Playing Boyfriends 💋 | Season 2, Episode 5: What She Took (Patreon)
Content
All characters depicted in this story are fictional and 18 years of age or older. Everything portrayed is safe, sane, and consensual.This chapter is written from both Adrian’s and Matteo’s points of view.
Adrian Cole’s POV
Matteo was already asleep when I slipped out of bed.
The room was dark except for the thin strip of light coming in under the curtains. His breathing was deep and even. One of his arms was still stretched across the space where I had been lying. I stood there for a few seconds watching him, then quietly picked up the grey sweatpants Matteo had discarded on the floor earlier that night and pulled them on. They sat low on my hips and still held a little of his warmth.
I left the bedroom and walked into the living room. The couch looked almost black in the dark. I switched on the small lamp near the window. Soft yellow light filled the corner of the room. Outside, Palermo was still awake in scattered places, a few windows glowing across the water.
I sat down on the couch and opened my journal.
For a while I just held the pen. Then I started writing. Journal Entry #143
The new couch still smells a little like the store. I noticed it again tonight when I sat down. Matteo bought it the same morning I told him the old one looked tired and sad. He didn’t even think about it. Just looked at me and said, “Then we get a new one.” We were standing in the middle of that furniture place and he kept asking if I liked the color, if the cushions felt right, if I could see us sitting on it and making out. I remember laughing and telling him, “It’s just a couch, Romano.” And he shrugged and said, “Yeah. But it’s our couch now.”
I keep thinking about that. How something as stupid as a piece of furniture can start to feel like proof. Proof that he listens. Proof that he wants this enough to change the shape of his apartment for me.
The apartment feels crowded even when Jessica is quiet. The silence has weight now. Every closed door feels like a reminder that we aren’t alone here.
I love him so much it scares me sometimes. Not in a loud, dramatic way. In a quiet way. The kind of fear that sits under all the good things and asks what if this is temporary for him. What if I am the experiment. The rebound. The thing he needed while he figured himself out.
I’ve been that for other people before. I have hooked up with men I wasn’t even attracted to just to feel something after someone left. Years ago I even kissed a girl at a bar just to check if maybe I had been wrong about myself the whole time. She tasted like vodka and disappointment. I remember pulling away and thinking, yeah, definitely not. Safe to say I am gay as fuck. I like men. I like this man who’s my best friend.
And the idea that he might one day wake up and decide this was only a phase makes my chest feel tight in a way I hate writing down.
I sat there for another minute after I finished the page. Then I closed the journal and left it on the coffee table. I didn’t look at it again.
In the kitchen I filled a glass with water and drank it slowly while leaning against the counter. The apartment was completely still. I found myself smiling a little for no clear reason, just the leftover warmth of being near him. When the glass was empty I turned off the kitchen light and walked back to the bedroom.
Matteo had shifted onto his back. I climbed in carefully and settled against his side. He made a small sound in his sleep and turned toward me without waking. I watched his face in the dark for a long time before my eyes finally closed.────────────────
Next morning, I woke up with my heart already racing.
The other side of the bed was empty. I could hear water running in the bathroom. For a second I just lay there, still half tangled in the sheet, trying to understand why my stomach felt wrong. Then it hit me.
The journal.
I sat up fast and looked at the nightstand. Nothing. I checked the floor, the chair in the corner, even under the bed like an idiot. My hands were not steady.
Matteo came out of the bathroom with a towel around his waist and stopped when he saw my face.
“What happened?”
“I can’t find my journal.”
He frowned and walked closer. “Maybe you left it in your bag?”
“No. I didn’t.” My voice came out tighter than I wanted. “Did you take it? Be honest. If you wanted to read it you could have just asked.”
Matteo stared at me like I had grown a second head. “Babe. I literally just woke up and went to take a shower. I haven’t touched anything of yours.”
I ran a hand through my hair and forced myself to breathe. “Okay. Sorry. I just… I know I had it last night.”
Then it hit me.
Last night. After I finished writing I had left the journal on the coffee table. I remembered setting it down, standing up in a sleepy haze, walking to the kitchen for water, and then coming straight back to bed. I never picked it back up.
I got out of bed fast and walked into the living room.
The coffee table was empty.
I stood there for a second staring at the blank surface, then turned and looked straight at Jessica’s closed door. Something hot and sharp moved through my chest. I walked over and started knocking hard.
“Jessica.”
No answer.
I knocked again, louder.
“I know you can hear me. Open the door.”
Behind me I heard Matteo’s footsteps. He came out of the bedroom still pulling a shirt over his head, hair a mess, eyes half focused.
“What’s wrong?” he asked.
“She took it,” I said. My voice came out tighter than I expected. “I left my journal on the coffee table last night and it’s gone. She took it.”
Matteo’s face changed. He stepped past me and knocked on the door himself, firmer.
“Jess. Open the door.”
Silence.
He tried again. “Did you take Adrian’s journal? Just answer me.”
Nothing. No movement. No voice. The door stayed closed like she had decided the best response was to pretend neither of us existed.
Matteo grabbed his phone from the bedroom and called her. We both heard it ringing inside her room. She didn’t pick up. He called a second time. Same result.
After the third unanswered call he lowered the phone and looked at me. His jaw was tight.
“She’s not coming out,” he said.
I let out a short, humorless breath and dragged a hand down my face. “Of course she isn’t.”
We stood there for another minute in the quiet hallway. The apartment felt smaller than it had the night before. Eventually Matteo exhaled and rubbed the back of his neck.
“We should get ready for work,” he said. “If she wants to hide in there all day, fine. We’ll deal with it later.”
I didn’t want to leave. Every part of me wanted to stay and keep knocking until she opened the door or maybe break the door too. But I also knew standing outside her room all morning wouldn’t make the journal magically reappear. So I nodded once, stiff, and went to get dressed.
We left for the office without talking much at first. The ride on the Vespa felt longer than usual. I kept my arms around Matteo’s waist but my mind was stuck on the empty coffee table and the closed door.
Halfway there I finally spoke, loud enough for him to hear over the engine.
“This isn’t right, Matteo. She has it. And if she’s probably already read everything.”
Matteo’s shoulders tensed under my hands. He didn’t answer right away. When he did, his voice was low and controlled in a way that told me he was holding something back.
“I know,” he said. “We’ll handle it tonight.”
I rested my forehead against his back and closed my eyes for a second. The city moved around us, ordinary and loud, while the only thing I could think about was a black notebook that was never supposed to leave my hands. The ride on the Vespa felt longer than usual. I kept my arms around Matteo’s waist but my mind was somewhere else entirely. Every few minutes the same thought circled back: she had gone into the living room while we were asleep and taken it.
At work I was useless. I answered emails without reading them properly. I avoided the break room. Matteo kept glancing over at my desk, but he didn’t push. At lunch he brought me a sandwich I didn’t finish. By late afternoon the low grade panic had settled into something heavier and quieter. Anger mixed with a sharp sense of exposure. Those pages were not meant for anyone else. Especially not her.
When we left the building that evening the air outside was still warm. Matteo unlocked the Vespa and looked at me over the seat.
“Coming back to mine?”
I hesitated. The honest answer sat in my throat for a few seconds before I let it out.
“I want some space tonight,” I said. “Not from you. From that woman. I am pretty sure she has it, Matteo. I don’t want to sleep under the same roof as her while she might be reading things I never meant for anyone else to see.”
Matteo’s jaw tightened. He looked like he wanted to argue, or go straight home and confront her, but something in my face must have stopped him. He nodded once, short and controlled.
“Okay,” he said. “I’ll drop you home.”
The ride to my place was quiet. When we stopped in front of my building he didn’t turn the engine off right away. He just sat there with both feet on the ground, hands still on the handlebars.
“Don’t worry about it, I’ll handle it,” he said.
“Okay.”
I climbed off and stood on the sidewalk for a second longer than necessary. Matteo looked at me like he was already regretting letting me go, but he didn’t try to change my mind. I leaned in and kissed him once, soft and brief.
“Night, Matteo” I said."
He nodded. I turned and walked into the building without looking back. Behind me I heard the Vespa pull away into the evening traffic.
────────────────Matteo Romano’s POV
I drove away from Adrian’s building with my hands tight on the handlebars and my jaw locked so hard it hurt.
The whole ride back I kept replaying the look on his face when he said he needed space. Not from me. From her. From the woman who still had a key to my apartment and somehow thought that gave her the right to touch things that didn’t belong to her.
By the time I parked the Vespa under the building I was past irritated. I was angry in a way that sat low in my chest and refused to move.
I took the stairs two at a time. When I pushed open the apartment door the living room was empty, but Jessica’s bedroom door was open a few inches. Light spilled out into the hallway.
I stopped.
For a second I just stood there, breathing hard. Then I walked straight to her door and pushed it the rest of the way open.
She was sitting on the edge of her bed. Adrian’s journal was right there next to her, black cover facing up, like she had been reading it and only put it down when she heard me come in.
Jessica looked up. Whatever excuse she had prepared died when she saw my face.
“Matteo—”
“So, you did take it.”
My voice came out flat. I stepped into the room and closed the door behind me so the whole building wouldn’t hear what came next.
She stood up too fast. “You two act like I don’t even live here anymore. Loud sex every night. Making out in the living room like I’m invisible. You think that doesn’t do anything to me?”
“So you go through his private things?” I shot back. “That’s your solution?”
“I didn’t plan it,” she said, defensive now. “It was just sitting there on the table. I was curious. You expect me to pretend none of this bothers me? You moved on in front of my face, Matteo. You didn’t even give it time.”
“We broke up months before anything happened with him.”
“And then you started fucking your best friend in the same apartment we used to share,” she snapped. “You think that doesn’t hurt? You think I enjoy hearing the two of you every night?”
I took a step closer. The anger that had been building for weeks finally had somewhere to go.
“You don’t get to use your feelings as an excuse to violate his privacy. That journal was not yours to open. It wasn’t yours to touch.”
Jessica’s eyes flashed. “And what about my feelings? Do those count for anything anymore? Or am I just the roommate who is in the way of your new perfect little relationship?”
Something in me snapped cleanly.
“I have put up with more than I should have because of your nonna,” I said, voice low and hard. “I made promises to her that I have tried to keep. But don’t mistake that for endless patience. You are lonely, Jessica. And instead of dealing with it you are trying to make everyone around you as miserable as you feel. That ends now.”
The words landed. I saw it happen. The fight drained out of her face and left something rawer behind. She looked genuinely hurt instead of just angry. Her eyes shone and she looked away quickly, jaw tight, like she was forcing the tears back.
I walked past her, picked up the journal from the bed, and held it at my side.
“Stay out of my boyfriend's things. Stay out of our relationship . And stop testing how far you can push me. You will not like where that ends.”
I didn’t wait for her to answer. I left the room and closed the door behind me. Through the wood I heard the soft, broken sound of her trying not to cry.
I stood in the hallway for a long moment with the journal in my hand, the anger slowly cooling into something heavier and more complicated. I hated that I had brought her nonna into it. I hated that the lonely comment had clearly cut deep. But I didn’t regret protecting Adrian.
In the bedroom, I sat on the edge of the mattress still wearing my work clothes. I took a picture of the journal on the nightstand and opened my chat with Adrian.
I typed, deleted, then typed again.
“Found it. It had fallen under the couch. Must have gotten kicked under last night.”
I sent the photo with the message. It was a soft lie. I didn’t want him carrying the weight of knowing she had actually read it. Not tonight.
His reply came almost immediately.
“Oh my god. Fuck. I feel like an asshole for blaming her so hard.”
I stared at the screen for a second before answering.
“Don’t. She has been pushing boundaries for weeks. You had every reason to think so.”
A moment later another message arrived.
“If you read even one page of that journal I am putting us on a sex break starting tomorrow. I am serious, Romano.”
I huffed a quiet, tired laugh through my nose. Some of the tightness in my chest loosened.
I typed back: “I would never. Your secrets are safe. Even the dramatic ones.”
Then I put the phone face down on the bed and sat there in the quiet. The apartment felt different after the argument. Heavier. I could still hear faint movement from Jessica’s room, but she didn’t come out.
I leaned forward with my elbows on my knees and rubbed both hands over my face. Bringing up her nonna had been a low blow, even if it was true. Calling her lonely had been worse because it was accurate. I knew the history. I knew why she was still here. And tonight I had used both of those things like weapons.
The guilt sat beside the anger and neither one fully won.
Eventually I stood up, stripped out of my work clothes, and changed into some shorts. When I got into bed, I kept the journal on the nightstand. I did not open it. I just turned off the light and lay down on the side of the bed that still smelled a little like Adrian.
The ceiling was the same ceiling it had always been. The apartment was the same apartment. But something had shifted tonight, and I could feel it even in the dark.
I reached for my phone one last time and sent Adrian a final message.
“Sleep well, Cole. And don’t you dare put me on a sex break. ”
Then I set the phone aside, closed my eyes, and let the quiet of the half empty apartment settle over me.
────────────────Playing Boyfriends 💋 | Season 2, Episode 6: Chiara Bellini