CHAPTER 114: Pre-orders and Promises (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 114: Pre-orders and Promises
Claire opened the Los Santos pre-order report the first Monday of November 2006 with the surgical calm of someone who was going to read a number and not flinch regardless of what number it was.
Fifty-two thousand pre-orders.
Fifty-two thousand people who had reserved a game they weren't going to receive until June of the following year, based on a three-minute trailer, on the May E3 coverage, on the August PAX panel, and on the September Geoff Keighley interview on GameTrailers TV. They had reserved on NG Store for PC, on Amazon for Xbox 360 and PS3, and on GameStop for PS2 and original Xbox. Five thousand had checked the option for the collector's edition NGS had announced in October for $79.99 and that included an extra disc with the complete soundtrack, a 60-page art book, and a physical map of Los Santos printed on thick paper that Marcus had designed over a weekend.
Claire printed the report. She folded it in four. She took it to George's office.
"Fifty-two thousand," Claire said.
George set down the pen. "It's good."
"It's quadruple the projection we had in August."
"What were you projecting in August?"
"Twelve thousand. Based on typical pre-orders for AAA games six months before launch. Fifty-two thousand breaks the model."
George looked at the printed figure. The figure meant nothing to him in absolute terms: five years earlier it would have been an impossible dream, five years later it was going to be a fraction of what Los Santos would generate in a single launch week. But in November 2006, in the context where NGS had sold a total of four million copies of three games in seven years, fifty-two thousand people reserving a game that didn't exist yet was a promise that weighed.
"Does it mean we're going to sell well?" George asked.
"It means people are waiting. The conversion of pre-order to day-one purchase is 80% historically. It means we have at least forty thousand confirmed buyers for launch day without counting anyone who didn't pre-order. It's the initial curve. And the initial curve is what defines the first week, and the first week is what defines the cultural conversation around the game."
"And what do we do with that?"
Claire sat in the chair on the other side of the desk. "We confirm it. Tomorrow we send an email to each pre-orderer with an update on the development status. No spoilers. No promises we can't keep. Just: the game is going well, the launch date holds, thank you for the trust. It's what a responsible studio does when fifty-two thousand people hand it money in advance: it reminds them that they exist and that the money is being well used."
George approved the email. Janet Park wrote it that night. It went out Tuesday morning to the fifty-two thousand pre-orderers. The open rate was 73%, which Janet described as "extraordinary" because gaming industry marketing emails had typical open rates of 18 to 25%.
Fifty-two thousand people hadn't only reserved the game. They were reading every email NGS sent them.
* * *
The first unexpected consequence of the E3 coverage was that the indie developers started to see NGS as a model.
George received seven emails from founders of small studios during September and October of 2006. Each email had the same structure: a paragraph of introduction, two paragraphs about the game the sender was developing, and a question about how NGS had managed to build Los Santos with a team of forty people when the equivalent AAAs needed four hundred.
George answered each email personally. The emails came from people who were where he had been in 1999: with an idea and with no one to ask how to turn it into a studio. George had learned seven years earlier that when you had answers, giving the answers was one of the few truly free things you could do.
The answers he gave were the same ones he gave himself: don't hire more people than necessary, don't accept money from publishers in exchange for creative control, make a single game at a time with the whole team, and write a design notebook before writing a line of code.
One of the emails came from a young developer who was making a solo platformer and who signed only with his initial. The email was long, technically detailed, and ended with the question: "How did you decide when the game was finished? Every time I think it's finished, I find something else to add." George answered him with a sentence Daniel had said to him three years earlier: "A game is never finished. It's released." The developer thanked him in another email.
* * *
Sony sent the first developer relations representative to the Townsend Street office the second Thursday of November.
His name was Hiroshi Yamada. Thirty-eight years old. He wore a perfectly ironed gray suit and a Sony Computer Entertainment America badge hanging from his neck even though he was at a private meeting in an office where no one was going to ask him for identification. Yamada spoke English with a slight accent and the rigorous courtesy of a Japanese executive who had learned that every word in a negotiation was interpreted twice: once for the literal meaning and once for the cultural subtext.
Claire received him in the conference room with two cups of American coffee Yamada accepted without touching. George was sitting on the other side of the table with the black notebook closed in front of him.
"Sony would like to propose a collaboration," Yamada said after the two minutes of opening courtesies that Japanese business culture demanded.
"What kind of collaboration?" Claire asked.
"Temporary exclusivity. Los Santos on PS3 before any other platform. A three-month window. Sony promotes the game on its channels as exclusive during those three months. Then it's released for Xbox 360, PS2, original Xbox, and PC. In exchange: additional financing of five million dollars for marketing and a premium slot at the Sony conference at E3 2007."
Claire processed the offer in silence for ten seconds. It was an aggressive offer. Sony was offering what no other platform had offered NGS: money in exchange for exclusivity. It was exactly the kind of deal the big publishers made to lock down promising games. And it was exactly the kind of deal Claire had decided years earlier that NGS was never going to accept.
"Thank you for the offer," Claire said with the diplomacy she had developed over six years of negotiating with publishers. "But NGS doesn't do exclusives. Los Santos is going to come out simultaneously on the five platforms we've announced. PS3, PS2, Xbox 360, original Xbox, and PC. On June 15, 2007."
Yamada nodded. The refusal didn't surprise him. It was part of the protocol: make the aggressive offer, receive the refusal, adjust.
"Understood. Could Sony have an exclusive period of one month? Two weeks?"
"Zero. Simultaneous on the five platforms. The players of each platform deserve access on the same day. That's the position of NGS and it isn't negotiable."
Yamada looked at George. George hadn't spoken. Yamada expected George to intervene to soften Claire's position, or to open an alternative Claire hadn't considered. George didn't intervene. Claire's position was the position of NGS, and the position of NGS didn't adjust according to who it was negotiating with.
"I understand," Yamada said finally. "In that case, Sony would like to offer another kind of collaboration. Technical resources. A PS3 optimization team that can work with your programmers over the next six months to make sure the PS3 version is the best possible version. At no cost to NGS. With no conditions."
Claire looked at George. George looked at Yamada. The new offer had no visible counterpart. Sony was offering free help.
"Why?" George asked.
Yamada allowed himself a small smile. The first of the meeting. "Because Los Santos is going to be one of the important games of 2007. Sony wants the PS3 version to be the one the press mentions first. For quality. If the PS3 version is the one that looks best and runs best, the reviews are going to say so, and the buyers are going to choose that platform. Sony wins without needing exclusivity."
George nodded. It was a smart offer. It was the offer a Japanese executive would make after learning that the Americans didn't accept exclusives but that they did accept technical help when the help came with no price.
"We accept," George said. "But the technicians work under Daniel's direction. And any change they make has to pass through our review before being integrated. Sony doesn't touch the code without our permission."
"Of course."
Yamada stood. He shook hands with Claire. He shook hands with George. He left with his courtesy intact and with a verbal agreement that was going to become a real collaboration when the four Sony technicians arrived at Townsend Street in January to work with Daniel.
When Yamada left, Claire looked at George from the table.
"You could have said yes to the exclusivity," Claire said. "Five million extra dollars and a slot at the Sony conference would have been good."
"They would have been dependence. Today we'd accept five million for exclusivity. Tomorrow we'd want ten for DLCs. Then thirty for an exclusive sequel. And in two years NGS would be a Sony first-party studio with a branch in California. That isn't what we are."
"I know. But it would have been nice to get five million."
George laughed. It was one of the few times Claire joked about money. Generally Claire treated money with the solemnity of a priest. But after seven years, Claire had developed a dry humor about the financial decisions NGS made against the easier money because the easier money always came with conditions the harder money didn't have.
* * *
Microsoft sent its own representative two weeks later.
She was a forty-year-old woman named Sarah Mitchell who wore a navy blue suit and a Microsoft Game Studios badge. Her offer was almost identical to Sony's but inverted: temporary exclusivity on Xbox 360 in exchange for five million for marketing and a slot at the Microsoft conference at E3 2007.
Claire rejected the offer with the same words she had used with Yamada. Mitchell offered technical help as an alternative, just like Yamada. Claire accepted.
What Claire didn't tell Mitchell was that she had already accepted the same technical help from Sony. What Mitchell didn't ask was whether Sony had been there two weeks earlier. The two companies knew NGS was talking with both. The negotiation was of explicit words but the information circulated through parallel channels: the two companies shared contacts in the industry, the rumors traveled, and the simple fact that Yamada had left the Townsend Street building in November was information that reached Mitchell's team without anyone having to say it.
George learned about the game from the inside through Daniel, who received the technicians of both companies when they arrived in January. The four Sony technicians and the three Microsoft technicians worked in the same Townsend Street office, at tables separated by ten meters. They didn't interact directly. But each one knew the other was there. And each one did his work with the silent awareness that any optimization they contributed to their platform was going to be compared with the optimizations of the other platform when the reviews came out in June.
The invisible rivalry worked. The PS3 version ran at a stable 30fps with high-resolution shadows. The Xbox 360 version ran at a stable 30fps with textures compressed 15% less than the PS3 version. The two versions were the best Los Santos could run on each platform. And both were the result of silent competition between two companies that knew NGS didn't accept exclusives but that it did accept help.
* * *
George closed the black Los Santos notebook in the Townsend Street office the last Friday of December 2006.
The year had started with the first public presentation of the game at E3 and had ended with fifty-two thousand pre-orders, two visits from console manufacturers offering money in exchange for exclusivity, seven emails from indie developers asking for advice, and a calendar that marked 169 days until the June 15 launch.
Marcus came over to the desk with two beers. It was the last day before the year-end break. The office was empty except for the two of them.
"Fifty-two thousand," Marcus said, sitting in the chair on the other side.
"Plus the ones coming in the next six months. We'll probably reach two hundred thousand pre-orders by May."
"Two hundred thousand people willing to pay in advance for something they haven't tried?"
"Two hundred thousand people who trust what we did before. They trust because of the three games we already made."
Marcus took a sip of beer. He stayed quiet for a moment.
"It's strange to think of it that way. That they trusted us before. And that now they buy in advance because they trusted before."
"That's what a studio does. Each game builds the trust of the next. That's why the launches matter: because each launch defines what we're going to be able to do in the next launch. If Los Santos goes badly, the pre-orders of the game that comes after are going to be five thousand, not two hundred thousand. If it goes well, they're going to be four hundred thousand. Each game is a promise we collect on in the next."
Marcus nodded. He took another sip.
"Are you nervous?"
George looked out the window. Townsend Street was empty at seven in the evening on the last Friday of December. The streetlamps had turned on half an hour earlier. The lights of the building across the street cast yellow circles on the sidewalk.
"Every night," George said. "But the nerves are about the people who are trusting. Two hundred thousand people believing we're going to deliver something worthwhile. The responsibility weighs more than the game. We control the game. We don't control the trust."
Marcus finished the beer. He set the bottle on the desk.
"The game is going to be fine. We did what needed to be done."
"I know."
"Let's go home. It's Christmas. Mom is waiting for you with chili."
George closed the notebook. He turned off the lamp. They went down together to the lobby. Marcus walked off toward Mission Street. George got in his car and drove toward Oakland with the radio tuned to KFOG and with the clear awareness that the next six months were going to determine whether the next ten years of NGS were built on success or on the other thing that five years earlier had seemed impossible and that now seemed only a distant possibility among many more probable ones.
End of Chapter 114