CHAPTER 101: The Independent (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 101: The Independent
Andrew Reiner arrived at Townsend Street on Tuesday, December 6, 2005, at nine in the morning with a handheld Marantz recorder, two notebooks, a sketchbook for jotting down visual ideas, and a Game Informer press pass hanging from his neck even though no one at NGS had asked him for it.
Reiner was thirty-four years old, had spent seven years working at the magazine, and had written reviews of most of the important games of the last five years. He was tall, wore black-framed glasses, and had the voice of someone who had learned to ask questions without it seeming like he was asking them. The editor of Game Informer, Andy McNamara, had approved the cover feature after a call from Claire in November. The agreement: four days in the office, access to the team, no topic off-limits, editorial review rights limited to technical inaccuracies. Claire had negotiated the last point for forty minutes. She had gotten it because the editor wanted the feature more than NGS needed it.
George received Reiner at the door. He shook his hand. He offered him coffee. He told him to consider himself at home, a lie both of them accepted as a gesture of courtesy and not as an operational promise.
"Where do we start?" Reiner asked.
"Wherever you want. The office is yours for four days."
Reiner started at the back wall, where Marcus had finished the mural in September. Four worlds on a single horizontal plane: the castle and its roots, the Isaac basement with the weeping creature, the Knight in the rain of City of Tears, and the street with palm trees and the orange sunset over the silhouette of CJ. Reiner stood for three minutes in front of the mural. He took five photos. He didn't ask what each part represented. He knew what each part represented. He had played the three previous games.
"We start here," Reiner said when he turned around. "I want to understand what these four worlds have in common."
George looked at him. It was the right question. The question he himself hadn't asked out loud.
"That none of them exists," George said.
Reiner opened the notebook. He wrote down the sentence.
*
The next four hours were an interview that didn't resemble an interview. Reiner walked through the office. He sat next to people. He asked questions that seemed trivial and that ended up opening forty-minute conversations. He was good at his job. George recognized it within half an hour and relaxed a degree.
Marcus showed him the reference wall of the art team. Ten people. Marcus at the front, Lukas the German to his right, Yuki the Japanese woman who had come via Kenji, Tomás as tester and reference from the office, Sam the kid from Detroit who had sent a portfolio without anyone asking, two environment artists hired after the E3 that wasn't, and the latest hire: Priya Sharma, she had been on the team for five years, had come from Academy of Art SF, and drew palm trees as if she had been born in Pasadena even though she was from Mumbai.
"It's the strangest team in the studio," Marcus told Reiner. "Ten people from six countries. The only thing we have in common is that none of us had made a 3D open world before Los Santos."
"And how do you coordinate?" Reiner asked.
"George doesn't tell us what to do," Marcus said. "He tells us what to believe."
Reiner wrote down the sentence with a circle around it. George was on the other side of the office but he heard it. Marcus had the kind of voice that reached the corners even when he spoke quietly.
*
Daniel showed the engine to Reiner in the afternoon. He sat him in the programming chair, opened the NGN editor, and started to explain the thirteen systems like a mechanic explaining the components of a V8 engine to a journalist who knew how to drive but didn't know how a fuel injection pump worked.
"Thirteen systems," Daniel said. "Streaming. Lighting. Shadows. Animation. Physics. NPC AI. Traffic AI. Spatial audio. Exterior rendering. Interior rendering. Day/night cycle. Weather. And the scripting system that joins the previous twelve into a single coherent simulation."
"You built it from scratch?"
"Layer by layer. The streaming first. The lighting on top. The shadows on top. Each layer supported by the previous one. If one of the thirteen fails, the other twelve tremble."
Reiner looked at the screen. Visible polygons. Wireframe of a five-story building in South Central. Half-applied textures. An NPC looping a walk animation aimlessly. Daniel showed him how the next chunk loaded when the player moved. He showed him how the streetlamps turned on with their specific delay. He showed him the system of lies, the two hundred optimizations that stopped calculating what the player didn't see.
"How long did this take you?" Reiner asked.
"Three years. And I'm still not done."
Reiner wrote it down. "And before NGS?"
"I studied at Berkeley. I made a toy compiler for my thesis. I saw the first NGS Castlevania. I sent George an email. George answered me in five minutes. That was 1999. I've been here ever since."
Reiner closed the notebook for a second and looked at Daniel. "Do you realize how strange this is?"
"What?"
"A proprietary 3D engine. Made by one person. At an indie studio. To make an open world. In 2007. Do you realize?"
Daniel shrugged. "George asked me to. I said yes."
*
Reiner crossed the Bay Bridge on Wednesday morning to visit Lena at the Mission studio. The studio was in a converted warehouse on Treat Avenue. Lena received him with a Schoeps microphone mounted on a boom stand and with a Sound Devices recorder connected to Sennheiser headphones. She explained the capture chain to him as if Reiner were a colleague.
"Schoeps because the self-noise is minimal. The Sound Devices because the preamp is transparent. The Sennheisers because after six hours your ears don't hurt. If your ears hurt, you stop hearing details. If you stop hearing details, you record anything."
Reiner asked the question he had prepared. "Why record everything live? Sound libraries exist."
Lena looked at him. It was the look of when someone asked the wrong question for the right reason, a look the NGS team knew and that Reiner discovered that morning.
"The libraries are sounds that already exist in other games. If I use a library, my game sounds like other games. If I record live, my game sounds like Los Santos. And Los Santos has to sound like Los Santos and like nothing else."
Lena showed him the recordings of the last month. The sound of the Santa Monica surf recorded at five in the morning when there were no tourists. The sound of a city bus starting up on Mission Street. The sound of a palm tree moving with a twelve-knot wind. The sound of a background conversation in a Chinese restaurant on Geary Boulevard that Lena had recorded with the owner's permission in exchange for mentioning the restaurant in the credits.
Reiner wrote it down. He took photos. Lena played him three bars of the piano that was going to be on CSR, the soul radio station of Los Santos. Reiner closed his eyes to listen. When he opened them, he said "this is going to make someone cry." Lena didn't answer. But she smiled.
*
On Thursday Reiner interviewed George in the back office for three hours straight. The office was small, with a wooden desk, two chairs, a window that looked onto the inner courtyard of the Townsend building, and the black Los Santos notebook open on the desk with sketches, notes, and a folded page that had the listing of the districts.
Reiner asked permission to photograph the notebook. George hesitated. The notebook had things he didn't want to be public, the names of the missions, the plot twists, the decisions of the last few months. But it also had the page of the districts, which was public in the broad sense of the word.
"The page of the districts, yes," George said. "The rest, no."
Reiner photographed that page. Then he closed the notebook and started the interview.
The questions Reiner asked were questions George had answered partially to other journalists but that Reiner formulated in a way that asked for deeper answers. Why Los Angeles? Why gangs? Why after Hollow Knight? Why an open world when NGS had built its reputation on closed, millimeter-designed worlds?
George answered with the partial honesty he had learned to manage. The partial honesty was the truth without the part about the other life. Enough truth for the answers to sound real. Little enough truth that the origin wasn't contaminated with impossible explanations.
"Castlevania, Isaac, Hollow Knight," George said. "Three games in worlds people couldn't inhabit. Caves. Basements. Subterranean kingdoms. Places where the camera stayed still and let the player do his thing in a two-dimensional space. What interested me about those games was the contrast between the physical scale of the world, small, and the emotional scale, gigantic. Hollow Knight fits on a screen but takes up a year of your life if you let it."
Reiner wrote it down.
"Los Santos is the opposite," George continued. "A world that technically fits in a single aerial view but that when you travel it by car takes twenty minutes to cross. Physically enormous. And the question I ask myself is: can a physically enormous world have the same emotional density as a physically small world? Or does the scale dilute it?"
"And the answer?"
"I don't know. I'll know when I launch it."
Reiner laughed. "It's the most honest answer I've heard in three years of interviews."
"It's the only answer I have."
*
Reiner left Friday afternoon with three hours of recording, two full notebooks, a hundred twenty digital photos, and the promise to send the pre-publication galley before sending it to print. Claire had demanded it. Reiner had agreed.
The galley arrived by email on December 18. Eight pages. Double-page photos. Reiner had written the feature with the cadence of a long profile from a non-specialized magazine: it started with the mural, passed through Marcus and Daniel and Lena, arrived at George, and closed with a reflection on what it meant that a forty-person studio was building a 3D open world in 2007.
The cover title: THE INDEPENDENT.
The subtitle: FIRST LOOK: LOS SANTOS.
George read the galley twice. The first time he read it as an editor, looking for technical inaccuracies, date errors, misinterpretations of mechanics. He found three and marked them. The second time he read it as the subject, as the person who was going to be read by five million households in January. And that second reading cost him.
Reiner had used the sentence as the hinge of the article. "George doesn't tell us what to do. He tells us what to believe." The sentence was quoted in the first paragraph, in the middle of the feature, and in the closing. Each time in a different context. Each time with an additional meaning. The first time as a description of a work method. The second as a description of a culture. The third as a description of a person.
George read the last quote for the third time. He closed the laptop. He stayed silent for a minute. He had worked eight years for the team to say sentences like that about him. And when they finally said them in public, he didn't know how to receive them.
Claire came into the office without knocking.
"Did you read it?" Claire asked.
"I read it."
"And?"
"I'm not comfortable with the First Look."
"George."
"It's a year before the launch. We're promising something we haven't finished yet."
Claire sat in the chair on the other side of the desk. She crossed her legs. She looked at him with the patience she had developed over eight years of making her brother understand how the business world worked.
"They need to anticipate," Claire said. "The First Look isn't a promise but a hinge. It's what makes the public start to wait for it. If they don't anticipate, they don't buy. If they don't buy, we don't recover the five million we already spent. Do you want us to give them the game or charge them for it?"
"I know they need to anticipate."
"Then accept the First Look and sleep easy."
George nodded. Claire was right. Claire was right nine out of ten times she explained something about business to him. The tenth time she was also right but George realized it later.
*
The January 2006 issue of Game Informer reached 5 million households in the first week. The GameStop subscribers received the magazine in the mail. The physical stores put it at the registers. The airport newsstands stacked it next to Wired and Sports Illustrated. The cover with the words THE INDEPENDENT in bold white on a black background became one of the most recognizable covers of the year.
In the Mission neighborhood of San Francisco, one Saturday at noon, a forty-year-old father went into the 7-Eleven on the corner of 24th and Mission with his ten-year-old son. They bought a Slurpee, two packets of Skittles, and a copy of Game Informer because the boy collected the issues of the months when the covers had something that interested him.
"Look," said the boy, opening the magazine to the feature page. "It's Los Santos. The one that comes out next year."
The father looked at the page. He saw the photo of George in front of the mural. He saw the name of the studio in the caption. New Game Studios.
"This is the thing from the Brannan Street guys," the father said.
"What?"
"Where this started. Before. On Brannan Street. That's where the old office was. I played Symphony of the Night when it came out."
The boy didn't know what Brannan Street was or what Symphony of the Night was. But he registered the fact. The father was saying that NGS had existed before Los Santos, that it had a history, that the Game Informer feature was just the most recent chapter. The boy was named Tommy Park. He was ten years old. He lived in Bernal Heights. His father was an architect.
They left the 7-Eleven with the Slurpee half-finished and the magazine folded in the boy's backpack. The father told him, as they walked back home, what Brannan Street was. What Castlevania was. What it meant for a San Francisco studio to make a 3D open world and end up on the cover of the biggest magazine in the country. The boy listened halfway. The things the father said got recorded halfway, in that zone of memory that remembers facts without knowing it remembers them until it recovers them two decades later.
*
George received the magazine in the mail on January 5. It arrived in a padded envelope with the Game Informer logo in the corner. He took it out of the envelope. He looked at it. The black cover with the white title. His own photo inside. The eight-page feature.
He took it to the office shelf. The shelf where he kept the publications that had covered NGS in the studio's seven years. PC Gamer from June 1999 with the Castlevania review. Wired from November 2003 with the short profile of George. And now Game Informer from January 2006 with the First Look of Los Santos.
Three magazines. Three moments. Seven years between the first and the last.
He put the Game Informer next to the other two. The shelf filled up. There was a small space left at the end, enough for one or two more before he would have to buy another shelf or reorganize the system.
George stood in front of the shelf for a minute. He thought about what it meant that three magazines could sum up seven years of work. Not much. And at the same time everything. The magazines weren't the work. But they were the marks the work had left on the outside world. And the marks, though small, were what said the work had happened.
He closed the shelf. He went back to his desk. He opened the black Los Santos notebook to the page of the East Beach district he had been reviewing before the magazine arrived. He had to decide whether the main avenue had three lanes or four. A decision no one was going to remember and that he was going to have to make before Friday.
The First Look was filed away. The work continued.
End of Chapter 101