Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 298728071.mp4

Missing 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Let us know what you think in the comments, or if you have any questions for our upcoming Q&A Videos on The Intel Report.

Comments

ISAF_Ace

With the wide 3 lane roads of Baghdad, it seems like the city was almost built for tank columns.

Aught

There's so much to unpack here, and I'm not nearly knowledgeable enough to comment on most of it. Just... wow. So much in this video is boggling. I guess if I had to pick one question, 'why did the Thunder Run not experience higher casualties'? I may just be a layman, but isn't driving armor through a heavily urbanized environment as a simple show of force an absolutely terrible idea? What exactly happened; poor weapons and training on the Iraqi side and heavy suppressive fire on the Coalition side? It's clear from earlier videos Iraq's military had declined substantially, and irregulars were mixed in with regular army. And against all common sense *no one* was warned of the Coalition's approach. The opposite, even - they were told the Coalition were still far off. Self preservation propaganda by Iraqi High Command? Defeatist attitudes? Radio jamming or lack of communications equipment? All of the above? It all just seems so chaotic and senseless, even though both sides clearly had ample opportunity to prepare and react well in advance of the launch of the Thunder Run. Who were the Coalition demoralizing? The dead men they left in their wake? Iraqi leadership? Could they even count on demoralizing Iraqi leadership? The circumstances are just so bizarre. A practical and concrete objective would've made so much more sense - at least to me, without military experience - in a tactical and strategic sense.

Ryan

I literally just finished re-reading Thunder Run earlier this month. Feel like I need to read it a third time now

EscapeEvade

Somehow a single tank with a mangled gun brazenly approaching is probably legitimately more terrifying than a whole armored column. I don't blame the Iraqis for running from that but not the entire column.

Teddy Young

One question: if the order was to never stop the column, what was the official plan for responding to disabled vehicles? Obviously army commanders would not just leave their soldiers for dead. I could see how picking up survivors but abandoning vehicles rather than attempt repairs could be an answer. In which case, Schwartz's decision to grind everything to a halt just to save a tank would have been crazy. So I doubt that such an order was actually given. Do you know what his orders were in this case?