Supernatural - Chapter 18: The Secret Club (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
The day after the rabbit's foot ordeal, Dean's first order of business was cashing in his $15,000 lottery ticket.
He was practically giddy with his winnings and had every intention of taking the money straight to a bar. Murphy caught him before he could disappear.
She divided the cash into separate funds for everyday expenses, weapons and medical supplies, and emergencies.
Dean objected, pouting that he'd scratched the winning ticket and deserved at least a little money specifically for enjoying himself. Then Murphy asked what he planned to spend it on. When he said booze, burgers, and a new stereo, Sam promptly sided with her.
Dean eventually talked them into giving him some spending money anyway. He burned through most of it in no time. Murphy wasn't surprised. She only warned him not to replenish his allowance out of their shared funds.
Summer gave way to late autumn, the months passing in a blur of gas stations, motel checkouts, and endless drives.
They passed through so many little towns that Murphy lost track of their names. Most of the cases they handled weren't remarkable enough to tell stories about afterward.
One family heard footsteps in the basement every night after moving into a new house. The former owner's bones turned up sealed inside a wall. On another stretch of highway, a ghost appeared in the back seats of cars driven by people traveling alone at night and frightened the drivers off the road.
Then there was the creature that stole babies' teeth. It wasn't powerful or especially dangerous, but it could run like hell. The three of them chased it around a stranger's attic for nearly half an hour, and the hunt ended with Dean putting his foot through the ceiling and dangling one leg into the bedroom below.
Little by little, Murphy went from barely keeping up with life as a hunter to accepting that, however ridiculous it was, this was her life now.
She learned to work on her laptop in the back seat of Baby, even managing to catch it with her knee when Dean took a sharp corner without warning.
She got better at playing whatever part a case required, too. All those years of people-watching had paid off. Her disguises and performances became more convincing than either brother's, and whenever Sam or Dean made a conversation awkward, Murphy was usually the one who rescued it.
Their division of labor settled into a routine. Sam researched cases, interviewed witnesses, and organized John's notes. Murphy sorted through online leads, surveillance footage, and forensic traces. Dean handled people who refused to cooperate. According to him, Sam looked too much like a nerd, Murphy looked underage, and that left him as the only one equipped to deal with the assholes in bars.
It had absolutely nothing to do with the pretty women in those bars, Dean insisted.
Sam also used the scanner Murphy had given him to digitize their paper records, and he helped bring some order to her chaotic computer folders.
Since Dean did most of the driving, he also controlled the music. Murphy heard his favorite tracks so often that she could tell him what song would come next the moment the current one started.
Sometimes she hummed along from the back seat. Whenever she did, Dean would glance at her in the mirror, then shoot Sam a smug look as if to say, See? She knows good music.
Sam usually answered with an eye roll.
During those months, Bobby repaired the Colt as well. Ruby had supplied the instructions, but Bobby did the actual work.
Murphy and the brothers hadn't seen Ruby themselves. Once she'd finished instructing Bobby, she'd stopped appearing at his house, and none of them knew why.
Their first case with the repaired Colt took them to a town that had abruptly descended into chaos. Casinos, bars, and establishments that never would have operated there before seemed to have sprung up overnight. People acted as if they'd thrown away their last shred of restraint, with violence, betrayal, and lust running rampant.
Murphy wasn't especially interested in most of the case. She did regret missing the spectacle of Dean failing to remember the Latin exorcism. What stayed with her, though, was the way Sam looked and acted when he finally killed the demons.
When Dean went missing, Murphy had a good idea where he was being held. She and Sam hurried there with the Colt. They arrived even before the priest who was possessed by a demon, though they never noticed him following them.
When the confrontation came, Sam fired without a moment's hesitation.
His first shot hit the priest. Almost immediately, he aimed his second at the female demon trapped alongside Dean. Dean called out to stop him. He'd wanted to leave her alive for the time being, but Sam had already pulled the trigger.
Sam's face was so cold and impassive that, for an instant, Dean hardly recognized the tall man standing in front of him.
Murphy watched them both without a word. When Sam's expression closed off like that, nobody could have called him harmless. He looked ready to tear someone apart.
The whole thing was over in moments.
On the drive back, Dean was quieter than usual. He still drove, complained about Sam choosing a longer route, and offered to stop for food as they passed a diner. But every few minutes his eyes flicked toward Sam.
Sam sat in the passenger seat reading through a file, apparently oblivious.
That night, they checked into a motel beside the highway.
Sam went across the road to buy dinner. When Murphy left her own room to look for Dean, she found him sitting on his bed with the repaired Colt in his hand.
He'd been holding its cylinder open for a while. He wasn't inspecting anything, just staring at the empty chambers.
Murphy sat on the opposite bed. “What's on your mind?”
Dean blinked and looked down, turning the cylinder with his thumb. “I never thought we'd actually get the Colt working again.”
“Are you questioning Bobby's handiwork? You know you'll break your poor old man's heart if he hears that.”
Dean gave a brief smile, but it vanished. He didn't tell her that Ruby was the one he didn't trust.
He snapped the cylinder shut and rubbed his fingers along the grip. After a while, he said, “You saw Sam shoot them.”
“I did.” Murphy suspected she knew what was bothering him.
“And you heard me tell him to stop.”
“Yeah.”
Dean turned toward her, waiting for more. Murphy said nothing yet. She watched the Colt in his hands, the motel lights outside throwing a cold glint across its metal.
“He wouldn't have done that before,” Dean said.
“Maybe you only think he wouldn't.” Murphy paused and turned to face him. “He has changed.”
Dean looked confused, but he let her continue.
“Who goes through death and comes back exactly the same? His mercy got him killed. Did you know he had a chance to kill Jake first? He spared him, and you know how that ended.”
“Then Sam woke up and found out you'd traded your life for his. Every day brings your deadline closer. How could all that leave him unchanged?”
Dean said nothing. His lips pressed together, his jaw tightening until he could feel his teeth grinding. He wanted to drag Jake out of Hell and kill him ten more times himself.
“He's been quicker to pull the trigger lately, and more willing to put saving you ahead of everything else. That's true,” Murphy continued. “But it doesn't mean he's become something else. I can guess what the Yellow-Eyed Demon said to you. He wanted you to doubt your brother.”
Dean looked down, absently stroking the Colt's grip with his thumb. “What if he was telling the truth?”
“I thought you were the last person who'd believe a demon's bullshit.” Murphy snapped her fingers in front of his face. “Once you let yourself doubt Sam, you'll start filling in the blanks. Every little thing he does will look like proof that he isn't the same person anymore.”
Dean looked at her, his lips parting, but nothing came out.
Her voice softened. “You can worry about the things he does. Just don't start doubting who he is.”
Silence settled over the room.
“He's scared,” she said. “Scared of losing control again and scared he won't be able to save you. It's making everything he feels worse, and he's going further than he used to. That's exactly why he needs people who'll pull him back. If you start doubting him too, he'll end up charging ahead all alone.”
Dean slowly slipped the Colt into its holster. “I'm not doubting him.”
Murphy didn't call him on the lie. “That's Sam Winchester. Who's been raising him since he was a baby? You know who your brother is. Better than anyone.”
Dean had no answer.
Outside the door, Sam stood with the takeout bags in his hands, one hand resting on the doorknob. He had been there for some time, utterly still.
Steam rose from the food and gathered in beads of moisture inside the plastic bags.
Only after Dean and Murphy's conversation had ended, followed by another long silence, did Sam look down at the bags. He sighed quietly and opened the door, pretending he'd only just arrived.
He didn't mention what he'd heard that night.
Cases continued to come and go. Outwardly, nothing about their life on the road changed. But Murphy began to notice Sam knocking on her motel-room door more and more often.
Sometimes he wanted to discuss a case. Sometimes he brought her organized files and stayed long enough to drink a coffee at her desk. Dean started grumbling that the two of them must have their own little secrets now. Murphy thought the accusation was completely unfair.
At first, they really did talk about ordinary things, from Dean's deal to the habits of different demons. Then one night, Sam sat silently in her room for a long while before saying, “I heard what you told Dean that night.”
Murphy had been idly messing around on her laptop. Her fingers stopped over the keyboard, and she turned toward him.
Sam sat by the window, his long legs barely fitting into the cramped space. An empty paper cup was still in his hand, its softened side dented where he'd pressed his thumb into it.
“How much did you hear?” Murphy asked. She'd hardly ever been alone with Dean, so she knew at once which conversation he meant.
“Pretty much all of it.”
“Do you not make any noise when you walk?” She stared at him. “I can't believe Dean didn't notice you either.”
“He had other things on his mind.” Sam turned the paper cup in his hands. After a moment, he asked, “Do you really think I'm just scared?”
“Aren't you?”
Sam didn't deny it.
Murphy closed her laptop and swiveled her chair toward him. “What do you want to know?”
He studied the cup, trying to decide where to start. “I know I've been quicker to act. Sometimes, when I run into a demon, I don't even stop to think about whether its host can be saved. All I can think is, what if I hesitate and Dean dies?”
His voice stayed level, but his fingers tightened until the cup began to crumple.
“I know it's wrong,” Sam said. “But I'm running out of time.”
Murphy took the nearly crushed cup from his hand, threw it away, and slid a can of coffee across the table to him. “Of course you're terrified of losing Dean. We all are. But you can't let saving him be the only thing you think about.”
Sam lifted his head, plainly unconvinced. “He's my brother. What am I supposed to do, stand there and watch him die?”
“Your brother wants Sam to live,” Murphy said. “Not some maniac who'll do absolutely anything to save him, no matter what he turns into along the way.”
She paused. “I'm not saying it's wrong to want him alive. I'm asking you to think about the things you've been ignoring. Like what Dean actually wants.”
Sam sat quietly for a long time. He touched the coffee can but didn't open it.
“Every time I bring up the deal, he cracks a joke,” he said, more quietly now. “Or he tells me it's already done and there's nothing we can change. It's like he's made peace with dying.”
“He hasn't,” Murphy replied. “He just doesn't dare let you see how scared he is.”
“Then why won't he just tell me?” Sam was sick of seeing Dean act like sacrificing himself for his little brother was the obvious thing to do.
“Because he's afraid to be afraid in front of you,” Murphy said bluntly. “He's trapped in this idea that the big brother has to look after the little one. He's been expected to do that since the day you were born. You can't expect him to undo more than twenty years of it overnight.”
Sam dropped his eyes, his mouth tightening slightly. “Sometimes that makes me hate Dad.”
“Who wouldn't?” Murphy said softly. She thought of the even crueler truths that still lay ahead for the brothers.
Sam didn't suddenly tell Murphy every secret he had after that night. He still spent ages thinking things over and tried to find solutions by himself. But some of the thoughts he'd once had to keep buried finally had somewhere to go.
So when they finished a case involving a string of deaths straight out of fairy tales, and Sam secretly summoned a crossroads demon, he eventually returned to the motel and told both Dean and Murphy what he'd done.
The answer he'd gotten wasn't surprising. The crossroads demon couldn't release Dean from his deal because her superior held the contract. Murphy had told them that already. What infuriated Dean was that Sam had gone off alone to face a demon with the Colt again.
“You knew she might have backup.” Dean stood beside the table, slamming his palm against it. “You knew demons love setting traps, and you still went without telling either of us?”
“I was prepared. I had the Colt.” Sam's voice hardened. “And I came back.”
“Oh, great. You want a medal?” Dean couldn't believe what he was hearing.
Murphy sat between the two beds, looking from one brother to the other. She hadn't meant to interfere, but their voices kept rising. Soon they'd be shouting too loudly to hear each other at all.
“The fact that Sam came back and told us is progress.” She looked at Dean, then at Sam, and clapped to get their attention. “But summoning a demon by yourself was still incredibly stupid. Both things can be true.”
Sam pressed his lips together and didn't argue.
Dean perked up, apparently delighted to have an ally. “You hear that?”
Murphy raised a hand to cut him off. “Don't look so pleased with yourself. You know perfectly well why he didn't tell you beforehand.”
Dean bristled. “What's that got to do with me?”
“Because every time Sam brings up your deal, you find a way to dodge the conversation.”
“I don't dodge it.”
“You know the answer to that better than I do,” Murphy said evenly.
Dean frowned and raised his voice. “I said I don't.”
Sam and Murphy simply looked at him.
Dean's righteous indignation slowly wilted. At last, he raked a hand through his hair. “Fine. I get it.”
Dean remained sour all evening, and Sam didn't apologize. Yet the next morning, they climbed into Baby together as naturally as ever, as if the argument had been just another part of being brothers.
Murphy assumed that was the end of it.
A few days later, though, Dean took advantage of Sam going out to buy supplies and slipped into Murphy's room looking suspiciously furtive. “So, what do you two talk about these days?”
Murphy looked up from the documents she was organizing. “Who?”
“You and Sam.” Dean spun his car keys around one finger, making an obvious effort to sound casual. “Does he come to you about everything now?”
“Not everything.”
Dean was just beginning to look relieved when she added, “Only some things.”
His keys stopped spinning. “How many things?”
Murphy studied him. Understanding slowly dawned. “Are you upset about this?”
“Why would I be upset?” he shot back. Then, perhaps realizing he'd answered too quickly, he rubbed his nose. “He's my brother. It's just weird that he'd rather talk to you about some things than tell me.”
“Maybe that's exactly why. Because you're his brother.”
Dean frowned, plainly unhappy with that explanation. “So he's worried that I'll worry about him, and instead he comes over here so you can worry about him?”
Murphy was silent for two seconds. “...Yeah.”
A triumphant smile was just forming on Dean's face when she added, “But you could also stop covering up how you really feel with jokes every time he's trying to have a serious conversation.”
His smile fell away.
“I'm just trying to keep things from getting too heavy.”
“And Sam's just trying not to worry you more.” Murphy set her papers aside. “You're both doing the same thing for the same reason. You just think the other guy's doing it wrong.”
Dean leaned against the door, his keys motionless in his hand. After staring at the floor for a few seconds, he asked, “What does he tell you?”
“I can't tell you that.”
Dean's head snapped up. “Why not?”
“Because he told me in confidence.”
“I'm his brother.”
“Then you can ask him yourself.”
Dean looked even more irritated. He clearly wanted to argue, but he knew she wouldn't budge. At last he yanked the door open and walked out, muttering, “Secret club.”
Murphy watched him go and burst out laughing.
That evening, Sam knocked on her door again. He glanced down the hall after stepping inside, making sure Dean hadn't followed. Then he lowered his voice. “Did Dean say something to you today?”
Murphy stared at the Game Over message on her screen. For a long moment, she said nothing.
Sam shifted uneasily at the look on her face. “What's wrong?”
“I was just wondering...” She closed her laptop, unsure whether to laugh or cry. “When exactly did I become the emotional switchboard for you two?”
Sam blinked, then couldn't hold back a laugh.
“Is that so bad?” he asked, sounding faintly embarrassed.
“You two.” Murphy leaned back against her headboard. “If I were Bobby, I'd block both your numbers.”
...
By late October, the weather had turned properly cold. The following morning, Sam found a strange death in the Massachusetts news. A perfectly healthy woman had died in her bathroom, with seawater filling her lungs.
The location and cause of death immediately stirred Murphy's memories. She was staring at the blurry photograph in the paper when Dean's phone rang, before she had the chance to say a word.
He answered, listened for a few seconds, and grew steadily more annoyed.
“Well, isn't that convenient?” Dean held up the phone for the others to see. “Bela's interested in this one too.”
Murphy leaned back in her chair, suddenly uneasy.
She could only hope Bela understood what it meant to behave like a guest this time.