Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • AMCA July Patreon_mixdown.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

This month, we return to Leslye Headland's exploration of High Republic mystery, Jedi hypocrisy, and Sith arm muscles. After a middling start, can The Acolyte find its way into a more compelling, more consistent shape? Okay well. Barring that. Could it at least get a little more fun and sexy?

Show Notes

Osha & Qimir - Hands Gifset

 

Files

Comments

Solomon Mars

Y'all I had a crisis of faith at the end of episode 4 and I will say prices partially averted by the end of the season

JoanneBB

I’m looking forward to your takes. I watched the series with my kid and she (9 years old) is excited for more while I was underwhelmed.

Matthew Sampedro

Overall I enjoyed the series Show could have used more quiet beats spent with characters. Fight scenes were great. I want a season 2.

Cloudyskies

Maybe I'm just really protective of this show after seeing so much awful hate online (and review ratings really low) but I didn't hate this show much. Episode 7 is super messy but I didn't read the witches falling over as them dying, I read it as them falling unconscious. Which makes Sol pulling Osha away before she can investigate, and the ensuing fire killing them all, a bit more evil overall. Ultimately the Jedi twist in episode 7 was meh, but I really liked The Stranger in this show especially.

Mike

Dave and Skywalker Ranch keep shoveling shit on Yoda’s reputation and it’s marvelous

Emily Prechtl

This dropping just made my Friday

Richard Sharpe

I feel like the writers wrote this entire series backwards. They had plot points and plot goals (including season 2 renewal goals) and every single decision characters make were made to get to the those next scenes, rather than internal character motivation/progress/logic. There are good ideas in this show, but the writers fail to EARN any of them.

Kelvin

Very much not a fan of some of the decision making of the show even tho I still like the concepts. A lot of waste imo. But at least it had some things I liked tho so it’s above like, Obi wan and probably boba lol

PJ Molloy

At 1:08:00, the “stomach aches” that Vernestra got are explained in the books that introduced her. She gets force Visions while flying through hyperspace, but the way it’s written, it’s to show the senator doesn’t respect her enough to learn. Which is why she tried to correct him. Not ya’lls fault for not knowing it’s not explained well in the show.

ADeeyore

I met Manny a few times back when I did a lot of work in the Asian American entertainment community and the way Manny himself pronounces his surname has changed, back in the Good Place days, he pronounced his own surname with a hard "J", but in recent interviews, he's been using the "H" sound which is the Spanish pronunciation. It's definitely a relatable thing for me since I have a chinese surname that's also hard to pronounce for western tongues and have myself transitioned over the years to using the "actual" pronunciation when introducing myself instead of defaulting to the easier to pronounce version that a teacher used back in elementary school.

Molly Weinberger

They literally changed cinematographers halfway through. That's the reason episode 8 is so much better at handling the Osha/Mae stuff

Scott Henderson

I think the character beats would have been more impactful if the show gave it's characters any time to breathe on screen. So many characters tell us what they are feelings vs. show what they are feeling. I think there is good bones there, I think the Rashomon angle was an interesting take, but I think it could have much stronger if it was a linear story. I hope they get some of those things figured out in season 2, but man Season 1 was so disappointing and I didn't really care about any of the characters by the end. Also, Not everything has to be connected back to Luke Skywalker saga. For a universe about a huge galaxy, it feels so small when there is only one major plot thread in the universe.

Kelvin

I would describe this show as “sounding better in a Wikipedia article and imagining it than when actually watching it (except some fight scenes)”. There’s things there to like but maaaaaaan

Halfin

I was looking forward to this

Molly Weinberger

Basil's motivations seemed pretty obvious to me. He's the only non-Jedi dealing with all this shit. He thinks he's on the right side helping Sol to discover that Osha is Mae, but Sol's stunning of Mae as she tries to call the Jedi council for help freaks Basil out. He realises Sol's kind of fucked up. When Sol is trying to line up the shot to cover up the crimes he just admitted to through a murder, Basil prevents that from happening.

freejinx

Manny like our beautiful boy Hayden is a Canuck. Both of them are from out Bc way. He was born in Manila came over when he was a little. I don’t know if there is a connection with both him and Hayden growing up an hour from each other and going on to play spooky evil space wizards, but it is weird it’s happened twice. That’s like half of all sith.

Liam Muller

I also truly don't understand Basil because Mog knows him! He's like a commonly hired contractor for the jedi! He's gonna get hired again with none of the jedi knowing he is the biggest operational risk

loserlesbian

idk if it matters to the gang or not but vernestra is confirmed in the high republic books to be aro + ace, i don’t think the gang meant anything bad by the fun shipping speculation with sol and vern but just wanted to share some additional info :P

freejinx

First We got project necromancer. Now the idea of one mind in two bodies. Hear me out… this is a part of Sheevs clone horacrux. Buckle in for a The last skywalker retcon. Now all we need to know is where the scary penis star destroyers came from.

Halfin

Now having listened to the 5 star run time. I'm satiated. As Natalie said hearing you all talk about the show made me like it more.

Neale Nearing

Am I missing other places where Plagueis is pronounced differently from Episode 3 or maybe an in-joke?

Neale Nearing

Genuine question, I hope I don't sound like a dick. With all the BS names in Star Wars and how a few characters have their name said different ways already it hardly matters.

Aaron Wood

I didn't think that was Sol lining up blaster shots, I took it as him attempting to 'scoop' her craft up, like maybe the monitor he popped up and the switch he was about to hit was lining up a tow cable or tractor beam. I guess I don't know what was happening there! huh. I guess that was left vague intentionally?

Molly Weinberger

I'm really curious how they wrote that when all Jedi are supposed to be celibate and disallow themselves from feeling attracted to anyone else? Like, what makes her more aroace than any other Jedi?

Molly Weinberger

Same targeting thingy as Darth Vader in A New Hope

Solomon Mars

No, I don't think it's a joke. I think it's just a matter of different people pronounce stuff differently and with the podcast group they have a tendency to vocally mimic each other while in conversation. But they pronounced his name a couple of different ways.

Flex Mentallo

I'll be honest: I agree with a lot of the criticisms of the show y'all level, and also this was (in my opinion) the second best live-action Star Wars show. The action was solid-to-very-good, some fantastic costume design, some great performances from Manny Jacinto and Lee Jung-jae in particular... it's just a pretty good show. Its biggest flaw is that there isn't enough of it, tbh -- we needed more time to spend with characters, more time for the twists to hit, more time just with everything.

Zachary Jurbina

My Filipino-American ass with a J last name where you pronounce the Jay sound because the English language has had 125 years of influence on the Philippines.

Kyle HB Donnelly

Dang, do Jedi in the order have uncles? Torbin and Sol needed an uncle to sit them down with a Busch Light and say "world's not fair, dudes"

Chad H

This was appointment listening for me - thanks for getting it out so fast!

Emily Prechtl

I read the Qimir/Osha helmet scene as the helmet triggering some kind of witchy power in Osha similar to what her mom is able to do — Qimir’s eyes go black and he ends up in that void place like Torbin, and we see him struggle through it to get the helmet off, and we get a glimpse of weird red eyes from Osha before she snaps out of it

Emily Prechtl

Also was anyone else confused by Mae in the last few episodes? Seems like her character was totally sidelined in favor of Osha. It seemed like all those years of darkside training was all to fight her way into 1 conversation with Osha, and after that happened she’s like “ok I made my case, just chilling now”

Brandon Dorigatti

I would love for them to read the Plagueis book. Even with it not being cannon anymore it informs a lot of this show

G. Tyler Ernst

See, I think at the end of season 1 Darth Plagueis doesn't know how to control life and death, and I think that the plot of season 2 is him using Osha to discover how to do it. He needs her to figure out what her mom did, and he's willing to manipulate and destroy probably pretty much everything to learn that. This might be how Qimir here gets got.

G. Tyler Ernst

Yeah, I mean, look at how they even handled her backstory. Like, we don't know how she survived that night fr. Like, her whole family is dead, the Jedi leave, and her planet is totally uninhabited. Even if she survives how does she get off the planet or find anyone to get her to a force user?

G. Tyler Ernst

This, and I also think that in season 1, the characters' story they are least interested in telling are the mains. Like Osha and May get so little of their stories shown and are mostly just told. Like, Osha and Yore have like a whole history and we never get to see it, we don't get to see how May survived alone on her planet and got away over that 16 years, and we don't see how Sol dealt with training Osha and if her feelings about her inabilities to be a Jedi are real, or if they are things other people told her like Sol or something.

G. Tyler Ernst

Biggest thing I'm worrying about with Osha/May's Light side/Dark side stuff is that this is some awful callback to the Mortis arc and they are supposed to be the dark side and the light side kids, and then when one of them starts to go light, the other starts to go dark. God I hope that doesn't happen, but I can feel it, I can feel the stupid pull of it for someone out there.

Grassy Gnoll

Could Basil's confusion come from the fact Mai and Osha aren't twins, their the same person. Also, the part where Mai and Osha fight, they mirror each other almost perfectly, even though so far Mai has be show to be the more martial of the two. Is it the closer they are, the more "one" they are?

Grassy Gnoll

Sol and Jekki had some spark and their relationship felt real and grounded, unlike Osha who really came across as blank and the relationship felt forced from Sol, which kind of ties in story wise. In fact Jekki felt like the more emotionally adult of the pair.

Pazuzu

I really dislike this show, but it's frustrating because everyone else who dislikes it is an idiot or a Nazi

Kelvin

I thought he thought was trying to ram the ship into dust. But I definitely had to watch the scene like twice more to get it. Confused the hell out of me and it’s just not acknowledged bc nobody can talk to the dude. That aspect feels bad even when I get it

Kzinssie

There was another podcast I listen to (The Shrieking Shack) that briefly discussed The Acolyte and compared the stranger to Shadow the Hedgehog, and as someone extremely normal about that character specifically I actually think that's a really accurate comparison with how he fights (albeit with less teleporting)

B.E. Albert

I wanna shoutout the author who wrote Star Wars Ronin, Emma Mieko Candon, because she also wrote a REALLY good book about mechs and bodies and queerness called The Archive Undying, I highly recommend it to any fatt friends who love the Divine Cycle seasons (or cast members)

Will

About “THE” cameo appearance speculation, I just need to interject that y’all be out here slandering the good name of Hego Damask with all this Sith talk. That man is just out looking for prospective mining and investment opportunities. He’s just an entrepreneur making his way in the galaxy.

Boots MacLeod

My main frustration with the show is that it's difficult to tell what is supposed to be intentional characterization and what is just a writing issue. The first thing I noticed with Sol is when he's in the classroom telling the Padawans not to trust their eyes but a couple scenes later, he claims there's no way Mae could be alive because "He saw her fall with his own eyes." Either this is an intentional thing in which case Sol is just...a bad Jedi or an inconstancy with the writing.

Kzinssie

You're missing the strongest possible tragic end which is Osha and the Stranger successfully fuck off but then Mae gets got in such a way that it also kills Osha somehow and there's a tragic scene of her dying and not knowing why

Jan

I wonder how much OT Basil got for all that

Gin Riot

Jecki and Yord came off as much stronger characters than Osha because they seemed to have some personality/characterization. I don’t know how this show moves forward after culling every interesting character but The Stranger

Jacob Magraw

Great discussion. When they cut to the back of Yoda’s head I cancelled my Disney subscription. 5 stars.

wolfstar5

This happens consistently with Sol throughout - I feel like hypocrisy is his main thematic characterization

Bengeemon

Subbed to the Patreon for this, was not disappointed. Great discussion!

cole d

He's just a humble banker from Muunilist, a totally reputable guy

cole d

The Plagueis book is one of the few SW EU novels I own, it's currently my headcanon for Plagueis' story, how Palps got his start as Sidious, and the setup they did pre-phantom menace

Paul Carre

The only conceivable explanation for Basil is that someone lost a bet that they couldn't shoehorn a Great Mouse Detective reference into the show.

Paul W.

Hell yes, agree. This was a show getting its footing and by the end really drew me in - warts and all. I essentially chose to l selectively remember parts of the beginning 4 ho hum episodes and rolled with the vibes and explosion of ideas once Kimer mowed down the Jedi. Honestly, I even like this better than Rebels so far. I would have loved more screen time for the Acolyte as yall have asked for, but in Rebels the tone shifts come to hard for me to really enjoy it - also I don’t like Ezra or Sabine so that makes it hard. I had a lot of characters I liked in this show, all with very different motivations and teams they represented instead of just following the Ghost.

Divanté Malachi

Also God it being Plagueis kinda ruins it for me, I was so up on it being distinctly *not* Sith

Sola

I think you guys should do the other high republic stuff one day if you need another break from the main work. Especially if we get a season 2. The book events should be over by mid-2025. I’m interested where is Vernestra is there and her arc vs her in this show, 100 years on, perhaps as a microcosm of the greater Jedi decline during the period

Scott Davis

Finally a Patreon and getting to listen to this content. I was excited to get High Republic era stories but was immediately disheartened by the CW feel of the production/tone and then episode 5 landed and I thought wait a minute maybe…? My interest was peaked and by the end of 8 I too was on the Season 2 bandwagon bc I thought they maybe were getting into a lane that could amount to something maybe not amazing but intriguing/entertaining and dare I say contributing to the canon, even though the start was rough. Especially love the conspiracy and darkness woven into the highest ranks of the Jedi order bc as you all have noted there is no way dissent isn’t part of the narrative and we all know that power doesn’t usually come into being without some skeletons in the closet. By the end there was visible potential and I can’t tell if the series was scrapped bc of performance or the ensuing/awful clashes between fans/actors. Sadly I was left wanting for better from both the Disney production team and fandom at the end of this one. AMCA coverage was impeccable, passionate and hilarious as always (hence my new Patronage). Thanks all.

Mark Shatraw

Very late to this conversation lol but: Jecki is played by Dafne Keen, who plays X-23 in the various X-Men movies. She has extensive gymnastics training which has allowed her to do her own stunts, quite a bit. So when you hire Dafne Keen, you give her a good booking.

Bobby Chaudhuri

Read the legends Darth Plageuis novel as it slightly helps this series as uneven as it and really helps expand the events before the prequel trilogy Loved your podcast Thanks again

ViolitJ Art

I liked the conversation around lightsabers being things that people build. I've never interacted with High Republic stuff outside what was peppered in recent games, and I haven't seen this show. But I have a Jedi OC from that specific era who has a lightsaber that is either one long blade or taken apart into two shorter blades. They also have a speaker on them that connect to her implants that translate her sign language for her (she's a bit of a self insert haha). I love that more creative lightsabers are popping up and I hope we see some more interesting ones moving forward.