Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 81: Those Who Walked in the Rain

The first thing people shared of Hollow Knight was screenshots, before opinions.

City of Tears. Always City of Tears. Screenshots of the Knight standing in the rain with the buildings blurred behind him, the lanterns glowing in the puddles, the reflections rippling in the PC version. The players posted them on the forums like photographs from a trip: "Look where I was" with the same pride someone would show a photo of Venice or Kyoto.

But not only City of Tears. Greenpath with its swaying leaves. Crystal Peak with the crystals refracting the Knight's light into secondary halos. The Hive with its golden glow. And Deepnest, which the players posted with dark captures where you could barely see anything, accompanied by texts like "NO" or "WHY DID I COME IN HERE" or simply a row of exclamation marks.

George had never seen players share screenshots of Castlevania or Isaac with this intensity. Castlevania was beautiful but in a way the players appreciated in silence. Isaac was visually functional, not beautiful. Hollow Knight was the first NGS game that people wanted to show others because of how it looked. The screenshots were ambassadors: each one brought new players who saw the image and asked "what game is that?" and the answer was always "Hollow Knight by New Game Studios" and then "it's from the same studio that made Castlevania and Isaac" and the conversation ended in a sale.

*

The posts about the parry started the second week.

Most players didn't know the parry existed. George had designed it as an invisible mechanic: no tutorial, no indication, not a single moment in the game that said "you can destroy projectiles by attacking them." The players who discovered it did so by accident, like Tomás, and the reaction was always the same: confusion, experimentation, and then euphoria.

"I JUST DISCOVERED SOMETHING. If you attack with the nail right when a projectile is going to hit you, THE PROJECTILE DISAPPEARS. And it gives you more Soul than normal. I've been dodging projectiles for 15 hours like an idiot when I could have been DESTROYING THEM. Did everyone know this except me?"

The post had four hundred replies. Half were players who also didn't know. The other half were players who had discovered it and who were delighted to reveal that they had spent hours parrying without telling anyone because it felt like a secret superpower.

"I've been parrying for 20 hours and didn't tell anyone because I thought it was a glitch they were going to patch. Is it INTENTIONAL? Did they really put in a 3-frame window that destroys projectiles and not mention it ANYWHERE in the game?"

"I discovered the parry in my hour 2. It changed the game completely. The bosses that shoot are no longer a threat. They're a source of Soul. Hornet 2 went from being impossible to being my favorite boss because every needle I parry fills me with Soul and fills me with dopamine."

The debates about the parry window became a subgenre of the forum. Players who measured the frames with capture software and calculated that the window was 3 frames at 30 fps. Players who argued about whether 3 frames was fair or unfair. Players who posted their successful parry percentage as if it were a sports stat: "85% against Hornet 2," "60% against Soul Master orbs," "12% against Primal Aspids because those damn things shoot in a fan and I don't know which one to parry."

A player posted a video where he parried thirty consecutive projectiles of Hornet 2 without taking a single hit. The video was called "PERFECT PARRY HORNET" and racked up ten thousand views in a week, which on the internet of 2004 with dial-up connections and early broadband was an enormous number. The player moved around the arena with a fluidity that seemed choreographed: dash, attack, parry, dash, parry, attack, like a dance where each step was measured to the frame.

George saw the video and realized that the parry had achieved exactly what he had designed: to create a layer of skill that separated the players who simply played from the players who mastered. The player in the video wasn't playing Hollow Knight. He was performing it, like a musician performs a piece, with the technical precision and the personal expressiveness that turn execution into art.

*

The Hollow Knight community was different from those of Castlevania and Isaac. The Castlevania fans were cartographers who mapped every room. The Isaac fans were experimenters who tested every synergy. The Hollow Knight fans were detectives.

The Dream Nail had given them a tool to read the thoughts of the dead, and they used it with the meticulousness of forensic investigators at a crime scene. A Hollow Knight wiki appeared the third week after the launch, and by April it had more than two hundred pages of lore compiled, analyzed, debated, and connected by threads the players wove between fragments George had written in the green notebook without imagining anyone would assemble them with such precision.

A forum thread titled "THE COMPLETE HISTORY OF HALLOWNEST" collected every Dream Nail text, every NPC dialogue, every environmental inscription, every visual detail that suggested history, and organized them into a chronology that was more complete and more coherent than the one George had written in his GDD. The players had found connections George hadn't consciously planned: details of Marcus's tiles that implied things about the story Marcus hadn't put in intentionally but that emerged from the coherence of the world.

"If you look at the walls of the Abyss carefully, there are marks that look like claws but that are too uniform to be claws. They're tools. Someone DUG the Abyss. It isn't a natural place. It was built. The Pale King built the Abyss as a Vessel factory. The marks on the walls are the tools he used to dig the place where he would create his tools."

George read that post and stayed looking at the screen. Marcus had put marks on the walls of the Abyss as texture, as visual detail to break the monotony of the black surfaces. He hadn't thought of them as digging tools. But the player who analyzed them had found a meaning that was consistent with the story of the world, that fit perfectly with the lore of the Pale King, and that was now true because the player had made it true by interpreting it.

It was invisible narrative design taken to its natural conclusion: the game told a fragmentary story, and the players completed the fragments with their own interpretation, and the interpretation became canon because the story never said explicitly what was true and what wasn't. Hallownest was a world the players co-created with George without knowing it.

*

White Palace became a phenomenon.

A phenomenon of suffering, more than of admiration. The forums filled with posts about White Palace that were, in essence, screams of frustration turned into text:

"I've been in the saw room for FOUR HOURS. FOUR. HOURS. I've died 200 times. My hands are sweating. My girlfriend asked me if I was okay. I told her no. I'm not okay. The saws chase me in my dreams."

"Tip for White Palace: turn off the music. Not because it's bad (it's great) but because the silence lets you concentrate and hear your own curses in high definition."

"I completed White Palace. AMA (Ask Me Anything). No, seriously, ask me whatever you want. I earned it. I'm basically a god. A god with tendinitis."

The White Palace videos were the most shared of the game. Especially the failure videos, more than the successful ones: compilations of players dying against the same saw twenty times in a row, with screams of frustration that turned into laughter that turned into determination that turned into more screams. They were videos of shared suffering, the same phenomenon that had occurred with the Isaac death screens but amplified by the extreme difficulty and the duration of the attempts.

And the success videos were catharsis. A player who completed room 12 after hours of attempts and who screamed with a euphoria that was disproportionate to the act of moving a sprite across a screen but that was completely proportionate to the effort invested. The comments below these videos were of solidarity: "I did it too," "I cried when I completed it," "My hands shook for ten minutes afterward."

White Palace did something no other zone of the game did: it created a community within the community. The players who had completed White Palace formed a tacit club of people who had been through the same thing and who recognized each other on the forums with the camaraderie of war veterans who don't need to explain what they lived through because they all lived through it.

*

The posts about Deepnest were different from those about White Palace. White Palace produced frustration and then triumph. Deepnest produced fear and then more fear.

"I went into Deepnest at 11pm with headphones. Mistake. Catastrophic mistake. The sounds of that zone are designed to make you feel that something is behind you in real life. I took off the headphones three times. I finished the zone at 2am without headphones and with all the lights in my house on."

"My roommate came into my room while I was in Deepnest and touched my shoulder. I screamed. I really screamed. Like in a horror movie. I'm never going to forgive him and I'm never going to forget the face he made when he saw me screaming at a game about insects."

But Nosk. Nosk was the post that appeared every day, sometimes two or three times, always with the same narrative arc: a player who saw the false silhouette of the Knight, followed it out of curiosity, descended down the narrowing corridor with a growing sense that something was wrong, and then the transformation.

"I saw the other Knight and thought it was a bug. An NPC that looked like me. I followed it because I thought it was going to give me something, a Charm or information. The corridor kept getting narrower and I started to feel that I shouldn't be following it but I was already too far in to turn back. And then it turned into THAT. I'm not going to describe what it is. I'm just going to say that the sound I made when I saw the transformation was a sound I didn't know I could make."

"Nosk made me close the game. Literally Alt+F4. Not because it was hard (the fight is manageable) but because what it did before the fight turned my stomach in a way I didn't think possible with 2D pixels. Using the Knight's form to lure you into a trap is the most disturbing thing I've experienced in a game. More than Resident Evil. More than Silent Hill. Because it isn't monster horror but the horror of betrayed trust."

George read these posts with the complex satisfaction of a designer who achieved exactly what he wanted and who knows that what he wanted was to make people feel bad. Nosk was design cruelty: a mechanic that exploited the player's trust in the iconography of the character he controlled. It had worked better than George expected.

*

The debates about the endings started the fourth week and didn't stop.

The basic ending, where the Knight took the place of the Hollow Knight, generated the first wave of reactions:

"Are you telling me that after 25 hours the Knight ends up CHAINED in the Black Egg doing exactly what the Hollow Knight was doing? That I changed nothing? That the cycle continues? I need to sit down."

The true ending, with the Radiance, generated the second wave:

"I used the Dream Nail on the Hollow Knight while it was hurting itself. The game put me in a fight against a GIANT MOTH OF LIGHT in a white void while a choir ascended and the platforms disappeared below me. I died seven times. The eighth I killed it with the Dream Nail and the light went out and I fell into the Abyss among the remains of the Vessels and I sat there for five minutes without moving because I didn't know what to do. The game didn't tell me I had won. There were no credits. Just the silence and the remains of my brothers and the understanding that winning wasn't winning but surviving."

And the third ending, the one George had added in September, where the player left through the Dirtmouth door without fighting the Hollow Knight:

"THERE'S A THIRD ENDING. If you go to Dirtmouth after breaking the seals and leave through the entrance, the Knight goes. It doesn't fight. It doesn't save anything. It goes. The credits roll over a black screen. Nothing more. It's the saddest ending in the game and the most human. Sometimes the right answer is to leave."

The debates about which was the "true" ending filled hundreds of pages on the forums. George didn't intervene, because all the players' opinions were correct: each ending was true for the player who chose it, and the absence of a canonical answer was part of the design. Hollow Knight didn't have a good ending and a bad one. It had three endings that were three different answers to the same question: what do you do when you discover that you were created as a tool? Do you repeat the cycle? Do you destroy the cause? Or do you leave?

*

But the phenomenon George didn't anticipate, the one that surprised him more than the speedruns and the lore debates and the White Palace videos, was something simpler.

The players stayed.

Being there, not playing. Sitting on the benches of City of Tears listening to the rain. Standing in Greenpath watching the leaves sway. Walking through Dirtmouth to the rhythm of the piano. Just existing in Hallownest, apart from advancing or fighting or collecting or progressing, as if it were a place they wanted to be.

"I reached City of Tears after Deepnest. I was tense, stressed, with half a heart of life. I sat on the bench. The rain started. The piano started. And I stayed there twenty minutes. Breathing, not playing. Letting the rain calm me. I'd never done that in a game."

"Sometimes I open Hollow Knight just to be in Greenpath. Not to play, but to listen. My therapist told me I need a safe place to go when the anxiety is too much. Greenpath is that place."

"I'm going through a divorce. I don't want to talk about it. I just want to say that the first week after she left, I played Hollow Knight every night. Not for the action or the bosses but for the rain of City of Tears. There's something in that sound that makes everything bearable. Bearable, not better. And bearable was enough."

George read these posts in the office at eleven at night, as he did every night, with Marcus's new mural at his back and the Townsend Street office in silence. And he felt something he hadn't felt with Castlevania or Isaac: the responsibility of having created a place where people were going to feel better.

Castlevania was a game people played. Isaac was a game people couldn't stop playing. Hollow Knight was a place people went to be; to be, not to play. Like someone who goes to a park, or a church, or a friend's house. For how it feels to be there, more than for what you do.

George closed the laptop. He looked at the mural. The castle, the basement, the Knight in the rain. Three worlds he had created in six years. Each one served a different purpose. Castlevania served to amaze. Isaac served to challenge. Hollow Knight served to console.

End of Chapter 81

Comments

No comments found for this post.