Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey everyone!

This week, I talk about the Proton situation, why it looks so problematic to me, and potential sponsors I could find to replace them if it came to that, and on 13:09, I ramble about the current extremely divided state of the Linux / FOSS Community that makes every topic a minefield, especially if you try to have a half balanced approach.

Let me know what you think!

Comments

Linus Söderlind

As you already have a domain switch your mail to that and you do not have do the mail switch on all accounts. You still have to switch vpn, storage and so on but you at least own your own address.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah,I already have en email address there, but I liked separating the channel stuff from the personal, with 2 different ones. I guess I'll just setup a transfer from Proton to that address and bit by bit, change the mail for each account, at least if Proton's answer isn't satisfactory.

JF002

On the Proton situation : there has been a lot of new communications this week-end (repsonse from Andy, messages from employees, posts from angry customers, etc). It's becoming really difficult to tell what's true from what's that false and to forge an opinion. It looks like most of it is just internal drama that shouldn't have been made public. So now, I'm mostly waiting for an official response from the company and see what actions they'll take to fix this situation. About your situation as a content creator: I can only imagine how daunting it is trying to keep the whole internet mob happy. I follow you not because I agree with your opinions. I follow you because you have your own opinions and values and because you express them even if you know that some of your audience won't agree with you. And more importantly because you allow those opinions to change and evolve with the time (and I know the internet does not like that!). I noticed that you take a lot of precautions, you repeat again and again the same disclaimers about those controversial topics. It must be time and energy consuming to have to think about them for each and every topic or project you mention in your posts and videos. To me, that's not needed, but I understand that you have to please a big part of your audience as part of your own business.

Pirate

Thought provoking ramble…. I am a ‘visionary’ proton user, and have previously been enrolled in some of their beta testing. Like you, if the reports are true, I am very concerned about what is occurring internally. I want the existing apps to be improved before trying to conquer the world. ie bitcoin wallet, who wants that shit? So like you, I will have to seriously consider migrating several domains and an organisation elsewhere. Btw - I think your approach to the use of PI (pretend intelligence) is very sensible and . Keep up the good work!

Nik

I have to do the same. The kicker for me, even with a custom domain email, is the proxy aliases I've integrated with SimpleLogin/Proton Pass. I'm completely unaware of a similar service with another privacy-oriented provider and I guess I'll have to implement a Catch All on that domain in the interim, which sucks to prevent spam. Screams into the void: "Why Proton, why?!"

Nik

Sorry that you get disrespectful comments regarding your political alignment, despite nuances with disclaimers. Keep powering through, you're doing a great job. Alongside signposting people to your Ethics page, there's probably a case for encouraging people to leave respectful comments somewhere in your videos. Granted, I realise this is a bit like telling a toddler not to press a big shiny red button.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, I'll wait for an official response too. Internal drama or not, if the statements are true, it still shows a CEO that is... not the nicest person to their employees either, and a shift in focus from security and quality towards speed, which is rough, IMO. We'll see, I hope I don't have to switch providers. Yeah, it's hard to keep a balanced viewpoint (or at least a reasonable one, maybe?) and not get hateful messages. I just saw yet another comment that called me an AI hater from someone who said they'd look for news somewhere else, on the same video where I got a comment saying I'm an AI bootlicker now... In short: the internet :D

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, we won't change people on the internet, and I won't change my opinions to avoid backlash, I guess the community will curate itself as people who are annoyed by one position or another leave. The political alignment, I don't mind as much, it's fine: I'm vocal about what I like and what I don't, and people who fully disagree have left already, but the AI stuff is yet another minefield that is getting tiresome :D

Pieter van der Vegte

I can really understand why you're feeling pissed off, but it was kind of haha funny the way you spoke about it all. So, thanks. I enjoyed it 🙂 But, maybe I'm being too measured 🙃

phoebe headkittens

I pulled the trigger on my Proton subscription, fastmail is local to me and i can choose between the EU and United states for data storage, it's cheap and ethically they seem above board, no grand proclamations or anything, mind you. They did have a guide for moving from proton. it didn't have everything to 1:1 from them, but my mail is all backed up now, my domains redirected, any more trouble and i'm self-hosting. As for the commenters and AI, like, I was pretty steadfast anti, and I've shifted somewhat, I still want the bubble to burst and technology to be relatively affordable again. I wouldn't miss Nvidia the way their CEO is also complicit in this mess, but let's face it, they'll get some nothing fine and if we're lucky some regulatory action. I think we do forget that a lot of computer scientists bought into a bad ideal, that they could be the next bill gates or steve wozniak or what have you, then it shifted to 10x engineer and all that toxic work for free bullshit. These sorts of white collar jobs are so individualistic, so while teamwork is often required, they're often managed by HR normies or whatever. And yeah I guess in open source there's no filter because "it's not work" when yeah for a long time Linux was work, it did need that personal touch to be usable or something you could talk someone into. I think some of these people need to know shame, a healthy amount anyway, and rid themselves of the desire to control people. They'll be happier.

JF002

"hateful messages" That's tough and totally undeserved. It's indeed how the internet works these days : it's either black or white, with no nuance in-between. It's a shame and I honestly don't know how you are supposed to navigate through this!

JF002

"a shift in focus from security and quality towards speed". Did they really? In a post on reddit (https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xjo8d4/a_message_to_the_community/), Andy said "our use of AI will never be at the expense of security. [...] We also leverage AI to find vulnerabilities in our own code before attackers do." Again, I don't know what's true and what's corporate PR, but he also said that they would communicate more about their use of AI, how they code/security review, etc. So, wait and see ;-)

Eric Flores

You hit it right on the nose. Humans do not write perfect code. I know this by experience. I started using AI to help me find bugs in my own personal projects and I am surprised at all the bad code I write.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, wait and see, that's the approach. Nice to see they answered, an official communication would have been better than a Reddit post, but at least this gives us an idea of what they do, and we can judge on the real results afterwards!

JF002

They are probably in panic mode right now, and will do proper communication when they are ready. Maybe they avoid communicating about the whole situation in case they would take some legal actions against the potential "leakers" (this term was mentioned by someone on reddit).

Ryan Richards

NGL, I swapped back to windows 7 and kind of just opted out of modern tech after learning the Linux kernel is going all in on AI. I still like your content, and will continue listening / subbing here, but I have humanist objections to AI. I'm ok being a Luddite.

Eara

Keep fighting the good fight. I’m all camp measured, even when it comes to Politics;). There are more out there!

Steve C

Unfortunately, in the current cultural environment, blinders are frequently useful. I definitely appreciate your measured approach, despite having strong opinions myself. But even as an AI-hater (or strong disliker) I still find it useful in limited ways, and can rationalize some sort of balanced usage. The Linux community has always had its sharp edges, but it has gotten worse. And tech bro egos have gotten so large that they think their other whacky opinions about politics or whatever must also be brilliant. I wish they'd keep quiet and stick to the tech stuff. I get more than enough politics elsewhere. I hope you don't take it as a criticism., because I think you are balanced and careful. I was a moderator on a Linux forum a couple of decades ago. And even there and then I got tired of the inappropriate discussions about non-Linux topics, including even religion. I didn't last long as a moderator.

Rafał

You think Microsoft doesn't use AI to develop Windows?

Ryan Richards

Re-read my reply. Windows 7. I'm using a (largely) offline computer.

Rafał

Right, Windows 7... I guess this one is AI-free 😆

UsernamesAreHard

To be honest Nick, I wouldn't be surprised if your contact over at Proton will just sugarcoat the entire current situation, your audience is probably very receptive to you and Proton's products after all. I don't know if you saw or read the ai manifesto by Bart Butler, the CTO of Proton, but I think that it more or less confirms that there's a lot of shit happening behind closed doors over at Proton: https://proton.me/blog/ai-manifesto If you haven't read the manifesto, I highly encourage you to do so. First of all, why does a company like Proton need to write an AI manifesto? I thought that we were shielded a bit more against Ai techbro brainrot in Europe, but apparently it's just as bad. It really shatters the professional image I had about Proton, honestly. Second, I'll just paraphrase what Butler stated in his manifesto, talking about engineers working over at Proton : "Your job has fundamentally changed. It is no longer to write code, and LLMs are not here to help you write better code faster. Your job is to help the LLM write better code faster." While you can doubt that what media 404 reported is true, the fact that a company like Proton wrote such a manifesto putting Ai on a pedestal while spitting in the face of their engineers paints a pretty bleak image about Proton. While I doubt that we will ever see proof about the CEO calling engineers losers for wanting to do pen tests, or while I doubt that your contact will be 100% honest about the situation, the fact that the CTO himself wrote such a garbage manifesto is very telling about the toxic situation over at Proton and what media 404 reported last week is probably more likely to be true than false. I'm disappointed by Proton. Now that they finally added folders on the paid plans of Proton pass, I thought that it would be a good idea to subscribe. But with this entire shit show happening, it's just a reminder that no matter how virtuous a company claims or appears to be, money will always come first, before the customer's interests. I'll just stick to keepassxc, keepass2android and Syncthing, at least there are no brain rotten Ai tech bro CEO dictating how LLMs should be more important than security engineers.

UsernamesAreHard

If you want to have your own opinion, you could always read the manifesto written by Proton's CTO: https://proton.me/blog/ai-manifesto While what's been stated by media 404 can be true or false, I'm convinced that it's more likely to be true than false. Seems like there's a lot of turmoil happening behind closed doors over at Proton.

Marcel Kapfer

In my experience, the loudest people are rarely the majority. And the majority is often the most quiet. I don't have the numbers, but perhaps the feedback you get might got more "extremist" because there are now two more groups with a very strong opinion. I like your content and the IMO balanced approach, though I don't agree with some of your opinions. But it would be a strange world if everyone would think the same.

Dave McIntosh

Hi Nick, I fall on the same side of the fence as you and that's why I enjoy supporting your podcast. One thing to keep in mind is that at least in the linux community you have some freedom to choose your path instead of being a sheep that is forced to eat whatever Microsoft or Apple wants to feed you

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Oh yeah, I don't expect anyone to agree with me, or have a single unified thinking line, it's just the way that disagreement is expressed, and how quickly people jump to conclusions :)

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, I read all of that, and I'm not sure how I feel. I do trust Proton, at least I did until now, and I'm tempted to give them another chance, and ditch them at the first sign of anything sloppy or unethical, but I'm not sure, feels like a copout.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

yeah, I don't want everyone to think like me, disagreements are fine, it's the way the disagreement is expressed that is annoying, and the fact that people jump to some insane conclusions and attribute intentions to you just because you don't agree with them :)

Dave McIntosh

Yes, I get what you are saying. I've always been proud of being an open-minded and tolerant person, but above all a person who is respectful of others. It's getting harder and harder to do so with so many who seem to value none of those things

UsernamesAreHard

It's honestly hard to wrap your mind about this situation. I had this image of Proton being this professional, privacy and security conscious company and it's been kinda thrown out the window with this entire communication and management fiasco. I'm not interested changing providers every other year so I won't be using their products, that's certain.

Quidam

Everyone has a strong opinions on everything now-a-days. Algorithmic fuelled echo-chambers and Anonymous sharing has a lot to answer for. Even News is no longer subjective. If people share their opinion, for example, they are negative about AI, I just ask them to tell me a few positive things about AI. If they cannot do that or they struggle to think of any, then their opinion is not "balanced" and can be ignored. To be brutally honest Nick. I love this channel, but it is very opinionated. I don't read YouTube comments but I'm not surprised there are many crazy opinionated replies. Personally, I prefer to hear, for example, "Omarchy is created by DHH", rather than "Omarchy is created by DHH, who is a despicable human being yada yada yada". This is just "my opinion" ;-).

tkf

Wanted to add some feedback to the "opinion divide" topic, but plenty of others have worded it much better already. But a friend sent me a video about the Artcraft suite that I found to be an unusually balanced take, and it reminded me of this episode again, so here it is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H-r3aj0KOhI Thank you for keeping a sane and moderate approach to news! ❤️

Talya

as someone who's solidly in the anti-Ai SJW quadrant, i wanna try and get across why so many people in the anti-AI side are annoyed. let's imagine you weren't a Linux and FOSS guy, but an electricity and grid guy, and that you made a video about what new coal plant installations mean for the grid. it doesn't really matter if you start your video by saying "yeah coal has many issues, the mining is destructive and it causes cancer" if the tone of the video is one that says these plants will do great things for our power grid by providing a stable base load. coal obviously has benefits. if it didn't people wouldn't build coal power plants. but in the 21st century it needs to go the way of the dodo, and anything that doesn't say it explicitly ends up being pro-coal, even if that's not the intention. AI is a power-centralising technology (yes, centralising, not democratising). it's run by fascists and propped up by fascists. it's used by people like Trump and Putin to spread misinformation and by twitter users to create abuse material. AI companies and fossil fuel companies are BFFs and the rise of AI fully sealed the chances of complying with the Paris agreement. it's deskilling. it's extremely addictive and leads to the kinds of meltdowns we saw in Proton. it raises the maintenance burden on developers. and it's actively creating a hole in the development community that will destroy open source that will remain there even if the bubble pops tomorrow. and the benefits aren't guaranteed to stay. copyright laws have been made by corporations for corporations, so there's all the chances we'll see courts or new treaties decide that actually it's fine for AI companies to scrape the internet and copy your work, but you're not actually allowed to copy Adobe's work. so yeah, AI needs to go, and to me not saying that or spending more time talking about the benefits of AI than the harms is just another form of "enlightened centrism" that just ends up benefiting those in power.