CHAPTER 141: Four Thousand Seats (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 141: Four Thousand Seats
The Game Developers Conference of 2009 opened its doors on Monday, March 23, at the Moscone Center in San Francisco. For Claire Hightower it was the seventh edition she had set foot in as an attendee and the first she set foot in as a speaker. The difference between the two categories fit in four thousand seats.
The West hall of the Moscone was the largest in the venue. It had the geometry of an amphitheater remodeled for corporate conferences: sloped seating, two side screens the size of a bus, a catwalk of fixtures with microphones pointing toward a stage where they had placed a glass lectern and, behind the lectern, a central screen fifteen meters wide. The GDC organizers reserved the West hall for the keynotes they expected to fill. They had reserved the West hall for Claire.
Claire arrived backstage at twenty to nine in the morning. The keynote was scheduled for nine thirty. She wore a charcoal gray suit, a white blouse, flat shoes. Nothing in the outfit yielded to theatricality. She wore the same pulled-back hair she wore in the office and the same steel wristwatch she had worn since 2003. The only concession to the occasion was a small brooch on the lapel, silver, with no visible brand, that David had given her two nights earlier with the phrase so they know someone up there loves you. Claire had put it on without arguing.
A technician adjusted her headset microphone. Another asked if she needed water. Claire asked for a glass and left it on the lectern without touching it for the next ninety minutes. She was thirty-seven years old. She had been married to David for months. The belly didn't yet exist and the idea of Tommy was still a pending conversation for some Sunday, but that morning the only thing summoning her was the backstage clock.
At nine twenty-seven she entered the hall. The central screen said, in a sober typeface, How to run a profitable indie studio at scale. Beneath it, in smaller type: Claire Hightower, COO, NGS. There were no animated logos and no entrance music. Claire had vetoed both. The hall was full. Four thousand people. The front rows were occupied by executives and creative directors of the studios Claire knew by number of employees before name.
George was in row seven with Marcus, Daniel, and Tomás. Marcus wore the NGS sweatshirt, faded by five years of washing. Daniel wore a polo. Tomás had the laptop open on his knees because Tomás had the laptop open on his knees in any circumstance that didn't involve sleeping or swimming. George had nothing in his hands. He had decided that the only way to be present at the keynote was not to write, not to photograph, not to comment. To watch.
Claire began without a greeting. She began with a number.
"Twenty million dollars," she said. "That's what NGS billed in 2008 with forty-five people and a margin of thirty-six percent. I'll repeat them because I know some of you are doing the math: forty-five people, thirty-six percent margin. No publisher. No outside investors. No debt."
The hall fell silent. The GDC keynote was traditionally a space where the speakers talked about creativity and passion and game culture. Claire had begun with figures from an audited balance sheet. The shift in register changed the temperature of the hall in five seconds.
Marcus leaned toward George and whispered that Claire had just thrown the deck on the floor. George nodded without taking his eyes off the stage.
* * *
What followed were ninety minutes where Claire explained the five rules of NGS as an operating manual and a declaration of principles at once.
The five rules appeared one by one on the central screen. Teams of fewer than twenty people. The leads program, illustrate, write, or compose. Zero producers between the creative and the decision. Meetings of thirty minutes maximum or they aren't meetings. Direct access to George for anyone in the studio at any time without going through anyone.
Claire broke down each rule with the economy of someone who had lived them for six and a half years. She explained the real cost of a hundred-person team and the internal friction that appeared past twenty-five. She explained why the NGS leads were paid more than at other studios and why they couldn't delegate their creative work. She explained why a producer was, in her reading, a layer of translation that slowed information down and that was justified only when the creative didn't want to make decisions. She explained why long meetings were a symptom that no one knew what was being decided. And she explained why George answered a junior's email with the same speed with which he answered a lead's.
The hall took notes. Claire saw the laptop screens lit and the phones held horizontally recording video. She saw a man in row three, the manager of a studio she recognized but whose name she chose to forget in time, who shook his head as if Claire were saying impossible things. And she saw a young woman, two rows farther back, who was writing with an intensity Claire recognized: that of someone about to make a decision about her career.
At sixty minutes Claire added a sixth rule. The sixth rule wasn't in the presentation. The sixth rule was an inside joke David had suggested the night before in the kitchen while Claire rehearsed aloud and David played her audience.
"There's a sixth rule," Claire said. "It's not on the screen because it's mine, not NGS's. If Claire says there's no budget, there's no budget."
The hall laughed. It was a laugh of four thousand people, contained but unanimous, and Claire let it breathe three seconds before going on. George laughed too. Marcus laughed with the laugh of someone who had heard that phrase many times and knew the joke was a documentary truth.
* * *
Claire closed the keynote with an idea that wasn't in the printed script but that had been fermenting for months.
"We've spent twenty years talking about video games as an industry of creativity," she said. "The creativity exists. It's in the NGS teams and it's in yours. But creativity alone doesn't build a sustainable studio. Creativity builds a project. What builds a studio is the combination of creativity and business. And the industry conversation keeps looking at the first as if the second were shameful. Today I came to tell you that it's the engine that makes it possible for the creativity to keep existing next year and the year after. If you want your teams to keep creating, you have to let someone worry about the balance sheet. And you have to pay that person well."
The hall applauded standing. Claire came down from the stage at the same cadence with which she had gone up. Without waving, without thanking twice, without prolonging the moment.
George watched the applause from row seven and noticed something he had been noticing for a long time without naming it: that Claire needed that full hall, that public recognition, that validation that came from four thousand strangers. And that she needed it because of an internal accounting she had carried since she was sixteen and had realized that her family's finances depended on her holding them up alone.
* * *
The backstage corridor filled up in five minutes.
Mark Cerny was the first. Cerny was Sony's lead architect for PlayStation, an engineer with the face of a math professor and a resume that began at Atari in 1982. He shook Claire's hand with the formality of someone who recognizes a peer. He told her the sixth rule was the best part of the presentation and asked her whether NGS would be willing to talk with Sony about a technical collaboration for the next generation of consoles. Claire gave him a card. Cerny put it in the inside pocket of his suit.
Reggie Fils-Aimé came over two minutes later. The president of Nintendo of America had the physical presence of someone who played football in college and the smile of someone who knew that physical presence was a negotiating asset. Reggie asked for five minutes in the Moscone cafeteria the next day, instead of a formal meeting. Claire gave him an hour.
Thirty cards in twenty minutes. Claire counted them later, when she got back to the hotel and emptied them from the suit pocket onto the bed. Thirty cards, each from a studio or a platform or a publication. Claire ordered them alphabetically on the bedspread and put them in a plastic folder she carried in her suitcase for that exact purpose.
* * *
At noon George and Marcus left the Moscone by the Howard Street door.
There was a Mexican food truck parked half a block away, one of those white trucks with the bodywork paint faded by the sun and the menu written by hand on laminated cardboard. They ordered two carnitas burritos and two tangerine Jarritos. They sat on the curb, across from a building under construction, while the office workers passed with their employee badges hanging from their necks.
Marcus bit into the burrito and chewed three times before speaking.
"This changed," he said.
George nodded.
"Claire needed the recognition," he said. "The industry needs to see what's possible without a publisher. The two things happened in the same hour."
Marcus drank from the bottle of Jarritos. A long pause, not uncomfortable. Then he set the bottle on the ground between the two of them.
"And she needs to hear four thousand people applaud her," Marcus said.
George looked at the Howard Street traffic. A garbage truck was turning the corner with the specific slowness of San Francisco garbage trucks. The gulls screeched overhead.
"That too," George said.
* * *
Claire got back to Townsend Street at six in the evening.
The office was almost empty. It was a GDC Thursday and half the studio was at the Moscone in technical sessions. Claire went into her office without turning on the main light and took off her flat shoes and left them under the desk. She sat in the chair and rested her hands on her belly for a long minute. The pregnancy still didn't show under the suit but at six in the evening, after ninety minutes of keynote and four hours of corridors, the tiredness was the weight summoning her to stop.
David called her cell phone at six ten. He was at home. He had made soup. Claire told him she'd be there in twenty minutes.
David was waiting for her in the kitchen with the hot soup and two bowls on the table. The kitchen smelled of celery and chicken broth. David had put bread on a board. Claire left the bag on the chair, sat in front of her bowl, and looked at her husband with the expression of someone who knew the day had been important but didn't want to describe it yet.
David didn't ask how it had gone. David knew how it had gone. He had watched it on livestream from the computer in the living room. The only thing he said when Claire picked up the spoon was a short sentence.
"Sixth rule approved," he said.
Claire smiled. She ate the soup slowly. Thirty-seven years old. Four thousand people who that morning had applauded standing. And the hot soup in a bowl in front of a man who didn't need her to explain anything to him.
End of Chapter 141 (interlude, March 2009)