Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 646424155.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hello Patreon family! I hope you enjoy my detailed psychological analysis of episode 13 of Your Lie in April! This was the most emotional episode for me thus far, for the following reasons, as shown below.

My main takeaways from the episode

1) It is very hard, yet important not to judge someone by their biggest mistake (of course, context matters) because we all make mistakes, and humans are complicated

2) The episode really spotlighted the invisible sacrifices of mothers, especially single mothers, for me, who would do whatever it takes to ensure the future survival of their children; sometimes, the fine line between cruelty and love can be razor-thin

3) How can we fully judge others without actually living through their exact circumstances and internal landscape? What Kousei's mother did is absolutely cruel, yet I understand where she came from, and that makes the episode more emotional and difficult to sit with

Also, poor Kousei, I hope his renewed path is not carved with endless sorrow and grief...

Happy new week, everyone~

Files

Comments

Jeremy Herttna

I hate that I'm stuck at work all night and I can't properly watch this til morning. I've been waiting for this episode ever since you started the series. You can bet I'll be leaving another comment once I've gotten to watch.

Waiting4Erik

This is such brilliant writing. We’ve been fed the ghost of Saki, abusive demon mother, with only fleeting glimpses of the mother that Kousei loved. And here the tragedy of Saki is finally revealed, she never wanted him to be a professional pianist. And in her despair and anticipatory grief she’s harmed Kousei. It is for Kousei, not the audience to forgive his mother. But can the audience find compassion for Saki? We were forced to sit with Kousei’s trauma, but now the audience must sit uncomfortably with her love with her despair and self-loathing with her anticipatory grief. Can the audience grant her humanity? There are no rules and there is no roadmap for parenting. One can only hope to have done more good than harm in raising a child. Could we have done better in her shoes? Could we have done worse?

Waiting4Erik

I have to care for patients some of whom have challenging family dynamics. I have to care for the patient as they are today. Many have traumatized their now adult children and alienated family. Some family are assisting only out of obligation. Some want nothing to do with their parent - not even responsibility for their burial. And sometimes the patient wants nothing to do with their family - even children. I cannot provide optimal care to these people if I judge them or their family for their past and current mistakes. So I’ve made peace with myself so that I can feel compassion for these people. It can be difficult to do so. But it’s something that keeps me humble and human. The writing for this episode does the same. It asks the audience to be humble and human.

Brad

In simplest terms its a great demonstration of the old proverb "The road to hell is paved with good intentions." as Saki's good intention of giving Kousei a chance to support himself and form connections with others through music became wrapped in abuse leading to Kousei's mental break down and trauma. Though it can also be see as a perfect storm formed from the combination of a culture that's already known for towing line between parenting and abuse mixed with a mostly single parent household where the parent is dying. This leads to the Saki going over far over the line of abuse expecting Kousei to be on his own once she passes, not too unlike some other parents with children that show a natural gift/talent in specialties that tend to have an upper age limit on success.

Idalia González

I was crying through the whole thing 😭. I can't help it, si one of my favorite episodes.

Waiting4Erik

Mostly they are trying to do their best as parents in the only way they know how. I grew up with an Asian tiger parent. You can never be enough for a tiger parent. I chose to learn piano out of love for solo piano. But tiger parenting in the presence of “talent” killed the joy of playing in my home long before I quit. But for all but the most self-indulgent tiger parents, they just want to know that their child(ren) will be happy and successful. So if it isn’t according to the parent’s dreams they at least want to see that their child has the will to make it happen. That requires a child standing up to a tiger parent and making the parent feel that their child knows what they want. So while Kousei turned his defiance of his mother into a source of guilt and feelings of needing to be punished, his mother could take some solace that he stood up for himself. And if a tiger parent truly loves their child, this is when they will back off. It’s just one more part of Saki’s tragedy that Kousei finally stood up for himself only after she had pushed too far with her abuse. She realized too late. She never had a chance to atone or seek forgiveness. She could only hope that she had done more good than harm.

Jeremy Herttna

I lost my mother to cancer 15 years ago. Hardly a day goes by that I don't think about her in some way. I, thankfully, do not carry any trauma, or regret as I was lucky enough to be by her side as she left this world. Even still, this episode never fails to stir up my emotions and makes me wish I could have had her in my life longer than I did. This episode is such a beautiful display of emotional closure with such an amazing piano piece to use as a soundtrack. Thank you for your amazing analysis Benoit. And just when you think the anime has done enough emotional damage for one episode, there's the final line from Hiroko... it's like "We know!! We know she's not going to make it!! Why do you have to do this to me, Your Lie in April?!" Lol

Psychotherapist Reacts

Yeah…this show never ceases to amaze and sadden me at the same time. Glad you had emotional closure with your mother, and I can’t imagine when that day comes for me, a humble reminder to cherish those we love when they are alive

Soren

That sentiment at the end of the episode. I get it. As someone who used to write a lot of poetry. The… pain and anguish. The negative emotions were fuel for the writing. I’d say I’ve become happier in years since, and in so doing I stopped having inspiration for writing. For people like Kousei and myself, those negative experiences become inspiration. Which is tragic.

Psychotherapist Reacts

Thanks for sharing, and I’d argue we can train and re-condition ourselves to seek inspiration outside of the catalyzing emotions of sadness or grief, over time

Jon Daux

25:40 A very conservative translation from the subtitlers there, which misses the entire point of this arc, where Kousei is learning to play with every sense other than sound. In the Japanese, Kousei literally says "This piece smells of my mother" or "This piece gives off the scent of my mother", it's quite a beautiful sentiment.