Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey everyone!

In this one, we only have one thing: a report from 404 Media on the issues at Proton, their CEO's behavior, and their massive push for everyone to use AI for everything. Not a good look, IMO, here's the link:

https://www.404media.co/manifestos-fear-and-loser-thinking-inside-protons-ai-reckoning/

Files

Comments

phoebe headkittens

Proton always was one of those companies where you could say the CEO wasn't great, but the product was sound in ideal, if not application. It was only last year that guy's LLM deleted his production database or something, and that was before these models went for "hacking" as a goto. It got them a lot of free press, I wouldn't be surprised if that was intentional. The Australian government has always fallen for jangling keys like that. It's been so long since I started using Proton, i'll start looking into alternatives, maybe I can make moves to drop Gmail at the same time too.

JF002

As a Visionary subscriber, I find these reports very... troubling, to say the least. I thought only big US corporations would be crazy enough to think AI could fix all their internal issues and send their productivity through the roof. But we've only got one side of the story, those reports from 404 Media (I'm not sure how reliable they are, I don't know them). The other side is missing: the official answer from Proton as a company, Andy Yen's point of view, feedback from other employees… Are we entitled to any of it? Probably not, and realistically, some of it we'll simply never get. Also, we don't know whether these reports are true, or how much context is missing from them. I'm not trying to ignore what's happening right now, I'm not claiming any of this is false. But I'm simply saying that we should wait until we know more before forming an opinion on this matter. And yeah, if you hear back from your contact at Proton, feel free to let us know ;-)

Clint Eschberger

The fact that he often criticizes other companies using AI. Yeah, he has full-blown AI pchyscosis.

Eric Flores

Its sounds like Proton needs a new CEO. He is scrambling to save his job by bullying.

Steve C

It's weird watching this psychosis taking over one young male brain at a time. Note that I'm male, but it does seem to be somewhat gender-specific. I don't get it. I'm a control freak. So I don't want to give up control to some randomized circuits. It's particularly disappointing with Proton. I use their VPN, and hoped to eventually replace Gmail with Proton Mail. It ain't happening now, unless there's a change of management and strategy.

Quidam

If true, the way they handled it is terrible, however, this is nothing new. In the 80's, the company I worked for transformed to computers and CNC. It was all manual before that. Do you think anyone was told, if you want to stay with pen and paper you may do so? Nick, before you say it's not the same... it is! LOL.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

It isn’t ;) Moving to CNC and computers wasn’t done in mass content theft, using enormous amounts of energy and potentially ruining an entire generation economically ;) you could learn to use a computer or a cnc machine, an AI fully replaces you, at a much faster pace ;)

Quidam

It's on the internet, it's got to be true. Well said. Any "news" reports that don't investigate the full story for both sides is not journalism, it's just click bait.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Which is why I said (and in the weekly news video too), that I’ll wait for an official answer before taking any action :)

Quidam

This is one report based on anonymous accounts and selected material. It's worth reading, but we don't have the full picture or supporting evidence from every side, and Proton's detailed technical response would help people judge the claims. Also, a lot of coverage today isn't neutral, it can be framed to tell a particular story, and that's how this piece reads to me.

UsernamesAreHard

It's very troubling when a business selling services built with encryption as number one feature, tells one of its security engineers they're "losers" for wanting to test the security of their apps thoroughly. The real loser mentality here is to trust Ai more than your engineers. I was ready to close my eyes on Proton's past controversies namely the CEO's opinion on US politics at the time and I was considering subscribing to proton pass because it seemed like a good product to use. But Proton always jumping from an app to another and releasing new products when their other products aren't completed was already making me question Proton's real motives. On one hand I can understand the push for AI to release more feature and more apps, but if this comes at the detriment of security, which will then trickle down to the detriment of privacy, then no thanks, I won't use those products. And if the CEO is this toxic to his employees to chase clout, then he clearly needs to fuck off.

Quidam

Yes, sadly you are one of the few. You can even see in this small chat group, people have taken the report as fact.

Quidam

They said exactly the same, when it was compared to the invention of the car.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Well, the memo is public, and 2 different websites reported on the same topic, so there is something. Whether it’s been deformed, that remains to be seen!

Nick - The Linux Experiment

And look where that led us? Destroyed environment, cities built for cars and not public transports, ugly cities full of parking lots, massive personal expenses for everyone because you now NEED a car. Not a change for the better, IMO.