Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 667856855.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hello, Patreon family! Please enjoy my detailed analysis of the Apothecary Diaries Season 2, Episode 9. This might be one of the darkest and most unexpected turns of events, with my suspicion of sexual abuse from the Late Empress Dowager toward the Late Emperor...

Also, we apologize for the audio quality, the risk of my cats finally joining one of my recording sessions, and then immediately stepping on and unplugging one of my audio cords...

My main takeaways from the episode

1) Hurt people, hurt people, if we do not interrupt the intergenerational trauma cycle, such as sexual abuse and any other trauma; and our trauma does not excuse our actions of inflicting similar trauma onto others, especially onto children

2) Our words may deceive, but the pattern of our behaviors never lies; the late Emperor's repulsive reaction (trauma response) whenever adult women made physical contact with him was a clear example of this subtle yet significant behavioral signaling

I think this is the most shocked I felt, given my analysis and prediction, other than the Lakan's grand reveal in the last season...Holy cow!!! And, I still have no idea what the green 🐸 represents~

Happy new week, everyone!

Files

Comments

Leslie

I don't know if his mother abused him physically, or both physically AND sexually, but I do really think he was abused by his mother. Even if just physical abuse - if he was young, I think it would still make sense? Maomao conjectures about how the late empress "knew" her son wasn't fit to rule... I wonder what she put him through to reach that conclusion. I must admit I hope it wasn't sexual, but considering the parallel with Lady Anshi and the late Emperor for their second children I do think you might be on to something. That specific act being what broke him... Also, while Lady Anshi may have been ambitious and purposefully sought out the emperor for that ambition... I believe she also gave birth to the current Emperor at 9. She said her period started young on top of having a young face, not that she was older than the other girls. She was groomed to seek that role, and she still clearly isn't at peace with how she ended up here or anything that happened since with the late Emperor. I like that Jinshi presents another option - despite his trauma, despite Lady Anshi's participation in it, he DID remember her. She had the strongest impression on him of any woman, and it wasn't necessarily negative. I would love to know what he actually took away from that encounter. Finally, "child of immorality" "child of a mistake" - but what mistake? The mistake of what she did to the emperor, or the mistake of a child swap that could never be allowed to be known? This is a really good episode :)

Leslie

Oh, also! Historically a TON of paint colors have been super toxic. Lead and arsenic-based paint materials were often used for deep, bright colors. White, red, yellow... even in the 1900s, vivid greens and oranges made from arsenic-based materials or uranium were common.

Leslie

rewatched some of the meatier parts, which made me have a couple more thoughts to share. First: My favorite scene in the episode is towards the end, when Jinshi wonders who was really the center of the painting, and we get the really smooth transition from the painting to Anshi at various ages before returning to the current. It really makes you see how even the hair style is a perfect match for her. Second: I wonder what it was like, as the Late Empress, in the beginning? I've never thought about this before, but some of your comments about Lady Anshi's unique position made me think of it... A young woman, dead husband, no family around because she is the only of her family to be royal now, no one you cant trust, and a young son you now need to raise to become Emperor. Just like nothing excuses her son's actions, nothing excuses hers either, but... what an impossible and impossibly lonely task.

Dragons like Bananas

From some extra information the author has revealed it seams there are 2 reasons/sources for the previous emprors fear of women 1 :his mother's abuse (probably physical and verbal) to make him a " unthinking and compliant puppet" And 2: because of his extreme beauty he was abused,most likely sexually, by other concubines since a really young age

Symbolic Remnant

This was 🎨🖌️ You have likely seen 👻🔥 That just leaves the last of my emoji sets Also no, the lady in waiting with the baby emperor in that one scene is actually a much younger Suiren!

Summer08

Thank you Benoit, it was so nice to finally see your overlords make an appearance 🐱🐱 This episode is so much to take in. It took repeated viewings for me to truly understand. It’s so heartbreaking when you think about the fact that Lady Anshi is only 10 years older than her son which is the current Emperor 🥺 and how her father used her due to her beginning her cycle at such an early age. The ride has officially started.

KapteynG

which is really close noooow.

Dragons like Bananas

Although it's still possible that the previous empror suffered SA from his mother , since the author neve denies it. But from her mentioning things like how 'the Empress never stopped the previous Emprors actions because she saw it as an apology for not being able to protect him when she was a low ranking concubine ' makes me think it's not as likely.

Dragons like Bananas

Also I know a lot of people dislike that Previous Emperor and Jinshi look so similar, but personally I've always thought they're supposed to represent a kind of "what if" of each other If the previous Emperor was cared for and protected the way Jinshi was would he have become a decent person like Jinshi and not developed his "preferences"? Or more importantly had Jinshi remained as Ah-Duo's son , who at the time was of low status/ranking just like the Empress, would he have also fallen victim to his beauty and end up similar to the previous Emperor?

Symbolic Remnant

Anshi's terrible position: Doing what her father ordered on the promise it would make her powerful too... inevitably feeling violated in the process, put in actual physical danger both from assassins and the mere medical reality of being pregnant so young. She tried convincing herself it would at least make her special to the most powerful man in Li. It didn't... and the fact he could go on after what he did to her without giving her what she felt owed in return... she hated that more than anything... but she knew just how scared he was of adult women... and she had the dark realization that it meant she could show him EXACTLY how he had made her feel as a child. She conceived a child in doing so... a child she was emotionally detached from, perhaps detached enough to decide that trading him out for another recently-born royal infant would make herself more comfortable caring for a child than in keeping her own second son to herself. Anshi spends most of her average day nowadays trying to help the downtrodden and remove exploitation from the structures of the Linese Imperial Court... but part of that is out of guilt. Out of knowing that she tried the alternative of vindictive revenge already, in a very extreme way... and it did not heal her.

Psychotherapist Reacts

Oooof powerful analysis and so well said…again nobody won in the process..hurt people, hurt people

Talon Karrde

I think its implied that it was (through out of media stuff) other concubines when he became emperor, desperate to use the boy to become empress. That traumatized him which is why the Empress was so protective but also controlling of him. He wasnt all there mentally. And then he went on to abuse others.

Talon Karrde

Not just his beauty as a boy but more because women in the rear palace had 1 job, try to become empress... while the new emperor was a boy. They were trying to be the first to give him an heir.

Talon Karrde

This episode is a great example of Mao Maos ability to deny something she fully knows. Her asking if Jinshi visited the palace, coming to that connection, can only be true... if he is the prince. I love how the crucial part of the mystery connecting that rock to the former emperor, is a fact she pretends not to know.

Dragons like Bananas

True , I just assumed it started before he became emperor since his mother was still low ranking.

Talon Karrde

What Anshi did... was not ok. And she knows that, I think she regrets it very much. But also... by hurting the emperor and making him lock himself away. She in effect protected all the other girls.

JAMES D'ALESSANDRO

She was not older that what he liked. She was insanely young...between 9 and 10. She gave birth to her son when she was 10 years old and Jinshi is actually the current Emporer's son if we are to believe Maomao's theory about the baby switch

Sarah ODwyer

I think you’re bang on with the abuse by the late empress, if you recall in the episode where Jinshi is having the nightmare about the late emperor and empress, when the late empress approaches the emperor suddenly - he cowers down after which she tells him to return to his room. I actually never put that into perspective until this rewatch with your channel 😅….. & also 🐸

!! Nyck ☆ Palette ¡¡

Personally through this episode it seems so to me Mao Mao's theory of the baby switch makes even more sense, I don't think the timeline matches to consider jinshi the late emperor's and anshi's son as in contradiction to the current emperor. It will be sooo refreshing when all gets revealed!

!! Nyck ☆ Palette ¡¡

Man this storyline gives me goosebumps. Both victims, both perpetuated under abusive roles, an endless cycle of abused and abuser. As bittersweet as it is, it's a relief this came to an end when Anshi took matter into her own hands, sadly not in a positive way, but she saved so many children's lives by doing so, and she raised her son (the current emperor) to not fall into the late emperor's ways. You can clearly see by how delectable he is as an emperor, man and father. His preferences for mature and emotionally intelligent women, prefering having built a family with his first love Ah Duo despite that not having worked ou as perfectly as he wished... Giving that half-way up by focusing his vision on the good future of the imperial context of their country, purely from politics... And even making lady Lishu his concubine as to protect her :') i would go as far as considering he sees her close to something like a daughter, or atleast he feels he has to take that paternal role, since she has no one, also if you even consider her dynamic with lady Ah Duo. And by reflection of that, Jinshi, and the current dynamic of the rear palace seemingly in all good hands. So interesting! Anshi has a turbulent story, but she remained resilient as to stay in that role of guardian.

!! Nyck ☆ Palette ¡¡

yes hahah, i love reading the fans comments theorizing with my own thoughts...

Psychotherapist Reacts

Yeah so well said. Horrible cycle but happy-ish ending given how well Jinshi and the Emperor turned out

Surtgr

Per the Author's Instagram, the Former Empress Regnant was originally a low level concubine she was unable to protect her beautiful (you noticed the high similarities between Jinshi and him, think of how everyone describes Jinshi) son from the higher rank concubines. Her power grab was due to all of the Higher level princes dying and her artistic traumatized son was suddenly on the throne. So she became the Mother of the Emperor and built her power base to protect her son in the only way she could being suddenly thrust onto that high position. Anshi due to already being of high rank and the mother of the Crown prince soon to be Emperor was in a much better position to protect her own beautiful "child" from the same fate.

anty rak

I might be playing into the hype more but this anime only gets peakier?(is that even a word?) from now on. Like if season one as a whole was peak, this is mega peak.

JAMES D'ALESSANDRO

I don't think Anshi killed the Emporer, she only raped him and completely destroyed his mind and gave birth to either Jinshi or Ah-Duo's baby who died. I believe the Emporess physically and sexually abused him

Ana Maria Zuñiga

She desperately wants to not know, because she's fully aware of the dangerous position knowing would put her in. Same with the Lakan link and her real standing in society. Deep down, she knows everything but chooses to act as if she didn't to protect herself.

Talon Karrde

Perhaps the danger she still perceives speaks to another self delusion she has. That all these people in power truly care about her. She still thinks to herself that a mistake, or improper knowledge would get her executed. But she has so much favor with so many power. She has the friendship/favor of the emperor himself. In a sense. But she cant accept that. Because of how her mind works, and also perhaps how she was raised and that environment, perhaps she cant accept that she is... and deserves to be, loved.

Jeremy Herttna

What a dark episode brightened up by your curious Maomaos. I guess it would make sense for the late Emperor to be a victim of abuse or at least traumatized in some way. I didn't ever expect I would feel bad for him with his legacy of pedophilia being rampant in the series til now. I was actually not expecting this mystery to be solved in one episode. I wonder where the series goes from here?

Jon Daux

"The eyes of a young girl, full of ambition" is absolutely gut-wrenching knowing what happens next.

Jon Daux

1:06:50 I'm not sure it's actually that relevant what she told him. His mind was broken because she raped him as an adult woman despite his strong aversion to them, I'm surprised nobody has said this in the comments.

Peach

I like to think through all of the bleakness and everyone's horrible actions that he finally understood what he'd done to Anshi and others... whether it was what she did or what she said to him, since he'd probably never been fully confronted with the truth of his actions before because of his mother. Anshi realizing he had painted her long after they no longer had any contact, and the symbolism of her blossoming as the most significant woman to him, maybe even protecting the little girls painted around her... It's beautiful and heartbreaking, such an awful and powerful episode to watch. Anshi moving on after her revenge and most likely thinking she could protect her second son from any twisted feelings about his conception by switching the babies... and her deep care and desire to protect Jinshi from the same fate was so great that she kept him away from the Emperor as he tried to talk to them. He clearly wasn't able to be a normal husband or father, but I always felt like he wanted to show her the painting, he wanted to share his creative secret with his "son" too... And even though there was no way for them to reconcile in life, Maomao's investigation and Jinshi's memories truly helped Anshi find closure. Really loved your thoughts - I thought the late Empress abused him at first too, but I think after everything it makes sense that it was that she could not protect him, and instead became a demon to others and an overbearing presence to him, controlling him & enabling his abuse cycle, because of those awful experiences she went through too... and they were cooped up together at the end of his life, so I wondered if it's also symbolic of like, she procured the painting supplies for him the same way she procured young girls for him, and in the end brought them both to ruin; maybe being exposed to the paint hastened her death too... Did she demand his loyalty in the end because of her sacrifices? Did she know the painting wasn't her? Did he say that it was, while internally thinking about everything he realized because of Anshi? Aaaaah this show!!!!!!

Psychotherapist Reacts

Welcome, Peach!! And so well said loved what you said, maybe the late Emperors finally recognized his horrible deeds and the painting was the proof of that. This show is so unreal, I don’t understand how it’s getting better and better