Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 735386258.mp4

Downloads

Content

This is the AD- FREE and EARLY ACCESS version of the REACTION HIGHLIGHTS!

We go from last week's episode where Starbuck is suspiciously non-existent, to this week....where it's all Kara Thrace all the time! And she is a hot frakkin' mess y'all. Katee talks about how frustrating it was to play Starbuck in this storyline, where she is constantly failing and being torn to pieces by Kat of all people 😾

"Scar"
Directed by Michael Nankin
Written by Bradley Thompson and David Weddle

Shop Merch ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection

If you can, please go and leave your comments on the public version when it airs Thursday @ 11:30 AM PT as it helps push the success of the show :)

Click here to give some love on YT ❤️

Youtube Reactions

Files

Comments

Enrica Manes

Hi Katee and Robin! So nice and magic be connected with a so so deep involving episode as Scar Is✨🚀 Thank you also for your attention and for choosing some of my questions/reflections. This is one of my favorite episodes, and it truly highlights one of Starbuck’s defining traits: hiding her feelings and her own pain

Enrica Manes

Katee/Starbuck facial expressions are so tipical and unique: I love that way she frowns her brow and narrows her eyes ... THAT ICONIC SIGHT⚡

Nicole R-G

So…. Is there any way we can get Jamie Bamber in for Unfinished Business? It’s such an important messy episode for them 😅

Simply.Beyond

Katee’s dislike of Kat is me every rewatch 😂😂😂 I always hated how they made her one up Starbuck with every scene in this episode. But, I will say that Starbuck has been distracted for a while, it’s just the main focus for this episode. She really is the problem here, even if I am still on her side way more than Kat. I would be like Helo, defending her to others, but calling her on her bs in private. I don’t know if she really loved Anders at this point, but he definitely struck a nerve with her and got under her skin. And the fact that she made a promise to him, affects her the most, I think. He represents a clean slate and she doesn’t want to fail him the way she feels she’s failed others.

Enrica Manes

maybe the "dead guy" Is Lee himself... so different to the one Kara met and loved...she still loves him so much, but this scene shows how Lee don't or don't want understand...let emotions flows... Scar fight episode is so tough for Starbuck...she's lonely and hurted, she's starting to suffer, she drinks too much, far more beyond the excess, while the dualism with Kat is increasingly cruel, and it is heartbreaking in a sort of facing herself aknowledge tough step inside, while in her side Kara is going so deep into Scar's aim and in the meanwhile she looks inside herself. now it is a fight between Starbuck and Starbuck, while she reflects deeper and deeper about death and life...and she found herself hurted inside and completly forlorn... about the aim of the episode, It Is interesting see how the rivalry between Kara and Kat is not a simple competition for the title of top gun and, instead, it is a ruthless mirror of their traumas, their fear/disdain of death, the fear to be forgotten and the heavy burden of survival: right at the center of this clash moves Scar who embodies the constant horror of the end. We have two women and the impact of the machine in a breakdown dynamic where Scar can be seen as a machine of suffering, while the Cylon raider is not just an intelligent enemy fighter but It is a traumatized predator resurrected countless times (according to Sharon 's talk with Kara)... There is a tough parallel between Starbuck and Scar, because in it she sees a reflection of her own self-destruction, tormented by anxiety for Sam Anders trapped on Caprica and drowning in alcohol to numb the pain, and also the "insider" Kat between them. Kat coopes with fear by denying it, transforming it into an obsessive drive to prove herself - so the rivalry with Strabuck. Both fear to be forgotten and Kat too deeply fears oblivion and the judgment of fallen comrades, so they become there very similar, in a sort of asymmetrical clash where Kat views Starbuck as an unreachable role model to overcome and match. Meanwhile, Kara—consumed by her own existential pain—reacts with annoyance and cynism to the rookie's attempt to take her place. Then all bitterness explodes into physical and verbal clashes in the corridors and the ready room during the whole episode untill the final catharsis (one of main themes in Battlestar Galactica). During the asteroid patrol, Starbuck reaches the edge of the abyss but, at the end, chooses life at the very last second (she talks about It with Helo), breaking away her suicidal impulse and lure Scar directly into Kat's line of fire, granting her the kill and the "Top Gun" honour. But It Is not possible to hide the pain and, at the end, the inner wounds emerge. Starbuck remembering with a loud and clear voice all the names of every pilot lost proves that the true burden is not holding the titlenand the honour, but remembering those who are gone.

Jenn Starr

I hated the trope of putting two women against each other. So lame. But I think the unlikable character is Kara and not Kat. Kat is right in what she is saying right NOW. Yes, Starbuck is usually the hero but not here. Not now. (Being the hero all the time is also boring and unrealistic.) Kara is the problem and Kat is the obnoxious “solution” in this episode.

Charles Heyen

Paramount is def playing the episodes fast. could not keep the videos synced on this one again. lol

streaky

Syncs with the BluRay, I think you're fine. FWIW I think the issue is a bunch of things coming together at once - for one thing quite a lot of time has passed in the last few episodes and it is easy to miss that. Kat getting over the stims is reasonable on the timeline, I think the point is more that Starbuck is unspooling so much that even Kat can see it clearly let alone anybody else. We're also not super clear how long Starbuck was on Caprica anyway, either - though it might be more of a question of can you use missing an Anders as a proxy for a longer laundry list of problems that Starbuck is having without explicitly saying it and I suspect it might be more than just Anders per se. IDK, I used to not like Kat; and I think you're not supposed to. Kat still has that one episode that I originally hated and these days I consider to be one of my favourite episodes. I also think with Anders it's as much guilt from the promise as much as the other thing.

Robyn

The music for this episode is so great! Really sets the mood from the fight scenes with Scar and drums🥁 to Starbucks sadness and we hear the violins 🎻 and then back to the drums and Scar. Bear McCreary is a genius 🎼

Tiffany Johnson

I just have to say I love watching you two watch this together! Something about this episode made me really appreciate you two as a pair 🤗

Jo

About having zero chill: Robin, Katee grew up with an older brother. That sh*t changes you. 😂

Quinn Sharon

I’ve never felt like this episode felt out of place for Starbuck. She hasn’t had a moment to process all she saw on Caprica, losing her faith in Adama, her relationship with Lee has been off since coming back from Caprica, and she’s still processing the loss/betrayal of Sharon as they show in this episode. To me this episode and the previous episode are designed to show how the compartmentalizing that’s been allowing Lee and Kara (and certainly other pilots and officers) get to this point is starting to crumble under the pressure. I think the idea of we can’t just survive but have to be worthy of surviving is still lingering on Kara. As she says here she used to not have second guessed going for the glory and pulling herself out of the fire but I think she’s starting to realize that she needs something more than glory and being the “best” as a reason to survive. I think these episodes more feel jarring because they act as very standalone in comparison to the more overarching plot heavy episodes that season 2 has given us.

S.C. McKnight

I'm not watching on Paramount - I've had the DVDs forever - but the recap scene about the rescue is in the Extended Cut of Pegasus. I feel like a lot of the missing context for Starbuck's arc at this point is there in that extended Pegasus ep.

Lucas from UK

In the Battlestar Galactica episode "Scar", during a conversation with Starbuck, Athena mixes up "us" and "them" when referring to the Galactica pilots, hinting at her own divided loyalty. Was this slip of the tongue in the original script? Do you think Athena's confusion stems from her shared memories with Boomer, or from her gradual acceptance of becoming part of the Galactica crew?

Enrica Manes

It Is tough and disturbing, in a sense, because we have two women and the impact of the machine in a breakdown dynamic where Scar can be seen as a machine of suffering, while the Cylon raider is not just an intelligent enemy fighter but It is a traumatized predator resurrected countless times (according to Sharon 's talk with Kara) ; then there is a tough parallel between Starbuck and Scar, because in it she sees a reflection of her own self-destruction, tormented by anxiety for Sam Anders trapped on Caprica and drowning in alcohol to numb the pain, and also the "insider" Kat between them while, at the same time, Kat coopes with fear by denying it, transforming it into an obsessive drive to prove herself - so the rivalry with Starbuck.

Enrica Manes

the dualism with Kat is increasingly cruel, and it is heartbreaking in a sort of facing herself aknowledge tough step inside, while in her side Kara is going so deep into Scar's aim and in the meanwhile she looks inside herself. now it is a fight between Starbuck and Starbuck, while she reflects deeper and deeper about death and life...

Enrica Manes

I think the same, Kara begins to reflect, through the contrast/mirror with Scar, on the relationship between the value of life and death: Scar can be seen as a machine of suffering, while the Cylon raider is not just an intelligent enemy fighter but It is a traumatized predator resurrected countless times (according to Sharon 's talk with Kara). Kara sees a reflection of her own last second when she talks about It with Helo: breaking away her suicidal impulse and lure Scar directly into Kat's line of fire, She granted her the kill and the "Top Gun" honour but there Is more than this honour and this Is a new important step into self consciousness for Kara