CHAPTER 132: The Two Hundred Thousand Words and the Seven He Didn't Say (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 132: The Two Hundred Thousand Words and the Seven He Didn't Say
Torres wrote the script for The Witcher like a novelist cursed with the knowledge that no one would read his book from beginning to end.
That was the paradox of writing for a semi-open-world RPG: Torres had to write a complete story with a narrative arc, characters who developed, and a climax that depended on everything before it, but the player wasn't obliged to experience the story in order, or in full, or even with any attention. One player might do the main quests without touching the side quests and receive a coherent but incomplete story. Another might do all the side quests and two main ones and receive a rich world with no through line. Another might do everything in the most absurd order possible, and Torres had to guarantee that the experience kept working.
"It's like writing a novel where the reader can tear out the chapters, shuffle them, throw away half, and the book still has to make sense," Torres said in the first full story meeting, in early February 2009, with George's brown notebook open on the table and a coffee that had gone cold an hour earlier and that Torres kept holding as if the act of holding a coffee were what allowed him to think.
"It doesn't have to make complete sense," George said. "It has to make enough sense. The player who does everything gets the complete story. The player who does half gets a story that works with gaps that don't hurt. The player who does only the main quests gets the spine. Every level of depth is valid."
Torres nodded. It was the answer he needed to hear, and he needed it to use as a design principle even though he already knew it. The spine was the main story: 40 quests that told the search for Ciri across the three acts. The ribs were the 60 side quests that added flesh to the skeleton but could be missing without the body collapsing.
* * *
George gave Torres an instruction that Torres repeated so many times over the following months that it became the narrative team's mantra:
"If a side quest isn't worth playing for its own sake, it isn't worth existing."
The instruction eliminated fetch quests. It eliminated the "go gather 10 wolf pelts." It eliminated the "carry this package from village A to village B." It eliminated everything the RPGs of 2008 used as filler to inflate play time at the cost of the player's experience. Every side quest in The Witcher had to be a short story with a beginning, a middle, and an end. With characters who had a name and a motivation. With a decision the player had to make. With consequences the player had to live with.
Torres took the instruction as a personal challenge. He wrote each side quest as if it were a standalone tale that had to work outside the context of the game. He wrote the first draft. He read it aloud in his Bernal Heights apartment at eleven at night with a glass of whisky he didn't drink but held like a thinking prop. If the tale didn't move him, he rewrote it. If it didn't move him after three rewrites, he scrapped it and started a new one.
The Bloody Baron quest was the one that cost him the most.
Torres wrote it five times. The first version was a rural horror story: a violent noble searching for his wife. It was effective but flat, an obvious villain the player hated without effort. The second version added shades: the baron wasn't just violent, he was an alcoholic destroyed by the war who had brought the habits of the battlefield back home with him. It was better but still let the player judge him easily. The third version broke something. Torres gave the baron a moment of genuine tenderness, a scene where the baron remembered his wife before the war in a voice that belonged to the man the monster had been, not to the monster, and suddenly the character stopped being a villain and became something worse: a person.
"It's the hardest quest to write," Torres told George when he presented the third version, "because it has no villain. Only people who hurt each other. The baron beat his wife. The wife fled. The baron looks for her because he loves her. He truly loves her. But he loves her with the love of someone who doesn't know how to love without destroying. And the question the player has to answer is this: does someone who knows he's bad and can't stop being bad deserve a second chance?"
George read the third version. He read it twice. The second time, in the scene where the baron was left alone in his empty hall after his wife left, if the player chose to help her escape, George felt something he hadn't expected to feel reading a video game script at nine in the morning in a Townsend Street office: the specific pang of the sadness produced by someone who deserves what happens to him and is pitiable all the same.
"This is the reference quest," George said. "If they were all this good, the game would be perfect."
Torres didn't smile. Torres didn't smile when he received praise about his writing. He nodded with his head slightly lowered, like someone receiving a diagnosis he already knew, and went back to work with the renewed energy of a writer who has confirmed that what he feels about his own work is what others feel when they read it.
* * *
Torres wrote 200,000 words of script between February and August 2009.
It was longer than Sapkowski's novels. Torres worked it out one Friday in April when he finished the Velen quests and added up the word count of all the files: 200,347 words. Sapkowski's five novels came to roughly 180,000. Torres had written more than Sapkowski in seven months. Sapkowski had taken twelve years.
"But Sapkowski wrote good prose," Torres said with the dry modesty he used to disguise his pride. "I wrote dialogue that an actor is going to read in a recording studio and that a player is going to hear while hunting for where to buy Specter oil."
"Sapkowski's prose doesn't have to work when the reader reads it out of order," George said. "Yours does. Your job is harder."
Torres looked at George without knowing whether he'd just been paid a compliment or handed a diagnosis of his professional sentence. Then he said:
"Two hundred thousand words. Three acts. Forty main quests. Sixty side quests. Each one with branches. Each one with voices. Each one with consequences that cross with those of other quests in ways that sometimes even I can't trace without the diagram on the whiteboard. It's the longest and most complex text I've ever written. And the average player is going to experience 60% of it on their first playthrough."
"And they're going to play again to see the other 40%. And again to see what happens if they choose differently. The script doesn't have to work once. It has to work three times in three different ways."
Torres fell silent. Then he said something George understood as the surrender of a writer who has accepted that the magnitude of what he's doing exceeds what he can calculate and that the only option is to keep writing:
"Sapkowski had twelve years. I had seven months. If the game comes out and people say the script is good, I'm going to need a vacation. If they say it's bad, I'm going to need therapy."
George laughed. Torres didn't laugh. Torres was serious about the vacation and about the therapy with the same seriousness he brought to talking about Yennefer's dialogue and about the baron: the seriousness of a man who takes his work as something he cares about enough that it could destroy him if it went wrong.
* * *
Richard's spring checkup was a Tuesday in March 2009.
Margaret came along as always: sitting in the UCSF waiting room with a magazine she didn't read, because Margaret didn't read magazines in waiting rooms; Margaret watched the people with the attention of someone who finds human beings more interesting than any article in any magazine anywhere in the world.
George went too. He told Margaret he was going because he "happened to be in the neighborhood," which was a lie so transparent that Margaret detected it before George finished saying it. George didn't happen to be in the UCSF neighborhood. George lived in the Mission and worked on Townsend Street. The UCSF Medical Center was on Parnassus, which was on the way to nowhere George had any reason to be on a Tuesday at ten in the morning.
Margaret said nothing. Margaret looked at George with the smile she used when she knew something George didn't know she knew, which was the same smile she used when George was fifteen and told her he was going to a friend's house when he was going to a party: the smile that said "I know you better than you know yourself, but I'm going to let you believe your lie works because correcting you would take away your illusion of autonomy."
Richard went in for the checkup with the lead doctor. Margaret sat in the waiting room. And George walked down the cardiology hallway with the excuse of looking for a bathroom he knew perfectly well the location of but that gave him a reason to walk down the hallway where Sophie Chen worked.
Sophie was in the hallway. White coat. Ponytail. The same shadows under her eyes as last time, perhaps a millimeter deeper, the kind of detail George shouldn't have noticed but noticed anyway because George had the curse of noticing the details of the things that mattered to him with a precision that applied to nothing else in his life.
"Hi," George said.
Sophie returned the greeting. "Your father?"
"Spring checkup."
"How is he?"
"Good. Pressure under control. He takes his pills. My mother makes sure."
Sophie smiled. It was a professional smile with a personal edge: the smile of someone who asks about a patient but is glad for a person. "I'm glad. Give him my regards."
They talked for ten minutes. Standing in the cardiology hallway, with nurses passing by and the sound of the intercoms paging doctors with emergencies that weren't emergencies for anyone except the people something was happening to. They talked about nothing important: about San Francisco weather that was never predictable, about Parnassus traffic that was always bad, about the residency that was still exhausting. Sophie worked 80 hours a week. George worked 60. The two of them were tired in different ways that resembled each other more than either would have admitted: the tiredness of people who do something that matters to them and whose price for it mattering is that they can't stop doing it even when they should.
George wanted to ask her if she'd like to get a coffee. The sentence had formed in his head, "do you want to get a coffee sometime?" with the seven words in the right order and the intonation rehearsed in the three seconds it took him to think he wanted to say it. But he didn't say it. He didn't say it because a hospital hallway wasn't the place, and because Sophie was working, and because George Hightower, who had designed six worlds and written design documents hundreds of pages long and run studios of more than a hundred people, was incapable of saying seven words to a woman in a white coat without feeling that the seven words were harder than anything he had done in this life or the last.
The intercom paged Sophie. Sophie excused herself. George told her not to worry. Sophie went off down the hallway with the quick step of someone with patients waiting. George stood in the hallway with the seven words he hadn't said and the feeling that he'd just missed a 5-frame parry: the window had opened, the window had closed, and George hadn't pressed the button in time.
He went back to the waiting room. Margaret looked at him.
"Did you find the bathroom?" Margaret asked with the innocence of a woman who knew George hadn't looked for any bathroom and who enjoyed the fiction with the generosity of a mother who lets her children believe their secrets are secrets.
"Yes," George said.
"And did you see anyone interesting on the way?"
George looked at his mother. Margaret was looking at him with the eyes that saw everything: the eyes that had watched George button Richard's collar every New Year's Eve, the eyes that had watched George sit in the Townsend Street office at three in the morning working on games Margaret didn't understand but respected, the eyes that now watched George come back from a hospital hallway with the look of a man who has seen someone who matters to him and hasn't had the courage to say so.
"No," George said. "No one interesting."
Margaret smiled. A smile different from the "I know you better than you know yourself" one. The other smile. The smile of "when you're ready, you'll find the words." The smile of a mother who knows her son will do the right thing but also knows the right thing takes time and that the Hightowers, as a family, don't rush the things that matter.
George sat down next to Margaret in the waiting room. Richard came out of the checkup fifteen minutes later with the usual numbers: pressure under control, acceptable cholesterol, heart working with the stubbornness of a well-maintained engine. The three of them left the hospital. George drove his parents back to Oakland. Margaret talked about Sunday dinner. Richard talked about the weather. George thought about seven words he hadn't said and about a woman with shadows under her eyes who had asked about his father with a smile that had a personal edge.
Torres had written 200,000 words in seven months. George hadn't been able to say seven in ten minutes.
The worlds he built were easier than the life he was trying to live. And George, who had spent eight years discovering that in different ways, was beginning to accept that real life had no design notebook, no branching diagram, no decision system with predictable consequences. Real life was a hospital hallway and a window of opportunity that closed without your being able to calculate when it would open again.
But George was patient. George was the man who had waited seven years to make The Witcher and ten years to make Dark Souls. He could wait however long it took to say seven words.
‘Next time,’ George thought as he drove down Parnassus with the March sun coming in through the car window. ‘Next time.’
End of Chapter 132