Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey everyone! This week, you better clear your calendar, because on top of tomorrow's main feed episode covering the two part Rebels Season 3 season opener, we're giving you a five star run time conversation about The Acolyte's first four episodes and all of the mixed feelings they've generated for us. Enjoy!

Show Notes

Official Star Wars Eras Timeline

Star Wars Legends Books in Chronological Order 

Files

Comments

Grant M

5 Star Runtimes are BACK! We've never been more up.

Ethan Hoff

When I saw this come up on my feed I genuinely giggled like a child. I can’t wait to see what they got cookin in their noggins

logan

Star wars.com/eras needs to chill, that is too many eras.

Vio Darc

That feeling when there's a new long AMCA ep for the long drive home after work. Pure comfy

Kelvin

Realizing this is longer than all the episodes and going “nice”

Scotty Jones

Runtimes that make you go mucha shaka paka

Holocron Hoard

Tales from the Jedi kind of rips - you go around the rest of the planet Batuu (you never actually really go into Black Spire Outpost), there’s a bunch of missions where you’re playing as a common tech with a blaster, and then some flashbacks where you play as a Jedi Padawan in the past (or in one case, an IG droid). It’s not a bad package!

SoSo_Tsundere

Excellent. Finally justifies taking that Shyriiwook elective.

xandala117

To answer your question Austin, the tone of this show is completely different from the whole High Republic comics and novels.

Cas Swanson

Hey, as a High Republic reader, I can offer the idea from around 38 minutes that this is the High Republic in its waning days. Starlight Citadel and the opulence of the era has already fallen. The prison ship can't afford full guards. The Republic over-expanded and is in the early stages of the crumbling infrastructure we see in Clone Wars

Keeper

Yeah, there was a book that released before the show about the council like a year before TPM. And in that they go deep on how much the jedi order still has outside Coruscant. And its not much. Even places that everyone on the council like/spent much time at by this point have mostly been abandoned or given up to the republic due to rent/budget cuts/no jedi to run the outpost or whatever. When Dooku was a padawan they still had some stuff around the galaxy but it was vastly reduced from the height of the high republic where they built space stations just to show off/expand influence to protect people.

KaliWolf

Only a bit into the episode, but in reference to the look and vibrancy of the show, I agree that they likely messed with it too much and made it look not as good as it could. However, I did notice a rather significant difference in colors and vibrancy depending on what sort of device I was watching on. If you have access to a 4K TV, I’d highly recommend that, I think the show actually looks pretty nice on that.

Sloane Kenlee

I can't believe I'm posting Grimm corrections to the Patreon but most if not all of Grimm was in fact Portland for Portland! They shot at many local iconic bars and parks, the stars lived in Portland during production (a fact that some very loudly lamented to locals), and when the show ended their two huge, local prop warehouses were liquidated. A cafe I worked in was used for production staging for a holiday episode, so I got to sell coffee and pastries to the cast, crew, and background actors while they were dressed as candy canes and elves. I bought a nice jacket and a marble lamp from the warehouse sale. It was the major player in the film industry after Leverage stopped production in Portland.

Patrick Kay

Yes, The High Republic sub-series literally begins with the old opulent past being corrupted and destroyed, which makes Lucasfilm's synopsis of THR as "A Golden Age!" really weird. They want to act like it's happy and fun because there are a lot of new Jedi characters but the government is failing and those new Jedi are forced into previously unknown horrors. By the Prequel age the Republic/Jedi are decrepit.

G Goldhar

Hearing about Andor every time we talk about Star Wars is going to turn me into an Andor resenter

Kojiroll

Yoda big timing Acolyte so they gotta get Ki-Adi-Mundi is very funny to think about. Like yeah, he's got time for three star cruiser appearances but he's too busy for high republic stuff.

Sylvie

All this here has done the most anyone ever has to get me interested in the High Republic stuff. The gradual decline of an order stuffed to the gills with hubris? Yes please!

Sylvie

Seems to be one of the most popular ones in the galaxy. I'd love to talk to the wookie tourism folks that pulled that one off.

Cas Swanson

It's worth a try. I've been giving the novels a try on my library app. But there's usually a pretty big wait for the first few

Sylvie

And somehow that little green bastard is in all of them!

logan

It's the biggest example of what is wrong with Disney Star Wars. It's like if Spock was at the center of every major event in Star Trek

SoSo_Tsundere

They give great hugs and invented Life Day, what's not to love?

sulcata

I'm just one listener but personally I would be A-OK with y'all releasing these on the main feed!

Robot Ghost

Seen in a vision that this show is mid, I have. Available, I am not.

Lilith

This made running fun. No higher praise tbh.

Robot Ghost

The Disney live action shows are just a constant stream of baffled expectations. I can not believe they made a show where a Jedi shouts "the jedi do not kidnap children" as he reaches for his lightsaber to draw on the parent of a child he is about to kidnap and then my main take away from that show is that it was kinda boring. Also, I saw someone on twitter point out that at the end of episode 3 when Osha wakes up on the jedi's ship you can briefly see Tobin in the background and that huge scar that he has in the 2nd episode has appeared on his face.

Colin C.

Yup, they filmed near my workplace a couple times!

Jan

I’m just getting into some High Republic stuff and a pretty big plot point across several books is that there’s a secret evil force cult leader trying to gain political power. Jedha at that time is a place for many different force religions to gather and worship and debate philosophy. My assumption is that after the High Republic Jedi discover and inevitably defeat this force cult they start cracking down on any Force religions that don’t align with themselves, whether they are truly nefarious or not. Thus forcing this coven to hide out and operate in secret.

MuttonBandit

Sort of a clarification on Old Republic/High Republic. The High Republic is an era carved out of the prequels republic rather than the Old. I've never been clear on if the Old Republic is an seperate predecessor state that was restored, a la the New Republic restoring the republic after the empire, or just an era in one continous republic.

WGM

This makes funny listening after episode 5

Kyle HB Donnelly

You just cut it there?? How unnatural and ridiculous!! (Just kidding, loved the ranting fade-out)

A sudden absence of bees

I am also looking forward to your guyses episodes on Ahsoka for sicko reasons

Arentios

See, it's possible to have a 5 star runtime episode and still have a good natural stopping point before the next episode.

Will

I have complicated feelings about the show, but mostly positive. My hope for years now is that Lucasfilm would start dabbling in sub-100million dollar films, from Oscar-bait period dramas to romcoms, just set in Star Wars. Through that lense, it’s hard for me to say “x show is bad” when, at least on the tv side, they are taking swings, and it feels like the shows are different. However, it is baffling that they market all the shows like prestige tv.

Corey Brickley Illustration

okay so I'm glad Austin hit on the cinematography given episode 5 has dropped and they actually SWITCHED cinematographers from that episode forwards and in my opinion it is a MARKED improvement. The first guy was on Russian Doll and other sitcomish streaming stuff while the new guy is largely genre and action/war TV shows and movies. This is like a weird fixation I've developed and I'm glad someone else has noted how flat and Netflix-y the first few episodes felt

belle

The weird over-the-shoulder shots that made the actors look like they weren't looking at each other when they were talking was just killing me. I'm glad the back half will have a different person in charge of cameras.

Corey Brickley Illustration

Yeah especially with the martial arts movie evoking action scenes it felt really bizarre, because I could 100% see the vision behind the action but the photography was SO flat. Episode 5 was a huge step up

Grant Baker

I just watched episode 5 and I think it needs its own podcast episode! 😮

Derg

I also felt the weird color/grain filter problem. It had me restarting my tv multiple times until I realized

KittRembo

Really enjoyed the Coven scenes. Shoutout to PhilosophyTibe/Abigail Thorn who played one of the witches!! Also Korrill possessing Torbin was sick!

JennySighs

Isn't Osha's comment about the civilian robes just a joke when we hard cut to her in presumably those very robes? They're not very robe-like, but I thought they were similar enough to what Bazil was wearing that that's what they were. You're a non-Jedi working alongside the Jedi on a mission and under their protection? Here's your uniform.

Alex Potanos

Wait… is all of this building to the Civilians watching the sequel trilogy?! …Is the final episode of AMCA going to be Rise of Skywalker?! Jesus.

Emmet

Just chiming in about Grimm to say it was actually filmed mostly in Portland, I used to help cater lunches for the production team back when it was going and ended up getting minorly spoiled on a season finale monster from walking by a sign about costuming on the way to set up lunch

Patrick Kay

Finally getting to listen - thanks for the bonus ep! So one thing that has been driving me mad about the Mae/Osha twin reveal is that it's actually a twist. This wasn't alluded to in any trailers or marketing materials, up to and including...action figures from Hasbro. I'm a fig collector, so yes, I bought the first wave of Acolyte toys months ago. They had Mae available, and after the first two episodes dropped they revealed an Osha for a later date. But it's wild because if marketing (or scripting) had been upfront about this scenario from the jump, it would've been better for them financially! "One twin joins the Jedi Order, the other resents her and falls prey to a secretive Sith master" would've absolutely gotten more eyeballs. This is probably an overall Hollywood/"Prestige TV" problem where the revelation of basic plot details is seen as more important than what they *do* with the scenario presented. I've enjoyed the show fairly well as I do most all things Star Wars, but I think many failures (including gaffing and color grading) have to do more with the state of the industry than Leslye Headland's ability. Probably.

nickAF

These shows aren't seasons; they're one-shots.

Grassy Gnoll

I took have this feeling. Also, slow choreography, hahahaha. Just wait.

Kelvin

Yeah maybe they’ll do it later but someone with that origin should have *opinions* on things and they’re just not looking at her in that way. Like in addition to all what you mentioned she’s also a successful mechanic who’s found her own way in the world as a working class person with her own experiences but the show kinda treats her as if she’s just another Jedi initiate in how she acts an it’s incongruous

Travis

Listening to this right after watching ep 5 was a trip!

noshotsfired.tv

Well I very much appreciate this episode as it explained what on earth is going on in this show. It just seems like a mess to me and it very much hasn’t laid enough seeds about the stuff with coven for me to be very interested yet. Some cool characters but not much beyond that for me so far.

alex

i’m wondering if the weird dimness/lack of contrast in the show has to do with disney’s lightsaber lighting. because the lightsabers and their lighting cast on faces and stuff looks good, and i wonder if part of the issue is not wanting to have those scenes do the anti-seizure dimming thing that makes them stick out, so they reduced contrast everywhere else? idk if so that’s a bad reason lmao but it was a thought i had especially watching ep 5

Jinnigan

my hot take: surely this is a result of shooting in The Volume, since you need to light a very specific way for that. the background isn't a backdrop, it's actually emitting light! that makes it basically impossible to convincingly light the subjects as though they're in the location the volume is depicting, especially in dark scenes. then think about how you've got to light your non-volume scenes to match the footage shot on the volume. i think that's why everything feels like it was shot on a theater soundstage

alex

yeahhh that makes total sense

Jinnigan

jk. i just looked it up and the showrunner says they didn't use the volume at all. 0% volume use. so now we're back to square 1 on why any of this looks the way it does

electric_claire

I'm a little surprised about how down on the show they are. It's definitely not the most expertly produced but the ideas are so good, it reminds me of Clone Wars in that way.

Kzinssie

Hearing y'all talk about wishing it was a Jekyll and Hyde thing was kinda funny because as a plural system I was specifically dreading that outcome and kinda breathed a sigh of relief when it was just twins. Not necessarily even a Problematic thing so much as just "oh thank god I'm not going to have to have a Take on this corny CW-ass show"

Zach G

By the time we get to that point there will be another Rey trilogy after that lmao

Zach G

Yeah I thought that was the joke and it hit for me a little. The look on her face kinda drove it home

Zach G

I'm enjoying it as a YA CW style show despite plenty of faults and I wish every star wars thing didn't have to be the BIGGEST THING. I do think some of these performances are definitely carrying the show though (Jacinto, Lee, Turner-Smith). Manny Jacinto is so fun and has the potential to be a true Sith hottie like we haven't seen in a while. I get the feeling y'all aren't a huge fan of Amandla Stenberg here but I think she is charismatic enough to keep my interest despite the muddled way her characters are handled for ~mystery~ reasons. PS - I agree with Natalie about the high republic feeling exactly the same as the current republic aside from some added yellow, but I did appreciate that the ships do feel like they have a different design language. Mae's ship feels distinctly "bad guy" but not exactly TIE design like every other evil star wars person's ship, the Jedi ship feels a little bit 50s retrofuturistic, etc.

WGM

Yeah I easily prefered it to most of the things covered in the series. I was a little confused by the episode.

Cosimo

please cover the next two episodes, im losing my mind

Mike

Y’all got my $5 for putting this behind a paywall ya goofs.

tobias

for this show? glass houses

Ross Disney

On the latest main episode they've mused multiple times that a second Acolyte episode might be out as well, but unless they did one on just 5 and 6 there's no way this could be.

khorneight

As someone who lives in Oregon I gotta chime in: Grimm was in fact filmed here

Wiley Albright

Can't wait for the 2nd PT of this one. Episodes 5-8 took some interesting turns.

Bigbadbarron

I'm not "Tech Available" is totally entering my lexicon now

Lewis Randall

Loved the episode, agreed with basically all of it. There are ideas there, but they're just stating them outright rather than letting them emerge from the story. And so many nonsense decisions in order to get characters where they want them by the end of the episode. I think the biggest issue is putting Eps 3 and 7 as flashbacks and trying to frame the plot as a mystery, rather than putting them first and then jumping 16 years. So much of the dramatic (and physical) action lacks any weight because we don't have the context yet.

wolfstar5

I really disagree with your take on Mae's turn bc it felt clear that the entire reason she was on this killing spree was as an atonement for her guilt over Osha's death. Mae learning that Osha is alive means that she doesn't have any use or connection to becoming Sith anymore. I thought it was clear she was struggling with that SINCE the encounter earlier in the episode