Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

CHAPTER 145: The Golden City and the Ghosts That Speak

After Blighttown, after Sen's Fortress with its swinging blades and its bridges over the void that existed to kill whoever tried to cross them more than to connect two points, after hours of darkness and poison and eroded stone, the player reached Anor Londo.

And Anor Londo was light.

Marcus designed it as the game's visual reward. Everything Dark Souls had denied the player until that moment, color, openness, beauty, the sensation of being in a place someone built with pride instead of with despair, Anor Londo delivered in a single camera shot when the player crossed the gate and saw the city for the first time. Pillars of white marble that rose fifty meters toward a sky that for the first time in the game was golden, not gray, bathed by a perpetual sunset sun that came in through stained glass that cast spots of red, blue, and amber over the floors of polished stone.

Stairs that defied geometry, climbing at angles no real architect would have approved but that in Lordran had the logic of a world where the gods had built to impress other gods and where the laws of physics were suggestions that divine power ignored when it suited it.

It was the city of the gods. Or it had been. Because Anor Londo was empty.

The streets that should have been full of gods and their servants were deserted. The halls that should have echoed with voices and music were silent. The armors of the guards that should have patrolled the hallways were empty, standing in their positions like skeletons of metal that had forgotten they no longer had anyone inside. Marcus designed the empty armors as a visual statement: the presence of the form without the presence of the being. The player walked among armors that watched him with helmets that had no eyes, and the sensation was that of entering a museum where the exhibits had taken on a life that was memory of life more than life.

The beauty of Anor Londo was a lie. It was the most beautiful lie in the game: a golden city that seemed intact but that was dead, a facade of glory that hid the truth that the gods had gone and that the golden light was an illusion someone kept lit so no one would know that the sky of Anor Londo was as gray as that of Blighttown. Torres had written that revelation as one of the most striking narrative fragments in the game: if the player killed a certain boss and broke the illusion, the golden light disappeared and Anor Londo revealed itself as what it really was. Dark. Cold. Empty. The same city, the same pillars, the same stairs, but without the light that made them beautiful. It was the visual metaphor of all of Dark Souls: beauty as a mask of the void.

George walked through Anor Londo in the December build and stopped in the main hall where the stained glass cast its colors over the floor. He stood still for a minute watching how the light moved with the imperceptible rotation of the false sun the weather system simulated. It was beautiful. It was sad. It was both things at the same time, and the coexistence of beauty and sadness was what made Anor Londo work as the reward George had designed: a reward of understanding more than of joy.

The player who reached Anor Londo understood something he hadn't understood in the previous zones: that Lordran had already died and that it pretended to be alive with the desperation of someone who puts on the dead man's clothes and pretends the dead man is still walking.

Marcus received a "better" from Kenji when he showed him the final version of Anor Londo. Not an "again." A "better." Which coming from Kenji was like receiving a medal of honor from a general who didn't believe in medals.

* * *

The enemies of Anor Londo were different from those in the rest of the game. They were silver knights: the guards of the gods who kept patrolling an empty city because no one had told them to stop. They were bigger than Geralt, faster than the hollows of Undead Burg, and they carried shields that blocked most frontal attacks. The player who tried to fight a silver knight the way he fought a hollow died in three blows. The knights demanded respect: dodging behind, attacking in the moments when the shield dropped, and above all not fighting two at the same time because two silver knights together were an exam the player wasn't ready to pass yet.

Elena placed the knights in formations that told stories. Two knights patrolling a hallway: they had been guard partners and kept doing their round centuries after the round stopped making sense. A knight alone in front of a closed door: he guarded something that no longer existed but that his internal programming kept him from ceasing to guard. A knight kneeling before a broken statue of a god: the last act of faith of a servant who didn't know his god had gone.

Each formation was a fragment of lore the player could ignore completely or could stop to interpret. Elena and Torres worked together on the formations: Elena decided where to put the enemies and Torres decided what story each position told. It was environmental narrative through the placement of enemies, a technique no other game was using in 2009 and that George knew was going to be studied by designers for years.

* * *

Torres wrote the NPCs of Dark Souls as ghosts that spoke.

Ghosts in the figurative sense: people who existed in Lordran as remains of what they had been: warriors, mages, pyromancers, clerics who had come to Lordran with a purpose and who had discovered that the purpose made no sense or that the sense had been lost somewhere on the road between the first bonfire and the twentieth death.

Solaire of Astora was the first one the player encountered outside Firelink. A knight with a tabard that had a sun painted on it, sitting on a wall of Undead Burg looking at the horizon with the attitude of someone waiting for something that maybe was never going to come. Solaire spoke with an optimism that in any other context would have been normal but that in Lordran was disconcerting. He searched for "his own sun," a metaphor Torres left deliberately ambiguous: it could be a spiritual goal, a madness, a poetic way of saying he searched for a purpose, or all three at once. The players were going to debate for years what "Solaire's sun" meant and Torres knew the debate was more valuable than the answer, because the answer closed the conversation and the ambiguity kept it alive.

Solaire's questline was the longest in the game and the most painful. The player who followed him across the zones discovered that Solaire's optimism eroded with each encounter. In the first appearances, Solaire spoke of the light and of purpose with the warmth of someone who believes. In the last, he spoke of the dark and of loss with the broken voice of someone who has stopped believing but keeps searching because to stop searching would be worse than not finding.

And if the player didn't take certain actions in a certain order, actions the game didn't indicate and that required knowledge obtained only by dying and exploring and talking with NPCs at specific moments, Solaire went mad. The player found him in a late zone of the game, kneeling before a luminous insect Solaire had mistaken for his sun, and the player had to kill him.

Killing Solaire was the saddest death in the game. Sadder than Sif, the wolf that limped. Because Sif was an animal that didn't understand why it was being killed, but Solaire was a person the player had met, with whom he had talked, whose questline he had followed for hours, and who was now kneeling before an insect because the search for meaning in a world without meaning had broken him.

Siegmeyer of Catarina was the comic contrast that turned into tragedy. A fat knight with armor that looked like an onion and whom the player found stuck in front of each obstacle in the game with different excuses for not advancing. Siegmeyer feigned bravery with the clumsiness of someone who knows he isn't brave but needs others to believe it. His questline gradually revealed that Siegmeyer was in Lordran out of flight more than heroism: he had left his family because he couldn't admit that he wasn't the warrior he pretended to be, and the adventure was an excuse not to face the truth that he was an ordinary man in a world that asked for heroes.

Quelana of Izalith was the pyromancer who knew more than she said. She appeared in a late zone of the game, sitting beside a swamp, and only spoke if the player met specific conditions Torres designed as a puzzle of hidden requirements. Quelana revealed fragments of the story of the First Flame that no other NPC knew, and her dialogue, the longest in the game, although "long" in Dark Souls meant fifteen sentences instead of five, contained the keys to understanding why Lordran had fallen and why the player's final decision mattered.

Torres wrote 20 NPCs in total, each with a different narrative voice, each with a questline the player could complete or lose permanently. Twenty people scattered across a dead world who spoke in fragments and who said more in five sentences than other games said in five hours of cinematics.

* * *

George reviewed the NPCs in a reading session in January 2010 where Torres read the complete dialogue of the 20 characters aloud, one after another, like an actor performing a one-man play with twenty different voices.

The reading lasted two hours. Torres changed his voice for each character: Solaire with growing warmth that crumbled, Siegmeyer with a joviality that hid shame, Quelana with the cold precision of someone who has lived too much to feel, Crestfallen with the empty laugh of a man who has stopped trying. George listened without interrupting. Kenji, who was in the room because the NPCs were part of Team Souls, listened without moving.

When Torres finished, the room was silent. It was the dense silence of something that worked too well for the listeners' words to compete with the words they had just heard.

George thought of something he didn't say: that Torres had written for Dark Souls the opposite of what he had written for The Witcher. In The Witcher, Torres had filled a world with 200,000 words of dialogue where each character spoke with clarity and where the decisions were presented as explicit options. In Dark Souls, Torres had emptied a world until only fragments remained, and the fragments said more than the 200,000 words because they asked the player to complete what was missing with his imagination, and the player's imagination was more powerful than any dialogue Torres could write.

Two games. Two ways of telling. One that filled and one that emptied. And the same writer had done both, in the same year, with the same metaphorical typewriter and with two brains that worked in opposite directions according to the time of day and the notebook George set on the table.

Torres was, George thought, the most versatile writer he knew. And Torres probably needed the vacation he had mentioned months earlier.

End of Chapter 145

Comments

No comments found for this post.