant has Adaptations. In low threat level chronicles, they may outnumber their Variations. While seasoned Deviant players (especially those with access to the additional Adaptations in Shallow Graves) sometimes build entire character concepts around Adaptations, it’s easy for less experienced ones to overlook them except insofar as they reset per-chapter abilities.
As a Storyteller, however, it is important not to overlook these force multipliers. Planning should assume that Cephalists and Coactives with Focus and Consume can increase the Magnitude of any of their Tiered Variations to 5. It shouldn’t assume that a Chimeric with Untamed can be taken down by a single Scar. It needn’t be shy about dealing damage to an Invasive with Redundancy. And it should bear in mind that a Mutant with Unpredictable has access to any low-Magnitude Universal Variation he might require. The new Adaptations in Shallow Graves are no less potent and should shape decision-making just as surely.
By the same token, remind players of their Adaptations when they seem stumped by a problem that can be solved by one, particularly if you set up a challenge with that Adaptation in mind!
Forms
Most Deviants don’t have Forms. For those who do, however, they are a fundamental part of their character concept. Forms can be mechanically complex, especially those in The Clades Companion and Shallow Graves, which both offer players many customization options. Forms tell a story about the character in a way that Variations don’t always do, and a Storyteller should find ways to play into that story.
Mundane Traits
Attributes, Skills, Specialties, and Merits speak volumes about how a player sees his character and how he intends to overcome obstacles in play.
Attributes reflect raw talent, but for Deviants they also determine Scar Power, Finesse, and Resistance. So, choices of Attribute configurations must often be seen in that context. A character with a lot of Mental Scars is likely to have higher Mental Attributes — or at least a high Intelligence — and vice versa.
Skills reflect trained ability. With a few exceptions like Lash (Deviant, p. 122) and Deadly Ichor (Deviant, p. 149), they don’t affect supernatural abilities. Remade who don’t have an appropriate Variation to solve a problem (or those in situations where using them would carry too much of a risk or cost) usually fall back on their Skills to carry the day. Pay attention to each character’s Skill choices. Give them ample opportunity to use those in which they have two or more dots and occasional chances to use ones in which they have at least one dot.
Specialties provide a benefit in limited circumstances. Some players will choose Specialties tactically, such as a character who regularly carries a revolver with a Firearms Specialty in Pistols. Oftentimes, however, players will choose one or two quirky Specialties during character creation, such as an Academics Specialty in Ancient Babylon. In these cases, make a special point of trying to give characters a chance to use each one at least once during the chronicle. If a character has a Specialty in Ancient Babylon, introduce at least one situation or plot where knowledge of Ancient Babylon will be particularly useful. Keep in mind that players are less likely to remember the Specialties they picked during character creation, especially two or three stories into the chronicle, so you may need to provide a reminder in the form of the question: “Do any of you have a Specialty that might be relevant here?” They’ll look, and their eyes will light up, especially if they never really expected it to come up on play.
As problem-solving tools, most Merits sit somewhere between Variations and Skills. Using Overt Social Merits carries some of the same risks as deploying an Overt Variation. As expressions of who a character is (or was), many are closer to Forms in their importance.
Sometimes, the best way to emphasize a character’s capabilities is through her absence in an important scene where they would be most useful. An ambush that catches only the less combat-ready members of the cohort adds a level of desperation to the scene that wouldn’t be present if their heavy fighters were around, for example, and a negotiation can quickly turn into a fiasco if the only ones around to close the deal are the members of the cohort who have trouble waving “hello” without giving offense. Don’t overdo this. Most of the time, giving characters a chance to show off their assets is the best way to emphasize their deftness, and a Storyteller who goes out of his way to throw characters into the “wrong” scenes risks frustrating all the players at the table. But the occasional inconvenient absence can both provide comic relief and give the rest of the cohort a renewed appreciation for their companion’s abilities.
Competence and Failure
Players who invest a lot of dots or Experiences into a Skill want their characters to be seen as competent with it. But Fate and the dice often have other ideas. No one wants their master burglar character to fail to pick a cheap padlock — even in high pressure scenes — but when it happens, they don’t want it to make them look bad at their jobs. The Storyteller can take a lot of the sting out of a failure simply in how he chooses to frame it.
Look at the character’s Skill rating. Count it as one higher if she has a relevant Specialty. You can count it as one lower if the Attribute is 1, one higher if the related Attribute is 5 or higher, or as two higher if the Attribute is 8 or more.
Skill 0: The character has no real experience performing such a task, and any failure reflects that she is essentially flailing and hoping for the best. For Firearms, shots go wild, or the safety was on, for example, or someone attempting to be charming (for Socialize) comes across as patronizing or insulting. Dramatic failures betray genuine incompetence and often render further attempts in the current scene impossible. Success is never graceful and always attributable to dumb luck.
Skill 1-2: The character is reasonably competent, and a failure is as likely to be the result of bad luck or factors outside of his control than a matter of insufficient skill. For Weaponry, the target twists clear of the knife thrust, or the character slides on some loose gravel and can’t recover quickly enough to land a blow, for example, or maybe there’s just not a lot of information available about a particular politician (for Politics). Dramatic failures could be bonehead mistakes made under pressure — such as trying to pass on the shoulder during a car chase and not realizing there’s an abandoned vehicle there until too late — but it might just be that another car veers into his lane and sideswipes him by accident.
Skill 3-4: The character’s skills are finely honed. Failure is usually the result of circumstances beyond her control or operating under impossible conditions. For Expression, her performance is interrupted by a power outage, or a network error corrupts the file containing her carefully composed essay, for example, or an inconvenient thunderstorm or incompetent cops disturbed the crime scene beyond usefulness (for Investigation). A dramatic failure is usually a stroke of bad luck, with the occasional act of enemy sabotage to blame at least some of the time. For Larceny, someone jammed the locking mechanism with a broken off paperclip, and it wouldn’t open even if she had the key, for example, or a snake bites the horse she’s riding so that it rears and forces her to dismount with considerably less than her usual grace.
Skill 5+: The character is among the best at what he does, and even when he fails to achieve an obvious goal, it is because he noticed something the uninitiated wouldn’t have. For Athletics, he takes one look at the gap between the buildings and decides not to jump, instead taking a moment to find another way across, for example, or he spots a bystander in his backdrop who could be hurt if he takes the shot and takes his finger off the trigger just in time (for Firearms). At this level, failure doesn’t waste resources or create complications; it only delays the inevitable. Dramatic failures are the same as for Skill 3-4 but should be notably rarer.
Optional Rule: Safe Sevens
To convey the competence of characters with large dice pools in Skills, consider implementing the following rule:
If a character has at least seven dice (including situational modifiers, equipment bonuses, and Specialties) to roll on an unopposed (not resisted or contested) instant action, the player may choose not to make the roll, instead treating the result as a basic success.
Increase this threshold to eight dice if the player meets it by spending Willpower. Reduce it to four dice if the character enjoys the rote quality on the action. Keep it at seven if both apply.
This mechanic is especially handy for rolls to remember pertinent information, as it ensures that the Storyteller can dispense crucial exposition. But it can also render routine such tasks as climbing over fences or repairing a car engine that would be difficult for most people.
Liabilities
Even the most supernaturally potent Deviant has vulnerabilities, pressure points that can force a reaction if one knows the right place to squeeze. The conspiracies of the Web of Pain understand this, and those that pursue Renegades to press into service are often as patient as a garrote. When faced with unfamiliar Remade with heretofore unknown abilities, conspiracy agents learn from every encounter. Many apparent attacks are simply probing maneuvers intended to encourage the Broken to use their Variations so that the conspiracy can document them and identify potential countermeasures for future encounters. Early surveillance likewise focuses on the Remade’s associations and habits to identify Scars and Loyalty Touchstones that can be used to bring the Deviant to heel. Ruthless conspiracies also try to determine a Deviant’s Conviction Touchstones — not just so they know which of their agents the Broken are most likely to target but because these make as tempting a bait as Loyalty Touchstones. Some will actively recruit — or even manufacture — these Conviction Touchstones specifically so they can dangle them in view of the transformed and lure her into their traps. It’s not unthinkable that they might be willing to sacrifice an extraneous agent to help a targeted Deviant recover some of her equilibrium when her Instability threatens to destroy the conspiracy’s carefully cultivated investment.
Storytellers should take this as permission to tailor challenges to the cohort’s exhibited weaknesses, especially as the chronicle progresses and the conspiracy familiarizes itself with the Renegades’ Variations, Scars, Touchstones, and general modus operandi. Practically speaking, it simplifies narrative structure and keeps the players on their toes. The Storyteller characters they feel most strongly about are the ones who keep turning up, which is especially important for an antagonist. The unusual stimulus or weird Bane shows up at inopportune times not just by happenstance but because the conspiracy has learned the value of using it against the Deviant.
From an out of character perspective, Scars (and to a lesser extent, Loyalty Touchstones) are the main source of Beats. If they never come up, character advancement slows to a crawl. Most players figure this out pretty quickly and will seek out (or even request) situations that will bring their Scars into play or force them to take risks to protect their Loyalty Touchstones. When Scars and Touchstones become liabilities, it also creates drama and drives engaging stories, which are the real business of most tabletop roleplaying games, Deviant among them. Deviant is somewhat unusual in the degree to which it requires players to give the Storyteller ways to mess with or hurt their characters, but with vulnerabilities specific to each Remade, the Storyteller can at least be reasonably confident that the player is on board with the Scars that are being used against him. One doesn’t take a Scar like Amnesia and expect that all the forgotten memories are happy or unimportant ones; horrible revelations about the past are virtually assured.
Aspiration
Broken only have one Aspiration that serves as the player’s short-term goal for the next chapter. The Aspiration a player chooses at the beginning of the chronicle gives the Storyteller some idea of what she expects the opening chapter to be like. An Aspiration like “look for a job” or “go to a museum” implies a more of a slice of life opening chapter, while “win a fight” or “escape my captors” anticipates violent action.
Where possible, attempt to include an opportunity for each character to satisfy their Aspiration during the first chapter. This often won’t be realistic, however — especially if you have a clear idea of how the chronicle will open and your players select Aspirations that aren’t compatible with that. This is okay. Make sure to remind players at the end of the chapter that they can change Aspirations to be more in line with how they expect the next chapter to go. It’s likely they will be closer to the mark once they see the direction the chronicle is going.
As with Touchstones, some players will be tempted to leave their Aspiration blank. This isn’t as much of a problem for Aspirations, however. They’re meant to be short-term goals and aren’t nearly as crucial to a Deviant’s story as Touchstones are. At the end of the first scene of the opening chapter, consider asking each player to tell you what his current Aspiration is and give him a chance to select or change that Aspiration immediately. He will likely have a better idea what he can hope to achieve before the end of the chapter once he sees the general trajectory of the opening story. This consideration is seldom necessary for later chapters, and a Storyteller can usually find a way to include most Aspirations when planning the next chapter.
Touchstones
Touchstones are a key driver of individual character behavior. Threatening a Loyalty Touchstone or offering a chance to make a Conviction Touchstone miserable (or dead) is an unmistakable, and usually irresistible, sign to the player that a plot thread is important. If a Touchstone is involved, the cohort is likely to become involved sooner rather than later — a fact a Storyteller can and will use to her advantage throughout a typical Deviant chronicle.
The risk is in allowing the way in which she uses Touchstones to become repetitive. There’s only so many times the conspiracy can kidnap a Loyalty Touchstone, and so many times the cohort can face off against a Conviction Touchstone and his goons, before it loses its impact.
Using Loyalty Touchstones
Protecting and maintaining relationships with Loyalty Touchstones consumes a significant amount of a Deviant’s attention. The obvious threat is that the conspiracy will abduct or kill the Remade’s loved ones, and that’s certainly a common (and effective) enough trope. However, it isn’t the only one a Storyteller can use to bring the Broken into a storyline. Roleplaying games being echoes of the media that inspired them, genre-savvy players will generally assume that any unprovoked mention of a Loyalty Touchstone means the Storyteller has something unpleasant in mind for them, and the conspiracy will be involved somehow. Occasionally subverting that expectation — or seeming on the point of doing so before turning it around — keeps players guessing without tempting them to ignore potential threats entirely.
Living Loyalty Touchstones
Abductee: Someone kidnaps the Deviant’s friend. This could be the conspiracy’s attempt to secure a hostage to force the cohort’s cooperation — and players will usually expect this. However, it could instead be unrelated to the conspiracy on the surface. If the abductee has connections to wealth or power, her kidnappers could want ransom money or political concessions of some kind. It’s even possible that the abductor’s demands are ones the Remade would support under different circumstances and that the cohort might turn an apparent enemy into an ally once the messy hostage situation is defused. If the kidnappers aren’t so sympathetic, this can make for a straightforward chapter to introduce when one or more players are absent; it can even be challenging, if the abductors have supernatural resources of their own to call upon.
Medical Emergency: The Broken’s friend has an accident or suffers a heart attack, stroke, or similar medical event that sends him to the hospital. Unless the troupe has powerful healing Variations at their disposal, the Touchstone will need to remain there for days or weeks, making her a tempting target for the conspiracy to surveil or abduct. Even after they’re discharged from the hospital, people recovering from surgery require additional support while they recover, and the cohort may find themselves needing to add running errands or doing chores for the Broken’s friend to their busy schedule of avoiding conspiracy attention and plotting the demise of Conviction Touchstones.
Terminal Illness: The Deviant’s friend is diagnosed with a life-threatening illness or condition that will more than likely kill them. This carries many of the same obligations as helping a Touchstone recover from a stay in the hospital but with no happy end in sight. As obsessed as they are with preserving their Loyalty Touchstones from harm, this presents a scenario that the Remade can’t murder or mayhem their way out of. If the conspiracy steps out of the shadows to offer the Broken a cure (or even a treatment), will they accept it?
Traitor: The Remade’s friend is a spy or traitor. He might have been working for the conspiracy all along, or maybe this is a new development. Possibly, he used to be a pawn of the conspiracy, but he has since defected or gone rogue, but the Deviant never learned of those secret loyalties. It might not be something the friend can control or is aware of, such as if the conspiracy has installed a hidden, microscopic camera, microphone, and transmitter in his skull or can access his senses clairvoyantly. His masters might not even be the current conspiracy — or any conspiracy at all — but it’s undeniable that he is working on behalf of someone other than the Broken.
Favor: The Touchstone calls upon the Deviant’s friendship to help her out of a jam. Maybe her babysitter cancelled at the last minute, and she needs the Remade to watch her children for just a few hours, for example, or possibly her car broke down and she needs a ride home. These favors are seldom an issue in themselves, but they are time-sensitive and can create a complication if the request comes when the Broken is actively engaged in a delicate operation or trying to go to ground after a near miss with conspiracy agents.
Illegal Favor: The Touchstone tests adage about the things real friends will help you move. He asks the Deviant to cover up a crime, steal something, kill someone, or otherwise commit or aid in the commission of a crime. This carries all the potential complications of a more mundane favor but is much less likely to result in wacky hijinks and much more likely to end with the cohort in the crosshairs of law enforcement. It also invites questions about why the Loyalty Touchstone is making this request and whether he is taking advantage of the Remade’s disinclination to refuse him anything.
New Friend: The Broken’s Loyalty Touchstone makes a new friend or takes a lover external to the cohort. This relationship takes time away from the Deviant, but it also makes her happy. How does the Remade navigate this new social dynamic? Does he draw the friend into the cohort’s confidences, or maintain his distance? If the conspiracy targets the Touchstone’s friend as a way of getting at the Broken, how does he respond? What happens if it turns out that the Touchstone’s lover is an agent of the conspiracy, albeit one who clearly loves her and is good for her?
Toxic Relationship: The Deviant’s friend enters (or is already in) a toxic relationship. It could be an abusive parent, controlling romantic partner, exploitative boss, parasitic relative, or violent friend. Whatever the specifics, leaving the relationship is complicated, whether socially, emotionally, or economically. Simply throwing the offender from a high building won’t solve these problems and will certainly alienate the Loyalty Touchstone but letting them suffer isn’t a situation the Remade can easily stomach.
Crush: The Broken’s friend aspires to enter a relationship with someone other than the Deviant but is at least temporarily frustrated in his desire. This might be romantic, but it could instead be a potential mentor, employer, or membership in an elite club. It could even be a longing for a material possession, such as a house or car. Or maybe he doesn’t have anyone particularly in mind but likes the general idea of meeting someone, getting married, having kids and pets, and living in a nice house together. Whatever the specifics, the Touchstone spends a lot of time mooning over and moaning about his feelings and the unattainability of this beloved figure. He might call upon the Remade to play matchmaker or wingman, however unsuited the Broken might be for that role. It could also happen that the Deviant doesn’t approve of the friend’s crush.
Special Occasion: The Loyalty Touchstone invites the Remade (or possibly the whole cohort) to a social gathering — from something casual like a dinner party or helping her move to something formal like being a bridesmaid at her wedding. Once committed to such a scheduled event, cancellation is rarely an option without Faltering. Such scenarios can be played for laughs or as deadly serious explorations of the ways the Divergence is alienating. Depending on the other guests, it can also produce situations where the Broken must defend her friend from conspiracy agents or is forced to interact with a Conviction Touchstone socially — all without disrupting her Loyalty Touchstone’s special day.
Dangerous Hobby: The Deviant’s friend has (or takes up) a dangerous hobby, unhealthy habit, or self-destructive addiction. It could be entirely mundane, like skydiving or smoking, but it could come with occult entanglements or a connection to the conspiracy.
Criminal Entanglements: The Loyalty Touchstone is involved with criminal elements. He might come from a criminal family that he can’t fully extricate himself from. Perhaps he borrowed money from a loan shark or did some favors for unsavory characters who are now blackmailing into continuing to work for them. He might need the Deviant’s help getting out of a bad situation, or he might ask the Remade to help him work his way higher up the food chain in his gang or the city underworld.
New Job: The Remade’s friend gets a new job, and it tests her relationship with the Broken. Perhaps she has to work long or odd hours, and it cuts into the activities they used to share. Or maybe the new job is connected to the Web of Pain or otherwise potentially dangerous to her. Depending on the job market and her financial obligations, quitting it might not be an option — assuming she doesn’t love her new position.
Vacation: The Loyalty Touchstone decides to take a long vacation or sabbatical, and the Deviant isn’t invited. It could be the trip he’s been talking about for years or one he planned on a whim or after winning a mysterious sweepstakes. This puts the Remade in an awkward position. Not only does it mean they won’t be able to spend time together, her friend will be beyond her ability to protect him for days, weeks, or even months. It’s not hard to imagine all the things that could go wrong in such a situation but stalking him to his vacation destination is hardly becoming behavior.
Stowaway: The Broken’s friend tags along, stows away, or otherwise turns up during one of the cohort’s operations. This places her at the center of the danger and forces the Deviant to take extra measures to protect her from danger — which might include the terrible truth about what he gets up to when she’s not around, if he’s managed to keep it a secret from her.
Bad Influence: The Loyalty Touchstone’s association with the Remade gradually changes his behavior so that he acts less and less like a well-adjusted member of Baseline society and more like a Renegade. For some Broken, this will barely register as a problem, but others will regard this with horror — particularly if they are the Touchstone’s parent or other caregiver.
Moderating Influence: The Deviant’s friend puts her foot down and demands that the Renegade temper his behavior. She might object to his casual use of threats and violence to get what he wants, for example, or perhaps she insists that he be a better person in some other way. The implication is that if he doesn’t at least try to live up to her expectations, he might lose her for good — emotionally, if not physically. A Loyalty Touchstone who refuses to accept the Deviant’s behavior as blindly as he accepts hers — or a naïve one who nevertheless reacts with shock and terror when she sees the horrors he can unleash — can serve as a moderating influence on an entire cohort.
Loyalty Fates
Loyalty Touchstones are natural targets for enemy action. For the most part, conspiracies prefer to keep them intact to use them as leverage against Renegades. Sometimes they go too far, however, and Loyalty Touchstones are damaged or destroyed in the process. These can introduce new story possibilities to a chronicle.
Scarred: The Deviant’s friend is maimed, horrifically scarred, traumatized, or put into a coma. While this doesn’t have the grim finality of death, the Touchstone’s condition serves as a reminder of the damage his association with the Broken can cause.
Remade: The Loyalty Touchstone suffers the Divergence. This is a particularly horrific situation for one of the Broken, who know all too well what this experience signifies. From a storytelling perspective, it permits the introduction of new classes of potential complications, especially if the newly transformed friend’s Scars are disruptive.
Ambiguous Death: By all appearances, the Deviant’s friend dies, but circumstances conspire to prevent her from recovering a body. This carries the full consequences of the confirmable destruction of a Loyalty Touchstone but gives the Storyteller the option of bringing the friend back into the story later — typically with serious complications (such as amnesia, Divergence, or being in the service of the conspiracy). Should this happen, allow the Remade’s player to immediately replace another Touchstone with the resurrected one and without it first being Wavering, even if he has already designated a new Touchstone in the current chapter.
Funeral: The cohort has an opportunity to reflect upon and mourn their companion’s deceased friend. Perhaps they bear the sad responsibility of disposing of the body and organizing a ceremony for memorializing him. Maybe this instead falls to non-Remade who may or may not welcome the Broken at the funeral. Even if they can be present at his memorial, attendance might be unwise. The conspiracy could send agents to capture the Deviant, not caring whether they disrupt the funerary rites or hurt its Baseline attendants. Or they might send an agent or two to infiltrate the event and befriend the Remade while she is vulnerable (and likely has an empty Touchstone slot).
Mourner: The Broken was not the only person who cared about the Loyalty Touchstone or who was affected her death. It might be a child, partner, parent, or other relative, or it could be a friend, coworker, nosy journalist, or police detective investigating the suspicious circumstances of her death. They might need the cohort’s protection — from the conspiracy, if not because they are too young or too infirm to care for themselves — or insist on joining their quest for revenge. Or they might blame the Deviant for their friend’s death and quickly set themselves up on a collision course with this friend of a friend whom they now consider an enemy. Whomever they are, they could help fill the void (and Touchstone slot) left by the deceased friend, whether they serve as a focus for intense devotion or intense hatred.
Using Conviction Touchstones
Conviction Touchstones shape a Deviant’s actions. Because they are often entangled with the conspiracy pursuing the cohort, they frequently provide motivation for the entire cohort. Not all Conviction Touchstones need be objectively villainous characters, but Renegades don’t forge these connections without some reason that at least makes sense to them, so usually they are. Nor must every villain the cohort faces be a Conviction Touchstone; sufficiently frustrating recurring villains usually become Conviction Touchstones eventually, so most of the advice below applies to antagonists more generally.
Conviction Behavior
Whether they begin their life as a little more than a name on a player’s character sheet, as a lovingly detailed nemesis in a backstory, or are someone the Storyteller introduces before anyone realizes the cohort is expected to hate them, a character is only a villain insofar as their behavior is villainous and is only an antagonist insofar as their actions and goals put them at odds with the cohort. A Conviction Touchstone need not be either, but in a game focused on getting bloody revenge against those who wronged its protagonists, it’s preferable for them to have wronged the Remade — or to have at least wronged someone.
Conspiracy: A character who is the agent of the conspiracy the Renegades currently oppose is a natural antagonist. This is especially true if the Touchstone is a true believer in the conspiracy’s principles, rather than a naïve dupe who doesn’t know about the atrocities it commits. However, a conspiracy agent who turns against his masters when he learns the truth offers a potential redemption story for that character.
Villainy: Villains hurt people. It may be direct and physical, such as murder, assault, or torture (or being the one to order these). It could be by curtailing personal autonomy through abduction, brainwashing, or blackmail. It might target personal property through theft, arson, or vandalism. Harming many people through pollution (whether intentional or negligent), drug dealing, or selling shoddy or dangerous merchandise can also be villainous behavior. Even if they have some redeeming qualities, a villain does more harm than good — at least in the eyes of the Deviant who has named him a Conviction Touchstone.
Antagonism: An antagonist is an impediment to the Remade achieving her goals or that acts against her interests. An antagonist is not necessarily a villain, although in the black-and-white view of the Broken they may seem to be. The monster hunter looking to capture the strange angelic being witnesses all around town have reported bears the Deviant no particular grudge, but his success would be very bad for the Remade, for example. An antagonist who is just doing his job could pose a significant obstacle to the cohort’s interests without taking any villainous actions they can easily use to justify hurting or killing him.
Personal: The Conviction Touchstones who are most effective at drawing an emotional response from a player are those who wed villainy and antagonism and direct it at the Broken in an intentional and direct way. They don’t just hurt innocent people, for example. They hurt the Deviant and his Loyalty Touchstones, and they do so with full awareness of what they are doing. They can do so in any number of ways popularized by the inspirational media — abduction, brainwashing, blackmail, taunts, and more. Shallow Graves provides lists of ways to express Conviction (Shallow Graves, p. 33) and of ways to express Loyalty in ways that are likely to make their object uncomfortable (Shallow Graves, p. 35), any of which can burnish a Conviction Touchstone’s credentials as a villain.
Need: Merely earning the enmity of a Deviant is dangerous. Repeatedly throwing oneself in her path in ways that frustrate her is almost certain to end in violence. Anyone who does so intentionally has a reason for playing this volatile game of Russian roulette, usually some need so overriding that they can’t deny it. Whether they have an unhealthy fascination with the Remade or hate her, a compelling recurring villain needs the Broken. It could be imposed on them from without, such as if the conspiracy has tasked him with capturing the Deviant, with failure resulting in severe penalties, up to and including (possibly even exceeding) the termination of his employment. It might be a matter of honor, pride, curiosity, or some other internal behavioral driver. Need means that the Conviction Touchstone can’t merely kill the Remade at the first opportunity; she and her companions are much more valuable to him alive.
Conviction Survival
Once a Conviction Touchstone enters the chronicle — whether he was on a character sheet from the start or is someone who earned the Renegades’ ire along the way — quite often one of the Storyteller’s greatest challenges is keeping the cohort from killing him before he can serve as a proper antagonist. Endowed as they are with superhuman abilities, a group of Deviants can overcome most individual opponents who attempt to stand against them. A Storyteller can deploy many different techniques to ensure that a Conviction Touchstone’s first on-screen appearance isn’t his last — nor is it the first time he is relevant to the events of the chronicle:
Obscurity: The Touchstone is the hidden mastermind behind the plots against the cohort, such that the connection between her and the events she orchestrates may approach undetectable. She could very well arrange red herrings so that others are blamed for the events she orchestrated. Merely confirming her involvement poses a challenge, and as long as she is far enough off-screen, bringing her to the rude justice of violent demise is off the table.
Absence: The villain remains off-screen, but he makes no secret of his involvement. He may simply send them threatening messages, whether they’re packages delivered by a courier who has no connection to the conspiracy or phone calls delivered to bystanders who hand them a phone and nervously explain that “it’s for you”. If some conspiracy presence is needed, he works through intermediaries who do his dirty work for him — and who take any lumps the Remade may dish out in retaliation. Often, these are conspiracy goons, but they’re nearly as likely to be unwitting catspaws or even innocent bystanders manipulated into the position by the Touchstone’s machinations. Killing these proxies does no lasting harm to the cohort’s enemy or the conspiracy he serves.
Leverage: If the Conviction Touchstone must be present, it is safest for her to do so when it is clear to the Renegades that the cost of opening hostilities against her is much higher than any advantage gained from doing so. It might involve a hostage, the remedy to a problem the cohort can’t solve without the villain’s help, information they can’t get anywhere else, or dire warnings that if they hurt her it will put them in the sights of law enforcement or provoke a strong reaction from the conspiracy she serves. The first of these works best if the antagonist can both prove that the hostage is within his power (whether through physical proximity or a live feed that can serve as proof of life) and that her inaction (rather than her action) will cause the victim to be harmed. This is what is known as a dead man’s switch and is an effective way of disincentivizing ambushes and unexpected heroics. For leverage to work, the cohort must believe she has it, must believe her capable of making good on her threats, and must regard the threatened consequences as worse than allowing the Conviction Touchstone to have her way.
Alliance: Rather than resorting to threats, which tend to put even Baselines on edge, to say nothing of Broken, the Conviction Touchstone reaches out his hand in friendship — whether temporary or lasting, feigned or genuine. This works best if he can offer them something the cohort wants even more than his blood, such as help taking down a worse villain, committing an act of sabotage against the heart of the conspiracy, or working together to escape capture by enemies who have imprisoned them both. As with leverage, this works best if killing the Conviction Touchstone will create significant complications for the cohort that his continued survival allows them to avoid. The danger of this strategy is that he’s trying to broker a truce or alliance with Broken. Even if the cohort agrees that he’s more useful to them as a friend than as an enemy, it only takes one of them disagreeing with their fellows to leave the Conviction Touchstone bleeding out in the snow of the frozen wasteland they’ve all been stranded in.
Repentance: The Conviction Touchstone sees (or at least pretends to see) the error of their ways. They make apologies, promise to abandon bad behavior patterns, and otherwise say whatever they must to convince the Deviants that they aren’t such a bad person after all — or at least not one that is beyond redemption. This usually reads as insincere and desperate if the cohort has their enemy in their power; a villain pleading for their life when staring death in the face seldom convinces a neutral witness, much less overcomes the all-consuming loathing of the Remade for a Conviction Touchstone. It is much more effective if this repentance comes after a show of good faith, such as if they rescue the Broken or her Loyalty Touchstone or commit some act of radical defiance against the conspiracy. Clever Conviction Touchstones might actually orchestrate assassination attempts they can thwart dramatically in hopes of forcing a reversal from Conviction to Loyalty — or to at least lower the priority the Deviant places on their death.
Retreat: Linchpins who survive their first few encounters with Renegades quickly learn that the best place to be in a fight with Remade is literally anywhere else. An antagonist can put in a brief, on-screen appearance to issue ultimatums, make threats, or bark orders at conspiracy agents and still leave as soon as actual violence erupts — or preferably before. She must assume that her enemies will prioritize her, and so any escape must make it difficult to follow her. It could be a secret passage, an idling car, or a waiting helicopter, and is almost always accompanied by a large number of goons or an impending catastrophe that draws the cohort’s attention away from her long enough for her to make her escape.
Ruthlessness: When violence is likely or inevitable, a smart villain takes pains to stack the deck in his favor. This could take the form of numerous and heavily armed backup, fortifications and controlled environments that afford a homefield advantage, or advanced personal equipment and Icons. If the Conviction Touchstone is a Deviant or has other occult connections, it likely includes supernatural powers. Likewise, exploiting the cohort’s Scars or using their known proclivities can strengthen his negotiating power. Enough of these taken together and prominently displayed can convince the Renegades not to resort to violence in the first place.
Possum: A Renegade is usually single-minded where his Conviction Touchstones are concerned. He will often fight against overwhelming odds if there is a chance he can land the killing blow on one. An antagonist can use this to her advantage by letting the Deviant have what he wants — or at least allowing him to think he has gotten it. Whether a hidden bulletproof vest wards away the deadly shot or she reacts to a glancing blow as though suffering a mortal wound, going down and then staying down can preserve her from the dreaded double-tap. This works best if the cohort doesn’t have the luxury of sticking around to check for a pulse, such as if there are a lot of armed goons still standing or if the environment is unstable or dangerous.
Surrender: When violence fails, and escape proves impossible, unexpected surrender can forestall death at Renegade hands. Deviants, although are not renowned for their mercy, need their Conviction Touchstones, and destroying one is most satisfying on the Remade’s terms. Many Broken entertain fantasies of revenge for years, and putting a hasty bullet in the back of their Progenitor’s head before the cops show up may seem insufficiently poetic. This tactic is a dangerous one. It can lead to a lengthy and painful imprisonment. However, a Linchpin with any amount of foresight has contingency plans to arrange for his rescue or extraction from enemy hands, assuming he has no discreet means of making good his escape when his captors’ backs are turned.
Optional Conspiracy Action: Improbable Escape
This uses the expanded conspiracy action rules from The Devoted Companion (p. 19).
The conspiracy uses one of its actions to preserve its agent in a scene from capture or death. It might already have a contingency in place, or it may quickly arrange an extraction after things take an unexpectedly bad turn — but before he is captured or killed. In action scenes, circumstances remove the target from the scene at the end of the turn following the turn in which the conspiracy used this action. In other kinds of scenes, this takes place within a few minutes. The Renegades know that the target escaped; there’s no confusion about whether he was killed.
Modifiers: The target escapes under circumstances that make it seem like he may have died, such as being on a ship when it sinks or inside a burning building when it collapses (–2). The target escapes after being captured but not while under guard (–2). The target miraculously survives an unambiguous death, whether because the victim was a decoy or the conspiracy was able to resuscitate him from the brink of death — as long as the cohort could not personally dispose of his body (–4). The target escapes the Renegades’ custody while under guard by someone other than a member of the cohort (–4). The target returns to the story despite the cohort burying, burning, or otherwise preventing the conspiracy from recovering his remains (–6). The target escapes the Renegades’ custody despite one or more of them guarding him at the time (–6). The conspiracy extracts or preserves twice as many of its agents (–2 per doubling). The conspiracy is calling upon Finesse instead of Power (–2).
Rescues typically take place during the chapter following the one in which the target is captured or the conspiracy takes the conspiracy action (whichever comes second). Resurrections typically occur during the next story. The conspiracy can suffer an additional penalty to restore a captured target to their service at the end of the next scene (–4), or resurrect an agent at the end of the next chapter (–4) or scene (–6).
Conviction Demise
The trouble with irresistible bait is that it tends to get eaten. In a typical Renegades-focused chronicle, Conviction Touchstones will and should die. A villain’s death doesn’t mean an end to his ability to cause trouble for the Remade:
No Body: A Conviction Touchstone whose demise is ambiguous may survive the fall, cave-in, explosion, or whatever other certain death scenario she found herself in to return with a story of how she survived and, in all probability, some mark from her experience. This could be scarring, a lost limb, or even Divergence, depending on the circumstances of her death. The apparent death of a Conviction Touchstone triggers the full benefits of destroying her (to do otherwise would give away the game). Should this happen, allow the Broken’s player to immediately replace another Touchstone with the resurrected one and without it first being Wavering, even if he has already designated a new Touchstone in the current chapter.
Resurrection: The Myriad Form (Clades Companion, p. 12) and certain Variations and Icons can bring the dead back to life. Or perhaps the conspiracy resuscitates the Conviction Touchstone by triggering the Divergence in him, bringing him back into their service as a cyborg, human-animal hybrid, or other mockery of life.
Decoy: The person the Deviant killed wasn’t really the Conviction Touchstone. Maybe it was a bodyguard disguised as the villain. Perhaps it was an innocent hostage imprisoned in a mechanized suit the antagonist was controlling remotely, speaking through it via a transmitted signal. Possibly, the Touchstone can jump bodies, and they simply vacate the one the cohort kills. Whatever the specifics, when the Remade turns the corpse on its back or pulls off the mask or otherwise attempts to confirm the identity of the deceased, he discovers that it is not his Conviction Touchstone after all.
The three twists above are common tropes in media. They have the advantage of permitting the thrill of defeating a recurring villain without losing the use of that character forever. Creating a compelling villain doesn’t happen every day, after all, and discarding one with whom an audience has a strong connection can seem wasteful. However, overuse of such twists in a roleplaying game is both trite and frustrating for the players.
As a general rule, resist the urge to bring back a dead villain more than once unless he has unusual resources that explain this capability — and be sure to make it clear what those are so that the cohort can take action to deprive him of it. They might defeat the AI that has a factory filled with android bodies by destroying that facility, for example, or by introducing malicious code that corrupts its backup and prevents it from leaving the body it currently occupies. That drives a story in a way that an endless parade of identical androids that betray no vulnerabilities doesn’t.
Retaliation: Agents of a conspiracy and pawns of supernatural societies serve important functions within those organizations. Many of these groups do not take the murder of their loyal servants lightly. Killing a Conviction Touchstone can draw down the conspiracy’s wrath upon the cohort as it redirects resources (Effort) that it would have invested in Projects into the capture or elimination of the Broken responsible.
Cycle of Violence: A Conviction Touchstone is a person and almost always has friends, family, or colleagues who care about him. Any of these might decide to investigate and avenge his untimely demise, which puts her on a collision course with the Deviants who did the deed. This can create moral complexities, particularly if the avenger is not the villain the Touchstone was. The conspiracy may draw this person into its orbit, making her its knowing or unwitting pawn in its quest to ensnare or kill the Remade. It can also humanize a deceased villain and reveal secrets or motives that were not made clear while he was alive.
Murder Investigation: Unattended dead bodies with marks of violence on them tend to attract the attention of law enforcement. Although a conspiracy will certainly do anything in its power to keep police away from the sites of violent confrontations between Renegades and its own agents, it may permit or even encourage the investigation of a murder that took place in the agent’s home or otherwise away from its facilities. Individual law enforcement officers are seldom a match for a cohort of Broken, but they can flush Deviants out of hiding or force them to temporarily suspend their actions against the conspiracy’s interests. After all, killing cops who get too close to solving a murder only serves to attract the attention of more cops with better resources.
Successor: Conspiracies fill vacancies in their ranks. If a Linchpin or other person in a key role meets an unexpected end, another will fill the power vacuum. This person may turn out to be even worse than their predecessor, especially as they probably know the fate she met.
Disappointment: The Conviction Touchstone’s death and the way the Remade dispensed it damage her relationship with a Loyalty Touchstone, her cohort, or someone else whose regard she values. Whether it’s a companion’s moral outrage at what amounted to cold-blooded murder, reflects his fear that he could be arrested and charged as an accessory, or disappointment at the clumsiness of her methodology, the act of killing an enemy can strain a relationship or traumatize those the Broken cares about.
Murder Most Awesome: Even in a horror game, not every Conviction Touchstone’s death needs to produce unexpected and unwanted consequences. Giving players the occasional cathartic, fist-pumping moment of standing over the cooling corpse of an unabashed and irredeemable villain no one will miss or mourn isn’t bad storytelling. If interspersed with the various twists above, it might actually make the players wonder what the Storyteller has up her sleeve this time.
Web of Pain
The conspiracies of the Web of Pain provide the most consistent source of external motivation for a cohort. Their surveillance is everywhere. They have a seemingly endless supply of agents. Their resources never run out unless the Renegades actively work to deplete them. Even the weakest are antagonists that can’t be defeated — much less destroyed — with a single bullet, act of arson, or explosion. In short, they are the most durable of recurring villains, so it is essential that the Storyteller make them fittingly compelling as enemies.
Construction
A conspiracy’s skeleton develops before the first chapter of the chronicle begins. Deviant includes a lengthy section on designing conspiracies (p. 217-235), and The Devoted Companion spends its longest chapter offering more detailed mechanics for Nodes, conspiracy actions, and Projects. This section instead focuses on storytelling techniques to maximize the impact of those systems and processes.
Cooperative Conspiracy Design
Deviant assumes that the players will take a role in the process of creating the conspiracy, ultimately shaping its Principles, Virtue, and Vice, as well as describing roughly half of its Nodes, Linchpins, and Icons. This is meant to increase the players’ investment in the chronicle, given how central the conspiracy is to its events. It also lightens the Storyteller’s chronicle planning burden somewhat and communicates the kind of collective enemy the troupe wants to face for the first few stories (if not the duration of the chronicle).
For a troupe that is used to such an open approach to the cooperative storytelling exercise at the root of all roleplaying games, this can be one of the most enjoyable parts of session zero. For those used to Storytellers keeping most such information secret from the players, however, it can feel awkward and counterintuitive. The following techniques can help:
Group Effort: Give each player a chance to define a Node and Linchpin, but if they can’t think of one, let the other players come up with a suitable one instead. Some very collaborative troupes will also prefer this approach, passing ideas back and forth with each player adding flourishes.
Reserve: If a player is stumped, let them save their Node and/or Linchpin to define later in the chronicle, preferably no later than the end of the first story. This works well with the optional Flashback mechanic (Shallow Graves, p. 167). Use a similar approach if the players are stumped on the conspiracy’s Principles, Virtue, and/or Vice. This applies to the Nodes, Linchpins, and Icons the Storyteller will define; it’s okay to leave some undefined elements and introduce them during play to fill a narrative or mechanical need.
Assigned: If the troupe prefers not to have such direct involvement in conspiracy building, the Storyteller can design each “player’s” Node and Linchpin. She then gives a summary of one Node and Linchpin to each player, which he can share or keep concealed from the rest of the cohort as circumstances and the character’s personality dictate.
Hidden: If the troupe really doesn’t want to help design the conspiracy, they don’t have to. It puts the cohort at an initial disadvantage since they won’t have built-in leads on where the conspiracy has assets and who oversees them.
Narrative Control and Dramatic Tension
Deviant offers players numerous opportunities to control the chronicle’s antagonists. They define many of the Nodes and Linchpins of the conspiracy pursuing them. By choosing Conviction Touchstones they are defining some of the chronicle’s key antagonists. And the optional Set the Stage rule lets them participate in conversations between antagonists that their characters have no way of knowing are happening. Shouldn’t all these things be secrets the Storyteller invents and reveals only when she’s ready?
This design decision adds horror to the chronicle by creating dramatic tension. The horror genre is filled with examples of the storyteller giving the audience information that the characters have — whether it’s as simple as knowing that this is a horror story (“don’t go up to the creepy attic to check out the weird noises!”) or as elaborate as, yes, a scene from the monster’s or villain’s point of view when the heroes aren’t around.
The players’ characters are the protagonists of the story, but the players are the audience. If they’re genre-conscious, knowing what horrors await their characters can make them more likely to walk into them, not less. The players can still be surprised because they don’t know exactly when or how events will unfold — only that the threat exists.
As an added benefit, having some measure of control over the nature of the threats their characters will face can avoid unpleasant situations where the player is shocked rather than their character — and not in a fun way. For example, maybe a player suggests that one Node is a network of foster homes that allow the conspiracy to perform experiments on children. If another player is not comfortable with that topic, shutting it down while it’s still in a purely hypothetical state will be easier narratively than waiting until the Storyteller has spent months building up to such a revelation without knowing that such a topic would cross one of the players’ lines.
Objectives
Consider the conspiracy’s goals. To some extent, its Principles, Virtue, and Vice describe this, but flesh them out. Is the conspiracy primarily motivated by monetary gain, the advancement of science, religious zeal, or something else entirely? How did it learn of the Divergence or the Remade as a whole? Does it only recognize the potential of the Renegades it pursues, or does it see the big picture potential of creating more Deviants?
Remember also that a conspiracy is a collective antagonist made up of many individuals, the vast majority of whom are Baselines. What draws these agents into the conspiracy’s service and how does it prevent them from leaving, blowing the whistle on its atrocities, or defecting to its rivals? Traditional spycraft holds that there are four main levers by which a person may be controlled, often referred to by the mnemonic MICE:
Money: The conspiracy pays well or has good benefits the agent wouldn’t otherwise enjoy. Six-figure salaries and a great retirement plan are the obvious examples, but this can also include medical care not available anywhere else — such as treatment for an otherwise incurable disability or life-threatening illness, or a means by which a Devoted can manage his Scars. Conspiracy agents motivated by money can often be persuaded to betray or leave the conspiracy if a competitor offers them more, unless their current employer has other leverage.
Ideology: The conspiracy embodies or allows the agent to pursue her ideals more readily. The agent might be a true believer in its Principles. Possibly, it protects her from the consequences of acting on an ideology that would otherwise bring down legal or social disapproval, such as if it has local police under its control so that she can engage in indiscretions that would otherwise put her in jail. In some cases, the conspiracy expresses sympathy for victims of persecution and gives them shelter against the real or perceived abuse they suffer from their government, religious leaders, or society at large. Turning an agent who is motivated by ideology is difficult. Zealots given proof that the conspiracy is not as ideologically pure as it claimed to be might reconsider their loyalties, but oftentimes the conspiracy can lure them back with contrary evidence or promises to reform. Agents who rely on the protection of the conspiracy may turn against it if it fails to provide the promised protection when it’s needed.
Coercion/Compromise: The conspiracy controls the agent through blackmail or threats. These can concern him directly (such as an ankle monitor that delivers a painful electric shock if he leaves his assigned conspiracy facility, or threats to send compromising photos of him with a lover to his spouse) or be pointed at people, things, or institutions he cares about (whether they’re literal hostages or something like the loss of funding for a charity that is utterly dependent on the conspiracy’s donations). An agent controlled through coercion alone is usually the least loyal. If he can be freed from the shackles that bind him to the conspiracy, he’ll often gleefully betray it. For this reason, unless they have reliable supernatural means of enforcing it, most conspiracies don’t rely on coercion exclusively. It’s best used to motivate expendable or otherwise short-term assets.
Ego/Excitement: The conspiracy controls the agent by appealing to her emotional vulnerabilities. She may have a false sense of her own importance, a thirst for vengeance, a desire for excitement, or a need for praise. The conspiracy feeds this need through a combination of love bombing, enabling her worst impulses, and encouraging her to cut ties with anyone outside of the conspiracy (because they clearly don’t respect her as much as the conspiracy does). This is a common tool for cults and abusers alike. Not only does it use the target’s own weaknesses against her, but it also conveniently isolates her from those she might turn to in order to escape the situation once it becomes intolerable. Taken together, breaking this type of control can be almost impossible unless the agent already wants to escape it.
Ideally, a conspiracy exerts control along multiple vectors so that the sudden elimination of one of its levers doesn’t overcome the power of the others.
Traits
Conspiracy traits imply the means they use to achieve their goals. Attributes express whether they are prone to direct action (Power) or working through intermediaries (Finesse), or whether they’re primarily endurance predators (Resistance). Nodes and their arrangement reinforce these preferences. Temporal Nodes command knowing agents, while Exploitative ones rely on catspaws. Structural Nodes connect the conspiracy with the larger Web of Pain (Deviant, p. 226). Hierarchical Nodes represent the conspiracy’s center (or centers) of power.
As representations of its institutional “superpowers”, Icons convey the conspiracy’s most remarkable advantages. They range from benefits that improve the mundane abilities of its agents to terrifying and obviously supernatural effects. Onachus’s Location Isolator (Deviant, p. 258) makes it exceptionally difficult to hide from the conspiracy, for example, while The Society for Cultural Preservation’s Healing Pools (Deviant, p. 265) make it almost certain that its most favored agents won’t stay dead for long. These capabilities shape the cohort’s interactions with the conspiracy and give them clear obstacles that they must either compensate for or target for destruction. The Devoted Companion provides more detailed systems for designing Icons.
Privileges (The Devoted Companion, p. 23) enhance the actions of other Nodes and reflect preferred conspiracy actions. A conspiracy that is heavily invested in Privileges that improve its ability to send in more and better-equipped agents to further its goal is very different from one with Privileges that sabotage its enemies’ resources.
Appetites
Finally, consider what the conspiracy wants from the Renegades. Be aware that while the conspiracy may want one thing from the Deviants, it’s very likely that individual Linchpins and other important figures within the conspiracy have (and pursue) their own designs for the Remade.
Service: This tends to be the default response. The conspiracy wants the Deviants to join the ranks of its Devoted and will take any reasonable steps to secure their cooperation. Unfortunately, “reasonable steps” for the conspiracies of the Web of Pain encompass blackmail, coercion through threats of violence, hostage-taking, abduction, and brainwashing.
Sale: The conspiracy sells the Remade it captures to other conspiracies. It may take out contracts or turn them in for bounties, or it might sell them to the highest bidder to do with what they please.
Containment: The conspiracy regards the Broken as a threat not just to its own interests but to a larger social order — or even to all of humanity. Its intent is to safely contain the Deviants so that they can’t cause any damage or, failing that, to destroy them.
Intellectual Property: The conspiracy regards the Remade as its property and believes he should not be allowed to use his Variations except with its permission. Such a conspiracy can be quite reasonable if it remains convinced that the Broken is only wielding proprietary technology in accordance with contractual arrangements, although it often expects him to submit to continual close monitoring, if not unlimited access to his abilities when it requests that of him.
Indirect Weapon: The conspiracy manipulates the Deviant into attacking its enemies, often another conspiracy. If it reveals itself to the Renegades at all, it is as a friendly face warning them of worse conspiracies in the Web of Pain that they may want to destroy. Or it may frame the target conspiracy by setting the cohort on the trail and letting them follow it to the obvious conclusion. Perhaps it wishes to maintain some level of plausible deniability as it probes a rival for weaknesses. Maybe it earnestly believes that it is one of the “good” conspiracies that has taken it upon itself to eliminate some of the “bad” conspiracies of the Web of Pain. Possibly, it simply doesn’t want to dirty its hands or risk its own Devoted unnecessarily.
Controlled Opposition: The conspiracy has no real interest in capturing or destroying the Renegades. Rather, they allow the cohort to operate with relative freedom as a way of testing the loyalty of its other agents. The conspiracy monitors the cohort to determine which of its agents befriends or offers to help the Broken. Or it administers loyalty tests in the form of directives to abduct, seduce, or harm the Deviants’ Loyalty Touchstones. It quietly purges those who fail these tests, whether by executing them outright or marking them for the most dangerous duties (which often amounts to the same thing). Securing the cooperation of the Renegades isn’t the goal, although the conspiracy agents are meant to think it is.
Field Experiments: The conspiracy has determined that the laboratory is a wholly inadequate venue for studying the Divergence. Test subjects who know they are test subjects — especially if they were unwilling recipients of their Variations — are likely to hold back. Only by providing Renegades with the illusion of freedom, coupled with threats to that freedom that they can rage against, can the conspiracy unlock the full potential of the Remade. In this scenario, the conspiracy doesn’t really want the Deviants’ cooperation. Rather, it wants the Broken to face trials and challenges that will force them to fully explore what they’re capable of so that the conspiracy can document every technique and adaptation that emerges from the interplay. Disposable agents are sent with orders to capture or kill the Renegades, but the conspiracy never sends enough of them nor provides the kinds of equipment needed to accomplish this nominal goal, and should a group of agents get lucky and seem on the point of achieving the objective, the conspiracy will call them off to prevent the Remade from suffering any permanent damage.
Instability: The conspiracy is interested in the phenomenon of Instability. It seeks to deny the Broken opportunities to regain their equilibrium. Perhaps it doesn’t know about End Stage and has no idea how dangerous a game it’s playing, or perhaps it’s fully aware of this but believes her death from Instability will benefit it in some way.
Death: The conspiracy wants the Renegades dead or, at best, permanently out of its proverbial hair. This should be a rare situation and not one a Storyteller introduces lightly. Even a small conspiracy, if single-minded in its mission to kill the cohort, will almost certainly succeed, which can make for a bummer of a chronicle ending. It works better if the conspiracy with such a goal is a secondary one, rather than the main antagonist of the chronicle. Or if it rarely expends its resources on this goal, whether because it invests most of its Effort on Projects that are more likely to bear lasting fruit or because it has so many enemies that it’s forced to focus its killing power on only the largest threats it currently faces.
Action Economics
A conspiracy’s actions flow from its objectives. One focused on creating more Remade spends its Effort very differently than one developing new Icons or one engaged in a bloody shadow war with a rival conspiracy. While pressing the Renegades is probably on the priority list somewhere, it often isn’t at the top of it.
This assumption is partially an acknowledgment that a conspiracy that always spends all its actions on messing with the cohort can make for a chronicle that gives very little breathing room for exploring characters and intracohort dynamics. It also recognizes that the conspiracy is meant to be a looming threat. Players come to expect occasional run-ins with conspiracy agents, such that when they suddenly stop, they start to get nervous because it means the conspiracy is investing all the Effort it’s saving on something out of the Renegades’ view. And when that mysterious Project reaches its completion, it’s going to be bad news for the cohort. After one or two such surprise reveals, any peace and quiet will likely send the Renegades into research and attack mode; not only does disrupting such a Project mean the conspiracy doesn’t become an even greater threat, but it can also wipe out several chapters’ worth of accrued Effort at once without leaving the conspiracy anything to show for it. Dividing a conspiracy’s resources between the short-term hits of conspiracy actions and the slow build of Projects can set up a dynamic of constant harassment punctuated by occasional desperate (and not always successful) operations to stop the conspiracy from gaining a new advantage.
The Devoted Companion includes expanded rules and extensive examples of conspiracy actions.
Bait
Conspiracy actions and Projects have mechanics, but both primarily exist to draw the players’ characters into stories involving the conspiracy. Here are some ways to do that:
Loyalty: Targeting the cohort’s Loyalty Touchstones is a surefire way to get the Renegades involved in a story. While abduction and threats are the first approaches that come to mind, don’t underestimate the dramatic potential of unexpected gestures of friendship. Sending agents to befriend, seduce, or turn the Deviant’s friends against her can be a very effective way to hurt a Renegade.
Conviction: The appearance or involvement of a Conviction Touchstone forces the Broken’s hand. They can’t help but act. To do otherwise means Faltering. Putting Conviction Touchstones in charge of essential conspiracy activities because they are competent certainly makes sense but dangling them in front of the Remade to distract the cohort from higher priority Projects or using them to bait an obvious trap can be an even more effective use of these resources.
Raids: Conspiracies have more resources at their disposal than Renegades do. They can afford the occasional probing strike to achieve some nominal objective, even if it’s a low-priority one and the action fails to achieve it. If the cohort has spent a couple of chapters ignoring the conspiracy, a sudden attack on them or their interests can shake things up and remind them that the conspiracy is not the kind of enemy they can safely ignore. The addition of a few entirely expendable Devoted to these groups can likewise hint that the conspiracy is actively recruiting or creating Deviants and spur the cohort to target these efforts for dismantlement.
Taunts: The conspiracy creates complications for the cohort. Not only does this deny the Renegades access to already scarce resources, but it also serves as a reminder that the conspiracy is a constant threat. Because the conspiracy can only properly wield such effects when it successfully surveils a target, these taunts also put the Deviants on notice that the conspiracy has them in its sights and can attack them whenever it wishes. That knowledge in itself can prompt a cohort to act before it is fully ready to do so.
Disinformation: The conspiracy finds a way to deliver false intelligence to the cohort. If the Renegades have a history of capturing agents and interrogating them, the conspiracy might brief the agent on a fabricated conspiracy goal and give the Remade an opportunity to capture her. If the conspiracy can’t locate the Broken, it might publish a news article, send out a press release, or update its website to talk up a new project (whether real or fabricated) to tempt the Renegades to come out of hiding to disrupt it. The purpose of this might be to bait a trap, but it could just as easily be a way to trick the cohort into revealing their whereabouts.
Stochastic Surveillance: A conspiracy attempting to flush out an elusive group of Remade engages the unwitting assistance of Baselines. It might set up a social media contest with a prize awarded to anyone who manages to get a selfie with one of the Renegades, for example, or it could submit a missing persons report to engage law enforcement and citizens alike in its search. Appearing on the nightly news is upsetting enough for most Broken, but even more so if they’ve been framed for a robbery or shooting spree. This is even more likely to draw the cohort out of hiding if they’re being blamed for the actions of the conspiracy or if the conspiracy is using the consequences of the Deviants’ actions to generate public sympathy.
Calling Card: The conspiracy’s agents leave a mark the Remade are intended to recognize. It might be conspiracy iconography showing up in graffiti all over town, for example, or a symbol branded onto the foreheads of the victims of a string of atrocious murders. Although these attract public attention, they’re not easily traced back to the conspiracy, but the Renegades are meant to see these as either a taunt or a hint at the conspiracy’s next move. It’s a way to flush them out of hiding.
Projects: If the conspiracy doesn’t have a good bead on the Deviants, and they haven’t made trouble for it lately, it quietly advances its other goals. It invests in Projects or engages in conflicts (or builds alliances) with rivals in the Web of Pain.
Alliances: The conspiracy allies with or hires another conspiracy. This could be anything from a joint effort to hunt down the Renegades that have been plaguing them to merger talks. Regardless, this should set off alarm bells for any Remade who regard either conspiracy as an enemy. One faceless organization with too many resources gunning for them is bad enough.
War: The conspiracy goes to war against a rival conspiracy. This might be a matter of self-defense or reflect the conspiracy’s acquisitive nature. War consumes a lot of resources, leaving the conspiracy fewer assets to devote to Projects or the pursuit of rogue Broken. A cohort could pick a worse time for an attack. In some cases, however, the war is staged to create an illusion of weakness where one doesn’t exist and so draw out the conspiracy’s traitors, false friends in the Web of Pain, and enterprising Renegades looking to take advantage of the situation.
Projects
Most conspiracies invest the majority of their actions into generating Effort to further Projects. Troupes with access to The Devoted Companion will find expanded mechanics for and examples of common Projects a conspiracy may undertake, so this section will discuss less what they can do and instead focus on why they might do it.
Conspiracy Projects normally take multiple chapters to come to fruition, which gives the Renegades an opportunity to disrupt them. Alert Remade can often spot warning signs of a Project in progress long before their enemies complete it. This allows a Storyteller to use an impending Project as a plot device to drive players to act on the information they stumble onto and quickly confirm.
Optional Rule: Setbacks
While destroying the Node connected to a Project is a surefire way to disrupt it, attacks on supply lines can often set it back and delay its completion. The Renegades might liberate a shipment of unwilling recruits, for example, or break up a gun-smuggling ring that was supplying weapons to the conspiracy.
Any Renegade attack on a Node, Linchpin, or Project counts as a conspiracy action against the conspiracy’s per-chapter limit. Under this rule, however, an operation that successfully disrupts the flow of personnel and materiel necessary for a Project also prevents the conspiracy from advancing that Project at all.
The conspiracy cannot invest Effort in the targeted Project at the end of the current chapter or the next one. The Accelerate Project action (The Devoted Companion, p. 20) cannot be used to hasten such a Project.
Devoted Army: The conspiracy recruits or creates as many new Devoted as it can, focusing on quantity over quality. As these often rely on known methodologies and use existing Devoted as models (but mostly because it’s easier for the Storyteller), they usually have identical or substantively similar Scars and Variations. In most cases, they are inferior to (have less Variation Magnitude than) the Renegades. These Devoted add complexity to scenes involving them, whether they’re veritable tanks in a fight or invisible lurkers seemingly spying on the Renegades’ every move.
Warning Signs: A sudden uptick in disappearances of local Deviants (if recruiting Devoted) or Baselines (if creating them). The conspiracy puts out a large number of vague “help wanted” ads, becomes more active on recruitment sites, and otherwise makes it clear that they’re actively hiring pretty much anyone who might be interested. The conspiracy hires human traffickers to meet their need for workers. The conspiracy purchases a large quantity of materials and equipment necessary to trigger the Divergence according to its preferred methodology.
Countermeasure Devoted: Having seen the Deviants’ Variations in action on multiple occasions and finding it has no good way to address them, the conspiracy takes pains to develop or recruit Devoted who can. These might possess Variations that are twins to the Renegades’ (with a few twists), with the assumption that the abilities the Broken have at their disposal are also the ones that can negate their advantage. The Devoted might instead be specially designed to be resistant to the Renegades’ abilities and favored tactics or to take aim at their Scars. Even one such Devoted can be frightening, with the mere implication that the conspiracy is developing an antidote to the Renegades likely to spur either caution or action. A confrontation with an entire anti-cohort can be climactic, but overuse of these (or the existence of multiple anti-cohorts) can instead frustrate the players and strain credulity; after all, if the conspiracy can create Devoted with the same capabilities as the Renegades, why is it still pursuing the Renegades?
Warning Signs: Conspiracy agents seem suddenly intent upon recording the Renegades’ abilities, bringing cameras and specialized scanners to each skirmish and fleeing the scene when they have the information they’re looking for. Conspiracy agents dig through the cohort’s refuse or steal hair, blood, and tissue samples from the Remade. The conspiracy sends a disposable prototype anti-Renegade against the Broken to see what works and where the design could use improvement.
New Icon: The conspiracy seeks out or develops a new Icon. These are among the most potent (and most expensive in terms of Effort) tools at a conspiracy’s disposal, so rumor that another one will be coming online makes for a useful plot device.
Warning Signs: Conspiracy agents depart for a far-off and remote destination (or return from it with a mysterious and heavily guarded package destined for a conspiracy facility). The conspiracy puts out a press release announcing the development of a miracle cure or invention that hints the capabilities of the planned Icon. Conspiracy agents convene at the site of a recently unearthed ruin or new occult anomaly, which becomes the object of their study or the focal point of a grand ritual.
Activate Icon: Some Icons take time to “charge” before they unleash their full effects. Many of these have powerful narrative effects, such as causing natural disasters (Deviant, p. 259) or unleashing a nebulously awful worldwide catastrophe (Deviant, p. 268). As with new Icons, disrupting these events often has a high priority among Renegades.
Warning Signs: The area near the related Node experiences power fluctuations, brown/blackouts, or energy surges. Animals, occult beings, and supernaturally aware people flee the area, seek shelter, or rant about the end times on street corners.
New Node/Attribute/Privilege: The conspiracy establishes a new Node or seizes control of one created by a rival (and possibly defunct) conspiracy. Or else it increases an Attribute or develops a new Privilege (The Devoted Companion, p. 23). Although usually not as alarming as a new Icon, these represent an expansion of the conspiracy’s power and influence. Physical strikes can delay the construction of a Node, while attacks on the conspiracy’s reputation or finances are often the best way to frustrate its Attribute/Privilege ambitions.
Warning Signs: The conspiracy breaks ground on the construction of a new facility or purchases/leases an existing one. The conspiracy is mentioned in business news as a red-hot investment or exciting new company; if it is a cult, its adherents show up in the news and are given a platform to explain their beliefs to a wider audience. The conspiracy hires consultants, announces a partnership with local politicians (or whatever group it is incorporating into its organization), or conducts an unusually large number of initiation and investiture ceremonies to welcome new members and promote existing members to positions of leadership.
Rebuild: Following attacks on its interests or other sources of institutional attrition, the conspiracy takes measures to retain its existing agents, fill organizational gaps, and recruit new talent. Mechanically, this downgrades or heals damage to its Association. As hard as it is to hurt a conspiracy, Renegade cohorts don’t like to see their enemies recover and will often take steps to thwart that process.
Warning Signs: The conspiracy offers retention, recruitment, and hiring bonuses or offers more generous benefits. The conspiracy organizes a mandatory team-building retreat to raise the morale of its agents. Cult faith leaders mingle with rank-and-file agents or lead grand ceremonies to express their appreciation. A non-profit conspiracy fundraises off public sympathy generated by its recent misfortunes.
In addition to the specific Projects above, conspiracies sometimes engage in novel tactics when investing their Effort:
Reserve Projects: If given a free hand, the conspiracy queues up one or more Projects it expects to need to complete in a hurry at some future date but leaves them just short of the needed Effort. These give them options when dealing with an anticipated crisis, such as damage to Association (which it quickly downgrades and heals) or the destruction of a Node or Icon (which it promptly replaces). It can also serve as a way to force some action (or inaction) from the Renegades, such as if the conspiracy can reasonably threaten to activate a powerful Icon or unleash dozens of Manticores and/or Devoted.
Hard Burn: Sometimes if a conspiracy finds itself in a desperate position or wants to convince its enemies that it has more resources at its disposal than expected, it will accept significant lethal damage to its Association to take more than its usual allotment of conspiracy actions, invest large amounts of Effort into a Project that would have otherwise required several chapters to complete, or both. This is usually a bad long-term strategy, although even otherwise rational actors may adopt it as a last resort if the conspiracy faces an existential threat (such as an attack against a Hierarchical Node). Narratively, conspiracy agents are forced to work extra shifts and ignore safety protocols, which moves objectives to completion more quickly but results in more casualties and turnover among agents than it suffers in less extreme circumstances.
Purge: Sometimes a conspiracy doesn’t have time to rebuild itself through Projects, or it’s suffered so much damage to its Association that the cost of doing so is prohibitive. The conspiracy engages in a purge (Deviant, p. 234) to clear the damage to its Association or perform one last act in the furtherance of its Principles before it dissolves entirely.
Spinoffs: Some large conspiracies create spinoff conspiracies to accomplish specialized tasks while permitting the parent conspiracy a degree of plausible deniability. A spinoff might pretend to be opposed to its parent in order to approach and forge alliances with enemies (including the Renegades), for example, or it might serve as a target for its enemies’ hostility that doesn’t endanger the parent organization. The process of building such a subsidiary is similar to creating a new conspiracy (The Devoted Companion, p. 39), but the parent conspiracy can invest Effort directly or sever some of its Nodes for the subsidiary to assimilate. This follows the rules for playing with multiple conspiracies (Deviant, p. 226), with the spinoff usually becoming the active conspiracy, while its parent gradually accumulates (and spends) Effort as an inactive conspiracy.
Other Motivations
Touchstones and the Web of Pain provide obvious, readymade sources of motivation for Renegade cohorts, but they’re not the only plot hooks that can drive them. These are not mechanically reinforced to the same degree as Touchstones or the conspiracy. Whether a cohort takes the bait greatly depends on whether the players and characters are interested in the story it presents and whether circumstances give the Renegades very little option to ignore it.
Survival: The Deviants struggle to secure the basics of life — food, water, clothing, and shelter against the elements. This can mean needing to survive a trek across the wilderness or the aftermath of a natural disaster (or plane crash) or living homeless and broke on a city’s streets.
Resource Acquisition: The Remade find they need a resource they can’t easily get. It might be a chemical compound one of them needs to recharge her powers, no-questions-asked medical care, or just a reliable car with enough seats for the whole cohort.
Legal Entanglements: The Broken have committed (or been framed for) a crime that law enforcement is investigating. If they’re not yet suspects, the goal might be to ensure that the trail of evidence leads away from them or, better still, towards one of their enemies. If they’re already in the investigators’ sights, eluding pursuit becomes the priority. Even the best-equipped cohort seldom has the firepower to annihilate entire police forces, and attempting to do so only escalates matters, as first SWAT teams and then military personnel respond to the threat.
Mentor: Renegades tend not to remain alive and free for long, but those who do often accumulate a wealth of knowledge about the Deviant condition and a mastery of their abilities that can be valuable to less experienced Remade. The cohort seeks out one of these elusive mentors.
Background Exploration: Many Broken have mysteries in their backgrounds, skeletons in their closets, or just loose ends that are unrelated to the Web of Pain or their Touchstones. Whether it’s finding out the truth about their birth parents, rescuing her pet cat from the house they know the conspiracy is probably watching, or checking in on how the kids at the elementary school where the Deviant once taught have been coping with her sudden disappearance, these can flesh out a character’s pre-Divergence history and personality — often as a way to juxtapose it with her life as a Renegade.
Vacation: Although evading and attacking the conspiracy rarely leaves a lot of time or money to spare on lengthy vacations to exotic destinations, even Renegades can appreciate the occasional break to enjoy the sorts of pleasures they took for granted back when they had 9-to-5 jobs. It could be a trip to the beach with the cohort (and possibly a couple of Loyalty Touchstones), a camping expedition, or just a visit to a favorite local museum. These provide opportunities for Renegades to get to know each other better and to explore the personalities of the Remade apart from their opposition to the conspiracy and their Conviction Touchstones.
Instability and Distractions
As focused as they are on their Touchstones — to the point where failing to advance those can have lethal consequences — it may seem difficult to imagine a cohort of Renegades taking a vacation for any length of time. Here are some reasons why they might engage in pursuits not related to their Touchstones:
They have no choice. No matter how little animosity the Deviant may feel towards the local kingpin, the mobster isn’t going to back down. Being shipwrecked on a deserted island may never have been the plan, but that’s the circumstance the Remade finds herself in. Sometimes, misfortunes put meat-and-blood survival first and foremost above maintaining Stability.
Their Touchstones are there. There’s usually no reason why a Broken can’t invite a Loyalty Touchstone along on a riverboat cruise, and sometimes circumstances throw Deviant and Conviction Touchstone into a situation where they must work together to survive. A plot not driven by Touchstones or the Web of Pain can still involve them.
It creates tension. A short story built around a situation that prevents the Renegades from advancing their Touchstones creates conflict. It encourages them to solve the unwanted crisis quickly, but not always optimally, which often leads to future problems.
It’s measured in chapters. A weeklong chapter spent dealing with mutant bears while camping is no worse for a Deviant’s Instability than spending an entire chapter engaged in a lengthy shootout with a crime lord’s goons, even if the shootout only takes minutes of time in-world. Depending on whether the Remade had a chance to advance a Touchstone before the camping trip and how quickly he’s able to return to advance a Touchstone afterward (either of these things potentially falling within the same chapter), he might be able to avoid the additional Instability entirely.
It’s not a quick, sure death. The drip of Instability due to missing an interaction with a Touchstone is one minor Instability per chapter. While not a problem that can be ignored chapter after chapter, the damage caused by a single chapter can be reversed by advancing any Touchstone at least once during the next session. Choosing a course of action that won’t advance a Touchstone is a calculated risk, but it may be a negligible one for Remade who have largely kept their Instability under control.
Criminal Entanglements: Renegades are often on the wrong side of the law, and people on the wrong side of the law rarely enjoy the protection of law enforcement. As well, conspiracies of the Web of Pain regularly corrupt police departments to suborn their resources, so even Broken not currently on the lam regard cops with deep suspicion. If they’re targeted by others who are on the outs with the law — whether it’s burglars and carjackers or armed robbers and loan sharks — Broken are often forced to face the problems on their own.
Recruitment: Renegades are hopelessly outnumbered by the agents of the Web of Pain, but some Deviants aren’t content to let that remain the case. Whether by rescuing imprisoned Remade or turning Devoted against their masters, the cohort expands its circle of influence to encompass additional Broken. This could be a network of allied Renegade cohorts, the favor of Devoted who serve conspiracies opposed to the one the Deviants fight, or even the foundation of a new conspiracy.
Mysteries: Sometimes a cohort’s curiosity leads it to delve into mysteries that have no obvious connection to the Web of Pain. A Loyalty Touchstone’s relative might ask them to investigate a murder or theft, for example, or they might encounter a strange wolfman and become interested in its nature and origin. In other cases, the Renegades might seek an understanding of the Divergence beyond what the conspiracy has learned, possibly hoping to reverse their transformation.
Odd Jobs: Whether for money or as part of an exchange of favors, the Remade perform requested services for another party. This can be fellow Renegades, agents of the conspiracy’s rival, unrelated supernatural creatures, or anyone else with a need the Broken can meet and the money (or other acceptable currencies or commodities) these freelancers demand.
Occult Beings: Deviants aren’t the only supernatural creatures out there. Sorcerers, ghosts, monster hunters, and stranger things have their own societies and capabilities. Some Renegades befriend these creatures, while others run afoul of them. It isn’t unknown for Remade to find themselves embroiled in complex political conflicts or outright hidden wars between factions of these mysterious societies, although this can draw them into dangerously unstable situations.