Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Here are two things I know to be true: the holidays are upon us, and if I see a Pillsbury Bake-Off cookbook for sale, I'm going to buy it. I found this beauty--the 1978 edition--last month, and while visiting friends last week, I tried out a recipe from it. And it is... possibly the perfect recipe? It's definitely my perfect recipe, and it's my holiday gift to you. 

Here's the recipe written out for the copy-pasters of the world, with all its glorious product placement intact:

Patricia Kinstrey's Lemon Crescent Pull-Aparts

1/2 cup [60 mL] honey

1 tablespoon [15 mL] margarine or butter, melted

1 teaspoon [5 mL] McCormick or Schilling Lemon Extract

2 (8-oz.) cans Pillsbury Refrigerated Quick Crescent Dinner Rolls

1 teaspoon [5 mL] grated lemon peel or McCormick or Schilling Lemon Bits

16 pecan halves or 1/4 cup [40 grams] chopped nuts, if desired

Heat oven to 375 degrees F [190 C]. In 8- or 9-inch round or square pan, combine the first three ingredients; spread over bottom of pan.

Separate crescent dough into four large rectangles. Sprinkle each with 1/4 teaspoon lemon peel. Starting at shortest side, roll up; seal. Cut each roll into four slices. Press pecan half into cut side of each pinwheel or sprinkle chopped nuts over honey mixture in pan. Arrange rolls nut side down over honey mixture.

Bake at 375 degrees F for 35 to 45 minutes or until deep golden brown. Cool in pan 2 minutes; turn onto serving plate. Serve warm or cool. 8 to 10 servings.

Note: this recipe calls for nuts, if desired; I never desire nuts in a crescent roll situation, which to me is perfect for its very softness. (See also: cream corn.) Obviously use whatever brands you prefer. I go heavy on the lemon zest and use about a tablespoon total for the rolls, if not more. I've used various other citrus zests too. And these rolls have always been ready for me at 35 minutes on the dot.

Here's how they look, flanked by some period-appropriate publications: 

There is, in my opinion, an awful lot to love about this recipe. It comes together in about twenty minutes of active prep time (probably ten if you're more efficient than I am); it solves the eternal problem of crescent rolls, which is that they cool down in about twelve seconds. It can be a dessert or a side or a breakfast. I've served it five times now to a few different groups of people and it always disappears in minutes. It involves a moment of dramatic unveiling, where you flip it onto a plate like you're unveiling a Jell-O mold. It's humble on top and looks--to my untrained eyeballs--like a croquembouche on the bottom. It represents the work and time and creativity of a woman in a kitchen somewhere, expressing herself through food, and it uses convenience food to make something easy and gorgeous. It's infinitely customizable and also perfect just as it is. It's my gift to you if you need to make a dessert that implies effort, but you have basically no effort left to give. 

Patricia Kinstrey passed away just three years ago, and when I found her obituary, I learned this:

She was an excellent cook and baker. One of her fondest achievements was being one of 100 finalists in the National Pillsbury Bake-off for an original recipe in 1978. She received an all-expense paid trip to New Orleans, Louisiana to perform the cook-off on national TV. She was featured in the Life section of the Daily Freeman with a full page interview on Jan. 10, 1978. She enjoyed many family times with her brothers, sister and their families at her father's pool in High Falls. She loved long walks with her husband at Mohonk. She spent weekends boating on the Hudson river in their cabin cruiser. She watched Mackenna's Gold a zillion times. She was a restless, determined soul with a thirst for knowledge and a great sense of humor. She was an avid reader and even enjoyed reading the dictionary. She was a writer and sold an article for a small royalty. She was working on a novel before MS robbed her of her cognitive ability. She held a patent for an eye glass holder. She gave much to many charities.

Thank you, Patricia. 

If you try this recipe I would love to hear how it goes, about any changes you make to it, and what you think--and what else you're cooking, and/or eating, in these last days of 2022.

Expect a delicious bonus episode in this space in a few days. Until then, have a happy and a joyful and a bright one.

Love,

Sarah

Files

Comments

Rosie

Ily sarah thank u

cass

ooh i might try this for christmas breakfast. lovely post, thank you for sharing

Tess Mize

Thank you Sarah! I love the way you write (I forget that sometimes, given that the main way I consume your creation is through my ears these days); I feel like I can taste these scrumptious lemon beauties already.

Katie Larson

My kids and I make an incredible similar recipe on Christmas morning, except with brown sugar and butter instead of honey. We’ve never added the lemon and I’m intrigued to try this “new” mix! We just got our basic sugar cookies out of the oven to decorate! I saw you at your Portland show and am excited to see you next year with the Bechdel cast! Have a very happy holiday season!!

JenGelfling

Sarah Marshall I didn't think it was possible to love you more but this has proven me wrong. You are a wonderful person and a gift to humanity. Happy holidays and thanks for all that you give to us

Corey Ann

What an absolute GEM Patricia sounds like!

Bridget

This looks tasty, and, also, thank you for sharing her obituary with a link to the entire text. Patricia was damned impressive.

Michelle Corey

I have already said that I was done with my holiday grocery shopping but nope because I have to make these asap 😅 Happy Holidays to you all 💕

M R

MS is cruel, but she sounds like she made the most of her life regardless. I can't wait to try this recipe and honor its creator.

ramohse

Literally going to make these tomorrow, thank you Sarah (and Patricia)

Anna McDuff

This is beautiful, thank you.

Kristy Moore

I loved that whole obit. Also, I have everything in my house to make this, so I know what we're having for breakfast tomorrow!

Dannah Dennis

Thank you for this and for everything, Sarah!

Liz LaManche

What a fun recipe and story, thank you! I bet my mom will love these. The butter and honey mixture takes me right back to my grandmother’s baklava recipe (sans lemon of course… oh wow lemon baklava, hmmmm now). Thank you Sarah for the hours of fun you have given me and my sweetie, filling our long car rides with entertaining yarns as we pillaged your back catalog for more of the weirdness that humans do, with your wholesome and funny commentary. What I’m cooking a lot of this year is Swedish mandel kakor which is basically a sugar cookie with a touch of biscotti, and a scandalous amount of almond extract. People see them and go ”oh cookies.” Then they try one and their eyes widen and they say something to the effect of “Holy crap these are GOOD!” and proceed to eat several more. The trick is to bullshit your way into a restaurant supply store and score a quart of almond extract, because it’s SO much cheaper that way, and this recipe will use a whole one of those dinky expensive supermarket bottles. It’s basically just your standard cookie, but you bake them in big thick pancakes and then halfway through, interrupt the baking to cut them gently into smol squares and turn the heat down a bit. Swedish mandel kakor: Preheat oven to 350 1c butter, room temperature or soft 1c sugar 3c flour 1Tb baking powder 1/2 tsp salt 1-1/2 oz almond extract 1 beaten egg for brushing on top 1/2 cup or more Swedish pearl sugar OR nonpareil sugar sprinkles OR colored sprinkles Cream together butter and sugar, add almond extract Mix dry ingredients well, gradually add to sugar mixture Separate into 4 balls, pat each into a thick circle a little less than a half inch thick, put each on its own cookie sheet, brush with beaten egg and sprinkle on sugar topping. Bake 20 min. Remove from oven and cut gently into small squares, separating them so there’s air space on all sides. Lower oven to 300 and bake another 10-20 min ( you can leave them a bit chewy or let them start to turn barely golden on the edges for crisp cookies) I do 2 pans at a time in the oven to give the cookies plenty of space, don’t forget to turn the oven back up to 350 for round 2! Whatever you’re all cooking or eating, have an excellent holiday season! 🎄⭐️🎉

Reni Ellis

Sarah-in a funny coincidence, I’m good friends with Patricia’s granddaughter. I shared this post with her and she said she’s so happy to hear that her grandma’s recipe is still appreciated so many years later! Happy holidays!

Katrina Walsh

I live in Australia, a land without crescent dough, but I DO have a large quantity of frozen puff pastry dough I'm trying to use before I move early January (Christmas lunch is pastry heavy this year). How disastrous would this be if I attempted it with puff pastry?

Joyclyn Vincent

Please try it! I’m in Australia too and was initially excited to try the recipe and then saw the ingredients and immediately gave up haha.

sun the bun.

Thank you, can’t wait to try it for Xmas this year :)! Also I appreciate the zines in the background, adds the perfect level of 40 year old(?) cultural distortion to your pastries

Tharon

Using crescent rolls in creative ways is kind of my jam. I’ve utilized them in a sausage casserole that sustained me through my early twenties. I have one clarifying question: how do you cut the rolled dough into four equal parts? A rolled up crescent (🥐) will not in my mind yield 4 equal clumps of dough, but the pictures of the finished product make it look very uniform.

yourewrongabout

This was hard for me to picture without the rolls in front of me but basically each container contains eight rolls and you're rolling up each of the undivided sheets of four rolls, which gives you a nice uniform log that you can slice into four pinwheels

Tharon

Got it! Thank you

Kevin Lechuga

Thank you for everything, Sarah.

Judith

We eat a whole lot of Raclette (melted Swiss cheese) this time of year. On the more festive days people will serve a whole lot of stuff with it, but for me, all you really need is the cheese, some nice skin-on potatoes and a crusty baguette. Add a glas of white wine to the mix, and I am in heaven. Happy Holidays to everyone!

Katie Z

Recipe looks delish but honestly the “how to control your temper” on the Seventeen magazine cover is absolutely stealing the show for me lmao

Kristy Moore

I substituted orange extract and orange zest (well I had mandarins on hand) for the lemon and sliced almonds for the pecans and used orange blossom honey and I think I may now have the most perfect Christmas Eve morning breakfast?

Sara Amorosi

Looks like there's an importer in Melbourne that occasionally gets Pillsbury dough in: https://usafoods.com.au/ Nothing available right now of course hahaha. Keen to try the recipe you shared, Sarah!

Sara Amorosi

My dad was a late arrival from Italy to Australia (i.e. 1980s rather than post-war 1950s like mum's side) and my mum interrogated him about traditions that would make him feel at home. So we have a white (plastic) tree and bake provincial Italian treats. The best and most popular are calzoncelli: deep fried ravioli-like pastries filled with a chickpea, cocoa, and Cointreau mixture. There's a heavy dose of cloves and cinnamon that's the perfect accompaniment to the chocolate-orange base flavour. My favourite food tradition.

Angela

It’s Christmas morning and I’m making the sticky buns!! Please make Pillsbury Bake-off recipes a standing feature! ❤️❤️

Erika Zar

Just made them for Christmas morning! Easy yet impressive, deliciously indulgent. Thank you for the amazing recipe and happy holidays!

Erica Boisvert

Sarah, you're always a pleasure. Thank you for bringing humanity to everything you do. Happy Everything!

Lola Cavanna

You bring us so much joy with little vintage snippets! Merry Christmas Sarah!

KSCHatch

If I can figure out how to make this gluten free I am so going to try it. This looks amazing.

Maciej Gieradka

Guys which episode of the podcast is that, where Sarah tells Mike about all those reddit stories and theories? Including the one where there's an old little lady sitting and she turns out to be a trafficker?

Annie

Halloween Special: Creepy Encounters! October 19 2020