Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 300349034.mp4

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Let us know what you think in the comments, or if you have any questions for our upcoming Q&A Videos on The Intel Report.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Scott

A classic situation of “they learn, we learn”. The Iraqis learned how to counter the deep strike that they had seen before, and the U.S. had not anticipated this. We were forced to revise our tactics in the field to adapt, which was done successfully. The process of evaluating potential responses and counters isn’t glamorous, but it is what makes future success more likely.

ISAF_Ace

Deep strikes seem to rely on several things: no enemy air power, no enemy integrated air defence, large enemy concentrations, no nearby civilian infrastructure. The strategy seems to be too specialised for certain situations.

Darth Rust

The criticisms of Deep Strike sounds overly hardware focused on Apache. The doctrine was designed around fighting the Soviets in Europe, with training and readiness to match, and other things going on in support of it. When an operation goes awry, in a different war that doesn’t match the doctrine assumptions, that’s not a hardware problem, and Destiny Reach showed that. It's like there's a rush to declare the next sunset-of-Battleships, similar to how quick (and poor) analysis of the early days of Ukraine were suspiciously fast to say that Tanks are outmoded, Starlink is critical, HIMARs saved-the-day, none of which has stood close scrutiny because there's more to war than hardware.

Aught

Amazing what happens when you allow seasoned professional soldiers, instead of career politicians, time and executive control over planning your war fighting. Rushed and haphazard vs. methodical and precise. What a stark contrast between deep strikes.

matthew robin

"similar to how quick (and poor) analysis of the early days of Ukraine were suspiciously fast to say that ... Starlink is critical" Can you link to the analysis that showed that Starlink's importance was overstated?

Darth Rust

The Russia Contingency podcast behind the pay wall at WoTR. Both Michael Kofman and Rod Lee observed that while Ukr has adapted to it's presence and used it for what it is, their force isn't maneuvering above the Company level. We're it to vanish, the line of contact would still be defined by rage from artillery positions and prepared defenses. Starlink is important if not critical in some instances, but it's not generated a significant effect at the OWL or above. There some othere sources such as ISW and SWJ that have insinuated the same without saying it, and a lot of the NYT and similar coverage has been somewhere between naive and dumv because they're chasing squirrels. If you have a WoTR account I can throw EP numbers but it's a recurring theme after Mike and Rob visit Ukr about 3 times a year.