CHAPTER 137: Two Worlds, Two Palettes, Two Souls (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 137: Two Worlds, Two Palettes, Two Souls
Marcus Webb painted Polish swamps in the morning and nightmare cathedrals in the afternoon.
It was his literal schedule before it was a metaphor. From eight in the morning to one in the afternoon, Marcus worked with the Witcher art sub-team on the ground floor of Townsend Street: he reviewed the textures of Velen, adjusted the color palette of Vizima, gave feedback on the models of Slavic monsters the artists produced based on the art bibles Marcus had written during the first half of 2009. The swamps had to look wet, like the sensation of dampness translated into pixels, beyond the mere photo of a swamp.
The taverns had to smell of old wood just by looking at them: the texture of the planks, the curve of the beams, the color darkened where the hands of generations had left their grease. The faces of the peasants had to tell their lives without needing dialogue: wrinkles the Velen sun had carved, eyes that had seen the war and that looked out with the distrust of people who know peace is temporary.
From two in the afternoon to seven in the evening, Marcus crossed the office, literally: he climbed the stairs from the ground floor to the upper floor and sat with the Dark Souls art sub-team. The cathedrals of Anor Londo with their pillars that defied geometry and their golden light that came in through stained glass no one had built because the gods who commissioned it no longer existed. The walls of Undead Burg covered in lichen and ash, with the texture of stone that had been proud and was now crumbling like the civilization that had built it.
The twisted roots of Darkroot Garden that grew in directions no real tree would grow because the trees of Lordran weren't trees but the remains of something that had been a forest before the world began to die. The impossible architecture of Sen's Fortress with its swinging-blade traps and its bridges over the void that existed not to connect two points but to kill whoever tried to cross them.
The transition cost him.
"I spend the morning painting Polish swamps and the afternoon painting nightmare cathedrals," Marcus told George one Friday in July, sitting at George's desk with a coffee he held in his left hand because the right had stains of digital paint that never came off during the workday, like a mechanic who doesn't clean off the grease until he closes the shop. "My brain doesn't know what century it's in. At eleven I'm thinking about how the light filters through the willows of Velen with that gray-green quality light has in Northern Europe when it's overcast. At three I'm thinking about how the dark eats the pillars of Anor Londo from the bottom up, as if the shadow were a liquid rising. They're two opposite visual languages and I speak them both in the same day."
"Is that a problem?" George asked.
Marcus thought about it. He really thought about it, with the slowness of an artist evaluating whether what he does works or whether it only seems to work. George knew that pause. He had seen it in Marcus since 1999, since the Fulton Street apartment where Marcus drew Alucard with his left hand: the pause of a man who took his work seriously enough not to lie to himself about the quality of what he produced.
"No," Marcus said. "It would be a problem if they were similar. If The Witcher and Dark Souls had similar palettes, my brain would mix one with the other and the two would contaminate each other. But they're so different that the switch is like switching languages: when I speak Spanish I think in Spanish, when I speak English I think in English. When I paint Witcher I think in green and brown. When I paint Souls I think in gray and gold. They don't mix because they have nothing in common."
* * *
The art bible of The Witcher had 45 pages Marcus had written and drawn.
The first page defined the visual philosophy: stylized medieval realism with Slavic influence. The specific medieval of Eastern Europe, far from the generic medieval of Western RPGs with their gray castles of pointed towers and dragons on every mountain: wood instead of stone, thatched roofs instead of tile, mud instead of cobblestone, colors muted by the damp climate of northern Europe that never let the sun arrive with the strength needed for the colors to shine.
Marcus hadn't traveled to Eastern Europe like Lena. He had used the photos of Prague and Krakow, plus an archive of 3,000 reference images he had compiled over months: Orthodox churches with domes that looked like onions of gold, rural villages of Poland and Ukraine where the wooden houses sank slightly into the earth as if the ground wanted to swallow them, boreal forests of Scandinavia where the trees grew so close together that the ground received no sun and the moss covered everything with a green that was almost black, medieval markets reconstructed in open-air museums where the wooden stalls and the thatched roofs showed how people had lived before concrete replaced wood and steel replaced stone.
The palette of The Witcher was earthy. Muted greens, the gray-green of a forest where the sun doesn't reach the ground, far from any bright green of a tropical forest. Browns of mud and damp wood. Grays of stone covered in moss. And a warm orange reserved exclusively for the interiors: the taverns with hearths where Geralt rested were the only spaces in the game with warm colors. The exterior was cold. The interior was warmth. Marcus wanted the player to feel relief on entering a tavern, not just because of the resting mechanic but because of the visual change from cold to warmth, from gray-green to orange-gold, as if the tavern door were a portal between two emotional worlds.
* * *
The art bible of Dark Souls had 38 pages and was the visual opposite of The Witcher in every respect.
Where The Witcher was organic, Dark Souls was architectural. Where The Witcher was wood and earth, Dark Souls was stone and ash. Where The Witcher had colors muted by dampness, Dark Souls had them muted by death: grays of eroded rock, blacks of shadows that didn't dissipate because the source of light that created them no longer existed, and a gold Marcus reserved for a single place: Anor Londo, the city of the gods, where the light came in through the stained glass with a warmth that was the most beautiful lie in the game because the city was empty and the light was the memory of a glory that no longer existed.
Marcus designed the architecture of Dark Souls as "grandeur in decay." Every building, every bridge, every stairway of Lordran had been built to last for eternity and was falling to pieces. The pillars of Anor Londo had cracks that snaked from the base to the capital like dry rivers. The walls of Undead Burg had sections where the stone had come loose and revealed the inner structure: bricks stacked without mortar that held together out of habit more than engineering. The bridges of Sen's Fortress had missing planks that were not just mechanical obstacles but narrative details: someone had walked those bridges so many times that the wood had worn away to nothing.
"The architecture of Dark Souls tells the story without words," Marcus wrote on the first page of the art bible. "A castle in ruins says: there was power here. A broken bridge says: there was connection here. A headless statue says: there was someone here who deserved to be remembered and was forgotten. Each ruin is a sentence. All of Lordran is a novel written in stone."
Marcus had a team of 15 artists divided into two sub-teams: 8 for The Witcher and 7 for Dark Souls. The Witcher artists worked with photographic references of Eastern Europe: photos of villagers, of forests, of taverns that still existed in the rural areas of Poland. The Dark Souls artists worked with references of Gothic cathedrals, illustrations by Gustave Doré, engravings by Giovanni Piranesi, and a folder Marcus called "beautiful ruins": photos of abandoned churches, castles in decay, and ghost cities where nature was reclaiming what humans had built, vines climbing the walls, trees growing through the roofs, the slow victory of the organic over the architectural.
The two sub-teams didn't talk to each other about the other's projects. Marcus decided it deliberately: he didn't want visual contamination between the two games. An artist who saw the swamps of Velen could unconsciously add green to the walls of Undead Burg. An artist who saw the gold of Anor Londo could unconsciously warm the palette of Vizima. The separation was strict. The two sub-teams worked on the same floor but on opposite sides, with Marcus as the only bridge between the two: the man who walked from one century to another every day and who kept the two worlds separate in his head with the discipline of a bilingual who never mixes the languages.
* * *
Lena composed for both games with the same temporal division as Marcus: Witcher mornings, Souls afternoons.
But where Marcus moved from one visual language to another, Lena moved from one emotional language to another. And the difference was deeper than it seemed from outside, because music wasn't just sound but mood, and changing moods twice a day was like changing personalities: possible but exhausting in a way that wasn't measured in hours but in the brain's capacity to feel different things in rapid sequence.
The Witcher was melancholy. The Bulgarian gadulka Lena had brought from Prague. The violin that played the six notes of Geralt's theme with the roughness of an instrument that has traveled far. The female choirs of Krakow that added a layer of voices that sounded of distance and of loss. The Slovak fujara that was the wind in the fields of Velen. Every Witcher piece had the quality of something remembering: the soft sadness of something that happened long ago, different from the sadness of something happening now, and that the music brought back the way a scent brings back a place.
Dark Souls was silence.
Lena said it in the audio meeting where she presented the musical philosophy of Dark Souls with a sentence George repeated so many times that it became another team mantra:
"Dark Souls is 80% silence. The music only appears in the bosses and in Firelink Shrine. The rest is the sound of the player's footsteps and the echo of an empty world."
The silence was a design decision, not a limitation. Lena composed music for every zone of Lordran and then deleted it. The music was excellent, according to George, who heard it before Lena decided to erase it; she erased it because the silence said more than the music in a world where civilization had fallen. An empty corridor of Undead Burg with background music was a video game corridor. The same corridor with only the sound of the player's footsteps and the distant dripping of water was a corridor where something terrible had happened and where no one was left to remember it.
"The absence of music is the music of Dark Souls," Lena said. "The player walks for twenty minutes hearing nothing except his footsteps. And when he reaches the boss and the choir begins, the music strikes with a force it wouldn't have if the player had been hearing music the whole time. The silence amplifies the sound the way the dark amplifies the light."
Lena recorded the Dark Souls choir with a group of twelve singers from the San Francisco Conservatory one Saturday in August. The singers were classical music students Lena had contacted through a professor she knew from her years at Berklee and who owed her a favor since Lena had helped him orchestrate a piece for an end-of-term recital. The choir sang in an invented Latin Lena and Torres had written together: phrases that sounded liturgical but meant nothing in real Latin.
They meant something in the context of the game, they were fragments of the story of the First Flame, but the player wasn't going to know that unless he looked up the translation in the forums, which some players would inevitably do because Dark Souls players searched for meaning in every detail of the game like theologians searching for meaning in every line of a sacred text.
The Firelink Shrine theme was the last thing Lena composed for Dark Souls. A solo harp. No choir, no strings, no percussion. Just a harp that played a circular melody that returned to the beginning every 90 seconds, like a slow breath that didn't stop. It was the simplest piece Lena had composed for NGS, three chords, an eight-note melody, no variation, and it was the most effective because the solo harp in Firelink Shrine was the sound of the one good thing left in a world where everything else had died. It was rest turned into music. It was the bonfire made sound. It was the sound of sitting by the fire after surviving something you shouldn't have survived, and of knowing you were going to have to get up and go out again.
"Geralt's theme is solitude on a road," Lena said. "The Firelink theme is rest in a ruin. Both are solos. Geralt's is a solo violin. Firelink's is a solo harp. Because both games are about lonely people in worlds that don't belong to them."
* * *
George watched Marcus and Lena work one Tuesday in August and thought about what he was asking of them.
He was asking them to live in two worlds at the same time. For their brains to inhabit two opposite emotional universes every day, switching from one to the other like someone changing channels but with the depth of someone who doesn't change channels but moves house twice a day. He was asking them for something no other studio would ask because no other studio would make two games so different at the same time with the same artists.
And Marcus and Lena did it. Not without cost, Marcus had new shadows under his eyes and Lena had begun drinking green tea in quantities Claire considered "a concerning budget line item," but they did it with the quality George needed because the two of them understood something they didn't need to articulate: that the duality was a privilege before it was a burden. Few artists in the history of video games had had the chance to define the visual and sonic identity of two simultaneous worlds. Marcus and Lena had it. And they paid for it with shadows under their eyes and with green tea and with brains that didn't know what century they were in, but they paid for it gladly because the work was good and because good work justified the price.
Two worlds. Two palettes. Two musical souls. An artist who walked between the medieval mud and the Gothic stone. A composer who walked between the gadulka and the harp. And a director who walked between the two notebooks every morning with the growing certainty that the two games were going to be the best NGS had ever made, and they would be precisely because making them at the same time made them different: The Witcher was warmer because Dark Souls was colder, and Dark Souls was colder because The Witcher was warmer. The two defined each other by contrast, the way light defines shadow and shadow defines light.
Arc 3 was complete. Dark Souls was designed. The black and red notebook had all its pages written. Now it was time to build the two worlds in parallel: the Continent and Lordran, the witcher and the knight, the gadulka and the harp, the mud and the ash.
End of Chapter 137