Rival Rugby Captains 🏉 | 02 (Patreon)
Content
All characters depicted in this story are fictional and 18 years of age or older. Everything portrayed is safe, sane, and consensual.
02 - Length v/s Thickness
The rivalry between the two captains had defined rugby in Bayport for years. Mason led Northridge University while Jax led Southgate College. Their teams clashed constantly in the local league, and the tension always carried off the pitch. It had started back a few years earlier during their first match against each other when both were younger and hungrier. Every game since then had been personal, marked by late hits, trash talk, and stares that lasted too long. Neither man could stand the other, yet neither could stay away when their paths crossed again.
Tonight was no different. Northridge had fallen short once more as Jax had played like he owned the field and his team had walked away with the win. The post match gathering spilled into a popular late night spot where both squads usually unwound together. Mason sat with his guys at one end of the room while Jax held court with his at the other. Their eyes met across the space and the air shifted. Mason felt the familiar pull mixed with irritation. Jax looked good, too good, with that broad chest still damp from the sweat and the easy smirk that said he knew exactly how the night had gone. Mason hated how his stomach tightened at the sight. He hated even more how his body reacted to the cocky confidence rolling off the other captain.
Mason pushed up from his seat and headed outside for air. The night felt cooler than the charged room behind him. He was annoyed at the loss and at seeing that handsome asshole with the permanent smirk like he had already won everything. He leaned against the brick wall in the alley behind the bar and let out a slow breath. The quiet helped for about thirty seconds.
Footsteps sounded behind him as Jax stepped out into the alley. He had followed without hesitation. The door clicked shut and left them alone in the dim light. Jax leaned against the opposite wall at first, then pushed off and walked closer. He wore blue jeans and a fitted gray t-shirt that clung in all the right places.
“We’ve got to stop meeting like this,” Jax said, his voice carrying that same low cocky edge from every clash they had ever had.
Mason turned his head. “Like what exactly, captain?”
Jax grinned and closed more of the distance. “Like this. You slipping away after your team gets beat again. Me having to come find you to make sure you don’t disappear completely.”
Mason snorted, but the sound lacked real bite. “Your team won again. Big deal. You don’t have to chase me down every time.”
Jax stopped a couple inches away. The alley felt smaller suddenly. “It’s becoming a pattern though. Every time our teams play you end up out here looking like you want to punch something or someone.”
The banter stayed light at first with talk about the match. Jax poked at specific plays while Mason fired back about cheap shots and lucky breaks. It was the same dance they had done for years, but underneath it the air grew thicker. Jax’s eyes kept dropping and coming back up, and Mason felt the weight of every glance.
Jax took one more step, close enough now that Mason caught his scent. It hit him hard, that clean expensive fragrance layered over the raw masculine musk of sweat and effort from the game. The combination made the space between them feel charged in a way that had nothing to do with the match. It was familiar and new at the same time, warm, inviting, and impossible to ignore how close they were standing.
Jax’s voice dropped. “Still owe me that admission from last time. Or are we pretending it never happened?”
Mason’s brow furrowed as he tried to play it off like the words meant nothing, like he didn’t remember the night in the sauna two weeks earlier when they had ended up alone and things had escalated fast. The jerk off contest. The way they had stroked side by side until Mason had lost control first. The thick load that had painted his abs. He kept his face neutral. “I don’t know what the fuck you are talking about.”
Jax chuckled, the sound low and knowing, and stepped even closer until his chest almost brushed Mason’s. “You sure about that, Mason? I remember your big dick shooting a pretty thick load. It’s hard to forget something like that.”
Mason chuckled, the sound coming out cocky and low. “Ah, that night in the sauna. I remember your thick cock leaking too. Couldn’t keep it under control even then.”
Jax didn’t back down, his voice staying sure. “Yeah but my thick cock shot a bigger load than yours in the end.”
Mason felt defensive heat rise in his chest as he straightened up. “Length is what matters. A long cock like mine looks better. Feels better when it’s sliding deep. Size in inches wins.”
The length versus thickness debate rose up again from there like it had never left. The words came quicker now as the old rivalry mixed with everything that had happened two weeks earlier.
Jax’s eyes darkened with amusement and challenge as he did not back down. “Thickness is what actually fills someone up. What stretches and pushes in the right ways. Your long pretty dick might look impressive but mine is what counts when it is buried inside. Girth beats length every single time.”
The debate heated fast, voices staying low but the words growing sharper. Mason defended his length with cocky pride while Jax fired back with confidence about thickness and how it felt in a hand or a mouth. The alley seemed to shrink around them as their bodies leaned in without either man noticing at first. The rivalry from the pitch mixed with something heavier, something that had started in that sauna and had not gone away.
Jax glanced toward the parking lot. “We need privacy to settle this properly. My truck is right over there.”
Mason hesitated for half a second then nodded. They walked the short distance without another word. The night air did nothing to cool the tension. Jax unlocked the truck and they both climbed in. The cab felt enclosed and private. Mason took the passenger seat while Jax settled behind the wheel.
The banter picked up again almost immediately. Jax started it with a smirk. “Your team really fucking sucks lately. Or maybe you are just a terrible captain who cannot keep them in line.”
Mason shot back without missing a beat. “Or maybe your team does all the heavy lifting while you stand around taking all the credit. I saw how many times they covered for your mistakes tonight.”
They kept going, the insults staying light but pointed. While they talked their hands moved. Mason unbuttoned his jeans as Jax did the same. They slid their underwear down in the dim light of the truck. Cocks came free, both already rock hard from the alley tension and the building argument. The sight hit them both at once.
Mason’s cock stood long and proud, thick enough but clearly longer than average, curving slightly upward. Jax’s was shorter by a clear margin but noticeably thicker, the girth looking substantial, veined and heavy as it stood straight and flushed dark. They looked at each other’s cocks, faces showing the same mix of cocky challenge and raw attraction as eyes lingered and breaths came a little faster.
Mason spoke first, his voice carrying that familiar brag. “See. A big dick always looks better. Long and ready to go deep.”
Jax’s gaze stayed on Mason’s length as he reached over slowly, his hand moving without rush. “Can I?”
Mason hesitated, his cock twitching at the question, then he shrugged like it did not matter. Jax’s fingers wrapped around the shaft. The touch sent a slow wave of heat through Mason’s body. Jax measured with his grip. “What’s this? Like seven or eight inches?”
Mason felt every inch of the contact, the warm firm hold, the way Jax’s fingers slid down the full length and made it stand even taller. Pleasure sparked low in his gut. “Seven and a half,” he said, proudly.
Jax smirked, his hand keeping up a slow stroke that made Mason’s hips shift. “Don't chicks choke on it or something?”
Mason’s mouth curved, the words coming easy. “Fuck yeah they do. But they like it. They beg for more once they get used to the length hitting the back.”
Jax’s eyes flicked up, curiosity mixing with the cocky heat already there. “Let’s see if I choke on it too.”
Jax leaned across the console, his mouth finding Mason’s cock as he took the head in slowly then pushed down further. The length hit the back of his throat and he gagged hard around it, drool spilling from the corners of his mouth and running down the shaft in thick strands. His throat worked but the size made it difficult. He pulled back with a wet cough and a short laugh, leaning back in his seat as saliva glistened on his chin and lips. “Yeah. Hard not to choke on a big dick like that.”
Mason smirked. “Fuck yeah.”
Jax wiped his mouth with the back of his hand, his eyes staying locked on Mason. “You owe me a fucking blowjob too by the way.”
Mason looked at the fat girth of Jax’s cock then back at Jax’s face. “Why the fuck would I do that?”
Jax smirked. “You lost the fucking contest in the sauna. And by the rules, the loser has to do whatever the winner says.” He paused for a beat. “And you seem to be losing a lot lately.”
The words hung in the air between them. Mason felt hesitation rise again as his eyes flicked once more to Jax’s thick cock. The girth looked even more substantial up close. Part of him wanted to say no and pull away. The memory of the sauna still burned in the back of his mind, the way he had lost control, the way Jax had tasted his cum after. He stayed still for a long moment. Jax did not push. He just waited with that same cocky patience, his hand resting lightly on his own thigh.
“That kinda looks intimidating.”said Mason, looking at Jax’s thick cock.
Jax stroked himself once, slow and deliberate, the thick shaft filling his hand. “It is. You’ve got to really open your mouth nice and big.”
Eventually Mason leaned forward, his hand resting on Jax’s thigh for balance. He lowered his head toward the thick shaft and tried to wrap his lips around the head. The girth stretched him immediately. Jax’s hand came up, fingers brushing Mason’s jaw, gentle but firm. “Don’t resist it, Captain. Let the cock slide in.”
Mason opened wider as Jax guided him down. The thick shaft slid past his lips, the stretch burning in the best way. Saliva pooled fast and dripped down the shaft onto Jax’s crotch. Mason’s tongue worked along the underside. He was not skilled at it, his movements staying a little awkward, but the wet heat and the way Jax’s cock pulsed against his tongue felt better than anything he expected. Jax groaned low, one hand staying on Mason’s head.
Jax’s voice came rough between breaths. “Fuck. That mouth. Keep going captain. You are getting the hang of it.”
Mason pulled back for air, spit connecting his lips to the head. Jax laughed once, the sound dark and pleasing.
“Get back on the dick. I am getting close already,” said Jax.
Mason went down again as Jax’s hips started to move in small thrusts up into the wet heat. The rhythm built. Mason’s jaw ached but he did not stop. Saliva ran freely. Jax’s cock filled his mouth completely. The taste and the stretch and the low sounds Jax made mixed into something overwhelming.
Jax’s hand tightened in Mason’s hair, his voice dropping to something almost gentle under the cocky edge. “Yeah. You want to taste what winning is like. Go on. Take it.”
Mason rolled his eyes up at him, the look staying cocky even with the thick cock stretching his lips. He kept going. Jax’s thrusts grew sharper. Then Jax came, thick ropes flooding Mason’s mouth, hot and salty sweet. Mason swallowed around it, the taste filling his senses. He pulled back slowly, some cum escaping the corner of his mouth before he licked it clean. He gulped the rest down.
Jax watched every second, his breathing staying heavy. “Good fucking boy. You liked that?”
Mason wiped his mouth with the back of his hand, his voice coming out rough. “It’s alright. Not bad.”
Jax laughed, the sound filling the truck. “Ah fuck off. You enjoyed it. Don’t fucking lie, Mason.”
Mason’s cock still stood hard and aching as he met Jax’s eyes. “Whatever. Finish me off too.”
Jax did not hesitate this time. He leaned over and took Mason’s seven and a half inch cock into his mouth in one smooth motion. There was no choking or gagging at all. Jax deepthroated the full length with ease, his throat opening smoothly around it as he bobbed his head in steady expert strokes. His tongue worked along every inch with practiced skill that had Mason’s head falling back against the seat almost right away. Jax handled the big dick effortlessly and built the rhythm fast. The suction and the wet slide pulled Mason toward the edge in no time. His hips lifted as Jax took it all without any struggle. Mason’s orgasm hit hard and quick. He came with a low groan, thick ropes shooting into Jax’s mouth. Jax swallowed every drop without pulling away.
Jax pulled off slowly, his lips swollen and a satisfied smirk on his face as he swallowed the last of it. Mason was surprised. “You’ve clearly done this before.”
Jax just smiled, not answering right away. “That was hot as fuck.”
Mason’s tone was annoyed even as his cock softened from the intense release. “Why were you pretending to choke on it earlier, if you could swallow me like that?”
Jax chuckled. “Had to make the loser captain think he had the upper hand for a second before I made him submit properly.”
Mason was annoyed but still buzzing from the orgasm. They pulled their pants back up in the quiet that followed. The truck smelled like cum and that same expensive clean scent from Jax.
As he started to get out of the truck he asked, “So, big dick wins?”
Jax laughed as he got out too. “I don’t think I really fucking care about it. A dick is a dick when it feels this good.”
They walked back toward the bar together. The alley felt different now, charged in a new way.
Before they reached the back door, Jax turned, blocking the entry with his body. His cocky grin had not faded. His voice came low and sure, full of heat. “If you lose the next game, captain, next time I am not just stopping at blowjobs.”
Jax pushed the door open and stepped inside, leaving Mason standing in the alley. The night air felt cooler against Mason’s skin. His body still hummed from everything that had just happened. The rivalry had crossed lines that couldn’t be uncrossed. The tension with Jax had become something else entirely, something Mason could not control and something a part of him already wanted more of. He knew this was not ending anytime soon, and deep down he didn’t want it to stop.________________________________Rival Rugby Captains 🏉 | 03