Supernatural - Chapter 17: I Lost My Shoe (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
Dean was back in no time.
The moment Murphy opened the door, he squeezed past her. He swept his eyes over the room, made sure Bela was gone and nobody else was waiting in ambush, then finally turned his attention to Murphy and Sam.
Water from the bathroom had spread into the main room, soaking a wide patch of carpet. The broken shower curtain rod and pieces of door trim were stacked against a wall, and a lamp lay shattered. Sam sat drenched in a chair, his damp hair a mess from running his hands through it. A red lump stood out on his forehead. He looked thoroughly miserable.
Dean stood motionless for several seconds. “I haven't even been gone an hour.”
“Exactly.” Murphy surveyed the damage with him. “You should be glad you're back already. Give it another hour and you might have had to dig us out of the motel's rubble.”
“Did Bela hurt either of you?” Ignoring her joke, Dean stepped over to examine Sam's forehead.
“No.” Sam looked distinctly uncomfortable. “She threatened Murphy, so I gave her the rabbit's foot.”
Dean gently felt the swollen spot, confirmed the skin hadn't broken, and withdrew his hand. “You did the right thing.”
Sam seemed relieved to hear that. Dean straightened. “She had a gun on Murphy. What else were you supposed to do? Let her shoot somebody just to find out if she was bluffing?”
“I almost got the gun away from her,” Murphy protested. “If that pipe hadn't burst at exactly the wrong moment, we might have had Bela pinned in the bathtub and beaten the crap out of her.”
Dean glanced at the bathroom, still dripping water. “Yeah. If. That's the important part.”
Murphy wasn't particularly convinced by her own defense. She bent to move a piece of wood out of the way, only for a deep ache to flare where she'd struck her waist against the sink. She paused, then straightened as though nothing had happened. Dean noticed anyway.
“What happened to your back?”
“Banged it against something. I'm fine.”
“Let me see.”
Murphy looked down at her waist, then at him. “Are you serious?”
He was already standing in front of her, frowning and motioning for her to raise her arms. “You bent over like somebody'd punched you in the kidneys. Come on. What, are you embarrassed?”
“It's not that dramatic.” Still feeling awkward, Murphy lifted the hem of her shirt a little. There wasn't an obvious bruise yet, but the skin was already flushed red. Dean bent to inspect it and pressed gently around her ribs. She was about to insist she felt fine when his fingers reached the most painful spot. She sucked in a breath and flinched away.
Dean looked up. “And that's your idea of fine?”
“It's nothing serious. Worst case, I'll have a bruise.” She promptly lowered her shirt. “It'll be gone in a couple of days.”
Dean looked ready to argue, but his phone rang. Bobby had tracked down Bela's temporary address through his contacts. She was staying in a short-term rental apartment near the motel, and there was a good chance the buyer would show up there too.
After giving Dean the address, Bobby reminded him that Sam's run of bad luck would only get worse. They needed that rabbit's foot back, fast.
Dean wrote down the address and immediately began checking his gun and spare magazines. Sam watched in silence before speaking up. “I want to come.”
“No.” Dean didn't even look up. “You're making light bulbs explode just by sitting still. I'm not taking you to confront a thief with a gun.”
“So I'm supposed to stay here?” Sam frowned at all the things he'd inadvertently destroyed. “I can't do anything. Somebody even has to stay behind to watch me.”
“Sam, listen.” Murphy turned toward him. “You willingly took on a curse that kills people within a week because you wanted to save me. That's not being useless.”
“But I gave her the rabbit's foot. That's why we're in this mess.” Sam still looked discouraged. He wanted to contribute something.
“You can't judge the first decision by everything that happened afterward.” Murphy leaned against the table, her voice serious. “You made the best choice you could with what you knew then. A bad outcome later doesn't make that choice wrong.”
Sam pressed his lips together and fell silent.
“And you do have a job right now,” she added.
He glanced up. “What job?”
“Try not to let anything in this room kill you.” Murphy eyed the chair that was practically falling apart. “At this point, that's going to be hard enough.”
Sam couldn't quite maintain his gloomy expression. He gave a helpless sigh instead. Dean had finished packing his things and picked up his car keys. “I'm going after the rabbit's foot,” he told Murphy.
“Good luck. As soon as you've got it, we'll head straight for the cemetery to destroy it.”
There were also those two hunters who were originally supposed to abduct Sam. Since Murphy had kept Sam off the internet this time, surely they'd be less likely to find him. Surely?
Dean paused, feeling oddly reassured by her words. Then he left without saying anything.
The room fell quiet again. Surveying the wreckage, Murphy realized they had a much more immediate problem. They'd finally managed to stay in a suite for once, and within hours the bathroom had flooded, the lamp had broken, and pieces of trim had come off the walls. It looked as if a giant had torn through the place.
“Oh my God... We have to get out before the manager sees this.” She sighed and rubbed her temples. They'd never even had a suite before!
Sam examined the damage, looking equally grim. “You're right. I guess we can only hope nobody finds us before Dean gets back.”
“Don't say that!” Murphy was genuinely alarmed. With the luck Sam was having, who knew whether he'd just jinxed them?
Sam opened his mouth, thought better of it, and said nothing.
Murphy spread dry towels across the bathroom doorway to keep the water from spreading. She gathered the broken lamp and glass into a garbage bag, then moved everything away from the soaked electrical outlets without daring to touch the outlets themselves. The moment Dean returned, they were packing and running.
Sam watched her work from the middle of the room. Several times he tried to get up and help, only to be pinned back in place by a look from Murphy.
“Sam. I've got this.”
“Murphy,” he protested weakly.
“Sam,” she replied, giving him nothing more than his own name.
They stared at each other for a few seconds. Sam was the first to give in.
Murphy went back to collecting the broken glass. At some point the garbage bag had split along the bottom, and a shard she'd failed to wrap properly rolled out beside her foot. She noticed too late. When she pulled her foot away, her shoe slipped on the wet carpet and she pitched backward.
Sam sprang up on instinct and managed to grab her, but his own foot struck the already cracked chair. One of its legs snapped. He and Murphy went down together with a tremendous crash, hard enough to rattle the things on the bedside table.
For two seconds, they lay there in silence.
“You okay?” Sam pushed himself up first.
“This time I'm not even going to pretend I'm fine. I'm definitely not fine.” Murphy clutched the part of her back that had taken far too many hits today. “I think I'm practically paralyzed.”
Sam was scrambling to help her up when somebody knocked on the door.
“Room service.” A man's voice came from the hallway. “We heard what sounded like a fall. Is everything all right in there?”
Both of them froze and stared at each other in horror.
Already? Had the motel staff heard the crash and come to investigate? If anyone saw the suite now, a chunk of their fifteen thousand dollars in lottery winnings would go toward paying for pipes, a lamp, a shower rod, and every other object Sam had managed to break, before they'd even cashed the tickets.
“We're fine!” Murphy called. Then she lowered her voice. “Sam, sit down. Whatever you do, don't make another sound.”
Sam hunched his shoulders and kept quiet.
“Ma'am?” The man knocked again. “Are you sure you don't need help? We have to make sure our guests are safe.”
Murphy got up, one hand pressed to her aching back. She kicked the garbage bag out of sight, nudged the shower rod farther into the bathroom with her foot, and straightened her damp clothes. Sam returned to his chair, now supported by three and a half legs, and watched nervously as she approached the door.
“I'll get rid of him,” she whispered. “Don't move.”
Through the peephole she saw a man in a motel work jacket, his cap pulled low over his face and a stack of clean towels in his arms. Nothing seemed suspicious. Murphy opened the door a crack, kept her body in the gap, and smiled. “Sorry, I just slipped. We're...”
Before she could finish, the man rammed the door with his shoulder and seized her wrist. Murphy stumbled half a step into the hallway as a cold gun barrel pressed against her waist. A second man appeared beside him, slipped into the room, and shut the door.
When Murphy got a proper look at the second man's face, she recognized them both. Kubrick and Creedy.
So much for being careful.
“Get your gun out. Slowly,” Creedy ordered, keeping her at gunpoint.
Murphy raised her empty hands to show she wasn't armed. Sam had already risen from the chair and was glaring at them. Kubrick trained his gun on him and warned him not to move.
“Twice in one day.” Creedy shoved Murphy farther into the room, and she sighed. “Could God cut me a little slack? Actually, forget it. Let's not talk about the God in this world.”
Creedy gave her a surprised look. Apparently he'd expected a little less commentary from his hostage. His grip on her wrist didn't loosen. “Shut up. Keep walking.”
Both hunters were concentrating on Sam. According to Gordon, Sam was the dangerous one. As far as they were concerned, Murphy was just an ordinary civilian tagging along with the Winchesters.
That was perfectly fine by her.
Creedy marched her toward the center of the room, preparing to have Kubrick search her. Murphy abruptly stopped. She stamped hard on Creedy's instep, ducked as his arm tightened reflexively, and twisted around. Gripping the wrist of his gun hand, she wrenched it outward with all her strength.
Creedy released his hold in pain. Murphy snatched the gun, drove an elbow into his stomach, then slipped behind him as he doubled over. She locked an arm around his neck and pressed the muzzle firmly against his head.
It happened so quickly that by the time Kubrick swung his gun toward her, Creedy was already her hostage.
“Don't move.” Murphy threw his own warning back at him. “Maybe your intelligence report should've told you not to underestimate people.”
Sam immediately reached for another gun on the table. His fingers had barely touched the edge when the already unstable table tipped sideways. The laptop and a glass of water slid off together. He stepped back to avoid the computer and planted his shoe directly on the shard that had fallen out of the garbage bag.
His foot skidded. Losing his balance, he stumbled straight toward Kubrick, as though he'd delivered himself into the man's arms.
Kubrick reacted instantly, caught Sam around the neck, dragged him in front of himself, and jammed his gun against Sam's temple.
In a heartbeat, the room had turned into the most ridiculous standoff imaginable.
Murphy had Creedy. Kubrick had Sam. Neither side dared move. Sam, struggling against the arm around his neck, looked down at the glass near his feet and then up at Murphy. His expression said everything about how thoroughly sick he was of his own luck.
“Bad luck, huh?” he muttered.
“Yeah, yeah. Terrible luck.” Murphy sounded just as helpless. “Pretend you're a statue, okay?”
Kubrick wasn't interested in their conversation. He stared at Sam's profile, his voice full of disturbing certainty. “Gordon said you opened the Devil's Gate. You let hundreds of demons out.”
“He was trying to close it!” Murphy tightened her arm, leaving Creedy gasping for breath. “Gordon wasn't even there to see what happened. You're going to murder someone on his say-so?”
“Everything that's happened on the way here led us to this,” Kubrick insisted. “We happened to hear a noise from this room, and we happened to find Sam Winchester. God guided us here.”
“That's his rotten luck.” Murphy glanced at the glass near Sam's feet. “What's God got to do with it? Okay, maybe a little, but you can't blame every coincidence on Him.”
Creedy didn't seem nearly as certain as his partner. With Murphy's arm around his neck, he managed to rasp, “Kubrick... maybe we should check first.”
“No need.” Kubrick kept his gun at Sam's head. “Demons are experts at making people doubt.”
His reasoning gave Murphy a headache. Whatever they said, Kubrick could dismiss it as a demon's lie. There was no arguing with someone who'd built a belief system that explained away every objection. Worse, Sam was still cursed. The longer they stayed like this, the worse their position would get.
Just then, a phone began vibrating beneath the bed.
Murphy's screen lit up, its ringtone muffled by the bed frame. All four of them glanced toward the sound. Nobody dared reach for it.
Elsewhere, Dean had finally managed to get his hands on the rabbit's foot after a confrontation with Bela. The instant his good luck returned, Bela's gun jammed. When she gave chase, she caught her foot in the carpet and fell. Dean left the apartment with the rabbit's foot, barely having to work for it.
He called Murphy. No answer. He tried Sam, with the same result. His grin faded. Dean sprinted to Baby and drove back to the motel as fast as he could.
When someone kicked the door open, the four people inside were still locked in their absurd hostage standoff.
Dean stood in the doorway, rabbit's foot in hand. He looked first at Sam, trapped in Kubrick's grip, and then at Murphy, holding Creedy at gunpoint. For a moment his expression went blank. Clearly, this wasn't what he'd expected to walk into.
“What kind of new game are you people playing?”
“Save the jokes.” Murphy's arm was getting sore from holding Creedy. “Help your brother first.”
Kubrick instantly swung toward Dean and tried to fire. His gun jammed. As he stared down at it in disbelief, Murphy took the opening and kicked the back of Creedy's knee, forcing him to the floor.
Creedy tried to fight back, only to step onto the same cursed shard of glass that had already caused so much trouble for Murphy and Sam. His foot slipped and his head struck the edge of the bed. Kubrick dropped his jammed pistol and reached for another weapon, but Dean had already scooped up a remote control by the doorway and hurled it.
It hit Kubrick square between the eyes.
He toppled backward and passed out on the spot.
Still aiming at Creedy, Murphy stared for two seconds. Dean examined the rabbit's foot in his hand, then the two hunters sprawled on the floor. His grin grew impossible to contain.
“I'm Batman.”
Sam, mentally and physically exhausted by his bad luck, gave him a flat look. “Yeah. You're Batman.”
Murphy had been flexing her aching wrist. At that, she looked up. Dean stood there clutching the rabbit's foot, absurdly pleased with himself, acting like an overgrown child. And somehow, she found it adorable.
The thought made her pause. Then she hurried to deal with the disaster in front of her.
Sam's bad luck really had driven her out of her mind. Why was she thinking about that now?
But then she came up with a perfectly good justification. She'd spent years freely admiring the brothers' faces on television. Why should she stop just because they were standing right in front of her? If anything, she could admire them even more!
Dean freed Sam first and then helped Murphy deal with the two hunters. Once he'd made sure neither of them was seriously injured, he told them to pack. They had the rabbit's foot back and needed to burn it at the cemetery. Besides, there was no way they could stay in this suite another night.
The three of them stuffed their belongings into their bags as quickly as possible. Dean surveyed the wreckage. “How much do you think we're gonna have to pay for all this?”
Murphy picked up the laptop bag. “If we leave fast enough, the bill can't catch us.”
Dean shot her a look. “Now you're starting to sound like a hunter.”
“A hunter like you two?” Murphy caught the implication immediately.
Sam sat watching them rush around. “What about me?”
They both turned to him.
After a few seconds, Sam said, “Let's just get out of here.”
Before they left, Murphy stuck a hand out toward Dean. “Lottery tickets. Hand them over.”
Dean immediately clapped a hand over his jacket pocket. “Why?”
“Trust me. I'm better at keeping your money safe than you are.”
“That sounds a little suspicious.”
“Then keep two yourself, and we'll see who's right.”
They stared each other down for a while before Dean reluctantly surrendered the tickets. Murphy photographed the numbers with her phone, made him sign the backs, and sealed them in a waterproof bag. Then she tucked it into the hidden compartment beneath the weapons case in Baby's trunk and locked it herself.
Once their bags were loaded, Sam could finally leave the room. He took each step with extreme care, avoiding broken bottles on the ground, a car that unexpectedly reversed, and another motel guest who nearly collided with him.
When Baby came into view, he visibly relaxed.
A passing car drove through a puddle, throwing up a sheet of muddy water. Sam stepped sideways to avoid it. At some point his shoelace had come undone, and the sole caught on a broken iron grate covering a storm drain. When he lifted his foot, the entire shoe slipped off, bounced twice across the pavement, and disappeared down the drain.
All three of them went silent.
Sam stared at the sock on his bare foot, then at the black opening in the pavement. Several seconds passed before he spoke, looking utterly wronged by the universe. “I lost my shoe.”
Murphy turned away immediately, but her shoulders wouldn't stop shaking. She might remember this for the rest of her life. She'd thought she was going to miss seeing it happen today!
“Are you laughing?”
“No.” Murphy fought to steady her trembling voice. “I'm observing a moment of silence for your shoe.”
Dean had been trying to act like a concerned big brother. The sight of Murphy struggling not to laugh was too much for him.
“You're both laughing at me,” Sam said, looking even more miserable.
“No.” Dean turned away and faked a cough. “Absolutely not.”
In the end, Sam followed them with only a sock on one foot. He wasn't about to risk losing the other shoe too.
It was already dark when they reached the cemetery.
Dean built a fire among the headstones. Following the instructions Bobby had confirmed, Murphy poured the bone ash and cayenne pepper into it. Sam hovered nearby, shifting his unshod foot uneasily. Nowhere felt safe to put it.
Dean was about to throw the rabbit's foot into the flames when a shot rang out from somewhere in the darkness.
Sam jerked as the bullet hit his left shoulder. The impact sent him staggering backward, and he crashed to the ground beside a headstone.
Murphy drew her gun almost the instant Sam fell and fired toward the sound. Bela, concealed behind a headstone, hadn't expected her to react so quickly. She moved a fraction too slowly, and Murphy's bullet grazed her upper arm, leaving a shallow but painful wound.
“You shot me?” Bela clutched her arm, incredulous.
Murphy was already kneeling beside Sam, pressing hard on his bleeding shoulder with one hand while keeping her pistol raised with the other. “I warned you not to threaten any of our lives.”
“I wasn't aiming at anything vital!” Bela sounded almost offended.
“You bitch.” Dean was furious, but the anger only seemed to sharpen his thoughts.
Bela's choice of target was obvious. Sam was still cursed, making him the easiest of the three to hit, and he was the one person Dean would never abandon. She'd evidently dismissed Murphy as harmless. That mistake had already cost her a wound.
“Say whatever you like. Throw me the rabbit's foot,” Bela called from behind the headstone. “Or the next bullet might not hit his shoulder.”
Dean glanced at the blood on Sam's shoulder. His expression was frightening, but he suddenly raised his arm and tossed the rabbit's foot toward Bela.
“Catch.”
Bela reached out without thinking.
The moment the rabbit's foot landed in her palm, she went rigid.
Murphy stared at her. “Why would you catch it with your bare hand?”
Bela looked down at what she was holding, her face slowly darkening.
“Sam put it in a bag first. Remember that part?” Murphy glanced at Dean. “You two really are brothers. Neither of you bothers to warn anybody before throwing things.”
Sam held his injured shoulder, his voice weak. “Can't help it. We're brothers.”
Bela had touched the rabbit's foot. If she lost it again, the curse would pass to her. Dean pointed his gun toward the fire and motioned for her to throw it in. She stood in silence for a moment, then tossed the foot into the flames with a stony expression.
The fire flared up, sending the smell of bone ash and cayenne pepper toward them. The rabbit's foot swiftly burned to a blackened lump. At last, Sam's run of bad luck was over.
Clutching her wounded arm, Bela glanced at Murphy before leaving. “You'd better find a way to break that contract.”
“Until then, try to stay alive,” Murphy replied. “And next time you visit, knock first.”
Bela's face darkened another shade. She turned and disappeared among the graves.
Dean immediately returned to Sam and examined his shoulder. The bullet was still lodged inside. They needed somewhere safe to deal with it as soon as possible.
Together they made their way back to Baby, helping Sam along. Murphy opened the trunk for the first-aid kit and took a moment to check the hidden compartment beneath the weapons case. The lock hadn't been disturbed. The sealed bag of winning lottery tickets was exactly where she'd left it, every ticket accounted for.
Dean saw what she was doing, and some of the tension finally left his face. “Still there?”
“Every one.” Murphy handed him the first-aid kit and locked the compartment again. “Bela never even saw what the tickets looked like.”
Dean nodded with satisfaction, as though they'd finally found something worth celebrating in this entire mess.
He took the bandage and pressed it against Sam's shoulder. Leaning against the back seat, Sam had gone pale from the pain, but he still found the energy to complain. “Could we maybe do something about the bullet in me before you celebrate saving fifteen thousand dollars?”
“Working on it, Princess.” Dean pressed a little harder, making Sam wince. “Hang in there. We'll get that bullet out, and I'll buy you a new pair of shoes tomorrow.”
Sam closed his eyes and slumped against the seat. “Rabbits are now my second least favorite thing in the world.”
“Still can't beat clowns?” Murphy asked with a laugh.
Sam fell silent. Dean and Murphy took one look at his miserable face and finally gave up trying to restrain themselves. They both burst out laughing.
Their laughter startled a group of unidentified animals somewhere in the cemetery.
Murphy climbed into the back seat and helped secure Sam's makeshift bandage. Dean shut the trunk, started Baby, and drove away. The black car left the cemetery behind, along with the last fading flames of the fire.
The rabbit's foot was destroyed, Sam's bad luck had ended, and they still had every lottery ticket.
As for the wrecked motel suite and the shoe that would remain at the bottom of the storm drain forever, they'd decided not to think about either of those things just yet.