CHAPTER 144: Firelink, Undead Burg, and the Abyss of Blighttown (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 144: Firelink, Undead Burg, and the Abyss of Blighttown
Kenji built Firelink Shrine as the first thing Team Souls produced with final art.
It was September 2009. The Witcher was in the home stretch of production, with Team Witcher working 12 hours a day on the ground floor to reach the November code complete. On the upper floor of Townsend Street, Team Souls operated at a different pace: slower, more meticulous, with the patience of a team that knew its game still had a year of development ahead and that each piece had to be exact because the inexact pieces accumulated like debts that had to be paid later with interest.
Firelink Shrine was the heart of the game. The hub. The only space in Lordran where the enemies didn't attack, where the bonfire burned without threat, and where the player could sit, breathe, and plan his next move before going out into the hostile world. It was the place the player returned to after every defeat and after every victory, the fixed point in a universe that turned, and that was why it had to be perfect: because a player who spent 60 hours in Dark Souls was going to spend 10 of those hours in Firelink, and every one of those hours had to feel like rest.
Marcus designed it as a version of Dirtmouth distilled to the bone. Dirtmouth, the town above Hallownest in Hollow Knight, was melancholy: a sad but habitable place, with houses and lanterns and an NPC who talked with the Knight and gave the player the sense that someone cared. Firelink was desolate. Not sad. Desolate. The difference was that sadness implied that something had been lost and someone remembered it. Desolation implied that something had been lost and no one was left to remember it.
A ruined sanctuary on a cliff where the stone crumbled like the civilization that had built it. Grass that grew between the cracks in the floor of what had once been a ceremonial courtyard. Broken columns that had held up a roof that no longer existed, letting the gray sky of Lordran come in unobstructed. And in the center, the bonfire: a fire someone had lit at some point in the past and that kept burning as if the flame itself refused to accept that the world had ended.
The NPCs of Firelink were the remains of people who had been something before Lordran fell. A hollow warrior sitting against a wall with his head down and his rusted sword in his lap: he didn't speak, didn't move, only existed as a reminder that people could break to the point of no longer functioning. A merchant in a corner who sold items at prices that changed with the player's progress, more expensive as the world darkened, as if he knew that what he sold was worth more the less remained of the world where things had a price.
And the Crestfallen Warrior. The man sitting by the bonfire who laughed for no reason.
Torres wrote Crestfallen as the first NPC the player encountered in the game: a warrior who spoke with the irony of someone who has waited so long that the waiting has become his identity. Crestfallen gave the player the only instructions Dark Souls offered: "There are two bells. One above and one below. Ring them and something will happen. Or not. I don't care anymore." He didn't tell him where the bells were. He didn't tell him how to get there. He didn't tell him what happened if he rang them. He only gave him a vague objective and an attitude that suggested the objective maybe wasn't worth it. It was the perfect welcome to Dark Souls: a game that told you the minimum and expected you to find the maximum on your own.
Lena composed the Firelink theme: the solo harp she had created in her apartment at two in the morning, the eight notes that sounded of rest in the middle of the apocalypse. When Kenji heard the theme for the first time in the September build, the harp playing over the crackle of the bonfire while the player sat in the ruins of the sanctuary and looked at Lordran stretching downward, he nodded once. He didn't say "again." He said nothing. He just nodded. And Lena understood that the nod was the same as a standing ovation from anyone else.
* * *
Undead Burg was the zone Elena designed as the tutorial Dark Souls didn't call a tutorial.
Because Dark Souls had no tutorial. It had no separate section where the game paused the action and explained the controls to the player with text windows and arrows pointing to buttons. What it had was Undead Burg: a complete zone of the game designed to teach everything the player needed to know without telling him anything directly.
Elena designed each encounter in Undead Burg as a lesson disguised as gameplay. The first enemy the player encountered was alone, with his back turned, in a narrow hallway: it taught that enemies could be surprised and that attacks from behind did more damage. The second encounter was two enemies in an open space: it taught that managing multiple threats required movement and positioning. The third encounter was an enemy behind a corner who attacked when the player turned it: it taught that corners were dangerous and that looking before walking was a survival skill.
Each stairway taught the verticality of the world. Each bridge taught the extension. Each dead end taught that retracing your steps was part of exploration, not a failure. And each death taught what death always taught in Dark Souls: what you did wrong and what you could do differently.
"Undead Burg is an exam disguised as a class," Elena said in the meeting where she presented the design to Kenji and George. "Every zone after Undead Burg assumes the player learned the lessons of Undead Burg. If he didn't learn them, the following zones are going to remind him of them the hard way."
Kenji looked at the design for two minutes without speaking. Elena waited. George waited. The team in the room waited. Two minutes of Kenji looking at a diagram was a long time for someone who normally decided in thirty seconds whether something was right or needed an "again."
"The shortcut," Kenji said finally. He pointed to a spot on the Undead Burg map: a door at the end of the zone that connected back to Firelink Shrine. "Can the player see it from the start?"
"No," Elena said. "The door is at the end of an alley that looks like a dead end. The player finds it after exploring the whole zone."
"Good. If he could see it from the start, he'd know it exists. If he doesn't know it exists, finding it is a revelation. And the revelation is the reward."
Elena added a detail Kenji didn't ask for but that she knew he would approve: when the player opened that door and saw Firelink Shrine below, with the bonfire burning and the view of Lordran stretching in every direction, the game made an imperceptible pause, a quarter of a second where the camera adjusted slightly downward that forced the player to look. To see the whole world from a high point and to understand that the stairs he had climbed, the hallways he had traveled, the enemies he had killed, existed in a continuous space that could be seen whole if you found the right place from which to look.
That moment of reconnection. The moment George had described in the black and red notebook as "Dark Souls." Elena built it with the precision of an architect who knows that a building is defined by its windows: by the points where the space opens and lets you see what lies beyond.
* * *
Blighttown was the zone George almost ruined.
He ruined it with framerate. The most hated zone in the game, designed on purpose to be oppressive, hostile, and unpleasant, had a technical problem that turned the intentional difficulty into unintentional frustration: the framerate collapsed.
Blighttown was an abyss. A city built on scaffolds of rotting wood that stretched vertically over a swamp of green poison that glowed in the dark with the particle effect the artists had implemented as a constant dripping of toxic substance. The scaffolds were narrow: platforms two meters wide connected by stairs and bridges that swayed with the animation of a shader simulating wood that bears weight but would rather not. The enemies poisoned. The mosquitoes, particles with a hitbox that buzzed around the player, applied a poison effect that reduced health gradually. And the fall: a misstep on the scaffolds meant falling 50 meters into the swamp of poison, which meant instant death.
The problem was that the scaffolds, the enemies, the poison particles, the dripping effect, the mosquitoes, and the glowing swamp consumed resources the engine couldn't handle without dropping the framerate from 30fps to 15 in the worst moments. 15fps was unplayable. The controls responded with half a second of lag. The dodges didn't register in time. The enemy attacks that were legible at 30fps turned into teleportations at 15fps.
George played Blighttown in the November build and died six times. Three times to the enemies. Three times to the framerate.
"The framerate of Blighttown is part of the experience," George said in the meeting with Daniel, half joking, half serious. It was the excuse he would have used if Dark Souls were a game that accepted excuses. But Dark Souls didn't accept excuses. Dark Souls was a game that promised that every death was the player's fault, and three of his six deaths in Blighttown had been the engine's fault. That violated the fundamental contract of the game.
Daniel looked at him with the expression of an engineer who knows the joke isn't a joke.
"I can optimize it," Daniel said. "If I reduce the swamp particles by 40% and limit the mosquitoes to 10 on screen instead of 20, I get up to 25fps in the worst moments. It's not 30 but it's playable."
"Is the particle reduction noticeable?"
"The swamp glows a little less. The mosquitoes are half. Blighttown is still disgusting. Just a little less disgusting."
George authorized the optimization. The difficulty of Blighttown had to come from the enemies, from the poison, from the narrow platforms and the deadly fall. Not from the framerate. Fair frustration was design. Frustration from technical performance was error. And George wasn't going to release a game whose philosophy was "every death is your fault" with a zone where the deaths were the engine's fault.
Daniel optimized Blighttown in two weeks. The framerate rose to 25fps in the worst moments, 30 in the best. The mosquitoes were 10 instead of 20. The swamp glowed 40% less. Blighttown was still the most hated zone in the game, but now it was hated for the right reasons: because it was hard, because it was oppressive, because the scaffolds were narrow and the enemies poisoned and the fall killed. No longer because the screen stuttered.
Lena didn't compose music for Blighttown. It was one of the zones that were in the 80% silence of Dark Souls. What Blighttown had was ambient audio design: the constant dripping of poison that fell from the scaffolds into the swamp with a sound Lena described as "the sound of something rotting in real time." The buzz of the mosquitoes like a low tone that varied in intensity according to proximity. And the creak of the wood under the player's feet, each step accompanied by a groan of the structure that suggested the scaffolds could collapse at any moment, which wasn't mechanically true but kept the player in a state of tension the music would have diluted.
"Blighttown sounds like sickness," Lena said. "Not like danger. Like sickness. Danger has adrenaline. Sickness has nausea. And Blighttown has to provoke nausea because the zone doesn't want the player to feel excited to be there. It wants the player to want to leave."
* * *
George went down through Blighttown in the December build, the optimized version, with the framerate corrected, and reached the bottom of the abyss after forty minutes of descent that felt like forty hours.
The scaffolds had ended. The ground was toxic mud. The mosquitoes buzzed. The swamp glowed with the sickly green the remaining 60% of particles produced, an organic glow, like the bioluminescence of something that shouldn't be alive. And at the end of the swamp, in a cave the artists had decorated with the roots of dead trees and cobwebs so large they suggested that the spiders of Lordran were the size of dogs, was the Blighttown bonfire.
George sat at the bonfire. The Firelink harp didn't play here: the Blighttown bonfire had no music. Only the dripping of the poison and the crackle of the fire. It was a rest without solace: the fire healed you but the world around it stayed sick. It was, George thought, the most honest bonfire in Dark Souls: a fire that didn't pretend things were all right. Just a fire that existed because the player needed to sit and because sitting was all the fire could offer.
Three zones built. Firelink as rest, Undead Burg as school, Blighttown as sickness. Three experiences that told the story of what Dark Souls asked of the player: rest, learn, suffer. And after suffering, rest again. And after resting, get up and keep going.
Because above waited Anor Londo.
End of Chapter 144