CHAPTER 109: The Rehearsals (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 109: The Rehearsals
Four weeks before E3 2006, NGS stopped making Los Santos and started making the demo of Los Santos.
The difference was important. Making Los Santos meant building an open world of thirty-six square kilometers with six districts and twenty-five Act 1 missions. Making the demo of Los Santos meant choosing fifteen minutes of the game that were going to represent everything else, making sure those fifteen minutes ran without a single crash, and polishing them until each frame was the best possible frame of the game.
George gathered the team on Monday, April 17, in the Townsend Street conference room with a blank whiteboard and a question written at the top in red marker: WHAT DO WE SHOW?
The answers came fast. Marcus wanted the Santa Monica sunset with the water shader. Daniel wanted the transition from South Central to Downtown because it was the most impressive technical proof. Elena wanted a complete mission, one from Act 1, so the journalists would see the quality of the design. Lena wanted the moment where the streetlamps turned on with their random delay because it was the detail that was going to sell the game without anyone knowing why.
George listened to them. Then he wrote on the whiteboard beneath the question:
FIVE MINUTES OF DRIVING THROUGH SOUTH CENTRAL. FIVE MINUTES OF A MISSION. FIVE MINUTES OF A CHASE.
"The journalists aren't going to see all of Los Santos. They're going to see what we show them. If we show them a sunset, they're going to remember a sunset. If we show them a mission, they're going to remember a mission. What we need is to show the system. The world, the story, and the consequence. Fifteen minutes where the engine proves the city exists, where the writer proves the people exist, and where the wanted-level system proves the actions have weight. If we capture those three, we capture the game."
*
Daniel made the first demo build on Wednesday, April 19.
It crashed at minute seven.
The crash occurred when CJ received a call from Sweet in the middle of the initial driving and the cutscene of the call interacted with the streaming system in a way the code hadn't anticipated: the chunk CJ was crossing unloaded during the cutscene and when the cutscene ended, the engine tried to render a chunk that no longer existed in memory. Black screen. Crash. Reboot.
Daniel spent the next eighteen hours tracking the bug. He found it at four in the morning on Thursday: the streaming system unloaded chunks based on CJ's position, not on whether CJ was in a cutscene. During a cutscene, CJ could technically be standing at one point of the map while the camera showed another point, which made the streaming unload the chunk where CJ's body wasn't even though the cutscene needed it.
The fix was simple: during cutscenes, the streaming blocked the unloading of any chunk that was visible in the camera, not at the player's position. Four lines of code Daniel wrote at four fifteen in the morning and that he tested until five before going to sleep three hours on the office couch.
The Thursday nine-in-the-morning build reached the end of the fifteen minutes with no crashes.
But something else was breaking.
*
Marcus found the second problem during the first complete rehearsal on Friday, April 21.
The four of them were in the conference room: George, Marcus, Daniel, and Elena. Marcus played the demo on the big screen while George timed it with a kitchen timer Claire had lent him and Daniel monitored the framerate from a second screen.
At exactly nine minutes, in the middle of the Act 1 shootout, Marcus stopped playing.
"The textures of the alley wall look worse than the rest," Marcus said, looking at a wall three meters from CJ.
Daniel looked at his screen. "The framerate is stable at 30. There's no LOD active. That texture is the final texture."
"The final texture is wrong."
George came over to the screen. The wall was a gray brick wall with bullet marks that accumulated with the shootout. And Marcus was right: the texture of the brick was visibly worse than the textures of the surrounding buildings. The bricks had a repetitive pattern that was noticeable from a meter away. The shadow didn't bounce with the light like the rest of the surfaces of the district.
"When was this texture made?" George asked.
Marcus closed his eyes. "In October of last year. When I was still calibrating the materials of the district."
"And no one updated it?"
"It was a test texture. I assigned it to the alley thinking I was going to replace it later. But five months later, the alley kept the test texture because no one touched it again."
George looked at the alley. It was exactly the kind of detail that went unnoticed in production and that was impossible to ignore in a rehearsal where it was known that every frame was going to be looked at by journalists with the attention of someone looking for defects.
"Replace it," George said.
"How long do I have?"
"Three weeks until E3. Two for the final build."
Marcus nodded. That night he stayed until two in the morning painting a new brick texture with the pattern variation and the response to lighting the alley required to look as good as the rest. He painted it three times because the first two didn't convince him. The third he integrated into the engine on Monday at nine and the afternoon build had the alley with the new texture, indistinguishable from the rest of the district to the eyes of anyone except Marcus's, who was going to know forever where the texture was that he had replaced three weeks before E3 because the old texture had survived five months of production.
*
Elena discovered the third problem on Tuesday, April 25.
The Act 1 shootout mission lasted six minutes. George had calibrated it for the player to complete it in four or five, depending on his skill. But in the rehearsal, Marcus, who wasn't a skilled shootout player, completed it in eight minutes. And in doing so, he demonstrated a problem the team hadn't detected in months of internal testing.
The Ballas in the shootout had little variety of behavior. Once the player understood the pattern, the Ballas were predictable. But the first minute, before the pattern became evident, the Ballas were chaotic: they came out of the doors with random timing, fired from angles the player couldn't anticipate, and took cover in places the AI chose with the fuzzy logic of a system that preferred surprise to realism.
For an experienced player, the chaos was trivial. For Marcus, it was frustrating. Marcus died three times in the first minute before learning that the Ballas always came out of the back door two seconds after CJ crossed the middle of the alley.
"The learning curve of the first minute is too hard," Elena said after the rehearsal. "If a journalist plays this at E3 and dies three times before he can demonstrate the system, he's going to remember that he died. He's not going to remember the system."
"Do we lower the difficulty of the demo?"
"No. We change the conditions of the mission. The mission of the full game is fine for a player who already played two hours. For the demo, let's make a version where the Ballas have more predictable patterns the first thirty seconds. The player learns the rhythm. Then the difficulty rises to normal levels."
George approved the demo version. Elena implemented it on Wednesday. Thursday's rehearsal with the new version made Marcus complete the mission in six minutes with no visible frustration, which was exactly what the demo needed: for the player to feel capable, for the system to be demonstrated, and for the journalist who was watching or playing to come away with the impression that Los Santos was a game where the player could do what he wanted because the game gave him back control instead of taking it away.
*
The two final weeks before E3 were the two most intense weeks NGS had lived since the launch of Castlevania seven years earlier.
Daniel optimized the framerate of the demo until reaching a stable 60fps on PC. Marcus refined each texture of the chunks the demo was going to travel through, making sure none was the old alley texture. Elena adjusted the timings of each mission and each cutscene so the fifteen minutes timed exactly. Lena finalized the audio mix with the radio playing at a volume that was audible but that didn't compete with the dialogues.
And George rewrote the opening cutscene three times.
The first version lasted three minutes. George considered it too long: three minutes before the player touched a button was asking too much patience. He cut it to two.
The second version of two minutes eliminated CJ's voice-over that established his motivation for coming back. George considered it too short: without the voice-over, CJ was a character with no context, and the journalists who saw the cutscene weren't going to understand why CJ was landing in LA instead of staying on the East Coast.
The third version lasted two minutes and fourteen seconds. It restored the voice-over but shortened the establishing shots of the city: instead of showing Los Santos from the air for thirty seconds, it showed only ten. And the voice-over came in earlier, over the first shots, which gave the player narrative information while he was still processing visually.
George took three days to accept that two minutes and fourteen seconds was the right duration. It was one of those decisions where any change felt like an improvement and a rejection at the same time: adding a second lost energy, removing a second lost clarity. The duration it had was the duration it had to be, and the only way to know it was to have tried it in both directions first.
*
Claire spent those weeks negotiating logistics.
The NGS stand at E3 measured twenty square meters and cost fifteen thousand dollars. Claire had considered hiring an events agency to set up the stand, but the cheapest quote was twelve thousand dollars just for the setup, which added to the rental made the whole stand cost more than the monthly payroll of the art team. Claire decided that NGS was going to set up the stand without an agency.
Daniel designed the structure: two aluminum tubes from Home Depot to hold the main banner, a folding plastic table for the demonstration PCs, four chairs. Marcus painted the cloth banner himself in the inner courtyard of the Townsend Street building over a weekend, using a projector to transfer the design and sun-resistant acrylic paint. The Los Santos logo over the silhouette of the city at sunset came out so well that Marcus considered painting it again on a bigger canvas to hang it in the office after E3.
Claire rented a van to transport everything to LA. Marcus, Daniel, and George were going to drive in shifts. Claire was going to travel by plane because someone had to be in San Francisco to answer the emails of the journalists confirming private interviews during the three days of E3 and because Claire preferred the predictable questions of the email to the unpredictable questions of the van.
*
The last Friday before E3, NGS did the last complete rehearsal of the demo.
It was eleven at night. The office was empty except for the four of them: George, Marcus, Daniel, and Elena. Lena had already gone to her Hayes Valley apartment after approving the final audio mix. Claire had left at nine after printing the itineraries and the press passes they were going to use during the three days.
Daniel started the demo. Marcus played it. George timed it. Elena took notes.
Fifteen minutes exactly. No crashes. Stable framerate. Opening cutscene in two minutes and fourteen seconds. Initial driving of three minutes with the radio playing at the right volume. The shootout mission in six minutes without Marcus dying more than once. Police chase in four minutes with the camera following the action without problems. Closing cutscene with CJ parking in front of his house in the sunset.
When it ended, the four of them stayed silent. It was the first time the demo had run complete without interruptions, without pauses to adjust timings, without a shout from Daniel when something broke. Fifteen clean minutes.
"It's ready," Elena said.
George looked at the black screen where the demo had ended. "It's ready," he repeated.
Daniel backed up the build on three USB hard drives he was going to carry to LA in three different pockets of three different jackets because Daniel was a man who understood that redundancy was the only antidote to disaster and that carrying three copies was the cheap cost of not having to explain why he carried fewer.
Marcus turned off the screen. The Townsend Street conference room was lit only by the light from the street coming through the back window.
"Tomorrow we travel," George said.
"Tomorrow we arrive at the Westin," Daniel said. "And on Monday E3 starts."
"And we find out if three years of work matter."
Marcus laughed. The laugh was tired. "Three years matter, George. The question is whether the journalists are going to think so too."
George closed the black Los Santos notebook he had brought to the room to take notes during the rehearsal and that he hadn't opened. He put it in the backpack. He turned off the light.
That night he slept five hours, which was an hour more than he had slept during the previous four weeks. Saturday morning, the three of them got in the van. Daniel drove the first shift. Marcus put on a nineties mixtape Lena had recorded him as a pre-E3 gift with the note "for the road and for luck" written on the cassette in green ink.
They crossed the Bay Bridge at nine thirty in the morning. The sun came through the windows of the van. The city of San Francisco was left behind. Ahead there were six hours of highway and the question Marcus had posed the night before: whether three years of work were going to matter to anyone besides themselves.
End of Chapter 109