The Sinking of Scharnhorst, The Battle of North Cape 1943 - Early Release Script (Patreon)
Content
The Royal Navy minesweeper HMS Gleaner is escorting Convoy JW 55B through the Arctic Circle enroute to deliver critical war supplies to the Soviet Union. Crewmen aboard Gleaner are carrying out their duties in freezing temperatures when they hear aircraft engines. A German Ju-88 bomber is sighted high above them and out of range for anti-aircraft guns. The convoy’s leader, Rear Admiral Boucher, radios the news to Admiral Bruce Fraser, Commander of the Home Fleet. Boucher is nervous, knowing that the reconnaissance plane has likely reported his convoy’s location to one of the Kreigsmarine’s most fearsome warships, the modern battlecruiser Scharnhorst. Unbeknownst to Boucher, this is exactly what Admiral Fraser wants. The convoy is serving as bait to lure Scharnhorst to its destruction. Admiral Fraser sets his plan in motion and Force 2 leaves Scapa Flow on the 23rd December.
By the end of 1943, the war in the Arctic Circle has reached a tipping point. In June of the previous year, the mere threat of the battleship Tirpitz encouraged the British Admiralty to scatter convoy PQ17 which ended in debacle for the merchant ships. Since then, the Allies have diverted massive naval resources to support the lend-lease effort to the Soviet Union. With the Tirpitz undergoing repairs after multiple British air raids, Scharnhorst is now the only German capital ship operating in the far north.
Aided by Ultra decrypts from Bletchley Park, Fraser will know exactly when Scharnhorst will leave to intercept the convoy and can choose the battlefield accordingly. A cruiser squadron known as Force 1 under the command of Rear Admiral Robert Burnett will escort the convoy from a distance and be the first to engage Scharnhorst. Meanwhile, Fraser will approach with the much stronger Force 2 and destroy the enemy with the guns of his flagship, the King George V-class battleship HMS Duke of York.
With the sighting of JW55B, Commander of the Scharnhorst battlegroup, Rear Admiral Erich Bey and the commander of the Kreigsmarine, Grand Admiral Karl Donitz are debating their next move. Luftwaffe reports indicate the British convoy is slow and extremely vulnerable, but a massive winter gale is expected to sweep the area on Christmas Day, severely limiting visibility and threatening Bey’s destroyer force. Bey is reluctant to risk Scharnhorst in such a perilous sortie where the Arctic sun will only rise for a couple of hours per day.
On the other hand, Grand Admiral Donitz is facing political pressure from the Fuhrer for the Kriegsmarine to contribute more to the war effort. He is eager to prove the usefulness of the Navy and orders Bey to stand by to launch Operation Ostfront, an all-out effort against the convoy.
Another full day passes as the convoy rounds the northernmost point of Norway. Early in the morning on Christmas Day, the German submarine U-601 spots the merchantmen and relays their position. A simple message from Donitz is forwarded to Rear Admiral Bey: ‘Ostfront 25/12’. Bey immediately orders his battlegroup to prepare for departure. After the German sailors dump their Christmas decorations into the Altenfjord the modern battlecruiser with five destroyers set sail.
The German battlegroup is immediately set upon by the winter storm battering the Arctic Sea. Bey sends a message to Admiral Donitz saying ‘Conditions are very unfavourable. Significant results cannot be expected. Therefore, propose cancellation.’ Donitz replies, ‘Important enemy convoy carrying supplies and munitions to the Russians further imperils the heroic struggle of our army on the Eastern front. We must help.’
On Duke of York, Admiral Fraser is handed a top-secret Ultra signal reading: ‘Emergency. Scharnhorst probably sailed.’ Rear Admiral Burnett’s cruisers are ordered to place themselves between the likely position of the German battlegroup and the convoy. They are to tie down the enemy until Force 2 arrives.
At 7:00am on the 26th, Rear Admiral Bey deploys his force in scouting formation, with the destroyers taking the lead 10 nautical miles ahead of the Scharnhorst. As a result, the battlecruiser loses visual contact with the destroyers as the snowstorm intensifies. Orders must now be passed by radio rather than signal as the German warships continue to search for the convoy. Over the next hour, Bey’s frustration builds when they fail to spot the enemy. At 8:20am, he orders Scharnhorst to turn north but fails to alert his destroyers to this course change. The battlecruiser is now completely alone.
At 8:34am, Force 1’s flagship, HMS Belfast, picks up a single unidentified radar contact and Rear Admiral Burnett orders his three cruisers, Belfast, Norfolk, and Sheffield, into a staggered line. At 9:21am, a lookout on Belfast spots a massive, dark shape through the blizzard and signals the bridge: ‘Enemy in Sight.’ The Germans are completely unaware they are sailing directly into an ambush. Five minutes later at 9:26am, Belfast fires a single star shell which illuminates the winter sky and bathes the Scharnhorst in light. The Battle of North Cape begins.
With the target visible, HMS Norfolk immediately opens fire with her eight-inch guns while the Germans are temporarily stunned by the artificial sunlight. However, Norfolk’s salvo falls short, and the captain Scharnhorst reacts quickly. He orders his ship to flank speed and lays a smoke screen while turning south to evade the British guns. During the turn, his battlecruiser’s 11-inch main batteries fire in succession. Scharnhorst and the British cruisers trade salvos as the dark sky is brightened by the flash of heavy guns. None of the German shells strike their targets, but only two of the British salvos hit Scharnhorst and no damage is caused below the waterline. The battlecruiser is better armored and outguns the ships of Force 1, but German naval doctrine is to avoid large surface engagements. Bey orders Scharnhorst to disengage and turn north to approach the convoy from a different angle. By 9:45am, the German ship is out of range and Burnett orders his force to break off.
The first skirmish of the battle is inconclusive, despite being caught by surprise the Scharnhorst has reacted quickly and is still hunting for Convoy JW 55B. Nevertheless, one of Norfolk’s salvos has scored a lasting result. An eight-inch shell has destroyed Scharnhorst’s forward radar controls rendering the battlecruiser virtually blind in the mounting blizzard. The German gun crews are now forced to watch for muzzle flashes, a task made more difficult by new flashless propellant used on many Royal Navy ships.
Rear Admiral Bey continues to move north, hoping the Arctic sun will rise long enough for him to engage and destroy any merchantmen he encounters. At the same time, the larger Royal Navy Force 2 is discovered by a German reconnaissance patrol which radios its location back to base. Fraser is concerned that this might compel Scharnhorst to run for home, ruining his plan to bring the ship to battle. However, this message is not passed on to Rear Admiral Bey for another three and a half hours.
Rear Admiral Burnett once again moves his cruisers in between Scharnhorst and the convoy when at 12:04pm, Belfast reacquires the German battlecruiser on radar. Admiral Fraser is relieved by the news and closes on the position with Force 2. When the enemy warship is within 11,000 yards of Force 1, Belfast fires off another star shell followed by a salvo of six- and eight-inch shells. The barrage straddles the battlecruiser, whose crew is surprised yet again. This time, the 6th Destroyer Division is positioned directly ahead of the Scharnhorst. Burnett orders Fisher to launch a surprise torpedo attack, but the signal never makes it to the destroyers and the opportunity is lost.
A duel breaks out between Burnett’s ships and Scharnhorst which once again turns away to use its superior speed to escape the trap. Scharnhorst takes multiple hits, but again the British shells fail to penetrate the battlecruiser’s armor belt. This time, the German warship zeroes in on Norfolk. One 11-inch shell damages her ‘X’ turret and knocks it out of action, while another explodes outside the secondary damage control center which causes the engine room to fill with smoke and fumes. Undeterred, the engine room crew simply dons their gas masks and carry on with their work.
Scharnhorst once again turns to the southwest and steams away from the British at 28 knots. Enough is enough, and Rear Admiral Bey officially cancels Operation Ostfront at 2:30pm, ordering his ship and the destroyers back to Norway. Yet, one the battlecruiser’s radiomen informs Captain Hintze that he has intercepted Royal Navy radio signals. Behind Scharnhorst, Sheffield and Norfolk have both experienced engine problems and must stop, but Belfast is shadowing the battlecruiser and sending constant updates on Bey’s position to the Royal Navy battleship HMS Duke of York.
At 4:17pm, Duke of York acquires the Scharnhorst on radar. The undetected Force 2 steadily closes the distance over the next half hour. The lack of surface radar on Scharnhorst means Duke of York closes to within 12,000 yards of the German ship without being noticed. At 4:48pm, Fraser orders Belfast to fire a starshell. This time, however, it is Duke of York’s massive 14-inch shells which follow the burst of artificial sunlight.
The first salvo is extremely accurate. One shell punches through the armor on Scharnhorst’s forward turret, killing most of the gun crew and jamming the gun turret. A fire breaks out which threatens to detonate her stored shells, but the Captain orders the magazine flooded to prevent this. The third salvo strikes the aft superstructure and destroys the seaplane hangar, starting a large fire that can be seen from the British warships. With the light cruiser HMS Jamaica also joining the battle, Bey orders a hard turn to port, intending to run away to the north again.
To his horror, Bey discovers that Burnett’s formation has joined forces with Fraser and is bearing down on the Scharnhorst from that direction. Norfolk and Sheffield have been repaired and along with Fisher’s 6th Destroyer Division have cut off that escape route. Force 1 opens fire, straddling the embattled German warship. At 5:05pm, another 14-inch shell explodes within the ventilation system of turret ‘Bruno’, knocking it out of action. Scharnhorst returns fire with her remaining guns while Bey orders a slight turn to starboard. His only hope is to escape to the east.
Scharnhorst is running for the third time and again uses its superior speed to put distance between her and the British ships. The range steadily increases as Admiral Fraser orders his destroyers to chase down the wounded, but still dangerous enemy. Despite extensive damage, Scharnhorst’s engines are intact, and she will soon be out of range. One German salvo straddles Duke of York and damages its radar set, hampering her gunnery. For the next hour, Duke of York and Scharnhorst trade fire at extreme range. Certain that the enemy is about to slip through his grasp yet again, a defeated Admiral Fraser signals Burnett, ‘I see little hope of catching Scharnhorst.’
Just minutes before the German battlecruiser is about to slip out of British radar range, the Duke of York fires one final salvo at 6:20pm. Miraculously, a shell penetrates the armored belt and explodes within the starboard machinery space. Steam pressure from the boilers drops significantly and the ship’s speed falls from 30 knots to 22. Without surface radar, the Scharnhorst’s remaining guns fire blindly into the snowstorm while the destroyers close for a torpedo attack.
At a range of 2,100 yards, the destroyer HMS Scorpion and the exiled Norwegian destroyer Stord launch a spread of eight torpedoes. On the port side, the destroyers Savage and Saumarez close in to launch their own torpedoes when Saumarez is struck by an 11-inch shell on the gun director tower, but it does not explode. Both destroyers fire a spread of 12 torpedoes a minute after Scorpion and Stord. The destroyer force peels off in either direction to avoid the battlecruiser’s guns.
Most of the torpedoes miss, but one from Stord strikes Scharnhorst on the starboard side while three explode on the port. The simultaneous impact of four torpedoes causes significant damage and the battlecruiser’s speed drops to just 10 knots. With the heavy guns of Force 1 and 2 approaching, Captain Hintze radios German naval command at 7:20pm, stating: ‘We shall fight to the last shell. Long live Germany. Long live the Führer.’ At the same time, Duke of York and Jamaica are back in range and open fire, scoring several hits. Despite the onslaught, Scharnhorst continues to resist. ‘Bruno’ turret has been hastily repaired and fires alongside ‘Caesar’ turret. The battlecruiser even attempts a doomed torpedo attack, but damage to the launchers means only one can be fired which fails to hit a Royal Navy ship. Scharnhorst is pounded by the intense bombardment.
Fraser orders Commander Fisher’s destroyers to deliver the final blow. HMS Musketeer, Virago, and Opportune launch their spreads from just 1,000 yards away. Of the 11 torpedoes launched, five hit the Scharnhorst. This is the final blow, and she slowly begins to capsize. At 7:40pm, Captain Hintze gives the order to ‘Abandon Ship’ and shakes hands with Admiral Bey on the bridge before the two men jump into the freezing sea, never to be seen again. Five minutes later, the battlecruiser slips below the surface while British ships move in to rescue survivors. Many survive the initial sinking, but the extreme temperature takes its toll. Of the almost 2,000 crewmen aboard Scharnhorst, only 36 are pulled alive from the Arctic Sea.
The Battle of North Cape marks one the final engagements in history between battleships and the last anti-convoy sortie of the Kreigsmarine’s surface force. Convoy JW 55B successfully unloads its war material and the Allies gain a decisive advantage in the far north. From this point forward, the majority of Germany’s naval effort will be dedicated to improving the U-Boat fleet while the few remaining surface raiders will spend the rest of their days in harbor. Almost a year later, Tirpitz will be sunk by the RAF, finally ending the threat to the Arctic convoys.