Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is a 2% Tier exclusive post. If you want to watch the un-edited reactions of BSG with me, join us in the 2%!

We go from last week's episode where Starbuck is suspiciously non-existent, to this week....where it's all Kara Thrace all the time! And she is a hot frakkin' mess y'all. Katee talks about how frustrating it was to play Starbuck in this storyline, where she is constantly failing and being torn to pieces by Kat of all people 😾

"Scar"
Directed by Michael Nankin
Written by Bradley Thompson and David Weddle

As a reminder, this is the UN-EDITED version of our reactions so you will need to have your own copy of the show to watch with us. Due to copyright rules we cannot post the full episode. You will start your version and use the timecode on our screen along with the blurred out video at the bottom to get your video as closely synced as possible.

Merch Store ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection

Full Watch-Along on YouTube: https://youtu.be/SsuucUP_dZg

If you can, please go and leave your comments on the public REACTION HIGHLIGHTS version when it airs Thursday @ 11:30 AM PT as it helps push the success of the show :)

Click here to give some love on YT ❤️

Youtube Reactions

Files

S2E15 "SCAR" | FULL WATCH-ALONG | Katee Sackhoff Watches BSG

We go from last week's episode where Starbuck is suspiciously non-existent, to this week....where it's all Kara Thrace all the time! And she is a hot frakkin' mess y'all. Katee talks about how frustrating it was to play Starbuck in this storyline, where she is constantly failing and being torn to pieces by Kat of all people 😾 As a reminder, this is the UN-EDITED version of our reactions so you will need to have your own copy of the show to watch with us. Due to copyright rules we cannot post the full episode. You will start your version and use the timecode on our screen along with the blurred out video at the bottom to get your video as closely synced as possible. Join us on Patreon! ‣ http://patreon.com/thesackhoffshow Shop Merch ‣ https://shopstands.com/collections/the-katee-sackhoff-collection Watch more episodes of The Sackhoff Show: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLiHvVvKZ9lt4-IZiosUjdxqB7IEQJJ6RU&si=e6pD8zR7TQeggRT4 ------------------------- Follow me and subscribe to keep updated on The Sackhoff Show, my film and television work, and my many other adventures! INSTAGRAM ‣ https://instagram.com/therealkateesackhoff/ FACEBOOK ‣ https://facebook.com/officialkateesackhoff/ TWITTER ‣ https://twitter.com/kateesackhoff YOUTUBE ‣ https://youtube.com/kateesackhoffofficial The Sackhoff Show SOCIAL: IG: https://www.instagram.com/thesackhoffshow TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@sackhoffshow

Comments

Will Benson

It’s not paramount cutting. RDM used to say that they’d do a cheat every now and again and show a cut scene in a previously.

Rowan K

I feel you Katee, I hated Kat so much in this episode. Such an annoying character.

Todd

FYI, I’m watching along with episodes on Apple (bought the “box set”) and everything has matched up with what you’ve been seeing on paramount so maybe the missing scenes were only on like the DVD’s or something…

Enrica Manes

Scar fight episode is so tough for Starbuck...she's lonely and hurted, she's starting to suffer, she drinks too much, far more beyond the excess, while the dualism with Kat is increasingly cruel, and it is heartbreaking in a sort of facing herself aknowledge tough step inside, while in her side Kara is going so deep into Scar's aim and in the meanwhile she looks inside herself. now it is a fight between Starbuck and Starbuck, while she reflects deeper and deeper about death and life...and she found herself hurted inside and completly forlorn...about the aim of the episode, It Is interesting see how the rivalry between Kara and Kat is not a simple competition for the title of top gun and, instead, it is a ruthless mirror of their traumas, their fear/disdain of death, the fear to be forgotten and the heavy burden of survival: right at the center of this clash moves Scar who embodies the constant horror of the end. We have two women and the impact of the machine in a breakdown dynamic where Scar can be seen as a machine of suffering, while the Cylon raider is not just an intelligent enemy fighter but It is a traumatized predator resurrected countless times (according to Sharon 's talk with Kara)... There is a tough parallel between Starbuck and Scar, because in it she sees a reflection of her own self-destruction, tormented by anxiety for Sam Anders trapped on Caprica and drowning in alcohol to numb the pain, and also the "insider" Kat between them. Kat coopes with fear by denying it, transforming it into an obsessive drive to prove herself - so the rivalry with Strabuck. Both fear to be forgotten and Kat too deeply fears oblivion and the judgment of fallen comrades, so they become there very similar, in a sort of asymmetrical clash where Kat views Starbuck as an unreachable role model to overcome and match. Meanwhile, Kara—consumed by her own existential pain—reacts with annoyance and cynism to the rookie's attempt to take her place. Then all bitterness explodes into physical and verbal clashes in the corridors and the ready room during the whole episode untill the final catharsis (one of main themes in Battlestar Galactica). During the asteroid patrol, Starbuck reaches the edge of the abyss but, at the end, chooses life at the very last second (she talks about It with Helo), breaking away her suicidal impulse and lure Scar directly into Kat's line of fire, granting her the kill and the "Top Gun" honour. But It Is not possible to hide the pain and, at the end, the inner wounds emerge. Starbuck remembering with a loud and clear voice all the names of every pilot lost proves that the true burden is not holding the titlenand the honour, but remembering those who are gone.

Enrica Manes

Me too, then, after the 3-4th rewatch, I started to think about in a more philosophical and tragical aim, as you can see from my reflections here...

Levi Gustafsson

I don't know the first thing about writing a television show besides putting words on paper, but maybe the flow of Starbuck's pining for Anders is weird because of the deleted scenes in previous episodes still being in the script to be shot and therefore effectively in the canon - but we didn't see those on the TV. Like how there's a deleted scene from Epiphanies that has Starbuck show up to Roslin's would-be deathbed to rip into her for not being allowed to return to Caprica. Funny how you disliked the storyline while shooting it, because I think this is Starbuck's probably best episode. How she's weighed down by guilt and responsibility. Before she just needed to be the best possible pilot. Not people are depending on her. Not only to keep them alive, but the entirety of humanity at time depends on how good she is in and out of a viper. That's heavy. I also have the benefit of hindsight and re-watching the show way too much. Starbuck hating the new and shiny version of herself (Kat) is so funny, and I like their duels. I do really like Kat now, but I'll admit I was also a bit peeved with her at first - how dare you come and show up my cool pilot character that I'm used to? Scar is the best of these "quiet before the storm"-episodes imo. So many good character moments that define Kara's relationships.

David V.

Starbuck is a star. Beautiful and powerful, but every so often, people around her are destroyed by her flairs. RIP BB

David V.

Question: if acting drunk is really hard, why don't actors get drunk? Sorry if it's a stupid question.

Tom K

I have watched this episode several times, and although I like the episode, especially compared to the ep. Black Market, I have another point of view on this one. It seems that Kat was acting too much like a CAG, and Apollo was not enough of one. And worse, Starbuck didn't fight Kat on how she was acting to Starbuck. She let it go, and based on the show so far, Starbuck should have fought back with Kat. But Starbuck fighting her personal demons were the theme of this episode, IMHO, and ...spoiler...spoiler...spoiler.

Anthony Doolittle

This episode is a great representation of the effects of long sustained combat conditions on the soldiers and how it affects them mentally.

ElectricalRadio

That sounds a bit risky. TV is shot on a tight schedule & the actors might start flubbing their lines. And not even care 😊!

ElectricalRadio

I liked the concept of a soldier being able to gain experience through death & resurrection to become a more deadly fighter. Perhaps a flawed fighter too, as their ("It's not a 'their' but an 'its!' gods dammit!") anger grows. I don't recall another series or movie including the idea of a living spacecraft, but they are in some SF stories. (The spaceship in one of Phillip J. Farmer's novels is sabotaged by being poisoned.)

Dave Mondo

Hey Guys! :) Regarding Paramount+. I honestly don't see what you guys are seeing because I have been on Amazon Prime since Reactica started and I see the same exact thing there that you are seeing on P+. Nothing more, nothing less. Hope that helps.

Eboe Thrasher

Paramount isn't really cutting scenes that much. I think that they just wanted to examine the little flashes of anger and stress we see from Kara, and everything comes to a head for everyone every now and again, and this clearly was a flashpoint for her. She was trying to hold it together with shit coming at her from every angle, and failing, and that's ok. Scar would be stressing all of them out, there clearly has been a lot of time since the last episode, so that's how Kat has become as clear headed as she has. But this is just a bad thing. The thing is that Kat isn't wrong a lot of the time. She acknowledged that Starbuck used to be good,and rightfully called out how bad she had been recently. They just don't tell us how long has transpired since the last episode very well on this show. This has probably been a month or two at least.

Travis Allen

The Paramount + and Apple TV versions are within 1 second of each other. The only place I've ever seen the extended cuts are on the DvDs

Travis Allen

Everone has their breaking point and Starbuck had really reached hers. There is a reflection of Tigh here in the way she was coping. Helo made the best point tht Scar was dead, Cat and Starbuck made it back

Kate

The episode is the same on the DVDs there are no missing scenes in the Paramount version.

Darren Tucci

I won't expound upon this episode as I feel others have done this quite well. However, as I stated last night on Discord, the final song used as Kara and Helo are boxing sounded eerily familiar. Turns out its the main theme song from the 1978 motion picture The Deer Hunter (Cavatina, by Stanley Myers). It is SUCH an incredibly emotive piece of music you'll well up if you let it get a hold of you. https://youtu.be/9Bbm-7vdlbs?si=T4nAsilmPtLLTqfJ

TJ

Kat really bugged me in this episode (i.e. the writers bugged me). She criticizes Kara for what she told a nugget, acting like Kara wasn't encouraging him enough. Yet a few scenes earlier she told a couple of nuggets that Scar would "smoke them like a fine cigar". Is that supposed to be encouraging? ... The tension between Kara and Kat felt very manufactured and unnecessary, and I don't like how Kat makes everything about her. Feels unearned and misplaced... Agreed, VERY well acted given the material all of you were provided.

Will Benson

Yeah but even during the original run when RDM was doing his weekly podcast he would point out “yeah…we never showed you that until now”. It was kinda a running joke.

Ranyen

I loved how they show how much of a positive influence Helo is to Starbuck this episode.

Joe Bright

One of the best parts of this episode is Scar itself. We get to see how a non-human looking Cylon can have emotions and rise above its programming. It is hurt and angry much like Starbuck and I think that is what this episode was going for.

Joe Bright

I agree. Nobody is the same after intense combat like that. It is not a switch that can by turned off or on. The show does a great job of showing the cost or war on the people who have to fight it.

The Real Andrew Kim

The apple doth protest too much wilith falleth fareth from the treeth????

Jo

The biggest reason I’m loving this reactica so much (apart from Katee and Robin’s antics) is watching Katee’s expressions while watching Starbuck at a low point. So much empathy on her face, like you would have for a best friend. P.S. Katee, you killed it as usual in this episode. I know you guys felt like Starbuck’s sudden inner turmoil was a leap or you were missing context but I buy it every time because Katee sells it. When Lee asks her “Are you okay?” there’s this quick intake of breath and she straightens her posture; puts the mask back on. Just stellar work.

Enrica Manes

Thank you! It is a pleasure for me to share these reflections because BSG is a realistic and extremely intense framework, capable of diving into the heart of human history and society. It also explores parts of ourselves to the point where we are no longer just simple spectators, but active participants in these emotions and values

Enrica Manes

Totally agree! the episode "Scar" is the true turning point for her character, she acts as a mature leader and not as a selfish loose cannon. Instead of seeking personal triumph, she realizes that the survival of the fleet and Kat's growth as a pilot are more important than her own glory. During the asteroid patrol, Starbuck reaches the edge of the abyss but, at the end, chooses life at the very last second (she talks about It with Helo), breaking away her suicidal impulse and lure Scar directly into Kat's line of fire, granting her the kill and the "Top Gun" honour.

Enrica Manes

Totally agree! It's Starbuck facing herself through the eyes of Scar and Kat. She's lonely and hurted, she's starting to suffer, she drinks too much, far more beyond the excess, while the dualism with Kat is increasingly cruel, and it is heartbreaking while in her side Kara is going so deep into Scar's aim and in the meanwhile she looks inside herself: now it is a fight between Starbuck and Starbuck, while she reflects deeper and deeper about death and life...

Mike Todd

Great point about the use of humor (often very dark!) to get you through the most intense and stressful parts of the show. I feel like our poor Robin has no idea just how dark this show gets down the road and when you do get the moments of levity it’s like a gasp of air while you are drowning! So cheers to some of my favorites past and yet to come! “No more Mr. Nice Gaius!” “Keep jumping” “p**** shortage” **** for spoiler protection, not censorship! It’s a different P word! 😂

Code Warriar

There are a lot of cut scenes from the paramount versions, and if I remember correctly they are the same versions that aired on Sci-Fi. However, if you can get you hands on the box set of the extended versions all 4 full seasons, you will see some of those scenes that were left out. I can honestly say, the extended versions adds more scenes, dialog associated with the episode. and more content on the backstory and present day story of the episodes and series. The extended version catalog is a must.

Anthony Doolittle

It captures the apathy emotionally as well as the expectation of death. If you’re out there long enough you just expect that you aren’t going home, and you accept that fact.

The Sackhoff Show

Because most scenes take 3-5 hours to shoot. How do you maintain the same level of drunk from every angle over the entire course of the scene….then go film 2-3 more scenes that day where you’re not meant to be drunk? Not possible.

Justin E.

This was maybe my least favorite episode in the whole series. Just terrible writing. Too many leaps to stories that weren't developed like Starbuck's decline. She's rattled because she's hung up on Anders and she left him behind but they just loaded that all into this episode. Kat being a super pilot all the sudden was dumb. The whole "Scar" thing wasn't worth a whole episode. Terrible episode by BSG standards. Even without the "missing scenes" issue, this would have been a really bad episode.

Jim

Lots of these “military” things are retelling of true stories from real life stories of real soldiers under this kind of stress. The fuss over being hard on new guys was done real well in To Hell and Back and Band of Brothers. Starbuck flying over the tables was portrayed similarly in The Flight of the Intruder..

John

The episode is the same on AppleTV as well but I will say the AppleTV episode screenshot do seem to match the episode. I would guess the cuts were the decision at the time of production. MAybe you need to ask Ron and David about it at some point.

Jo

I'm doing the watch along on Fandango, and the episodes over there don't have those missing scenes either.

Christopher Daniels

I get why people hated the Kat character - from a writing perspective though, art is supposed to make you feel something. So if you hated the character, then the character is doing its job. Or at least it is if the character was supposed to be hated ;-p Great episode!

zenzero

I love “Scar”, amazing episode. I have to say, though, that the whole “Kat is a great pilot” storyline is a little annoying: Kat only got Scar because Starbuck brought him right in front of her for an easy shot. So Starbuck is, and always will be, the best pilot in the Fleet. Period. Also, as painful as the Kara-Lee almost-sex scene is, I really like the way Lee is still there for her as a friend, despite everything. And the final scene, with Kara remembering all the names in the cafeteria, is one of the most moving moments in all of BSG.

zenzero

In Farscape, there’s Moya, a female Leviathan transport vessel, a living, sentient bio-mechanical spaceship. Great sci-fi series, btw :)

DJBluePDX

Re: Scar - I've got a couple things here, first that I think the juxtaposition between Kat and Starbucks is wild. I get where it's coming from, and my first question is how did playing Starbuck affect your roles following the conclusion of the show? And lastly, during scar you had a couple different comments about things that you didn't remember or weren't aware of and that were during parts of episodes that you guys were having a conversation. Which is hilarious, but just wanted to let you know

Michael Ducharme

The scene in the "previously on" was from the extended version of Pegasus which is often the one people watch these days, and I believe was the only version on the DVD's (not the aired version). It was a real shame that one scene was cut because it gave some context for why Starbuck was somewhat partial to Cain - she had just had her rescue plan idea shot down by Roslin and Adama, and Cain thought it was a great idea to go back to the colonies.