Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 122: The Big Magazines

The reviews of Los Santos in the gaming publications had taken up all of July. IGN, GameSpot, EGM, Edge, Game Informer, Eurogamer, Next Generation. The scores, the sales, the consolidation of NG Store as the second digital platform on the market. It was the avalanche seen from inside the industry.

What hadn't been told was the avalanche seen from outside.

Because something had happened between October and November 2007 that neither Claire nor George had anticipated. Los Santos had left the gaming niche. The magazines that covered it were no longer only the video game magazines. They were magazines, newspapers, and radio programs that covered culture. And the coverage wasn't limited to whether the game was good. It asked what it meant that it existed.

* * *

The first sign appeared on ESPN.com on October 18. A three-thousand-word article titled "The Soundtrack of a City That Doesn't Exist." The journalist, John Smallwood, had been a sports columnist for fifteen years. He had agreed to write the article because his fourteen-year-old son hadn't come out of his room in a week and because Smallwood had gone into the room trying to understand what had his son trapped.

Smallwood had found the game with the radio on. The radio was Bounce FM. Rick James was playing. Smallwood was African American, had grown up in Philadelphia, and recognized the music as the music of his own adolescence. He started playing with his son. He spent four hours. He went back to work the next day with the conviction that he had to write something.

The ESPN.com article talked about the eight radio stations of Los Santos as a music archive, not about the game as a game. It identified the songs, the decades, the genres. It mentioned the Kovac curation though it named her as "the studio's music director." It connected the game's radio with the real radio of Los Angeles in the nineties. And it closed with the question of whether a video game could function as a museum of popular music accessible to audiences who were never going to enter a museum.

The article was shared thirty thousand times in the first week. ESPN.com hadn't published an article about video games before. The editor of ESPN.com called Smallwood the following Monday and asked him for another.

* * *

Hot 97 in New York mentioned Los Santos on air the following week. Tony Touch, the host of the afternoon slot, had received an email from a listener asking him if he knew that the DJs of Radio Los Santos in the game used a style of "breaks" that was the same one Tony used on his show. Tony asked his producer to load a demo of the game. They loaded it. Tony listened. He recognized it.

That afternoon, on air, during a fifteen-minute segment between songs, Tony talked about the game. He said the curation was "respectful." He said the game's hip-hop was specific to a place and a time, far from the generic and from Hollywood. He said that when a cultural product used the music of the street with respect, the street noticed. And he said, toward the end of the segment, that he was going to buy the game because his younger brother had a PS2.

The segment lasted fourteen minutes. It aired on a Tuesday at four twenty-two in the afternoon. Ten thousand listeners heard it live. Another fifty thousand heard it in replays. And to the NGS office, the segment arrived as an email forwarded by a friend of Lena's who had heard it in Brooklyn. Lena didn't say anything when she read it. She just printed it and put it in a folder labeled "RADIO" that she had on her desk.

* * *

NPR came three weeks later.

The "All Things Considered" segment of November 7 lasted eight minutes. The host was Michele Norris. The piece was handled by a producer named Jenny Gold who had visited Townsend Street for a whole day in October. Gold had interviewed George, Marcus, and Lena. She had recorded Lena playing piano in the Mission studio for one of the CSR tracks. She had recorded the ambient sound of the Townsend office. She had gone back to NPR with four hours of audio and had edited eight minutes.

The segment was called "An Indie That Sells Like AAA." The structure was classic NPR: contextual introduction by Norris, audio of the office with the team's voices in the background, interview with George explaining what NGS was, interview with Lena explaining what she did with sound, audio of Lena playing a jazz progression on the piano, conclusion about what it meant that a studio of forty-five people was selling twenty-five million copies of a game with a fifteen-million-dollar budget in an industry where comparable games cost twenty times more.

The audio of the piano playing lasted forty seconds. NPR let it breathe. The progression was simple, in D minor, with a walking bass and a right hand that played with extended triads. Lena had composed it thinking about one of the late missions of Los Santos, a moment where CJ comes back alone to Grove Street after an event that changes his relationship with the neighborhood.

When the segment aired, eight million listeners heard it live between five thirty and seven in the evening on Wednesday. Another four million heard it in the night replays and in the podcast NPR had started distributing two years earlier.

Lena heard it in her car, driving south on the 101. She pulled over to the shoulder when the part with her piano started. She listened to it complete with her hands on the wheel. Then she kept driving. She didn't comment on it with anyone in the office the next day. But Tomás left a box of chocolates on her desk with a note that said "heard piano on the radio. Good piece."

* * *

The New York Times put Los Santos on the cover of the Arts section on Sunday, November 11.

For a video game to appear on the cover of the Arts section of the NYT in 2007 was a rare event. The Arts section covered theater, opera, ballet, museum exhibitions, independent film and, occasionally, television. It didn't cover video games. Video games had their own tiny section in Style or in Business. The editorial decision to put Los Santos in Arts had been made by the Arts editor in chief personally, after playing the PC version for two weekends.

The journalist was Seth Schiesel. Schiesel was one of the few video game critics who wrote for the NYT regularly. He had covered the industry since the late nineties. He was thirty-nine years old, lived in Brooklyn, and had written sober and precise reviews of games the general culture ignored. They had given him three thousand words for Los Santos. He used them all.

The article started with a description of Townsend Street. Schiesel had visited the office in October. He had walked through the ground floor. He had looked at the mural. He had talked with George for two hours. The description of the office took up the first four hundred words of the article and served as a physical anchor for the thesis Schiesel was going to develop: that NGS made inhabitable spaces more than video games. And that inhabitable spaces, once built, demanded to be thought of with the criteria with which other inhabitable spaces were thought of, architecture, urbanism, literature.

The longest part of the article dealt with the structure of the city more than with the mechanics of the game. Schiesel described Grove Street, South Central, Downtown, East LA, the districts as neighborhoods with distinct personalities. He compared the city of Los Santos with the cities of Saul Bellow's novels and with the cities of Edward Hopper's paintings. The comparison was ambitious. Schiesel sustained it with arguments. The Arts editor in chief approved the comparison when he reviewed the galley.

It closed with a sentence that was going to be quoted for weeks: "Los Santos is the first video game of which it can be said that it is a work of the year in any category."

George read the article on Sunday morning at the kitchen table of his apartment in Mission Bay. He read it twice. The second time in a low voice, articulating the words, as if he wanted to make sure that what he had read was what he had read.

"The first work of the year in any category," he murmured.

He called Claire. Claire had already read it. Claire was with David having breakfast. Claire said: "yes, George, I already saw it, it's good." As if the NYT putting Los Santos on the cover of Arts were one more operational eventuality in a week of operational eventualities. That was Claire.

* * *

Time Magazine included NGS in a list of "Three Studios That Are Redefining Video Game Culture" in its issue of November 19. The other two were Bungie and Blizzard. NGS was the third. The list came accompanied by a short essay of two thousand words written by Lev Grossman, the magazine's literary editor, where it was argued that video games were ceasing to be a niche and starting to behave like a cultural movement with its own authors, its own schools, and its own internal controversies.

The piece wasn't deep. Time wasn't the place for depth. But it was symbolic. For Time to put NGS next to Bungie and Blizzard meant the general culture was accepting a hierarchy of the industry in which NGS appeared as one of the relevant names. Before 2007, NGS was a name the gamers knew. After November 2007, NGS was a name the readers of Time knew. The difference wasn't small.

* * *

And then came the New Yorker.

Tad Friend had signed the article. Friend had written long profiles for the New Yorker since the late nineties. He had written profiles of Brad Pitt, of Jeff Bezos, of film directors, of star chefs, of figures of the entertainment industry the New Yorker considered worth examining with the depth of twelve thousand words. That was the length of his article about George Hightower.

The profile had taken six months of work. Friend had visited Townsend Street three times. He had traveled to Oakland to interview Richard and Margaret. He had traveled to Oakland to talk with a mechanic who had worked with Richard in the seventies. He had talked with Claire. With Marcus. With Lena. With Daniel. With Kenji Nakamura by videoconference from Tokyo. With Tomás in his new apartment in the Mission. With twelve more employees. And with George four times, in sessions of three hours each.

The article was published in the issue of November 26. The cover of the issue was a painting by Carol Anthony and didn't mention the profile. The profile was on pages 64 to 88. The title: "The Sunday Dinner."

The title came from a conversation with Margaret. Margaret had told Friend, in the kitchen of Oakland, that the Sundays of the Hightower family had always been sacred. That Richard and she had raised George and Claire at a table where Sunday was the day everyone sat down to eat and to talk. Friend had taken the image of the Sunday table as the organizing principle of the profile. The argument of the article was that NGS functioned like an extended Sunday table: a group of people who sat down to make things together and where the thing made emerged from the conversation, not from a plan.

The profile didn't reveal George's other life. It couldn't reveal it because George had never told anyone about it. But Friend, with the sensitivity of a veteran profiler, had detected something. In one of the four interviews with George, Friend had asked: "where do your ideas come from?" George had answered with the standard answer, observation, reading, conversation. Friend had insisted. He had asked: "and when you wake up in the middle of the night, what's in your head?" George had gone quiet. He had looked out the window. He had said: "things I shouldn't know."

Friend had kept the sentence. He had used it as the closing of the profile. The sentence stayed there, suspended, with no explanation. Friend had decided not to pursue the meaning. He had decided that the sentence with no explanation was more powerful than the sentence explained.

The profile was going to be quoted, commented on, and referenced for years. For many New Yorker readers who had never heard of NGS, Friend's profile was the first contact with the studio. For many NGS players, the profile was the first time they saw George Hightower described by someone who treated him as a cultural figure more than as a developer.

Tad Friend's profile anticipated, without either Friend or George knowing it, what Rachel Kim was going to do five years later with an even longer profile. But that was a future that hadn't happened yet.

* * *

In a UCSF waiting room in Parnassus, on the morning of November 26, 2007, a second-year cardiology resident read the latest issue of the New Yorker while she waited to be called for a new rotation. She was twenty-five years old, wore a white coat over her scrubs, and had her black hair pulled back in a low ponytail. Her name was Sophie Chen.

Sophie didn't play video games. She had never played one. The waiting room had four magazines: two old issues of National Geographic, a Sports Illustrated, and the New Yorker. She chose the New Yorker because it was the least handled. She opened it at random. She landed on page 64.

"The Sunday Dinner. By Tad Friend."

Sophie read the first three pages. Then she read the next ones. When they called her for the rotation at nine forty, she hadn't finished, but she had read enough to register the name. George Hightower. New Game Studios. San Francisco.

She didn't know why she registered the name. She had no reason to register it. But the profile had a quality that had stopped her, the quality of a text about someone who resembled her father in the way of thinking and who resembled her in the way of deciding what mattered. Things I shouldn't know. The closing sentence stuck with her.

Sophie closed the magazine. She got up. She went to the rotation. She wasn't going to read the profile again. But the name George Hightower was going to stay in a zone of her memory for a while, until the day she was going to meet him in San Francisco through a mutual friend neither of them knew they had.

That was still the future. But the future started that morning, in a waiting room, with a name in a magazine.

* * *

George received all the magazines and all the clippings throughout November and December. Some stayed in the Townsend Street office. Claire filed them in a folder labeled "EXTERNAL COVERAGE 2007" that she was going to use for the annual reports of the next five years. Others were taken to Oakland. Margaret had a hardcover album, one of those nineties photo albums with fake leather covers and adhesive pages with plastic over them where she had started keeping the articles about NGS since 1999. The album was almost full before Los Santos. In December 2007, Margaret had to buy a second album.

George sat at his Townsend Street desk one Friday at six in the evening with seven magazines spread in front of him. ESPN. The NPR transcript. The NYT. Time. The New Yorker. And two more that had arrived that week, a German culture magazine that had put Los Santos on the cover and a French film magazine that had written an essay about Michael Mann's influence on the game's visual direction.

Seven magazines. Seven different contexts. Seven different angles on the same thing.

He thought: ‘for eight years I thought I was making video games’. It turns out I was also making culture. The difference is important. Culture is something people use to understand who they are. If I'm doing that, then what I'm doing is more serious than I thought. And more dangerous. Because now I have to decide which version of the culture I'm helping to build.

Daniel passed by the back office at six twenty, on the way to the bathroom. He saw the desk covered in magazines. He stopped in the doorway.

"You lost control of the narrative," Daniel said.

George looked up. He looked at him. He smiled.

"I never had it."

Daniel nodded. He continued on to the bathroom.

George stayed alone in the back office with the seven magazines. He decided he was going to keep three on the shelf next to PC Gamer 1999, Wired 2003, Game Informer January 2006. The shelf needed a second level. He was going to ask Tomás for it on Monday. Tomás knew how to build shelves.

He closed the black Los Santos notebook. He got up. He turned off the light. He left the back office. He passed through the main floor where Marcus and Lena were watching a video review some YouTuber had uploaded and that had a hundred thousand views in two days. He greeted them. He went out onto Townsend Street.

It was a Friday in November. The lights of SF were on. He walked three blocks to the bus on the 30 line. He got on. He paid. He sat down. He looked out the window.

What he thought, while the bus moved north, was that the external coverage was symmetrical with something he had already learned at other moments: the work was one thing, the reading of the work was another. Both mattered. But they weren't the same thing. And most of the mistakes people made in their lives came from confusing them.

He got off the bus in Mission Bay. He walked to his apartment. Margaret had left a message on his answering machine asking if he was going to come to dinner on Sunday. George called. He told her yes. Margaret said she was going to make her lasagna. George said he was going to bring wine. Margaret said it wasn't necessary. George said he was going to bring it anyway.

That was a conversation with Margaret. It was the most important conversation of the week.

The seven magazines were still on the Townsend desk. On Monday Tomás was going to build the second level of the shelf. And the coverage was going to keep arriving for months, in magazines, in blogs, in radio programs George didn't know. Each article was going to be a mirror. The question was what he was going to do with the mirrors.

For now, what he was going to do was go on Sunday to eat lasagna.

End of Chapter 122

Comments

No comments found for this post.