Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 678026199.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hello Patreon family! I hope you enjoy my detailed psychological analysis of episode 18 of Your Lie in April! What a beautiful and inspiring performance this was, witnessing Kousei and Nagi's growth.

My main takeaways from the episode

1) We all need emotional anchors in our lives, whether that is Nagi (and Kaori) for Kousei, Watari for the friend's group, or how Kousei now became Kaori's anchor toward the end-stage of her life; who is your friendship anchor?

2) The invisible progress cannot be measured externally, but that does not mean our invisible progress does not have a tangible impact

What a beautiful and touching episode, especially the empowering message in the end~

Happy new week, everyone, and I hope we all navigate this path of life with our emotional anchors, whether family or friends!

Files

Comments

Jeremy Herttna

I love this episode and how Kousei decides to push Nagi during the performance. It was definitely not because Kousei was losing it. It was definitely for Nagi's growth and for Kaori to hear. Amazing, amazing episode and wonderful analysis as always! I did forget that the dub actually spells out that Kaori straight up asks Kousei to die with her. Very chilling, and tragic.

Waiting4Erik

Nagi saying “I’m Christine.” Is her acknowledging her transformation and a call back to a few episodes ago where she called herself the Phantom of the Opera - a villain. Christine is the heroine of Phantom of the Opera, “the girl who yearns to go onstage at the opera house.”

Waiting4Erik

Ready for more symbolism for Kaori’s wake up call from Kousei? He refused to play Ravel’s “Pavane For A Dead Princess” for Kaori. Instead he countered with Sergei Rachmaninoff’s duet arrangement of Tchaikovsky’s “Sleeping Beauty Waltz.” What could be a more appropriate song for waking up a sleeping princess?

Waiting4Erik

My view is that in the beginning Kousei feels distracted BECAUSE he can still hear the music. He hears his music when it is the written score. That is the old Kousei. That is not how he wants to play piano anymore. He wants to play the music from his soul, his music coming from within. When he thinks “I want it gone!” He begins playing by feeling and playing his emotions. The tone and intensity of his playing changes. Remember he is playing this for Kaori. This is his roar- his declaration of how strong he feels about waking Kaori up. His sideglance to Nagi is him saying - Can you keep up with this? Now you wake up your hero, too!

Jeremy Herttna

I agree. And you definitely explained it better than I could have.

Jeremy Herttna

I definitely caught the Phantom of the Opera reference.

Zabon

I think you misunderstood what Kousei was saying. He said he couldn't concentrate, he was distracted, because he could still hear the piano. It's a reversal of his problem, where previously he was scared because he couldn't hear the piano, and now he can't reach his highest peak without getting rid of the sound of the piano, unlocking his newfound 'gift' to fully express himself without being bound to the score as it is written. His playing wasn't bad, it's the opposite, it was on a level much higher than for the time and place, hence why Nagi was talking about him putting the pressure on her to keep up with him and why the people in the audience were surprised by the change in the intensity. It's the same thing that Kaori did to him when they played together. He wasn't doing it from a place of being conflicted or in a struggle with his inner emotions. It's the difference between playing a piece accurately, and playing it with emotion, interpretation, and improvisation in the moment.

Waiting4Erik

“Once you achieve technical facility, you're either a musician or you're not. You're either a creative person or a stenographer.” -Charles Mingus This is the lesson Kaori has been teaching Kousei. The Human Metronome was the greatest stenographer who had gone beyond mere technical facility to achieve near technical perfection. But musicians are artists and technique is simply the skill used to express one’s Art - it is not the expression of one’s own Art. It’s why Kaori keeps reminding Kousei that they are musicians. It’s the difference between technically masterful report writer Violet Evergarden and Auto-Memory Doll Violet Evergarden. The Human Metronome, like Violet Evergarden reporter, accurately reproduced someone else’s ideas but failed to convey emotional meaning. The parallels are interesting as both existed in similar places emotionally and their transformation relies on reaching a place of emotional expression, but the reasons are completely opposite. Violet never understood her own emotions, while Kousei has been suppressing his emotions behind the score. Music is freedom of expression, Art. And with this performance Kousei shows that he’s embraced musician as his vocation. Being a stenographer, playing to the score, leaves him still hearing the notes of the score and incapable of expressing his own emotions/Art. “I want it gone” is a declaration to rid himself of the emotional cage of the score and to embrace the emotional freedom of music. With that shift in tone and intensity he’s playing a letter to Kaori “ Wake up, Sleeping Beauty! You’re a musician just like me!” And Kaori is compelled to respond. His side glance to Nagi is also saying “you too. You’re a musician and you have something you want to say.” And that spurs Nagi to make the leap from stenographer to musician.

Jon Daux

Nah Benoit, I gotta say I think you misunderstood the performance here! Arima could still hear the music, and what he got from that was that they weren't doing enough. He wanted to fall into the pure artistry that stole his hearing before. He was challenging Nagi to rise to the brilliance he has risen to in previous performances—it's a good thing! And exactly what Nagi needed don't you think? She was already technically brilliant, this is exactly and probably the only thing that could help her to grow. I don't think it was accidental or subconscious at all.