Miya Travel Palette Unbox & Swatch- Student Grade Showdown & Art Supply Redemption? (Patreon)
Content
This is an early access video! I'm still working on populating the description with links, so for the full experience, check back when this has gone live on Youtube!
Comparable Palettes:
Travel:
Cotman
Amy Tangerine
Superior Fan
Superior Collapsable cup
Superior Watercolor Watch:
Paul Rubens pocket
Other Student Grade:
Phoenix Watercolors:
Meiliang Watercolors:
Superior Watercolors:
Shownotes:
MIYA travel palette
The packaging:
Shrink wrapped
Cardboard box
Plastic lid
Inside is palette and waterbrush
Plastic liner with flocking
Inside:
Watercolor paper packet
Watercolor palette
The palette itself is kind of unusual- it's like a metal and plastic sandwich. I assume this is to cut down on size and weight?
Swatching:
Given my experience with MIYA, I am not going to preactivate. Actually, these really NEED preactivation; they're really stiff
Loosen up a lot with preactivation, maybe too much?
I don't really like the provided watercup, it feels unstable, but then, I guess you're not forced to use it AS a water cup? Could be a brush holder.
Some small issues (weird activation) but actually kinda promising so far? But so was the Miya Diamond palette, so obviously, further testing is needed
While most of the colors seem finely milled, maybe even dye based, there are a couple colors (blue, sepia, black) that granulate quite a bit. This could be the natural pigments or the binder, or the extender; hard to tell at this stage.
None of the colors, including the white, have much opacity.
Lift Test:
Varying degrees of lifting and staining, but there's an obvious median ground that most hit
Color Mixing:
Decent selection of colors in this 18 color set. Reasonably easy to find your primaries, with a few of the more difficult to achieve colors (purple, indigo, a spring green, a viridian) thrown in. Paints seem like they'd get used up quickly, and these are extruded chicklets of paint rather than poured pans.
Optical:
These colors seem to glaze, although there are some harsh edges on some of the colors (the yellows)
Atomic:
Mixing colors is easy and fairly straightforward. While wet, mixes appear very vibrant but dull a bit as they dry. This is pretty normal with student-grade watercolors, but when combined with a cellulose paper, the effect will be very pronounced. There isn't a lot of mixing surface, but there was enough for what I needed and probably enough for a travel set. You may wish to bring an additional palette
Wet into Wet:
Wet into wet, these behaved better than I expected; the colors actually moved and intermixed and granulated, which they did NOT do when I fieldtested the original Miya palette.
Testing out the pack ins
Paper is interesting, probably not a cottonrag, but handles the paints well and even forces some granulation. The waterbrush is small and similar to a Pentel Aquash, and I find it challenging to control the amount of water.
These paints get used up fast.
Does Miya See Redemption?
It's really hard to tell right now. I thought these might be different from the Diamond palette I reviewed last year, but I see many similarities that concern me.
Pros and Cons:
Cons:
Well apparently, it's not available on Amazon, although the MIYA website shows it (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08F53J5PV/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1)
Seems very similar to the Diamond set, and while that set also seemed promising, it sorta fell apart during the field test
Kinda lean for a travel watercolor set
Kinda large for a travel watercolor set
Just sorta meh? HIMI is known for their jelly gouache, but their watercolors aren't really innovative
Seem to get used up fast
Pros:
Colors are bright and vibrant
Offer some granulation
Good selection of colors
Verdict:
Ehhhhhh. It's not a bad palette, but other palettes are doing more with less, and it's just not that interesting.
Music:
Sunny Travel- Nico Staf
Tranquility- Kevin MacLeod
The Story of One Life
Inner Light- Kevin MacLeod
Angevin 70- Kevin MacLeod
Sunset Dream-Cheel