Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 125: VOLUME 5: THE WITCHER AND THE ABYSS

The Two Notebooks

George bought the fifth notebook at a bookstore on Valencia Street one Saturday in January 2008.

He bought it far from the stationery shop where he usually got the office notebooks. It was at a neighborhood bookstore with wooden shelves and the smell of old paper, the kind of place where the notebooks rested on a table by the window, displayed as if they were books that hadn't been written yet. The notebook was brown. Leather. With a strap clasp that closed it like a belt. It was more expensive than the previous notebooks: the marbled Castlevania one had cost three dollars, the blue Isaac one five, the green Hollow Knight one four, the black Los Santos one six. This one cost twenty-eight.

George paid for it without thinking. Twenty-eight dollars for the notebook where he was going to design the most complex game New Game Studios had ever attempted. He opened it to the first page that same night, sitting in the Townsend Street conference room with the office empty and the five Andrzej Sapkowski novels stacked in front of him like a low wall of paper and ambition. He took the pen. And he wrote two words:

The Witcher.

Outside, San Francisco did what San Francisco does in January: fog that came in from the Pacific like a curtain someone forgot to draw back, streetlamps the fog turned into diffuse patches of yellow light, and the sound of the city muffled as if the whole world were wrapped in cotton. George heard none of it. George was in the Continent.

* * *

He had bought the rights to Sapkowski's novels in October 2000. Fifteen thousand dollars paid to a Polish author who considered video games a minor medium and who had sold the rights with the contemptuous certainty that no one would do anything significant with them. In his previous life, George had played other versions of these stories, made by other people, who with a similar amount had built a multimillion-dollar franchise. In this life, the rights had spent seven years in the bottom drawer of Claire's filing cabinet, waiting.

Claire had catalogued them under "acquired IPs, no project assigned." Each quarter, when she reviewed the company's assets with the meticulousness of a watchmaker who disassembles a mechanism to verify that every piece is still in its place, she asked George whether the Witcher rights should be reclassified as "in development" or kept as "reserve." Each quarter George answered: "Reserve. Not yet."

Until now.

George reread the five novels in a week. He no longer read them as in 2001, with the eyes of a twenty-three-year-old programmer looking for a promising IP. Now he read them with the eyes of a thirty-one-year-old director who knew exactly what kind of game he wanted to make with them. The first novel, Blood of Elves, was the introduction of the world. The Continent: a place where humans had invaded, elves had been marginalized, dwarves survived by usefulness, and witchers were mutants created to kill monsters no one else could kill. It was a world of political fantasy, where no one fought against evil because everyone had reasons and no one was right.

Geralt of Rivia was the protagonist. A witcher mutated as a child to be faster, stronger, more resilient than a human, but at the cost of suppressed emotions that Sapkowski repeatedly demonstrated weren't as suppressed as Geralt pretended. Geralt was a professional who killed monsters for money and who tried not to take sides in the human conflicts around him. He tried and failed, because he carried the curse that neutrality was impossible in a world where not acting was also acting.

George closed the last book. He put it on the pile. And he started writing in the brown notebook with the speed of someone who remembers more than he invents.

* * *

The memories of The Witcher were different from those of the previous games.

Of Castlevania he remembered 90%. Of Isaac, 80%. Of Hollow Knight, 50%. Of Los Santos, 70%. Each game was blurrier than the previous one because each game was further back in his memory of the previous life. Of The Witcher he remembered 65%. But the memories weren't of the first version.

In his previous life, George had played other versions of these stories, made by other people. The first was rigid, with clumsy combat and a structure that aged badly. A system of rhythmic timing where the player clicked at the right moment to chain attacks, innovative but that felt like a glorified quicktime event. A Geralt with amnesia who asked "who am I?" every ten minutes, a narrative trick that worked mechanically but that betrayed the character: the Geralt of the novels was a man with decades of experience, complex relationships, and a reputation that preceded him to every village. The second version was better but limited in scale. The third was the masterpiece: semi-open world, secondary missions that were complete stories, moral decisions with real consequences, and a Geralt who was the most human protagonist of the Western RPG.

George wasn't going to replicate the first game. He was going to take the Geralt of the third version, his mechanics, his philosophy, and put them in the first game. Without the rigidity of the original. Without the clumsy combat. Without the forced amnesia. His Geralt was going to be the complete Geralt from the first minute. With his history intact. With Yennefer as his past. With Ciri as his future. With a world that didn't need to be explained because Geralt already knew it and the game trusted that the player would discover it through immersion, without exposition.

It was a gamble. The RPGs of 2008 explained everything: two-hour tutorials, introductory cutscenes, NPCs that told you who you were and what you had to do. George was going to do the opposite: throw the player into the Continent with a Geralt who knew exactly who he was and let the player discover it through the conversations, the decisions, and the consequences.

"If the player doesn't understand who Geralt is in the first hour," George wrote in the brown notebook, "it's because he wasn't listening."

* * *

He designed The Witcher as a third-person action RPG with a semi-open world. Not a sandbox like Los Santos. Semi-open: large regions the player explored freely but that unlocked with the progression of the story. George chose semi-open for a narrative reason: The Witcher was a story with an arc. CJ in Los Santos could ignore the story and drive for hours because the story of Los Santos was secondary to the experience of the world. Geralt couldn't ignore his story because his story was the experience. Without the story, Geralt was a man with two swords walking through a swamp. With the story, he was a father looking for his adopted daughter in a world that tried to destroy them both.

The structure was three acts with branches. Act 1: Vizima and Velen, where Geralt investigated a series of disappearances that led him to discover a political conspiracy. The player's decisions determined whom Geralt supported: the crown, the rebels, or no one. Each choice changed who survived and who died in Act 2. Act 2: Oxenfurt and Novigrad, where the conspiracy widened and Geralt discovered that the disappearances were connected to a prophecy about Ciri.

Yennefer appeared looking for Ciri on her own. Triss offered help. The player decided whom Geralt worked with, and the decision affected not only the romantic relationship but the strategy for finding Ciri. Act 3: Skellige and the climax, where Geralt found Ciri and the final confrontation depended on every decision made in the two previous acts. Three main endings. Four variations of each. Twelve possible endings.

Torres, when he heard about the twelve endings in the first script meeting, leaned back in his chair with the expression of a man who has just been asked to write twelve novels instead of one. "Twelve endings? You want me to write twelve versions of the same climax?"

"I want you to write a climax that's different for each player."

Torres didn't answer immediately. He looked at the brown notebook George had put on the table. He looked at the thirty pages written in a week. He looked at George with the expression everyone at NGS had learned to recognize as the prelude to a reluctant acceptance: the eyes that said "this is crazy" while the hands were already reaching for the pen to start working.

* * *

The moral decision system was the heart of the design.

George wrote it in the brown notebook in large letters that took up a whole page: THERE IS NO GOOD OPTION. THERE IS NO BAD OPTION. THERE ARE ONLY OPTIONS WITH CONSEQUENCES.

In Los Santos, CJ didn't make moral decisions. He followed a linear story where the good guys were good and the bad guys were bad and Big Smoke was a traitor who deserved to die. In The Witcher, no one deserved anything. Every character had reasons for doing what they did. Every player decision benefited someone and harmed another. And the consequences didn't appear immediately: a decision in Act 1 could kill a character in Act 2, hours of play later. George designed the branches as a tree with crossing limbs. Paths that diverged at the decision and converged at the consequence, sometimes in ways the player couldn't predict.

The example he used to explain the philosophy to the team: a village in Velen has a monster. The monster kills peasants. The mayor asks Geralt to kill it. Geralt investigates and discovers that the monster is a cursed woman, an elf who was raped by human soldiers and whom the curse transformed into a beast. Geralt can kill the monster: the village is saved, the woman dies. He can lift the curse: the woman is saved, but the curse transfers to the mayor who organized the rape, and the mayor turned into a monster kills more peasants before someone stops him. Or he can do nothing: the woman keeps killing until the peasants kill her themselves, losing ten people in the process.

Three options. None good. None bad. All with consequences the player has to live with.

"The player is going to want an option where everyone is saved," Elena said when she heard the example.

"That option doesn't exist. And its absence is what makes the decision matter. If you can save everyone, there's no weight. If someone dies no matter what, every choice costs something."

Elena nodded slowly, her head slightly tilted, processing. It was the expression she made when a design convinced her by the emotion more than by the logic: when she understood that something was going to make the player feel something he couldn't help feeling. Elena designed levels as an architect of experiences, and what George described to her was an emotional labyrinth where every door led to a place that hurt in a different way.

George filled thirty pages of the brown notebook in the first week of January. The structure of the world. The combat mechanics: two swords, magic signs, alchemy. The decision system. The main characters: Geralt, Yennefer, Triss, Ciri. The bestiary of Slavic monsters. The regions of the map. The three acts with their branches. It was the most ambitious GDD he had ever written. More than Castlevania, which had been an action game in a castle. More than Isaac, which had been procedural generation in a basement. More than Hollow Knight, which had been exploration in a subterranean world. More than Los Santos, which had been an open world with a linear story. The Witcher was all of that and more: a world where the story changed according to the player's decisions. Where every playthrough was different. Where the game remembered what the player did and returned the consequences to him hours later.

George closed the brown notebook. He put it on the shelf next to the other four: marbled, blue, green, black, brown. Five notebooks. Five worlds. And something more that waited at the back of his memory like a nameless form that didn't yet have a notebook.

* * *

The sixth notebook didn't come from a bookstore.

George found it three days later at a leather goods shop on Haight Street. He wasn't looking for a notebook. He was walking down Haight one Sunday at ten in the morning, the hour when the neighborhood was empty and the shops were starting to open with the laziness of a January Sunday in San Francisco, and he saw the notebook in the window.

Black. With the edge of the pages in dark red. As if the notebook were bleeding along the sides.

George looked at it for ten seconds from the sidewalk. The leather was matte, without shine, the kind of black that absorbed the light instead of reflecting it. The red edges were the color of dried blood: a dark red that looked ancient, as if the pages had been dyed in some ritual no one remembered. George didn't believe in signs. George believed in notebooks that resembled the games they were going to contain.

He bought it. Thirty-five dollars. He took it to the office. He put it on the desk. He opened it to the first page. And the nameless form took a name:

Dark Souls.

* * *

Dark Souls didn't exist in this world.

The Witcher existed as a novel: Sapkowski had written the books and George had bought the rights. Castlevania existed as a concept, only Symphony of the Night wasn't Konami's in this universe. Isaac existed as a biblical reference. Hollow Knight existed as a concept other people in another life would have conceived. Los Santos existed as a reimagined Los Angeles.

Dark Souls didn't exist as anything. There was no prior concept. It was entirely George's.

Everything that existed was George's memory.

And George's memory remembered Dark Souls clearly. More than The Witcher. Because George had played it dozens of times in his previous life. He had completed it with every class, with every weapon, with every build. He knew Lordran the way he knew San Francisco: by repetition, by familiarity, by the hours of his life he had invested traveling the same paths over and over until they stopped being a map and became memory, instinct, the kind of knowledge that doesn't need to be thought because it's already inscribed in the body.

George didn't start the black-and-red notebook with mechanics. He started with a philosophy. On the first page, beneath "Dark Souls," he wrote three lines:

Death is not a punishment but a teacher.

Difficulty is not a setting but the design.

The player doesn't need to be helped. He needs to be respected.

* * *

Three lines that defined everything that came after.

The first line was about death. In every previous NGS game, death was an interruption. In Castlevania, you died and went back to the checkpoint. In Isaac, you died and started a new run. In Hollow Knight, you died and lost your money but could recover it. In Los Santos, you died and appeared at the hospital. In all cases, death was an obstacle the game put between the player and progress.

In Dark Souls, death was progress.

Every time the player died, he learned something. He learned that the enemy in the corner attacked with a half-second delay. That the bridge had a dragon. That the staircase had a trap. That the boss at the back of the room had a second phase. Every death was information. And the accumulated information turned a player who couldn't survive a minute into a player who could complete the whole game without dying. Death was education.

The second line was about difficulty. In 2008, the industry was obsessed with accessibility. Games had difficulty selection: easy, normal, hard. The tutorials lasted two hours. The NPCs told you where to go with shining arrows on the map. George thought the opposite. Frustration was part of the experience. The satisfaction of overcoming something hard was proportional to the difficulty of what you overcame. A boss you killed on the first try produced no satisfaction. A boss that killed you twenty times and that finally fell on the twenty-first try produced the purest emotion a game could offer: the earned triumph.

Dark Souls wasn't going to have difficulty selection. One difficulty. For everyone. The same for the veteran and for the novice. The difference was that the veteran died ten times and the novice died fifty, but both reached the same ending with the same satisfaction.

The third line was about respect. George believed that making an easy game was a form of condescension. It was telling the player: we don't think you can. We're going to help you. We're going to guide you. We're going to protect you from frustration because we don't trust that you can handle it. Dark Souls trusted the player. It didn't guide him. It didn't tell him where to go. It didn't explain the mechanics with text tutorials. It left him alone in a hostile world with a sword and told him: figure it out. And the player figured it out. Because players were smarter and more resilient than the industry gave them credit for, and Dark Souls was going to be the demonstration.

* * *

George drew the map of Lordran on the second page of the notebook.

It was a vertical map, not horizontal like Los Santos. A world that extended up and down from a central point, with zones connected by staircases, elevators, bridges, and tunnels that the player discovered gradually. George drew with the black pen he used for all the notebooks, a Bic that Claire bought him in packs of twelve because George lost them with the regularity of someone who uses things until they disappear and then looks for another without remembering where he left the first.

At the center: Firelink Shrine. A ruined sanctuary with a bonfire. The only safe place in the game. From Firelink, the world opened in all directions like the branches of an inverted tree.

Upward: Undead Burg, the Undead Parish, Sen's Fortress, and Anor Londo. To go up was to progress. Each higher zone was more difficult, more beautiful, and closer to the truth of why the world was broken. Downward: Blighttown, the Demon Ruins, the Lost Izalith. To go down was to descend to the origins. Each deeper zone was darker, more oppressive, and closer to the secrets the world hid beneath its surface.

And the connections. The connections were what made Lordran different from any world NGS had built. In Los Santos, the world was horizontal and continuous: you drove from one point to another by streets. In Hollow Knight, the world was an interconnected map with routes that opened with abilities. In Dark Souls, the world was a vertical labyrinth where the zones connected by paths the player didn't see until he found them.

The example George wrote in the notebook: the player started in Firelink Shrine. He went up to Undead Burg. He explored for an hour fighting hollows and dodging traps. He found a shortcut: a staircase that went down, a door that opened, and suddenly he was back in Firelink Shrine. The distance that had taken an hour to travel was compressed into thirty seconds because the shortcut existed the whole time, only it was closed from the other side.

"The moment of the shortcut," George wrote. "The moment where the player opens a door and sees Firelink below and understands that the world isn't separate zones but a single space. That moment is Dark Souls."

The bonfires were the system that made death work as a teacher. Each bonfire was a checkpoint. The player who died respawned at the last bonfire he had lit. But the bonfires reset the world: the enemies the player had killed reappeared. The traps reset. Only the collected items remained. To die meant retracing the path from the bonfire, with every enemy alive again, with every trap waiting again. But with the knowledge of what had killed you the time before.

And the souls. The souls were the currency of everything: experience, money, resource to upgrade weapons. The player earned souls by killing enemies. When he died, he left the souls at the point where he had died. If he reached the point of death, he recovered them. If he died on the way, he lost them forever. It was a system of constant risk George described as "the gamble": every step forward was a gamble. To keep advancing meant risking the accumulated souls. To go back to the bonfire meant spending the souls but losing the progress. And when you died with a thousand souls on you, the run back to the point of death was the most tense sequence in the game.

"The bonfires are rest," George wrote. "The souls are tension. The game alternates between the two until the player reaches the boss and the tension isn't resolved until one of the two dies."

* * *

George looked at the two new notebooks on his desk one Friday in January at eight at night.

The Townsend Street office was empty except for the light of his lamp and the hum of the air conditioning Claire kept on 24 hours a day because the NG Store servers generated heat and Claire preferred to pay for the electricity of the air conditioning than to pay for the repair of an overheated server. The light of the lamp fell on the two notebooks like a theater spotlight that illuminates the actors before the play begins.

The brown leather: The Witcher. A witcher in a world of gray decisions where saving someone meant condemning another. A narrative RPG with voices, cutscenes, branches, twelve endings. The most cinematic game NGS would make.

The black with the red edge: Dark Souls. A knight in a world of ash where to die was to learn and victory was to survive. An action RPG with no cutscenes, no tutorials, no guide. The most brutal game NGS would make.

Two games that resembled each other in nothing. Two opposite design philosophies. The Witcher spoke. Dark Souls stayed silent. The Witcher gave the player options. Dark Souls gave him a path and the certainty that he was going to die on it. The Witcher had twelve endings. Dark Souls had one that the player earned with blood.

George was going to make them at the same time. In parallel. With two separate teams that would build two worlds in the same Townsend Street office. The idea was ambitious to the point of irresponsibility, and George knew it. He knew Claire was going to look at the numbers and say the resources weren't enough for two simultaneous productions. He knew Daniel was going to look at the engine and say NGN needed upgrades that cost months before it could sustain either of the two games. He knew the team of forty-five people was going to have to divide into two, and that dividing a team was like dividing a family: necessary sometimes, painful always.

But George also knew something no one else in the office knew: that in his previous life, the third version of the Witcher had come out in 2015 and Dark Souls in 2011. Four years apart. George was going to compress those four years into a parallel development that would launch both games less than a year apart. It was impossible by the standards of the industry. It was possible by the standards of NGS, which had spent eight years doing things the industry considered impossible.

George closed the two notebooks. He put them on the shelf next to the other four. Six notebooks. Marbled, blue, green, black, brown, black-red. Four finished worlds. Two worlds to build. And a seventh notebook that didn't exist yet but that George could already see in his head: electric blue, for a city of neon called Night City that waited its turn in a drawer of the office.

But that was the future. And the future could wait.

In 2001, George had a notebook and an apartment. In 2008, he had six notebooks, an office, forty-five employees, four published games, a digital store with hundreds of thousands of users, and the roots of something that was going to be bigger than everything before it. The fifth notebook was full of a witcher who walked through a world that offered no easy answers. The sixth notebook was full of a knight who walked through a world that offered no mercy. They were, George thought, the two games most like real life he was going to make. Because real life offered no easy answers or mercy. It only offered decisions, consequences, and the possibility of getting up after every fall.

And George, who had spent eight years getting up with the memories of another life as a compass, knew better than anyone what that meant.

Now there was a witcher and a knight that needed to be born. And an engine that needed to grow to sustain them both.

End of Chapter 125

Comments

No comments found for this post.