CHAPTER 133: The Black and Red Notebook (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 133: The Black and Red Notebook
George opened the black notebook with the red edge in January 2009.
He had bought it a year earlier, the same month as the brown notebook for The Witcher, but he hadn't opened it. For twelve months the notebook had sat on the Townsend Street shelf, beside the other five, waiting with the patience of an object that knows its moment will come. George looked at it every morning when he arrived at the office and every night when he left. The black notebook looked back with its red edges that resembled dried blood along its sides, like a book that already held something the reader hadn't read yet.
Now was the moment. The Witcher was in production: Team Witcher had the brown notebook, had the GDD, had Torres writing the script, had Lena composing with the gadulka, had Elena designing the levels of Vizima. The witcher was underway. Now it was the knight's turn.
George sat at his desk at seven in the morning on a Monday, before anyone arrived, with the notebook open to the first page and a coffee that Claire would have described as "an inefficient investment in caffeine" given that George was going to let it go cold without drinking it, because when George wrote in the notebooks he didn't drink, didn't eat, didn't look at the clock. George wrote like someone recalling a dream before it fades: with urgency, with precision, with the awareness that every passing second is a detail being lost.
He wrote "Dark Souls" on the first page. And beneath it, in smaller letters:
"Original IP. Doesn't exist in this universe. Doesn't exist in any universe except my memory."
It was the first time George had written that explicitly. In the earlier notebooks, the relationship between his memories and the games he designed was implicit: George knew that he remembered, but he didn't write it down. He didn't articulate it. The earlier notebooks contained designs, not confessions. But Dark Souls was different from everything George had done before, and the difference deserved to be documented even if no one else would ever read the notebook.
The Witcher existed as a novel. Sapkowski had written the books. George had bought the rights. The game was an adaptation of something someone else had created. The same with Castlevania: the concept of Castlevania existed in this universe even if Symphony of the Night didn't. Isaac existed as a biblical reference. Hollow Knight existed as the concept of an underground kingdom of insects, even if no one else had conceived of it as a game. Los Santos existed as a reimagined Los Angeles. Every previous NGS game had an anchor in reality, a starting point that existed independently of George's memories.
Dark Souls had no anchor.
There was no novel. There was no preexisting mythology. There was no real city to reimagine. Dark Souls didn't exist as anything; it was entirely George's.
All that existed was George's memory. And George's memory was going to create something out of nothing.
Or rather, out of the 75% sharpness with which George remembered Dark Souls 1. Sharper than The Witcher, sharper than Hollow Knight, sharper than Los Santos. Because George had played Dark Souls dozens of times in his earlier life. He had completed it with every class: knight, pyromancer, thief, cleric. With every weapon: straight sword, greatsword, axe, spear, magic catalyst. With every build: strength, dexterity, faith, intelligence, and the hybrid builds that veterans created by combining stats in ways the original design hadn't foreseen but that worked because the system was deep enough to allow improvisation.
George knew Lordran the way he knew San Francisco: by repetition, by familiarity, by the hours of his life he had spent walking the same corridors over and over until the corridors stopped being geometry and became muscle memory. He knew where every enemy in Undead Burg was. He knew which door led back to Firelink. He knew exactly how many steps there were between the Anor Londo bonfire and the fog gate of Ornstein and Smough. He knew it because he had lived it so many times that the knowledge had settled into his body the way sediment settles at the bottom of a river: without effort, without intention, by the weight of time alone.
Now he had to turn that memory into a design document that other people could read, understand, and build.
* * *
George wrote the Dark Souls GDD like a manifesto.
The earlier GDDs were technical documents with sections organized by system (combat, levels, narrative, audio). This one began with a philosophy and derived everything else from that philosophy. It was a document that read like an argument: every mechanic, every design decision, every constraint existed because it served the central idea, and the central idea fit in three lines George had written a year earlier on the same first page he now looked at with the ink already dry:
Death is a teacher, not a punishment.
Difficulty is the design, not a setting.
The player needs to be respected, not helped.
From those three lines George derived everything else. If death is a teacher, then dying has to teach something: the player who dies must be able to identify what he did wrong and correct it on the next attempt. If difficulty is the design, then there is no difficulty selection: a single experience for everyone, calibrated to be fair but relentless. If the player needs to be respected, then there are no quest markers, no arrows on the map, no lengthy tutorials: the player discovers the world for himself because the game trusts that he's capable of it.
"I want to make a game where dying is learning," George wrote beneath the three lines. "Where every death leaves the player closer to victory because every death gives him information he didn't have before. Where frustration is the fuel: the frustration of dying transforms into the determination to try again, and the determination transforms into the skill that turns the impossible into the possible."
It was, George thought as he wrote, the opposite philosophy to The Witcher. The Witcher gave the player choices and said: choose. Dark Souls gave the player a wall and said: overcome it. The Witcher measured the player by his decisions. Dark Souls measured him by his persistence. Both games treated the player as an adult, but in opposite ways: The Witcher trusted that the player could think. Dark Souls trusted that the player could suffer.
* * *
George drew the map of Lordran on the second page of the notebook.
The map of Los Santos was horizontal: the city stretched in every direction from a center and the player traveled it by car along streets that connected the districts like arteries connecting the organs of a body. The map of Lordran was vertical. A world that extended upward and downward from a central point, with zones connected by stairs, elevators, bridges, and tunnels that the player discovered gradually, like a building where someone had torn down the floor signs and the only way to know where you were was to remember how you got there.
George drew with the black pen, the same Bic as always, tracing lines that connected circles representing zones. The drawing was functional: a diagram of nodes and connections that looked more like an electrical circuit than a fantasy map. But each node was a world and each connection was an experience the player was going to live.
At the center: Firelink Shrine. A ruined sanctuary on a cliff with a bonfire that burned for no apparent reason in the middle of the devastation. The only safe place in Lordran. From Firelink, the world opened in every direction like the branches of an inverted tree.
Upward: Undead Burg, the dead city where the hollows patrolled streets that had once been prosperous and were now ruins inhabited by the remains of people who had stopped being people. Then the Undead Parish, with its gargoyles on the roof and its bells the player had to ring without knowing why until the environmental narrative revealed it to him in fragments. Then Sen's Fortress, a trap fortress designed as a trial only the most persistent overcame: swinging blades, narrow bridges over chasms, and serpents guarding every hallway. And at the end of the ascent: Anor Londo, the city of the gods, bathed in a golden light that was the visual reward for having survived everything before it.
Downward: Blighttown, the toxic city built on scaffolds of rotting wood that stretched over a swamp of poison. It was the zone George remembered with the most clarity and the most distaste from his earlier life: the zone every player hated and every player remembered, because Blighttown was the proof that difficulty could be oppressive without being unfair. Then the Demon Ruins, the remains of a civilization that had fallen literally, as if the ground had opened and swallowed everything that had once been above. And at the end of the descent: Ash Lake, an underground lake with enormous trees that held up the world above, visible only to the players who found the secret walls that hid it.
* * *
The connections were what made Lordran different from any world NGS had ever built.
In Los Santos, the world was horizontal and continuous: you drove from one point to another along streets. If you wanted to go from Grove Street to Vinewood, you took the freeway and drove for three minutes of game time. The space between the two points was distance you traveled. In Hollow Knight, the world was an interconnected map with routes that opened with abilities: the dash that let you cross a chasm that had been impassable, the claw that let you scale walls that had been barriers. The space between two zones was a barrier that got unlocked.
In Dark Souls, the world was a vertical labyrinth where the zones connected by paths the player didn't see until he found them. And the moment of finding them was the moment that defined the experience.
George wrote the example in the notebook in quick strokes, like someone describing a scene he has watched many times:
"The player starts in Firelink Shrine. He climbs to Undead Burg. He explores for an hour, fighting hollows, dodging ambushes, dying and coming back and learning. He finds a shortcut: a stairway going down, a door that opens from the inside, and suddenly he's back in Firelink Shrine. The distance that took an hour to cover compresses into thirty seconds because the shortcut existed the whole time, it was just locked from the other side."
The shortcut was more than a mechanic. It was a revelation. It was the instant the player understood the design philosophy: that Lordran was an organism where every part was connected to the others in ways the design had hidden behind locked doors and paths visible only from one side. It was the moment the player's mental map, which until that point was a list of separate zones, reorganized into a three-dimensional map where everything fit like the parts of a clock you only understand when you see the gears from inside.
Elena, who was going to design those shortcuts when production of Dark Souls began, read the section of the GDD about the connections and said something George kept:
"It's like the castle of Castlevania but in 3D and with no map. The player builds the map in his head. And every shortcut he discovers is like finding a secret room in Castlevania: the reward is understanding, not an item."
"Exactly," George said. "In Castlevania the reward for exploring was finding a new weapon. In Dark Souls the reward for exploring is understanding where you are. The map is the puzzle. And the player is the one who solves it."
* * *
George filled forty pages of the black and red notebook in three weeks of January.
He wrote in the mornings before Team Witcher arrived and needed his attention. He wrote at night after everyone had left. He wrote on weekends in his Mission apartment with the notebook open on the kitchen table and the coffee going cold and the pages filling at the speed of someone transcribing more than inventing.
Because that was what George was doing with Dark Souls: transcribing. Turning memories into documents. Translating the experience of having played a game dozens of times in his other life into the instructions that would let other people build that game in this one. The 75% sharpness meant that three quarters of Lordran were clear in his head: the layouts of the zones, the patterns of the bosses, the connections between the areas, the position of the bonfires. The remaining 25% was fog: details George didn't remember and would have to invent or delegate to the team.
But 75% was enough. The 75% was the skeleton. And the skeleton of Dark Souls, a vertical interconnected world where death taught and victory was earned through persistence, was solid enough that the 25% of improvisation could complete it without weakening it.
George closed the notebook at the end of January. Forty pages. The map of Lordran. The 15 zones with their connections. The 20 bosses with their general patterns. The bonfire system. The soul system. The combat mechanics based on stamina. The environmental narrative told through items. The design philosophy that held everything up the way a spine holds up a body: invisible from outside, indispensable from within.
He set it on the shelf beside the brown notebook. Brown and black-red. The witcher and the knight. Two worlds designed on paper that now needed a team, a director, and the time required to turn ink into pixels.
The witcher was already in production. The knight waited his turn. And George, who walked between the two notebooks every day like a man who lives in two houses, knew that the knight's wait was about to end. Because somewhere in the video game industry there was a director who understood that difficulty was respect, and George was going to find him.
His name was Kenji Nakamura.
End of Chapter 133