CHAPTER 149: The Playable Novel (Patreon)
Content
CHAPTER 149: The Playable Novel
The Witcher went on sale on April 13, 2010.
Three simultaneous platforms. PC on NG Store at $49.99, PC at retail at $59.99, PS3 and Xbox 360 at $59.99. The ten-dollar difference between NG Store and retail followed the policy George had established with Los Santos: the digital version was cheaper and better. The NG Store version included an exclusive side quest Elena had designed as a monster contract with three resolutions and a unique item that affected the final fight. It was the incentive that pushed players toward the NGS platform, and it worked with the precision of a mechanism Claire had calibrated over four years: discreet enough that the retailers didn't complain, but attractive enough that the player who had the option chose NG Store.
George spent launch day in the office with Team Witcher. The ground floor of Townsend Street had the energy of a hospital waiting room: forty people who had worked two years on something that was now in the hands of strangers. Each person looked at their monitor with the mix of pride and anxiety that accompanies the moment when the work stops being yours and starts being everyone's.
Claire had the whiteboard. The numbers every hour. At nine in the morning: 15,000 downloads on NG Store. At noon: 60,000. At three: 115,000. At six: 180,000. At nine at night: 225,000.
The numbers fell below Los Santos, but above any other NGS launch. Claire noticed it at three in the afternoon with the contained gleam in her eyes George knew by heart: the gleam that appeared when the numbers did something Claire liked and that Claire disguised as neutrality because showing emotion over the numbers was, in the philosophy, a weakness the numbers didn't deserve.
First week: 1,050,000 copies. PS3: 300,000. Xbox 360: 250,000. PC retail: 150,000. NG Store: 350,000. George stopped at the last number. 350,000 from NG Store. A third of the total sales. With Los Santos, NG Store had been 14%. With the remasters, 25%. Now it was a third. The digital proportion grew with each launch like a tide rising slowly, month by month, game by game. Claire calculated the margins with the speed of someone who carries the numbers installed in the operating system of her brain: the 350,000 digital copies, which were only a third of the sales, generated 62% of the total profit of the first week. Digital distribution was already the financial engine of NGS.
* * *
The reviews arrived on launch day and over the following two weeks like a wave that grows before it breaks.
IGN published first. 9.4 out of 10. The review praised the decision system as the most significant of any RPG to date and the combat as demanding enough to reward mastery without punishing exploration. The only criticism was the PS3 framerate in Vizima, which dropped when the 30 NPCs of the market piled up in the field of view. Daniel read the criticism and accepted it with the resignation of an engineer who knows the PS3 was a poorly documented engineering miracle and that miracles had limits.
GameSpot: 9.2. The review focused on the side quests as short stories that rivaled the main quest in quality and emotional impact. The reviewer had played 60 hours and mentioned the Bloody Baron quest as the morally most complex quest he had played in a video game. Torres read that line and reread it three times before closing the browser with the silent expression of a writer who has just heard that something he wrote mattered to someone.
Rachel Kim published her review a week later. 5 out of 5. As always, what Rachel wrote was an essay. George Hightower had made six games, Rachel wrote. Each one had been the best version of what it tried to be. The Witcher tried to be a world where every action had weight. It succeeded. Completely. Rachel called The Witcher "a playable novel" and compared Geralt to a character of literary fiction who existed with the complexity of someone who didn't need a game to be interesting, but whom the game made more interesting than a novel could have, because the novel described the decisions and the game forced the player to make them.
George read the review twice. Rachel had the ability to articulate what George felt about his own games better than George could articulate it, which was admirable and slightly unsettling at the same time.
Andrzej Sapkowski called Claire one Thursday in May. Claire answered expecting the call of a server provider and instead heard a voice with a Polish accent that identified itself as the author of the novels you turned into a game. Claire handed George the phone. It was the first time they had spoken since 2001, when Sapkowski had signed the contract with the disdainful certainty that no one would do anything significant with his novels. Sapkowski had read the New York Times review.
The NYT had compared Geralt to a character of literary fiction and had mentioned Sapkowski by name as the author whose fantasy world had become one of the most talked-about game settings of the year. Sapkowski told George that his opinion of video games perhaps needed revising. He said it with the formality of a European who respects someone but who still doesn't want to admit he respects them. And he added that if they made a second part, he would like to participate more.
George hung up. Claire was looking at him with the expression of someone who knows that what she has just witnessed should be in a press release. Claire said that if Sapkowski wanted to participate, they paid him as a consultant and made sure he was happy. George asked how much. Claire answered: whatever was necessary for Sapkowski to keep saying that video games deserved revising.
* * *
The NG Store forums became a moral battlefield the week after the launch.
The most debated topic was the Bloody Baron. The thread was called "Did you save the baron or let him die?" and had 3,000 replies in the first week. The players shared their decisions with the intensity of people debating a real dilemma. A dilemma where every answer cost something and where the answer the player chose said as much about the player as about the character, far from the video game dilemmas where the right answer is obvious and the wrong one is a game over.
The debates were different from those of Los Santos. In Los Santos, the players debated mechanics: which was the best weapon, which was the best route, how to complete Wrong Side of the Tracks. In The Witcher, they debated ethics. Whether it was right to return a beaten wife to her abuser when the abuser promised to change. Whether it was right to kill a monster created by human injustice. To what extent a person's intentions mattered if their actions destroyed.
It was the first time an NGS game generated genuine moral debate instead of debate about mechanics. And the reason was that the decisions of The Witcher were designed so that the right answer was impossible to determine. The players who thought they had chosen well discovered, hours later, that their choice had caused suffering. The ones who thought they had chosen badly discovered that their choice had saved someone unexpected. The players began to share their "narrative paths": summaries of each decision and its consequences. Each path was different. In 3,000 replies to the baron thread, George counted 14 unique combinations of outcomes. Fourteen different stories born of the same quests with the same options but in different orders and contexts.
George read the forums for a week. He read the debates. He read the impassioned justifications and the confessions of guilt and the players who said they had put the game down for an hour after the baron quest because they needed to process what they had chosen before continuing to play. And he knew that The Witcher had achieved what it had been designed for: a game where the decisions weighed like the decisions of real life, where the context was as important as the choice, and where each player lived a story that was theirs and no one else's.
* * *
Gwent became a phenomenon that surprised everyone except George.
The first signs appeared in the second week. The forum posts stopped talking about the baron and began talking about cards. Players who had 15 hours of play and who had done 3 main quests because the rest of the time they were playing Gwent in every tavern of the Continent. Players who obsessively searched for the two cards they were missing to complete the collection of 120 and who had talked to every NPC in the game trying to find them. Players who described The Witcher to their friends as "a card game with a background story about a guy with swords."
The minigame George had added three weeks before code complete, the card system he had designed in a weekend and that Marcus had illustrated in five days, had become the most addictive mechanic in the game. The players asked in the forums for a standalone version of Gwent: a whole game of just cards, with online ranked matchmaking and tournaments. George read the posts and smiled. He knew this was going to happen because it had happened in his earlier life. He wouldn't make the standalone yet. He was saving it for the future.
What mattered now was that Gwent served exactly what George had designed it for: making the players talk to every NPC of the Continent. A player searching for cards went into every tavern, talked to every merchant, visited every village. And by talking to every NPC, he discovered side quests he would otherwise have ignored. Gwent was a funnel: it attracted the player with the addiction of the collection and pushed him toward the content of the world.
Claire saw the play-time statistics on NG Store, the platform tracked hours played per user, and showed George a number: the average play time per user was 68 hours. The main story took 35. The players were playing twice what the story needed. Side quests and Gwent. The two things George had added as complements were the ones keeping people playing. The complement was the product.
George walked through the Mission neighborhood one Saturday in June with his hands in his pockets and his head in a place between satisfaction and something harder to name. The Witcher was a success. The reviews confirmed it. The sales confirmed it. The forum debates confirmed it. But George felt something that accompanied every success since Castlevania: the awareness that part of what he had built came from memories no one knew he had. The Geralt of other versions made by other people in his earlier life. The quests he remembered. The mechanics he had seen work in another life. The 65% that was memory and the 35% that was invention.
But the praise was also partly deserved. Because George hadn't copied the game. He had taken what he remembered and turned it into something that was better than the original. And the improvements came from the team: from Marcus, from Lena, from Elena, from Torres, from Daniel, from the dozens of people who had added their talent to George's memories. The memories were the skeleton. The team was the flesh. And the result belonged to everyone.
Six games. Four genres. And a witcher who walked through a Continent a million people had bought in the first week and that 68 hours later they were still traveling without wanting to stop.
Now the knight was missing. Dark Souls awaited its turn.
End of Chapter 149