CHAPTER 134: Death as a Teacher and the Twenty Exams (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 134: Death as a Teacher and the Twenty Exams
The bonfires were the system that made death function as a teacher.
George designed them in March 2009 across a series of pages in the black and red notebook that looked more like a philosophical essay than a design document. Because the bonfires were more than checkpoints. Checkpoints existed in every game: a point where the game saved your progress so you didn't have to repeat everything from the start when you died. In Castlevania, the checkpoints were candelabras that glowed. In Hollow Knight, they were benches where the Knight sat. In Los Santos, they were hospitals where CJ showed up with less money and a worse mood. Checkpoints were pure mechanics: a partial reset that reduced the penalty of death.
The bonfires of Dark Souls were a philosophy made flesh in a fire.
Each bonfire was a resting point where the player could sit, level up, repair equipment, and prepare for what was coming. But sitting at a bonfire had a cost: all the enemies the player had killed respawned. The traps reset. The world returned to its original state except for two things: the items the player had picked up and the knowledge the player had acquired. The items remained. The knowledge remained. Everything else started over.
Dying worked the same way. The player who died reappeared at the last bonfire he had lit. The enemies were alive again. The traps waited again. The path the player had traveled, with its ambushes, its platforms, its enemies that attacked from the corners, was intact and ready to kill him again. But the player already knew. He already knew where the ambush was. He already knew which corner had an enemy. He already knew which platform crumbled. The world hadn't changed. The player had.
"The bonfire resets the world but doesn't reset the player," George wrote. "Every time the player returns to the bonfire, the world is the same but the player is better. That is death as a teacher: repeating the same test until you pass it, because you become more capable, not because the test gets easier."
George knew he was describing something that in his earlier life had gone by the name of "fair frustration." The frustration of Dark Souls was different from the frustration of Wrong Side of the Tracks in Los Santos. Wrong Side of the Tracks was a mission where the player failed because the design was unfair: the train moved faster than the bike, Big Smoke couldn't aim, the victory conditions were arbitrary. The frustration of that mission produced rage because the player felt the game was punishing him for something that wasn't his fault. The frustration of Dark Souls produced determination because the player felt the game was punishing him for something that was his fault: not dodging in time, not observing the pattern, not being patient enough.
The difference was critical. Rage made the player stop playing. Determination made the player try again.
* * *
And the souls. The souls were what turned every step forward into a gamble.
Souls were the single currency of Dark Souls: experience to level up, money to buy items, resource to upgrade weapons. The player earned souls by killing enemies. Each enemy gave a fixed amount: a hollow gave 50, a black knight gave 1,000, a boss gave 10,000 or more. The souls accumulated. And the accumulation was the problem.
Because when the player died, he left all his souls at the exact spot where he had died. A glowing stain on the ground that held everything the player had accumulated since the last time he had spent souls. If the player returned to the spot of death and touched the stain, he recovered the souls. All of them. With no penalty. Death was reversible if the player was able to retrace the path that had killed him without dying again.
But if the player died on the way back, if the same enemies that had killed him the first time killed him the second, the souls were lost. Forever. With no recovery. With no second chance. The stain vanished and a new stain appeared at the new spot of death with the zero souls the player had at that moment.
It was a risk/reward system George described in the notebook as "the constant gamble." Every step the player took away from the bonfire was a gamble. Pressing on meant risking the accumulated souls: if you found a new enemy you didn't know and it killed you, you lost everything you had earned unless you could get back to the spot of death and recover it. Returning to the bonfire meant spending the souls on upgrades and resetting the risk to zero, but it also meant losing the exploration progress because the enemies respawned.
The player who accumulated 5,000 souls and kept going instead of returning to spend them was betting 5,000 souls that he could survive. And when that player died with 5,000 souls on him, the run back to the spot of death was the tensest sequence in the game: the player sprinting along a path he already knew, dodging enemies he had already dodged, his heart pounding because the souls at stake made every mistake cost something real.
"The bonfires are rest," George wrote. "The souls are tension. The game alternates between the two until the player reaches the boss and the tension doesn't resolve until one of the two dies."
* * *
George designed the 20 bosses of Dark Souls in April 2009 with Elena.
Elena had been temporarily assigned to Team Souls to design the combat encounters while her temporary replacement covered level design on Team Witcher. It was a loan George had negotiated with himself, since he was director of both teams, and that Claire had authorized on the condition that Elena return to Team Witcher before the Skellige quests entered production.
Each boss was an exam. A specific test of what the player had learned in the zone preceding the boss, not a random obstacle blocking progress. George explained it with a metaphor Elena adopted as a design principle:
"Each zone teaches a lesson. The boss is the final exam of that lesson. If the player learned the lesson, he can pass the exam. If he didn't learn it, the boss is going to teach it to him the hard way."
The Asylum Demon was the exam of the tutorial: a fat demon with a big hammer in a small room. It taught the player three things: that bosses were bigger than he was, that their attacks were slow but devastating, and that patience was more valuable than aggression. The player who attacked nonstop died crushed. The one who waited, observed the pattern, hammer strike, pause, side swing, longer pause, and attacked in the pauses survived. It was the easiest boss in the game and the most important because it established the contract between the game and the player: I'm going to kill you, but I'm going to show you how to avoid it. The rest is up to you.
The Gargoyles of the Parish were the exam of multitasking: two bosses that began as one and became two halfway through the fight when the second gargoyle woke on the roof and came down breathing fire. The player who fixated on one took the hit from the other. The lesson was spatial awareness: knowing where every enemy was at all times, not just the one you were looking at.
The Great Grey Wolf Sif was the emotional exam. A giant wolf guarding the grave of his dead master. Sif attacked out of loyalty, not malice. The sword of his dead master, which Sif held in his mouth, was the weapon he fought with. And when his health dropped to 20%, Sif began to limp. The attacks slowed. The sword dragged along the ground. The wolf kept fighting with the determination of an animal that doesn't know how to surrender but can no longer win. The player who killed him felt guilt instead of satisfaction. It was the first boss in the game that made the player question whether killing was the right answer.
George designed Sif with the same philosophy as the monsters of The Witcher: an enemy that frightened from afar and saddened up close. But where in The Witcher the player had the option not to kill, in Dark Souls there was no option. Sif had to die for the player to advance. And the impossibility of choosing was what made the guilt weigh more: you couldn't tell yourself "I chose wrong" because you hadn't chosen anything. The game forced you to kill the wolf and then forced you to live with the image of the wolf limping.
* * *
Ornstein and Smough were the ultimate exam.
George designed them with Elena over an entire week in the Townsend Street meeting room, with the whiteboard covered in diagrams of attack patterns, distances, timings, and the doodles Elena made when she was focused: circles with arrows representing movements, numbers representing frames, and margin notes that said things like "here the player cries" and "here the player screams" and "here the player turns off the console and then turns it back on because he can't let it go."
Two simultaneous bosses in a huge hall of Anor Londo, the city of the gods. Ornstein was tall, fast, with a spear that electrified. Smough was fat, slow, with a hammer that crushed. The two patterns were legible individually. Together they were a coordinated chaos that required the player to do three things at once: dodge Ornstein, position himself away from Smough, and attack one of the two in the microseconds where the patterns left a gap.
And when the player killed one, the other absorbed his power and entered a second phase with new attacks. Killing Ornstein first produced an electrified Smough with area attacks that covered half the hall. Killing Smough first produced a giant Ornstein with charges that crossed the hall in two seconds. The choice of whom to kill first changed the second phase completely, which meant the player had to master both versions to feel he had truly conquered the fight.
Elena designed the hall with pillars the player could use as temporary cover against Ornstein's charge. The pillars were destructible: Smough broke them with his hammer. The player who relied too much on the pillars was left without cover. It was a finite resource that added a layer of management to the fight: how many pillars you used and when you sacrificed them.
"How many times is the average player going to die?" Elena asked when they finished calibrating the fight's timings at the end of the week.
"Between 10 and 30," George said.
"Thirty deaths against one boss is fair?"
"Every death teaches something. Death 1 teaches that Ornstein is fast. Death 5 teaches the timing of his charge. Death 10 teaches positioning. Death 15 teaches when to attack. Death 20 teaches the second phase. Death 25 teaches not to panic. And death 30 is the death where the player says ‘not this time’ and wins. Thirty deaths aren't thirty failures. They're thirty lessons."
Elena looked at the diagrams on the whiteboard. The lines representing Ornstein and Smough's movements, the numbers representing the frames of each attack, the empty spaces between the attacks that were the windows where the player could act. And she said:
"A fair boss kills the player with a move the player saw coming but didn't dodge in time. If the player didn't see the move coming, the boss is unfair. If the player saw it and dodged it, the boss is easy. The line between the two is thin. Ornstein and Smough are on the line."
George nodded. Being on the line was exactly where they had to be. Because the line between fair and unfair, between hard and impossible, between productive frustration and destructive frustration, was the line where Dark Souls existed. A millimeter to one side and the game was cruel. A millimeter to the other and the game was trivial. George and Elena's job was to find the exact millimeter and hold it across 20 bosses and 60 hours of play.
Twenty bosses. Twenty exams. Twenty versions of the same question Dark Souls asked the player every time the mist of a boss fog dispersed and something enormous appeared on the other side:
Can you?
And the answer, every time, was the same: not yet.
End of Chapter 134